{
  "schema_version": "election-bundle/v1",
  "election": {
    "election_id": "ca-2026-11-03-general",
    "name": "California General Election",
    "jurisdiction": "CA",
    "election_type": "general",
    "date": "2026-11-03",
    "dates": {
      "ballots_mailed": "2026-10-05",
      "election_day": "2026-11-03",
      "certification_deadline": "2026-12-11",
      "certified_at": null
    },
    "previous_stage": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
    "coverage_note": "All 14 statewide propositions and the Secretary of State certified office roster. City guides cover San Francisco and Sunnyvale citywide and applicable regional measures. Address-specific local coverage is available for the North Sunnyvale covered location."
  },
  "contests": [
    {
      "contest_id": "governor",
      "office": "Governor",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "xavier-becerra",
          "name": "Xavier Becerra",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Voting Rights Attorney",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 2591857,
            "vote_share": 0.2798,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "subject_id": "xavier-becerra",
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "Campaign finance is shown on the evidence profile."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "steve-hilton",
          "name": "Steve Hilton",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 2277318,
            "vote_share": 0.2459,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "subject_id": "steve-hilton",
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "Campaign finance is shown on the evidence profile."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "lieutenant-governor",
      "office": "Lieutenant Governor",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "fiona-ma",
          "name": "Fiona Ma",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Treasurer/CPA",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 1631935,
            "vote_share": 0.1912,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "gloria-romero",
          "name": "Gloria Romero",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Educator/Businesswoman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 1521181,
            "vote_share": 0.1783,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "secretary-of-state",
      "office": "Secretary of State",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "shirley-n-weber",
          "name": "Shirley N. Weber",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California Secretary of State",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 5092491,
            "vote_share": 0.587,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "donald-p-don-wagner",
          "name": "Donald P. (Don) Wagner",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Orange County Supervisor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 3187180,
            "vote_share": 0.3674,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "controller",
      "office": "Controller",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "malia-m-cohen",
          "name": "Malia M. Cohen",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Controller/Mother",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 4909613,
            "vote_share": 0.568,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "herb-w-morgan",
          "name": "Herb W Morgan",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Chief Investment Officer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 3244252,
            "vote_share": 0.3753,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "treasurer",
      "office": "Treasurer",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "eleni-kounalakis",
          "name": "Eleni Kounalakis",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Lieutenant Governor of California",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 3154323,
            "vote_share": 0.3669,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jennifer-hawks",
          "name": "Jennifer Hawks",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Business Executive",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 2063253,
            "vote_share": 0.24,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "attorney-general",
      "office": "Attorney General",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "rob-bonta",
          "name": "Rob Bonta",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California Attorney General",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 4979967,
            "vote_share": 0.5662,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "michael-e-gates",
          "name": "Michael E. Gates",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Deputy United States Attorney",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 3337433,
            "vote_share": 0.3794,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "insurance-commissioner",
      "office": "Insurance Commissioner",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ben-allen",
          "name": "Ben Allen",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Senator",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 1649501,
            "vote_share": 0.1941,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jane-kim",
          "name": "Jane Kim",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Attorney/Consumer Advocate",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 2328836,
            "vote_share": 0.274,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "superintendent-of-public-instruction",
      "office": "Superintendent of Public Instruction",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "nonpartisan_runoff",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "richard-barrera",
          "name": "Richard Barrera",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": "State Superintendent Advisor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 1558298,
            "vote_share": 0.203,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "sonja-shaw",
          "name": "Sonja Shaw",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": "School District President",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 1737735,
            "vote_share": 0.2264,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:superintendent-of-public-instruction"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "boe-1",
      "office": "Board of Equalization Member District 1",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "boe",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "nelson-esparza",
          "name": "Nelson Esparza",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Teacher/Economist/Councilmember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 664072,
            "vote_share": 0.3405,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "shannon-grove",
          "name": "Shannon Grove",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator/Businesswoman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 672039,
            "vote_share": 0.3446,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "boe-2",
      "office": "Board of Equalization Member District 2",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "boe",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sally-j-lieber",
          "name": "Sally J. Lieber",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Incumbent",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 1336379,
            "vote_share": 0.5676,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "john-pimentel",
          "name": "John Pimentel",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member, Board of Trustees, San Mateo County Community College District",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 371920,
            "vote_share": 0.158,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "boe-3",
      "office": "Board of Equalization Member District 3",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "boe",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mike-gipson",
          "name": "Mike Gipson",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember/Father",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 516324,
            "vote_share": 0.2788,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "samuel-p-sukaton",
          "name": "Samuel P. Sukaton",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Labor Union Organizer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 337313,
            "vote_share": 0.1821,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "boe-4",
      "office": "Board of Equalization Member District 4",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "boe",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "tom-umberg",
          "name": "Tom Umberg",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Businessman/Senator",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 446715,
            "vote_share": 0.2069,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "denis-bilodeau",
          "name": "Denis Bilodeau",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilmember/Civil Engineer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 972838,
            "vote_share": 0.4506,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-1",
      "office": "United States Representative District 1",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mike-mcguire",
          "name": "Mike McGuire",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Senator",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 92121,
            "vote_share": 0.4176,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA01269/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA01269",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1827711.04,
            "disbursements": 1675105.4,
            "cash_on_hand": 152605.64,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "james-gallagher",
          "name": "James Gallagher",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative/Farmer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 92975,
            "vote_share": 0.4215,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA01285/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA01285",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1488905.68,
            "disbursements": 1156006.5,
            "cash_on_hand": 332899.18,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-2",
      "office": "United States Representative District 2",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jared-huffman",
          "name": "Jared Huffman",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 139662,
            "vote_share": 0.5648,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA06259/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA06259",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 978276.98,
            "disbursements": 886216.68,
            "cash_on_hand": 1076703.24,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "robin-littau",
          "name": "Robin Littau",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Enterprise Elementary School Board Member",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 28222,
            "vote_share": 0.1141,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA02309/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA02309",
            "as_of": null,
            "receipts": 0.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 0.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-3",
      "office": "United States Representative District 3",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ami-bera",
          "name": "Ami Bera",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Congressman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 76653,
            "vote_share": 0.3426,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H0CA03078/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H0CA03078",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1250126.28,
            "disbursements": 1293160.46,
            "cash_on_hand": 1830337.53,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "robb-tucker",
          "name": "Robb Tucker",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "County Supervisor/Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 66808,
            "vote_share": 0.2986,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA03174/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA03174",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 258139.01,
            "disbursements": 242139.34,
            "cash_on_hand": 15999.67,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-4",
      "office": "United States Representative District 4",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "eric-jones",
          "name": "Eric Jones",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Businessman/Nonprofit Executive",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 45992,
            "vote_share": 0.2223,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA04222/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA04222",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 8378928.57,
            "disbursements": 7723210.3,
            "cash_on_hand": 655718.27,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "mike-thompson",
          "name": "Mike Thompson",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of Congress",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 84753,
            "vote_share": 0.4097,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H8CA01109/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H8CA01109",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 4204013.13,
            "disbursements": 4337764.87,
            "cash_on_hand": 1075736.66,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-5",
      "office": "United States Representative District 5",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "5"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "michael-masuda",
          "name": "Michael Masuda",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Foreign Affairs Officer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 51418,
            "vote_share": 0.2431,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA05377/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA05377",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 361735.22,
            "disbursements": 272283.71,
            "cash_on_hand": 89451.51,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "tom-mcclintock",
          "name": "Tom McClintock",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 129653,
            "vote_share": 0.6129,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H8CA04152/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H8CA04152",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 928787.61,
            "disbursements": 875520.62,
            "cash_on_hand": 201471.98,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-6",
      "office": "United States Representative District 6",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "6"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "richard-pan",
          "name": "Richard Pan",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Doctor/Health Advocate",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 45008,
            "vote_share": 0.2317,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA03158/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA03158",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1098282.7,
            "disbursements": 739150.71,
            "cash_on_hand": 359131.99,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "kevin-kiley",
          "name": "Kevin Kiley",
          "party_preference": "No Party Preference",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 47165,
            "vote_share": 0.2428,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA03157/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA03157",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 2988805.45,
            "disbursements": 1245830.82,
            "cash_on_hand": 2123952.7,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-7",
      "office": "United States Representative District 7",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "7"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "doris-matsui",
          "name": "Doris Matsui",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 61114,
            "vote_share": 0.2909,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA05195/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA05195",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 3192087.39,
            "disbursements": 3031300.44,
            "cash_on_hand": 467455.75,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "mai-vang",
          "name": "Mai Vang",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Teacher/City Councilmember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 65617,
            "vote_share": 0.3123,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA07175/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA07175",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1086084.32,
            "disbursements": 980548.31,
            "cash_on_hand": 105536.01,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-8",
      "office": "United States Representative District 8",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "8"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "john-garamendi",
          "name": "John Garamendi",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of Congress",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 97155,
            "vote_share": 0.5441,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H0CA10149/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H0CA10149",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 489134.65,
            "disbursements": 557834.27,
            "cash_on_hand": 1196018.11,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "rudy-recile",
          "name": "Rudy Recile",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Business Owner/Consultant",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 49599,
            "vote_share": 0.2778,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA00153/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA00153",
            "as_of": "2026-09-30",
            "receipts": 20073.0,
            "disbursements": 20875.45,
            "cash_on_hand": 235.29,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-9",
      "office": "United States Representative District 9",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "9"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "josh-harder",
          "name": "Josh Harder",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Father/Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 79946,
            "vote_share": 0.6078,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H8CA10126/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H8CA10126",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 4083527.6,
            "disbursements": 1032871.24,
            "cash_on_hand": 4739488.08,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "john-mcbride",
          "name": "John McBride",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Athletic Performance Coach",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 30625,
            "vote_share": 0.2328,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA09101/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA09101",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 52177.65,
            "disbursements": 33569.2,
            "cash_on_hand": 18738.45,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-10",
      "office": "United States Representative District 10",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "10"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mark-desaulnier",
          "name": "Mark DeSaulnier",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Congressman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 132246,
            "vote_share": 0.5968,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H0CA10073/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H0CA10073",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 567257.94,
            "disbursements": 609747.82,
            "cash_on_hand": 586497.44,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jeff-frese",
          "name": "Jeff Frese",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 28671,
            "vote_share": 0.1294,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA10187/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA10187",
            "as_of": null,
            "receipts": 0.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 0.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-11",
      "office": "United States Representative District 11",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "11"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "connie-chan",
          "name": "Connie Chan",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "San Francisco Supervisor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 69899,
            "vote_share": 0.297,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA11268/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA11268",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1094321.06,
            "disbursements": 732236.42,
            "cash_on_hand": 362084.64,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Open seat"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "scott-wiener",
          "name": "Scott Wiener",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 95816,
            "vote_share": 0.4071,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H8CA11116/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H8CA11116",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 4561120.07,
            "disbursements": 3326427.62,
            "cash_on_hand": 1234692.45,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Open seat"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-12",
      "office": "United States Representative District 12",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "12"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jamie-joyce",
          "name": "Jamie Joyce",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Nonprofit Executive Director",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 28372,
            "vote_share": 0.156,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA12209/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA12209",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 31247.25,
            "disbursements": 22446.95,
            "cash_on_hand": 8800.3,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "lateefah-simon",
          "name": "Lateefah Simon",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 153190,
            "vote_share": 0.8424,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "No FEC committee totals matched this candidate."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-13",
      "office": "United States Representative District 13",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "13"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "adam-gray",
          "name": "Adam Gray",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative/Educator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 41086,
            "vote_share": 0.4197,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA13115/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA13115",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 4192448.14,
            "disbursements": 2312294.67,
            "cash_on_hand": 2072111.19,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "kevin-lincoln",
          "name": "Kevin Lincoln",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 27157,
            "vote_share": 0.2774,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA09093/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA09093",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 2237083.78,
            "disbursements": 1423322.68,
            "cash_on_hand": 837885.23,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-14",
      "office": "United States Representative District 14",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "14"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "melissa-hernandez",
          "name": "Melissa Hernandez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Healthcare Services Director",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 26579,
            "vote_share": 0.1718,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA14163/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA14163",
            "as_of": "2026-09-07",
            "receipts": 1990728.52,
            "disbursements": 1910152.64,
            "cash_on_hand": 80575.88,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Open seat"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "aisha-wahab",
          "name": "Aisha Wahab",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 59238,
            "vote_share": 0.3828,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H0CA15213/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H0CA15213",
            "as_of": "2026-09-07",
            "receipts": 874397.73,
            "disbursements": 641473.16,
            "cash_on_hand": 232924.57,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Open seat"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-15",
      "office": "United States Representative District 15",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "15"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "kevin-mullin",
          "name": "Kevin Mullin",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 107496,
            "vote_share": 0.6503,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA14162/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA14162",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 819661.88,
            "disbursements": 651698.03,
            "cash_on_hand": 219735.09,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "charles-hoelter",
          "name": "Charles Hoelter",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Training Supervisor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 30476,
            "vote_share": 0.1844,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA15194/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA15194",
            "as_of": null,
            "receipts": 0.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 0.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-16",
      "office": "United States Representative District 16",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "16"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sam-liccardo",
          "name": "Sam Liccardo",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 139399,
            "vote_share": 0.7561,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA16197/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA16197",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 3489297.65,
            "disbursements": 1426732.34,
            "cash_on_hand": 2152957.41,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "peter-sundin-soule",
          "name": "Peter Sundin Soulé",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Investor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 19841,
            "vote_share": 0.1076,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA16176/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA16176",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 400.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 400.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-17",
      "office": "United States Representative District 17",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "17"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ro-khanna",
          "name": "Ro Khanna",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Congressmember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 83051,
            "vote_share": 0.623,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA12055/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA12055",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 13761490.91,
            "disbursements": 7540830.12,
            "cash_on_hand": 16929752.19,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "ritesh-tandon",
          "name": "Ritesh Tandon",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "CEO/Entrepreneur/Researcher",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 19793,
            "vote_share": 0.1485,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H0CA17193/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H0CA17193",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 37653.48,
            "disbursements": 36762.76,
            "cash_on_hand": 890.72,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-18",
      "office": "United States Representative District 18",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "18"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "zoe-lofgren",
          "name": "Zoe Lofgren",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Congresswoman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 65291,
            "vote_share": 0.5486,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA16049/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA16049",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1721916.01,
            "disbursements": 1318327.45,
            "cash_on_hand": 643340.91,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "shane-lewis",
          "name": "Shane Lewis",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Electrical Test Engineer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 34883,
            "vote_share": 0.2931,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA18172/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA18172",
            "as_of": "2026-09-30",
            "receipts": 107048.56,
            "disbursements": 103699.32,
            "cash_on_hand": 3349.24,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-19",
      "office": "United States Representative District 19",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "19"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jimmy-panetta",
          "name": "Jimmy Panetta",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 127294,
            "vote_share": 0.5843,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA20152/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA20152",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 2887609.62,
            "disbursements": 1492690.44,
            "cash_on_hand": 5109557.79,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "peter-coe-verbica",
          "name": "Peter Coe Verbica",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 44590,
            "vote_share": 0.2047,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA19154/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA19154",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 76324.0,
            "disbursements": 51642.41,
            "cash_on_hand": 24681.59,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-20",
      "office": "United States Representative District 20",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "20"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sandra-van-scotter",
          "name": "Sandra Van Scotter",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Disability Community Advocate",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 48611,
            "vote_share": 0.288,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "No FEC committee totals matched this candidate."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "vince-fong",
          "name": "Vince Fong",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 115035,
            "vote_share": 0.6816,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA20181/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA20181",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1849356.3,
            "disbursements": 1434838.05,
            "cash_on_hand": 453749.65,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-21",
      "office": "United States Representative District 21",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "21"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jim-costa",
          "name": "Jim Costa",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Farmer/Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 43461,
            "vote_share": 0.4223,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA20082/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA20082",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1338630.34,
            "disbursements": 608733.94,
            "cash_on_hand": 938778.5,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "kyle-kirkland",
          "name": "Kyle Kirkland",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Entrepreneur/Nonprofit CEO",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 27076,
            "vote_share": 0.2631,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA13199/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA13199",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 338970.81,
            "disbursements": 321036.88,
            "cash_on_hand": 17933.93,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-22",
      "office": "United States Representative District 22",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "22"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "randy-villegas",
          "name": "Randy Villegas",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Teacher/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 25808,
            "vote_share": 0.3236,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA22190/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA22190",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 2645565.53,
            "disbursements": 2073773.21,
            "cash_on_hand": 571792.32,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "david-g-valadao",
          "name": "David G. Valadao",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Congressman/Dairy Farmer",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 32491,
            "vote_share": 0.4074,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA20094/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA20094",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 4927601.63,
            "disbursements": 1607549.91,
            "cash_on_hand": 3365587.25,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-23",
      "office": "United States Representative District 23",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "23"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "tessa-lynn-hodge",
          "name": "Tessa Lynn Hodge",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Social Worker/Businesswoman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 30292,
            "vote_share": 0.2125,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA23230/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA23230",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 79499.12,
            "disbursements": 69261.97,
            "cash_on_hand": 10237.15,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jay-obernolte",
          "name": "Jay Obernolte",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Congressman/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 81346,
            "vote_share": 0.5708,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H0CA08135/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H0CA08135",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1455867.71,
            "disbursements": 809485.78,
            "cash_on_hand": 1644221.69,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-24",
      "office": "United States Representative District 24",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "24"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "salud-carbajal",
          "name": "Salud Carbajal",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of Congress",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 113716,
            "vote_share": 0.5436,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA24303/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA24303",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1650355.41,
            "disbursements": 910621.09,
            "cash_on_hand": 3383603.83,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "bob-smith",
          "name": "Bob Smith",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Defense Systems Engineer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 75085,
            "vote_share": 0.3589,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA24345/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA24345",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 203264.29,
            "disbursements": 156136.18,
            "cash_on_hand": 47128.11,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-25",
      "office": "United States Representative District 25",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "25"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "raul-ruiz",
          "name": "Raul Ruiz",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Emergency Physician/Congressman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 88699,
            "vote_share": 0.6001,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA36439/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA36439",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 2093907.02,
            "disbursements": 1240151.98,
            "cash_on_hand": 2556494.44,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "joe-males",
          "name": "Joe Males",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Mayor Pro Tem",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 27927,
            "vote_share": 0.1889,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA25219/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA25219",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 936496.34,
            "disbursements": 921649.38,
            "cash_on_hand": 14846.96,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-26",
      "office": "United States Representative District 26",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "26"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jacqui-irwin",
          "name": "Jacqui Irwin",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 79790,
            "vote_share": 0.4129,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA26266/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA26266",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 822382.31,
            "disbursements": 526903.83,
            "cash_on_hand": 295478.48,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Open seat"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "sam-gallucci",
          "name": "Sam Gallucci",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Business Executive/Pastor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 40334,
            "vote_share": 0.2087,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA26241/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA26241",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 377077.94,
            "disbursements": 343397.33,
            "cash_on_hand": 33680.61,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Open seat"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-27",
      "office": "United States Representative District 27",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "27"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "george-whitesides",
          "name": "George Whitesides",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative/Father",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 62214,
            "vote_share": 0.4063,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA27111/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA27111",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 3963530.22,
            "disbursements": 1735346.94,
            "cash_on_hand": 2554916.64,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jason-gibbs",
          "name": "Jason Gibbs",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "City Councilmember/Engineer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 62758,
            "vote_share": 0.4098,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA27306/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA27306",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 379439.88,
            "disbursements": 177562.84,
            "cash_on_hand": 201877.04,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-28",
      "office": "United States Representative District 28",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "28"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "judy-chu",
          "name": "Judy Chu",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 116321,
            "vote_share": 0.6223,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H0CA32101/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H0CA32101",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 930123.25,
            "disbursements": 857831.85,
            "cash_on_hand": 3674296.35,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "april-a-verlato",
          "name": "April A. Verlato",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 60020,
            "vote_share": 0.3211,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA28127/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA28127",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 250.0,
            "disbursements": 7882.46,
            "cash_on_hand": 205.19,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-29",
      "office": "United States Representative District 29",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "29"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "angelica-maria-duenas",
          "name": "Angélica María Dueñas",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Mother/Community Organizer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 30469,
            "vote_share": 0.2493,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H8CA29100/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H8CA29100",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 37153.03,
            "disbursements": 33707.28,
            "cash_on_hand": 3349.48,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "luz-maria-rivas",
          "name": "Luz Maria Rivas",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Congresswoman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 62385,
            "vote_share": 0.5104,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA29141/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA29141",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 670678.01,
            "disbursements": 557465.01,
            "cash_on_hand": 377476.23,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-30",
      "office": "United States Representative District 30",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "30"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "laura-friedman",
          "name": "Laura Friedman",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member, United States House of Representatives",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 102384,
            "vote_share": 0.5268,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA30149/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA30149",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 827895.09,
            "disbursements": 655389.44,
            "cash_on_hand": 469253.89,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "scott-alan-meyers",
          "name": "Scott Alan Meyers",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 32216,
            "vote_share": 0.1658,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA30250/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA30250",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 58294.0,
            "disbursements": 55677.87,
            "cash_on_hand": 2616.13,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-31",
      "office": "United States Representative District 31",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "31"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "gil-cisneros",
          "name": "Gil Cisneros",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Congressman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 94805,
            "vote_share": 0.6106,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H8CA39174/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H8CA39174",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 705263.13,
            "disbursements": 485535.59,
            "cash_on_hand": 259803.37,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "eric-ching",
          "name": "Eric Ching",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Entrepreneur",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 36999,
            "vote_share": 0.2383,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA39151/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA39151",
            "as_of": "2026-09-30",
            "receipts": 96569.8,
            "disbursements": 122507.96,
            "cash_on_hand": 14302.41,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-32",
      "office": "United States Representative District 32",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "32"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "brad-sherman",
          "name": "Brad Sherman",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Congressman/Dad",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 76755,
            "vote_share": 0.3677,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA24113/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA24113",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 2514329.68,
            "disbursements": 3767794.41,
            "cash_on_hand": 2668479.97,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "larry-thompson",
          "name": "Larry Thompson",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Attorney/Film Producer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 68295,
            "vote_share": 0.3272,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA32137/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA32137",
            "as_of": "2026-09-30",
            "receipts": 52881.34,
            "disbursements": 51926.25,
            "cash_on_hand": 955.09,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-33",
      "office": "United States Representative District 33",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "33"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "pete-aguilar",
          "name": "Pete Aguilar",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 64068,
            "vote_share": 0.5354,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA31125/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA31125",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 4722834.83,
            "disbursements": 3914264.13,
            "cash_on_hand": 3457641.87,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "stephanie-m-vargas",
          "name": "Stephanie M. Vargas",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Chief Deputy Clerk",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 20952,
            "vote_share": 0.1751,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA33114/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA33114",
            "as_of": null,
            "receipts": 0.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 0.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-34",
      "office": "United States Representative District 34",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "34"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jimmy-gomez",
          "name": "Jimmy Gomez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative/Parent",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 54993,
            "vote_share": 0.4599,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H8CA34266/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H8CA34266",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1175128.2,
            "disbursements": 482161.47,
            "cash_on_hand": 781725.64,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "angela-gonzales-torres",
          "name": "Angela Gonzales-Torres",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Advocate For Justice",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 36708,
            "vote_share": 0.307,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "No FEC committee totals matched this candidate."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-35",
      "office": "United States Representative District 35",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "35"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "norma-j-torres",
          "name": "Norma J. Torres",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 76029,
            "vote_share": 0.5954,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA35031/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA35031",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 769060.59,
            "disbursements": 733128.45,
            "cash_on_hand": 339247.17,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "mike-cargile",
          "name": "Mike Cargile",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 51641,
            "vote_share": 0.4044,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H0CA35146/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H0CA35146",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 4759.0,
            "disbursements": 2356.76,
            "cash_on_hand": 2873.01,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-36",
      "office": "United States Representative District 36",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "36"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ted-w-lieu",
          "name": "Ted W. Lieu",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative, 36th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 142982,
            "vote_share": 0.6094,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA33119/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA33119",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1832768.92,
            "disbursements": 1319376.98,
            "cash_on_hand": 1188398.69,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "houston-brignano",
          "name": "Houston Brignano",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Technology Executive",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 35851,
            "vote_share": 0.1528,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA36208/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA36208",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 5139.13,
            "disbursements": 4337.84,
            "cash_on_hand": 801.29,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-37",
      "office": "United States Representative District 37",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "37"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sydney-kamlager-dove",
          "name": "Sydney Kamlager-Dove",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative, 37th District",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 70990,
            "vote_share": 0.5518,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "No FEC committee totals matched this candidate."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "samantha-mota",
          "name": "Samantha Mota",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Community Advocate",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 15019,
            "vote_share": 0.1167,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA37339/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA37339",
            "as_of": "2026-09-30",
            "receipts": 11408.93,
            "disbursements": 11193.64,
            "cash_on_hand": 208.29,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-38",
      "office": "United States Representative District 38",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "38"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "hilda-solis",
          "name": "Hilda Solis",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "County Supervisor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 65369,
            "vote_share": 0.4762,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA38139/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA38139",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1049534.17,
            "disbursements": 895031.39,
            "cash_on_hand": 154502.78,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "pedro-antonio-casas",
          "name": "Pedro Antonio Casas",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "No Ballot Designation",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 49196,
            "vote_share": 0.3584,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA31212/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA31212",
            "as_of": null,
            "receipts": 0.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 0.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-39",
      "office": "United States Representative District 39",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "39"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mark-takano",
          "name": "Mark Takano",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Congressman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 75467,
            "vote_share": 0.6104,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA43245/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA43245",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 893848.27,
            "disbursements": 976794.27,
            "cash_on_hand": 186223.88,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "steve-manos",
          "name": "Steve Manos",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Mayor/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 48177,
            "vote_share": 0.3896,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA39145/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA39145",
            "as_of": null,
            "receipts": 0.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 0.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-40",
      "office": "United States Representative District 40",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "40"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ken-calvert",
          "name": "Ken Calvert",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 75811,
            "vote_share": 0.3489,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA37023/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA37023",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 6142469.38,
            "disbursements": 4907603.65,
            "cash_on_hand": 1497001.34,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "young-kim",
          "name": "Young Kim",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative, 40th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 44818,
            "vote_share": 0.2063,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H8CA39240/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H8CA39240",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 8837238.63,
            "disbursements": 8893141.93,
            "cash_on_hand": 1680489.97,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-41",
      "office": "United States Representative District 41",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "41"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "linda-sanchez",
          "name": "Linda Sánchez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Congresswoman/Mom",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 61651,
            "vote_share": 0.3751,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA39078/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA39078",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1602789.55,
            "disbursements": 1612831.35,
            "cash_on_hand": 415745.67,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "mitch-clemmons",
          "name": "Mitch Clemmons",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Plumbing Contractor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 58785,
            "vote_share": 0.3577,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "No FEC committee totals matched this candidate."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-42",
      "office": "United States Representative District 42",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "42"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "robert-garcia",
          "name": "Robert Garcia",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Congressman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 114942,
            "vote_share": 0.5647,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA47188/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA47188",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 2615120.28,
            "disbursements": 1646080.73,
            "cash_on_hand": 1381467.45,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "brian-burley",
          "name": "Brian Burley",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Trustee, Huntington Beach City School District",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 41919,
            "vote_share": 0.206,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H0CA48172/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H0CA48172",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 231370.76,
            "disbursements": 231639.1,
            "cash_on_hand": 5508.52,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-43",
      "office": "United States Representative District 43",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "43"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "maxine-waters",
          "name": "Maxine Waters",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Congresswoman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 75693,
            "vote_share": 0.6379,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA23011/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA23011",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 863682.82,
            "disbursements": 710470.47,
            "cash_on_hand": 269668.83,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "cristian-morales",
          "name": "Cristian Morales",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Manufacturing Executive",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 20009,
            "vote_share": 0.1686,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA43188/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA43188",
            "as_of": null,
            "receipts": 0.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 0.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-44",
      "office": "United States Representative District 44",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "44"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "nanette-diaz-barragan",
          "name": "Nanette Diaz Barragan",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative, 44th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 84690,
            "vote_share": 0.7701,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA44103/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA44103",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 785765.2,
            "disbursements": 1178896.16,
            "cash_on_hand": 1088422.95,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "genevieve-angel",
          "name": "Genevieve Angel",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Family Nurse Practitioner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 25276,
            "vote_share": 0.2298,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA44210/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA44210",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 13897.97,
            "disbursements": 5151.68,
            "cash_on_hand": 8746.29,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-45",
      "office": "United States Representative District 45",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "45"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "derek-tran",
          "name": "Derek Tran",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Representative/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 86184,
            "vote_share": 0.5376,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA45170/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA45170",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 4981276.64,
            "disbursements": 2051201.75,
            "cash_on_hand": 3257397.68,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "chuong-v-vo",
          "name": "Chuong V. Vo",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Police Officer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 24591,
            "vote_share": 0.1534,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA45191/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA45191",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 495762.84,
            "disbursements": 420886.99,
            "cash_on_hand": 74875.85,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-46",
      "office": "United States Representative District 46",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "46"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "lou-correa",
          "name": "Lou Correa",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Congressmember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 61587,
            "vote_share": 0.5194,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA46116/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA46116",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1226103.73,
            "disbursements": 613912.12,
            "cash_on_hand": 2479554.24,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "david-pan",
          "name": "David Pan",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Professor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 38993,
            "vote_share": 0.3288,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA46137/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA46137",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 80725.51,
            "disbursements": 77368.17,
            "cash_on_hand": 6237.67,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-47",
      "office": "United States Representative District 47",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "47"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "dave-min",
          "name": "Dave Min",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "United States Representative/Father",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 89515,
            "vote_share": 0.4545,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H4CA47085/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H4CA47085",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 3381161.06,
            "disbursements": 1664867.18,
            "cash_on_hand": 1889359.66,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jenny-rae-le-roux",
          "name": "Jenny Rae Le Roux",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Entrepreneur/Investor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 49231,
            "vote_share": 0.25,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "No FEC committee totals matched this candidate."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-48",
      "office": "United States Representative District 48",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "48"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "marni-von-wilpert",
          "name": "Marni von Wilpert",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilwoman/Health Advocate",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 39327,
            "vote_share": 0.2081,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "No FEC committee totals matched this candidate."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jim-desmond",
          "name": "Jim Desmond",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "San Diego County Supervisor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 73508,
            "vote_share": 0.389,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA49128/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA49128",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 2258835.81,
            "disbursements": 1028804.49,
            "cash_on_hand": 1230031.32,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Open seat"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-49",
      "office": "United States Representative District 49",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "49"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mike-levin",
          "name": "Mike Levin",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative, 49th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 125869,
            "vote_share": 0.5585,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H8CA49058/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H8CA49058",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 3164023.36,
            "disbursements": 2015523.36,
            "cash_on_hand": 1418236.98,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "armen-kurdian",
          "name": "Armen Kurdian",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Navy Captain",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 58822,
            "vote_share": 0.261,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA49169/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA49169",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 58783.73,
            "disbursements": 40867.3,
            "cash_on_hand": 17916.43,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-50",
      "office": "United States Representative District 50",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "50"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "scott-peters",
          "name": "Scott Peters",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of Congress",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 102057,
            "vote_share": 0.4815,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA52089/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA52089",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 1810961.02,
            "disbursements": 1363206.09,
            "cash_on_hand": 2598275.74,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "steve-cohen",
          "name": "Steve Cohen",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Television News Consultant",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 84340,
            "vote_share": 0.3979,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA50324/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA50324",
            "as_of": null,
            "receipts": 0.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 0.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-51",
      "office": "United States Representative District 51",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "51"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sara-jacobs",
          "name": "Sara Jacobs",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "U.S. Representative",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 111765,
            "vote_share": 0.5774,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "No FEC committee totals matched this candidate."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "ricardo-cabrera",
          "name": "Ricardo Cabrera",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 71692,
            "vote_share": 0.3704,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA51140/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA51140",
            "as_of": null,
            "receipts": 0.0,
            "disbursements": 0.0,
            "cash_on_hand": 0.0,
            "incumbent_challenge": null
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "us-house-cd-52",
      "office": "United States Representative District 52",
      "office_level": "federal",
      "district": {
        "kind": "cd",
        "id": "52"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "juan-vargas",
          "name": "Juan Vargas",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of Congress",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 71608,
            "vote_share": 0.5648,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H2CA50026/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H2CA50026",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 568519.67,
            "disbursements": 495684.42,
            "cash_on_hand": 163675.89,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Incumbent"
          }
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jeff-belle",
          "name": "Jeff Belle",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 42090,
            "vote_share": 0.332,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "FEC candidate page",
              "url": "https://www.fec.gov/data/candidate/H6CA52163/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": {
            "source": "FEC",
            "source_key": "fec:house-totals:1",
            "fec_candidate_id": "H6CA52163",
            "as_of": "2026-06-30",
            "receipts": 25498.1,
            "disbursements": 24134.18,
            "cash_on_hand": 1363.92,
            "incumbent_challenge": "Challenger"
          }
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
        "fec:house-totals:1"
      ],
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-2",
      "office": "State Senate District 2",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "damon-connolly",
          "name": "Damon Connolly",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 232240,
            "vote_share": 0.7338,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "tief-gibbs",
          "name": "Tief Gibbs",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Businesswoman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 51149,
            "vote_share": 0.1616,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-4",
      "office": "State Senate District 4",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jaron-brandon",
          "name": "Jaron Brandon",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "County Supervisor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 109094,
            "vote_share": 0.4133,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "alexandra-duarte",
          "name": "Alexandra Duarte",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Mother/Farmer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 84630,
            "vote_share": 0.3206,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-6",
      "office": "State Senate District 6",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "6"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sean-frame",
          "name": "Sean Frame",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 81323,
            "vote_share": 0.285,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "roger-niello",
          "name": "Roger Niello",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Senator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 160336,
            "vote_share": 0.5619,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-8",
      "office": "State Senate District 8",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "8"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "angelique-ashby",
          "name": "Angelique Ashby",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Senator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 138974,
            "vote_share": 0.681,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "susan-a-mason",
          "name": "Susan A Mason",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Nurse",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 55573,
            "vote_share": 0.2723,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-10",
      "office": "State Senate District 10",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "10"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "scott-sakakihara",
          "name": "Scott Sakakihara",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilmember/Navy Officer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 52762,
            "vote_share": 0.2908,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "linda-r-price",
          "name": "Linda R. Price",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Businesswoman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 42079,
            "vote_share": 0.232,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-12",
      "office": "State Senate District 12",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "12"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "nathan-magsig",
          "name": "Nathan Magsig",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "County Supervisor/Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 122702,
            "vote_share": 0.5949,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "william-brown-jr",
          "name": "William Brown Jr.",
          "party_preference": "Libertarian",
          "ballot_designation": "Social Worker/Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 54728,
            "vote_share": 0.2653,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-14",
      "office": "State Senate District 14",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "14"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "esmeralda-soria",
          "name": "Esmeralda Soria",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 59522,
            "vote_share": 0.4582,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "darin-s-dupont",
          "name": "Darin S. DuPont",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilman/Water Attorney",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 52440,
            "vote_share": 0.4037,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-16",
      "office": "State Senate District 16",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "16"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "melissa-hurtado",
          "name": "Melissa Hurtado",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 38123,
            "vote_share": 0.3561,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "guillermo-asuncion-gonzalez",
          "name": "Guillermo Asuncion Gonzalez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 48434,
            "vote_share": 0.4524,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-18",
      "office": "State Senate District 18",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "18"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "steve-padilla",
          "name": "Steve Padilla",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Senator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 102089,
            "vote_share": 0.6384,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "art-hodges",
          "name": "Art Hodges",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "CEO/Educator/Pastor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 57835,
            "vote_share": 0.3616,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-20",
      "office": "State Senate District 20",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "20"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "caroline-menjivar",
          "name": "Caroline Menjivar",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 97191,
            "vote_share": 0.6205,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "tony-rodriguez",
          "name": "Tony Rodriguez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "No Ballot Designation",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 43622,
            "vote_share": 0.2785,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-22",
      "office": "State Senate District 22",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "22"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "susan-rubio",
          "name": "Susan Rubio",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator/Teacher",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 107472,
            "vote_share": 0.623,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "mike-netter",
          "name": "Mike Netter",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 59749,
            "vote_share": 0.3464,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-24",
      "office": "State Senate District 24",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "24"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "john-m-erickson",
          "name": "John M. Erickson",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilmember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 62397,
            "vote_share": 0.205,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "brian-goldsmith",
          "name": "Brian Goldsmith",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 55627,
            "vote_share": 0.1828,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-26",
      "office": "State Senate District 26",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "26"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sara-hernandez",
          "name": "Sara Hernandez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Affordable Housing Advocate",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 54799,
            "vote_share": 0.3117,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "sarah-rascon",
          "name": "Sarah Rascón",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Environmental Protection Director",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 34158,
            "vote_share": 0.1943,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-28",
      "office": "State Senate District 28",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "28"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "lola-smallwood-cuevas",
          "name": "Lola Smallwood-Cuevas",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 151178,
            "vote_share": 0.7751,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "joe-lisuzzo",
          "name": "Joe Lisuzzo",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "LA Neighborhood Councilmember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 31606,
            "vote_share": 0.162,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-30",
      "office": "State Senate District 30",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "30"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "bob-j-archuleta",
          "name": "Bob J. Archuleta",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 124926,
            "vote_share": 0.6511,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "araceli-martinez",
          "name": "Araceli Martinez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 66945,
            "vote_share": 0.3489,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-32",
      "office": "State Senate District 32",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "32"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "tiffanie-tate",
          "name": "Tiffanie Tate",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Doctor/Educator/Author",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 105870,
            "vote_share": 0.4183,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "kelly-seyarto",
          "name": "Kelly Seyarto",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 147211,
            "vote_share": 0.5817,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-34",
      "office": "State Senate District 34",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "34"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "avelino-valencia",
          "name": "Avelino Valencia",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 92826,
            "vote_share": 0.6519,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "rhonda-shader",
          "name": "Rhonda Shader",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Local Small Businesswoman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 49569,
            "vote_share": 0.3481,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-36",
      "office": "State Senate District 36",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "36"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "chris-duncan",
          "name": "Chris Duncan",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Anti-Tariff Attorney",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 126952,
            "vote_share": 0.4657,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "tony-strickland",
          "name": "Tony Strickland",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "State Senator/Businessman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 145638,
            "vote_share": 0.5343,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-38",
      "office": "State Senate District 38",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "38"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "catherine-s-blakespear",
          "name": "Catherine S. Blakespear",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Senator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 155938,
            "vote_share": 0.5471,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "laura-bassett",
          "name": "Laura Bassett",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 129078,
            "vote_share": 0.4529,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-senate-sd-40",
      "office": "State Senate District 40",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "sd",
        "id": "40"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mara-elliott",
          "name": "Mara Elliott",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Ethics Attorney",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 125669,
            "vote_share": 0.4795,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "kristie-bruce-lane",
          "name": "Kristie Bruce-Lane",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Businesswoman/Victims Advocate",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 72709,
            "vote_share": 0.2774,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-1",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 1",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "dianna-margaret-james",
          "name": "Dianna Margaret James",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Community Organizer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 63056,
            "vote_share": 0.3849,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "heather-hadwick",
          "name": "Heather Hadwick",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Farmer/Assemblywoman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 79748,
            "vote_share": 0.4868,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-2",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 2",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "chris-rogers",
          "name": "Chris Rogers",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 107900,
            "vote_share": 0.6973,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "michael-greer",
          "name": "Michael Greer",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Teacher",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 46846,
            "vote_share": 0.3027,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-3",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 3",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "dom-belza",
          "name": "Dom Belza",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Agricultural Businessman/Father",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 46076,
            "vote_share": 0.452,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "james-jamie-johansson",
          "name": "James \"Jamie\" Johansson",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Farmer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 29828,
            "vote_share": 0.2926,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-4",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 4",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "cecilia-m-aguiar-curry",
          "name": "Cecilia M. Aguiar-Curry",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 90380,
            "vote_share": 1.0,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-5",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 5",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "5"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "neva-parker",
          "name": "Neva Parker",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Community Advocate",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 72855,
            "vote_share": 0.3991,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "joe-patterson",
          "name": "Joe Patterson",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of State Assembly, 5th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 109708,
            "vote_share": 0.6009,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-6",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 6",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "6"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "maggy-krell",
          "name": "Maggy Krell",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Constitutional Attorney/Assemblywoman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 83563,
            "vote_share": 0.8587,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jagtar-singh",
          "name": "Jagtar Singh",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Caregiver/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 13752,
            "vote_share": 0.1413,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-7",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 7",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "7"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "amy-l-slavensky",
          "name": "Amy L. Slavensky",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Public School Educator",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 60513,
            "vote_share": 0.4715,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "josh-hoover",
          "name": "Josh Hoover",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of the State Assembly, 7th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 65279,
            "vote_share": 0.5086,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-8",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 8",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "8"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "david-jariustokaeutulelei-tangipa",
          "name": "David Jariustokaeutulelei Tangipa",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 103817,
            "vote_share": 1.0,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-9",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 9",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "9"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "matthew-adams",
          "name": "Matthew Adams",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Teacher",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 28522,
            "vote_share": 0.2588,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "heath-flora",
          "name": "Heath Flora",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Father/Farmer/Assemblyman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 33684,
            "vote_share": 0.3057,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-10",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 10",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "10"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "stephanie-nguyen",
          "name": "Stephanie Nguyen",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 75220,
            "vote_share": 0.7173,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "vinaya-singh",
          "name": "Vinaya Singh",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Application Developer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 29645,
            "vote_share": 0.2827,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-11",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 11",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "11"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "lori-d-wilson",
          "name": "Lori D Wilson",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember, 11th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 72397,
            "vote_share": 0.6532,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jenny-leilani-callison",
          "name": "Jenny Leilani Callison",
          "party_preference": "No Party Preference",
          "ballot_designation": "Legislative Consultant",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 26106,
            "vote_share": 0.2355,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-12",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 12",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "12"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jackie-elward",
          "name": "Jackie Elward",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilwoman/Educator",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 36196,
            "vote_share": 0.2258,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "eric-lucan",
          "name": "Eric Lucan",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "County Supervisor/Father",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 45350,
            "vote_share": 0.2828,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-13",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 13",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "13"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "rhodesia-ransom",
          "name": "Rhodesia Ransom",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 40088,
            "vote_share": 0.5828,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "tom-patti",
          "name": "Tom Patti",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Businessman/Father",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 24282,
            "vote_share": 0.353,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-14",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 14",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "14"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "buffy-wicks",
          "name": "Buffy Wicks",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember/Mom",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 105311,
            "vote_share": 0.8124,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "mark-rendon",
          "name": "Mark Rendon",
          "party_preference": "Green",
          "ballot_designation": "Teacher",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 12939,
            "vote_share": 0.0998,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-15",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 15",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "15"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "anamarie-avila-farias",
          "name": "Anamarie Avila Farias",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of the State Assembly, District 15",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 78693,
            "vote_share": 0.6959,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "arthur-webb",
          "name": "Arthur Webb",
          "party_preference": "No Party Preference",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Technology Manager",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 34390,
            "vote_share": 0.3041,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-16",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 16",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "16"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "rebecca-bauer-kahan",
          "name": "Rebecca Bauer-Kahan",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember/Mother",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 101017,
            "vote_share": 0.6562,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "joseph-a-rubay",
          "name": "Joseph A. Rubay",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Businessman/Father",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 47142,
            "vote_share": 0.3062,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-17",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 17",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "17"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "matt-haney",
          "name": "Matt Haney",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 106260,
            "vote_share": 0.9943,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "manuel-noris-barrera",
          "name": "Manuel Noris-Barrera",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "No Ballot Designation",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 468,
            "vote_share": 0.0044,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-18",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 18",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "18"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mia-bonta",
          "name": "Mia Bonta",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember, Assembly District 18",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 84226,
            "vote_share": 0.769,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "andre-sandford",
          "name": "Andre Sandford",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Housing Program Director",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 11918,
            "vote_share": 0.1088,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-19",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 19",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "19"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "catherine-stefani",
          "name": "Catherine Stefani",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 108403,
            "vote_share": 0.8303,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "philip-louis-wing",
          "name": "Philip Louis Wing",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Financial Advisor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 22149,
            "vote_share": 0.1697,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-20",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 20",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "20"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "liz-ortega",
          "name": "Liz Ortega",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 76306,
            "vote_share": 0.7513,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "patricia-muga",
          "name": "Patricia Muga",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Real Estate Appraiser",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 25262,
            "vote_share": 0.2487,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-21",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 21",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "21"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "diane-papan",
          "name": "Diane Papan",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 91401,
            "vote_share": 0.7874,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jabra-j-muhawieh",
          "name": "Jabra J Muhawieh",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Enrolled Agent/Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 24681,
            "vote_share": 0.2126,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-22",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 22",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "22"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "juan-alanis",
          "name": "Juan Alanis",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblyman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 51246,
            "vote_share": 1.0,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-23",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 23",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "23"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "marc-berman",
          "name": "Marc Berman",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 96074,
            "vote_share": 0.7733,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "david-g-johnson",
          "name": "David G. Johnson",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 18170,
            "vote_share": 0.1462,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-24",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 24",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "24"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "alex-lee",
          "name": "Alex Lee",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 55856,
            "vote_share": 0.6538,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "max-hsia",
          "name": "Max Hsia",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 21339,
            "vote_share": 0.2498,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-25",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 25",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "25"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ash-kalra",
          "name": "Ash Kalra",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 56052,
            "vote_share": 0.7218,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "himat-singh-bainiwal",
          "name": "Himat Singh Bainiwal",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Attorney",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 21609,
            "vote_share": 0.2782,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-26",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 26",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "26"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "patrick-ahrens",
          "name": "Patrick Ahrens",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 60368,
            "vote_share": 0.7543,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "tim-gorsulowsky",
          "name": "Tim Gorsulowsky",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 19664,
            "vote_share": 0.2457,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-27",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 27",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "27"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "brian-pacheco",
          "name": "Brian Pacheco",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "County Supervisor/Farmer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 29581,
            "vote_share": 0.4033,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "mike-murphy",
          "name": "Mike Murphy",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 31802,
            "vote_share": 0.4336,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-28",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 28",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "28"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "gail-pellerin",
          "name": "Gail Pellerin",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 94902,
            "vote_share": 0.7198,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "carol-pefley",
          "name": "Carol Pefley",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 36949,
            "vote_share": 0.2802,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-29",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 29",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "29"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "robert-rivas",
          "name": "Robert Rivas",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California Assembly Speaker",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 53157,
            "vote_share": 0.6647,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "dennis-p-sanchez",
          "name": "Dennis P. Sanchez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Businessman/Father",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 14444,
            "vote_share": 0.1806,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-30",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 30",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "30"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "dawn-addis",
          "name": "Dawn Addis",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember/Teacher",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 83505,
            "vote_share": 0.548,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "shannon-kessler",
          "name": "Shannon Kessler",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Children's Advocate/Businesswoman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 54649,
            "vote_share": 0.3587,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-31",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 31",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "31"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "annalisa-perea",
          "name": "Annalisa Perea",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "City Councilmember/Mother",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 26832,
            "vote_share": 0.4459,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jim-polsgrove",
          "name": "Jim Polsgrove",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Engineering Technician",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 20682,
            "vote_share": 0.3437,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-32",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 32",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "32"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "david-couch",
          "name": "David Couch",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Kern County Supervisor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 90040,
            "vote_share": 1.0,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-33",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 33",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "33"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "hipolito-angel-cerros",
          "name": "Hipolito Angel Cerros",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Public Policy Fellow",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 24656,
            "vote_share": 0.3877,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "alexandra-ali-macedo",
          "name": "Alexandra (Ali) Macedo",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Cattlewoman/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 38938,
            "vote_share": 0.6123,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-34",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 34",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "34"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "randall-putz",
          "name": "Randall Putz",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Mayor/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 40110,
            "vote_share": 0.3923,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "charles-frederick-hughes",
          "name": "Charles Frederick Hughes",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 37528,
            "vote_share": 0.367,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-35",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 35",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "35"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "andrae-gonzales",
          "name": "Andrae Gonzales",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilmember/Nonprofit Director",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 18338,
            "vote_share": 0.3673,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "saul-ayon",
          "name": "Saul Ayon",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Mayor/Teacher",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 18299,
            "vote_share": 0.3666,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-36",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 36",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "36"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ida-s-obeso-martinez",
          "name": "Ida S. Obeso-Martinez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Mayor/Nurse",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 19661,
            "vote_share": 0.2406,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jeff-gonzalez",
          "name": "Jeff Gonzalez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember/Father",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 36468,
            "vote_share": 0.4462,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-37",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 37",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "37"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "gregg-hart",
          "name": "Gregg Hart",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 71528,
            "vote_share": 0.6254,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "sari-domingues",
          "name": "Sari Domingues",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Business Analyst",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 42848,
            "vote_share": 0.3746,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-38",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 38",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "38"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "steve-bennett",
          "name": "Steve Bennett",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of the Assembly, 38th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 56992,
            "vote_share": 0.6942,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "michael-macdonald",
          "name": "Michael MacDonald",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "City Clerk",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 25106,
            "vote_share": 0.3058,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-39",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 39",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "39"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "juan-carrillo",
          "name": "Juan Carrillo",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 35480,
            "vote_share": 0.6233,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "paul-andre-marsh",
          "name": "Paul Andre Marsh",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Community Services Liaison",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 21439,
            "vote_share": 0.3767,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-40",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 40",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "40"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "pilar-schiavo",
          "name": "Pilar Schiavo",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 74496,
            "vote_share": 0.5563,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "rickey-tracy-hayes-ii",
          "name": "Rickey Tracy Hayes II",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Lineman/Entrepreneur/Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 29879,
            "vote_share": 0.2231,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-41",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 41",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "41"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "john-harabedian",
          "name": "John Harabedian",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 92071,
            "vote_share": 0.6332,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "adam-christopher-vena",
          "name": "Adam Christopher Vena",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Father/Sanitation Employee",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 53332,
            "vote_share": 0.3668,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-42",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 42",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "42"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "deborah-klein-lopez",
          "name": "Deborah Klein Lopez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "City Councilmember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 85368,
            "vote_share": 0.5274,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "ted-nordblum",
          "name": "Ted Nordblum",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 41522,
            "vote_share": 0.2565,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-43",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 43",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "43"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "celeste-rodriguez",
          "name": "Celeste Rodriguez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 53703,
            "vote_share": 0.749,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "ricardo-benitez",
          "name": "Ricardo Benitez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Plumber/Electrical Contractor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 17999,
            "vote_share": 0.251,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-44",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 44",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "44"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "nicholas-nick-schultz",
          "name": "Nicholas \"Nick\" Schultz",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 97191,
            "vote_share": 0.7117,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "carolyn-daniels",
          "name": "Carolyn Daniels",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Independent Contractor/Mother",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 28269,
            "vote_share": 0.207,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-45",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 45",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "45"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "james-c-ramos",
          "name": "James C. Ramos",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 44283,
            "vote_share": 0.6563,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "greg-abdouch",
          "name": "Greg Abdouch",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 23188,
            "vote_share": 0.3437,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-46",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 46",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "46"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jesse-gabriel",
          "name": "Jesse Gabriel",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of the State Assembly, 46th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 68506,
            "vote_share": 0.662,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "tracey-schroeder",
          "name": "Tracey Schroeder",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Teacher",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 34973,
            "vote_share": 0.338,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-47",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 47",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "47"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "leila-namvar",
          "name": "Leila Namvar",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Civil Servant/Mom",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 46256,
            "vote_share": 0.3235,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "greg-wallis",
          "name": "Greg Wallis",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of the State Assembly",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 68831,
            "vote_share": 0.4813,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-48",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 48",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "48"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "blanca-rubio",
          "name": "Blanca Rubio",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember/Teacher",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 59612,
            "vote_share": 0.6526,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "dan-t-tran",
          "name": "Dan T. Tran",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Real Estate Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 31738,
            "vote_share": 0.3474,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-49",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 49",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "49"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mike-fong",
          "name": "Mike Fong",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 60484,
            "vote_share": 0.6816,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "long-david-liu",
          "name": "Long David Liu",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Attorney/Father",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 28250,
            "vote_share": 0.3184,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-50",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 50",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "50"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "robert-garcia",
          "name": "Robert Garcia",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember/Educator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 44497,
            "vote_share": 0.582,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "victoria-viveros-mageno",
          "name": "Victoria Viveros Mageno",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Cucamonga School District Member Governing Board Area 1",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 29596,
            "vote_share": 0.3871,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-51",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 51",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "51"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "colin-d-hernandez",
          "name": "Colin D. Hernandez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Digital Communication Strategist",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 29026,
            "vote_share": 0.2209,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "rick-chavez-zbur",
          "name": "Rick Chavez Zbur",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 71047,
            "vote_share": 0.5407,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-52",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 52",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "52"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jessica-caloza",
          "name": "Jessica Caloza",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 95743,
            "vote_share": 0.8576,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "andrea-lee-anderson",
          "name": "Andrea Lee Anderson",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "No Ballot Designation",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 15895,
            "vote_share": 0.1424,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-53",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 53",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "53"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "michelle-rodriguez",
          "name": "Michelle Rodriguez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember/Mom",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 45994,
            "vote_share": 0.6231,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "rafaela-romero",
          "name": "Rafaela Romero",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Special Education Aide",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 27823,
            "vote_share": 0.3769,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-54",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 54",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "54"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mark-gonzalez",
          "name": "Mark Gonzalez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of the State Assembly",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 48751,
            "vote_share": 0.9972,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "alexandra-briseno",
          "name": "Alexandra Briseno",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "No Ballot Designation",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 137,
            "vote_share": 0.0028,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-55",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 55",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "55"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ashley-m-brown",
          "name": "Ashley M. Brown",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "School Social Worker",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 23242,
            "vote_share": 0.189,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "isaac-g-bryan",
          "name": "Isaac G. Bryan",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 79396,
            "vote_share": 0.6455,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-56",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 56",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "56"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "lisa-calderon",
          "name": "Lisa Calderon",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assembly Member/Mom",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 60224,
            "vote_share": 0.6411,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "jessica-martinez",
          "name": "Jessica Martinez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Teacher",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 33711,
            "vote_share": 0.3589,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-57",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 57",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "57"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sade-elhawary",
          "name": "Sade Elhawary",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 40160,
            "vote_share": 0.857,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "constance-jewel-menzies",
          "name": "Constance Jewel Menzies",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "In-Home Care Provider",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 6701,
            "vote_share": 0.143,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-58",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 58",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "58"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "clarissa-cervantes",
          "name": "Clarissa Cervantes",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilmember/Businesswoman/Mother",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 45598,
            "vote_share": 0.5454,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "leticia-castillo",
          "name": "Leticia Castillo",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblywoman/Licensed Psychotherapist",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 38002,
            "vote_share": 0.4546,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-59",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 59",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "59"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "phillip-chen",
          "name": "Phillip Chen",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblyman/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 83929,
            "vote_share": 0.6629,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "victor-hernandez",
          "name": "Victor Hernandez",
          "party_preference": "Green",
          "ballot_designation": "Account Sales Manager",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 42685,
            "vote_share": 0.3371,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-60",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 60",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "60"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "corey-a-jackson",
          "name": "Corey A Jackson",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assembly Member",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 40189,
            "vote_share": 0.598,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "ed-delgado",
          "name": "Ed Delgado",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "City Council Member",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 16898,
            "vote_share": 0.2514,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-61",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 61",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "61"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "tina-simone-mckinnor",
          "name": "Tina Simone McKinnor",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 79047,
            "vote_share": 0.9862,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "brian-lockwood",
          "name": "Brian Lockwood",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "No Ballot Designation",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 1104,
            "vote_share": 0.0138,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-62",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 62",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "62"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jose-luis-solache",
          "name": "José Luis Solache",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 51049,
            "vote_share": 0.7312,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "paul-irving-jones",
          "name": "Paul Irving Jones",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Retired Combat Marine",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 18767,
            "vote_share": 0.2688,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-63",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 63",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "63"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "natasha-johnson",
          "name": "Natasha Johnson",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblywoman/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 80160,
            "vote_share": 0.9929,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "kevin-akin",
          "name": "Kevin Akin",
          "party_preference": "Peace and Freedom",
          "ballot_designation": "No Ballot Designation",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 575,
            "vote_share": 0.0071,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-64",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 64",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "64"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "blanca-pacheco",
          "name": "Blanca Pacheco",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblywoman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 58939,
            "vote_share": 0.6653,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "raul-ortiz-jr",
          "name": "Raul Ortiz Jr.",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Pest Control Manager",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 29655,
            "vote_share": 0.3347,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-65",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 65",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "65"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ayanna-davis",
          "name": "Ayanna Davis",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Educator/School Boardmember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 33514,
            "vote_share": 0.4626,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "lydia-a-gutierrez",
          "name": "Lydia A. Gutiérrez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Public School Teacher",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 13940,
            "vote_share": 0.1924,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-66",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 66",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "66"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sara-deen",
          "name": "Sara Deen",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "School Boardmember/Businesswoman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 34098,
            "vote_share": 0.2464,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "paul-seo",
          "name": "Paul Seo",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Mayor/Corruption Prosecutor",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 36802,
            "vote_share": 0.2659,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-67",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 67",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "67"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mark-pulido",
          "name": "Mark Pulido",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "City Councilmember",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 23236,
            "vote_share": 0.2587,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "paulo-morales",
          "name": "Paulo Morales",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Law Enforcement Officer",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 28372,
            "vote_share": 0.3159,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-68",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 68",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "68"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jessie-lopez",
          "name": "Jessie Lopez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "City Councilwoman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 22504,
            "vote_share": 0.3142,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "david-penaloza",
          "name": "David Penaloza",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilmember/Dad/Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 23305,
            "vote_share": 0.3254,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-69",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 69",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "69"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "carolyn-j-essex",
          "name": "Carolyn J. Essex",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Legislative Policy Analyst",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 26596,
            "vote_share": 0.2851,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "josh-lowenthal",
          "name": "Josh Lowenthal",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Business Owner/Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 63944,
            "vote_share": 0.6855,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-70",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 70",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "70"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "paula-swift",
          "name": "Paula Swift",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Small Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 45348,
            "vote_share": 0.4622,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "tri-ta",
          "name": "Tri Ta",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "California Assemblyman/Businessman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 52758,
            "vote_share": 0.5378,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-71",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 71",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "71"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jj-galvez",
          "name": "JJ Galvez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Appointed Director, Silverado-Modjeska Recreation and Park District",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 59255,
            "vote_share": 0.4182,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "kate-sanchez",
          "name": "Kate Sanchez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblywoman",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 82430,
            "vote_share": 0.5818,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-72",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 72",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "72"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "chris-kluwe",
          "name": "Chris Kluwe",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Businessman/Coach/Father",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 70530,
            "vote_share": 0.438,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "gracey-van-der-mark",
          "name": "Gracey Van Der Mark",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Councilwoman/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 60688,
            "vote_share": 0.3769,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-73",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 73",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "73"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "cottie-petrie-norris",
          "name": "Cottie Petrie-Norris",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 60261,
            "vote_share": 0.6088,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "urson-russell",
          "name": "Urson Russell",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 38720,
            "vote_share": 0.3912,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-74",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 74",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "74"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sergio-farias",
          "name": "Sergio Farias",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "City Councilmember/Businessman",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 66403,
            "vote_share": 0.4771,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "laurie-davies",
          "name": "Laurie Davies",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblywoman/Business Owner",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 72782,
            "vote_share": 0.5229,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-75",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 75",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "75"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "gerald-c-boursiquot",
          "name": "Gerald C. Boursiquot",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "IT Contractor/Father",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 57811,
            "vote_share": 0.4032,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "carl-demaio",
          "name": "Carl DeMaio",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Businessman/State Legislator",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 85573,
            "vote_share": 0.5968,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-76",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 76",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "76"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "darshana-patel",
          "name": "Darshana Patel",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 69235,
            "vote_share": 0.558,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "carrie-s-espinoza-villanueva",
          "name": "Carrie S. Espinoza Villanueva",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "College Administration Support",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 54838,
            "vote_share": 0.442,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-77",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 77",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "77"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "tasha-boerner",
          "name": "Tasha Boerner",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "California State Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 93341,
            "vote_share": 0.6182,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "trinity-hannaway",
          "name": "Trinity Hannaway",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Taxpayer Advocate",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 57656,
            "vote_share": 0.3818,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-78",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 78",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "78"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "chris-ward",
          "name": "Chris Ward",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Member of the State Assembly, 78th District",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 93750,
            "vote_share": 0.6848,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "payton-galvez",
          "name": "Payton Galvez",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Constituent Services Manager",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 38865,
            "vote_share": 0.2839,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-79",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 79",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "79"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "lashae-sharp-collins",
          "name": "LaShae Sharp-Collins",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Incumbent",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 55472,
            "vote_share": 0.6466,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "andrew-lawson",
          "name": "Andrew Lawson",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Spring Valley Community Planning Group Member",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 30320,
            "vote_share": 0.3534,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "state-assembly-ad-80",
      "office": "State Assembly Member District 80",
      "office_level": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "ad",
        "id": "80"
      },
      "contest_kind": "top_two",
      "seats": 1,
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "david-a-alvarez",
          "name": "David A. Alvarez",
          "party_preference": "Democratic",
          "ballot_designation": "Assemblymember",
          "incumbent": true,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 53372,
            "vote_share": 0.5912,
            "rank": 1
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        },
        {
          "entry_id": "alejandro-galicia",
          "name": "Alejandro Galicia",
          "party_preference": "Republican",
          "ballot_designation": "Business Owner/Commissioner",
          "incumbent": false,
          "prior_stage": {
            "election_id": "ca-2026-06-02-primary",
            "votes": 30871,
            "vote_share": 0.342,
            "rank": 2
          },
          "links": [
            {
              "label": "Search CAL-ACCESS Power Search",
              "url": "https://powersearch.sos.ca.gov/"
            }
          ],
          "finance": null,
          "finance_missing_reason": "State candidate finance (CAL-ACCESS) is not ingested for this contest yet."
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list",
        "sos:sov:voter-nominated"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-supreme-court-kelli-m-evans",
      "office": "Associate Justice of the Supreme Court",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice of the Supreme Court KELLI M. EVANS be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "kelli-m-evans",
          "name": "Kelli M. Evans",
          "name_as_printed": "KELLI M. EVANS",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-supreme-court-joshua-groban",
      "office": "Associate Justice of the Supreme Court",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice of the Supreme Court JOSHUA GROBAN be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "joshua-groban",
          "name": "Joshua Groban",
          "name_as_printed": "JOSHUA GROBAN",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-charles-a-smiley",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice CHARLES A. SMILEY be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "charles-a-smiley",
          "name": "Charles A. Smiley",
          "name_as_printed": "CHARLES A. SMILEY",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-kathleen-m-banke",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice KATHLEEN M. BANKE be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "kathleen-m-banke",
          "name": "Kathleen M. Banke",
          "name_as_printed": "KATHLEEN M. BANKE",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-monique-langhorne-wilson",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice MONIQUE LANGHORNE WILSON be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "monique-langhorne-wilson",
          "name": "Monique Langhorne Wilson",
          "name_as_printed": "MONIQUE LANGHORNE WILSON",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-therese-m-stewart",
      "office": "Presiding Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division Two",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Presiding Justice THERESE M. STEWART be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "therese-m-stewart",
          "name": "Therese M. Stewart",
          "name_as_printed": "THERESE M. STEWART",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-tara-m-desautels",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division Two",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice TARA M. DESAUTELS be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "tara-m-desautels",
          "name": "Tara M. Desautels",
          "name_as_printed": "TARA M. DESAUTELS",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-ioana-petrou",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice IOANA PETROU be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "ioana-petrou",
          "name": "Ioana Petrou",
          "name_as_printed": "IOANA PETROU",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-victor-a-rodriguez",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice VICTOR A. RODRIGUEZ be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "victor-a-rodriguez",
          "name": "Victor A. Rodriguez",
          "name_as_printed": "VICTOR A. RODRIGUEZ",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-tracie-l-brown",
      "office": "Presiding Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division Four",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Presiding Justice TRACIE L. BROWN be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "tracie-l-brown",
          "name": "Tracie L. Brown",
          "name_as_printed": "TRACIE L. BROWN",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-mark-simons",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division Five",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice MARK SIMONS be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mark-simons",
          "name": "Mark Simons",
          "name_as_printed": "MARK SIMONS",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-danny-y-chou",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division Five",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice DANNY Y. CHOU be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "danny-y-chou",
          "name": "Danny Y. Chou",
          "name_as_printed": "DANNY Y. CHOU",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-1-gordon-burns",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, First District, Division Five",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "1"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice GORDON BURNS be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "gordon-burns",
          "name": "Gordon Burns",
          "name_as_printed": "GORDON BURNS",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-michelle-c-kim",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice MICHELLE C. KIM be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "michelle-c-kim",
          "name": "Michelle C. Kim",
          "name_as_printed": "MICHELLE C. KIM",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-gregory-j-weingart",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice GREGORY J. WEINGART be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "gregory-j-weingart",
          "name": "Gregory J. Weingart",
          "name_as_printed": "GREGORY J. WEINGART",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-steve-goorvitch",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Two",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice STEVE GOORVITCH be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "steve-goorvitch",
          "name": "Steve Goorvitch",
          "name_as_printed": "STEVE GOORVITCH",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-anne-richardson",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Two",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice ANNE RICHARDSON be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "anne-richardson",
          "name": "Anne Richardson",
          "name_as_printed": "ANNE RICHARDSON",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-rashida-a-adams",
      "office": "Presiding Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Presiding Justice RASHIDA A. ADAMS be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "rashida-a-adams",
          "name": "Rashida A. Adams",
          "name_as_printed": "RASHIDA A. ADAMS",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-mark-hanasono",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice MARK HANASONO be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mark-hanasono",
          "name": "Mark Hanasono",
          "name_as_printed": "MARK HANASONO",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-helen-zukin",
      "office": "Presiding Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Four",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Presiding Justice HELEN ZUKIN be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "helen-zukin",
          "name": "Helen Zukin",
          "name_as_printed": "HELEN ZUKIN",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-audra-m-mori",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Four",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice AUDRA M. MORI be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "audra-m-mori",
          "name": "Audra M. Mori",
          "name_as_printed": "AUDRA M. MORI",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-nicholas-daum",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Four",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice NICHOLAS DAUM be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "nicholas-daum",
          "name": "Nicholas Daum",
          "name_as_printed": "NICHOLAS DAUM",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-armen-tamzarian",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Four",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice ARMEN TAMZARIAN be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "armen-tamzarian",
          "name": "Armen Tamzarian",
          "name_as_printed": "ARMEN TAMZARIAN",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-brian-m-hoffstadt",
      "office": "Presiding Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Five",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Presiding Justice BRIAN M. HOFFSTADT be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "brian-m-hoffstadt",
          "name": "Brian M. Hoffstadt",
          "name_as_printed": "BRIAN M. HOFFSTADT",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-tari-l-cody",
      "office": "Presiding Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Six",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Presiding Justice TARI L. CODY be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "tari-l-cody",
          "name": "Tari L. Cody",
          "name_as_printed": "TARI L. CODY",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-kenneth-r-yegan",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Six",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice KENNETH R. YEGAN be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "kenneth-r-yegan",
          "name": "Kenneth R. Yegan",
          "name_as_printed": "KENNETH R. YEGAN",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-gonzalo-c-martinez",
      "office": "Presiding Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Seven",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Presiding Justice GONZALO C. MARTINEZ be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "gonzalo-c-martinez",
          "name": "Gonzalo C. Martinez",
          "name_as_printed": "GONZALO C. MARTINEZ",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-natalie-stone",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Seven",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice NATALIE STONE be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "natalie-stone",
          "name": "Natalie Stone",
          "name_as_printed": "NATALIE STONE",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-john-wiley",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Eight",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice JOHN WILEY be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "john-wiley",
          "name": "John Wiley",
          "name_as_printed": "JOHN WILEY",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-matthew-a-scherb",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Eight",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice MATTHEW A. SCHERB be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "matthew-a-scherb",
          "name": "Matthew A. Scherb",
          "name_as_printed": "MATTHEW A. SCHERB",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-2-victor-g-viramontes",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Second District, Division Eight",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "2"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice VICTOR G. VIRAMONTES be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "victor-g-viramontes",
          "name": "Victor G. Viramontes",
          "name_as_printed": "VICTOR G. VIRAMONTES",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-3-laurie-earl",
      "office": "Administrative Presiding Justice, Court of Appeal, Third District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Administrative Presiding Justice LAURIE EARL be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "laurie-earl",
          "name": "Laurie Earl",
          "name_as_printed": "LAURIE EARL",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-3-shama-mesiwala",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Third District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice SHAMA MESIWALA be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "shama-mesiwala",
          "name": "Shama Mesiwala",
          "name_as_printed": "SHAMA MESIWALA",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-3-david-b-sapp",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Third District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall DAVID B. SAPP be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "david-b-sapp",
          "name": "David B. Sapp",
          "name_as_printed": "DAVID B. SAPP",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-3-lauri-damrell",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Third District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice LAURI DAMRELL be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "lauri-damrell",
          "name": "Lauri Damrell",
          "name_as_printed": "LAURI DAMRELL",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-3-stacy-boulware-eurie",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Third District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice STACY BOULWARE EURIE be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "stacy-boulware-eurie",
          "name": "Stacy Boulware Eurie",
          "name_as_printed": "STACY BOULWARE EURIE",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-3-aimee-a-feinberg",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Third District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice AIMEE A. FEINBERG be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "aimee-a-feinberg",
          "name": "Aimee A. Feinberg",
          "name_as_printed": "AIMEE A. FEINBERG",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-3-jonathan-renner",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Third District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice JONATHAN RENNER be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jonathan-renner",
          "name": "Jonathan Renner",
          "name_as_printed": "JONATHAN RENNER",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-eran-m-bermudez",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice ERAN M. BERMUDEZ be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "eran-m-bermudez",
          "name": "Eran M. Bermudez",
          "name_as_printed": "ERAN M. BERMUDEZ",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-jose-s-castillo",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice JOSE S. CASTILLO be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "jose-s-castillo",
          "name": "Jose S. Castillo",
          "name_as_printed": "JOSE S. CASTILLO",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-truc-t-do",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice TRUC T. DO be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "truc-t-do",
          "name": "Truc T. Do",
          "name_as_printed": "TRUC T. DO",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-lisa-rodriguez",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall San Diego County Superior Court Judge LISA RODRIGUEZ be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "lisa-rodriguez",
          "name": "Lisa Rodriguez",
          "name_as_printed": "LISA RODRIGUEZ",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-david-m-rubin",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice DAVID M. RUBIN be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "david-m-rubin",
          "name": "David M. Rubin",
          "name_as_printed": "DAVID M. RUBIN",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-william-s-dato",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice WILLIAM S. DATO be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "william-s-dato",
          "name": "William S. Dato",
          "name_as_printed": "WILLIAM S. DATO",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-julia-c-kelety",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division One",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice JULIA C. KELETY be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "julia-c-kelety",
          "name": "Julia C. Kelety",
          "name_as_printed": "JULIA C. KELETY",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-corey-g-lee",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division Two",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice COREY G. LEE be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "corey-g-lee",
          "name": "Corey G. Lee",
          "name_as_printed": "COREY G. LEE",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-michael-j-raphael",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division Two",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice MICHAEL J. RAPHAEL be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "michael-j-raphael",
          "name": "Michael J. Raphael",
          "name_as_printed": "MICHAEL J. RAPHAEL",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-joanne-motoike",
      "office": "Presiding Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Presiding Justice JOANNE MOTOIKE be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "joanne-motoike",
          "name": "Joanne Motoike",
          "name_as_printed": "JOANNE MOTOIKE",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-nathan-r-scott",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice NATHAN R. SCOTT be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "nathan-r-scott",
          "name": "Nathan R. Scott",
          "name_as_printed": "NATHAN R. SCOTT",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-juliet-o-macaulay",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice JULIET O. MACAULAY be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "juliet-o-macaulay",
          "name": "Juliet O. Macaulay",
          "name_as_printed": "JULIET O. MACAULAY",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-martha-k-gooding",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice MARTHA K. GOODING be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "martha-k-gooding",
          "name": "Martha K. Gooding",
          "name_as_printed": "MARTHA K. GOODING",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-thomas-a-delaney",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice THOMAS A. DELANEY be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "thomas-a-delaney",
          "name": "Thomas A. Delaney",
          "name_as_printed": "THOMAS A. DELANEY",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-4-deborah-c-servino",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Division Three",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "4"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice DEBORAH C. SERVINO be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "deborah-c-servino",
          "name": "Deborah C. Servino",
          "name_as_printed": "DEBORAH C. SERVINO",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-5-arlan-l-harrell",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fifth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "5"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice ARLAN L. HARRELL be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "arlan-l-harrell",
          "name": "Arlan L. Harrell",
          "name_as_printed": "ARLAN L. HARRELL",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-5-sonny-s-sandhu",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fifth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "5"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice SONNY S. SANDHU be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "sonny-s-sandhu",
          "name": "Sonny S. Sandhu",
          "name_as_printed": "SONNY S. SANDHU",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-5-amy-k-guerra",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fifth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "5"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice AMY K. GUERRA be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "amy-k-guerra",
          "name": "Amy K. Guerra",
          "name_as_printed": "AMY K. GUERRA",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-5-kathleen-a-meehan",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fifth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "5"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice KATHLEEN A. MEEHAN be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "kathleen-a-meehan",
          "name": "Kathleen A. Meehan",
          "name_as_printed": "KATHLEEN A. MEEHAN",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-5-mark-w-snauffer",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fifth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "5"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice MARK W. SNAUFFER be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "mark-w-snauffer",
          "name": "Mark W. Snauffer",
          "name_as_printed": "MARK W. SNAUFFER",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-5-thomas-desantos",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Fifth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "5"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice THOMAS DESANTOS be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "thomas-desantos",
          "name": "Thomas Desantos",
          "name_as_printed": "THOMAS DESANTOS",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-6-daniel-h-bromberg",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Sixth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "6"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice DANIEL H. BROMBERG be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "daniel-h-bromberg",
          "name": "Daniel H. Bromberg",
          "name_as_printed": "DANIEL H. BROMBERG",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-6-charles-e-wilson-ii",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Sixth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "6"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice CHARLES E. WILSON II be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "charles-e-wilson-ii",
          "name": "Charles E. Wilson II",
          "name_as_printed": "CHARLES E. WILSON II",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-6-charles-f-adams",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Sixth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "6"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice CHARLES F. ADAMS be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "charles-f-adams",
          "name": "Charles F. Adams",
          "name_as_printed": "CHARLES F. ADAMS",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-6-frederick-s-chung",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Sixth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "6"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Superior Court Judge FREDERICK S. CHUNG be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "frederick-s-chung",
          "name": "Frederick S. Chung",
          "name_as_printed": "FREDERICK S. CHUNG",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": false,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    },
    {
      "contest_id": "retention-appeal-6-allison-marston-danner",
      "office": "Associate Justice, Court of Appeal, Sixth District",
      "office_level": "judicial",
      "district": {
        "kind": "appellate",
        "id": "6"
      },
      "contest_kind": "retention",
      "seats": 1,
      "question": "Shall Associate Justice ALLISON MARSTON DANNER be elected to the office for the term provided by law?",
      "entries": [
        {
          "entry_id": "allison-marston-danner",
          "name": "Allison Marston Danner",
          "name_as_printed": "ALLISON MARSTON DANNER",
          "party_preference": null,
          "ballot_designation": null,
          "incumbent": true,
          "links": []
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "sos:cert-list"
      ],
      "tier": "T0"
    }
  ],
  "measures": [
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-1",
      "contest_id": "prop-1",
      "number": "1",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "AUTHORIZES BONDS FOR HOUSING AFFORDABILITY PROGRAMS. LEGISLATIVE STATUTE.",
      "measure_type": "legislative_statute",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by the Legislature",
      "summary": "Authorizes $11.25 billion in state general obligation bonds for housing affordability programs, including multifamily rental housing, mortgages for veterans, supportive housing, preservation of existing affordable housing, and downpayment assistance.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Increased state cost of $500 million to $600 million annually for about 25 years to repay the housing bond.",
      "supporters": "US Vets; CA Federation of Teachers; Self-Help for the Elderly; Habitat for Humanity CA; CA Alliance of Child & Family Services",
      "opponents": "None submitted",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: The state could borrow $11.25 billion to support veterans and affordable housing.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: The state could not borrow $11.25 billion to support veterans and affordable housing.",
      "pro_short": "Prop. 1 builds affordable homes for veterans, seniors, people with disabilities, low- and middle-income working families, vulnerable Californians and essential workers—teachers, firefighters and nurses. Expands homeownership opportunities, fast-tracks affordable shovel-ready homes, helps those one crisis away from homelessness. Requires strict fiscal accountability and public oversight with no new taxes.",
      "con_short": "NO ARGUMENT AGAINST PROPOSITION 1 WAS SUBMITTED.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "info@yesonprop1ca.com",
          "yesonprop1ca.com"
        ],
        "against": []
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "info@yesonprop1ca.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@yesonprop1ca.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "yesonprop1ca.com",
          "url": "https://yesonprop1ca.com"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Authorizes $11.25 billion in state general obligation bonds for housing affordability programs, including for California veterans, and to finance housing development projects seeking federal tax credits.",
        "Allocates funds:",
        "$5.1 billion to build and rehabilitate multifamily rental housing;",
        "$2.1 billion to acquire, rehabilitate, or preserve affordable housing units, and provide supportive housing for those experiencing homelessness;",
        "$1.25 billion for state-funded mortgages for California veterans;",
        "$1.1 billion for homeownership and downpayment assistance;",
        "$1 billion for farmworker, tribal, and student housing;",
        "$500 million for housing infrastructure; and",
        "$200 million to support local housing programs.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST’S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Increased state cost of $500 million to $600 million annually for about 25 years to repay the housing bond.",
        "State Bond Cost Estimate",
        "FINAL VOTES CAST BY THE LEGISLATURE ON SB 417 (PROPOSITION 1)",
        "(CHAPTER 16, STATUTES OF 2026)",
        "Senate:",
        "Ayes 29",
        "Noes 2",
        "Assembly:",
        "Ayes 61",
        "Noes 7",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Public Sector Funds Some Home Building. In most years, about 100,000 houses and apartments are built in California. Most of these housing units are built entirely with private dollars. Some, however, receive financial help from federal, state, or local governments. In the case of housing funded by the state, the state government generally provides local governments, nonprofit organizations, and private developers with grants or low-cost loans to fund a portion of the housing units’ construction costs. Typically, housing built with these funds must be sold or rented to Californians with low incomes.",
            "Bonds Are a Common Way for the State to Fund Home Building and Homeownership Programs. Over the past few decades, the state has used general obligation bonds to fund various housing programs. Bonds are a way the state borrows money to cover the up-front costs of a development and then repays the money plus interest over time. The last statewide general obligation bond for affordable housing was approved by voters in 2024, providing $2 billion to provide housing for veterans and other people with mental health or substance use challenges who are facing homelessness.",
            "Home Loan Program for Veterans. The state’s veterans home loan program provides home loans to eligible veterans, including veterans who may not otherwise qualify for a home loan. Under the program, the state sells general obligation bonds to investors and uses the funds to provide loans to veterans to purchase homes. Participating veterans repay the cost of the bonds through their payments on their home loan. The last statewide general obligation bond for veterans home loans was approved by voters in 2018, which provided $1 billion for the program."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Public Sector Funds Some Home Building",
              "text": "In most years, about 100,000 houses and apartments are built in California. Most of these housing units are built entirely with private dollars. Some, however, receive financial help from federal, state, or local governments. In the case of housing funded by the state, the state government generally provides local governments, nonprofit organizations, and private developers with grants or low-cost loans to fund a portion of the housing units’ construction costs. Typically, housing built with these funds must be sold or rented to Californians with low incomes.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Bonds Are a Common Way for the State to Fund Home Building and Homeownership Programs",
              "text": "Over the past few decades, the state has used general obligation bonds to fund various housing programs. Bonds are a way the state borrows money to cover the up-front costs of a development and then repays the money plus interest over time. The last statewide general obligation bond for affordable housing was approved by voters in 2024, providing $2 billion to provide housing for veterans and other people with mental health or substance use challenges who are facing homelessness.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Home Loan Program for Veterans",
              "text": "The state’s veterans home loan program provides home loans to eligible veterans, including veterans who may not otherwise qualify for a home loan. Under the program, the state sells general obligation bonds to investors and uses the funds to provide loans to veterans to purchase homes. Participating veterans repay the cost of the bonds through their payments on their home loan. The last statewide general obligation bond for veterans home loans was approved by voters in 2018, which provided $1 billion for the program.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "New General Obligation Bond for Housing. Proposition 1 allows the state to sell $11.25 billion in general obligation bonds for housing purposes. This amount consists of (1) a $10 billion bond for a variety of state housing programs that would be repaid by the General Fund and (2) a $1.25 billion bond that would be repaid by veterans’ payments on their home loans. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons. For more information on the state’s General Fund-supported bonds, please see “Overview of State Bond Debt” later in this guide.)",
            "State Housing Programs. Proposition 1 provides bond funding for various types of housing programs, which are summarized in Figure 1. The funds would be allocated over a number of years. The major categories of housing programs supported by the bond are:",
            "Affordable Multifamily Housing Programs. Proposition 1 provides $7.2 billion to acquire, build, or renovate rental housing, such as apartment buildings. These programs generally provide local governments and private developers with low-interest loans to fund part of the project cost. In exchange, projects generally must reserve units for low-income households for a period of 55 years. Some of this funding would be used for supportive housing, which provides on-site service (such as mental health and substance use counseling) to certain residents.",
            "Homeownership Programs. Proposition 1 provides $1.1 billion to support homeownership for low- and moderate-income households. Some of the funds would be used to provide homebuying assistance for first-time homebuyers through loans that generally do not have to be paid back until the home is sold or paid off. Other funds would be provided to nonprofit organizations and other entities for activities such as acquiring land to build homes for eligible low-income homebuyers and repairing existing homes owned by low-income households.",
            "Infrastructure Programs. Proposition 1 provides $500 million for a variety of infrastructure projects to support affordable housing developments, such as water, sewage, parks, and transportation improvements.",
            "Farmworker Housing Program. Proposition 1 provides $450 million in loans and grants to build or renovate housing for farmworkers. Program funds could be used for both rental and owner-occupied housing.",
            "Higher Education Student Housing Programs. Proposition 1 provides $350 million, split evenly between the University of California and California State University, for affordable student housing.",
            "Tribal Housing Program. Proposition 1 provides $200 million in grants to tribes. Funds could be used for various housing-related purposes, including construction and repair of rental and owner-occupied housing.",
            "Proposed Uses of Bonds Funds",
            "Local Pilot Programs. Proposition 1 provides $200 million that would be available to cities, counties, and certain other entities for pilot projects aimed at developing housing at reduced costs.",
            "Veterans Housing Program. Proposition 1 also provides $1.25 billion for home loan assistance to veterans. Veterans generally use these loans to purchase single-family residences, condominiums, farms, and mobile homes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "New General Obligation Bond for Housing",
              "text": "Proposition 1 allows the state to sell $11.25 billion in general obligation bonds for housing purposes. This amount consists of (1) a $10 billion bond for a variety of state housing programs that would be repaid by the General Fund and (2) a $1.25 billion bond that would be repaid by veterans’ payments on their home loans. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons. For more information on the state’s General Fund-supported bonds, please see “Overview of State Bond Debt” later in this guide.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": "State Housing Programs",
              "text": "Proposition 1 provides bond funding for various types of housing programs, which are summarized in Figure 1. The funds would be allocated over a number of years. The major categories of housing programs supported by the bond are:",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Affordable Multifamily Housing Programs. Proposition 1 provides $7.2 billion to acquire, build, or renovate rental housing, such as apartment buildings. These programs generally provide local governments and private developers with low-interest loans to fund part of the project cost. In exchange, projects generally must reserve units for low-income households for a period of 55 years. Some of this funding would be used for supportive housing, which provides on-site service (such as mental health and substance use counseling) to certain residents.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Homeownership Programs. Proposition 1 provides $1.1 billion to support homeownership for low- and moderate-income households. Some of the funds would be used to provide homebuying assistance for first-time homebuyers through loans that generally do not have to be paid back until the home is sold or paid off. Other funds would be provided to nonprofit organizations and other entities for activities such as acquiring land to build homes for eligible low-income homebuyers and repairing existing homes owned by low-income households.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Infrastructure Programs. Proposition 1 provides $500 million for a variety of infrastructure projects to support affordable housing developments, such as water, sewage, parks, and transportation improvements.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Farmworker Housing Program. Proposition 1 provides $450 million in loans and grants to build or renovate housing for farmworkers. Program funds could be used for both rental and owner-occupied housing.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Higher Education Student Housing Programs. Proposition 1 provides $350 million, split evenly between the University of California and California State University, for affordable student housing.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Tribal Housing Program. Proposition 1 provides $200 million in grants to tribes. Funds could be used for various housing-related purposes, including construction and repair of rental and owner-occupied housing.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposed Uses of Bonds Funds",
              "kind": "figure",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Local Pilot Programs. Proposition 1 provides $200 million that would be available to cities, counties, and certain other entities for pilot projects aimed at developing housing at reduced costs.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Veterans Housing Program",
              "text": "Proposition 1 also provides $1.25 billion for home loan assistance to veterans. Veterans generally use these loans to purchase single-family residences, condominiums, farms, and mobile homes.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Increased State Cost to Repay the $10 Billion Bond for Housing Programs. The state General Fund cost to repay the bond would be $500 million to $600 million annually for about 25 years. The estimated annual cost would be about one-quarter of 1 percent (0.25 percent) of the state’s total General Fund budget. Since the state has to pay interest on the money it borrows, the total cost of the bond would be about 15 percent more (after adjusting for inflation) than if the state paid up front with money it already has.",
            "No Direct State Cost for Veterans Housing Program. Veterans participating in the home loan program would make monthly payments to the state, allowing the state to repay the bonds. These payments have always covered the amount owed on the bonds, meaning the program has always operated at no direct cost to the state.",
            "Administrative Costs. A number of state entities would experience increased costs to administer the various housing programs. A portion of the bond funds would cover these costs.",
            "Impact of Funds. Much of the funding from Proposition 1 would be used together with other government monies to provide housing assistance. The bond funds would provide subsidies for up to 40,000 multifamily rental units, as well as about 2,500 units for farmworkers and about 1,200 beds for university students. The funds also would help up to 40,000 households, including about 2,100 veterans, with homeownership by providing homebuyer assistance and supporting the production and repair of homes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Increased State Cost to Repay the $10 Billion Bond for Housing Programs",
              "text": "The state General Fund cost to repay the bond would be $500 million to $600 million annually for about 25 years. The estimated annual cost would be about one-quarter of 1 percent (0.25 percent) of the state’s total General Fund budget. Since the state has to pay interest on the money it borrows, the total cost of the bond would be about 15 percent more (after adjusting for inflation) than if the state paid up front with money it already has.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": "No Direct State Cost for Veterans Housing Program",
              "text": "Veterans participating in the home loan program would make monthly payments to the state, allowing the state to repay the bonds. These payments have always covered the amount owed on the bonds, meaning the program has always operated at no direct cost to the state.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Administrative Costs",
              "text": "A number of state entities would experience increased costs to administer the various housing programs. A portion of the bond funds would cover these costs.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Impact of Funds",
              "text": "Much of the funding from Proposition 1 would be used together with other government monies to provide housing assistance. The bond funds would provide subsidies for up to 40,000 multifamily rental units, as well as about 2,500 units for farmworkers and about 1,200 beds for university students. The funds also would help up to 40,000 households, including about 2,100 veterans, with homeownership by providing homebuyer assistance and supporting the production and repair of homes.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/ measure-contributions/2026- ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee’s top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "not_submitted"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "not_submitted"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "YES ON PROP. 1: AFFORDABLE HOMES FOR VETERANS, SENIORS, PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES AND WORKING FAMILIES—WITHOUT RAISING TAXES",
            "All Californians deserve a safe and affordable place to call home, but California has a housing shortage that is driving the nation’s worst housing affordability crisis. More than half of renters spend over 30% of their income on rent and only 22% of households can afford a median-priced home, yet only 1% of California’s state budget goes to housing.",
            "Prop. 1 gives Californians the opportunity to:",
            "Fast-track housing production;",
            "Provide housing to working families, veterans, people with disabilities and seniors;",
            "Help prevent homelessness by keeping our most vulnerable neighbors in their homes;",
            "Expands homeownership opportunities;",
            "Maintains strict fiscal accountability and transparency with NO NEW TAXES.",
            "PROP. 1 HONORS OUR VETERANS",
            "Dedicates $1.25 billion solely to veterans’ housing and homeownership opportunities through the existing CalVet Home Loan Program, which has already helped almost a million veterans and their families.",
            "“California has one of the largest populations of homeless veterans in the nation. After their service, our veterans deserve a place to call home. Prop. 1 delivers on that promise.”—Michael Blecker, President, CA Association of Veteran Service Agencies",
            "PROP. 1 BUILDS HOMES LOW- AND MIDDLE-INCOME FAMILIES CAN AFFORD",
            "Prop. 1 jumpstarts the construction of tens of thousands of shovel-ready affordable homes across California, quickly turning stalled construction into move-in ready homes. The teacher in your child’s classroom, the firefighter who protects your neighborhood, first-time homebuyers, low- and middle-income Californians, and the nurse at your local hospital can no longer afford to live in most California communities. Prop. 1 builds more homes working people can actually afford.",
            "NO NEW TAXES—STRICT ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY",
            "Prop. 1 doesn’t raise taxes and every dollar comes with strict accountability and public reporting. Voters will be able to see exactly how many homes get built, where, and at what cost. Prop. 1 unlocks federal matching funds, bringing tax dollars we send to Washington back home to California.",
            "PROP. 1 HELPS SENIORS, VETERANS & OUR MOST VULNERABLE",
            "Prop. 1 creates and preserves housing to help those who are one crisis away from homelessness stay off the streets, low-income seniors on fixed incomes, survivors of domestic violence and their families, veterans, at risk and foster youth, and people with disabilities who all deserve safe and stable homes.",
            "PROP. 1 INVESTS IN COMMUNITIES & ESSENTIAL WORKERS",
            "Quality, affordable housing is the foundation of thriving communities. Prop. 1 strengthens that foundation by helping essential workers—from firefighters and teachers to nurses—afford to live in the communities they serve. Working families and essential workers across California are being priced out and left behind. Prop. 1 enables the construction of affordable housing for these essential workers who dedicate their lives to our communities.",
            "YES ON PROP. 1: SUPPORTED BY VETERANS, SENIORS, TEACHERS, FIREFIGHTERS, AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVOCATES including Habitat for Humanity California, California Alliance for Retired Americans, Housing California, California Housing Consortium, California Alliance of Child and Family Services.",
            "VOTE YES ON PROP. 1, Veterans and Affordable Housing Bond, to honor those veterans who served; provide safe and stable housing to California’s most vulnerable; guarantee strict fiscal accountability with no new taxes; and build the affordable homes all Californians deserve.",
            "YesOnProp1CA.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Anni Chung, President",
            "Self-Help for the Elderly",
            "Jeffery Freitas, President",
            "California Federation of Teachers",
            "John H. Ing, Chief Financial Officer",
            "US Vets"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Anni Chung",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Self-Help for the Elderly"
            },
            {
              "name": "Jeffery Freitas",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Federation of Teachers"
            },
            {
              "name": "John H. Ing",
              "title": "Chief Financial Officer",
              "organization": "US Vets"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "not_submitted",
          "printed_as": "NO ARGUMENT AGAINST PROPOSITION 1 WAS SUBMITTED."
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/1/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/1/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop1-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/1/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop1-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "AFFORDABLE HOMES FOR VETERANS, SENIORS, PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES AND WORKING FAMILIES",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would provide affordable homes for veterans, seniors, people with disabilities, and working families.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 1 provides $7.2 billion to acquire, build, or renovate rental housing, such as apartment buildings.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "WITHOUT RAISING TAXES",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would not raise taxes.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The state General Fund cost to repay the bond would be $500 million to $600 million annually for about 25 years.",
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California has a housing shortage",
          "claim": "California has a housing shortage.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California has a housing shortage that is driving the nation’s worst housing affordability crisis.",
          "claim": "California's housing shortage is causing the nation's worst housing affordability crisis.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "More than half of renters spend over 30% of their income on rent",
          "claim": "More than half of California renters spend over 30 percent of their income on rent.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "only 22% of households can afford a median-priced home",
          "claim": "Only 22 percent of California households can afford a median-priced home.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "only 1% of California’s state budget goes to housing.",
          "claim": "Only 1 percent of California's state budget goes to housing.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Fast-track housing production;",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would accelerate housing production.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Help prevent homelessness by keeping our most vulnerable neighbors in their homes;",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would help prevent homelessness by keeping vulnerable people in their homes.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Expands homeownership opportunities;",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would expand homeownership opportunities.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 1 provides $1.1 billion to support homeownership for low- and moderate-income households.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Maintains strict fiscal accountability and transparency with NO NEW TAXES.",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would maintain strict fiscal accountability and transparency.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Maintains strict fiscal accountability and transparency with NO NEW TAXES.",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would not impose new taxes.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The state General Fund cost to repay the bond would be $500 million to $600 million annually for about 25 years.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Dedicates $1.25 billion solely to veterans’ housing and homeownership opportunities",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would dedicate $1.25 billion to veterans' housing and homeownership opportunities.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 1 also provides $1.25 billion for home loan assistance to veterans.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "through the existing CalVet Home Loan Program",
          "claim": "The $1.25 billion would be provided through the existing CalVet Home Loan Program.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "The state’s veterans home loan program provides home loans to eligible veterans, including veterans who may not otherwise qualify for a home loan.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "which has already helped almost a million veterans and their families.",
          "claim": "The CalVet Home Loan Program has already helped almost one million veterans and their families.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California has one of the largest populations of homeless veterans in the nation.",
          "claim": "California has one of the nation's largest populations of homeless veterans.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "BUILDS HOMES LOW- AND MIDDLE-INCOME FAMILIES CAN AFFORD",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would build homes that low- and middle-income families can afford.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 1 provides $1.1 billion to support homeownership for low- and moderate-income households.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 1 jumpstarts the construction of tens of thousands of shovel-ready affordable homes across California, quickly turning stalled construction into move-in ready homes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would quickly turn stalled, shovel-ready affordable-housing construction into move-in-ready homes across California.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "The teacher in your child’s classroom, the firefighter who protects your neighborhood, first-time homebuyers, low- and middle-income Californians, and the nurse at your local hospital can no longer afford to live in most California communities.",
          "claim": "Teachers, firefighters, first-time homebuyers, low- and middle-income Californians, and nurses can no longer afford to live in most California communities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 1 builds more homes working people can actually afford.",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would build more homes that working people can afford.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The bond funds would provide subsidies for up to 40,000 multifamily rental units, as well as about 2,500 units for farmworkers and about 1,200 beds for university students.",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:21",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 1 doesn’t raise taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would not raise taxes.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The state General Fund cost to repay the bond would be $500 million to $600 million annually for about 25 years.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:22",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "every dollar comes with strict accountability and public reporting.",
          "claim": "Every dollar under Proposition 1 would have strict accountability and public reporting requirements.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:23",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Voters will be able to see exactly how many homes get built, where, and at what cost.",
          "claim": "Voters would be able to see how many homes are built, where they are built, and their cost.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:24",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 1 unlocks federal matching funds",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would unlock federal matching funds.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:25",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "bringing tax dollars we send to Washington back home to California.",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would bring federal tax dollars paid by Californians back to California.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:26",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 1 creates and preserves housing to help those who are one crisis away from homelessness stay off the streets, low-income seniors on fixed incomes, survivors of domestic violence and their families, veterans, at risk and foster youth, and people with disabilities who all deserve safe and stable homes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would create and preserve housing for people near homelessness, low-income seniors, domestic-violence survivors and their families, veterans, at-risk and foster youth, and people with disabilities.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Some of this funding would be used for supportive housing, which provides on-site service (such as mental health and substance use counseling) to certain residents.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:27",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 1 strengthens that foundation by helping essential workers—from firefighters and teachers to nurses—afford to live in the communities they serve.",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would help essential workers, including firefighters, teachers, and nurses, afford to live in the communities they serve.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 1 provides $1.1 billion to support homeownership for low- and moderate-income households.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:28",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Working families and essential workers across California are being priced out and left behind.",
          "claim": "Working families and essential workers across California are being priced out and left behind.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-1:argument_for:29",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 1 enables the construction of affordable housing for these essential workers who dedicate their lives to our communities.",
          "claim": "Proposition 1 would enable construction of affordable housing for essential workers.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "These programs generally provide local governments and private developers with low-interest loans to fund part of the project cost. In exchange, projects generally must reserve units for low-income households for a period of 55 years.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-1:analysis": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
            "vig:prop-1:arguments": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-1:overview",
        "vig:prop-1:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-1:analysis",
        "vig:prop-1:arguments",
        "vig:prop-1:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-1:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-2",
      "contest_id": "prop-2",
      "number": "2",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "INCREASES STATE’S RAINY DAY FUND. LEGISLATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.",
      "measure_type": "legislative_constitutional_amendment",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by the Legislature",
      "summary": "Increases California's Rainy Day Fund, approved by voters in 2014, to provide funding for education, health care, public safety, and other essential services during economic downturns.",
      "fiscal_impact": "State budget reserves would be higher.",
      "supporters": "CA Professional Firefighters; LA Chamber of Commerce; Gavin Newsom; Xavier Becerra; Assemblymember Jesse Gabriel",
      "opponents": "None submitted",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: Rules for building state budget reserves and paying down extra state debts would change. As a result, state budget reserves would be higher. The state also would be required to make extra debt payments for longer.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: Rules for building state budget reserves and paying down extra state debts would not change.",
      "pro_short": "Vote yes on Proposition 2 to protect schools, healthcare, and public safety funding. Proposition 2 doubles the state's Rainy Day Fund, stops politicians from overspending when there is a budget surplus, and ensures education funding continues during economic downturns. It has bipartisan support from firefighters, hospitals, health clinics, and educators.",
      "con_short": "Proposition 2 guarantees more spending, not savings, creating a loophole that makes taxpayer rebates less likely by excluding reserve deposits from California's constitutional spending limit. It provides no new funding for education, healthcare, or public safety. Vote No to protect taxpayer rebates and constitutional limits.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "Yes on Prop. 2",
          "445 S. Figueroa Street",
          "Suite 2400",
          "Los Angeles, CA 90071",
          "YesonProp2.com"
        ],
        "against": [
          "David Tangipa,",
          "Assemblymember",
          "RejectProp2@gmail.com"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "YesonProp2.com",
          "url": "https://www.yesonprop2.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "RejectProp2@gmail.com",
          "url": "mailto:RejectProp2@gmail.com"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Increases California’s Rainy Day Fund, approved by voters in 2014, to provide funding for education, health care, public safety, and other essential services during economic downturns.",
        "Doubles the budget reserve cap from 10% to 20% of General Fund revenues, requiring savings until Fund’s balance equals 20% of General Fund.",
        "Requires additional savings in years when tax revenues are high.",
        "Increases budget reserves available for education, state debts, and pension obligations.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "State budget reserves would be higher.",
        "FINAL VOTES CAST BY THE LEGISLATURE ON ACA 20 (PROPOSITION 2)",
        "(CHAPTER 130, STATUTES OF 2026)",
        "Senate:",
        "Ayes 29",
        "Noes 2",
        "Assembly:",
        "Ayes 59",
        "Noes 8",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [],
          "blocks": []
        },
        {
          "section_id": "the-state-budget",
          "heading": "THE STATE BUDGET",
          "paragraphs": [
            "How Does the State Spend Its Money? This year, the state plans to spend about $250 billion from the General Fund to pay for services to the public. The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services. About half of this spending is for schools, community colleges, and the state's public universities. (The State Constitution sets a minimum spending level for schools and community colleges.) About another one-third of state spending is for health and human services programs, mainly for the state's low-income health insurance program, Medi-Cal. The rest goes mostly to prisons, courts, and other state services.",
            "How Does the State Raise Revenue? The income tax is the state's largest tax. It pays for most spending from the General Fund. Other major taxes include the corporation tax and the sales tax. Much of the income tax is paid by high-income taxpayers, whose incomes often include gains from stocks and other investments.",
            "State Revenues Are Unpredictable. State revenues go up and down a lot from year to year. This is because revenues depend on how the economy and stock market are doing. When things are going well, revenues can grow quickly. When things are going badly, like during a recession or a stock market crash, revenues can decline by tens of billions of dollars. During a bad recession or market crash, total revenue declines over a few years can equal 50 percent or more of annual General Fund revenues.",
            "The State Must Meet Certain Budgeting Requirements Each Year. The State Constitution requires the Legislature to pass a balanced budget each year. This means the state cannot adopt a budget that spends more money than is available. In addition, the State Constitution limits how much tax revenue the state can spend. This limit is called the “state appropriations limit.” Certain kinds of spending—like infrastructure—do not count toward the limit. All other spending, including money put into reserves, does count toward the limit."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "How Does the State Spend Its Money? This year, the state plans to spend about $250 billion from the General Fund to pay for services to the public. The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services. About half of this spending is for schools, community colleges, and the state's public universities. (The State Constitution sets a minimum spending level for schools and community colleges.) About another one-third of state spending is for health and human services programs, mainly for the state's low-income health insurance program, Medi-Cal. The rest goes mostly to prisons, courts, and other state services.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "How Does the State Raise Revenue? The income tax is the state's largest tax. It pays for most spending from the General Fund. Other major taxes include the corporation tax and the sales tax. Much of the income tax is paid by high-income taxpayers, whose incomes often include gains from stocks and other investments.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": "State Revenues Are Unpredictable",
              "text": "State revenues go up and down a lot from year to year. This is because revenues depend on how the economy and stock market are doing. When things are going well, revenues can grow quickly. When things are going badly, like during a recession or a stock market crash, revenues can decline by tens of billions of dollars. During a bad recession or market crash, total revenue declines over a few years can equal 50 percent or more of annual General Fund revenues.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": "The State Must Meet Certain Budgeting Requirements Each Year",
              "text": "The State Constitution requires the Legislature to pass a balanced budget each year. This means the state cannot adopt a budget that spends more money than is available. In addition, the State Constitution limits how much tax revenue the state can spend. This limit is called the “state appropriations limit.” Certain kinds of spending—like infrastructure—do not count toward the limit. All other spending, including money put into reserves, does count toward the limit.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "reserves",
          "heading": "RESERVES",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Reserves Allow the State to Maintain Spending When Revenues Decline. The state puts money into reserves when the economy is doing well. This means that money is saved instead of being spent on public programs during these periods of time. When the economy gets worse and revenues decline, the state uses reserves to help maintain spending on public programs. Reserves help the state avoid some spending cuts, tax increases, and borrowing to balance the budget. Currently, the state has about $20 billion in reserves that can be used for any public program.",
            "State Constitution Requires the State to Save Money in the “Rainy Day Fund.” The State Constitution requires the state to deposit 0.75 percent of General Fund tax revenues in the state's main rainy day fund, which is called the Budget Stabilization Account, each year. Money in the rainy day fund can be used for any state program. In addition, the state must put more money into the rainy day fund in years when revenue from taxes on investment gains is higher than normal. During a budget emergency, the state can stop making deposits and/or take money out of the rainy day fund.",
            "Savings Are No Longer Required Once the Rainy Day Fund Reaches a Certain Level. Once money in the rainy day fund reaches 10 percent of General Fund taxes, the state is no longer required to make additional deposits. The money that would have gone into the rainy day fund instead must be spent on infrastructure (like highways and housing)."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Reserves Allow the State to Maintain Spending When Revenues Decline",
              "text": "The state puts money into reserves when the economy is doing well. This means that money is saved instead of being spent on public programs during these periods of time. When the economy gets worse and revenues decline, the state uses reserves to help maintain spending on public programs. Reserves help the state avoid some spending cuts, tax increases, and borrowing to balance the budget. Currently, the state has about $20 billion in reserves that can be used for any public program.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "State Constitution Requires the State to Save Money in the “Rainy Day Fund.” The State Constitution requires the state to deposit 0.75 percent of General Fund tax revenues in the state's main rainy day fund, which is called the Budget Stabilization Account, each year. Money in the rainy day fund can be used for any state program. In addition, the state must put more money into the rainy day fund in years when revenue from taxes on investment gains is higher than normal. During a budget emergency, the state can stop making deposits and/or take money out of the rainy day fund.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Savings Are No Longer Required Once the Rainy Day Fund Reaches a Certain Level",
              "text": "Once money in the rainy day fund reaches 10 percent of General Fund taxes, the state is no longer required to make additional deposits. The money that would have gone into the rainy day fund instead must be spent on infrastructure (like highways and housing).",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "debt",
          "heading": "DEBT",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The State Has Different Kinds of Debts. The state has more than $250 billion in debts. These include debt for infrastructure and pension and retiree health benefits earned by state employees. The state also sometimes borrows money from other state funds to help pay General Fund costs. State debts are repaid over time, usually according to a schedule or plan. Each year, the state makes payments toward its debts.",
            "State Constitution Requires the State to Make Extra Debt Payments Toward Pension and Health Benefits. The State Constitution requires the state to make extra debt payments above those normally made each year. The amount of these extra debt payments is the same as the amount initially deposited into the rainy day fund each year. The state may only use these extra debt payments to pay down long-term pension and retiree health care debts. Making extra payments toward these debts saves the state money in the long run.",
            "Extra Debt Payments Optional After 2030. The requirement for extra debt payments ends in 2030. After that, the Legislature and the Governor could decide to deposit the money for extra debt payments into the rainy day fund instead. Or, the Legislature and the Governor could make smaller extra debt payments and put the rest of the money into the rainy day fund."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "The State Has Different Kinds of Debts",
              "text": "The state has more than $250 billion in debts. These include debt for infrastructure and pension and retiree health benefits earned by state employees. The state also sometimes borrows money from other state funds to help pay General Fund costs. State debts are repaid over time, usually according to a schedule or plan. Each year, the state makes payments toward its debts.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": "State Constitution Requires the State to Make Extra Debt Payments Toward Pension and Health Benefits",
              "text": "The State Constitution requires the state to make extra debt payments above those normally made each year. The amount of these extra debt payments is the same as the amount initially deposited into the rainy day fund each year. The state may only use these extra debt payments to pay down long-term pension and retiree health care debts. Making extra payments toward these debts saves the state money in the long run.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Extra Debt Payments Optional After 2030",
              "text": "The requirement for extra debt payments ends in 2030. After that, the Legislature and the Governor could decide to deposit the money for extra debt payments into the rainy day fund instead. Or, the Legislature and the Governor could make smaller extra debt payments and put the rest of the money into the rainy day fund.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Save More in the Rainy Day Fund. Proposition 2 requires the state to make deposits into the rainy day fund until it reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes (instead of 10 percent of General Fund taxes). In addition, the state would make even larger deposits in years when revenues from taxes on investment gains are very high, like when the stock market is booming.",
            "Extend and Expand Extra Debt Payments. Proposition 2 also requires the state to make extra debt payments through 2040 (instead of through 2030). These debt payments would be the same as the amount initially deposited into the rainy day fund each year. In addition, the amount set aside for extra debt payments could be used for an expanded set of purposes. Specifically, these payments could be used to make required payments to schools and community colleges, repay borrowing from other state funds, and repay certain loans from the federal government.",
            "Change How Rainy Day Fund Deposits Count Toward the State Appropriations Limit. Deposits into the rainy day fund would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out.",
            "Change How Other Deposits Count Toward the State Appropriations Limit. The state has an account to set aside funds when revenues are surging. By setting these funds aside, the state can avoid overspending when revenue estimates are particularly uncertain. Under Proposition 2, deposits into this account also would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out. This exclusion could not be larger than 10 percent of General Fund taxes in each year."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Save More in the Rainy Day Fund",
              "text": "Proposition 2 requires the state to make deposits into the rainy day fund until it reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes (instead of 10 percent of General Fund taxes). In addition, the state would make even larger deposits in years when revenues from taxes on investment gains are very high, like when the stock market is booming.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Extend and Expand Extra Debt Payments",
              "text": "Proposition 2 also requires the state to make extra debt payments through 2040 (instead of through 2030). These debt payments would be the same as the amount initially deposited into the rainy day fund each year. In addition, the amount set aside for extra debt payments could be used for an expanded set of purposes. Specifically, these payments could be used to make required payments to schools and community colleges, repay borrowing from other state funds, and repay certain loans from the federal government.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Change How Rainy Day Fund Deposits Count Toward the State Appropriations Limit",
              "text": "Deposits into the rainy day fund would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Change How Other Deposits Count Toward the State Appropriations Limit",
              "text": "The state has an account to set aside funds when revenues are surging. By setting these funds aside, the state can avoid overspending when revenue estimates are particularly uncertain. Under Proposition 2, deposits into this account also would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out. This exclusion could not be larger than 10 percent of General Fund taxes in each year.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Budget Reserves Would Be Higher. By continuing to require deposits into the rainy day fund until the balance reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes, the state would save more over time. In addition, by depositing more money when revenues are surging, the state likely would save more in the rainy day fund in certain years. More reserves would make balancing the budget somewhat easier when revenues decline.",
            "Possibly More Debt Payments. By requiring the state to make extra debt payments through 2040, the state might make more debt payments than it would without Proposition 2."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Budget Reserves Would Be Higher",
              "text": "By continuing to require deposits into the rainy day fund until the balance reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes, the state would save more over time. In addition, by depositing more money when revenues are surging, the state likely would save more in the rainy day fund in certain years. More reserves would make balancing the budget somewhat easier when revenues decline.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Possibly More Debt Payments",
              "text": "By requiring the state to make extra debt payments through 2040, the state might make more debt payments than it would without Proposition 2.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The supporters of Proposition 2 want you to believe this measure is about fiscal responsibility and protecting funding for education, public safety, and healthcare. Within 24 hours of introducing this measure, many of the same politicians who praised it as a way to build reserves also supported legislation to suspend more than $5 billion in required deposits into the state’s savings account. Proposition 2 asks Californians to double the size of the savings account while making it less likely that taxpayers will receive the rebates they are constitutionally owed.",
            "PROP. 2 MAKES TAXPAYER REBATES LESS LIKELY",
            "State revenues that exceed constitutional spending limits must be returned to taxpayers. Proposition 2 creates a loophole, allowing politicians to shift billions into reserve accounts that no longer count towards the spending limit, making your rebate far less likely.",
            "PROP. 2 DOES NOT GUARANTEE ANY NEW FUNDING FOR HEALTHCARE, EDUCATION OR PUBLIC SAFETY",
            "Supporters claim Prop. 2 will protect education, healthcare, and public safety. Currently, it doesn’t dedicate any new dollars to any of those priorities. Sacramento politicians will continue to decide how much to spend each year, not you. Prop. 2 only allows for politicians to spend more on pet projects.",
            "Sacramento doesn’t need another budget gimmick or wasteful spending. It needs the discipline to live within the constitutional limits that voters have already approved.",
            "Vote NO on Proposition 2."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "David Tangipa, Vice Chair",
            "Assembly Budget Committee",
            "Carl DeMaio, Chairman",
            "Reform California",
            "Steven Choi, Vice Chair",
            "Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "David Tangipa",
              "title": "Vice Chair",
              "organization": "Assembly Budget Committee"
            },
            {
              "name": "Carl DeMaio",
              "title": "Chairman",
              "organization": "Reform California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Steven Choi",
              "title": "Vice Chair",
              "organization": "Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROPOSITION 2 PROTECTS CALIFORNIANS FROM BOOM-AND-BUST BUDGETS",
            "Opponents say the state needs “discipline,” not a new tool. But relying on their definition of “discipline” alone gave California a $100 billion surplus followed by a $50 billion deficit—exactly the boom-and-bust cycle Proposition 2 is designed to prevent. That instability, not this measure, is what leads to layoffs, healthcare cuts, slashed services, and tax hikes.",
            "STOPS SACRAMENTO POLITICIANS FROM OVERSPENDING—Proposition 2 does not give Sacramento any new money to spend. On the contrary, it doubles the state’s reserve requirement and forces more savings—rather than new spending—when tax revenues spike.",
            "PROTECTS SCHOOLS, PUBLIC SAFETY, AND HEALTHCARE—When the economy slows, Proposition 2 helps protect funding for schools, hospitals, health clinics, and public safety instead of placing them first in line for cuts. The theoretical “rebate” opponents refer to relies on a 50-year-old accounting gimmick that rewards spending instead of saving. Proposition 2 closes that loophole and mandates a real 20% Rainy Day Fund.",
            "Don’t be fooled by those who call themselves “watchdogs.” California’s official nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office has recommended that the state expand the Rainy Day Fund to prevent boom-and-bust budget cycles. That’s why Proposition 2 is backed by the California Professional Firefighters, small business advocates, health clinics, hospitals, and education leaders—people who understand what happens when reserves run dry.",
            "VOTE YES ON PROPOSITION 2—www.YesonProp2.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Dr. Linda Darling-Hammond, President",
            "California State Board of Education",
            "Carmela Coyle, CEO",
            "California Hospital Association",
            "Francisco J. Silva, CEO",
            "California Primary Care Association"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Dr. Linda Darling-Hammond",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California State Board of Education"
            },
            {
              "name": "Carmela Coyle",
              "title": "CEO",
              "organization": "California Hospital Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Francisco J. Silva",
              "title": "CEO",
              "organization": "California Primary Care Association"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE YES ON PROPOSITION 2 TO PROTECT SCHOOLS, HEALTHCARE, PUBLIC SAFETY AND CALIFORNIA'S FINANCIAL FUTURE.",
            "California's Rainy Day Fund, established by voters in 2014, was built for exactly this moment: an economy that swung our state budget from a $100 billion surplus to a $50 billion deficit in just a few years.",
            "Proposition 2 strengthens that fund, so schools, healthcare, and public safety don't pay the price for Sacramento's boom-and-bust budgeting. Voting YES on Proposition 2 will:",
            "DOUBLE THE STATE'S RESERVE REQUIREMENT—from 10 to 20 percent of General Fund revenues—so California has a real cushion, not a token one, when the next downturn hits.",
            "STOP SACRAMENTO POLITICIANS FROM OVERSPENDING—When tax revenues spike, this measure forces politicians to budget smarter by requiring the state to bank more of that windfall instead of committing it to new ongoing spending California can't sustain.",
            "GUARANTEE EDUCATION FUNDING IS PROTECTED IN THE STATE CONSTITUTION, even as reserves grow.",
            "INCREASE FINANCIAL SECURITY—As Washington moves to cut billions in health care and food assistance funding, this measure will ensure California is better prepared to absorb those losses without slashing the programs Californians depend on.",
            "This is not a partisan idea. Republicans and Democrats in the state Legislature and Governor Gavin Newsom support Proposition 2.",
            "California's own nonpartisan Legislative Analyst's Office has recommended that the state should be saving significantly more than current rules require. Proposition 2 follows that advice.",
            "Please join the California Professional Firefighters, small business organizations, and former Health Secretary Xavier Becerra in supporting Proposition 2 because they see, firsthand, what happens when reserves run dry: healthcare clinics closed, schools defunded, essential services cut, and fire protection slashed.",
            "Saving for a rainy day is what California families do. It's what California's state government should do too. Vote YES on Proposition 2—and make sure the next time the economy turns, California is ready.",
            "Learn more at YesOnProp2.com."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Darrell Roberts, President",
            "California Professional Firefighters",
            "Jesse Gabriel, Chair",
            "California State Assembly Budget Committee",
            "Maria S. Salinas, CEO",
            "Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Darrell Roberts",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Professional Firefighters"
            },
            {
              "name": "Jesse Gabriel",
              "title": "Chair",
              "organization": "California State Assembly Budget Committee"
            },
            {
              "name": "Maria S. Salinas",
              "title": "CEO",
              "organization": "Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Voting NO on Prop. 2 means more money in your pocket— and less wasteful spending!",
            "PROP. 2 CREATES A SLUSH FUND FOR SACRAMENTO POLITICIANS",
            "In 1978 California voters overwhelmingly voted to amend the state constitution to impose a spending limit on state politicians—and the politicians have hated that spending limit ever since. Prop. 2 allows the politicians to gut the voter-imposed spending limit. What the politicians dishonestly call a “rainy day fund” is actually a SLUSH FUND! Politicians can raid this new slush fund to feed their runaway spending habits.",
            "PROP. 2 CANCELS YOUR TAX REBATE",
            "California already has the highest taxes in the nation, but the state constitution requires that a tax rebate be provided to you when revenues exceed the spending limit. Prop. 2 creates loopholes and accounting gimmicks so politicians can eliminate any chance of you getting your tax rebate.",
            "PROP. 2 ALLOWS FOR MORE WASTEFUL SPENDING",
            "California’s state budget has grown by 76% since 2018—and the size of state government has mushroomed by 40% even after adjusting for inflation! Do you feel like you are getting 40% more services and benefits today than you did in 2018? Of course not! In fact, many core services to citizens have been gutted. We’re spending more, but getting less.",
            "That’s because state politicians have diverted your tax dollars to boondoggle projects and no-bid contracts that reward their campaign contributors. Of the little money spent on important programs, too much of it is being lost because of fraud and wasteful spending. By eliminating the spending limit on politicians we will see even more wasteful spending.",
            "PROP. 2 MAKES OUR BUDGET MORE VOLATILE",
            "When times are good, the state is supposed to set money aside so families and businesses are not hit with tax increases, cuts to essential services, or budget chaos during the next economic downturn. Sacramento doesn’t need a new tool to save money. It needs the discipline to follow the rules already in place and stop spending money it doesn’t have. Prop. 2 makes our budget more volatile— putting us at greater risk of a financial crisis.",
            "PROP. 2 IS OPPOSED BY TRUSTED BUDGET WATCHDOGS",
            "Take a look at who is supporting Prop. 2: politicians who have repeatedly mismanaged our budget and special interests that get government contracts! Within 24 hours of putting it on the ballot, the politicians backing Prop. 2 voted to suspend more than $5 billion in required deposits into the state’s budget reserve. In contrast, opponents of Prop. 2 are government accountability and transparency watchdogs—including the Reform California and the Transparency Foundation. Californians do not need another budget gimmick dressed up as reform. We need honest budgeting, reform of wasteful spending, and a real spending limit to hold politicians accountable.",
            "VOTE NO ON PROP. 2."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "David Tangipa, Vice Chair",
            "Assembly Budget Committee",
            "Steven Choi, Vice Chair",
            "Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendment Committee",
            "Carl DeMaio, Chairman",
            "Reform California"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "David Tangipa",
              "title": "Vice Chair",
              "organization": "Assembly Budget Committee"
            },
            {
              "name": "Steven Choi",
              "title": "Vice Chair",
              "organization": "Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendment Committee"
            },
            {
              "name": "Carl DeMaio",
              "title": "Chairman",
              "organization": "Reform California"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/2/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/2/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop2-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/2/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop2-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California's Rainy Day Fund, established by voters in 2014",
          "claim": "California voters established the Rainy Day Fund in 2014.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "an economy that swung our state budget from a $100 billion surplus to a $50 billion deficit in just a few years.",
          "claim": "The economy shifted the state budget from a $100 billion surplus to a $50 billion deficit within a few years.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 2 strengthens that fund",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 increases the Rainy Day Fund's requirements.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 2 requires the state to make deposits into the rainy day fund until it reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes (instead of 10 percent of General Fund taxes).",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "so schools, healthcare, and public safety don't pay the price for Sacramento's boom-and-bust budgeting.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 will prevent schools, health care, and public safety from bearing the effects of budget volatility.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "DOUBLE THE STATE'S RESERVE REQUIREMENT—from 10 to 20 percent of General Fund revenues",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 raises the Rainy Day Fund threshold from 10 percent to 20 percent of General Fund revenues.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 2 requires the state to make deposits into the rainy day fund until it reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes (instead of 10 percent of General Fund taxes).",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "this measure forces politicians to budget smarter",
          "claim": "The measure requires more prudent state budgeting.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "requiring the state to bank more of that windfall instead of committing it to new ongoing spending California can't sustain.",
          "claim": "When tax revenues spike, the measure requires the state to save more revenue instead of committing it to ongoing spending.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "In addition, the state would make even larger deposits in years when revenues from taxes on investment gains are very high, like when the stock market is booming.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "GUARANTEE EDUCATION FUNDING IS PROTECTED IN THE STATE CONSTITUTION, even as reserves grow.",
          "claim": "The measure constitutionally guarantees protection of education funding as reserves grow.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Specifically, these payments could be used to make required payments to schools and community colleges, repay borrowing from other state funds, and repay certain loans from the federal government.",
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": "condition_dropped",
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "this measure will ensure California is better prepared to absorb those losses without slashing the programs Californians depend on.",
          "claim": "The measure will prepare California to absorb federal health care and food-assistance cuts without reducing programs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Republicans and Democrats in the state Legislature and Governor Gavin Newsom support Proposition 2.",
          "claim": "Republicans, Democrats in the Legislature, and Governor Gavin Newsom support Proposition 2.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California's own nonpartisan Legislative Analyst's Office has recommended that the state should be saving significantly more than current rules require.",
          "claim": "The Legislative Analyst's Office recommended that California save significantly more than current rules require.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 2 follows that advice.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 follows the Legislative Analyst's Office recommendation to save more.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "healthcare clinics closed, schools defunded, essential services cut, and fire protection slashed.",
          "claim": "When reserves run dry, health care clinics close.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "gave California a $100 billion surplus followed by a $50 billion deficit",
          "claim": "Reliance on the opponents' definition of discipline produced a $100 billion surplus followed by a $50 billion deficit.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 2 is designed to prevent.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 was designed to prevent boom-and-bust budget cycles.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "That instability, not this measure, is what leads to layoffs, healthcare cuts, slashed services, and tax hikes.",
          "claim": "Budget instability causes layoffs, health care cuts, service cuts, and tax increases.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 2 does not give Sacramento any new money to spend.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 does not provide Sacramento with additional money to spend.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Deposits into the rainy day fund would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "it doubles the state’s reserve requirement",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 doubles the Rainy Day Fund threshold.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 2 requires the state to make deposits into the rainy day fund until it reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes (instead of 10 percent of General Fund taxes).",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "forces more savings—rather than new spending—when tax revenues spike.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 requires more saving rather than new spending when tax revenues spike.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "In addition, the state would make even larger deposits in years when revenues from taxes on investment gains are very high, like when the stock market is booming.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 2 helps protect funding for schools, hospitals, health clinics, and public safety instead of placing them first in line for cuts.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 protects funding for schools, hospitals, health clinics, and public safety during an economic slowdown.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "reserves",
          "analysis_quote": "When the economy gets worse and revenues decline, the state uses reserves to help maintain spending on public programs. Reserves help the state avoid some spending cuts, tax increases, and borrowing to balance the budget.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The theoretical “rebate” opponents refer to relies on a 50-year-old accounting gimmick that rewards spending instead of saving.",
          "claim": "The taxpayer rebate relies on a 50-year-old accounting mechanism that rewards spending instead of saving.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 2 closes that loophole",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 closes a loophole affecting taxpayer rebates.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Deposits into the rainy day fund would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "mandates a real 20% Rainy Day Fund.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 requires deposits until the Rainy Day Fund reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 2 requires the state to make deposits into the rainy day fund until it reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes (instead of 10 percent of General Fund taxes).",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_against:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "California’s official nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office has recommended that the state expand the Rainy Day Fund to prevent boom-and-bust budget cycles.",
          "claim": "The Legislative Analyst's Office recommended expanding the Rainy Day Fund to prevent boom-and-bust budget cycles.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Voting NO on Prop. 2 means more money in your pocket",
          "claim": "Voting against Proposition 2 will leave taxpayers with more money.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "less wasteful spending!",
          "claim": "Voting against Proposition 2 will reduce wasteful spending.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "In 1978 California voters overwhelmingly voted to amend the state constitution to impose a spending limit on state politicians",
          "claim": "California voters amended the state constitution in 1978 to impose a state spending limit.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 2 allows the politicians to gut the voter-imposed spending limit.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 allows politicians to substantially weaken the state appropriations limit.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Deposits into the rainy day fund would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "What the politicians dishonestly call a “rainy day fund” is actually a SLUSH FUND!",
          "claim": "The Rainy Day Fund is a fund politicians can use at their discretion for improper purposes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "reserves",
          "analysis_quote": "Money in the rainy day fund can be used for any state program. In addition, the state must put more money into the rainy day fund in years when revenue from taxes on investment gains is higher than normal.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Politicians can raid this new slush fund to feed their runaway spending habits.",
          "claim": "Politicians can use the proposed fund for excessive spending.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "reserves",
          "analysis_quote": "During a budget emergency, the state can stop making deposits and/or take money out of the rainy day fund.",
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "California already has the highest taxes in the nation",
          "claim": "California has the highest taxes in the nation.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the state constitution requires that a tax rebate be provided to you when revenues exceed the spending limit.",
          "claim": "The state constitution requires taxpayer rebates when revenues exceed the spending limit.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 2 creates loopholes and accounting gimmicks so politicians can eliminate any chance of you getting your tax rebate.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 changes accounting rules so politicians can eliminate taxpayer rebates.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Deposits into the rainy day fund would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out.",
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "California’s state budget has grown by 76% since 2018",
          "claim": "California's state budget has grown 76 percent since 2018.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the size of state government has mushroomed by 40% even after adjusting for inflation!",
          "claim": "The size of state government has grown 40 percent since 2018 after inflation adjustment.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "many core services to citizens have been gutted.",
          "claim": "Many core public services have been substantially reduced.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "We’re spending more, but getting less.",
          "claim": "California is spending more while providing fewer public services or benefits.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "state politicians have diverted your tax dollars to boondoggle projects and no-bid contracts that reward their campaign contributors.",
          "claim": "State politicians have directed tax dollars to projects and no-bid contracts that financially benefit their campaign contributors.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "too much of it is being lost because of fraud and wasteful spending.",
          "claim": "Too much spending on important programs is lost to fraud and wasteful spending.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "By eliminating the spending limit on politicians we will see even more wasteful spending.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 eliminates the spending limit on politicians.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Deposits into the rainy day fund would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": {
            "from_label": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "to_label": "context_missing",
            "reason": "The analysis says rainy day fund deposits would stop counting toward the appropriations limit until they are taken out. That loosens the limit for some money but keeps it; the argument overstates a real change rather than stating its opposite.",
            "reviewed_by": "agent s11-claims (Claude), PR #37 follow-up",
            "reviewed_at": "2026-10-08"
          },
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "we will see even more wasteful spending.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 will increase wasteful spending.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the state is supposed to set money aside so families and businesses are not hit with tax increases, cuts to essential services, or budget chaos during the next economic downturn.",
          "claim": "The state is supposed to save money to avoid tax increases, service cuts, and budget instability during economic downturns.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "reserves",
          "analysis_quote": "Reserves help the state avoid some spending cuts, tax increases, and borrowing to balance the budget.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Sacramento doesn’t need a new tool to save money.",
          "claim": "California does not need a new mechanism to save money.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 2 makes our budget more volatile",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 will make the state budget more volatile.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "More reserves would make balancing the budget somewhat easier when revenues decline.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:21",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "putting us at greater risk of a financial crisis.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 will increase the risk of a financial crisis.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:22",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "politicians who have repeatedly mismanaged our budget",
          "claim": "Politicians supporting Proposition 2 have repeatedly mismanaged California's budget.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:23",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "special interests that get government contracts!",
          "claim": "Special-interest supporters of Proposition 2 receive government contracts.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:24",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Within 24 hours of putting it on the ballot, the politicians backing Prop. 2 voted to suspend more than $5 billion in required deposits into the state’s budget reserve.",
          "claim": "Within 24 hours of placing Proposition 2 on the ballot, its political backers voted to suspend more than $5 billion in required budget-reserve deposits.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:argument_against:25",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "opponents of Prop. 2 are government accountability and transparency watchdogs—including the Reform California and the Transparency Foundation.",
          "claim": "Reform California and the Transparency Foundation oppose Proposition 2 and are government accountability and transparency watchdogs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "The supporters of Proposition 2 want you to believe this measure is about fiscal responsibility and protecting funding for education, public safety, and healthcare.",
          "claim": "Supporters intend voters to view Proposition 2 as a fiscal-responsibility measure that protects education, public safety, and health care funding.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "many of the same politicians who praised it as a way to build reserves also supported legislation to suspend more than $5 billion in required deposits into the state’s savings account.",
          "claim": "Many politicians who praised Proposition 2 as a reserve-building measure also supported legislation suspending more than $5 billion in required savings-account deposits.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 2 asks Californians to double the size of the savings account",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 doubles the Rainy Day Fund threshold.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 2 requires the state to make deposits into the rainy day fund until it reaches 20 percent of General Fund taxes (instead of 10 percent of General Fund taxes).",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "making it less likely that taxpayers will receive the rebates they are constitutionally owed.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 makes constitutionally required taxpayer rebates less likely.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Deposits into the rainy day fund would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "State revenues that exceed constitutional spending limits must be returned to taxpayers.",
          "claim": "State revenues exceeding constitutional spending limits must be returned to taxpayers.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 2 creates a loophole, allowing politicians to shift billions into reserve accounts that no longer count towards the spending limit",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 allows reserve deposits to stop counting toward the state appropriations limit.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Deposits into the rainy day fund would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "making your rebate far less likely.",
          "claim": "The accounting change makes taxpayer rebates far less likely.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 2, deposits into this account also would not count toward the state appropriations limit. Instead, the money would count toward the limit when it is taken out. This exclusion could not be larger than 10 percent of General Fund taxes in each year.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Currently, it doesn’t dedicate any new dollars to any of those priorities.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 does not dedicate new funding to health care, education, or public safety.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Specifically, these payments could be used to make required payments to schools and community colleges, repay borrowing from other state funds, and repay certain loans from the federal government.",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Sacramento politicians will continue to decide how much to spend each year, not you.",
          "claim": "State politicians, rather than voters, will continue deciding annual state spending levels.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-2:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 2 only allows for politicians to spend more on pet projects.",
          "claim": "Proposition 2 only allows politicians to spend more on pet projects.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 2 also requires the state to make extra debt payments through 2040 (instead of through 2030).",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-2:analysis": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
            "vig:prop-2:arguments": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-2:overview",
        "vig:prop-2:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-2:analysis",
        "vig:prop-2:arguments",
        "vig:prop-2:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-2:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-3",
      "contest_id": "prop-3",
      "number": "3",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "PROVIDES PERMANENT FUNDING FOR SCHOOLS AND HEALTH CARE BY EXTENDING EXISTING TAX ON HIGH INCOMES. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.",
      "measure_type": "initiative_constitutional_amendment",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures",
      "summary": "Makes permanent existing voter-approved tax rates for individuals earning over $371,000 (adjusted annually for inflation). Allocates tax revenues to public education.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Maintains $5 billion to $15 billion of annual state income tax revenue by making a temporary tax increase on high-income earners permanent instead of letting it expire in 2031.",
      "supporters": "California Teachers Association; CA School Nurses Organization; California State PTA; Planned Parenthood Affiliates of CA",
      "opponents": "California Taxpayers Association; Family Business Association of California; California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: An income tax increase on high-income earners in place since 2012 would become permanent instead of expiring in 2031.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: An income tax increase on high-income earners in place since 2012 would expire in 2031.",
      "pro_short": "PROPOSITION 3 PROTECTS OUR SCHOOLS AND HEALTHCARE WITHOUT RAISING YOUR TAXES. Prop. 3 prevents a massive tax cut for millionaires and billionaires by maintaining the current tax rates the wealthiest 2% have paid for 15 years and requires strict accountability and audits to ensure school funding gets to classrooms. Vote YES.",
      "con_short": "Californians already pay the nation’s highest income, sales, and gas taxes—and have the highest cost of living. Prop. 3 makes temporary income taxes permanent while Sacramento wastes billions on failed programs instead of voters’ priorities. Don’t reward failure. Fix spending first before making taxes permanent. No on Prop. 3.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "Yes on Prop 3",
          "555 Capitol Mall, Suite 400",
          "Sacramento, CA 95814",
          "info@YesProp3CA.com",
          "YesProp3CA.com"
        ],
        "against": [
          "info@VoteNoProp3.com",
          "VoteNoProp3.com"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "info@YesProp3CA.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@YesProp3CA.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "YesProp3CA.com",
          "url": "https://www.yesprop3ca.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "info@VoteNoProp3.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@VoteNoProp3.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "VoteNoProp3.com",
          "url": "https://votenoprop3.com/"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Makes permanent the existing 2012 voter-approved tax rates for high-income Californians, currently set to expire in 2031.",
        "Rates apply to income over about $371,000 for single filers, $742,000 for joint filers, and $505,000 for heads of household (2025 levels; adjusted annually for inflation).",
        "Allocates tax revenues 89% to K–12 schools, 11% to community colleges.",
        "Allows local school boards to decide how revenues are spent; bars use for administrative costs.",
        "Increases General Fund revenues available for health care, budget reserves, and other programs.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Maintains $5 billion to $15 billion of annual state income tax revenue by making a temporary tax increase on high-income earners permanent instead of letting it expire in 2031.",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Most State Money Comes From the Income Tax. The income tax is the state’s largest tax. It pays for most spending from the state’s main operating account, the General Fund. The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons. The tax applies to most types of income, such as salaries, wages, interest, and profits from the sale of stocks, property, and other investments. The income tax rate starts out low and gradually goes up for taxpayers with higher incomes. For example, a married couple pays a 1 percent tax on the first $21,000 of income, a 2 percent tax on income between $21,000 and $50,000, and a 4 percent tax on income between $50,000 and $80,000.",
            "Prior Voter-Approved Tax Increases. Voters approved Proposition 30 in 2012 to temporarily increase income tax rates on high-income taxpayers. In 2016, voters approved Proposition 55 to extend these higher rates until 2030. The top 2 percent of California taxpayers pay these higher rates. These taxpayers pay about half of all state income taxes.",
            "How Does the State Spend Its Money? This year, the state plans to spend about $250 billion from the General Fund to pay for services to the public. About half of this spending is for schools, community colleges, and the state’s public universities. (The State Constitution sets a minimum spending level for schools and community colleges.) About another one-third of state spending is for health and human services programs, mainly for the state’s low-income health insurance program, Medi-Cal. The rest goes mostly to prisons, courts, and other state services."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Most State Money Comes From the Income Tax",
              "text": "The income tax is the state’s largest tax. It pays for most spending from the state’s main operating account, the General Fund. The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons. The tax applies to most types of income, such as salaries, wages, interest, and profits from the sale of stocks, property, and other investments. The income tax rate starts out low and gradually goes up for taxpayers with higher incomes. For example, a married couple pays a 1 percent tax on the first $21,000 of income, a 2 percent tax on income between $21,000 and $50,000, and a 4 percent tax on income between $50,000 and $80,000.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Prior Voter-Approved Tax Increases",
              "text": "Voters approved Proposition 30 in 2012 to temporarily increase income tax rates on high-income taxpayers. In 2016, voters approved Proposition 55 to extend these higher rates until 2030. The top 2 percent of California taxpayers pay these higher rates. These taxpayers pay about half of all state income taxes.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "How Does the State Spend Its Money? This year, the state plans to spend about $250 billion from the General Fund to pay for services to the public. About half of this spending is for schools, community colleges, and the state’s public universities. (The State Constitution sets a minimum spending level for schools and community colleges.) About another one-third of state spending is for health and human services programs, mainly for the state’s low-income health insurance program, Medi-Cal. The rest goes mostly to prisons, courts, and other state services.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031. Figure 1 shows what income tax rates would be if this measure passes and what they would be if it is rejected."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031. Figure 1 shows what income tax rates would be if this measure passes and what they would be if it is rejected.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Proposition 3 Would Bring in Between $5 Billion and $15 Billion Each Year. The amount of money brought in by Proposition 3 will go up and down a lot from year to year. This is because much of the revenue comes from taxing income that is closely tied to the stock market, which is always changing. In a weak year, the proposition might bring in around $5 billion in revenue to the state. In a strong year, the proposition might bring in $15 billion in revenue to the state. In most years, revenue would be in between these amounts.",
            "Funding for Education and Other Programs. Proposition 3 results in funding for education and other programs. Roughly 40 percent of the funding would go to schools and community colleges. The rest would go to other state programs. Part of this amount would be set aside in budget reserves the state could use to fund these programs when revenues decline."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Proposition 3 Would Bring in Between $5 Billion and $15 Billion Each Year",
              "text": "The amount of money brought in by Proposition 3 will go up and down a lot from year to year. This is because much of the revenue comes from taxing income that is closely tied to the stock market, which is always changing. In a weak year, the proposition might bring in around $5 billion in revenue to the state. In a strong year, the proposition might bring in $15 billion in revenue to the state. In most years, revenue would be in between these amounts.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Funding for Education and Other Programs",
              "text": "Proposition 3 results in funding for education and other programs. Roughly 40 percent of the funding would go to schools and community colleges. The rest would go to other state programs. Part of this amount would be set aside in budget reserves the state could use to fund these programs when revenues decline.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "NO ON PROP. 3—STOP PERMANENTLY HIGHER INCOME TAXES",
            "In 2012, politicians and special interests promised Californians that their income tax increases would be TEMPORARY. Now they’re claiming that making those taxes permanent somehow ISN’T a tax increase at all. Don’t buy it. Prop. 3 locks in what would become the largest permanent state income tax increase in California history— costing taxpayers up to $15 billion every year.",
            "NO ON PROP. 3—REMIND POLITICIANS WHAT “TEMPORARY” MEANS",
            "Temporary: lasting for a limited time only; not permanent.",
            "California taxpayers kept their end of the bargain—paying temporary higher income taxes for 16 years. Politicians should keep theirs and stop pushing for even higher taxes.",
            "NO ON PROP. 3—STOP WASTEFUL SPENDING",
            "Prop. 3 does nothing to stop the waste, fraud and reckless spending that turned a $100 billion budget surplus into a $30 billion deficit in just three years. If Sacramento had spent responsibly, they wouldn’t be asking taxpayers to make “temporary” taxes permanent.",
            "NO ON PROP. 3—DON’T MAKE CALIFORNIA EVEN MORE EXPENSIVE",
            "Californians have the highest cost of living and pay the highest income, sales and gas taxes in America. Making a temporary tax permanent only makes California more expensive.",
            "NO ON PROP. 3—FIX THE SPENDING PROBLEM FIRST",
            "California doesn’t have a tax revenue problem—it has a spending problem. California’s population grew by less than 2% in the past decade while the politicians doubled spending. Say no to permanently higher taxes. Join us to oppose higher income taxes at VoteNoProp3.com.",
            "NO ON PROP. 3"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Jon Coupal, President",
            "Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association",
            "Carlos Solorzano, CEO",
            "Hispanic Chambers of Commerce of San Francisco",
            "Clint Olivier, President",
            "Central Valley Business Federation"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Jon Coupal",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Carlos Solorzano",
              "title": "CEO",
              "organization": "Hispanic Chambers of Commerce of San Francisco"
            },
            {
              "name": "Clint Olivier",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Central Valley Business Federation"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Proposition 3 protects our schools, our healthcare and our communities—without raising your taxes.",
            "PROP. 3 KEEPS THE TAX RATES THE TOP 2% HAVE PAID FOR THE PAST 15 YEARS AND DOES NOT RAISE YOUR TAXES.",
            "Prop. 3 maintains the current tax rates the wealthiest 2% of Californians have been paying for 15 years, ensuring couples that earn more than $740,000 continue to pay their fair share.",
            "WITHOUT PROP. 3 MILLIONAIRES AND BILLIONAIRES GET A MASSIVE TAX CUT—AND THE REST OF US PAY FOR IT.",
            "Teacher and staff layoffs, overcrowded classrooms and fewer counselors in our schools; cuts to Medi-Cal, children’s healthcare and the clinics families rely on; and less for the firefighters, emergency response and wildfire protection that keep our communities safe.",
            "PROP. 3 HAS STRICT ACCOUNTABILITY AND FUNDS EDUCATION DIRECTLY.",
            "Prop. 3’s funding goes straight to local schools and community colleges. Sacramento politicians cannot touch it or redirect it. Not one penny may be spent on bureaucracy or administrative overhead. Every dollar is independently audited every year, districts must post their spending online, and any official who misuses the money faces prosecution and criminal penalties.",
            "PROP. 3 PROTECTS HEALTHCARE AND FIRE PROTECTION.",
            "By guaranteeing funding for our classrooms, Prop. 3 ensures California can also invest in Medi-Cal and children’s healthcare, and in the firefighters and wildfire protection our communities depend on. That’s why teachers, school employees, nurses and firefighters agree: VOTE YES ON PROPOSITION 3.",
            "www.YesProp3CA.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Jeff Freitas, President",
            "California Federation of Teachers",
            "Darrell Roberts, President",
            "California Professional Firefighters",
            "Adam Weinberger, President",
            "California School Employees Association"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Jeff Freitas",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Federation of Teachers"
            },
            {
              "name": "Darrell Roberts",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Professional Firefighters"
            },
            {
              "name": "Adam Weinberger",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California School Employees Association"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROPOSITION 3 PROTECTS OUR SCHOOLS, HEALTHCARE AND OUR COMMUNITIES WITHOUT RAISING YOUR TAXES.",
            "Proposition 3 is NOT a new tax and does NOT raise taxes on anyone. Prop. 3 prevents millionaires and billionaires from getting a tax cut, and requires strict accountability and audits to ensure school funding gets to classrooms.",
            "PROP. 3 PREVENTS BILLIONS IN CUTS TO OUR SCHOOLS AND HEALTHCARE.",
            "Without Prop. 3, California’s 8 million public school and community college students face billions in cuts, including teacher layoffs, overcrowded classrooms and bigger class sizes. Families could lose access to preventive healthcare and affordable prescription drugs, and the Medi-Cal coverage that millions of Californians rely on could be put at risk.",
            "PROP. 3 ONLY EXTENDS THE CURRENT TAX RATES ON THE WEALTHIEST TOP 2%.",
            "Prop. 3 maintains the income tax rates that the wealthiest Californians have paid for the past 15 years. If those tax rates are allowed to expire, it would give millionaires and billionaires a massive tax cut at the expense of our classrooms, clinics and communities. Proposition 3 keeps the existing rates on the top 2% of incomes.",
            "GUARANTEES THE MONEY REACHES THE CLASSROOM— NOT SACRAMENTO.",
            "Proposition 3 includes Constitutional protections and tough accountability. It guarantees that funds from Proposition 3 go directly to local schools—the Legislature and Sacramento politicians cannot touch it, redirect it, or spend a single dollar on bureaucracy or administrative overhead. Prop. 3’s school guarantee then frees up billions that help fund Medi-Cal for children, seniors and families.",
            "Every dollar in Prop. 3 is independently audited every year and any official who misuses the money faces prosecution and criminal penalties. Local school districts must post annual accounting online to guarantee that Californians know exactly how and where funds are spent.",
            "PROP. 3 SECURES OUR CHILDREN’S FUTURE.",
            "For more than a decade, these revenues have helped fund critical programs California families and communities count on—from school lunches, smaller class sizes and mental health counselors to children’s healthcare and Medi-Cal. They’ve also helped stave off cuts during economic downturns by investing more in the state’s Rainy Day Fund, protecting our schools and healthcare when the economy slows. Proposition 3 keeps that progress going for the next generation.",
            "PROP. 3 IS SUPPORTED BY TEACHERS, NURSES, AND HEALTHCARE WORKERS.",
            "Yes on 3 is supported by:",
            "California State PTA",
            "California Federation of Teachers",
            "California Nurses Association",
            "California School Employees Association",
            "California School Nurses Organization",
            "California Teachers Association",
            "Community College League of California",
            "Nurse Alliance of SEIU California",
            "Planned Parenthood Affiliates of CA",
            "The educators in our classrooms and the nurses who care for our kids all agree: Vote YES on Proposition 3. Let’s protect what matters most, without raising your taxes. Vote YES on Proposition 3.",
            "www.YesProp3CA.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "David Goldberg, President",
            "California Teachers Association",
            "Katie Nilsson, RN, President",
            "California School Nurses Organization",
            "Jodi Hicks, President",
            "Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "David Goldberg",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Teachers Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Katie Nilsson",
              "title": "RN, President",
              "organization": "California School Nurses Organization"
            },
            {
              "name": "Jodi Hicks",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROP. 3—TURNS “TEMPORARY” TAXES INTO PERMANENT HIGHER INCOME TAXES",
            "Sacramento politicians make big promises to get our support for higher taxes. Then they spend our tax dollars with no accountability—losing billions to waste, fraud and overspending.",
            "Take Prop. 3. Politicians told voters higher income taxes would be temporary—only for seven years to cover a budget deficit. Then those “temporary” taxes were extended for another 12 years with the promise to voters that the higher taxes would solve the problems the politicians created. Now the special interests and politicians want to make these higher income taxes PERMANENT.",
            "California voters should say NO to PERMANENTLY higher income taxes.",
            "PROP. 3—HIGHER INCOME TAXES = HIGHER COST OF LIVING",
            "Californians have the nation’s highest cost of living partly because we also suffer from the highest income taxes, highest sales taxes and highest gas taxes of all fifty states. The same politicians also gave us the highest gasoline prices in the nation, higher insurance costs, higher utility costs, higher food costs, and higher housing costs. Now they want to make higher income taxes permanent, while adding new taxes on your health insurance, new taxes on software—and they are even considering a “jobs” tax. Say NO to INCREASING our cost of living with higher taxes.",
            "PROP. 3—VOTERS DESERVE REAL RESULTS, NOT BROKEN PROMISES",
            "Waste, fraud and overspending by state government is not an excuse to raise our taxes even higher.",
            "The politicians and special interests promised temporary income taxes were needed to avoid big cuts to government programs. Since the “temporary” increases were first passed, government spending has increased by $150 billion—a more than 2.5X increase. Over the same time period, our schools, infrastructure and public safety have gotten worse. Say NO to endless broken promises.",
            "NO ON PROP. 3—STOP WASTEFUL SPENDING",
            "The politicians and special interests turned a $100 billion budget surplus into a $30 billion budget deficit in just three years. They mismanaged our tax dollars so badly, they now want voters to bail them out with permanently higher taxes.",
            "Say NO to $100 billion wasted on a train to nowhere.",
            "Say NO to $37 billion wasted on homeless programs that don’t work.",
            "Say NO to $31 billion wasted on unemployment fraud.",
            "NO ON PROP. 3—FIX SACRAMENTO’S SPENDING PROBLEM BEFORE RAISING TAXES",
            "California doesn’t have a revenue problem. We have a spending problem. California’s population barely grew in the past 10 years, but the politicians more than doubled spending.",
            "It’s not just state taxes that keep going up. Politicians and special interests have imposed more than 2,000 new local tax increases in just the past ten years—making it much harder for struggling Californians to make ends meet.",
            "Californians shouldn’t support any higher taxes until we get spending under control.",
            "STOP WASTEFUL SPENDING.",
            "NO NEW TAXES.",
            "NO ON PROP. 3."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Robert Gutierrez, President",
            "California Taxpayers Association",
            "Robert Rivinius, President",
            "Family Business Association of California",
            "Julian Canete, President",
            "California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Robert Gutierrez",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Taxpayers Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Robert Rivinius",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Family Business Association of California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Julian Canete",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/3/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/3/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop3-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/3/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop3-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROPOSITION 3 PROTECTS OUR SCHOOLS, HEALTHCARE AND OUR COMMUNITIES WITHOUT RAISING YOUR TAXES.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would protect schools, health care, and communities without raising taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 3 is NOT a new tax and does NOT raise taxes on anyone.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would not create a new tax or raise anyone's taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 3 prevents millionaires and billionaires from getting a tax cut",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would prevent millionaires and billionaires from receiving a tax cut.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "The top 2 percent of California taxpayers pay these higher rates.",
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "requires strict accountability and audits to ensure school funding gets to classrooms.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would require accountability measures and audits for school funding.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 3 PREVENTS BILLIONS IN CUTS TO OUR SCHOOLS AND HEALTHCARE.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would prevent billions of dollars in cuts to schools and health care.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Without Prop. 3, California’s 8 million public school and community college students face billions in cuts",
          "claim": "Without Proposition 3, California's 8 million public school and community college students would face billions of dollars in cuts.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "including teacher layoffs, overcrowded classrooms and bigger class sizes.",
          "claim": "Without Proposition 3, school cuts would include teacher layoffs, overcrowded classrooms, and larger class sizes.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Families could lose access to preventive healthcare and affordable prescription drugs",
          "claim": "Without Proposition 3, families could lose access to preventive health care and affordable prescription drugs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "the Medi-Cal coverage that millions of Californians rely on could be put at risk.",
          "claim": "Without Proposition 3, Medi-Cal coverage used by millions of Californians could be at risk.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 3 ONLY EXTENDS THE CURRENT TAX RATES ON THE WEALTHIEST TOP 2%.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would extend current income tax rates that apply only to the wealthiest 2 percent of taxpayers.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "The top 2 percent of California taxpayers pay these higher rates.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 3 maintains the income tax rates that the wealthiest Californians have paid for the past 15 years.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would maintain income tax rates that the wealthiest Californians have paid for the past 15 years.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Voters approved Proposition 30 in 2012 to temporarily increase income tax rates on high-income taxpayers. In 2016, voters approved Proposition 55 to extend these higher rates until 2030.",
          "confidence": 0.83,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "If those tax rates are allowed to expire, it would give millionaires and billionaires a massive tax cut",
          "claim": "Allowing the higher tax rates to expire would give millionaires and billionaires a tax cut.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "at the expense of our classrooms, clinics and communities.",
          "claim": "Allowing the higher tax rates to expire would harm classrooms, clinics, and communities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 3 keeps the existing rates on the top 2% of incomes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would retain the existing rates for the top 2 percent of incomes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "GUARANTEES THE MONEY REACHES THE CLASSROOM— NOT SACRAMENTO.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would guarantee that its money reaches classrooms rather than Sacramento.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Roughly 40 percent of the funding would go to schools and community colleges. The rest would go to other state programs.",
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 3 includes Constitutional protections and tough accountability.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 includes constitutional protections and accountability requirements.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "It guarantees that funds from Proposition 3 go directly to local schools",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would guarantee that its funds go directly to local schools.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Roughly 40 percent of the funding would go to schools and community colleges. The rest would go to other state programs.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "the Legislature and Sacramento politicians cannot touch it, redirect it, or spend a single dollar on bureaucracy or administrative overhead.",
          "claim": "The Legislature and Sacramento politicians would be unable to use or redirect Proposition 3 funds, including for bureaucracy or administrative overhead.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 3’s school guarantee then frees up billions that help fund Medi-Cal for children, seniors and families.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3's school funding guarantee would free up billions of dollars that help fund Medi-Cal for children, seniors, and families.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Roughly 40 percent of the funding would go to schools and community colleges. The rest would go to other state programs.",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Every dollar in Prop. 3 is independently audited every year",
          "claim": "Every Proposition 3 dollar would be independently audited annually.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:21",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "any official who misuses the money faces prosecution and criminal penalties.",
          "claim": "An official who misuses Proposition 3 money would face prosecution and criminal penalties.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:22",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Local school districts must post annual accounting online",
          "claim": "Local school districts would have to post annual accounting online.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:23",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "For more than a decade, these revenues have helped fund critical programs California families and communities count on—from school lunches, smaller class sizes and mental health counselors to children’s healthcare and Medi-Cal.",
          "claim": "For more than a decade, the revenues have helped fund school lunches, smaller classes, mental health counselors, children's health care, and Medi-Cal.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Roughly 40 percent of the funding would go to schools and community colleges. The rest would go to other state programs.",
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_for:24",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "They’ve also helped stave off cuts during economic downturns by investing more in the state’s Rainy Day Fund",
          "claim": "The revenues have helped prevent cuts during economic downturns by increasing investment in the state's Rainy Day Fund.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 3 protects our schools, our healthcare and our communities—without raising your taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would protect schools, health care, and communities without raising taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 3 KEEPS THE TAX RATES THE TOP 2% HAVE PAID FOR THE PAST 15 YEARS",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would keep tax rates paid by the top 2 percent for the past 15 years.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Voters approved Proposition 30 in 2012 to temporarily increase income tax rates on high-income taxpayers. In 2016, voters approved Proposition 55 to extend these higher rates until 2030.",
          "confidence": 0.83,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "DOES NOT RAISE YOUR TAXES.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would not raise taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 3 maintains the current tax rates the wealthiest 2% of Californians have been paying for 15 years",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would maintain current tax rates paid by the wealthiest 2 percent of Californians for 15 years.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "The top 2 percent of California taxpayers pay these higher rates.",
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "couples that earn more than $740,000 continue to pay their fair share.",
          "claim": "Couples earning more than $740,000 would continue paying the applicable tax rates.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "WITHOUT PROP. 3 MILLIONAIRES AND BILLIONAIRES GET A MASSIVE TAX CUT—AND THE REST OF US PAY FOR IT.",
          "claim": "Without Proposition 3, millionaires and billionaires would receive a tax cut and other people would bear its cost.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Teacher and staff layoffs, overcrowded classrooms and fewer counselors in our schools;",
          "claim": "Without Proposition 3, schools would have teacher and staff layoffs, overcrowded classrooms, and fewer counselors.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "cuts to Medi-Cal, children’s healthcare and the clinics families rely on;",
          "claim": "Without Proposition 3, Medi-Cal, children's health care, and family clinics would be cut.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "less for the firefighters, emergency response and wildfire protection that keep our communities safe.",
          "claim": "Without Proposition 3, spending for firefighters, emergency response, and wildfire protection would decline.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 3’s funding goes straight to local schools and community colleges.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 funding would go directly to local schools and community colleges.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Roughly 40 percent of the funding would go to schools and community colleges. The rest would go to other state programs.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Sacramento politicians cannot touch it or redirect it.",
          "claim": "Sacramento politicians would be unable to use or redirect Proposition 3 funding.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Not one penny may be spent on bureaucracy or administrative overhead.",
          "claim": "No Proposition 3 money could be spent on bureaucracy or administrative overhead.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Every dollar is independently audited every year",
          "claim": "Every Proposition 3 dollar would be independently audited annually.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "districts must post their spending online",
          "claim": "Districts would have to post their spending online.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "any official who misuses the money faces prosecution and criminal penalties.",
          "claim": "An official who misuses the money would face prosecution and criminal penalties.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_against:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "By guaranteeing funding for our classrooms, Prop. 3 ensures California can also invest in Medi-Cal and children’s healthcare, and in the firefighters and wildfire protection our communities depend on.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3's classroom funding guarantee would allow California to invest in Medi-Cal, children's health care, firefighters, and wildfire protection.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The rest would go to other state programs. Part of this amount would be set aside in budget reserves the state could use to fund these programs when revenues decline.",
          "confidence": 0.81,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 3—TURNS “TEMPORARY” TAXES INTO PERMANENT HIGHER INCOME TAXES",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would turn temporary higher income taxes into permanent higher income taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Then they spend our tax dollars with no accountability—losing billions to waste, fraud and overspending.",
          "claim": "State politicians spend tax dollars without accountability and lose billions to waste, fraud, and overspending.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Politicians told voters higher income taxes would be temporary—only for seven years to cover a budget deficit.",
          "claim": "Politicians told voters that higher income taxes would be temporary for seven years to cover a budget deficit.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "other_records",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "those “temporary” taxes were extended for another 12 years",
          "claim": "The temporary higher income taxes were extended for another 12 years.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "In 2016, voters approved Proposition 55 to extend these higher rates until 2030.",
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the special interests and politicians want to make these higher income taxes PERMANENT.",
          "claim": "Special interests and politicians seek to make the higher income taxes permanent.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Californians have the nation’s highest cost of living",
          "claim": "Californians have the nation's highest cost of living.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "we also suffer from the highest income taxes, highest sales taxes and highest gas taxes of all fifty states.",
          "claim": "California has the highest income, sales, and gas taxes of all states.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "The same politicians also gave us the highest gasoline prices in the nation, higher insurance costs, higher utility costs, higher food costs, and higher housing costs.",
          "claim": "Politicians caused California to have the nation's highest gasoline prices and higher insurance, utility, food, and housing costs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Now they want to make higher income taxes permanent",
          "claim": "Politicians want to make higher income taxes permanent.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "adding new taxes on your health insurance, new taxes on software",
          "claim": "Politicians are adding new taxes on health insurance and software.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "they are even considering a “jobs” tax.",
          "claim": "Politicians are considering a jobs tax.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Waste, fraud and overspending by state government is not an excuse to raise our taxes even higher.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would raise taxes higher.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "government spending has increased by $150 billion",
          "claim": "Government spending has increased by $150 billion since the temporary increases were first passed.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "a more than 2.5X increase.",
          "claim": "Government spending has increased by more than 2.5 times since the temporary increases were first passed.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "our schools, infrastructure and public safety have gotten worse.",
          "claim": "Schools, infrastructure, and public safety have worsened over that period.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "The politicians and special interests turned a $100 billion budget surplus into a $30 billion budget deficit in just three years.",
          "claim": "Politicians and special interests turned a $100 billion budget surplus into a $30 billion budget deficit in three years.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "They mismanaged our tax dollars so badly, they now want voters to bail them out with permanently higher taxes.",
          "claim": "Politicians seek permanently higher taxes to address consequences of tax-dollar mismanagement.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "$100 billion wasted on a train to nowhere.",
          "claim": "California wasted $100 billion on a train project.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "$37 billion wasted on homeless programs that don’t work.",
          "claim": "California wasted $37 billion on homeless programs that do not work.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "$31 billion wasted on unemployment fraud.",
          "claim": "California wasted $31 billion on unemployment fraud.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:21",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "California doesn’t have a revenue problem. We have a spending problem.",
          "claim": "California's fiscal issue is spending rather than revenue.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:22",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "California’s population barely grew in the past 10 years",
          "claim": "California's population barely grew during the past 10 years.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:23",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the politicians more than doubled spending.",
          "claim": "Politicians more than doubled spending during the past 10 years.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:argument_against:24",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Politicians and special interests have imposed more than 2,000 new local tax increases in just the past ten years",
          "claim": "Politicians and special interests imposed more than 2,000 local tax increases in the past 10 years.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "NO ON PROP. 3—STOP PERMANENTLY HIGHER INCOME TAXES",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would make higher income taxes permanent.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "In 2012, politicians and special interests promised Californians that their income tax increases would be TEMPORARY.",
          "claim": "In 2012, politicians and special interests said the income tax increases would be temporary.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "making those taxes permanent somehow ISN’T a tax increase at all.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 proponents claim that making the taxes permanent is not a tax increase.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 3 locks in what would become the largest permanent state income tax increase in California history",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would create California's largest permanent state income tax increase in history.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "costing taxpayers up to $15 billion every year.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would cost taxpayers up to $15 billion every year.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "In a weak year, the proposition might bring in around $5 billion in revenue to the state. In a strong year, the proposition might bring in $15 billion in revenue to the state. In most years, revenue would be in between these amounts.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "California taxpayers kept their end of the bargain—paying temporary higher income taxes for 16 years.",
          "claim": "California taxpayers paid temporary higher income taxes for 16 years.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 3 does nothing to stop the waste, fraud and reckless spending",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would do nothing to stop waste, fraud, and reckless spending.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "turned a $100 billion budget surplus into a $30 billion deficit in just three years.",
          "claim": "Waste, fraud, and reckless spending turned a $100 billion budget surplus into a $30 billion deficit in three years.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Californians have the highest cost of living and pay the highest income, sales and gas taxes in America.",
          "claim": "Californians have the highest cost of living and pay the highest income, sales, and gas taxes in America.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Making a temporary tax permanent only makes California more expensive.",
          "claim": "Making the temporary tax permanent would make California more expensive.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "California doesn’t have a tax revenue problem—it has a spending problem.",
          "claim": "California's fiscal issue is spending rather than tax revenue.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "California’s population grew by less than 2% in the past decade",
          "claim": "California's population grew by less than 2 percent in the past decade.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "the politicians doubled spending.",
          "claim": "Politicians doubled spending in the past decade.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-3:rebuttal_to_for:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Say no to permanently higher taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 3 would make taxes permanently higher.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 3 makes the higher income tax rates established by Proposition 30 permanent instead of letting them expire in 2031.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-3:analysis": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
            "vig:prop-3:arguments": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-3:overview",
        "vig:prop-3:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-3:analysis",
        "vig:prop-3:arguments",
        "vig:prop-3:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-3:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-4",
      "contest_id": "prop-4",
      "number": "4",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "REPEALS PROHIBITION AGAINST PUBLIC FUNDING OF ELECTION CAMPAIGNS. LEGISLATIVE STATUTE.",
      "measure_type": "legislative_statute",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by the Legislature",
      "summary": "Repeals prohibition on state and local governments offering public funding of candidate election campaigns. Public funding programs may not use funds earmarked for education, transportation, or public safety.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Ongoing costs to the state of a few hundred thousand dollars each year for the Fair Political Practices Commission to answer questions from state and local governments about public campaign finance programs.",
      "supporters": "League of Women Voters of CA; California Nurses Association; Mental Health Advocacy; Social Security Works; Consumer Watchdog",
      "opponents": "California Taxpayers Assn; Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn; Family Business Assn of California; United Latinos Action",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: State and local governments could create public campaign financing programs for public office candidates, subject to limits on which public funds could be used, how the public funds could be used, and who could receive them.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: State and most local governments would remain unable to create public campaign finance programs for public office candidates.",
      "pro_short": "YES ON 4. California is the ONLY state that bans public funding of campaigns— communities in all other 49 states have this right. Special interests want to keep the ban to protect their power. Prop. 4 removes it. Strict taxpayer safeguards. Vote YES: Elections should be won, not bought.",
      "con_short": "Prop. 4 allows politicians to use YOUR taxpayer money to fund their negative campaigns. Prop. 4 has NO LIMIT on the number of candidates who can get taxpayer money and NO LIMIT on how much taxpayer money they can get. Worse yet, Prop. 4 allows SPECIAL INTEREST MONEY IN POLITICS. NO ON PROP. 4.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "Yes on Proposition 4,",
          "Californians for Fair",
          "Elections, sponsored by",
          "Government Reform",
          "Advocates",
          "info@CAFairElections.org",
          "www.CAFairElections.org"
        ],
        "against": [
          "California Taxpayers",
          "Association",
          "www.caltax.org/prop4"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "info@CAFairElections.org",
          "url": "mailto:info@CAFairElections.org"
        },
        {
          "label": "www.CAFairElections.org",
          "url": "https://www.yesfairelections.org/"
        },
        {
          "label": "www.caltax.org/prop4",
          "url": "https://www.caltax.org/prop4"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Current law prohibits state and local governments from using public funds for election campaigns except in charter cities and counties.",
        "This measure repeals that prohibition and allows state and local governments to establish public campaign financing programs for candidates who agree to specified spending limits and meet eligibility criteria.",
        "Prohibits public funding programs from using funds earmarked for education, transportation, or public safety.",
        "Prohibits candidates from using public funds for legal defense costs, fines, or repayment of personal loans to campaigns.",
        "Triples maximum fine for campaign contributions by foreign entities.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Ongoing costs to the state of a few hundred thousand dollars each year for the Fair Political Practices Commission to answer questions from state and local governments about public campaign finance programs.",
        "FINAL VOTES CAST BY THE LEGISLATURE ON SB 42 (PROPOSITION 4)",
        "(CHAPTER 245, STATUTES OF 2025)",
        "Senate:",
        "Ayes 29",
        "Noes 8",
        "Assembly:",
        "Ayes 59",
        "Noes 20",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Political Reform Act. Many people, groups, and businesses spend money to support or oppose candidates for public office and ballot measures. California's Political Reform Act sets rules for how money can be used in politics and requires public reporting of political spending. These rules apply to state and local candidates, ballot measures, and other public officials, but not to federal candidates or officials. (Federal law establishes campaign finance and reporting requirements for federal offices.) The Political Reform Act has been updated by voters over the years.",
            "Ban on Public Funds to Pay for Campaigns. The Political Reform Act bans the use of public funds for political candidates' campaigns. This ban applies to most elected offices at the state level and local level. (This ban does not apply to city office elections in certain charter cities. Los Angeles, San Francisco, Long Beach, Oakland, and Berkeley are current examples of charter cities that provide public funds to certain campaigns.)",
            "Entities That Oversee Campaign Finance Laws. California's campaign finance laws are administered by the Fair Political Practices Commission and the California Secretary of State. State law requires people and groups to report how much money they give, receive, and spend on political campaigns. This information is available to the public on the Secretary of State's website. The Fair Political Practices Commission enforces and interprets the Political Reform Act. The Fair Political Practices Commission reviews the finance reports and can fine candidates and donors who break the law. The Fair Political Practices Commission issues guidance based on its interpretation of the Political Reform Act."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "The Political Reform Act",
              "text": "Many people, groups, and businesses spend money to support or oppose candidates for public office and ballot measures. California's Political Reform Act sets rules for how money can be used in politics and requires public reporting of political spending. These rules apply to state and local candidates, ballot measures, and other public officials, but not to federal candidates or officials. (Federal law establishes campaign finance and reporting requirements for federal offices.) The Political Reform Act has been updated by voters over the years.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Ban on Public Funds to Pay for Campaigns",
              "text": "The Political Reform Act bans the use of public funds for political candidates' campaigns. This ban applies to most elected offices at the state level and local level. (This ban does not apply to city office elections in certain charter cities. Los Angeles, San Francisco, Long Beach, Oakland, and Berkeley are current examples of charter cities that provide public funds to certain campaigns.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Entities That Oversee Campaign Finance Laws",
              "text": "California's campaign finance laws are administered by the Fair Political Practices Commission and the California Secretary of State. State law requires people and groups to report how much money they give, receive, and spend on political campaigns. This information is available to the public on the Secretary of State's website. The Fair Political Practices Commission enforces and interprets the Political Reform Act. The Fair Political Practices Commission reviews the finance reports and can fine candidates and donors who break the law. The Fair Political Practices Commission issues guidance based on its interpretation of the Political Reform Act.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Lifts Ban on Use of Public Funds to Pay for Candidates' Campaigns. Proposition 4 lifts the ban on using public funds for political candidates' campaigns. Removing the ban allows state and local governments to create public campaign financing programs in the future if they wish. Proposition 4 does not create a public campaign finance system for the state or local governments directly.",
            "Sets Rules for Future State and Local Public Campaign Finance Programs. Proposition 4 sets broad rules for future state and local public campaign finance programs but leaves many key design decisions to future state and local decision makers. Proposition 4 limits which public funds can be used for campaigns, who can receive the funds, and how the funds can be spent in any future public campaign finance program. For example, money meant for education, transportation, or public safety cannot be used for campaigns. Candidates can only receive public funds if they show broad-based support in their district and agree to spending limits and other program rules. Public funds cannot be used for legal defense fees or fines, or to repay a candidate's personal campaign loan. State and local governments can design and implement their own programs within the broad rules set by Proposition 4.",
            "Fair Political Practices Commission Would Issue Guidance on Public Campaign Finance Programs. Proposition 4 specifies that the Fair Political Practices Commission is not required to administer or enforce local public campaign finance programs. Rather, state and local government officials could ask the Fair Political Practices Commission for guidance on how to create public campaign finance programs consistent with Proposition 4."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Lifts Ban on Use of Public Funds to Pay for Candidates' Campaigns",
              "text": "Proposition 4 lifts the ban on using public funds for political candidates' campaigns. Removing the ban allows state and local governments to create public campaign financing programs in the future if they wish. Proposition 4 does not create a public campaign finance system for the state or local governments directly.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Sets Rules for Future State and Local Public Campaign Finance Programs",
              "text": "Proposition 4 sets broad rules for future state and local public campaign finance programs but leaves many key design decisions to future state and local decision makers. Proposition 4 limits which public funds can be used for campaigns, who can receive the funds, and how the funds can be spent in any future public campaign finance program. For example, money meant for education, transportation, or public safety cannot be used for campaigns. Candidates can only receive public funds if they show broad-based support in their district and agree to spending limits and other program rules. Public funds cannot be used for legal defense fees or fines, or to repay a candidate's personal campaign loan. State and local governments can design and implement their own programs within the broad rules set by Proposition 4.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Fair Political Practices Commission Would Issue Guidance on Public Campaign Finance Programs",
              "text": "Proposition 4 specifies that the Fair Political Practices Commission is not required to administer or enforce local public campaign finance programs. Rather, state and local government officials could ask the Fair Political Practices Commission for guidance on how to create public campaign finance programs consistent with Proposition 4.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Costs of Possible Public Campaign Finance Programs Depend on Future Decisions. Proposition 4 does not create a public campaign finance program. However, it allows state and local governments to create such programs in the future. The cost of these programs could be significant for governments that choose to create them. The total cost would depend on which governments created such programs and how those programs were designed.",
            "Minor State Costs to Support State and Local Governments Considering Public Campaign Finance Programs. If voters approve Proposition 4, state and local government officials likely would ask the Fair Political Practices Commission for guidance on creating public campaign finance programs under the Political Reform Act. This likely would require the Fair Political Practices Commission to hire more legal staff to help answer these questions. As a result, state costs would be a few hundred thousand dollars each year. This amount is much less than one-tenth of 1 percent (0.1 percent) of the state's total General Fund budget. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.)"
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Costs of Possible Public Campaign Finance Programs Depend on Future Decisions",
              "text": "Proposition 4 does not create a public campaign finance program. However, it allows state and local governments to create such programs in the future. The cost of these programs could be significant for governments that choose to create them. The total cost would depend on which governments created such programs and how those programs were designed.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Minor State Costs to Support State and Local Governments Considering Public Campaign Finance Programs",
              "text": "If voters approve Proposition 4, state and local government officials likely would ask the Fair Political Practices Commission for guidance on creating public campaign finance programs under the Political Reform Act. This likely would require the Fair Political Practices Commission to hire more legal staff to help answer these questions. As a result, state costs would be a few hundred thousand dollars each year. This amount is much less than one-tenth of 1 percent (0.1 percent) of the state's total General Fund budget. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Here is what the politicians supporting Proposition 4 do not tell you:",
            "Proposition 4 REPEALS the voter-approved law that PROHIBITS candidates from using taxpayer money to run for office.",
            "Proposition 4 has NO LIMIT on the number of candidates who can get taxpayer money. In the election last June, more than 60 candidates ran for Governor. Proposition 4 would allow thousands of candidates to get taxpayer money!",
            "Proposition 4 has NO LIMIT on how much taxpayer money a candidate can get. Proposition 4 opens the door to taxpayer-funded campaigns but provides no limits on how much taxpayer money a candidate can get and NO LIMIT on spending. It will lead to more negative ads, more junk mail, and more annoying text messages.",
            "Proposition 4 does NOT PROHIBIT SPECIAL INTEREST MONEY in campaigns. Proposition 4 ALLOWS candidates to get taxpayer money AND to get special interest money! Where exactly is the money going to come from to fund thousands of political campaigns? Proposition 4 does not say. But you know the answer. It is coming from YOU, the taxpayers! Less money for schools, less money for public safety, less money for healthcare. More money for politicians.",
            "Proposition 4 is a BLANK CHECK. It is based on false promises and failed solutions.",
            "Proposition 4 does NOT protect taxpayers. That is why Proposition 4 is opposed by California's leading taxpayer organizations.",
            "Proposition 4 does NOT provide for “fair elections.” That is why Proposition 4 is opposed by former Commissioners of the Fair Political Practices Commission.",
            "Vote NO ON PROPOSITION 4."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Robert Gutierrez, President",
            "California Taxpayers Association",
            "Jon Coupal, President",
            "Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association",
            "Dan Schnur, Former Chair",
            "Fair Political Practices Commission"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Robert Gutierrez",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Taxpayers Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Jon Coupal",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Dan Schnur",
              "title": "Former Chair",
              "organization": "Fair Political Practices Commission"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "DON'T BE MISLED BY SPECIAL INTERESTS WHO WANT TO KEEP BUYING ELECTIONS",
            "California is the ONLY state that bans public funding of campaigns. Communities in all 49 other states have the right to adopt public financing to allow qualified candidates to compete against wealthy donors. California doesn't. Prop. 4 simply removes that ban and gives local voters the same choice everyone else has, while instituting strict taxpayer safeguards.",
            "PROP. 4 GIVES POWER BACK TO LOCAL COMMUNITIES AND EMPOWERS VOTERS, NOT DONORS",
            "Prop. 4 doesn't spend a single taxpayer dollar or institute public financing anywhere. It simply removes the ban to give every city, county, and the state the right to adopt public funding if local voters want it. The details are appropriately left to each community. But any system MUST require candidates to abide by spending limits and demonstrate broad-based support in their district to qualify.",
            "PROP. 4 MAKES ELECTED OFFICIALS ACCOUNTABLE TO VOTERS, NOT DONORS",
            "Corporate special interests oppose Prop. 4 because public financing allows candidates to run and win without relying on them—threatening their grip on California elections.",
            "Thousands of candidates from different backgrounds have been elected across the country using public financing, for a tiny cost. Because they don't rely on wealthy donors, they can speak their minds and work for the people, not special interests.",
            "DON'T BE FOOLED BY CORPORATE SPECIAL INTERESTS HIDING BEHIND NICE-SOUNDING NAMES.",
            "VOTE YES ON 4 to let local voters and communities reclaim their elections so they're won, not bought."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Carmen Balber, Executive Director",
            "Consumer Watchdog",
            "Camerina Davidson, President",
            "California National Organization for Women",
            "Darius Kemp, Executive Director",
            "California Common Cause"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Carmen Balber",
              "title": "Executive Director",
              "organization": "Consumer Watchdog"
            },
            {
              "name": "Camerina Davidson",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California National Organization for Women"
            },
            {
              "name": "Darius Kemp",
              "title": "Executive Director",
              "organization": "California Common Cause"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "YES ON PROPOSITION 4, THE CALIFORNIA FAIR ELECTIONS ACT: ELECTIONS SHOULD BE WON, NOT BOUGHT",
            "The amount of money in California elections is outrageous; it's distorting our democracy. Since 2020, more than $1 billion has been spent on California state candidate races alone. This massive spending gives special interests greater access and influence while drowning out the voices of ordinary Californians.",
            "PROP. 4 HELPS QUALIFIED CANDIDATES COMPETE",
            "Running for office today often requires either personal wealth or access to wealthy donors. Deep pockets have become an unofficial requirement to run for office, leaving too many qualified candidates behind.",
            "PROP. 4 CHANGES THE WAY WE FINANCE ELECTION CAMPAIGNS",
            "Programs like small-dollar donation matching help candidates compete without relying on wealthy donors. However, most California communities are banned from using these tools, allowing the influence of big money to grow.",
            "Proposition 4 lifts that ban, giving voters and local governments the option to adopt public financing with strict safeguards so qualified candidates—regardless of their income—can compete against candidates who are backed by wealthy interests.",
            "PROP. 4 BUILDS ON A PROVEN MODEL",
            "We know this reform works because it's working in other states. Thousands of candidates from different backgrounds have been elected in fourteen states and 26 localities using similar systems. They are new people with good ideas from all walks of life. Because they don't rely on wealthy donors, they can speak their mind and work for the people, not the special interests.",
            "PROP. 4 GIVES LOCAL COMMUNITIES A CHOICE",
            "Proposition 4 does not create a public financing program. It simply gives local governments the option to adopt one if they choose.",
            "If a community does, the cost is as little as $1 per resident each year—a small investment to help counter the billions spent influencing California's elections.",
            "PROP. 4 PROTECTS TAXPAYERS",
            "Taxpayer Safeguards:",
            "Requires candidates to meet strict eligibility criteria and abide by spending limits to qualify for public funds.",
            "Prohibits public funding from favoring incumbents or discriminating based on political party.",
            "Prohibits the use of public funds for legal defense or fines.",
            "PROP. 4 CRACKS DOWN ON ILLEGAL FOREIGN MONEY",
            "Proposition 4 triples the maximum fines for illegal foreign campaign contributions and expenditures, strengthening penalties for those who attempt to interfere in California's elections.",
            "PROP. 4 IS SUPPORTED BY LEADERS ACROSS CALIFORNIA",
            "Proposition 4 is backed by a broad coalition including League of Women Voters of California, California Nurses Association, Mental Health Advocacy Services, Social Security Works, California Clean Money Campaign, California Common Cause, California National Organization for Women, Californians for Disability Rights, Consumer Watchdog, Courage California, Democracy for America, Indivisible California: Statestrong, La Defensa, Money Out Voters In, Voters Right to Know, and many others.",
            "PROP. 4 GIVES CALIFORNIANS THE OPPORTUNITY TO RECLAIM THEIR ELECTIONS and ensure they reflect the values of the people, not just the wealthiest donors.",
            "YES ON 4—Restore power to voters, not wealthy donors"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Lorrel Plimier, Co-President",
            "League of Women Voters of California",
            "Catherine Kennedy, President",
            "California Nurses Association",
            "Tom Umberg, California State Senator"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Lorrel Plimier",
              "title": "Co-President",
              "organization": "League of Women Voters of California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Catherine Kennedy",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Nurses Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Tom Umberg",
              "title": "California State Senator",
              "organization": null
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Why did Sacramento politicians put Proposition 4 on the ballot? They want access to YOUR TAXPAYER MONEY to fund THEIR OWN CAMPAIGNS.",
            "Proposition 4 repeals a voter approved law that PROHIBITS these politicians from using public taxpayer funds for their own campaigns. That's right, Proposition 4 allows politicians to use your taxpayer money to fund their campaigns.",
            "Proposition 4 has NO LIMIT on the number of candidates who can get taxpayer money and NO LIMIT on how much money they can get! Proposition 4 is a BLANK CHECK. There isn't even a limit on how much they can spend on their campaigns! More negative ads. More junk mail. More annoying text messages. More, more, more.",
            "Proposition 4 is so poorly written, it could allow every state or local “candidate” to get public funding. They don't even have to actually qualify for the ballot to get taxpayer money. Proposition 4 allows for public funding of thousands of state and local candidates. It even allows for public financing of candidates for county political party committees.",
            "In just the last primary election, there were more than 60 candidates for Governor. Do you want YOUR TAXPAYER MONEY going to support more of their negative campaign ads and junk mail?",
            "Proposition 4 has NO LIMIT on how much taxpayer money a candidate can receive. It says it requires “strict criteria” to receive taxpayer funds but provides NO DETAILS on what the criteria are! Read the fine print:",
            "“‘Strict criteria' means the requirement set by statute, ordinance, or charter that candidates must meet to receive public funds.”",
            "But there is no current statute, ordinance or charter setting any criteria. Guess who will be setting the criteria? The same politicians who want to get your taxpayer money!",
            "Some good government groups support public financing of campaigns because they want to get special interest money out of politics. BUT PROPOSITION 4 DOES NOT GET RID OF SPECIAL INTEREST MONEY! Under Proposition 4, candidates can raise money from special interests AND get public funding too.",
            "Proposition 4 is the worst kind of public financing scheme. It provides no specifics. It leaves all the details to be worked out by the same politicians who want to get access to public funds.",
            "It is a blank check. But worse than that, Proposition 4 allows special-interest funding of political campaigns.",
            "Please join California's leading taxpayer protection organizations, including the California Taxpayers Association, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, the Family Business Association of California, United Latinos Action, as well as former members of California's Fair Political Practices Commission, who all oppose Proposition 4.",
            "PLEASE VOTE NO ON THE POLITICIANS' BLANK CHECK PROPOSITION. VOTE NO ON PROP. 4."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Dan Schnur, Former Chair",
            "Fair Political Practices Commission",
            "Colleen McAndrews, Former Commissioner",
            "Fair Political Practices Commission",
            "Julian Canete, President",
            "California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Dan Schnur",
              "title": "Former Chair",
              "organization": "Fair Political Practices Commission"
            },
            {
              "name": "Colleen McAndrews",
              "title": "Former Commissioner",
              "organization": "Fair Political Practices Commission"
            },
            {
              "name": "Julian Canete",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/4/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/4/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop4-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/4/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop4-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Since 2020, more than $1 billion has been spent on California state candidate races alone.",
          "claim": "More than $1 billion has been spent on California state candidate races since 2020.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "This massive spending gives special interests greater access and influence while drowning out the voices of ordinary Californians.",
          "claim": "Large campaign spending gives special interests greater access and influence and reduces the influence of ordinary Californians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Running for office today often requires either personal wealth or access to wealthy donors.",
          "claim": "Running for office often requires personal wealth or access to wealthy donors.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Deep pockets have become an unofficial requirement to run for office, leaving too many qualified candidates behind.",
          "claim": "Personal wealth has become an unofficial requirement for running for office and excludes qualified candidates.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Programs like small-dollar donation matching help candidates compete without relying on wealthy donors.",
          "claim": "Small-dollar donation matching programs help candidates compete without relying on wealthy donors.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "most California communities are banned from using these tools",
          "claim": "Most California communities are barred from using public campaign-financing tools such as small-dollar donation matching.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "The Political Reform Act bans the use of public funds for political candidates' campaigns. This ban applies to most elected offices at the state level and local level.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "allowing the influence of big money to grow.",
          "claim": "The ban on these tools allows big-money influence to grow.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 lifts that ban",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 lifts the ban on public campaign financing.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 4 lifts the ban on using public funds for political candidates' campaigns.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "giving voters and local governments the option to adopt public financing",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 gives voters and local governments an option to adopt public campaign financing.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Removing the ban allows state and local governments to create public campaign financing programs in the future if they wish.",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "with strict safeguards",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 includes strict safeguards for public financing.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 4 sets broad rules for future state and local public campaign finance programs but leaves many key design decisions to future state and local decision makers.",
          "confidence": 0.74,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "so qualified candidates—regardless of their income—can compete against candidates who are backed by wealthy interests.",
          "claim": "Public financing would enable qualified candidates regardless of income to compete against candidates backed by wealthy interests.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "We know this reform works because it's working in other states.",
          "claim": "Similar public-financing reforms work in other states.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Thousands of candidates from different backgrounds have been elected in fourteen states and 26 localities using similar systems.",
          "claim": "Thousands of candidates from different backgrounds have been elected using similar systems in fourteen states and 26 localities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Because they don't rely on wealthy donors, they can speak their mind and work for the people, not the special interests.",
          "claim": "Candidates using similar systems can speak freely and work for people rather than special interests because they do not rely on wealthy donors.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 does not create a public financing program.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 does not directly create a public campaign-financing program.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 4 does not create a public campaign finance system for the state or local governments directly.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "It simply gives local governments the option to adopt one if they choose.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 allows local governments to adopt a public campaign-financing program if they choose.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Removing the ban allows state and local governments to create public campaign financing programs in the future if they wish.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "the cost is as little as $1 per resident each year",
          "claim": "A community's public campaign-financing program can cost as little as $1 per resident each year.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The cost of these programs could be significant for governments that choose to create them. The total cost would depend on which governments created such programs and how those programs were designed.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Requires candidates to meet strict eligibility criteria and abide by spending limits to qualify for public funds.",
          "claim": "Candidates must meet eligibility criteria and agree to spending limits to receive public funds.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Candidates can only receive public funds if they show broad-based support in their district and agree to spending limits and other program rules.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prohibits public funding from favoring incumbents or discriminating based on political party.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 prohibits public campaign financing from favoring incumbents or discriminating based on political party.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prohibits the use of public funds for legal defense or fines.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 prohibits using public funds for legal defense or fines.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Public funds cannot be used for legal defense fees or fines, or to repay a candidate's personal campaign loan.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_for:21",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 triples the maximum fines for illegal foreign campaign contributions and expenditures",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 triples maximum fines for illegal foreign campaign contributions and expenditures.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "SPECIAL INTERESTS WHO WANT TO KEEP BUYING ELECTIONS",
          "claim": "Special interests want to continue buying elections.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "California is the ONLY state that bans public funding of campaigns.",
          "claim": "California is the only state that bans public funding of campaigns.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Communities in all 49 other states have the right to adopt public financing",
          "claim": "Communities in all other states may adopt public campaign financing.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "California doesn't.",
          "claim": "California communities do not have the right to adopt public campaign financing.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "This ban does not apply to city office elections in certain charter cities. Los Angeles, San Francisco, Long Beach, Oakland, and Berkeley are current examples of charter cities that provide public funds to certain campaigns.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 4 simply removes that ban and gives local voters the same choice everyone else has",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 removes the ban and gives local voters a choice to adopt public campaign financing.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Removing the ban allows state and local governments to create public campaign financing programs in the future if they wish.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 4 doesn't spend a single taxpayer dollar or institute public financing anywhere.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 neither spends taxpayer money nor directly establishes public campaign financing.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "As a result, state costs would be a few hundred thousand dollars each year.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "It simply removes the ban to give every city, county, and the state the right to adopt public funding if local voters want it.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 removes the ban and allows every city, county, and the state to adopt public financing if local voters want it.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "State and local governments can design and implement their own programs within the broad rules set by Proposition 4.",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The details are appropriately left to each community.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 leaves program details to local communities.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 4 sets broad rules for future state and local public campaign finance programs but leaves many key design decisions to future state and local decision makers.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "any system MUST require candidates to abide by spending limits and demonstrate broad-based support in their district to qualify.",
          "claim": "Any future public campaign-financing system must require candidates to agree to spending limits and demonstrate broad-based district support.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Candidates can only receive public funds if they show broad-based support in their district and agree to spending limits and other program rules.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Corporate special interests oppose Prop. 4 because public financing allows candidates to run and win without relying on them",
          "claim": "Corporate special interests oppose Proposition 4 because public financing would let candidates run and win without relying on them.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Thousands of candidates from different backgrounds have been elected across the country using public financing, for a tiny cost.",
          "claim": "Thousands of candidates from different backgrounds have been elected across the country using public financing at low cost.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_against:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Because they don't rely on wealthy donors, they can speak their minds and work for the people, not special interests.",
          "claim": "Publicly financed candidates can speak freely and work for people rather than special interests because they do not rely on wealthy donors.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "They want access to YOUR TAXPAYER MONEY to fund THEIR OWN CAMPAIGNS.",
          "claim": "Sacramento politicians put Proposition 4 on the ballot because they want taxpayer money for their own campaigns.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 repeals a voter approved law that PROHIBITS these politicians from using public taxpayer funds for their own campaigns.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 repeals a voter-approved prohibition on using public funds for political candidates' campaigns.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 4 lifts the ban on using public funds for political candidates' campaigns.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 allows politicians to use your taxpayer money to fund their campaigns.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 permits public money to be used for politicians' campaigns.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Removing the ban allows state and local governments to create public campaign financing programs in the future if they wish. Proposition 4 does not create a public campaign finance system for the state or local governments directly.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 has NO LIMIT on the number of candidates who can get taxpayer money",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 sets no numerical limit on candidates who can receive public funds.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "NO LIMIT on how much money they can get!",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 sets no limit on the amount of public funding a candidate can receive.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "There isn't even a limit on how much they can spend on their campaigns!",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 does not limit how much publicly funded candidates may spend on campaigns.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Candidates can only receive public funds if they show broad-based support in their district and agree to spending limits and other program rules.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "More negative ads. More junk mail. More annoying text messages.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 will result in more negative advertisements, junk mail, and text messages.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "it could allow every state or local “candidate” to get public funding.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 could allow every state or local candidate to receive public funding.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Candidates can only receive public funds if they show broad-based support in their district and agree to spending limits and other program rules.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "They don't even have to actually qualify for the ballot to get taxpayer money.",
          "claim": "A person can receive public funds without qualifying for the ballot.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 allows for public funding of thousands of state and local candidates.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 allows public funding of thousands of state and local candidates.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "State and local governments can design and implement their own programs within the broad rules set by Proposition 4.",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It even allows for public financing of candidates for county political party committees.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 allows public financing for candidates for county political party committees.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "In just the last primary election, there were more than 60 candidates for Governor.",
          "claim": "More than 60 candidates ran for Governor in the most recent primary election.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It says it requires “strict criteria” to receive taxpayer funds but provides NO DETAILS on what the criteria are!",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 requires strict criteria for public funds but does not provide details about those criteria.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Candidates can only receive public funds if they show broad-based support in their district and agree to spending limits and other program rules.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": {
            "from_label": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "to_label": "context_missing",
            "reason": "The analysis names two conditions (broad-based support, agreeing to spending limits) and leaves many design decisions to future decision makers. It describes broad rules, so 'no details' is missing context, not the opposite of the analysis.",
            "reviewed_by": "agent verifier, PR #37 review",
            "reviewed_at": "2026-10-08"
          },
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "“‘Strict criteria' means the requirement set by statute, ordinance, or charter that candidates must meet to receive public funds.”",
          "claim": "The measure defines strict criteria as requirements set by statute, ordinance, or charter that candidates must meet to receive public funds.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "But there is no current statute, ordinance or charter setting any criteria.",
          "claim": "No current statute, ordinance, or charter establishes criteria for receiving public campaign funds.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Guess who will be setting the criteria? The same politicians who want to get your taxpayer money!",
          "claim": "Politicians seeking taxpayer money for campaigns will set the eligibility criteria.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Some good government groups support public financing of campaigns because they want to get special interest money out of politics.",
          "claim": "Some good-government groups support public campaign financing because they want to reduce special-interest money in politics.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "PROPOSITION 4 DOES NOT GET RID OF SPECIAL INTEREST MONEY!",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 does not eliminate special-interest money from campaigns.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Under Proposition 4, candidates can raise money from special interests AND get public funding too.",
          "claim": "Candidates may receive both special-interest money and public funding under Proposition 4.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It provides no specifics.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 provides no specifics for public campaign-financing programs.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 4 limits which public funds can be used for campaigns, who can receive the funds, and how the funds can be spent in any future public campaign finance program.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": {
            "from_label": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "to_label": "context_missing",
            "reason": "The analysis says the measure sets broad rules on which funds, who, and how, and leaves many key design decisions open. 'No specifics' overstates that; it is missing context, not a contradiction.",
            "reviewed_by": "agent verifier, PR #37 review",
            "reviewed_at": "2026-10-08"
          },
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:21",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It leaves all the details to be worked out by the same politicians who want to get access to public funds.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 leaves all program details to politicians who want access to public funds.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 4 sets broad rules for future state and local public campaign finance programs but leaves many key design decisions to future state and local decision makers.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": {
            "from_label": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "to_label": "context_missing",
            "reason": "The analysis says the measure 'leaves many key design decisions to future state and local decision makers', which largely agrees with 'leaves all the details'. Missing context, not a contradiction.",
            "reviewed_by": "agent verifier, PR #37 review",
            "reviewed_at": "2026-10-08"
          },
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:argument_against:22",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 allows special-interest funding of political campaigns.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 allows special-interest funding of political campaigns.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 REPEALS the voter-approved law that PROHIBITS candidates from using taxpayer money to run for office.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 repeals a voter-approved prohibition on candidates using taxpayer money for campaigns.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 4 lifts the ban on using public funds for political candidates' campaigns.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 has NO LIMIT on the number of candidates who can get taxpayer money.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 sets no numerical limit on candidates who can receive public funds.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "In the election last June, more than 60 candidates ran for Governor.",
          "claim": "More than 60 candidates ran for Governor in the election last June.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 would allow thousands of candidates to get taxpayer money!",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 would allow thousands of candidates to receive public funds.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Candidates can only receive public funds if they show broad-based support in their district and agree to spending limits and other program rules.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 has NO LIMIT on how much taxpayer money a candidate can get.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 sets no limit on public funds a candidate can receive.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 opens the door to taxpayer-funded campaigns",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 permits future taxpayer-funded campaign programs.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Removing the ban allows state and local governments to create public campaign financing programs in the future if they wish.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "provides no limits on how much taxpayer money a candidate can get",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 provides no limits on how much public funding a candidate can receive.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "NO LIMIT on spending.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 imposes no campaign spending limits.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Candidates can only receive public funds if they show broad-based support in their district and agree to spending limits and other program rules.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It will lead to more negative ads, more junk mail, and more annoying text messages.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 will lead to more negative advertisements, junk mail, and text messages.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 does NOT PROHIBIT SPECIAL INTEREST MONEY in campaigns.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 does not prohibit special-interest money in campaigns.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 ALLOWS candidates to get taxpayer money AND to get special interest money!",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 allows candidates to receive both public money and special-interest money.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 4 does not say.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 does not specify where money for public campaign financing would come from.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It is coming from YOU, the taxpayers!",
          "claim": "Taxpayers will fund the public campaign-financing programs enabled by Proposition 4.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The cost of these programs could be significant for governments that choose to create them. The total cost would depend on which governments created such programs and how those programs were designed.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Less money for schools, less money for public safety, less money for healthcare.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 will reduce money available for schools, public safety, and health care.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-4:rebuttal_to_for:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "More money for politicians.",
          "claim": "Proposition 4 will result in more public money for politicians.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 4 does not create a public campaign finance program. However, it allows state and local governments to create such programs in the future.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-4:analysis": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
            "vig:prop-4:arguments": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-4:overview",
        "vig:prop-4:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-4:analysis",
        "vig:prop-4:arguments",
        "vig:prop-4:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-4:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-5",
      "contest_id": "prop-5",
      "number": "5",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "CHANGES RECALL ELECTION PROCESS FOR STATEWIDE OFFICERS. LEGISLATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.",
      "measure_type": "legislative_constitutional_amendment",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by the Legislature",
      "summary": "Under current law, voters elect replacement candidates at the same time as the recall election. This measure instead fills recall vacancies by subsequent special election or appointment.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Net fiscal effect unknown. In the event of a recall, savings or costs of millions of dollars to administer the election depending on the office recalled.",
      "supporters": "None submitted",
      "opponents": "None submitted",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: Recall elections would no longer include a question about who should fill the vacancy. Instead, vacancies typically would be filled through special elections or appointments, depending on the office and timing.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: Voters would continue to be asked who should fill the vacancy as part of recall elections.",
      "pro_short": "Proposition 5 restores the recall to its original purpose: removing corrupt officials. It closes the loophole that allows replacements to win with a small fraction of the vote, reducing the politics and costs of future recalls. Endorsed by League of Women Voters of California and California Common Cause. Vote YES",
      "con_short": "Proposition 5 degrades California’s century-old recall process by limiting voters’ right to select a replacement for recalled officials. Instead, when statewide elected officials are recalled, other politicians would choose a replacement. For lower offices, another costly, taxpayer-funded election would come months later, leaving the office vacant and the people unrepresented.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "Josh Newman",
          "Californians for a Prosperous",
          "Golden State",
          "101 E. Commonwealth Ave.",
          "Suite A, Fullerton 92832",
          "(818) 585-4601",
          "hello@fixtherecall.com",
          "fixtherecall.com"
        ],
        "against": []
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "hello@fixtherecall.com",
          "url": "mailto:hello@fixtherecall.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "fixtherecall.com",
          "url": "https://fixtherecall.com/"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Under current law, voters decide at the same election whether (1) to recall a state officer, and (2) who will replace that officer if recalled.",
        "Under this measure:",
        "if the Governor is recalled, the Lieutenant Governor becomes Governor for the remainder of the term or until a successor is elected;",
        "for all other recalled officers, the office will remain vacant until filled by a subsequent special election or appointment as specified in existing law; and",
        "a recalled officer may be a candidate in a special election to fill the office.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Net fiscal effect unknown. Possible state and local government savings or costs of millions of dollars to administer recall elections. These costs or savings would be rare, and depend on the office recalled and how often recalls occur.",
        "FINAL VOTES CAST BY THE LEGISLATURE ON SCA 1 (PROPOSITION 5)",
        "(CHAPTER 204, STATUTES OF 2024)",
        "Senate:",
        "Ayes 32",
        "Noes 8",
        "Assembly:",
        "Ayes 59",
        "Noes 17",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Election of State Officials. The State Constitution establishes legislative, executive, and judicial state offices. Some state officials represent parts of the state, known as districts. Other state officials, like the Governor or Attorney General, represent the entire state. Voters elect people to represent them in state offices for set terms. For example, a state Assembly Member is elected to a two-year term and the Governor is elected to a four-year term. To run for a state office, candidates must submit specific nomination documents before the election. State law sets when this “nomination period” occurs.",
            "Recall of State Officials. The State Constitution allows voters to remove state officials from office before their term ends through a recall. A recall is an election in which voters are asked whether to remove an official from office. To qualify a recall for the ballot, supporters of the recall must collect a certain number of signatures from the official’s district (or statewide for statewide offices). Since 1913, 11 state recall efforts have qualified for the ballot (nine legislators and two Governors) and six have resulted in an official’s removal from office (five legislators and one Governor).",
            "Two Questions in Recall Elections. In a recall election, voters are asked two questions: (1) whether the official should be removed from office and (2) who should replace the official if removed from office. The number of candidates appearing in the second question varies. For example, there were 135 candidates in the 2003 Governor recall election and 46 candidates in the 2021 Governor recall election. If a state official is recalled, the person who receives the most votes in the second question assumes the office.",
            "Vacant State Offices. State officials may leave office before the end of their term for reasons other than a recall. For example, they may die or resign. When this happens, the office becomes vacant. The process to fill a vacant office varies by office. Typically, a vacant seat in the Assembly or Senate is filled through a special election called by the Governor. The Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor when there is a vacancy in the office of the Governor. Vacancies in other executive offices (for example, the Lieutenant Governor or Attorney General) and the Supreme Court and Courts of Appeal are filled by appointments by the Governor.",
            "Frequency of Elections. Statewide elections in California are scheduled every two years. In scheduled election years, a primary election is held in either March or June, depending on the year, and a general election is held in November. In addition to scheduled elections, the state and local governments may call special elections to address specific issues. For example, the Governor may call a special election to fill a vacant Assembly seat.",
            "Elections Administration in California. County elections officials administer most elections in California. As part of this work, they print and mail ballots and other voting materials to registered voters. Some state agencies also have election-related workload. For example, the Secretary of State oversees elections across the state and prepares and mails the state Voter Information Guide.",
            "Paying for State Recall Elections. State law requires the California Department of Finance to work with state and local elections officials to estimate the cost of a recall election for a state office. The department is required to send the estimate to the Legislature. The Legislature reviews the estimate and may provide funding for the election. Any remaining costs are paid by the Secretary of State’s and counties’ budgets."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Election of State Officials",
              "text": "The State Constitution establishes legislative, executive, and judicial state offices. Some state officials represent parts of the state, known as districts. Other state officials, like the Governor or Attorney General, represent the entire state. Voters elect people to represent them in state offices for set terms. For example, a state Assembly Member is elected to a two-year term and the Governor is elected to a four-year term. To run for a state office, candidates must submit specific nomination documents before the election. State law sets when this “nomination period” occurs.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Recall of State Officials",
              "text": "The State Constitution allows voters to remove state officials from office before their term ends through a recall. A recall is an election in which voters are asked whether to remove an official from office. To qualify a recall for the ballot, supporters of the recall must collect a certain number of signatures from the official’s district (or statewide for statewide offices). Since 1913, 11 state recall efforts have qualified for the ballot (nine legislators and two Governors) and six have resulted in an official’s removal from office (five legislators and one Governor).",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Two Questions in Recall Elections",
              "text": "In a recall election, voters are asked two questions: (1) whether the official should be removed from office and (2) who should replace the official if removed from office. The number of candidates appearing in the second question varies. For example, there were 135 candidates in the 2003 Governor recall election and 46 candidates in the 2021 Governor recall election. If a state official is recalled, the person who receives the most votes in the second question assumes the office.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Vacant State Offices",
              "text": "State officials may leave office before the end of their term for reasons other than a recall. For example, they may die or resign. When this happens, the office becomes vacant. The process to fill a vacant office varies by office. Typically, a vacant seat in the Assembly or Senate is filled through a special election called by the Governor. The Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor when there is a vacancy in the office of the Governor. Vacancies in other executive offices (for example, the Lieutenant Governor or Attorney General) and the Supreme Court and Courts of Appeal are filled by appointments by the Governor.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Frequency of Elections",
              "text": "Statewide elections in California are scheduled every two years. In scheduled election years, a primary election is held in either March or June, depending on the year, and a general election is held in November. In addition to scheduled elections, the state and local governments may call special elections to address specific issues. For example, the Governor may call a special election to fill a vacant Assembly seat.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Elections Administration in California",
              "text": "County elections officials administer most elections in California. As part of this work, they print and mail ballots and other voting materials to registered voters. Some state agencies also have election-related workload. For example, the Secretary of State oversees elections across the state and prepares and mails the state Voter Information Guide.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Paying for State Recall Elections",
              "text": "State law requires the California Department of Finance to work with state and local elections officials to estimate the cost of a recall election for a state office. The department is required to send the estimate to the Legislature. The Legislature reviews the estimate and may provide funding for the election. Any remaining costs are paid by the Secretary of State’s and counties’ budgets.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "As described below, Proposition 5 changes the recall process to make it like the existing process for filling vacant state offices, except for the process to recall the Governor.",
            "Removes Second Question From Recall Elections. Proposition 5 removes the second question—who should replace a recalled official—from a recall election. This means, in future recall elections, voters would only decide whether to remove an elected official from a state office, not who would replace the official.",
            "Specifies Steps for Filling Vacant Offices. If a state official is recalled, Proposition 5 makes the office of the recalled official vacant. Except for the office of the Governor, Proposition 5 uses the existing process for filling vacancies to fill the office. In the case of an office in the state Senate or Assembly, this means that a replacement typically would be elected through a separate special election. The Governor would choose who would fill a vacancy in any other office (other than office of the Governor).",
            "Creates Separate Process for Filling the Office of the Governor. The process for filling the office of the Governor depends on when the recall occurs. If the Governor is recalled before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the term, Proposition 5 says that the Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor until voters elect a new Governor at a future statewide election. If the Governor is recalled later in the term, the Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor for the rest of the term."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "As described below, Proposition 5 changes the recall process to make it like the existing process for filling vacant state offices, except for the process to recall the Governor.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Removes Second Question From Recall Elections",
              "text": "Proposition 5 removes the second question—who should replace a recalled official—from a recall election. This means, in future recall elections, voters would only decide whether to remove an elected official from a state office, not who would replace the official.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Specifies Steps for Filling Vacant Offices",
              "text": "If a state official is recalled, Proposition 5 makes the office of the recalled official vacant. Except for the office of the Governor, Proposition 5 uses the existing process for filling vacancies to fill the office. In the case of an office in the state Senate or Assembly, this means that a replacement typically would be elected through a separate special election. The Governor would choose who would fill a vacancy in any other office (other than office of the Governor).",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Creates Separate Process for Filling the Office of the Governor",
              "text": "The process for filling the office of the Governor depends on when the recall occurs. If the Governor is recalled before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the term, Proposition 5 says that the Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor until voters elect a new Governor at a future statewide election. If the Governor is recalled later in the term, the Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor for the rest of the term.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Fiscal Effects Depend on Frequency of Recalls and the Offices Recalled. Whether there would be costs or savings compared with today depends on the frequency of future recalls and the offices recalled. A recall of a statewide office (for example, Lieutenant Governor) would affect state elections officials and local elections officials in all 58 counties. A recall of a district-based office (for example, a state Senator or Assembly Member) would only affect state elections officials and local elections officials in those districts.",
            "Potential Costs. Proposition 5 could result in higher costs associated with future recall elections if a special election is necessary to fill the vacant office after a recall. For example, a legislative office made vacant after a recall typically would be filled through a special election. If that special election could not be consolidated with a scheduled election, elections officials would need to run a standalone special election. The cost to state and local elections officials to administer such a special election could be millions of dollars per election.",
            "Potential Savings. Proposition 5 could result in lower costs by removing the second question from the ballot. These savings would occur when a Governor is recalled in the latter part of the term and for other offices where vacancies are filled by appointment. There would be savings because ballots and voting materials would no longer include information about replacement candidates. The amount of savings would depend on how many candidates there would have been on the ballot if the second question remained but could be millions of dollars per election.",
            "Net Effect Depends on Circumstances of Future Recall Efforts. The net fiscal effect is unknown because it depends on future recall elections. Proposition 5 could lead to savings or costs potentially in the range of millions of dollars to administer recall elections. How these savings or costs would be shared by state and county governments would depend on future decisions by the Legislature. This net fiscal effect represents less than one-tenth of 1 percent (0.1 percent) of the state’s total General Fund budget. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.)"
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Fiscal Effects Depend on Frequency of Recalls and the Offices Recalled",
              "text": "Whether there would be costs or savings compared with today depends on the frequency of future recalls and the offices recalled. A recall of a statewide office (for example, Lieutenant Governor) would affect state elections officials and local elections officials in all 58 counties. A recall of a district-based office (for example, a state Senator or Assembly Member) would only affect state elections officials and local elections officials in those districts.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Potential Costs",
              "text": "Proposition 5 could result in higher costs associated with future recall elections if a special election is necessary to fill the vacant office after a recall. For example, a legislative office made vacant after a recall typically would be filled through a special election. If that special election could not be consolidated with a scheduled election, elections officials would need to run a standalone special election. The cost to state and local elections officials to administer such a special election could be millions of dollars per election.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Potential Savings",
              "text": "Proposition 5 could result in lower costs by removing the second question from the ballot. These savings would occur when a Governor is recalled in the latter part of the term and for other offices where vacancies are filled by appointment. There would be savings because ballots and voting materials would no longer include information about replacement candidates. The amount of savings would depend on how many candidates there would have been on the ballot if the second question remained but could be millions of dollars per election.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Net Effect Depends on Circumstances of Future Recall Efforts",
              "text": "The net fiscal effect is unknown because it depends on future recall elections. Proposition 5 could lead to savings or costs potentially in the range of millions of dollars to administer recall elections. How these savings or costs would be shared by state and county governments would depend on future decisions by the Legislature. This net fiscal effect represents less than one-tenth of 1 percent (0.1 percent) of the state’s total General Fund budget. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Disregard the mental gymnastics the other side is doing here to tie us in knots and try to make sense of the truly nonsensical.",
            "They say Proposition 5 “protects democracy.” It does the opposite—it erodes one of the fundamental elements of our recall process: to choose who replaces the recalled politician.",
            "That’s not protecting democracy—that’s protecting political elites.",
            "They call California’s system a “dangerous loophole.” It’s worked for 100 years, ousting politicians who abuse their office and replacing them with whoever the voters decide will do better.",
            "Proposition 5 would create a loophole, not close one. The other side is gaslighting you. They think you won’t notice. Don’t be fooled.",
            "If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. Our recall process is only ‘broke’ for those who find themselves on the business end of it, like Proposition 5’s author did when he raised taxes after breaking campaign promises.",
            "Now, he wants to burn it down on his way out the door—making future recalls less effective and keeping politicians like him less accountable.",
            "If you traded in your car, would you want to know what you were getting in return—or would you be happy to sign it away and let the salesman stick you in a jalopy of their choosing after you’ve already committed? That’s what Proposition 5 asks you to do.",
            "Our recall system will continue to work just fine, if we don’t let political elites with sour grapes tinker with it to their benefit.",
            "Vote NO!"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Brian W. Jones, Senate Minority Leader",
            "Joe Patterson, Assemblymember"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Brian W. Jones",
              "title": "Senate Minority Leader",
              "organization": null
            },
            {
              "name": "Joe Patterson",
              "title": "Assemblymember",
              "organization": null
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Don’t be misled. Proposition 5 preserves your power to recall an official by majority vote while closing the loophole that allows a replacement candidate to take office with a small fraction of the vote.",
            "Under current law, voters decide whether to remove an official by majority vote, but the replacement can win with far less than a majority. In 2021, a replacement candidate could have become Governor with support from 28% of recall voters. That is not majority rule.",
            "Opponents want you to believe Proposition 5 takes away your right to choose. It does not. The real question is whether someone should become Governor with support from only a small fraction of California voters.",
            "Proposition 5 preserves the recall while separating the decision to remove an officeholder from the decision about who should serve next. If a Governor is recalled, the Lieutenant Governor—elected statewide by California voters—provides continuity of government until voters choose the next Governor through a regular election. Voters will still choose their elected officials. But candidates seeking statewide office should earn that office in a regular election based on their qualifications, record, and plans for California, not use a recall as a shortcut to power.",
            "A recall should decide whether an officeholder remains in office. Choosing who governs should happen in a regular election, where candidates earn the support of California voters. Proposition 5 protects the recall, respects majority rule, and ensures candidates run on their own merits. Vote YES on Proposition 5."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Lorrel Plimier, Co-President",
            "League of Women Voters of California",
            "Darius L. Kemp, MPA, Executive Director",
            "California Common Cause"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Lorrel Plimier",
              "title": "Co-President",
              "organization": "League of Women Voters of California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Darius L. Kemp",
              "title": "MPA, Executive Director",
              "organization": "California Common Cause"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "California’s recall process should protect our democracy by allowing for the removal of an elected official who is corrupt or abusing their power. It should never be used as a tactic to ‘redo’ an election as a political or partisan scheme. Proposition 5 will restore the recall to its original purpose by making it fair, democratic, and accountable to the will of the majority.",
            "Under current law, a statewide recall ballot asks voters two questions in sequence:",
            "(1) Should the official be recalled? (2) If so, who should replace them?",
            "By being connected, these two questions create a dangerous loophole. An elected official can be removed by a narrow majority. Then, a candidate listed in question #2 can win the office with far less than 50% of the votes cast in the election. This encourages political actors to target officials they couldn’t defeat in a regular election and to install replacements who lack broad public support.",
            "We saw this play out in the 2021 gubernatorial recall. Voters rejected it decisively. The recall lost by nearly the same number of votes that the Governor won the regular election with. But California taxpayers were forced to spend more than $200 million on an election whose outcome simply reconfirmed what voters had already decided. Nearly 70% of California likely voters called the effort a waste of taxpayer money. And had the recall succeeded, the leading replacement candidate would have taken office with support from only about 28% of all recall voters.",
            "Proposition 5 makes a single, commonsense change: it removes the second question from the recall ballot.",
            "Under Prop. 5, in a state-level recall, voters would decide one very simple and important question: whether an officeholder should be removed. If a majority votes yes, that office becomes vacant and is filled under existing vacancy rules. If a Governor is recalled, the Lieutenant Governor would become Governor and if the recall occurs early enough, voters would elect a replacement at the next statewide election; other statewide officers would be filled by appointment under existing rules; legislative seats by special election. No shortcuts, no loopholes, and no replacement candidate winning office without majority voter support.",
            "In most states with recalls, vacancies are already filled by succession or a separate election, not a same-day replacement contest.",
            "By eliminating the second question, Proposition 5 removes the incentive and ability to weaponize recalls as a shortcut for partisan advantage. Recalls could not be gamed to overturn the results of regular elections or install candidates who couldn’t win under normal conditions.",
            "The framers of our recall process intended to safeguard voters against corrupt and unaccountable officials, not to provide a weapon for political operators to undo election results they don’t like. Proposition 5 preserves the recall as a tool for accountability while preventing it from being used to sidestep regular elections and majority rule.",
            "Vote YES on Proposition 5 to protect majority rule, defend taxpayers, and restore California’s recall process back to the voters it was designed to serve."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Lorrel Plimier, Co-President",
            "League of Women Voters of California",
            "Darius L. Kemp, MPA, Executive Director",
            "California Common Cause",
            "Dan Schnur, Former Chair",
            "California Fair Political Practices Commission"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Lorrel Plimier",
              "title": "Co-President",
              "organization": "League of Women Voters of California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Darius L. Kemp",
              "title": "MPA, Executive Director",
              "organization": "California Common Cause"
            },
            {
              "name": "Dan Schnur",
              "title": "Former Chair",
              "organization": "California Fair Political Practices Commission"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Proposition 5 will take away your voice and erode your ability to remove and replace failed or corrupt politicians from office.",
            "California politicians already have too much power. Proposition 5 gives them even more—and it does it by taking power away from you, the voters.",
            "For over 100 years, California’s recall process has given us the ability to remove elected officials who abuse their office, break promises or fail to do the job they were elected to do. And, when that happens, the current process allows you—not politicians—to choose who replaces them.",
            "Proposition 5 changes that system forever and takes power away from the people.",
            "Today, a recall election asks two simple questions: Should the elected official be removed from office? If so, who should replace them? That means Californians can remove a failed politician and immediately choose someone new to take their place.",
            "Proposition 5 keeps the first part but eliminates your ability to vote for a replacement.",
            "Instead, Sacramento political insiders would decide what happens next. In many cases, politicians themselves—not voters—would choose who fills the vacancy, essentially allowing them to appoint another one of their friends or political allies to replace the one you just ousted.",
            "In other cases, rather than an immediate replacement, the seat would sit vacant until another costly election—funded by you, the taxpayer—was scheduled months later. And here’s the kicker; that failed politician you just ran out the door for failure or corruption, they'd be allowed to run in that next election to regain control of the seat they just lost.",
            "In either case, your vote matters less, and the political establishment gains more control.",
            "Californians deserve the right to remove an elected official—and to choose who comes next. Proposition 5 takes away half of that right, and that’s wrong.",
            "Supporters claim this measure improves democracy. It doesn’t. Democracy means voters—not Sacramento politicians—get to choose their leaders, when to give them the boot and who to replace them with. Proposition 5 undermines that fundamental concept.",
            "Ask yourself: if you vote to remove a governor or another statewide elected official, shouldn’t you also decide who replaces them?",
            "The answer is clear.",
            "It’s also worth wondering why this measure is on the ballot in the first place. Why fix a system that isn’t broken and has been working just fine for over a century?",
            "Well, the author of this proposal himself was recalled by California voters when he voted to raise gas taxes after promising not to. Instead of respecting the will of the people, he now wants to rewrite the rules and protect politicians like him from any meaningful accountability. California’s recall belongs to the people—not politicians. Protect your voice. Protect your vote. Protect your right to hold elected officials accountable.",
            "Vote NO on Proposition 5."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Brian W. Jones, Senate Minority Leader",
            "Joe Patterson, Assemblymember"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Brian W. Jones",
              "title": "Senate Minority Leader",
              "organization": null
            },
            {
              "name": "Joe Patterson",
              "title": "Assemblymember",
              "organization": null
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/5/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/5/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop5-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/5/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop5-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 will restore the recall to its original purpose by making it fair, democratic, and accountable to the will of the majority.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 is intended to restore the recall process to its original purpose.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Under current law, a statewide recall ballot asks voters two questions in sequence:",
          "claim": "A statewide recall ballot currently asks voters two questions.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Two Questions in Recall Elections. In a recall election, voters are asked two questions: (1) whether the official should be removed from office and (2) who should replace the official if removed from office.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "An elected official can be removed by a narrow majority.",
          "claim": "An elected official can be removed by a majority vote in a recall election.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "This means, in future recall elections, voters would only decide whether to remove an elected official from a state office, not who would replace the official.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Then, a candidate listed in question #2 can win the office with far less than 50% of the votes cast in the election.",
          "claim": "A replacement candidate can win a recall election with less than 50 percent of votes cast.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "If a state official is recalled, the person who receives the most votes in the second question assumes the office.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "This encourages political actors to target officials they couldn’t defeat in a regular election and to install replacements who lack broad public support.",
          "claim": "The current recall process encourages political actors to target officials they could not defeat in regular elections.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Voters rejected it decisively.",
          "claim": "Voters rejected the 2021 gubernatorial recall.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "The recall lost by nearly the same number of votes that the Governor won the regular election with.",
          "claim": "The 2021 recall's losing margin was nearly the same as the Governor's regular-election winning margin.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California taxpayers were forced to spend more than $200 million on an election whose outcome simply reconfirmed what voters had already decided.",
          "claim": "California taxpayers spent more than $200 million on the 2021 gubernatorial recall election.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Nearly 70% of California likely voters called the effort a waste of taxpayer money.",
          "claim": "Nearly 70 percent of likely California voters called the 2021 recall effort a waste of taxpayer money.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "had the recall succeeded, the leading replacement candidate would have taken office with support from only about 28% of all recall voters.",
          "claim": "Had the 2021 recall succeeded, its leading replacement candidate would have taken office with about 28 percent support among recall voters.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "it removes the second question from the recall ballot.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 removes the recall ballot's second question.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 5 removes the second question—who should replace a recalled official—from a recall election.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "If a majority votes yes, that office becomes vacant and is filled under existing vacancy rules.",
          "claim": "If a majority votes to recall an official, Proposition 5 makes the office vacant and generally applies existing vacancy procedures.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "If a state official is recalled, Proposition 5 makes the office of the recalled official vacant. Except for the office of the Governor, Proposition 5 uses the existing process for filling vacancies to fill the office.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "If a Governor is recalled, the Lieutenant Governor would become Governor",
          "claim": "If a Governor is recalled, the Lieutenant Governor becomes Governor.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "If the Governor is recalled before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the term, Proposition 5 says that the Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor until voters elect a new Governor at a future statewide election. If the Governor is recalled later in the term, the Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor for the rest of the term.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "if the recall occurs early enough, voters would elect a replacement at the next statewide election",
          "claim": "If a Governor is recalled early enough, voters elect a new Governor at the next statewide election.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "If the Governor is recalled before the close of the nomination period for the next statewide election during the first two years of the term, Proposition 5 says that the Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor until voters elect a new Governor at a future statewide election.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "other statewide officers would be filled by appointment under existing rules; legislative seats by special election.",
          "claim": "Other statewide-officer vacancies are filled by appointment and legislative-seat vacancies are filled by special election.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "In the case of an office in the state Senate or Assembly, this means that a replacement typically would be elected through a separate special election. The Governor would choose who would fill a vacancy in any other office (other than office of the Governor).",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "In most states with recalls, vacancies are already filled by succession or a separate election, not a same-day replacement contest.",
          "claim": "Most states with recalls fill vacancies through succession or a separate election rather than a same-day replacement contest.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 removes the incentive and ability to weaponize recalls as a shortcut for partisan advantage.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 removes incentives and ability to use recalls for partisan advantage.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Recalls could not be gamed to overturn the results of regular elections or install candidates who couldn’t win under normal conditions.",
          "claim": "Under Proposition 5, recalls could not be used to overturn regular-election results or install candidates who could not win under normal conditions.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "The framers of our recall process intended to safeguard voters against corrupt and unaccountable officials",
          "claim": "The framers intended the recall process to safeguard voters against corrupt and unaccountable officials.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 preserves the recall as a tool for accountability while preventing it from being used to sidestep regular elections and majority rule.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 is intended to preserve recall accountability while preventing recalls from sidestepping regular elections and majority rule.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 preserves your power to recall an official by majority vote while closing the loophole that allows a replacement candidate to take office with a small fraction of the vote.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 preserves recall by majority vote.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "This means, in future recall elections, voters would only decide whether to remove an elected official from a state office, not who would replace the official.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Under current law, voters decide whether to remove an official by majority vote, but the replacement can win with far less than a majority.",
          "claim": "Under current law, voters decide removal by majority vote and a replacement can win with less than a majority.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "If a state official is recalled, the person who receives the most votes in the second question assumes the office.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "In 2021, a replacement candidate could have become Governor with support from 28% of recall voters.",
          "claim": "In 2021, a replacement candidate could have become Governor with support from 28 percent of recall voters.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 takes away your right to choose.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 takes away voters' right to choose a replacement official.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "This means, in future recall elections, voters would only decide whether to remove an elected official from a state office, not who would replace the official.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "someone should become Governor with support from only a small fraction of California voters.",
          "claim": "A person can become Governor with support from only a small fraction of California voters in a recall replacement contest.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "If a state official is recalled, the person who receives the most votes in the second question assumes the office.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 preserves the recall while separating the decision to remove an officeholder from the decision about who should serve next.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 separates the removal decision from the process for selecting a successor.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 5 removes the second question—who should replace a recalled official—from a recall election.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "If a Governor is recalled, the Lieutenant Governor—elected statewide by California voters—provides continuity of government until voters choose the next Governor through a regular election.",
          "claim": "If a Governor is recalled, the Lieutenant Governor serves until voters choose the next Governor through a regular election.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "If the Governor is recalled later in the term, the Lieutenant Governor serves as Governor for the rest of the term.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 will take away your voice and erode your ability to remove and replace failed or corrupt politicians from office.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 erodes voters' ability to remove and replace elected officials.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "This means, in future recall elections, voters would only decide whether to remove an elected official from a state office, not who would replace the official.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "California politicians already have too much power.",
          "claim": "California politicians have too much power.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 gives them even more—and it does it by taking power away from you, the voters.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 gives politicians more power and takes power away from voters.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "For over 100 years, California’s recall process has given us the ability to remove elected officials who abuse their office, break promises or fail to do the job they were elected to do.",
          "claim": "California's recall process has allowed voters to remove elected officials for more than 100 years.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "The State Constitution allows voters to remove state officials from office before their term ends through a recall.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the current process allows you—not politicians—to choose who replaces them.",
          "claim": "The current recall process lets voters choose the replacement official.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "In a recall election, voters are asked two questions: (1) whether the official should be removed from office and (2) who should replace the official if removed from office.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 changes that system forever and takes power away from the people.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 changes the recall system.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "As described below, Proposition 5 changes the recall process to make it like the existing process for filling vacant state offices, except for the process to recall the Governor.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Today, a recall election asks two simple questions: Should the elected official be removed from office? If so, who should replace them?",
          "claim": "A current recall election asks whether to remove the official and who should replace the official if removed.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "In a recall election, voters are asked two questions: (1) whether the official should be removed from office and (2) who should replace the official if removed from office.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "That means Californians can remove a failed politician and immediately choose someone new to take their place.",
          "claim": "Under the current process, Californians can choose a replacement in the same recall election.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "If a state official is recalled, the person who receives the most votes in the second question assumes the office.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 keeps the first part but eliminates your ability to vote for a replacement.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 keeps the removal question but eliminates the vote for a replacement.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 5 removes the second question—who should replace a recalled official—from a recall election.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "In many cases, politicians themselves—not voters—would choose who fills the vacancy",
          "claim": "In many recall-vacancy cases, politicians rather than voters would choose who fills the vacancy.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The Governor would choose who would fill a vacancy in any other office (other than office of the Governor).",
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "essentially allowing them to appoint another one of their friends or political allies to replace the one you just ousted.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 would allow politicians to appoint friends or political allies to replace recalled officials.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the seat would sit vacant until another costly election—funded by you, the taxpayer—was scheduled months later.",
          "claim": "A recalled office could remain vacant until a later costly election funded by taxpayers.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 5 could result in higher costs associated with future recall elections if a special election is necessary to fill the vacant office after a recall.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "they'd be allowed to run in that next election to regain control of the seat they just lost.",
          "claim": "A recalled official would be allowed to run in the next election for the seat.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "In either case, your vote matters less, and the political establishment gains more control.",
          "claim": "Under Proposition 5, voters' votes matter less and the political establishment gains more control.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 takes away half of that right",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 takes away half of voters' right to remove an elected official and choose the successor.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 undermines that fundamental concept.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 undermines the principle that voters choose their leaders and replacements.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Why fix a system that isn’t broken and has been working just fine for over a century?",
          "claim": "California's recall system has worked well for more than a century.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the author of this proposal himself was recalled by California voters",
          "claim": "The proposal's author was recalled by California voters.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "when he voted to raise gas taxes after promising not to.",
          "claim": "The proposal's author voted to raise gas taxes after promising not to do so.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:argument_against:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "he now wants to rewrite the rules and protect politicians like him from any meaningful accountability.",
          "claim": "The proposal's author intends to rewrite the rules to protect politicians like himself from meaningful accountability.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It does the opposite—it erodes one of the fundamental elements of our recall process: to choose who replaces the recalled politician.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 removes the recall-process element in which voters choose the replacement official.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "This means, in future recall elections, voters would only decide whether to remove an elected official from a state office, not who would replace the official.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "That’s not protecting democracy—that’s protecting political elites.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 is intended to protect political elites.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It’s worked for 100 years, ousting politicians who abuse their office and replacing them with whoever the voters decide will do better.",
          "claim": "California's recall system has worked for 100 years.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "replacing them with whoever the voters decide will do better.",
          "claim": "The current recall system replaces recalled officials with the candidate voters select.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "If a state official is recalled, the person who receives the most votes in the second question assumes the office.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 5 would create a loophole, not close one.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5 would create a loophole.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Our recall process is only ‘broke’ for those who find themselves on the business end of it, like Proposition 5’s author did when he raised taxes after breaking campaign promises.",
          "claim": "Proposition 5's author raised taxes after breaking campaign promises.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Now, he wants to burn it down on his way out the door—making future recalls less effective and keeping politicians like him less accountable.",
          "claim": "The proposal's author intends to make future recalls less effective and politicians less accountable.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Our recall system will continue to work just fine, if we don’t let political elites with sour grapes tinker with it to their benefit.",
          "claim": "The recall system will continue to work well if Proposition 5 does not pass.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-5:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "political elites with sour grapes tinker with it to their benefit.",
          "claim": "Political elites seek to change the recall system for their own benefit.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-5:analysis": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
            "vig:prop-5:arguments": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-5:overview",
        "vig:prop-5:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-5:analysis",
        "vig:prop-5:arguments",
        "vig:prop-5:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-5:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-37",
      "contest_id": "prop-37",
      "number": "37",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "CREATES LOAN PROGRAM FOR MIDDLE-INCOME BUYERS OF QUALIFIED NEW HOMES. INITIATIVE STATUTE.",
      "measure_type": "initiative_statute",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures",
      "summary": "Authorizes $25 billion in bonds to offer eligible buyers fixed-rate mortgages for up to 17% of purchase price of a newly constructed home priced below about $1.5 million. Borrowers must be California residents, occupy the home, meet income limits, and pay at least 3% down. Bonds repaid by mortgage payments, not State.",
      "fiscal_impact": "No direct state or local costs.",
      "supporters": "United Nurses Associations of California; California Conference of Carpenters; California State Treasurer Fiona Ma",
      "opponents": "None submitted",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: The state would create a new homebuying assistance program. The state could sell up to $25 billion in revenue bonds to fund the program. Bonds would be paid back by homeowners’ payments on their home loans.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: The state would not be required to create a new homebuying assistance program.",
      "pro_short": "Zero Taxpayer Cost—No Taxpayer Risk. Prop. 37 makes buying a home more affordable, keeping homeownership attainable for hardworking and middle-class Californians, with low-interest mortgages funded by private bond investors, NOT TAXPAYERS. Must be CA resident to qualify, meet income requirements, occupy home, make monthly payments, repay loan. Strict accountability/audits.",
      "con_short": "NO ARGUMENT AGAINST PROPOSITION 37 WAS SUBMITTED.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "https://voteyeson37.com/",
          "Info@voteyeson37.com"
        ],
        "against": []
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "https://voteyeson37.com/",
          "url": "https://voteyeson37.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Info@voteyeson37.com",
          "url": "mailto:Info@voteyeson37.com"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Authorizes up to $25 billion in bonds to offer eligible buyers fixed-rate mortgages for up to 17% of the purchase price of a “qualified new home” (new construction or first sale of converted nonresidential property, priced below about $1 million–$1.5 million, depending on county, adjusted annually).",
        "Borrowers must be California residents for one year, occupy the home, earn less than twice the area’s median income, and pay at least 3% down.",
        "Requires that bonds be repaid by homeowners’ mortgage payments, not the State.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "No direct state or local costs.",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "State Revenue Bonds. Bonds are a way that governments borrow money, most commonly for public projects such as schools or bridges. The state sells bonds to investors to receive up-front funding for these projects. Over time, investors are repaid with interest. The state sells two main types of bonds: general obligation bonds and revenue bonds. The state usually repays general obligation bonds using the state General Fund. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.) In contrast, revenue bonds are repaid using revenue from fees or other payments by the users of the project (such as from bridge tolls).",
            "Some People Seek Down Payment Assistance. When purchasing a home, most people pay some of the cost up front—typically 3 percent to 20 percent of the home price. The up-front payment is known as a down payment. If people cannot afford the down payment, there are different government programs available to provide down payment assistance to eligible homebuyers. To cover the remaining cost of the home, homebuyers get a loan, called a mortgage. Homebuyers then pay off the mortgage by making monthly payments that include interest.",
            "California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA). CalHFA is a state entity that administers programs designed to help low- and moderate-income Californians afford housing. CalHFA has a few programs that provide down payment assistance to homebuyers. The down payment assistance programs are loans that must be repaid under certain terms and conditions.",
            "Construction Defect Law. To try to prevent construction defects, state law sets minimum standards that builders must follow for new residential construction. Current law also establishes a process that homeowners and housing builders must follow before a homeowner is able to sue a builder for alleged violations of those minimum standards. For example, the homeowner must provide notice to the builder that includes certain information concerning a claim of construction defect."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "State Revenue Bonds",
              "text": "Bonds are a way that governments borrow money, most commonly for public projects such as schools or bridges. The state sells bonds to investors to receive up-front funding for these projects. Over time, investors are repaid with interest. The state sells two main types of bonds: general obligation bonds and revenue bonds. The state usually repays general obligation bonds using the state General Fund. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.) In contrast, revenue bonds are repaid using revenue from fees or other payments by the users of the project (such as from bridge tolls).",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Some People Seek Down Payment Assistance",
              "text": "When purchasing a home, most people pay some of the cost up front—typically 3 percent to 20 percent of the home price. The up-front payment is known as a down payment. If people cannot afford the down payment, there are different government programs available to provide down payment assistance to eligible homebuyers. To cover the remaining cost of the home, homebuyers get a loan, called a mortgage. Homebuyers then pay off the mortgage by making monthly payments that include interest.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030"
            },
            {
              "lead": "California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA)",
              "text": "CalHFA is a state entity that administers programs designed to help low- and moderate-income Californians afford housing. CalHFA has a few programs that provide down payment assistance to homebuyers. The down payment assistance programs are loans that must be repaid under certain terms and conditions.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Construction Defect Law",
              "text": "To try to prevent construction defects, state law sets minimum standards that builders must follow for new residential construction. Current law also establishes a process that homeowners and housing builders must follow before a homeowner is able to sue a builder for alleged violations of those minimum standards. For example, the homeowner must provide notice to the builder that includes certain information concerning a claim of construction defect.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Revenue Bond to Pay for a New Down Payment Assistance Program. Proposition 37 allows CalHFA to sell up to $25 billion in revenue bonds. CalHFA would use the bond funds to create a down payment assistance program called the “middle-class homeownership loan.” Each loan would cover up to 17 percent of the home price. (Homebuyers would need to provide a down payment of at least 3 percent of the home price.) Homeowners’ monthly payments on their loan would be designed to repay the bonds over time and cover the program’s administrative costs. CalHFA also would be required to keep interest costs for homebuyers as low as possible. CalHFA would decide how much of the bonds to issue (up to $25 billion) and over what time period.",
            "Buyers and Homes Must Meet Certain Requirements. To participate in a middleclass homeownership loan, people and homes would need to meet certain requirements. For example, an applicant would need to be a resident of the state and have a household income no more than double the typical income level in their area. For a home to be eligible for purchase through the program, among other requirements, the buyer would need to be the first purchaser of the home and the price could not exceed certain limits.",
            "Housing Developer Options. Under Proposition 37, all developers could build homes eligible for purchase under the program. Developers also could choose to participate in a “qualified builder option.” Developers that chose this option would be required to meet higher labor standards, such as using workers with a certain type of training for certain types of housing projects. In exchange, developers would be subject to different construction defect rules, which generally aim to provide more flexibility to developers."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Revenue Bond to Pay for a New Down Payment Assistance Program",
              "text": "Proposition 37 allows CalHFA to sell up to $25 billion in revenue bonds. CalHFA would use the bond funds to create a down payment assistance program called the “middle-class homeownership loan.” Each loan would cover up to 17 percent of the home price. (Homebuyers would need to provide a down payment of at least 3 percent of the home price.) Homeowners’ monthly payments on their loan would be designed to repay the bonds over time and cover the program’s administrative costs. CalHFA also would be required to keep interest costs for homebuyers as low as possible. CalHFA would decide how much of the bonds to issue (up to $25 billion) and over what time period.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Buyers and Homes Must Meet Certain Requirements",
              "text": "To participate in a middleclass homeownership loan, people and homes would need to meet certain requirements. For example, an applicant would need to be a resident of the state and have a household income no more than double the typical income level in their area. For a home to be eligible for purchase through the program, among other requirements, the buyer would need to be the first purchaser of the home and the price could not exceed certain limits.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Housing Developer Options",
              "text": "Under Proposition 37, all developers could build homes eligible for purchase under the program. Developers also could choose to participate in a “qualified builder option.” Developers that chose this option would be required to meet higher labor standards, such as using workers with a certain type of training for certain types of housing projects. In exchange, developers would be subject to different construction defect rules, which generally aim to provide more flexibility to developers.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "No Direct State or Local Costs. Because Proposition 37 uses the payments from homebuyers to repay bond investors, it would not result in direct state or local costs.",
            "Other Potential Effects. A number of factors, which are unknown at this time, could affect Proposition 37’s scope and impact. These include (1) the extent to which investors want to buy the bond, (2) how much the loans available under this proposed program cost homebuyers compared with other down payment assistance options, and (3) whether the program results in increased home construction and homebuying."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "No Direct State or Local Costs",
              "text": "Because Proposition 37 uses the payments from homebuyers to repay bond investors, it would not result in direct state or local costs.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Other Potential Effects",
              "text": "A number of factors, which are unknown at this time, could affect Proposition 37’s scope and impact. These include (1) the extent to which investors want to buy the bond, (2) how much the loans available under this proposed program cost homebuyers compared with other down payment assistance options, and (3) whether the program results in increased home construction and homebuying.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "not_submitted"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "not_submitted"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE YES ON PROPOSITION 37: the California Middle- Class Homeownership & Family Home Construction Act. Proposition 37 creates affordable homeownership opportunities for working and middle-class Californians and encourages new home construction—with ZERO COST TO TAXPAYERS.",
            "California has the second-worst homeownership rate in the nation; rising costs push homeownership further out of reach every year.",
            "With the statewide median home price now exceeding $930,000, a traditional 20% down payment can require saving over $186,000 just to get in the door. Teachers, nurses, veterans, and firefighters work hard and pay their bills. They can afford monthly mortgage payments but are locked out of homeownership in the communities where they live and work because down payment requirements are too high.",
            "Proposition 37 gives working and middle-class Californians a fair shot at homeownership.",
            "KEEPING HOMEOWNERSHIP WITHIN REACH.",
            "Prop. 37 is a practical solution. It makes consumer-friendly, low-interest downpayment assistance loans available to qualified California residents for purchasing a newly built home, with no cost to taxpayers.",
            "This is not a handout. Homebuyers must qualify for a mortgage, meet income requirements, pay at least 3% down, occupy the home as their primary residence, make monthly payments, and fully repay their loans.",
            "Prop. 37 is designed for renters, first-time homebuyers, and working families who earn too much to qualify for renter assistance programs, but not enough to save the massive down payment required to buy a home.",
            "“Proposition 37 will boost homeownership without burdening taxpayers. As a state revenue bond, downpayment assistance loans are funded by private bond investors and repaid by home borrowers, not taxpayers.”—Malia Cohen, California State Controller",
            "BUILDS MORE HOMES, CREATES GOOD JOBS.",
            "California hasn’t built enough homes to keep up with demand. By helping qualified buyers purchase newly built homes, Prop. 37 will help accelerate construction, creating thousands of good-paying jobs and generating economic investment.",
            "Expanding the housing supply helps workers and families to stay in California, build equity, raise their children, and live in the communities where they work.",
            "ZERO COST TO TAXPAYERS.",
            "Taxpayer advocates and California’s Legislative Analyst agree: Proposition 37 has no cost to taxpayers. Loans are funded by private bond investors and repaid by home borrowers—not taxpayers.",
            "STRICT ACCOUNTABILITY AND CONSUMER PROTECTIONS.",
            "Prop. 37 includes fiscal accountability and transparency requirements, construction accountability standards, and annual audits detailing the status of loans made and the fund’s financial condition.",
            "Consumer benefits include below-market, fixed-rate loans, protections from unfair lending practices, strict limits on lender fees, and no penalty for early repayment.",
            "BROAD, BIPARTISAN SUPPORT",
            "Proposition 37 is supported by Democrats & Republicans, labor and businesses, construction workers, taxpayer and housing advocates, veterans, the California Teachers Association, and United Nurses Association of California.",
            "For generations, homeownership provided stability, security, and a path to the middle class. But today, that path is simply out of reach for too many Californians. Proposition 37 is a practical solution that tackles one of the biggest barriers to homeownership, without burdening taxpayers.",
            "Vote YES to expand middle-class homeownership, build more homes, create good jobs, and give working Californians a fair chance to live, work, raise a family, and stay in California.",
            "VoteYeson37.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Danny Curtin, Director",
            "California Conference of Carpenters",
            "Fiona Ma, Boardmember",
            "California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA)",
            "David West, Chair",
            "California State Commanders Veterans Council"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Danny Curtin",
              "title": "Director",
              "organization": "California Conference of Carpenters"
            },
            {
              "name": "Fiona Ma",
              "title": "Boardmember",
              "organization": "California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA)"
            },
            {
              "name": "David West",
              "title": "Chair",
              "organization": "California State Commanders Veterans Council"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "not_submitted",
          "printed_as": "NO ARGUMENT AGAINST PROPOSITION 37 WAS SUBMITTED."
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/37/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/37/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop37-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/37/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop37-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 37 creates affordable homeownership opportunities for working and middle-class Californians and encourages new home construction—with ZERO COST TO TAXPAYERS.",
          "claim": "Proposition 37 would have zero cost to taxpayers.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Because Proposition 37 uses the payments from homebuyers to repay bond investors, it would not result in direct state or local costs.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California has the second-worst homeownership rate in the nation;",
          "claim": "California has the second-worst homeownership rate in the nation.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "rising costs push homeownership further out of reach every year.",
          "claim": "Rising costs make homeownership less attainable each year.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "With the statewide median home price now exceeding $930,000,",
          "claim": "California's statewide median home price exceeds $930,000.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "a traditional 20% down payment can require saving over $186,000 just to get in the door.",
          "claim": "A traditional 20 percent down payment can require more than $186,000 in savings.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "They can afford monthly mortgage payments but are locked out of homeownership in the communities where they live and work because down payment requirements are too high.",
          "claim": "Teachers, nurses, veterans, and firefighters can afford monthly mortgage payments but cannot buy homes in their communities because down payment requirements are too high.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "It makes consumer-friendly, low-interest downpayment assistance loans available to qualified California residents for purchasing a newly built home, with no cost to taxpayers.",
          "claim": "Proposition 37 would make down payment assistance loans available to qualified California residents.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "To participate in a middleclass homeownership loan, people and homes would need to meet certain requirements. For example, an applicant would need to be a resident of the state and have a household income no more than double the typical income level in their area.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "low-interest downpayment assistance loans",
          "claim": "The program's down payment assistance loans would have low interest rates.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "CalHFA also would be required to keep interest costs for homebuyers as low as possible.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "for purchasing a newly built home",
          "claim": "The loans would be available to purchase newly built homes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.72,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "with no cost to taxpayers.",
          "claim": "The program would have no cost to taxpayers.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Because Proposition 37 uses the payments from homebuyers to repay bond investors, it would not result in direct state or local costs.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Homebuyers must qualify for a mortgage,",
          "claim": "Homebuyers must qualify for a mortgage to receive program loans.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "meet income requirements,",
          "claim": "Homebuyers must meet income requirements to receive program loans.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "an applicant would need to be a resident of the state and have a household income no more than double the typical income level in their area.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "pay at least 3% down,",
          "claim": "Homebuyers must provide a down payment of at least 3 percent of the home price.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Each loan would cover up to 17 percent of the home price. (Homebuyers would need to provide a down payment of at least 3 percent of the home price.)",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "occupy the home as their primary residence,",
          "claim": "Homebuyers must occupy the purchased home as their primary residence.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "make monthly payments,",
          "claim": "Homebuyers must make monthly payments on program loans.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Homeowners’ monthly payments on their loan would be designed to repay the bonds over time and cover the program’s administrative costs.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "fully repay their loans.",
          "claim": "Homebuyers must fully repay program loans.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Homeowners’ monthly payments on their loan would be designed to repay the bonds over time and cover the program’s administrative costs.",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 37 is designed for renters, first-time homebuyers, and working families who earn too much to qualify for renter assistance programs, but not enough to save the massive down payment required to buy a home.",
          "claim": "Proposition 37 was designed for renters, first-time homebuyers, and working families unable to save the required down payment.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "who earn too much to qualify for renter assistance programs",
          "claim": "The intended beneficiaries earn too much to qualify for renter assistance programs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "downpayment assistance loans are funded by private bond investors and repaid by home borrowers, not taxpayers.",
          "claim": "Home borrowers, rather than taxpayers, repay the down payment assistance loans.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Because Proposition 37 uses the payments from homebuyers to repay bond investors, it would not result in direct state or local costs.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "downpayment assistance loans are funded by private bond investors and repaid by home borrowers, not taxpayers.",
          "claim": "Private bond investors fund the down payment assistance loans, and home borrowers repay them.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:21",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California hasn’t built enough homes to keep up with demand.",
          "claim": "California has not built enough homes to meet housing demand.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:22",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 37 will help accelerate construction,",
          "claim": "Proposition 37 will help accelerate home construction.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:23",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "creating thousands of good-paying jobs and generating economic investment.",
          "claim": "Proposition 37 will create thousands of good-paying jobs and generate economic investment.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:24",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Expanding the housing supply helps workers and families to stay in California, build equity, raise their children, and live in the communities where they work.",
          "claim": "Expanding the housing supply helps workers and families remain in California, build equity, raise children, and live near their work.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:25",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 37 has no cost to taxpayers.",
          "claim": "Proposition 37 has no cost to taxpayers.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Because Proposition 37 uses the payments from homebuyers to repay bond investors, it would not result in direct state or local costs.",
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:26",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Loans are funded by private bond investors and repaid by home borrowers—not taxpayers.",
          "claim": "Home borrowers, rather than taxpayers, repay the loans.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Because Proposition 37 uses the payments from homebuyers to repay bond investors, it would not result in direct state or local costs.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:27",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Loans are funded by private bond investors and repaid by home borrowers—not taxpayers.",
          "claim": "Private bond investors fund the loans and home borrowers repay them.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:28",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 37 includes fiscal accountability and transparency requirements, construction accountability standards, and annual audits detailing the status of loans made and the fund’s financial condition.",
          "claim": "Proposition 37 includes fiscal accountability and transparency requirements.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:29",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "annual audits detailing the status of loans made and the fund’s financial condition.",
          "claim": "Proposition 37 requires annual audits on loan status and the fund's financial condition.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:30",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "below-market, fixed-rate loans,",
          "claim": "The program provides below-market fixed-rate loans.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "CalHFA also would be required to keep interest costs for homebuyers as low as possible.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:31",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "protections from unfair lending practices,",
          "claim": "The measure provides protections from unfair lending practices.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:32",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "strict limits on lender fees,",
          "claim": "The measure imposes strict limits on lender fees.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:33",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "no penalty for early repayment.",
          "claim": "The measure prohibits penalties for early repayment.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:34",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "homeownership provided stability, security, and a path to the middle class.",
          "claim": "Homeownership has provided stability, security, and a path to the middle class.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:35",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "that path is simply out of reach for too many Californians.",
          "claim": "Homeownership is out of reach for too many Californians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-37:argument_for:36",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 37 is a practical solution that tackles one of the biggest barriers to homeownership, without burdening taxpayers.",
          "claim": "Proposition 37 would not burden taxpayers.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Because Proposition 37 uses the payments from homebuyers to repay bond investors, it would not result in direct state or local costs.",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-37:analysis": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
            "vig:prop-37:arguments": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-37:overview",
        "vig:prop-37:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-37:analysis",
        "vig:prop-37:arguments",
        "vig:prop-37:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-37:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-38",
      "contest_id": "prop-38",
      "number": "38",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "AUTHORIZES BONDS FOR IMMUNOLOGY MEDICAL RESEARCH. INITIATIVE STATUTE.",
      "measure_type": "initiative_statute",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures",
      "summary": "Authorizes $8.4 billion in general obligation bonds for immunology and immunotherapy research, half to a single University of California-affiliated nonprofit medical research institute, half to research grants.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Increased state cost of $500 million to $600 million annually for about 20 years to repay the research bond, with some or all of the cost offset if the funded research generates revenue.",
      "supporters": "Michael J. Fox Foundation; Alzheimer’s Los Angeles; Kidney Cancer Assoc; American Nurses Assoc\\CA",
      "opponents": "Robert M Kaplan Ph.D.",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: The state could borrow $8.4 billion to support medical research in immunology and immunotherapy conducted by California research institutes and universities.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: The state could not borrow $8.4 billion to support medical research in immunology and immunotherapy conducted by California research institutes and universities.",
      "pro_short": "YES on 38 supports life-saving immunology research to cure and prevent diseases like cancer, heart disease, Alzheimer’s. Strong accountability including independent audits. Mandates 20% Rx discount. Designed to ensure no cost to taxpayers. YES on 38 could save your life and someone you love. Alzheimer’s Association, The Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson’s Research urge YES on 38! www.YESon38.com",
      "con_short": "California should continue supporting biomedical research, but Proposition 38 is the wrong approach. It would commit taxpayers to decades of new bond debt while limiting California’s flexibility to address changing health priorities. Research funding should be guided through the normal budget process—not by ballot initiatives.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "YES on 38: Californians for",
          "Life-Saving Immunology",
          "Research and Cures",
          "lnfo@YesOn38.com",
          "https://yeson38.com"
        ],
        "against": [
          "Robert M Kaplan",
          "Stanford University School of",
          "Medicine, Clinical Excellence",
          "Research Center",
          "Stanford CERC, CAM Building",
          "453 Quarry Road,",
          "Palo Alto, CA 94305",
          "(301) 412-0205",
          "bob.kaplan@stanford.edu"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "lnfo@YesOn38.com",
          "url": "mailto:lnfo@YesOn38.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "https://yeson38.com",
          "url": "https://yeson38.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "bob.kaplan@stanford.edu",
          "url": "mailto:bob.kaplan@stanford.edu"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Authorizes $8.4 billion in state general obligation bonds for immunology and immunotherapy research (technologies that use body’s immune system to treat disease), with half dedicated to cancer, heart disease, and Alzheimer’s disease.",
        "Allocates funds equally between (1) a single University of California-affiliated nonprofit medical research institute, and (2) research grants for public or nonprofit universities and institutions.",
        "Requires funding recipients to sell technology and drugs derived from research in California for 20% below national average price.",
        "Appropriates money from General Fund to repay bonds; General Fund receives 10% of licensing royalties until bonds are repaid.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Increased state cost of $500 million to $600 million annually for about 20 years to repay the medical research bond. The state could recover part or all of this cost in subsequent decades if the funded research leads to discoveries that generate revenue.",
        "State Bond Cost Estimate",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Medical Research and Development (R&D) Is a Multi- Stage Process. The first stage of this process is basic research, which focuses on discovering new knowledge about how the human body works. The next stage is applied and clinical research, which aims to develop and test treatments for specific diseases. Universities do most of the basic research, while companies do most of the applied and clinical research. The third R&D stage is to have regulators review new treatments to make sure they are safe and effective. If a new treatment is approved, then it may be used on patients. Most R&D projects do not make it through all of these stages.",
            "Medical R&D Is Funded in Various Ways. Funding for medical R&D in the United States totaled about $300 billion in 2023. Companies and government agencies (such as the National Institutes of Health) are the major funding sources for R&D nationally and in California. Beyond these funding sources, California voters have approved two ballot measures— Proposition 71 (2004) and Proposition 14 (2020)— giving the state authority to issue general obligation bonds to fund specified medical research. Combined, the two measures allowed the state to issue $8.5 billion in bonds for stem cell research. Bonds are a way for the state to borrow money, then repay it with interest over time. A general obligation bond is typically repaid from the state General Fund. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.) For more information about bonds, see “Overview of State Bond Debt” later in this guide."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Medical Research and Development (R&D) Is a Multi- Stage Process",
              "text": "The first stage of this process is basic research, which focuses on discovering new knowledge about how the human body works. The next stage is applied and clinical research, which aims to develop and test treatments for specific diseases. Universities do most of the basic research, while companies do most of the applied and clinical research. The third R&D stage is to have regulators review new treatments to make sure they are safe and effective. If a new treatment is approved, then it may be used on patients. Most R&D projects do not make it through all of these stages.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Medical R&D Is Funded in Various Ways",
              "text": "Funding for medical R&D in the United States totaled about $300 billion in 2023. Companies and government agencies (such as the National Institutes of Health) are the major funding sources for R&D nationally and in California. Beyond these funding sources, California voters have approved two ballot measures— Proposition 71 (2004) and Proposition 14 (2020)— giving the state authority to issue general obligation bonds to fund specified medical research. Combined, the two measures allowed the state to issue $8.5 billion in bonds for stem cell research. Bonds are a way for the state to borrow money, then repay it with interest over time. A general obligation bond is typically repaid from the state General Fund. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.) For more information about bonds, see “Overview of State Bond Debt” later in this guide.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "New Bond for Specified Medical Research. Proposition 38 allows the state to issue an $8.4 billion general obligation bond for research in immunology and immunotherapy. Immunology is the study of the body’s immune system and how it protects the body from abnormal cells and other causes of disease. Immunotherapy develops treatments that help the immune system fight diseases more effectively. The measure requires that at least $4.2 billion of the bond funds be used for immunology research on cancer, heart disease, and Alzheimer’s disease. No more than 2 percent of total bond funds may be used for state administrative costs. Payments on the bond would come from the state General Fund.",
            "Supports a Research Institute. About half of the bond funds would go to a research institute specializing in immunology and immunotherapy. The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) would select the institute. The selected institute must meet several criteria, including criteria related to its size, funding, and collaboration with a University of California (UC) campus. The institute would use the bond funds for research. Each year, the institute must issue a public report on its activities and have an independent financial audit.",
            "Supports Research Grants. A council would give out the other half of bond funds as competitive research grants focused on immunology and immunotherapy. The council would consist of representatives from 7 UC campuses and 10 to 15 other universities and nonprofit research institutions in California. The council would set research priorities and select grant recipients from among its member organizations. Similar to the institute, the council would have public reporting and audit requirements.",
            "Requires 10 Percent of Revenue From Discoveries First Be Used to Repay the State. Proposition 38 requires that the institute, in consultation with CDPH, try to generate the most revenue possible from the funded research. (Research, for example, could lead to the development of a new medical treatment.) Ten percent of any revenue generated must be given to the state. This revenue must first go into the state General Fund until it repays the cost of the research bond (the amount borrowed plus the interest). Any additional revenue would be used for future immunology and immunotherapy research.",
            "Has Two Other Notable Provisions.",
            "Requires Purchases From California Suppliers. Grant recipients must buy at least half of their goods and services from California suppliers when reasonably possible.",
            "Requires California Patient Discount. Any treatment developed through funded research and sold in California must generally be offered at a 20 percent discount."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "New Bond for Specified Medical Research",
              "text": "Proposition 38 allows the state to issue an $8.4 billion general obligation bond for research in immunology and immunotherapy. Immunology is the study of the body’s immune system and how it protects the body from abnormal cells and other causes of disease. Immunotherapy develops treatments that help the immune system fight diseases more effectively. The measure requires that at least $4.2 billion of the bond funds be used for immunology research on cancer, heart disease, and Alzheimer’s disease. No more than 2 percent of total bond funds may be used for state administrative costs. Payments on the bond would come from the state General Fund.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Supports a Research Institute",
              "text": "About half of the bond funds would go to a research institute specializing in immunology and immunotherapy. The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) would select the institute. The selected institute must meet several criteria, including criteria related to its size, funding, and collaboration with a University of California (UC) campus. The institute would use the bond funds for research. Each year, the institute must issue a public report on its activities and have an independent financial audit.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Supports Research Grants",
              "text": "A council would give out the other half of bond funds as competitive research grants focused on immunology and immunotherapy. The council would consist of representatives from 7 UC campuses and 10 to 15 other universities and nonprofit research institutions in California. The council would set research priorities and select grant recipients from among its member organizations. Similar to the institute, the council would have public reporting and audit requirements.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Requires 10 Percent of Revenue From Discoveries First Be Used to Repay the State",
              "text": "Proposition 38 requires that the institute, in consultation with CDPH, try to generate the most revenue possible from the funded research. (Research, for example, could lead to the development of a new medical treatment.) Ten percent of any revenue generated must be given to the state. This revenue must first go into the state General Fund until it repays the cost of the research bond (the amount borrowed plus the interest). Any additional revenue would be used for future immunology and immunotherapy research.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Has Two Other Notable Provisions.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Requires Purchases From California Suppliers. Grant recipients must buy at least half of their goods and services from California suppliers when reasonably possible.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Requires California Patient Discount. Any treatment developed through funded research and sold in California must generally be offered at a 20 percent discount.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Increased State Cost of $500 Million to $600 Million Annually for About 20 Years to Repay the Bond. The state General Fund cost to repay the bond would be $500 million to $600 million annually for about 20 years. The annual cost would be about one-quarter of 1 percent (0.25 percent) of the state’s total General Fund budget. Since the state has to pay interest on the money it borrows, the total cost of the bond would be about 10 percent more (after adjusting for inflation) than if the state paid up-front with money it already has.",
            "Potential State Revenue From Research Discoveries. The state could receive revenue from research funded by Proposition 38. The amount of revenue is uncertain but could be significant. It would depend on how many research projects lead to marketable treatments and how much money any given treatment generates. The timing of these revenues and how long it would take to offset the state’s bond cost is also uncertain, but could take decades.",
            "Potential Indirect Fiscal Effects. Proposition 38 likely would have some indirect fiscal effects, particularly on costs for state health programs (such as Medi-Cal, which pays for health care for low-income Californians). For example, if the funded research leads to new medical treatments, the average cost of patient care could either increase or decrease. As a result, the overall effect on program costs is uncertain."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Increased State Cost of $500 Million to $600 Million Annually for About 20 Years to Repay the Bond",
              "text": "The state General Fund cost to repay the bond would be $500 million to $600 million annually for about 20 years. The annual cost would be about one-quarter of 1 percent (0.25 percent) of the state’s total General Fund budget. Since the state has to pay interest on the money it borrows, the total cost of the bond would be about 10 percent more (after adjusting for inflation) than if the state paid up-front with money it already has.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Potential State Revenue From Research Discoveries",
              "text": "The state could receive revenue from research funded by Proposition 38. The amount of revenue is uncertain but could be significant. It would depend on how many research projects lead to marketable treatments and how much money any given treatment generates. The timing of these revenues and how long it would take to offset the state’s bond cost is also uncertain, but could take decades.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Potential Indirect Fiscal Effects",
              "text": "Proposition 38 likely would have some indirect fiscal effects, particularly on costs for state health programs (such as Medi-Cal, which pays for health care for low-income Californians). For example, if the funded research leads to new medical treatments, the average cost of patient care could either increase or decrease. As a result, the overall effect on program costs is uncertain.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "California should continue supporting biomedical research. Everyone hopes for new treatments for heart disease, cancer, Alzheimer’s disease, and other serious illnesses. I do too. But Proposition 38 is the wrong way to achieve that goal.",
            "The claim that Proposition 38 will pay for itself is speculative. Audits, public disclosure, and limits on administrative costs promote accountability, but they cannot guarantee that research investments will generate enough economic returns to offset billions of dollars in bond repayments.",
            "California faces a continuing structural budget deficit.",
            "Proposition 38 would require approximately $8.4 billion in bond repayments. According to the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office, taxpayers would be committed to roughly $500 million in annual debt payments for the next 25 years. That long-term obligation would further reduce the state’s fiscal flexibility to respond to changing priorities.",
            "Meanwhile, recent actions by the Trump administration have placed funding for essential California public health programs at risk, including disease surveillance, emergency preparedness, HIV prevention, vaccination infrastructure, laboratory capacity, and community prevention. These challenges extend well beyond biomedical research.",
            "If California chooses to replace declining federal support, elected officials should be able to consider all health priorities together. Proposition 38 instead earmarks billions of borrowed dollars for one scientific field, regardless of future needs or discoveries. Research priorities should be guided through the normal budget process—not by ballot measures that lock taxpayers into decades of debt. Vote No on Proposition 38."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Robert M Kaplan, Ph.D."
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Robert M Kaplan",
              "title": "Ph.D.",
              "organization": null
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "YES ON PROP. 38 IS VITALLY NEEDED FOR LIFE-SAVING IMMUNOLOGY MEDICAL RESEARCH",
            "Today, breakthrough immunotherapies are already curing cancers like melanoma, lung cancer and leukemia. Promising research is underway to cure and prevent diseases including Alzheimer’s, heart disease, Parkinson’s, ALS and more.",
            "MASSIVE FEDERAL FUNDING CUTS ARE THREATENING PROGRESS TOWARD LIFE-SAVING CURES",
            "YES on 38 will ensure California universities and nonprofit research institutions can continue vitally needed immunology research to cure and prevent the most debilitating diseases.",
            "“Immunology saved my life—I now live cancer-free, and it could save millions of other lives too.”",
            "—Andrew Dale, Immunotherapy Patient and Cancer Survivor",
            "YES ON 38 IS DESIGNED TO PAY FOR ITSELF—WITH NO COST TO TAXPAYERS",
            "Ten percent (10%) of revenue from licensing immunotherapies must be returned to California to offset bond costs. These requirements are locked into this measure.",
            "YES ON 38 MANDATES STRONG ACCOUNTABILITY & TRANSPARENCY",
            "2% Cap on State Administrative Expenses",
            "Public Disclosure of Spending",
            "Independent Financial Audits",
            "YES ON 38 LOWERS HEALTHCARE COSTS",
            "Immunotherapies developed through Prop. 38 must be provided to California patients at 20% discount. Preventing and curing diseases will also save families and the state billions of dollars in long-term healthcare expenses.",
            "DOCTORS, NURSES AND PATIENT ADVOCATES URGE YES ON 38",
            "• Alzheimer’s Association • American Nurses Association\\ California • ALS Association • Kidney Cancer Association • Melanoma Research Alliance • National Multiple Sclerosis Society • The Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson’s Research ... and many more.",
            "Support Life-Saving Cures. Please Vote YES on 38.",
            "www.YESon38.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Andrew Dale, Cancer Survivor",
            "Santa Monica",
            "Anne M. Holloway, Board Member",
            "The Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson’s Research",
            "Chris Tarver, R.N., President",
            "American Nurses Association\\California"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Andrew Dale",
              "title": "Cancer Survivor",
              "organization": "Santa Monica"
            },
            {
              "name": "Anne M. Holloway",
              "title": "Board Member",
              "organization": "The Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson’s Research"
            },
            {
              "name": "Chris Tarver",
              "title": "R.N., President",
              "organization": "American Nurses Association\\California"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PATIENT ADVOCATES, DOCTORS, NURSES AND MEDICAL RESEARCHERS URGE YES ON PROP. 38",
            "Leading patient advocates including the Alzheimer’s Association, Michael J. Fox Foundation, American Nurses Association\\ California, ALS Association, National Multiple Sclerosis Society and Prostate Cancer Foundation all urge YES on PROP. 38 because it could save your life and the life of someone you love.",
            "“I was just weeks away from losing my life when a breakthrough immunotherapy gave me a second chance. Vote YES on PROP. 38 because every family facing a devastating diagnosis deserves this same hope.”",
            "—Laurie Adami, Cancer Survivor and Patient Advocate, Los Angeles",
            "YES ON PROP. 38—TO CURE AND PREVENT DISEASES THROUGH LIFE-SAVING IMMUNOLOGY RESEARCH",
            "PROP. 38 accelerates development of breakthrough treatments and cures for the diseases that impact nearly every family. At least half of all funds are specifically dedicated to cancer, heart disease and Alzheimer’s research.",
            "“Immunology harnesses the body’s immune system to detect and stop diseases. Today, breakthrough immunotherapies are already curing cancers like melanoma, lung cancer and leukemia. Promising research is underway to prevent diseases including Parkinson’s, heart disease, diabetes and more.”",
            "—Mark Davis, Ph.D., Member of the National Academy of Sciences and the National Academy of Medicine",
            "“One in nine people over 65 are living with Alzheimer’s, but there are currently no effective cures. YES on PROP. 38 provides real promise to find treatments and cures for the millions of patients and their families living with Alzheimer’s and dementia.”",
            "—Susan Disney Lord, Board Chair of Alzheimer’s Los Angeles",
            "HELPS OFFSET FEDERAL FUNDING CUTS TO MEDICAL RESEARCH",
            "Massive federal funding cuts and uncertainty are disrupting vitally needed medical research at nonprofit research institutes and universities, delaying progress toward life-saving cures.",
            "PROP. 38 creates a stable source of funding for breakthrough immunology research. All funds are dedicated exclusively to California-based nonprofit universities and research institutes— helping California lead the nation in medical innovation, fostering collaboration among top scientists and universities, and creating tens of thousands of good-paying jobs.",
            "“Immunotherapy is transforming the future of cancer care. PROP. 38 will help accelerate life-saving cures while strengthening California’s role as a global leader in medical innovation.”",
            "—Gina Carithers, President and CEO, Prostate Cancer Foundation",
            "LOWERS HEALTHCARE COSTS FOR CALIFORNIANS",
            "Any cure or immunotherapy developed through PROP. 38 must be provided to California patients at a 20% DISCOUNT. Preventing and curing the most pressing diseases will also reduce long-term healthcare expenses and save the state and families tens of billions of dollars in avoided medical expenses.",
            "STRONG ACCOUNTABILITY & TAXPAYER PROTECTIONS",
            "PROP. 38 is designed to pay for itself WITH NO NET COST TO THE STATE OR TAXPAYERS. Ten percent of revenue from the licensing of successful immunotherapies must be returned to California to offset the costs of the bond, including interest.",
            "PROP. 38 also includes strict accountability requirements, including:",
            "2% Cap on State Administrative Expenses",
            "Public Disclosure of Spending",
            "Independent Financial Audits",
            "For-profit corporations are not eligible for grant funding",
            "YES ON PROP. 38: SUPPORTED BY DOCTORS, NURSES AND PATIENT ADVOCATES",
            "• ALS Association • Alzheimer’s Association • American Nurses Association\\California • Blood Cancer United • California Colorectal Cancer Coalition • Liver Coalition • Michael J. Fox Foundation • National Multiple Sclerosis Society • Parkinson Association of Northern California ... and many more.",
            "YES on PROP. 38 could save your life and someone you love. Please, vote Yes.",
            "www.YesOn38.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Susan Disney Lord, Board Chair",
            "Alzheimer’s Los Angeles",
            "Eugene P. Brandon, Ph.D., Board of Trustees",
            "ALS Association",
            "Dr. Brian Shuch, M.D., Board of Directors Member",
            "Kidney Cancer Association"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Susan Disney Lord",
              "title": "Board Chair",
              "organization": "Alzheimer’s Los Angeles"
            },
            {
              "name": "Eugene P. Brandon",
              "title": "Ph.D., Board of Trustees",
              "organization": "ALS Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Dr. Brian Shuch",
              "title": "M.D., Board of Directors Member",
              "organization": "Kidney Cancer Association"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "California recognizes that continued investment in science is essential. But this proposition is not the best way to achieve that goal.",
            "The measure would authorize approximately $8.4 billion in state borrowing to support immunology and immunotherapy research through a new University of California institute. Although the objective is appealing, the financing and policy framework are flawed.",
            "First, the proposition continues the use of ballot initiatives to direct research funding toward selected topics. California has already created separate funding programs for stem cell research and precision medicine. This measure would add another highly focused program. Research priorities should be established through scientific review and public health planning—not by election campaigns. Cancer, Alzheimer’s disease, and heart disease deserve attention, but so do mental illness, kidney disease, eye diseases, and many other conditions. Ballot-box science inevitably favors the most visible topics rather than the greatest scientific opportunities or public health needs.",
            "Second, borrowing is an inappropriate way to finance scientific research. According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the bonds authorized by this measure would obligate taxpayers to $500 million in annual debt payments for about 25 years. Bonds are commonly used for highways, schools, and other long-lived infrastructure with predictable benefits. Scientific research is different. Discoveries often require decades before they improve patient care, and many promising lines of investigation never produce marketable treatments.",
            "Third, the proposition assumes that successful discoveries will generate revenues to offset state costs. In reality, universities rarely commercialize new therapies on their own. Publicly funded research lays the scientific foundation, but private companies typically invest the far greater resources required for product development, clinical testing, manufacturing, and regulatory approval. The public benefits are real, but they generally do not flow back to the state treasury.",
            "Finally, the proposition requires certain therapies developed with state support to be sold in California at discounted prices. While this may sound attractive, it could incentivize companies to prioritize selling these products in other states where the prices are not controlled.",
            "California should continue to support biomedical research. But research funding should be strategic, flexible, and fiscally responsible. Decisions about scientific priorities should be based on expert evaluation of emerging scientific opportunities and public health needs, not on a series of expensive ballot measures financed through long-term debt.",
            "California has better options. For example, Senator Scott Wiener has proposed creating a state-funded research agency modeled on the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation. Rather than directing resources to specific areas of science, such an institution could establish priorities through expert scientific review and adapt its investments as new opportunities emerge. Although the legislation has not advanced, it received support from the University of California, the United Auto Workers, and the Union of American Physicians and Dentists. Similar legislation is likely to be considered in the future.",
            "A “No” vote does not reject science. It rejects an inefficient financing mechanism and a fragmented approach to setting research priorities. California can and should support medical research through more coordinated, sustainable policies."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Robert M Kaplan, Ph.D."
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Robert M Kaplan",
              "title": "Ph.D.",
              "organization": null
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/38/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/38/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop38-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/38/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop38-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "it could save your life and the life of someone you love.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 could save the lives of voters or their loved ones.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "YES ON PROP. 38—TO CURE AND PREVENT DISEASES THROUGH LIFE-SAVING IMMUNOLOGY RESEARCH",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 is intended to cure and prevent diseases through immunology research.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 38 accelerates development of breakthrough treatments and cures for the diseases that impact nearly every family.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 accelerates development of treatments and cures.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "At least half of all funds are specifically dedicated to cancer, heart disease and Alzheimer’s research.",
          "claim": "At least half of Proposition 38 funds are dedicated to research on cancer, heart disease, and Alzheimer's disease.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The measure requires that at least $4.2 billion of the bond funds be used for immunology research on cancer, heart disease, and Alzheimer’s disease.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "“Immunology harnesses the body’s immune system to detect and stop diseases.",
          "claim": "Immunology uses the body's immune system to detect and stop diseases.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Immunology is the study of the body’s immune system and how it protects the body from abnormal cells and other causes of disease.",
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Today, breakthrough immunotherapies are already curing cancers like melanoma, lung cancer and leukemia.",
          "claim": "Immunotherapies are already curing melanoma, lung cancer, and leukemia.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Promising research is underway to prevent diseases including Parkinson’s, heart disease, diabetes and more.",
          "claim": "Research is underway to prevent Parkinson's disease, heart disease, diabetes, and other diseases.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "One in nine people over 65 are living with Alzheimer’s, but there are currently no effective cures.",
          "claim": "One in nine people over age 65 are living with Alzheimer's disease.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "YES on PROP. 38 provides real promise to find treatments and cures for the millions of patients and their families living with Alzheimer’s and dementia.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 offers a prospect of finding treatments and cures for Alzheimer's disease and dementia.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Massive federal funding cuts and uncertainty are disrupting vitally needed medical research at nonprofit research institutes and universities, delaying progress toward life-saving cures.",
          "claim": "Federal funding cuts and uncertainty are disrupting medical research at nonprofit research institutes and universities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 38 creates a stable source of funding for breakthrough immunology research.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 creates a stable funding source for immunology research.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 38 allows the state to issue an $8.4 billion general obligation bond for research in immunology and immunotherapy.",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "All funds are dedicated exclusively to California-based nonprofit universities and research institutes",
          "claim": "All Proposition 38 funds are dedicated exclusively to California-based nonprofit universities and research institutes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The council would consist of representatives from 7 UC campuses and 10 to 15 other universities and nonprofit research institutions in California.",
          "confidence": 0.75,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "helping California lead the nation in medical innovation",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 will help California lead the nation in medical innovation.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "fostering collaboration among top scientists and universities",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 will foster collaboration among scientists and universities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "creating tens of thousands of good-paying jobs.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 will create tens of thousands of well-paid jobs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Any cure or immunotherapy developed through PROP. 38 must be provided to California patients at a 20% DISCOUNT.",
          "claim": "Treatments developed through Proposition 38 must be offered to California patients at a 20 percent discount.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Any treatment developed through funded research and sold in California must generally be offered at a 20 percent discount.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Preventing and curing the most pressing diseases will also reduce long-term healthcare expenses and save the state and families tens of billions of dollars in avoided medical expenses.",
          "claim": "Preventing and curing diseases will reduce long-term health care expenses and save tens of billions of dollars.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 38 is designed to pay for itself WITH NO NET COST TO THE STATE OR TAXPAYERS.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 is intended to impose no net cost on the state or taxpayers.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Ten percent of revenue from the licensing of successful immunotherapies must be returned to California to offset the costs of the bond, including interest.",
          "claim": "Ten percent of licensing revenue from successful immunotherapies must be returned to California to offset bond costs and interest.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Ten percent of any revenue generated must be given to the state. This revenue must first go into the state General Fund until it repays the cost of the research bond (the amount borrowed plus the interest).",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "2% Cap on State Administrative Expenses",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 caps state administrative expenses at 2 percent.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "No more than 2 percent of total bond funds may be used for state administrative costs.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:21",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Public Disclosure of Spending",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 requires public disclosure of spending.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Each year, the institute must issue a public report on its activities and have an independent financial audit.",
          "confidence": 0.83,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:22",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Independent Financial Audits",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 requires independent financial audits.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Each year, the institute must issue a public report on its activities and have an independent financial audit.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_for:23",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "For-profit corporations are not eligible for grant funding",
          "claim": "For-profit corporations cannot receive Proposition 38 grant funding.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The council would set research priorities and select grant recipients from among its member organizations.",
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Today, breakthrough immunotherapies are already curing cancers like melanoma, lung cancer and leukemia.",
          "claim": "Immunotherapies are already curing melanoma, lung cancer, and leukemia.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Promising research is underway to cure and prevent diseases including Alzheimer’s, heart disease, Parkinson’s, ALS and more.",
          "claim": "Research is underway to cure and prevent Alzheimer's disease, heart disease, Parkinson's disease, ALS, and other diseases.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "MASSIVE FEDERAL FUNDING CUTS ARE THREATENING PROGRESS TOWARD LIFE-SAVING CURES",
          "claim": "Federal funding cuts are threatening progress toward cures.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "YES on 38 will ensure California universities and nonprofit research institutions can continue vitally needed immunology research to cure and prevent the most debilitating diseases.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 will ensure California universities and nonprofit research institutions can continue immunology research.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "it could save millions of other lives too.",
          "claim": "Immunology could save millions of lives.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "YES ON 38 IS DESIGNED TO PAY FOR ITSELF—WITH NO COST TO TAXPAYERS",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 is intended to pay for itself with no cost to taxpayers.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Ten percent (10%) of revenue from licensing immunotherapies must be returned to California to offset bond costs.",
          "claim": "Ten percent of immunotherapy licensing revenue must be returned to California to offset bond costs.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Ten percent of any revenue generated must be given to the state. This revenue must first go into the state General Fund until it repays the cost of the research bond (the amount borrowed plus the interest).",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "These requirements are locked into this measure.",
          "claim": "The revenue-return requirements are contained in Proposition 38.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 38 requires that the institute, in consultation with CDPH, try to generate the most revenue possible from the funded research.",
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "2% Cap on State Administrative Expenses",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 caps state administrative expenses at 2 percent.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "No more than 2 percent of total bond funds may be used for state administrative costs.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Public Disclosure of Spending",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 requires public disclosure of spending.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Each year, the institute must issue a public report on its activities and have an independent financial audit.",
          "confidence": 0.83,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Independent Financial Audits",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 requires independent financial audits.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Each year, the institute must issue a public report on its activities and have an independent financial audit.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Immunotherapies developed through Prop. 38 must be provided to California patients at 20% discount.",
          "claim": "Immunotherapies developed through Proposition 38 must be offered to California patients at a 20 percent discount.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Any treatment developed through funded research and sold in California must generally be offered at a 20 percent discount.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_against:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Preventing and curing diseases will also save families and the state billions of dollars in long-term healthcare expenses.",
          "claim": "Preventing and curing diseases will save families and the state billions of dollars in long-term health care expenses.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "The measure would authorize approximately $8.4 billion in state borrowing",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 would authorize approximately $8.4 billion in state borrowing.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 38 allows the state to issue an $8.4 billion general obligation bond for research in immunology and immunotherapy.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "to support immunology and immunotherapy research through a new University of California institute.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 would support immunology and immunotherapy research through a new University of California institute.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "About half of the bond funds would go to a research institute specializing in immunology and immunotherapy. The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) would select the institute.",
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "California has already created separate funding programs for stem cell research and precision medicine.",
          "claim": "California has created separate funding programs for stem cell research and precision medicine.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "California voters have approved two ballot measures— Proposition 71 (2004) and Proposition 14 (2020)— giving the state authority to issue general obligation bonds to fund specified medical research.",
          "confidence": 0.76,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This measure would add another highly focused program.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 would add a program focused on a specified research area.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 38 allows the state to issue an $8.4 billion general obligation bond for research in immunology and immunotherapy.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Ballot-box science inevitably favors the most visible topics rather than the greatest scientific opportunities or public health needs.",
          "claim": "Research funding decided through ballot measures favors visible topics over scientific opportunities or public health needs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the bonds authorized by this measure would obligate taxpayers to $500 million in annual debt payments for about 25 years.",
          "claim": "The bonds would require taxpayers to make $500 million in annual debt payments for about 25 years.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The state General Fund cost to repay the bond would be $500 million to $600 million annually for about 20 years.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Bonds are commonly used for highways, schools, and other long-lived infrastructure with predictable benefits.",
          "claim": "Bonds are commonly used for highways, schools, and other long-lived infrastructure.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Discoveries often require decades before they improve patient care",
          "claim": "Scientific discoveries often take decades to improve patient care.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "many promising lines of investigation never produce marketable treatments.",
          "claim": "Many promising scientific investigations never produce marketable treatments.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Most R&D projects do not make it through all of these stages.",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the proposition assumes that successful discoveries will generate revenues to offset state costs.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 assumes successful discoveries will generate revenue that offsets state costs.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The amount of revenue is uncertain but could be significant. It would depend on how many research projects lead to marketable treatments and how much money any given treatment generates.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "universities rarely commercialize new therapies on their own.",
          "claim": "Universities rarely commercialize new therapies without other entities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Publicly funded research lays the scientific foundation, but private companies typically invest the far greater resources required for product development, clinical testing, manufacturing, and regulatory approval.",
          "claim": "Private companies typically invest more than publicly funded research in product development, clinical testing, manufacturing, and regulatory approval.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Universities do most of the basic research, while companies do most of the applied and clinical research.",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "they generally do not flow back to the state treasury.",
          "claim": "Benefits of publicly funded research generally do not return to the state treasury.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The state could receive revenue from research funded by Proposition 38. The amount of revenue is uncertain but could be significant.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the proposition requires certain therapies developed with state support to be sold in California at discounted prices.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 requires certain state-supported therapies sold in California to be offered at discounted prices.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Any treatment developed through funded research and sold in California must generally be offered at a 20 percent discount.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "it could incentivize companies to prioritize selling these products in other states where the prices are not controlled.",
          "claim": "The California discount could cause companies to prioritize sales in other states.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Senator Scott Wiener has proposed creating a state-funded research agency modeled on the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation.",
          "claim": "Senator Scott Wiener has proposed a state-funded research agency modeled on the National Institutes of Health and National Science Foundation.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "such an institution could establish priorities through expert scientific review and adapt its investments as new opportunities emerge.",
          "claim": "The proposed alternative institution could set priorities through expert review and adapt investments to new opportunities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the legislation has not advanced",
          "claim": "The proposed legislation has not advanced.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "it received support from the University of California, the United Auto Workers, and the Union of American Physicians and Dentists.",
          "claim": "The proposed legislation received support from the University of California, the United Auto Workers, and the Union of American Physicians and Dentists.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:argument_against:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Similar legislation is likely to be considered in the future.",
          "claim": "Similar legislation is likely to be considered in the future.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "The claim that Proposition 38 will pay for itself is speculative.",
          "claim": "The assertion that Proposition 38 will pay for itself is speculative.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The amount of revenue is uncertain but could be significant.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Audits, public disclosure, and limits on administrative costs promote accountability",
          "claim": "Audits, public disclosure, and limits on administrative costs promote accountability.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "they cannot guarantee that research investments will generate enough economic returns to offset billions of dollars in bond repayments.",
          "claim": "The accountability provisions cannot guarantee returns sufficient to offset bond repayments.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The timing of these revenues and how long it would take to offset the state’s bond cost is also uncertain, but could take decades.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "California faces a continuing structural budget deficit.",
          "claim": "California has a continuing structural budget deficit.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 38 would require approximately $8.4 billion in bond repayments.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 would require approximately $8.4 billion in bond repayments.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Since the state has to pay interest on the money it borrows, the total cost of the bond would be about 10 percent more (after adjusting for inflation) than if the state paid up-front with money it already has.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "taxpayers would be committed to roughly $500 million in annual debt payments for the next 25 years.",
          "claim": "Taxpayers would be committed to roughly $500 million in annual debt payments for 25 years.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The state General Fund cost to repay the bond would be $500 million to $600 million annually for about 20 years.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "That long-term obligation would further reduce the state’s fiscal flexibility to respond to changing priorities.",
          "claim": "The bond obligation would reduce the state's fiscal flexibility to respond to changing priorities.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "recent actions by the Trump administration have placed funding for essential California public health programs at risk",
          "claim": "Recent Trump administration actions have put funding for essential California public health programs at risk.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "including disease surveillance, emergency preparedness, HIV prevention, vaccination infrastructure, laboratory capacity, and community prevention.",
          "claim": "The public health programs at risk include disease surveillance, emergency preparedness, HIV prevention, vaccination infrastructure, laboratory capacity, and community prevention.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-38:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 38 instead earmarks billions of borrowed dollars for one scientific field, regardless of future needs or discoveries.",
          "claim": "Proposition 38 earmarks borrowed funds for immunology and immunotherapy research rather than future unspecified needs or discoveries.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 38 allows the state to issue an $8.4 billion general obligation bond for research in immunology and immunotherapy.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-38:analysis": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
            "vig:prop-38:arguments": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-38:overview",
        "vig:prop-38:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-38:analysis",
        "vig:prop-38:arguments",
        "vig:prop-38:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-38:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-39",
      "contest_id": "prop-39",
      "number": "39",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "PROHIBITS CITIZENS FROM VOTING UNLESS THEY PRESENT GOVERNMENT-ISSUED IDENTIFICATION. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.",
      "measure_type": "initiative_constitutional_amendment",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures",
      "summary": "Invalidates mail ballots that do not have last four digits of designated government-issued identification number written on envelope. Prohibits in-person voting without presenting government-issued identification.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Costs of between tens of millions of dollars and low hundreds of millions of dollars each year to implement new voting requirements.",
      "supporters": "The Transparency Foundation; Latino American Political Assn; Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assn; CA Women’s Leadership Assn",
      "opponents": "ACLU California Action; Common Cause; League of Women Voters of California",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: Voters would be required to present additional identifying information to elections officials each time they vote.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: A voter’s identity would continue to be established with the voter’s signature.",
      "pro_short": "Yes on Prop. 39 gives California a BIPARTISAN solution for VOTER ID. Supported by a solid majority of Democratic, Independent and Republican voters. Increases trust and confidence in our elections.",
      "con_short": "No on Prop. 39. This would advance Trump’s voter suppression agenda by adding costly, unnecessary barriers that could block eligible California voters, expose personal information to identity theft, and waste hundreds of millions in taxpayer dollars. Don’t let MAGA billionaires decide which voters count. Vote No.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "YES on Proposition 39—",
          "Californians for Voter ID",
          "Info@voteridca.org",
          "www.VoterIDCA.org"
        ],
        "against": [
          "No on Prop. 39—Californians",
          "for Voting Rights",
          "info@caforvotingrights.org",
          "CAforvotingrights.org"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "Info@voteridca.org",
          "url": "mailto:Info@voteridca.org"
        },
        {
          "label": "www.VoterIDCA.org",
          "url": "https://www.voteridca.org/"
        },
        {
          "label": "info@caforvotingrights.org",
          "url": "mailto:info@caforvotingrights.org"
        },
        {
          "label": "CAforvotingrights.org",
          "url": "https://noonprop39.com/"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Prohibits voting by mail unless voter designates a government-issued identification number for their voter registration.",
        "Invalidates mail ballots if envelope does not include last four digits of a government-issued identification number matching the number designated in the voter’s registration (e.g., if voter designates Social Security number for registration, but provides driver’s license number on envelope, their ballot would not count).",
        "Prohibits voting in person without presenting government-issued identification.",
        "Requires elections officials to annually report percentage of each county’s voters whose citizenship status they have verified.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "State and local government costs of between tens of millions of dollars and low hundreds of millions of dollars each year to implement new voting requirements. Costs depend on future decisions by the Legislature, state departments, local governments, and voters.",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Elections Administration. County elections officials administer most elections in California. As part of this work, they print and mail ballots and other voting materials to registered voters. Some state agencies also have workload related to voting. For example, the Secretary of State oversees elections across the state and prepares and mails the state Voter Information Guide.",
            "United States Citizenship Required to Vote in Federal, State, and Almost All Local Elections A person must be a U.S. citizen to vote in any state or federal election. A noncitizen who votes in a state or federal election can be fined and/or sentenced to prison. A person must be a U.S. citizen to vote in the vast majority of local elections. (San Francisco and Oakland have a special process for people who are not U.S. citizens to vote only in school board elections if they are the parent, guardian, or legally recognized caregiver of a student in the school district.)",
            "Voter Registration. In order to vote, people first must register with elections officials. People register to vote in the county where they live. To be eligible to register, a person must be a U.S. citizen, live in California, be at least 18 years old, not currently be in prison, and not be found unable to vote by a court. A person who makes a false statement when attempting to register to vote in California, such as by falsely stating that they are a U.S. citizen, is guilty of the crime of perjury. People can register online through the Secretary of State’s website, by mail, in person at a county elections office, or through the California Department of Motor Vehicles. A voter’s identity is established through the registration process by using their driver’s license number, state identification number, or last four digits of their Social Security number. Voters who do not provide this identifying information through the registration process may be asked to present identification the first time they vote.",
            "Voter Rolls Maintenance. A voter roll is a list of people who are registered to vote. Elections officials are required to keep the voter rolls up to date by removing people who are no longer eligible to vote from the list. For example, elections officials receive regular updates from other government entities to identify people who have died or are in prison.",
            "Voting. All registered voters in California receive a vote by mail (VBM) ballot. Voters can mail their ballot, drop it off at a ballot drop-off location, or vote in person at a voting location. In the November 2024 Presidential Election, about 16 million people voted in California. About 13 million voted using a VBM ballot, and about 3 million voted in person.",
            "Voter Identification. Voters identify themselves when they vote in California. If they vote in person, they typically identify themselves by signing a list of registered voters before voting. If they vote by mail, they identify themselves by signing the envelope of their ballot. Elections officials verify signatures for VBM ballots before counting them. Elections officials generally do not verify signatures from in-person voters before counting the ballots.",
            "California State Auditor’s Office (State Auditor). The State Auditor is an independent and nonpartisan office in state government. It reviews how well the state and local governments use money and run their programs. These reviews include performance audits to see if the government is following the law and working efficiently. The State Auditor may give recommendations to help improve government operations and efficiency. Some audits happen regularly, while others are done only once."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Elections Administration",
              "text": "County elections officials administer most elections in California. As part of this work, they print and mail ballots and other voting materials to registered voters. Some state agencies also have workload related to voting. For example, the Secretary of State oversees elections across the state and prepares and mails the state Voter Information Guide.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "United States Citizenship Required to Vote in Federal, State, and Almost All Local Elections A person must be a U.S. citizen to vote in any state or federal election. A noncitizen who votes in a state or federal election can be fined and/or sentenced to prison. A person must be a U.S. citizen to vote in the vast majority of local elections. (San Francisco and Oakland have a special process for people who are not U.S. citizens to vote only in school board elections if they are the parent, guardian, or legally recognized caregiver of a student in the school district.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Voter Registration",
              "text": "In order to vote, people first must register with elections officials. People register to vote in the county where they live. To be eligible to register, a person must be a U.S. citizen, live in California, be at least 18 years old, not currently be in prison, and not be found unable to vote by a court. A person who makes a false statement when attempting to register to vote in California, such as by falsely stating that they are a U.S. citizen, is guilty of the crime of perjury. People can register online through the Secretary of State’s website, by mail, in person at a county elections office, or through the California Department of Motor Vehicles. A voter’s identity is established through the registration process by using their driver’s license number, state identification number, or last four digits of their Social Security number. Voters who do not provide this identifying information through the registration process may be asked to present identification the first time they vote.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Voter Rolls Maintenance",
              "text": "A voter roll is a list of people who are registered to vote. Elections officials are required to keep the voter rolls up to date by removing people who are no longer eligible to vote from the list. For example, elections officials receive regular updates from other government entities to identify people who have died or are in prison.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Voting",
              "text": "All registered voters in California receive a vote by mail (VBM) ballot. Voters can mail their ballot, drop it off at a ballot drop-off location, or vote in person at a voting location. In the November 2024 Presidential Election, about 16 million people voted in California. About 13 million voted using a VBM ballot, and about 3 million voted in person.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Voter Identification",
              "text": "Voters identify themselves when they vote in California. If they vote in person, they typically identify themselves by signing a list of registered voters before voting. If they vote by mail, they identify themselves by signing the envelope of their ballot. Elections officials verify signatures for VBM ballots before counting them. Elections officials generally do not verify signatures from in-person voters before counting the ballots.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "California State Auditor’s Office (State Auditor)",
              "text": "The State Auditor is an independent and nonpartisan office in state government. It reviews how well the state and local governments use money and run their programs. These reviews include performance audits to see if the government is following the law and working efficiently. The State Auditor may give recommendations to help improve government operations and efficiency. Some audits happen regularly, while others are done only once.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Requires State and Local Elections Officials to Verify U.S. Citizenship Status of Registered Voters. Proposition 39 requires state and local elections officials to make “best efforts” using government data to verify that voters on the rolls are U.S. citizens. Proposition 39 requires elections officials to report every year the percentage of registered voters in each county whose citizenship status has been verified.",
            "Requires Voters to Select Government- Issued Identification for Voting by Mail. Proposition 39 requires new and existing voters to select a government-issued identification in their voter registration to vote by mail.",
            "Requires Voters to Provide Additional Identifying Information to Vote. Proposition 39 requires voters to provide additional identifying information each time they cast a ballot in any election in California. Elections officials would be required to verify voters’ identities before counting their ballots. The identification requirement would depend on whether a voter casts their ballot in person or by mail:",
            "In-Person Voting. When voting in person, Proposition 39 requires voters to present government-issued identification for identity verification.",
            "Voting by Mail. When voting by mail, Proposition 39 requires voters to provide the last four digits of their selected government-issued identification number on the ballot envelope. Elections officials would verify that the identification numbers provided on the ballot envelope match the voter’s registration information.",
            "Creates New State-Issued Voter Identification Card. Proposition 39 requires the state to provide a voter identification card at no cost to voters who request one. The voter identification card could be used as the government-issued identification that verifies a voter’s identity when voting.",
            "Requires State Auditor to Audit State and County Election Compliance Regularly. In every odd-numbered year, Proposition 39 requires the State Auditor to report how well the state and each county comply with the measure and make recommendations for improvement.",
            "Requires Legislative Action for Full Implementation. Proposition 39 requires the Legislature to pass additional laws to implement the measure. The Legislature would need to clarify several details that are not defined in the proposition, like which forms of identification could be used and what steps would be considered best efforts to verify the citizenship status of registered voters."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Requires State and Local Elections Officials to Verify U.S. Citizenship Status of Registered Voters",
              "text": "Proposition 39 requires state and local elections officials to make “best efforts” using government data to verify that voters on the rolls are U.S. citizens. Proposition 39 requires elections officials to report every year the percentage of registered voters in each county whose citizenship status has been verified.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Requires Voters to Select Government- Issued Identification for Voting by Mail",
              "text": "Proposition 39 requires new and existing voters to select a government-issued identification in their voter registration to vote by mail.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Requires Voters to Provide Additional Identifying Information to Vote",
              "text": "Proposition 39 requires voters to provide additional identifying information each time they cast a ballot in any election in California. Elections officials would be required to verify voters’ identities before counting their ballots. The identification requirement would depend on whether a voter casts their ballot in person or by mail:",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "In-Person Voting. When voting in person, Proposition 39 requires voters to present government-issued identification for identity verification.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Voting by Mail. When voting by mail, Proposition 39 requires voters to provide the last four digits of their selected government-issued identification number on the ballot envelope. Elections officials would verify that the identification numbers provided on the ballot envelope match the voter’s registration information.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Creates New State-Issued Voter Identification Card",
              "text": "Proposition 39 requires the state to provide a voter identification card at no cost to voters who request one. The voter identification card could be used as the government-issued identification that verifies a voter’s identity when voting.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Requires State Auditor to Audit State and County Election Compliance Regularly",
              "text": "In every odd-numbered year, Proposition 39 requires the State Auditor to report how well the state and each county comply with the measure and make recommendations for improvement.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Requires Legislative Action for Full Implementation",
              "text": "Proposition 39 requires the Legislature to pass additional laws to implement the measure. The Legislature would need to clarify several details that are not defined in the proposition, like which forms of identification could be used and what steps would be considered best efforts to verify the citizenship status of registered voters.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "State and Local Costs Depend on Future Decisions. Proposition 39 would increase state and local government costs each year by tens of millions of dollars to low hundreds of millions of dollars. These costs represent less than one-quarter of 1 percent (0.25 percent) of the state’s total General Fund budget. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.) The exact cost would depend on future choices made by the Legislature, state departments, local governments, and voters. For example, the costs could vary depending on decisions around the design and requirements of the voter identification card and the number of cards requested. There also could be some amount of savings. These savings would be due to fewer people registered to vote—for example, due to the removal of ineligible voters or eligible voters lacking government-issued identification. These savings likely would not exceed the costs of the measure."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "State and Local Costs Depend on Future Decisions",
              "text": "Proposition 39 would increase state and local government costs each year by tens of millions of dollars to low hundreds of millions of dollars. These costs represent less than one-quarter of 1 percent (0.25 percent) of the state’s total General Fund budget. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.) The exact cost would depend on future choices made by the Legislature, state departments, local governments, and voters. For example, the costs could vary depending on decisions around the design and requirements of the voter identification card and the number of cards requested. There also could be some amount of savings. These savings would be due to fewer people registered to vote—for example, due to the removal of ineligible voters or eligible voters lacking government-issued identification. These savings likely would not exceed the costs of the measure.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "NO on PROP. 39—Stop Trump from rigging our elections. Don’t believe the lies. Prop. 39 MAKES VOTING HARDER, MORE EXPENSIVE, AND LESS SAFE for Californians.",
            "PROP. 39 IS FUNDED BY MAGA RIGHTWING BILLIONAIRES. Follow the money. MAGA billionaires have spent millions spreading election lies. Republican operatives have pushed this voter suppression agenda for years. They want Trump to have unlimited power so they get more tax breaks for the rich while cutting funding to healthcare and schools for the rest of us.",
            "California election officials already verify voters. Prop. 39 just ADDS EXTRA HURDLES for citizens. THE FACTS DON’T LIE. When Texas tried this, they threw out 12 times more mail ballots than California.",
            "Prop. 39 creates new threats of identity theft. No citizen should have to choose between their privacy and their right to vote.",
            "The nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office found that Prop. 39 could COST HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS EACH YEAR—read it for yourself. MAGA extremists want to use your taxpayer dollars to buy Trump an expensive gift: blocking eligible voters and giving the Big Lie a win in California. We won’t fall for it.",
            "PROP. 39 TRIES TO DISTRACT US from how Trump and his billionaire friends have failed Americans. Hospitals are closing. Fire victims are still waiting for help. Groceries and housing costs are more expensive than ever. Now they want to use Prop. 39 to control our elections and avoid accountability.",
            "NO KINGS. NO LIES. NO PROP. 39."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Alex Padilla, U.S. Senator for California",
            "Catherine Kennedy, President",
            "California Nurses Association",
            "Adam Weinberger, President",
            "California School Employees Association"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Alex Padilla",
              "title": "U.S. Senator for California",
              "organization": null
            },
            {
              "name": "Catherine Kennedy",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Nurses Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Adam Weinberger",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California School Employees Association"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROP. 39 IS BIPARTISAN—NOT ABOUT DONALD TRUMP OR GAVIN NEWSOM",
            "Prop. 39 gives California a bipartisan solution for election security. While politicians in D.C. fight over partisan control of elections, Californians can adopt our own solution: Voter ID. Opponents will claim this measure is about Donald Trump or Gavin Newsom. It isn’t. Prop. 39 is a California solution to growing mistrust in our elections. Democrats, Republicans, and Nonpartisans encourage you to reject the big-money partisan allegations and vote yes on Prop. 39 to encourage voter participation and protect our elections.",
            "PROP. 39 IMPROVES ELECTION MANAGEMENT",
            "Prop. 39 improves the accuracy of our voter lists and requires independent audits to strengthen election management.",
            "VOTER ID INCREASES TRUST IN ELECTIONS",
            "States with voter ID laws have not seen decreases in voter participation. When voters trust elections, participation increases.",
            "YES ON PROP. 39",
            "Opponents will claim this is about national politics or that Voter ID suppresses voters. Don’t be fooled. Prop. 39 is supported by Democrats, Republicans, and Nonpartisans, as well as men, women, young, and old—Californians across many communities.",
            "If you believe California should strengthen trust in elections while keeping voting accessible for eligible voters, vote YES on Prop. 39 for a clean, bipartisan California solution."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Johnathan Hale, Executive Director",
            "The Transparency Foundation",
            "Cynthia Kaui, Executive Director",
            "California Women’s Leadership Association",
            "Ed Cervantes, President",
            "Latino American Political Association"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Johnathan Hale",
              "title": "Executive Director",
              "organization": "The Transparency Foundation"
            },
            {
              "name": "Cynthia Kaui",
              "title": "Executive Director",
              "organization": "California Women’s Leadership Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Ed Cervantes",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Latino American Political Association"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTER ID: A BIPARTISAN WAY TO INCREASE TRUST IN OUR ELECTIONS",
            "Democratic, Independent, and Republican voters all agree on one thing: Voter ID is a common-sense reform to increase trust and participation in our elections. That’s why almost half the signatures to put Prop. 39 on the ballot came from Democratic and Independent voters and polls show widespread super-majority support across all political parties for Voter ID.",
            "PROP. 39 KEEPS VOTING ACCESSIBLE AND GUARANTEES A FREE VOTER ID",
            "Prop. 39 keeps mail ballots, extended polling hours and all other conveniences in place for voting accessibility.",
            "Voters can use a variety of easily-obtained government IDs to vote—and this measure even guarantees every voter a FREE Voter ID if they want one.",
            "California currently uses a slow process to check signatures on mail ballots that not only delays election results but also puts your vote at risk of not being counted if your signature is flagged as not matching. Many voters say they cannot always remember how they signed their name years ago when they first registered to vote. In the last election, more than 100,000 ballots were rejected due to signature mismatches—and more than 200,000 voters endured hassles just to get their vote to count.",
            "VOTER ID INCREASES PARTICIPATION",
            "Voter ID does not suppress voting—in fact it increases voter participation. Every state with Voter ID laws and free identification for eligible voters that cannot afford or access identification, has seen an increase in voting. Suppression and lower turnout happen when voters do not have trust and confidence in the integrity of the process. Voter ID gives all voters a reason to trust that their vote will matter.",
            "PROP. 39 INCLUDES AUDITS AND CITIZENSHIP VERIFICATION",
            "Prop. 39 holds election officials accountable for keeping California’s voter lists accurate and updated. Election officials will also be required to check voter rolls to ensure only citizens are registered. Prop. 39 requires an independent audit be conducted every two years to give the public the confidence they deserve in the way our elections are conducted.",
            "YES ON PROP. 39: FOR A NON-PARTISAN SOLUTION TO VOTER ID",
            "Politicians and partisan organizations who oppose Prop. 39 are desperately trying to inject toxic partisanship into this debate. That’s because they benefit from unfounded election conspiracy theories and rapidly declining trust in our elections.",
            "In contrast, supporters of Prop. 39 include solid majorities of Democratic, Republican and Independent voters and a diverse coalition including Latino American Political Association, California Women’s Leadership Association, Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, the Transparency Foundation, and trusted voting rights organizations. Vote YES on Prop. 39 to create a national model for implementing Voter ID in a bipartisan way."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Margit Whitlock, Democratic Coalition Chair",
            "Californians for Voter ID",
            "Tafa Jefferson, Republican Coalition Chair",
            "Californians for Voter ID",
            "Joe Green, Independent Coalition Chair",
            "Californians for Voter ID"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Margit Whitlock",
              "title": "Democratic Coalition Chair",
              "organization": "Californians for Voter ID"
            },
            {
              "name": "Tafa Jefferson",
              "title": "Republican Coalition Chair",
              "organization": "Californians for Voter ID"
            },
            {
              "name": "Joe Green",
              "title": "Independent Coalition Chair",
              "organization": "Californians for Voter ID"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE NO. Donald Trump lies about elections and uses those lies to grab power.",
            "STOP TRUMP’S POWER GRAB. Trump wants revenge on California—he has delayed LA wildfire relief, undone laws to keep our air and water clean, and constantly attacked our immigrant friends and neighbors. Now he wants to undo our freedoms and democracy with Prop. 39. Trump’s cronies want to rig California elections so they can seize and keep control of Congress and the White House. Trump will do whatever it takes to tear apart our right to vote, dodge accountability, and hold onto authoritarian power.",
            "CALIFORNIANS WON’T FALL FOR IT. We have a chance to fight back and stop Trump by voting NO on Prop. 39. Don’t let California become the next state where politicians pick which voters count.",
            "WASTES HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS.",
            "Trump and his accomplices want California to spend hundreds of millions of dollars to chase their election lies and conspiracy theories. Californians are struggling, and Trump wants YOU to pay for his conspiracies.",
            "PUTS YOUR IDENTITY AT RISK. Prop. 39 will make every vote by mail voter include their personal details on their return envelope—making voters easy targets for identity theft. Voters would have to choose between voting and protecting their privacy.",
            "BLOCKS CITIZENS FROM VOTING. Prop. 39 adds new hurdles—voters would have to include a personal ID number on their ballot envelope that has to exactly match state records. Get one digit wrong, and a valid ballot could get thrown out. If you don’t take extra steps to tell officials which ID you want to use for voting—you may not get a mail ballot at all. And if the address on your ID is not up to date or your name is misspelled—your vote might be rejected.",
            "PUSHES OUT VOTERS. “Free” state IDs aren’t free: voters still pay for transportation, time off work, and costs like childcare or getting required documents. Seniors, students, low-income workers, voters of color, and the millions of women who changed their names at marriage are hit hardest. These unfair barriers help politicians choose their voters instead of the other way around.",
            "TRUMP LIES TO GRAB POWER. DON’T LET THOSE LIES TAKE AWAY YOUR VOTE.",
            "PROTECT YOUR VOICE. PROTECT YOUR VOTE. VOTE NO.",
            "Learn more at CAforVotingRights.org"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "David Trujillo, Executive Director",
            "ACLU California Action",
            "Darius Kemp, California State Director",
            "Common Cause",
            "Lorrel Plimier, Co-President",
            "League of Women Voters of California"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "David Trujillo",
              "title": "Executive Director",
              "organization": "ACLU California Action"
            },
            {
              "name": "Darius Kemp",
              "title": "California State Director",
              "organization": "Common Cause"
            },
            {
              "name": "Lorrel Plimier",
              "title": "Co-President",
              "organization": "League of Women Voters of California"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/39/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/39/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop39-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/39/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop39-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "VOTER ID: A BIPARTISAN WAY TO INCREASE TRUST IN OUR ELECTIONS",
          "claim": "Voter ID is bipartisan.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Voter ID is a common-sense reform to increase trust and participation in our elections.",
          "claim": "Voter ID would increase trust and participation in elections.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "almost half the signatures to put Prop. 39 on the ballot came from Democratic and Independent voters",
          "claim": "Nearly half of Proposition 39 petition signatures came from Democratic and Independent voters.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "polls show widespread super-majority support across all political parties for Voter ID.",
          "claim": "Polls show supermajority support for voter ID across political parties.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 39 KEEPS VOTING ACCESSIBLE AND GUARANTEES A FREE VOTER ID",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 keeps voting accessible.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 requires voters to provide additional identifying information each time they cast a ballot in any election in California.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 keeps mail ballots, extended polling hours and all other conveniences in place for voting accessibility.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 keeps mail ballots in place.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 requires new and existing voters to select a government-issued identification in their voter registration to vote by mail.",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Voters can use a variety of easily-obtained government IDs to vote",
          "claim": "Voters may use a variety of easily obtained government IDs to vote under Proposition 39.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The Legislature would need to clarify several details that are not defined in the proposition, like which forms of identification could be used",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "this measure even guarantees every voter a FREE Voter ID if they want one.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 provides a free voter ID to every voter who requests one.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 requires the state to provide a voter identification card at no cost to voters who request one.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California currently uses a slow process to check signatures on mail ballots",
          "claim": "California uses a slow process to check signatures on mail ballots.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "delays election results",
          "claim": "California's mail-ballot signature-checking process delays election results.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "puts your vote at risk of not being counted if your signature is flagged as not matching.",
          "claim": "A mail ballot with a signature flagged as nonmatching may not be counted.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Elections officials verify signatures for VBM ballots before counting them.",
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Many voters say they cannot always remember how they signed their name years ago when they first registered to vote.",
          "claim": "Many voters report that they cannot always remember the signature they used when registering to vote.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "In the last election, more than 100,000 ballots were rejected due to signature mismatches",
          "claim": "More than 100,000 ballots were rejected for signature mismatches in the last election.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "more than 200,000 voters endured hassles just to get their vote to count.",
          "claim": "More than 200,000 voters faced difficulties getting their votes counted in the last election.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "VOTER ID INCREASES PARTICIPATION",
          "claim": "Voter ID increases voter participation.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Voter ID does not suppress voting",
          "claim": "Voter ID does not reduce voting.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "it increases voter participation.",
          "claim": "Voter ID increases voter participation.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Every state with Voter ID laws and free identification for eligible voters that cannot afford or access identification, has seen an increase in voting.",
          "claim": "Every state with voter ID laws and free accessible identification for eligible voters has had increased voting.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Suppression and lower turnout happen when voters do not have trust and confidence in the integrity of the process.",
          "claim": "Lack of voter trust and confidence causes suppression and lower turnout.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Voter ID gives all voters a reason to trust that their vote will matter.",
          "claim": "Voter ID gives all voters reason to trust that their vote will matter.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:21",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 39 INCLUDES AUDITS AND CITIZENSHIP VERIFICATION",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 includes audits.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "In every odd-numbered year, Proposition 39 requires the State Auditor to report how well the state and each county comply with the measure and make recommendations for improvement.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:22",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 holds election officials accountable for keeping California’s voter lists accurate and updated.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 holds election officials accountable for keeping California voter lists accurate and updated.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 requires state and local elections officials to make “best efforts” using government data to verify that voters on the rolls are U.S. citizens.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:23",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Election officials will also be required to check voter rolls to ensure only citizens are registered.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 requires election officials to check voter rolls to ensure that only citizens are registered.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 requires state and local elections officials to make “best efforts” using government data to verify that voters on the rolls are U.S. citizens.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:24",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 requires an independent audit be conducted every two years",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 requires an independent audit every two years.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "In every odd-numbered year, Proposition 39 requires the State Auditor to report how well the state and each county comply with the measure and make recommendations for improvement.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:25",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Politicians and partisan organizations who oppose Prop. 39 are desperately trying to inject toxic partisanship into this debate.",
          "claim": "Opponents are trying to make the Proposition 39 debate partisan.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:26",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "they benefit from unfounded election conspiracy theories and rapidly declining trust in our elections.",
          "claim": "Opponents of Proposition 39 benefit from election conspiracy theories and declining trust in elections.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_for:27",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "supporters of Prop. 39 include solid majorities of Democratic, Republican and Independent voters",
          "claim": "Solid majorities of Democratic, Republican, and Independent voters support Proposition 39.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 39 IS BIPARTISAN—NOT ABOUT DONALD TRUMP OR GAVIN NEWSOM",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 is not about Donald Trump or Gavin Newsom.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 39 IS BIPARTISAN—NOT ABOUT DONALD TRUMP OR GAVIN NEWSOM",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 is bipartisan.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 gives California a bipartisan solution for election security.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 provides California a bipartisan election-security solution.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "politicians in D.C. fight over partisan control of elections",
          "claim": "Politicians in Washington, D.C., fight over partisan control of elections.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Californians can adopt our own solution: Voter ID.",
          "claim": "California voters can adopt voter ID through Proposition 39.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "When voting in person, Proposition 39 requires voters to present government-issued identification for identity verification.",
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 is a California solution to growing mistrust in our elections.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 was intended as a response to growing mistrust in elections.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Democrats, Republicans, and Nonpartisans encourage you to reject the big-money partisan allegations",
          "claim": "Democrats, Republicans, and nonpartisans encourage voters to reject allegations that partisan interests supply large amounts of money.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 improves the accuracy of our voter lists",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 improves the accuracy of voter lists.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "requires independent audits",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 requires independent audits.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "In every odd-numbered year, Proposition 39 requires the State Auditor to report how well the state and each county comply with the measure and make recommendations for improvement.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "States with voter ID laws have not seen decreases in voter participation.",
          "claim": "States with voter ID laws have not had reduced voter participation.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "When voters trust elections, participation increases.",
          "claim": "Voter trust in elections increases participation.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Opponents will claim this is about national politics",
          "claim": "Opponents will claim Proposition 39 concerns national politics.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 is supported by Democrats, Republicans, and Nonpartisans, as well as men, women, young, and old—Californians across many communities.",
          "claim": "People of the listed political affiliations, genders, ages, and communities support Proposition 39.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_against:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 for a clean, bipartisan California solution.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 is a bipartisan California solution.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Donald Trump lies about elections and uses those lies to grab power.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump makes false statements about elections to gain power.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Trump wants revenge on California",
          "claim": "Donald Trump seeks revenge on California.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "he has delayed LA wildfire relief",
          "claim": "Donald Trump delayed Los Angeles wildfire relief.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "undone laws to keep our air and water clean",
          "claim": "Donald Trump undid laws intended to keep air and water clean.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "constantly attacked our immigrant friends and neighbors.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump has repeatedly attacked immigrants.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Now he wants to undo our freedoms and democracy with Prop. 39.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump seeks to use Proposition 39 to undo freedoms and democracy.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Trump’s cronies want to rig California elections so they can seize and keep control of Congress and the White House.",
          "claim": "Trump allies seek to rig California elections to gain and retain control of Congress and the White House.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Trump will do whatever it takes to tear apart our right to vote, dodge accountability, and hold onto authoritarian power.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump intends to undermine voting rights, avoid accountability, and retain power.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "politicians pick which voters count.",
          "claim": "Politicians would choose which voters' ballots count.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Elections officials would be required to verify voters’ identities before counting their ballots.",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "WASTES HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 wastes hundreds of millions of dollars.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 would increase state and local government costs each year by tens of millions of dollars to low hundreds of millions of dollars.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Trump and his accomplices want California to spend hundreds of millions of dollars to chase their election lies and conspiracy theories.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump and his allies want California to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on Proposition 39.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 would increase state and local government costs each year by tens of millions of dollars to low hundreds of millions of dollars.",
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Trump and his accomplices want California to spend hundreds of millions of dollars to chase their election lies and conspiracy theories.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump and his allies seek spending on Proposition 39 to pursue election lies and conspiracy theories.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Trump wants YOU to pay for his conspiracies.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump wants voters to pay for election conspiracy theories.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 will make every vote by mail voter include their personal details on their return envelope",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 requires every vote-by-mail voter to include personal details on the return envelope.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "When voting by mail, Proposition 39 requires voters to provide the last four digits of their selected government-issued identification number on the ballot envelope.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "making voters easy targets for identity theft.",
          "claim": "The proposition's mail-ballot information requirement makes voters easy targets for identity theft.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 adds new hurdles",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 adds new voting requirements.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 requires voters to provide additional identifying information each time they cast a ballot in any election in California.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "voters would have to include a personal ID number on their ballot envelope that has to exactly match state records.",
          "claim": "Vote-by-mail voters must put a personal ID number on their ballot envelope that exactly matches state records.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Elections officials would verify that the identification numbers provided on the ballot envelope match the voter’s registration information.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Get one digit wrong, and a valid ballot could get thrown out.",
          "claim": "A valid ballot could be rejected if a voter enters one ID-number digit incorrectly.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Elections officials would verify that the identification numbers provided on the ballot envelope match the voter’s registration information.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "If you don’t take extra steps to tell officials which ID you want to use for voting—you may not get a mail ballot at all.",
          "claim": "A voter who does not select an ID for voting may not receive a mail ballot.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 requires new and existing voters to select a government-issued identification in their voter registration to vote by mail.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "if the address on your ID is not up to date or your name is misspelled—your vote might be rejected.",
          "claim": "A vote might be rejected because an ID address is outdated or a name is misspelled.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:21",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "“Free” state IDs aren’t free: voters still pay for transportation, time off work, and costs like childcare or getting required documents.",
          "claim": "Voters may incur transportation, missed-work, childcare, and document costs to obtain state IDs.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:22",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Seniors, students, low-income workers, voters of color, and the millions of women who changed their names at marriage are hit hardest.",
          "claim": "The listed groups bear the greatest burden from the ID requirements.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:argument_against:23",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "These unfair barriers help politicians choose their voters instead of the other way around.",
          "claim": "The voting requirements help politicians choose voters.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 MAKES VOTING HARDER, MORE EXPENSIVE, AND LESS SAFE for Californians.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 makes voting more expensive for Californians.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 MAKES VOTING HARDER, MORE EXPENSIVE, AND LESS SAFE for Californians.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 makes voting harder for Californians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 39 IS FUNDED BY MAGA RIGHTWING BILLIONAIRES.",
          "claim": "MAGA right-wing billionaires fund Proposition 39.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "MAGA billionaires have spent millions spreading election lies.",
          "claim": "MAGA billionaires have spent millions spreading election lies.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Republican operatives have pushed this voter suppression agenda for years.",
          "claim": "Republican operatives have promoted the voter-suppression agenda for years.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "They want Trump to have unlimited power so they get more tax breaks for the rich while cutting funding to healthcare and schools for the rest of us.",
          "claim": "Republican operatives seek unlimited power for Donald Trump so they can obtain tax breaks for wealthy people and cut health care and school funding.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 just ADDS EXTRA HURDLES for citizens.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 adds new requirements for citizens voting in California.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 requires voters to provide additional identifying information each time they cast a ballot in any election in California.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "When Texas tried this, they threw out 12 times more mail ballots than California.",
          "claim": "Texas rejected mail ballots at 12 times California's rate after adopting this policy.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 39 creates new threats of identity theft.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 creates new identity-theft risks.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "No citizen should have to choose between their privacy and their right to vote.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 forces citizens to choose between privacy and the right to vote.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "The nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office found that Prop. 39 could COST HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS EACH YEAR",
          "claim": "The Legislative Analyst's Office found that Proposition 39 could cost hundreds of millions of dollars annually.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 39 would increase state and local government costs each year by tens of millions of dollars to low hundreds of millions of dollars.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "MAGA extremists want to use your taxpayer dollars to buy Trump an expensive gift: blocking eligible voters and giving the Big Lie a win in California.",
          "claim": "MAGA extremists seek to use taxpayer funds through Proposition 39 to block eligible voters and advance election-fraud claims.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 39 TRIES TO DISTRACT US from how Trump and his billionaire friends have failed Americans.",
          "claim": "Proposition 39 was intended to distract from Donald Trump and his billionaire friends' failures.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Hospitals are closing.",
          "claim": "Hospitals are closing.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Fire victims are still waiting for help.",
          "claim": "Fire victims are still awaiting assistance.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Groceries and housing costs are more expensive than ever.",
          "claim": "Grocery and housing costs are at their highest levels ever.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-39:rebuttal_to_for:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Now they want to use Prop. 39 to control our elections and avoid accountability.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump and his billionaire friends seek to use Proposition 39 to control elections and avoid accountability.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-39:analysis": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
            "vig:prop-39:arguments": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-39:overview",
        "vig:prop-39:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-39:analysis",
        "vig:prop-39:arguments",
        "vig:prop-39:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-39:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-40",
      "contest_id": "prop-40",
      "number": "40",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "IMPOSES ONE-TIME TAX ON CERTAIN TAXPAYERS. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT AND STATUTE.",
      "measure_type": "initiative_constitutional_amendment_and_statute",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures",
      "summary": "Imposes 5% tax on certain taxpayers with assets over $1 billion; revenue primarily for health care. Exempts revenues from constitutional requirements for school funding and spending limit.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Temporary revenue increase of tens of billions of dollars spread over several years from wealth tax on billionaires. Possible ongoing decrease of less than $1 billion per year in income tax revenue from billionaires.",
      "supporters": "US Senator Bernie Sanders; SEIU United Healthcare Workers West",
      "opponents": "California Primary Care Association; California School Boards Association; California Taxpayers Association",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: The state would collect a one-time tax from billionaires equal to 5 percent of their wealth.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: The state would not collect a one-time tax from billionaires equal to 5 percent of their wealth.",
      "pro_short": "Vote YES on 40 to tax billionaires. Trump slashed healthcare funding to pay for billionaire tax breaks, eliminating coverage for over a million Californians and doubling health insurance premiums for millions more. It’s time to make billionaires pay their fair share and stop sticking the middle class with the bill.",
      "con_short": "Prop. 40 is a flawed, one-time tax scheme that hurts our economy, damages our state budget, and contains a loophole exposing all Californians to taxes we can’t afford—but does nothing to lower healthcare costs. No safeguards, no accountability. Join California Teachers Association, California Medical Association, California Children’s Hospital Association, California Professional Firefighters, State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, Democrats and Republicans: NO on 40.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "Suzanne Jimenez",
          "SEIU-UHW",
          "5480 Ferguson Drive",
          "Los Angeles, CA 90022",
          "(855) 507-7562",
          "info@YesOn40.com",
          "www.yeson40.com"
        ],
        "against": [
          "Californians to Protect Funding",
          "for Schools, Healthcare and",
          "Public Safety",
          "Info@VoteNoOn40.org",
          "VoteNoOn40.org"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "info@YesOn40.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@YesOn40.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "www.yeson40.com",
          "url": "https://yeson40.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Info@VoteNoOn40.org",
          "url": "mailto:Info@VoteNoOn40.org"
        },
        {
          "label": "VoteNoOn40.org",
          "url": "https://votenoon40.org/"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Imposes one-time tax of up to 5% on certain taxpayers with covered assets valued over $1 billion; covered assets include businesses, securities, art, collectibles, and intellectual property, but exclude real property and some pensions and retirement accounts.",
        "Allocates 90% of these tax revenues for health care, 10% for food assistance or education-related programs; prohibits using revenues to replace existing funding for these purposes.",
        "Exempts such tax revenues from constitutional requirements for school funding, budget reserves, and state spending limit.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Temporary state revenue increase from a new wealth tax on billionaires. These wealth tax revenues probably would add up to tens of billions of dollars spread over several years.",
        "Possible ongoing decrease of less than $1 billion per year in state income tax revenue collected from billionaires.",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "California Is Home to Many Billionaires. Several of the wealthiest people in the world live in California. Wealth is the value of all the things a person owns. Wealth is different from income, which is how much a person earns in a set period of time, like one year. A person’s wealth typically is measured by their net worth. A person’s net worth is the value of all the things they own, like stocks, businesses, or other investments, minus their debts. California is home to a few hundred people with net worth over $1 billion, often called billionaires. Many of these billionaires gained their wealth as executives or investors in California technology companies.",
            "Health Care Is a Major Category of State Spending. The state and federal government spend over $200 billion per year on state health care programs. Most state health care spending is for Medi-Cal, the state’s health insurance program for low-income people. State spending also supports public health programs, mental health care, and drug and alcohol treatment."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "California Is Home to Many Billionaires",
              "text": "Several of the wealthiest people in the world live in California. Wealth is the value of all the things a person owns. Wealth is different from income, which is how much a person earns in a set period of time, like one year. A person’s wealth typically is measured by their net worth. A person’s net worth is the value of all the things they own, like stocks, businesses, or other investments, minus their debts. California is home to a few hundred people with net worth over $1 billion, often called billionaires. Many of these billionaires gained their wealth as executives or investors in California technology companies.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Health Care Is a Major Category of State Spending",
              "text": "The state and federal government spend over $200 billion per year on state health care programs. Most state health care spending is for Medi-Cal, the state’s health insurance program for low-income people. State spending also supports public health programs, mental health care, and drug and alcohol treatment.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Establishes One-Time Wealth Tax on Billionaires. Under Proposition 40, billionaires who were residents of California on January 1, 2026 would have to pay a one-time state tax equal to 5 percent of their net worth. The tax would be due in 2027. Taxpayers would have the option to spread the payments over five years but would have to pay more to do so. Real estate, pensions, and retirement accounts generally would be excluded from the tax.",
            "Most of the Money Must Be Spent on Health Care. The state would decide how and when to spend the money from the wealth tax, but it would have to be spent on certain types of services. Ninety percent of the money would have to be spent on health care services for the public. The rest would have to be spent on education, food assistance, and administration of the wealth tax. Existing rules in the State Constitution that limit spending and require the state to spend a certain amount on schools and community colleges would not apply to this money."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Establishes One-Time Wealth Tax on Billionaires",
              "text": "Under Proposition 40, billionaires who were residents of California on January 1, 2026 would have to pay a one-time state tax equal to 5 percent of their net worth. The tax would be due in 2027. Taxpayers would have the option to spread the payments over five years but would have to pay more to do so. Real estate, pensions, and retirement accounts generally would be excluded from the tax.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Most of the Money Must Be Spent on Health Care",
              "text": "The state would decide how and when to spend the money from the wealth tax, but it would have to be spent on certain types of services. Ninety percent of the money would have to be spent on health care services for the public. The rest would have to be spent on education, food assistance, and administration of the wealth tax. Existing rules in the State Constitution that limit spending and require the state to spend a certain amount on schools and community colleges would not apply to this money.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Temporary State Revenue Increase From Wealth Tax. The state probably would collect tens of billions of dollars from the wealth tax. This temporary increase in state tax collections would be spread across several years. Exactly when and how much the state would collect is very hard to predict for many reasons. For example, it is hard to know what actions billionaires would take to reduce the amount of tax they pay. Also, much of the wealth is based on stock prices, which are always changing.",
            "Possible Ongoing Decrease in State Income Tax Revenues. California billionaires, like all those earning money in the state, currently pay state taxes on their annual income. Billionaires may respond to a new wealth tax in ways that reduce their income tax payments. For example, some billionaires may decide to leave California. The income taxes they currently pay to the state also would go away. These responses probably would reduce state revenues by less than $1 billion per year. This could mean less money for the state’s General Fund, which is the account that pays for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.",
            "State Costs to Administer the Wealth Tax. The state would have costs to determine how much wealth tax is owed and to collect tax payments. These costs could be tens of millions of dollars per year for several years. These costs would be paid from the new wealth tax revenues.",
            "Proposition 40 Figure 1. Potential Interactions With Other Propositions: If Proposition 41 or 42 on this same ballot receive more yes votes than Proposition 40, then Propostion 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters. This is because the courts could find that Proposition 41 or 42 conflict with 40."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Temporary State Revenue Increase From Wealth Tax",
              "text": "The state probably would collect tens of billions of dollars from the wealth tax. This temporary increase in state tax collections would be spread across several years. Exactly when and how much the state would collect is very hard to predict for many reasons. For example, it is hard to know what actions billionaires would take to reduce the amount of tax they pay. Also, much of the wealth is based on stock prices, which are always changing.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Possible Ongoing Decrease in State Income Tax Revenues",
              "text": "California billionaires, like all those earning money in the state, currently pay state taxes on their annual income. Billionaires may respond to a new wealth tax in ways that reduce their income tax payments. For example, some billionaires may decide to leave California. The income taxes they currently pay to the state also would go away. These responses probably would reduce state revenues by less than $1 billion per year. This could mean less money for the state’s General Fund, which is the account that pays for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e"
            },
            {
              "lead": "State Costs to Administer the Wealth Tax",
              "text": "The state would have costs to determine how much wealth tax is owed and to collect tax payments. These costs could be tens of millions of dollars per year for several years. These costs would be paid from the new wealth tax revenues.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition 40 Figure 1. Potential Interactions With Other Propositions: If Proposition 41 or 42 on this same ballot receive more yes votes than Proposition 40, then Propostion 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters. This is because the courts could find that Proposition 41 or 42 conflict with 40.",
              "kind": "figure",
              "source_sha256": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "CALIFORNIA’S EDUCATION, HEALTHCARE, PUBLIC SAFETY, LABOR AND BUSINESS LEADERS ALL OPPOSE PROP. 40’s FLAWED TAX SCHEME",
            "Prop. 40 is a flawed tax scheme that will damage our state while taxpayers pay the price.",
            "Here’s why a broad coalition of California teachers, doctors, clinics, hospitals, firefighters, taxpayers, blue-collar labor unions, businesses, Democrats and Republicans oppose 40:",
            "Prop. 40 won’t fill any funding gap—IT WILL COST CALIFORNIA $25 BILLION in lost revenue for schools, healthcare and public safety.",
            "Prop. 40 won’t fix healthcare or lower costs for consumers—it’s a blank check that ALLOWS THE LEGISLATURE TO GIVE BILLIONS TO HEALTH INSURANCE COMPANIES, with no guarantees struggling families see a single cent to help them with high healthcare costs.",
            "Prop. 40 won’t help schools: it exempts itself from California’s voter-approved protections for school funding. That SHORTCHANGES PUBLIC SCHOOLS $3 BILLION ANNUALLY.",
            "Prop. 40 doesn’t solve inequality in California. It just pushes out the companies and successful residents who drive California’s economy, jobs and tax base—FORCING OTHER TAXPAYERS TO MAKE UP THE DIFFERENCE.",
            "There’s more: the French economists and the lone group behind Prop. 40 knew the money from their flawed one-time tax would run out, so they included a loophole that lets the Legislature expand the tax without a vote of the people.",
            "Prop. 40 has no accountability or oversight, and no safeguards to ensure the money is spent as intended.",
            "California needs stable, accountable revenue to fund our schools, healthcare and public safety—NOT PROP. 40.",
            "Get the facts and vote no on Prop. 40."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "April O’Connor, Teacher",
            "California Teachers Association",
            "Rob Gutierrez, President",
            "California Taxpayers Association (CalTax)",
            "Chris Hannan, President",
            "State Building and Construction Trades Council of California"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "April O’Connor",
              "title": "Teacher",
              "organization": "California Teachers Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Rob Gutierrez",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Taxpayers Association (CalTax)"
            },
            {
              "name": "Chris Hannan",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "State Building and Construction Trades Council of California"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "LET’S CHECK THE FACTS",
            "1. Prop. 40 is a BILLIONAIRE tax. It cannot be applied to anyone else—working people already pay more than their fair share.",
            "2. Prop. 40 will GENERATE $100 billion to replace the healthcare funding Trump cut to fund billionaire tax breaks.",
            "3. Billionaires pay MUCH LOWER TAX RATES compared to what working families pay out of every paycheck. DON’T LISTEN TO BILLIONAIRE LIES",
            "The billionaires who helped Trump pass the “Big, Beautiful Bill” have spent millions to trick you into voting against a billionaire tax.",
            "Don’t be fooled. The endorsements and studies from the billionaires are hiding the truth—they’re pushing a Trump agenda that protects billionaires and hurts everyday taxpayers.",
            "ACTUAL DOCTORS, NURSES, TEACHERS, AND WORKERS SUPPORT PROP. 40",
            "While some organizational leaders and lobbyists have sided with billionaires, the working people they’re supposed to represent are standing behind Prop. 40 and urging you to vote YES. Supporters include:",
            "California Nurses Association, Representative Ro Khanna, Doctors with the Committee of Interns and Residents, SEIU, California League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC), Clergy and Laity United for Economic Justice (CLUE)",
            "OPPONENTS OF PROP. 40 HAVE NO PLAN TO SAVE YOUR HEALTHCARE",
            "The billionaires and their puppets have not put forth ANY viable solution to replacing the healthcare funding Trump took from us. They’d rather the middle class get stuck with shuttered hospitals and skyrocketing healthcare costs than pay their fair share.",
            "Vote YES on Prop. 40."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Suzanne Jimenez, Chief of Staff",
            "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West",
            "Victoria Barron, Patient Access Specialist",
            "Planned Parenthood of Pacific Southwest",
            "Denise Robb, Ph.D., Member of American Federation of Teachers",
            "Local 1521 Los Angeles College Faculty Guild"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Suzanne Jimenez",
              "title": "Chief of Staff",
              "organization": "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
            },
            {
              "name": "Victoria Barron",
              "title": "Patient Access Specialist",
              "organization": "Planned Parenthood of Pacific Southwest"
            },
            {
              "name": "Denise Robb",
              "title": "Ph.D., Member of American Federation of Teachers",
              "organization": "Local 1521 Los Angeles College Faculty Guild"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "YES ON PROP. 40 TO TAX BILLIONAIRES",
            "Trump’s “Big, Ugly Bill” slashed funding for healthcare in California to pay for more billionaire tax breaks, eliminating coverage for over a million Californians and doubling health insurance premiums for millions more. Vote YES on Prop. 40 to make billionaires finally pay their fair share in taxes and stop sticking the middle class with the bill.",
            "FUND HEALTHCARE, NOT BILLIONAIRE TAX BREAKS",
            "Prop. 40 makes approximately 200 California billionaires pay a modest, one-time tax on their global wealth to keep local hospitals and ERs open and healthcare affordable for millions of Californians.",
            "It will raise about $100 billion to replace the funding Trump and his billionaire donors took from working people to line their pockets. The funds will go to life-saving medical care for seniors, veterans, and families. It will allow millions of Californians to keep their health insurance and not see their premiums skyrocket. It will prevent mass teacher layoffs in our public schools and keep children fed through food assistance programs.",
            "BILLIONAIRES SHOULD PAY THEIR FAIR SHARE",
            "You pay your taxes out of every paycheck, but billionaires pay much lower rates than working families. They insist on paying less, even as they get bigger and bigger tax breaks.",
            "Prop. 40 enacts a one-time tax paid ONLY by Californians worth more than $1 billion, a small group of people who together hold $2 trillion in wealth—most of which will never be taxed due to loopholes that favor the ultra-wealthy.",
            "Billionaires amassed their extreme wealth on the backs of the middle class, and we have a chance to make them pay their fair share so WE aren’t stuck paying more for healthcare.",
            "BERNIE SANDERS SUPPORTS PROP. 40",
            "U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders strongly supports voting YES on Prop. 40, even if some politicians in Sacramento are protecting billionaires over working people.",
            "“The idea that [billionaires] are saying it’s ok for children to die, for people not to get the healthcare they need, that they’re going to punish the people of California—it’s outrageous.”",
            "—U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders.",
            "DON’T BELIEVE THE BILLIONAIRES’ LIES",
            "A small group of morally bankrupt billionaires is spreading lies about Prop. 40, because they want working people to foot the bill for their tax breaks.",
            "Google founder and Trump donor Sergey Brin’s wealth has DOUBLED to nearly $300 billion since Trump’s election. Now he’s spent over $57 million to oppose Prop. 40. He’d rather millions of Californians lose healthcare than pay his fair share in taxes.",
            "Billionaires like Brin have bought and paid for some corrupt politicians and organizational leaders to also oppose Prop. 40—but actual teachers, Planned Parenthood workers, nurses, and union members support it. Those opposing Prop. 40 have not put forth any viable solution to replacing the funding Trump took from us.",
            "Of course these billionaires and their puppets don’t want a billionaire tax, but you should—because someone has to pay, and working people are already paying enough for healthcare.",
            "SAVE LIVES. TAX BILLIONAIRES."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Suzanne Jimenez, Chief of Staff",
            "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West",
            "Victoria Barron, Patient Access Specialist",
            "Planned Parenthood of Pacific Southwest",
            "Denise Robb, Ph.D., Member of American Federation of Teachers",
            "Local 1521 Los Angeles College Faculty Guild"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Suzanne Jimenez",
              "title": "Chief of Staff",
              "organization": "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
            },
            {
              "name": "Victoria Barron",
              "title": "Patient Access Specialist",
              "organization": "Planned Parenthood of Pacific Southwest"
            },
            {
              "name": "Denise Robb",
              "title": "Ph.D., Member of American Federation of Teachers",
              "organization": "Local 1521 Los Angeles College Faculty Guild"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "No on 40—FLAWED WEALTH TAX “EXPERIMENT” HURTS ALL CALIFORNIANS",
            "Prop. 40 is a poorly designed tax scheme that will damage our economy and cost our state budget billions of dollars—without doing anything to lower healthcare costs for Californians.",
            "This measure is a one-time tax that only provides temporary funds. When the money runs out, the politicians will be back with yet another tax.",
            "PROP. 40 WILL COST CALIFORNIA $25 BILLION IN LOST REVENUE FOR HEALTHCARE, EDUCATION",
            "A study by Stanford University economists found the tax will cost California $25 billion as the tax drives companies and wealthy residents out-of-state.",
            "These residents create new businesses, drive our economic growth and already pay nearly half the income taxes that fund state programs. If they leave, it will create a huge hole in our budget, threatening core services like education, healthcare and public safety or forcing other taxpayers to make up the difference.",
            "California’s DOCTORS, HOSPITALS AND CLINICS OPPOSE PROP. 40 because the lost funding will endanger patients’ access to healthcare. “Prop. 40 doesn’t help the need for stable healthcare funding.",
            "Prop. 40 makes it worse.”—Jodi Hicks, President and CEO, Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California",
            "PROP. 40 IS WRITTEN TO GIVE POLITICIANS NEW POWER TO EXPAND THE TAX",
            "Prop. 40 isn’t just a “billionaire tax.” The special interests behind the measure wrote it to give the State Legislature power to amend the measure—without voter approval.",
            "Independent legal analysis found Prop. 40 opens the door to expanding the tax to the assets of ALL Californians—to your savings, home equity and even retirement funds. www.ReadltForYourself.org",
            "PROP. 40 TAXES RETIREMENT ACCOUNTS FOR THE FIRST TIME",
            "Prop. 40 would be the first in California history to tax retirement accounts—a dangerous precedent. If it passes, it will inevitably be expanded to tax more Californians’ retirement savings.",
            "PROP. 40 IS A RECIPE FOR MORE WASTEFUL SPENDING",
            "State government spending is up 79% since 2019, without delivering better results on key issues like crime, housing and homelessness. But Prop. 40 includes no accountability, transparency or oversight provisions to ensure funds are spent as intended.",
            "Instead, Prop. 40: • Exempts itself from voter-approved constitutional protections for schools, shortchanging classrooms over $3 billion annually. www.ProtectCaliforniaSchools.org • Exempts itself from the voter-approved state spending limit, including its requirement that excess revenues get returned to taxpayers. • Includes no safeguards to prevent billions from going directly to health insurance companies and CEOs.",
            "AUTHORS ADMIT THE ONE-TIME TAX IS AN EXPERIMENT",
            "The French economists who co-authored Prop. 40 have unsuccessfully proposed wealth taxes in France and the European Union that were rejected due to economic concerns. They call Prop. 40 “an experiment” that may backfire but say “California is the ideal place to test their idea.”",
            "We shouldn’t risk California’s future on a costly economic experiment. www.WhoWroteProp40.org",
            "PROP. 40 IS OPPOSED BY LABOR AND BUSINESS, DEMOCRATS AND REPUBLICANS, TEACHERS AND FIREFIGHTERS",
            "Prop. 40 is opposed by Governor Gavin Newsom, the Democratic and Republican candidates for governor, and the following organizations: California Teachers Association, Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California, California Children’s Hospital Association, State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, California Conference of Carpenters, California Professional Firefighters, California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce, California Council for Affordable Housing, California Taxpayers Association, California Chamber of Commerce, California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce",
            "Join us and vote no on this flawed tax scheme.",
            "Visit www.VoteNoOn40.org for more information."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "René Bravo, M.D., President",
            "California Medical Association",
            "Francisco Silva, CEO",
            "California Primary Care Association",
            "Dr. Debra Schade, President",
            "California School Boards Association"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "René Bravo",
              "title": "M.D., President",
              "organization": "California Medical Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Francisco Silva",
              "title": "CEO",
              "organization": "California Primary Care Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Dr. Debra Schade",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California School Boards Association"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/40/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/40/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop40-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/40/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop40-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "YES ON PROP. 40 TO TAX BILLIONAIRES",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 taxes billionaires.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 40, billionaires who were residents of California on January 1, 2026 would have to pay a one-time state tax equal to 5 percent of their net worth.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Trump’s “Big, Ugly Bill” slashed funding for healthcare in California",
          "claim": "Trump's bill reduced health care funding in California.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "eliminating coverage for over a million Californians",
          "claim": "The funding reduction eliminated health coverage for more than one million Californians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "doubling health insurance premiums for millions more",
          "claim": "The funding reduction doubled health insurance premiums for millions of Californians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 makes approximately 200 California billionaires pay a modest, one-time tax on their global wealth",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 imposes a one-time tax on approximately 200 California billionaires' global wealth.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 40, billionaires who were residents of California on January 1, 2026 would have to pay a one-time state tax equal to 5 percent of their net worth. The tax would be due in 2027. Taxpayers would have the option to spread the payments over five years but would have to pay more to do so. Real estate, pensions, and retirement accounts generally would be excluded from the tax.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "to keep local hospitals and ERs open and healthcare affordable for millions of Californians",
          "claim": "The measure will keep local hospitals and emergency rooms open and make health care affordable for millions of Californians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "It will raise about $100 billion",
          "claim": "The measure will raise about $100 billion.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The state probably would collect tens of billions of dollars from the wealth tax. This temporary increase in state tax collections would be spread across several years. Exactly when and how much the state would collect is very hard to predict for many reasons.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "The funds will go to life-saving medical care for seniors, veterans, and families.",
          "claim": "The measure's funds will go to medical care for seniors, veterans, and families.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The state would decide how and when to spend the money from the wealth tax, but it would have to be spent on certain types of services. Ninety percent of the money would have to be spent on health care services for the public.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "It will allow millions of Californians to keep their health insurance and not see their premiums skyrocket.",
          "claim": "The measure will let millions of Californians retain health insurance and avoid sharply rising premiums.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "It will prevent mass teacher layoffs in our public schools",
          "claim": "The measure will prevent mass teacher layoffs in public schools.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "keep children fed through food assistance programs",
          "claim": "The measure will preserve food assistance programs for children.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "billionaires pay much lower rates than working families",
          "claim": "Billionaires pay lower tax rates than working families.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 enacts a one-time tax paid ONLY by Californians worth more than $1 billion",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 imposes a one-time tax only on Californians worth more than $1 billion.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 40, billionaires who were residents of California on January 1, 2026 would have to pay a one-time state tax equal to 5 percent of their net worth.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "a small group of people who together hold $2 trillion in wealth",
          "claim": "The affected people collectively hold $2 trillion in wealth.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "most of which will never be taxed due to loopholes that favor the ultra-wealthy",
          "claim": "Most of billionaires' wealth will never be taxed because of loopholes favoring ultra-wealthy people.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "A small group of morally bankrupt billionaires is spreading lies about Prop. 40, because they want working people to foot the bill for their tax breaks.",
          "claim": "A group of billionaires opposes Proposition 40 because it wants working people to pay for the billionaires' tax breaks.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Google founder and Trump donor Sergey Brin’s wealth has DOUBLED to nearly $300 billion since Trump’s election.",
          "claim": "Sergey Brin's wealth has doubled to nearly $300 billion since Trump's election.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Now he’s spent over $57 million to oppose Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Sergey Brin has spent more than $57 million to oppose Proposition 40.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "He’d rather millions of Californians lose healthcare than pay his fair share in taxes.",
          "claim": "Sergey Brin prefers Californians losing health care to paying his share of taxes.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Billionaires like Brin have bought and paid for some corrupt politicians and organizational leaders to also oppose Prop. 40",
          "claim": "Billionaires such as Sergey Brin paid politicians and organizational leaders to oppose Proposition 40.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_for:21",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Those opposing Prop. 40 have not put forth any viable solution to replacing the funding Trump took from us.",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 opponents have not offered a viable solution to replace the identified funding reduction.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 is a BILLIONAIRE tax.",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 is a tax on billionaires.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 40, billionaires who were residents of California on January 1, 2026 would have to pay a one-time state tax equal to 5 percent of their net worth.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "It cannot be applied to anyone else",
          "claim": "The tax cannot be applied to anyone other than billionaires.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 40, billionaires who were residents of California on January 1, 2026 would have to pay a one-time state tax equal to 5 percent of their net worth.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 will GENERATE $100 billion",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 will generate $100 billion.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The state probably would collect tens of billions of dollars from the wealth tax. This temporary increase in state tax collections would be spread across several years. Exactly when and how much the state would collect is very hard to predict for many reasons.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Billionaires pay MUCH LOWER TAX RATES compared to what working families pay out of every paycheck.",
          "claim": "Billionaires pay much lower tax rates than working families pay from paychecks.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The billionaires who helped Trump pass the “Big, Beautiful Bill” have spent millions to trick you into voting against a billionaire tax.",
          "claim": "Billionaires who helped Trump pass the bill spent millions to persuade voters to oppose a billionaire tax.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The billionaires who helped Trump pass the “Big, Beautiful Bill” have spent millions to trick you into voting against a billionaire tax.",
          "claim": "The billionaires' campaign spending aims to trick voters into opposing a billionaire tax.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "they’re pushing a Trump agenda that protects billionaires and hurts everyday taxpayers.",
          "claim": "The endorsements and studies are intended to advance an agenda that protects billionaires and harms everyday taxpayers.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The billionaires and their puppets have not put forth ANY viable solution to replacing the healthcare funding Trump took from us.",
          "claim": "The opponents have not offered a viable solution to replace the identified health care funding reduction.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 is a poorly designed tax scheme that will damage our economy and cost our state budget billions of dollars",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 will damage California's economy and cost the state budget billions of dollars.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "These responses probably would reduce state revenues by less than $1 billion per year. This could mean less money for the state’s General Fund, which is the account that pays for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "without doing anything to lower healthcare costs for Californians.",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 will not lower health care costs for Californians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This measure is a one-time tax that only provides temporary funds.",
          "claim": "The measure is a one-time tax that provides temporary funding.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 40, billionaires who were residents of California on January 1, 2026 would have to pay a one-time state tax equal to 5 percent of their net worth.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "When the money runs out, the politicians will be back with yet another tax.",
          "claim": "Politicians will seek another tax after the measure's money runs out.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 40 WILL COST CALIFORNIA $25 BILLION IN LOST REVENUE FOR HEALTHCARE, EDUCATION",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 will cost California $25 billion in lost revenue for health care and education.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "These responses probably would reduce state revenues by less than $1 billion per year. This could mean less money for the state’s General Fund, which is the account that pays for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "A study by Stanford University economists found the tax will cost California $25 billion",
          "claim": "A Stanford economist study found that the tax will cost California $25 billion.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "These responses probably would reduce state revenues by less than $1 billion per year.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "as the tax drives companies and wealthy residents out-of-state.",
          "claim": "The tax will drive companies and wealthy residents out of California.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Billionaires may respond to a new wealth tax in ways that reduce their income tax payments. For example, some billionaires may decide to leave California.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "already pay nearly half the income taxes that fund state programs.",
          "claim": "These residents already pay nearly half of the income taxes that fund state programs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "If they leave, it will create a huge hole in our budget",
          "claim": "If these residents leave California, it will create a huge budget shortfall.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "These responses probably would reduce state revenues by less than $1 billion per year.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "the lost funding will endanger patients’ access to healthcare.",
          "claim": "Lost funding from the measure will endanger patients' access to health care.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 40 IS WRITTEN TO GIVE POLITICIANS NEW POWER TO EXPAND THE TAX",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 was written to give politicians new power to expand the tax.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "give the State Legislature power to amend the measure—without voter approval.",
          "claim": "The measure gives the Legislature authority to amend it without voter approval.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 opens the door to expanding the tax to the assets of ALL Californians",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 permits expansion of the tax to all Californians' assets.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 40 TAXES RETIREMENT ACCOUNTS FOR THE FIRST TIME",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 taxes retirement accounts.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Real estate, pensions, and retirement accounts generally would be excluded from the tax.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": "condition_dropped",
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "If it passes, it will inevitably be expanded to tax more Californians’ retirement savings.",
          "claim": "If approved, the measure will inevitably expand to tax more Californians' retirement savings.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "State government spending is up 79% since 2019",
          "claim": "California state government spending has increased 79 percent since 2019.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 includes no accountability, transparency or oversight provisions to ensure funds are spent as intended.",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 includes no accountability, transparency, or oversight provisions governing whether funds are spent as intended.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Exempts itself from voter-approved constitutional protections for schools",
          "claim": "The measure exempts its money from voter-approved constitutional school protections.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Existing rules in the State Constitution that limit spending and require the state to spend a certain amount on schools and community colleges would not apply to this money.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "shortchanging classrooms over $3 billion annually.",
          "claim": "The exemption will reduce classroom funding by more than $3 billion annually.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Exempts itself from the voter-approved state spending limit, including its requirement that excess revenues get returned to taxpayers.",
          "claim": "The measure exempts its money from the state spending limit and its excess-revenue return requirement.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Existing rules in the State Constitution that limit spending and require the state to spend a certain amount on schools and community colleges would not apply to this money.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:21",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Includes no safeguards to prevent billions from going directly to health insurance companies and CEOs.",
          "claim": "The measure lacks safeguards preventing billions from going directly to health insurance companies and chief executives.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:22",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "The French economists who co-authored Prop. 40 have unsuccessfully proposed wealth taxes in France and the European Union",
          "claim": "The French economists who co-authored Proposition 40 unsuccessfully proposed wealth taxes in France and the European Union.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:argument_against:23",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "They call Prop. 40 “an experiment” that may backfire",
          "claim": "The measure's co-authors call Proposition 40 an experiment that may backfire.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 won’t fill any funding gap—IT WILL COST CALIFORNIA $25 BILLION in lost revenue for schools, healthcare and public safety.",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 will cost California $25 billion in lost revenue for schools, health care, and public safety.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "These responses probably would reduce state revenues by less than $1 billion per year. This could mean less money for the state’s General Fund, which is the account that pays for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 won’t fix healthcare or lower costs for consumers",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 will not improve health care or lower consumer costs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "it’s a blank check that ALLOWS THE LEGISLATURE TO GIVE BILLIONS TO HEALTH INSURANCE COMPANIES",
          "claim": "The measure allows the Legislature to give billions to health insurance companies.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The state would decide how and when to spend the money from the wealth tax, but it would have to be spent on certain types of services. Ninety percent of the money would have to be spent on health care services for the public.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 won’t help schools: it exempts itself from California’s voter-approved protections for school funding.",
          "claim": "The measure exempts its money from California's voter-approved school-funding protections.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Existing rules in the State Constitution that limit spending and require the state to spend a certain amount on schools and community colleges would not apply to this money.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "That SHORTCHANGES PUBLIC SCHOOLS $3 BILLION ANNUALLY.",
          "claim": "The exemption reduces public school funding by $3 billion annually.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It just pushes out the companies and successful residents who drive California’s economy, jobs and tax base",
          "claim": "The measure will push companies and successful residents out of California.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Billionaires may respond to a new wealth tax in ways that reduce their income tax payments. For example, some billionaires may decide to leave California.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "FORCING OTHER TAXPAYERS TO MAKE UP THE DIFFERENCE.",
          "claim": "The measure will force other taxpayers to make up lost tax revenue.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "the French economists and the lone group behind Prop. 40 knew the money from their flawed one-time tax would run out",
          "claim": "The measure's proponents knew its one-time tax revenue would run out.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "they included a loophole that lets the Legislature expand the tax without a vote of the people.",
          "claim": "The measure includes a provision allowing the Legislature to expand the tax without a public vote.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-40:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 40 has no accountability or oversight, and no safeguards to ensure the money is spent as intended.",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 has no accountability, oversight, or safeguards to ensure spending follows its intended purpose.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-40:analysis": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
            "vig:prop-40:arguments": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-40:overview",
        "vig:prop-40:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-40:analysis",
        "vig:prop-40:arguments",
        "vig:prop-40:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-40:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-41",
      "contest_id": "prop-41",
      "number": "41",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "PROHIBITS NEW STATE TAXES THAT EXCLUDE REVENUES FROM STATE SPENDING LIMIT. REQUIRES AUDITS FOR NEW STATE SPECIAL TAXES. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.",
      "measure_type": "initiative_constitutional_amendment",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures",
      "summary": "Nullifies state taxes enacted after January 1, 2026 that exempt their revenues from voter-approved state spending limit. Requires pre-election and recurring audits of programs funded by new special taxes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "The net fiscal effect is unknown as it depends on future decisions by voters, the Legislature, and other policymakers.",
      "supporters": "CA Society of Certified Public Accountants (CalCPAs); CalAsian Chamber of Commerce; California Taxpayers Association (CalTax)",
      "opponents": "US Senator Bernie Sanders; SEIU United Healthcare Workers West",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: When special taxes are proposed by voter initiatives, the California State Auditor would review programs funded by the tax before the initiative appears on the ballot. The California State Auditor also would regularly review programs funded by special taxes approved by voters or the Legislature. In addition, the state might not be able to exclude any new special tax spending from its spending limit.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: The California State Auditor’s responsibility to review government programs would not change. The state spending limit requirements would not change.",
      "pro_short": "Californians deserve better results for our taxes. Billions have flowed into programs like homelessness, with too little to show for it. Prop. 41 requires the independent State Auditor to conduct PUBLIC AUDITS of programs funded by new taxes—so we get more transparency, more accountability and better outcomes for taxpayers.",
      "con_short": "Prop. 41 isn’t really about audits—it’s a billionaire-funded trick designed to undo the California Billionaire Tax. Billionaires would rather millions of Californians lose healthcare than pay a modest tax on their extreme wealth. Don’t fall for the billionaires’ lies. Vote NO on 41.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "Yes on 41—Californians for",
          "Transparency and",
          "Accountability, A Coalition of",
          "Small Businesses, Taxpayers,",
          "Good Government Advocates,",
          "Accountants, and Auditing",
          "Experts",
          "info@YesonProp41.org",
          "YesonProp41.org"
        ],
        "against": [
          "Suzanne Jimenez",
          "SEIU-UHW",
          "5480 Ferguson Drive",
          "Los Angeles, CA 90022",
          "(855) 507-7562",
          "info@YesOn40.com",
          "www.yeson40.com"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "info@YesonProp41.org",
          "url": "mailto:info@YesonProp41.org"
        },
        {
          "label": "YesonProp41.org",
          "url": "https://www.yesonprop41.org/"
        },
        {
          "label": "info@YesOn40.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@YesOn40.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "www.yeson40.com",
          "url": "https://yeson40.com/"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Prohibits any new state taxes that exclude their revenues from the state spending limit approved by voters in 1979.",
        "For statewide special taxes, requires (1) a pre-election audit of programs that would receive funding from a voter-proposed special tax, and (2) recurring audits of programs funded by special taxes enacted after January 1, 2026.",
        "States that other voter-approved measures appearing on the same ballot are void if they conflict with this measure and this measure receives more affirmative votes.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Unknown net fiscal effect. Increased costs for the California State Auditor to implement new one-time and ongoing audit requirements of programs funded by special taxes. These costs would be mostly paid from the new revenues collected from the special taxes. Possible savings associated with implementing recommendations from the audits.",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Elections Administration. The Secretary of State oversees elections across the state and prepares and mails the state Voter Information Guide (VIG).",
            "Voter Initiative Process. California citizens may propose state laws and constitutional amendments through the statewide initiative process. Supporters of an initiative collect signatures from registered voters to qualify their initiative for the ballot. State law sets how many valid signatures supporters must collect to qualify their initiative for the ballot. Supporters notify the Secretary of State once they have gathered 25 percent of the necessary signatures.",
            "Special Taxes. State taxes can be raised by the Legislature or by voters. When a “special tax” is created, the revenue from that tax is dedicated to a specific purpose or program. For example, certain fuel taxes can only be used to pay for public roads and other transportation programs.",
            "California State Auditor’s Office (State Auditor). The State Auditor is an independent and nonpartisan office in state government. It reviews how well the state and local governments follow the law, use money, and run their programs. These reviews are called audits. An audit may give recommendations to help improve government operations and efficiency. Some audits happen regularly over time while other audits are done only once."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Elections Administration",
              "text": "The Secretary of State oversees elections across the state and prepares and mails the state Voter Information Guide (VIG).",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Voter Initiative Process",
              "text": "California citizens may propose state laws and constitutional amendments through the statewide initiative process. Supporters of an initiative collect signatures from registered voters to qualify their initiative for the ballot. State law sets how many valid signatures supporters must collect to qualify their initiative for the ballot. Supporters notify the Secretary of State once they have gathered 25 percent of the necessary signatures.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Special Taxes",
              "text": "State taxes can be raised by the Legislature or by voters. When a “special tax” is created, the revenue from that tax is dedicated to a specific purpose or program. For example, certain fuel taxes can only be used to pay for public roads and other transportation programs.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            },
            {
              "lead": "California State Auditor’s Office (State Auditor)",
              "text": "The State Auditor is an independent and nonpartisan office in state government. It reviews how well the state and local governments follow the law, use money, and run their programs. These reviews are called audits. An audit may give recommendations to help improve government operations and efficiency. Some audits happen regularly over time while other audits are done only once.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Requires One-Time Audits Before Special Taxes Appear on the Ballot Through the Voter Initiative Process. Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to review each program that would receive funds from a new or increased special tax proposed through the voter initiative process. This audit would occur after supporters collect 25 percent of the signatures needed to qualify a measure for the ballot, which is before it is known whether the initiative will qualify for the ballot. Proposition 41 specifies what the State Auditor would include in these audits, including identifying ways to reduce an audited program’s annual costs by 10 percent. Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to write a summary of each audit. If a proposed voter initiative with a special tax qualifies for the ballot, Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor’s summary to be included in the VIG. If voters approve the special tax, the cost of the one-time audit would be paid from the new tax revenues.",
            "Ongoing Audits of Programs Receiving Funds From New or Increased Special Taxes. Proposition 41 also requires the State Auditor to periodically review programs that receive funding from special taxes created or increased by the Legislature or by voters after January 1, 2026. These ongoing audits would happen every four years. Proposition 41 specifies what the State Auditor will include in these audits, including recommendations to improve program efficiency. Proposition 41 specifies that the costs of this ongoing work will be paid using the new tax revenue.",
            "State Appropriations Limit. The State Constitution limits how much tax revenues the state can spend each year. The limit applies to both General Fund taxes and special taxes. However, certain types of spending, for example for infrastructure, are excluded from this limit. Under Proposition 41, the state might not be able to exclude new special tax spending from the limit."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Requires One-Time Audits Before Special Taxes Appear on the Ballot Through the Voter Initiative Process",
              "text": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to review each program that would receive funds from a new or increased special tax proposed through the voter initiative process. This audit would occur after supporters collect 25 percent of the signatures needed to qualify a measure for the ballot, which is before it is known whether the initiative will qualify for the ballot. Proposition 41 specifies what the State Auditor would include in these audits, including identifying ways to reduce an audited program’s annual costs by 10 percent. Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to write a summary of each audit. If a proposed voter initiative with a special tax qualifies for the ballot, Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor’s summary to be included in the VIG. If voters approve the special tax, the cost of the one-time audit would be paid from the new tax revenues.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Ongoing Audits of Programs Receiving Funds From New or Increased Special Taxes",
              "text": "Proposition 41 also requires the State Auditor to periodically review programs that receive funding from special taxes created or increased by the Legislature or by voters after January 1, 2026. These ongoing audits would happen every four years. Proposition 41 specifies what the State Auditor will include in these audits, including recommendations to improve program efficiency. Proposition 41 specifies that the costs of this ongoing work will be paid using the new tax revenue.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            },
            {
              "lead": "State Appropriations Limit",
              "text": "The State Constitution limits how much tax revenues the state can spend each year. The limit applies to both General Fund taxes and special taxes. However, certain types of spending, for example for infrastructure, are excluded from this limit. Under Proposition 41, the state might not be able to exclude new special tax spending from the limit.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Increased State Auditor Costs, Mostly Paid by New Revenues. Proposition 41 would increase State Auditor costs by creating new and ongoing audit requirements. The costs would depend on (1) the number of new or increased special taxes that are proposed and approved and (2) the complexity of the programs being audited. These costs likely would be in the range of the low millions of dollars per year but would grow over time. The one-time and ongoing audit costs associated with special taxes approved by voters or the Legislature would be paid from the revenues collected by the special taxes. One-time audit costs associated with special taxes that do not ultimately appear on the ballot or are rejected by voters would be paid from the state’s General Fund. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.)",
            "Higher Costs to Print and Mail VIG. Proposition 41 would require a summary of the State Auditor’s review to appear in the VIG when a voter initiative with a special tax appears on the ballot. These audit summaries could add several pages to the VIG, which would increase state printing and mailing costs by a few hundred thousand dollars per qualified initiative.",
            "Possible Savings if State Auditor Recommendations Are Implemented. Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to make recommendations for programs to reduce costs or improve efficiency. Proposition 41 could result in savings or improved services if policymakers implement the State Auditor’s recommendations and those recommendations prove effective. Any resulting savings would depend on future decisions and are not known.",
            "Net Effect Not Known. The net fiscal effect of Proposition 41 is unknown as it depends on future decisions by voters, the Legislature, and other policymakers.",
            "Proposition 41 Figure 1. If Proposition 41 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters. This is because the courts could find that Proposition 41 conflicts with Proposition 40."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Increased State Auditor Costs, Mostly Paid by New Revenues",
              "text": "Proposition 41 would increase State Auditor costs by creating new and ongoing audit requirements. The costs would depend on (1) the number of new or increased special taxes that are proposed and approved and (2) the complexity of the programs being audited. These costs likely would be in the range of the low millions of dollars per year but would grow over time. The one-time and ongoing audit costs associated with special taxes approved by voters or the Legislature would be paid from the revenues collected by the special taxes. One-time audit costs associated with special taxes that do not ultimately appear on the ballot or are rejected by voters would be paid from the state’s General Fund. (The General Fund is the account the state uses to pay for most public services, including education, health care, and prisons.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Higher Costs to Print and Mail VIG",
              "text": "Proposition 41 would require a summary of the State Auditor’s review to appear in the VIG when a voter initiative with a special tax appears on the ballot. These audit summaries could add several pages to the VIG, which would increase state printing and mailing costs by a few hundred thousand dollars per qualified initiative.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Possible Savings if State Auditor Recommendations Are Implemented",
              "text": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to make recommendations for programs to reduce costs or improve efficiency. Proposition 41 could result in savings or improved services if policymakers implement the State Auditor’s recommendations and those recommendations prove effective. Any resulting savings would depend on future decisions and are not known.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Net Effect Not Known",
              "text": "The net fiscal effect of Proposition 41 is unknown as it depends on future decisions by voters, the Legislature, and other policymakers.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition 41 Figure 1. If Proposition 41 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters. This is because the courts could find that Proposition 41 conflicts with Proposition 40.",
              "kind": "figure",
              "source_sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "THIS IS A BILLIONAIRE-FUNDED SMOKE SCREEN",
            "Don’t be fooled—Prop. 41 is not really about audits. This is all a trick so approximately 200 billionaires can keep avoiding paying their own taxes while YOU get stuck with the bill.",
            "PROP. 41 WOULD CANCEL OUT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
            "Prop. 41 is a billionaire-funded scheme designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
            "Prop. 41 was put on the ballot because billionaires don’t want to pay their fair share. They’d rather millions of working people lose healthcare than pay a modest, one-time tax on their extreme wealth.",
            "To add insult to injury, Prop. 41 isn’t just a scheme, it’s an expensive one—it would cost the state time and money. SOME OF DONALD TRUMP’S DONORS FUNDED THIS",
            "The billionaires behind this don’t care about accountability for taxpayers. They’ve been getting out of paying their own taxes for years through loopholes and tax breaks.",
            "This sham initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
            "IF YOU CARE ABOUT FUNDING FOR HEALTHCARE, PUBLIC EDUCATION, AND FOOD ASSISTANCE, VOTE NO ON PROP. 41",
            "Donald Trump slashed funding for our essential services so billionaires could hoard even more wealth.",
            "Passing the California Billionaire Tax is the only way to replace the money Trump took from us, so we’re not stuck with shuttered hospitals and skyrocketing healthcare costs.",
            "To save lives and keep healthcare costs down for Californians, reject the billionaires’ lies.",
            "Vote NO on Prop. 41."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Suzanne Jimenez, Chief of Staff",
            "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Suzanne Jimenez",
              "title": "Chief of Staff",
              "organization": "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "When state government programs don’t deliver, it hurts the people who rely on those services and the taxpayers who fund them.",
            "Prop. 41 requires the independent State Auditor to conduct performance and financial audits of the programs to be funded by new taxes—to help make programs more effective and efficient.",
            "Ask yourself: why would a single, solitary Sacramento special interest oppose transparency and accountability?",
            "YES ON 41: TAXPAYERS DESERVE BETTER RESULTS",
            "Some facts:",
            "• Our state budget is a record high $352 billion this year. • State spending is up 79% since 2019. • We’ve spent billions on programs like homelessness—with too little to show for it.",
            "With some of the highest taxes in the nation and a rising cost of living, we can’t afford to fund failure. Every dollar wasted is one that could go to help someone.",
            "Prop. 41 requires transparency and trackable progress of programs, to help improve education, health care and other public services Californians rely on.",
            "PROP. 41: PUBLIC AUDITS TO IMPROVE ACCOUNTABILITY",
            "“Independent performance audits give voters objective, credible information about public resources, strengthening accountability and public trust.” Denise LeDuc Froemming, President, California Society of Certified Public Accountants",
            "Under Prop. 41, the independent State Auditor publicly reviews the programs that new taxes would fund, exposes any waste or mismanagement, and recommends program improvements. The audit findings are published in the Voter Information Guide before you vote—with ongoing audits if a tax is approved.",
            "VOTERS DESERVE MORE TRANSPARENCY—even if special interests don’t like it.",
            "Vote Yes on Prop. 41. More transparency, more accountability, better results for our tax dollars."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Pat Fong Kushida, President",
            "California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce (CalAsian Chamber)",
            "Steve Westly, Fmr. California State Controller",
            "Robert Gutierrez, President",
            "California Taxpayers Association (CalTax)"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Pat Fong Kushida",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce (CalAsian Chamber)"
            },
            {
              "name": "Steve Westly",
              "title": "Fmr. California State Controller",
              "organization": null
            },
            {
              "name": "Robert Gutierrez",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Taxpayers Association (CalTax)"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "CALIFORNIANS DESERVE BETTER RESULTS FOR OUR TAX DOLLARS",
            "Prop. 41 requires the State Auditor to conduct independent public audits of programs funded by proposed new taxes in order to increase transparency and accountability and drive better outcomes.",
            "Californians pay some of the highest taxes in the country—on top of our high cost of living. This year alone, California’s state government will spend more than $350 billion—a 79% increase in spending since 2019. Billions of our tax dollars have flowed into state programs like homelessness efforts, with too little to show for it.",
            "We deserve better education, health care, infrastructure and other services in return for the hard-earned money we pay to the state.",
            "Prop. 41 requires more accountability, transparency and trackable progress of programs funded by our taxes, so that we stop funding failure and start funding successful outcomes.",
            "Here’s how Prop. 41 works.",
            "PUBLIC AUDITS TO PROVIDE ACCOUNTABILITY, TRANSPARENCY AND OVERSIGHT",
            "Prop. 41 requires the independent State Auditor to conduct performance and financial audits of the programs funded by new tax measures, with the results posted publicly. The audits must:",
            "• Track all program spending and assess whether it’s achieving its intended outcomes; • Determine whether programs have sufficient oversight and accountability; • Identify areas of waste, fraud and abuse; • Recommend how future waste and fraud can be avoided and programs made more effective.",
            "Prop. 41 requires audits both before taxes are voted on to provide transparency to voters, and ongoing audits of programs funded by approved taxes to ensure accountability. PROP. 41: INDEPENDENT, PUBLIC INFORMATION FOR VOTERS ON PROPOSED TAXES",
            "Before we vote on new taxes to fund programs, voters should have access to independent information about how those programs are being managed and whether they actually need more funding. Under Prop. 41, the Auditor’s findings must be posted publicly and in the Voter Information Guide—so voters can make informed decisions about new taxes without having to rely on information from special interests or politicians.",
            "“This commonsense, long overdue reform will finally instill some transparency and accountability in state spending— ensuring Californians get better government services for the taxes we pay. It provides an independent, public report card for government spending, so government programs work better for everyone.”—Pat Fong Kushida, President/CEO of the CalAsian Chamber of Commerce",
            "PROP. 41: A BETTER DEAL FOR TAXPAYERS",
            "Prop. 41 doesn’t raise taxes—it protects taxpayers’ interests:",
            "• Reduces the waste and fraud that have cost California taxpayers billions of dollars in recent years; • Requires all taxes to comply with the state’s voter-approved spending limit—including its requirement that excess revenues get refunded to taxpayers.",
            "Prop. 41 ensures taxpayers get better results—not just a bigger tax bill.",
            "“Every tax dollar we waste is a dollar that could actually help someone. Californians already pay the highest state income and sales taxes in the country—we need better transparency and accountability to make sure our tax dollars produce results. Prop. 41 delivers.”—Steve Westly, former Controller of California.",
            "Please join good government groups, small business owners, accountants, taxpayers and public transparency advocates in voting Yes on 41.",
            "For more information, visit: www.ResultsCA.org"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Denise LeDuc Froemming, CPA, President",
            "California Society of Certified Public Accountants (CalCPAs)",
            "Tom Hayes, Fmr. California State Auditor",
            "Robert Gutierrez, President",
            "California Taxpayers Association (CalTax)"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Denise LeDuc Froemming",
              "title": "CPA, President",
              "organization": "California Society of Certified Public Accountants (CalCPAs)"
            },
            {
              "name": "Tom Hayes",
              "title": "Fmr. California State Auditor",
              "organization": null
            },
            {
              "name": "Robert Gutierrez",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Taxpayers Association (CalTax)"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE NO ON PROP. 41. This is a billionaire-funded initiative designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
            "PROP. 41 WOULD CANCEL OUT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
            "Prop. 41 was put on the ballot for one reason—because billionaires don’t want to pay their fair share. This initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce. That’s why you must vote NO.",
            "Don’t fall for the billionaires’ lies. Prop. 41 isn’t about auditing new taxes. It’s about defeating one specific tax that billionaires want to avoid, because they’d rather millions of working people lose healthcare than pay a modest, one-time tax on their extreme wealth.",
            "PROP. 41 WAS FUNDED BY BILLIONAIRES WHO WANT YOU TO PAY MORE FOR HEALTHCARE",
            "One of Prop. 41’s main funders is Google founder and Trump donor Sergey Brin, whose wealth has DOUBLED to nearly $300 billion since Trump’s election. Now he’s spent over $57 million to fund sham measures like Prop. 41 that attempt to cancel out a billionaire tax. U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders called this arrogant move by Brin “unacceptable.”",
            "Donald Trump took money out of working peoples’ pockets and gave it to billionaires like Brin through massive tax breaks. Now, the billionaires backing Prop. 41 want YOU to pay more for your healthcare.",
            "VOTE NO ON PROP. 41 IF YOU SUPPORT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
            "We have a chance to make billionaires pay their fair share to keep hospitals open and healthcare affordable for California’s working families. Vote NO on Prop. 41."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Suzanne Jimenez, Chief of Staff",
            "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Suzanne Jimenez",
              "title": "Chief of Staff",
              "organization": "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/41/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/41/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop41-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/41/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop41-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 requires the State Auditor to conduct independent public audits of programs funded by proposed new taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to audit programs funded by proposed new taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to review each program that would receive funds from a new or increased special tax proposed through the voter initiative process.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California’s state government will spend more than $350 billion",
          "claim": "California state government spending this year will exceed $350 billion.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "a 79% increase in spending since 2019",
          "claim": "California state spending has increased 79 percent since 2019.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Billions of our tax dollars have flowed into state programs like homelessness efforts",
          "claim": "Billions of tax dollars have gone to state programs such as homelessness efforts.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 requires more accountability, transparency and trackable progress of programs funded by our taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 requires accountability, transparency, and trackable progress for tax-funded programs.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 also requires the State Auditor to periodically review programs that receive funding from special taxes created or increased by the Legislature or by voters after January 1, 2026.",
          "confidence": 0.83,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 requires the independent State Auditor to conduct performance and financial audits of the programs funded by new tax measures",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to conduct performance and financial audits of programs funded by new tax measures.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to review each program that would receive funds from a new or increased special tax proposed through the voter initiative process.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "with the results posted publicly",
          "claim": "Results of the audits must be posted publicly.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "If a proposed voter initiative with a special tax qualifies for the ballot, Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor’s summary to be included in the VIG.",
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Track all program spending and assess whether it’s achieving its intended outcomes",
          "claim": "The audits must track program spending and assess whether programs achieve intended outcomes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 specifies what the State Auditor would include in these audits, including identifying ways to reduce an audited program’s annual costs by 10 percent.",
          "confidence": 0.74,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Determine whether programs have sufficient oversight and accountability",
          "claim": "The audits must determine whether programs have sufficient oversight and accountability.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.68,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Identify areas of waste, fraud and abuse",
          "claim": "The audits must identify waste, fraud, and abuse.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.72,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Recommend how future waste and fraud can be avoided and programs made more effective.",
          "claim": "The audits must recommend ways to prevent future waste and fraud and improve programs.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 specifies what the State Auditor will include in these audits, including recommendations to improve program efficiency.",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 requires audits both before taxes are voted on",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 requires audits before voters vote on taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "This audit would occur after supporters collect 25 percent of the signatures needed to qualify a measure for the ballot, which is before it is known whether the initiative will qualify for the ballot.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "ongoing audits of programs funded by approved taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 requires ongoing audits of programs funded by approved taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "These ongoing audits would happen every four years.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "the Auditor’s findings must be posted publicly and in the Voter Information Guide",
          "claim": "The Auditor's findings must be public and included in the Voter Information Guide.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to write a summary of each audit. If a proposed voter initiative with a special tax qualifies for the ballot, Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor’s summary to be included in the VIG.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 doesn’t raise taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 does not raise taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to review each program that would receive funds from a new or increased special tax proposed through the voter initiative process.",
          "confidence": 0.77,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Requires all taxes to comply with the state’s voter-approved spending limit",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 requires all taxes to comply with the state spending limit.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 41, the state might not be able to exclude new special tax spending from the limit.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "including its requirement that excess revenues get refunded to taxpayers",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 requires excess tax revenues to be refunded to taxpayers.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.79,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Californians already pay the highest state income and sales taxes in the country",
          "claim": "Californians pay the highest state income and sales taxes in the country.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 requires the independent State Auditor to conduct performance and financial audits of the programs to be funded by new taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to conduct performance and financial audits of programs to be funded by new taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor to review each program that would receive funds from a new or increased special tax proposed through the voter initiative process.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Our state budget is a record high $352 billion this year.",
          "claim": "The state budget is a record-high $352 billion this year.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "State spending is up 79% since 2019.",
          "claim": "State spending has increased 79 percent since 2019.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "We’ve spent billions on programs like homelessness",
          "claim": "Billions have been spent on programs such as homelessness.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 requires transparency and trackable progress of programs",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 requires transparency and trackable progress for programs.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 also requires the State Auditor to periodically review programs that receive funding from special taxes created or increased by the Legislature or by voters after January 1, 2026.",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "the independent State Auditor publicly reviews the programs that new taxes would fund",
          "claim": "The State Auditor publicly reviews programs that new taxes would fund.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "If a proposed voter initiative with a special tax qualifies for the ballot, Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor’s summary to be included in the VIG.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "recommends program improvements",
          "claim": "The State Auditor recommends improvements to programs.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 specifies what the State Auditor will include in these audits, including recommendations to improve program efficiency.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The audit findings are published in the Voter Information Guide before you vote",
          "claim": "Audit findings are published in the Voter Information Guide before voters vote.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "If a proposed voter initiative with a special tax qualifies for the ballot, Proposition 41 requires the State Auditor’s summary to be included in the VIG.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_against:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "with ongoing audits if a tax is approved.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 provides for ongoing audits if a tax is approved.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 also requires the State Auditor to periodically review programs that receive funding from special taxes created or increased by the Legislature or by voters after January 1, 2026.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This is a billionaire-funded initiative designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 would undo Proposition 40, the California Billionaire Tax.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "If Proposition 41 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This is a billionaire-funded initiative designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Billionaires funded the Proposition 41 campaign.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This is a billionaire-funded initiative designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 was designed to undo Proposition 40.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 41 WOULD CANCEL OUT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 would cancel the billionaire tax.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "This is because the courts could find that Proposition 41 conflicts with Proposition 40.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 was put on the ballot for one reason—because billionaires don’t want to pay their fair share.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 was put on the ballot because billionaires do not want to pay taxes described as their fair share.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "claim": "The initiative would make a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "claim": "The initiative was created to trick voters into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 isn’t about auditing new taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 was not intended to audit new taxes.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It’s about defeating one specific tax that billionaires want to avoid",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 was intended to defeat a specific tax billionaires want to avoid.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "they’d rather millions of working people lose healthcare than pay a modest, one-time tax on their extreme wealth.",
          "claim": "Supporters of Proposition 41 would prefer that millions of working people lose health care rather than billionaires pay a one-time wealth tax.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 41 WAS FUNDED BY BILLIONAIRES WHO WANT YOU TO PAY MORE FOR HEALTHCARE",
          "claim": "Billionaires funded Proposition 41.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "One of Prop. 41’s main funders is Google founder and Trump donor Sergey Brin",
          "claim": "Sergey Brin is one of Proposition 41's main funders.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "whose wealth has DOUBLED to nearly $300 billion since Trump’s election.",
          "claim": "Sergey Brin's wealth has doubled to nearly $300 billion since Trump's election.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "he’s spent over $57 million to fund sham measures like Prop. 41",
          "claim": "Sergey Brin has spent more than $57 million to fund measures including Proposition 41.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "that attempt to cancel out a billionaire tax.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 attempts to cancel a billionaire tax.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders called this arrogant move by Brin “unacceptable.”",
          "claim": "U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders called Brin's move unacceptable.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Donald Trump took money out of working peoples’ pockets and gave it to billionaires like Brin through massive tax breaks.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump gave tax breaks to billionaires such as Sergey Brin at the expense of working people.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "We have a chance to make billionaires pay their fair share to keep hospitals open and healthcare affordable for California’s working families.",
          "claim": "Making billionaires pay their fair share would keep hospitals open and health care affordable for California working families.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "THIS IS A BILLIONAIRE-FUNDED SMOKE SCREEN",
          "claim": "Billionaires funded Proposition 41.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 is not really about audits.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 was not intended to be about audits.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "This is all a trick so approximately 200 billionaires can keep avoiding paying their own taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 was intended to let approximately 200 billionaires keep avoiding their own taxes.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "approximately 200 billionaires",
          "claim": "Approximately 200 billionaires would benefit from avoiding taxes.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "while YOU get stuck with the bill.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 would shift costs to voters.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The one-time and ongoing audit costs associated with special taxes approved by voters or the Legislature would be paid from the revenues collected by the special taxes.",
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 41 WOULD CANCEL OUT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 would cancel the billionaire tax.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 is a billionaire-funded scheme designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 would undo Proposition 40.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "This is because the courts could find that Proposition 41 conflicts with Proposition 40.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 is a billionaire-funded scheme designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Billionaires funded Proposition 41.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 is a billionaire-funded scheme designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 was designed to undo Proposition 40.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 41 was put on the ballot because billionaires don’t want to pay their fair share.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 was put on the ballot because billionaires do not want to pay taxes described as their fair share.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "They’d rather millions of working people lose healthcare than pay a modest, one-time tax on their extreme wealth.",
          "claim": "Supporters of Proposition 41 would prefer that millions of working people lose health care rather than billionaires pay a one-time wealth tax.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "it would cost the state time and money.",
          "claim": "Proposition 41 would cost the state money.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 41 would increase State Auditor costs by creating new and ongoing audit requirements.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "SOME OF DONALD TRUMP’S DONORS FUNDED THIS",
          "claim": "Some of Donald Trump's donors funded Proposition 41.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "They’ve been getting out of paying their own taxes for years through loopholes and tax breaks.",
          "claim": "The billionaires behind Proposition 41 have avoided paying their own taxes through loopholes and tax breaks for years.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "This sham initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "claim": "The initiative would make a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "This sham initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "claim": "The initiative was created to trick voters into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Donald Trump slashed funding for our essential services so billionaires could hoard even more wealth.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump reduced funding for essential services in order to let billionaires accumulate more wealth.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-41:rebuttal_to_for:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Passing the California Billionaire Tax is the only way to replace the money Trump took from us",
          "claim": "Passing the California Billionaire Tax is the only way to replace money Trump took from Californians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-41:analysis": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
            "vig:prop-41:arguments": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-41:overview",
        "vig:prop-41:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-41:analysis",
        "vig:prop-41:arguments",
        "vig:prop-41:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-41:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-42",
      "contest_id": "prop-42",
      "number": "42",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "PROHIBITS NEW STATE PERSONAL PROPERTY TAXES AND CERTAIN RETROACTIVE STATE TAXES. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.",
      "measure_type": "initiative_constitutional_amendment",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures",
      "summary": "Prohibits any new state tax (1) imposed on the ownership of personal property (all things people own other than real estate), or (2) that applies retroactively based on taxpayer’s past activities. Nullifies taxes enacted after January 1, 2026 that conflict with this measure.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Possibility that tax revenues will not go up as much in the future.",
      "supporters": "CA Professional Firefighters; State Building & Construction Trades Council of CA; AMVETS Department of CA",
      "opponents": "US Senator Bernie Sanders; SEIU United Healthcare Workers West",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: The state could not establish new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: The state would continue to have the option to establish new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property.",
      "pro_short": "California’s Constitution currently allows the Legislature to tax retirement and savings—even though you already paid taxes on that money when you earned it! Prop. 42 protects Californians from this double taxation, by prohibiting new and retroactive taxes on personal property, including retirement and savings. You earned it. Prop. 42 protects it.",
      "con_short": "This is just another billionaire-funded trick. Prop. 42 isn’t really about protecting your retirement savings—its only real purpose is to undo the California Billionaire Tax. Billionaires would rather millions of Californians lose healthcare than pay a modest tax on their extreme wealth. Vote NO on 42.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "Yes on 42—Protect Retirement",
          "and Life Savings, a coalition of",
          "retirees, blue-collar workers,",
          "seniors, veterans, small",
          "business and taxpayers",
          "info@yesonprop42.org",
          "YesOnProp42.org"
        ],
        "against": [
          "Suzanne Jimenez",
          "SEIU-UHW",
          "5480 Ferguson Drive",
          "Los Angeles, CA 90022",
          "(855) 507-7562",
          "info@YesOn40.com",
          "www.yeson40.com"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "info@yesonprop42.org",
          "url": "mailto:info@yesonprop42.org"
        },
        {
          "label": "YesOnProp42.org",
          "url": "https://yesonprop42.org/"
        },
        {
          "label": "info@YesOn40.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@YesOn40.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "www.yeson40.com",
          "url": "https://yeson40.com/"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Prohibits new state taxes on personal property, including business interests, intellectual property, and financial assets (including assets in retirement and investment accounts).",
        "Prohibits new state taxes that apply retroactively based on the taxpayer’s conduct, activities, or a status that occurred before the new tax’s effective date.",
        "Applies to new taxes that are enacted or take effect on or after January 1, 2026.",
        "States that other voter-approved measures appearing on the same ballot are void if they conflict with this measure and this measure receives more affirmative votes.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Possibility that tax revenues will not go up as much in the future.",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Certain Personal Property Is Taxed in California. Both the state and local governments tax the ownership of certain personal property. These taxes are based on the property’s value. Personal property is all the things that people own other than real estate. One example of these kinds of taxes is the vehicle license fee that car and truck owners pay to the Department of Motor Vehicles each year. Another example is the property taxes owners of business equipment pay to the county each year.",
            "Ownership of Financial Assets Is Not Taxed. The ownership of many types of personal property is not taxed. One major example is financial assets like stocks and investment accounts. Although the state does tax income people make from their financial assets, there is no tax for simply owning those assets."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Certain Personal Property Is Taxed in California",
              "text": "Both the state and local governments tax the ownership of certain personal property. These taxes are based on the property’s value. Personal property is all the things that people own other than real estate. One example of these kinds of taxes is the vehicle license fee that car and truck owners pay to the Department of Motor Vehicles each year. Another example is the property taxes owners of business equipment pay to the county each year.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Ownership of Financial Assets Is Not Taxed",
              "text": "The ownership of many types of personal property is not taxed. One major example is financial assets like stocks and investment accounts. Although the state does tax income people make from their financial assets, there is no tax for simply owning those assets.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Prohibits New Taxes on Financial Assets or Other Personal Property. Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
            "Limits Retroactive Taxes. Proposition 42 limits the situations that a ballot measure or the Legislature can raise any tax retroactively. A retroactive tax is one that applies to things that happened in the past. An example is a tax on money someone earned two years ago."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Prohibits New Taxes on Financial Assets or Other Personal Property",
              "text": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Limits Retroactive Taxes",
              "text": "Proposition 42 limits the situations that a ballot measure or the Legislature can raise any tax retroactively. A retroactive tax is one that applies to things that happened in the past. An example is a tax on money someone earned two years ago.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Possibility That Tax Revenues Will Be Lower in the Future. Proposition 42 restricts the options the state has to raise taxes in the future. This could make it somewhat harder for the state to raise taxes. This could reduce future tax revenues. When and by how much future revenues would be reduced is unclear.",
            "Potential Interactions With Other Propositions. If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters. This is because the courts could find that Proposition 42 conflicts with Proposition 40."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Possibility That Tax Revenues Will Be Lower in the Future",
              "text": "Proposition 42 restricts the options the state has to raise taxes in the future. This could make it somewhat harder for the state to raise taxes. This could reduce future tax revenues. When and by how much future revenues would be reduced is unclear.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Potential Interactions With Other Propositions. If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters. This is because the courts could find that Proposition 42 conflicts with Proposition 40.",
              "kind": "figure",
              "source_sha256": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "THIS IS ANOTHER BILLIONAIRE-FUNDED TRICK",
            "Don’t be fooled—Prop. 42 is not really about protecting your retirement savings from new taxes.",
            "It’s a redundant, expensive trick to allow approximately 200 billionaires to keep avoiding paying their own taxes while YOU get stuck with the bill.",
            "PROP. 42 WOULD CANCEL OUT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
            "Prop. 42 is a billionaire-funded scheme designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
            "Prop. 42 was put on the ballot because billionaires don’t want to pay their fair share. They’d rather millions of working people lose healthcare than pay a modest, one-time tax on their extreme wealth.",
            "WHO’S BEHIND THIS? SOME OF DONALD TRUMP’S DONORS",
            "The billionaires behind this don’t care about protecting your retirement savings. They’re protecting themselves. They’ve been getting out of paying their own taxes for years through loopholes and tax breaks.",
            "This sham initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce. That’s why you must vote NO.",
            "PROP. 40 WOULD ONLY TAX BILLIONAIRES’ $2 TRILLION IN WEALTH",
            "The billionaires behind Prop. 42 have spread lies about the California Billionaire Tax (Prop. 40), trying to trick voters into thinking that their retirement and savings are at risk.",
            "Don’t buy the fear-mongering. The California Billionaires Tax ONLY applies to billionaires. It’s about making billionaires finally pay their fair share so we’re not stuck with shuttered hospitals and skyrocketing healthcare costs.",
            "Vote NO on Prop. 42."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Suzanne Jimenez, Chief of Staff",
            "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Suzanne Jimenez",
              "title": "Chief of Staff",
              "organization": "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "WHO SUPPORTS PROP. 42",
            "Prop. 42 is supported by hundreds of thousands of seniors, veterans, firefighters, blue-collar workers, public-safety officers and working families because it protects the retirement and savings of ALL Californians from new taxes. Who opposes 42? One organization that wants to tax retirement accounts.",
            "WHY WE NEED PROP. 42",
            "Sacramento politicians and special interests have repeatedly tried to pass taxes on retirement and personal savings accounts in recent years. They’ve relied on a loophole in California’s Constitution that allows government to tax our income when we earn it, and AGAIN when it is simply sitting in our savings and retirement accounts.",
            "CALIFORNIA IS EXPENSIVE ENOUGH WITHOUT DOUBLE TAXATION",
            "Prop. 42 prohibits this double taxation by PROHIBITING ALL NEW TAXES ON RETIREMENT AND SAVINGS ACCOUNTS and other personal property, whether proposed by legislation or ballot measure, including proposals on this year’s ballot and in the future.",
            "It is a comprehensive constitutional protection against politicians or special interests trying to tax our retirement funds and savings accounts.",
            "WHO BENEFITS FROM PROP. 42",
            "Prop. 42 protects the retirement and savings for all Californians—young workers just beginning to save; teachers, firefighters and police officers with pensions; retirees and veterans who depend on their savings for financial security.",
            "You saved it. You deserve to keep it.",
            "Prop. 42 asks a simple question: should California politicians have the power to tax your personal property, including retirement and savings accounts?",
            "If you think your retirement and savings should be protected from taxes, vote Yes on 42."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Darrell Roberts, President",
            "California Professional Firefighters",
            "Chris Hannan, President",
            "State Building and Construction Trades Council of California",
            "Brian R. Marvel, President",
            "Peace Officers Research Association of California"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Darrell Roberts",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Professional Firefighters"
            },
            {
              "name": "Chris Hannan",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "State Building and Construction Trades Council of California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Brian R. Marvel",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Peace Officers Research Association of California"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "YES ON PROP. 42: PROTECT YOUR RETIREMENT AND LIFE SAVINGS FROM STATE TAXES",
            "California is now the third most expensive state to retire in the nation. Every year, higher costs and taxes make it harder to save. An April 2026 survey found 73% of Californians know someone who has had to delay retirement for financial reasons.",
            "CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION CURRENTLY ALLOWS DOUBLE TAXATION",
            "Yet, California’s Constitution currently allows the Legislature to tax the value of our personal property like retirement funds and savings accounts, even though residents already pay income tax on that money when they earn it. This means politicians can tax the same money twice: once when you earn it, and again when it is sitting in your retirement funds or savings accounts. That’s double taxation!",
            "In the last few years alone, the Legislature and special interests have introduced six separate proposals that would tax retirement and savings accounts.",
            "Taxes and cost of living are already too high in California—we need protections against taxes on our personal property and retirement savings.",
            "PROP. 42 PROHIBITS TAXES ON RETIREMENT AND SAVINGS",
            "Prop. 42 amends the state Constitution to protect Californians from this double taxation by special interests and politicians. Specifically, the measure:",
            "• Prohibits new taxes on personal property, such as retirement funds, pensions and savings accounts; • Prohibits retroactive taxes; and • Prohibits all new taxes on retirement and savings this year and in the future.",
            "PROP. 42 PROTECTS ALL FORMS OF RETIREMENT FUNDS AND SAVINGS FROM NEW TAXES",
            "Roughly 80% of Californians report having some form of retirement fund or savings, including young workers just beginning to save; teachers, firefighters and police officers with pensions; and retirees who depend on their savings for financial security.",
            "This measure protects all forms of personal property from new taxes, including 401ks, pensions, IRAs and personal savings.",
            "“Prop. 42 protects Californians’ savings and retirement. Whether it’s a union member’s hard-earned pension or a small business owner’s IRA, new taxes on retirement shouldn’t stand between people and the security they’ve planned for.”—Chris Hannan, President, State Building and Construction Trades Council of California representing hundreds of thousands of union construction trades workers.",
            "PROP. 42 PROHIBITS UNFAIR RETROACTIVE TAXES",
            "The state should not be able to pass new taxes that apply retroactively to money that taxpayers earned in the past. Prop. 42 requires any new taxes to apply only after voters have approved them.",
            "“It’s a question of fairness and common sense. People plan their retirement for years—they deserve stable, predictable rules that don’t change after years of saving and planning. Prop. 42 provides that certainty.”—Sean Morgan, licensed financial advisor",
            "Prop. 42 is supported by a broad coalition of seniors, veterans, small business owners, blue-collar workers, retirees, including groups like the California Professional Firefighters and Disabled American Veterans, Dept. of California.",
            "Californians are already struggling with high costs of living and high taxes. Many work their entire lives to achieve some measure of retirement security. It should be illegal for politicians and special interests to tax our retirement and savings.",
            "You earned and saved it. Now we need to protect it. Please join us in voting Yes on 42. YesonProp42.org"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Michael Hedges, President",
            "California Small Business Association",
            "Shelley Huff, Commander",
            "AMVETS, Department of California",
            "Jennifer Yoder, Board Member",
            "California Senior Alliance"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Michael Hedges",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Small Business Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Shelley Huff",
              "title": "Commander",
              "organization": "AMVETS, Department of California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Jennifer Yoder",
              "title": "Board Member",
              "organization": "California Senior Alliance"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE NO ON PROP. 42. This is a billionaire-funded initiative designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
            "PROP. 42 WOULD CANCEL OUT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
            "Prop. 42 was put on the ballot for one reason—because billionaires don’t want to pay their fair share. This initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce. That’s why you must vote NO.",
            "Don’t fall for the billionaires’ lies. Prop. 42 isn’t about preventing new taxes on personal property. It’s about preventing one specific tax that billionaires want to avoid, because they’d rather millions of working people lose healthcare than pay a modest, one-time tax on their extreme wealth.",
            "PROP. 42 WAS FUNDED BY BILLIONAIRES WHO WANT YOU TO PAY MORE FOR HEALTHCARE",
            "One of Prop. 42’s main funders is Google founder and Trump donor Sergey Brin, whose wealth has DOUBLED to nearly $300 billion since Trump’s election. Now he’s spent over $57 million to fund sham measures like Prop. 42 that attempt to cancel out a billionaire tax. U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders called this arrogant move by Brin “unacceptable.”",
            "Donald Trump took money out of working peoples’ pockets and gave it to billionaires like Brin through massive tax breaks. Now, the billionaires backing Prop. 42 want YOU to pay more for your healthcare.",
            "VOTE NO ON PROP. 42 IF YOU SUPPORT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
            "We have a chance to make billionaires pay their fair share to keep hospitals open and healthcare affordable for California’s working families. Vote NO on Prop. 42."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Suzanne Jimenez, Chief of Staff",
            "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Suzanne Jimenez",
              "title": "Chief of Staff",
              "organization": "SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop42-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop42-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROTECT YOUR RETIREMENT AND LIFE SAVINGS FROM STATE TAXES",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 would protect retirement and savings from state taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California is now the third most expensive state to retire in the nation.",
          "claim": "California is the third most expensive state in which to retire.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Every year, higher costs and taxes make it harder to save.",
          "claim": "Higher costs and taxes make saving harder each year.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "An April 2026 survey found 73% of Californians know someone who has had to delay retirement for financial reasons.",
          "claim": "An April 2026 survey found that 73 percent of Californians know someone who delayed retirement for financial reasons.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION CURRENTLY ALLOWS DOUBLE TAXATION",
          "claim": "California's Constitution currently allows double taxation.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.83,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California’s Constitution currently allows the Legislature to tax the value of our personal property like retirement funds and savings accounts",
          "claim": "California's Constitution currently allows the Legislature to tax the value of personal property such as retirement funds and savings accounts.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "residents already pay income tax on that money when they earn it.",
          "claim": "Residents pay income tax on money when they earn it.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "This means politicians can tax the same money twice: once when you earn it, and again when it is sitting in your retirement funds or savings accounts.",
          "claim": "Politicians can tax money when it is earned and again while it is in retirement funds or savings accounts.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "In the last few years alone, the Legislature and special interests have introduced six separate proposals that would tax retirement and savings accounts.",
          "claim": "The Legislature and special interests introduced six proposals in recent years that would tax retirement and savings accounts.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 amends the state Constitution",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 amends the state Constitution.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prohibits new taxes on personal property, such as retirement funds, pensions and savings accounts",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 prohibits new taxes on personal property, including retirement funds, pensions, and savings accounts.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prohibits retroactive taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 prohibits retroactive taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 42 limits the situations that a ballot measure or the Legislature can raise any tax retroactively.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prohibits all new taxes on retirement and savings this year and in the future.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 prohibits all new taxes on retirement and savings this year and in the future.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Roughly 80% of Californians report having some form of retirement fund or savings",
          "claim": "Roughly 80 percent of Californians report having retirement funds or savings.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "This measure protects all forms of personal property from new taxes, including 401ks, pensions, IRAs and personal savings.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 protects all forms of personal property, including 401ks, pensions, IRAs, and personal savings, from new taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": {
            "from_label": "supported_by_analysis",
            "to_label": "context_missing",
            "reason": "The analysis bans new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property and notes the state already taxes income from financial assets. 'Protects all forms of personal property from new taxes' drops that limit.",
            "reviewed_by": "agent s11-claims (Claude), PR #37 follow-up",
            "reviewed_at": "2026-10-08"
          },
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 protects Californians’ savings and retirement.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 protects Californians' savings and retirement.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 requires any new taxes to apply only after voters have approved them.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 requires every new tax to apply only after voter approval.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 42 limits the situations that a ballot measure or the Legislature can raise any tax retroactively.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "contradicted_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "it protects the retirement and savings of ALL Californians from new taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 protects the retirement and savings of all Californians from new taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "One organization that wants to tax retirement accounts.",
          "claim": "One organization opposing Proposition 42 wants to tax retirement accounts.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Sacramento politicians and special interests have repeatedly tried to pass taxes on retirement and personal savings accounts in recent years.",
          "claim": "Sacramento politicians and special interests repeatedly tried in recent years to pass taxes on retirement and personal savings accounts.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "They’ve relied on a loophole in California’s Constitution that allows government to tax our income when we earn it, and AGAIN when it is simply sitting in our savings and retirement accounts.",
          "claim": "California's Constitution contains a loophole allowing government to tax income when earned and again while it is in savings and retirement accounts.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 prohibits this double taxation",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 prohibits taxing income when earned and again while it is in retirement and savings accounts.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Although the state does tax income people make from their financial assets, there is no tax for simply owning those assets.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "PROHIBITING ALL NEW TAXES ON RETIREMENT AND SAVINGS ACCOUNTS and other personal property",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 prohibits all new taxes on retirement and savings accounts and other personal property.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "whether proposed by legislation or ballot measure",
          "claim": "The prohibition applies to taxes proposed by legislation or ballot measure.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 42 limits the situations that a ballot measure or the Legislature can raise any tax retroactively.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "including proposals on this year’s ballot and in the future.",
          "claim": "The prohibition applies to proposals on this year's ballot and future proposals.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "It is a comprehensive constitutional protection against politicians or special interests trying to tax our retirement funds and savings accounts.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 provides constitutional protection against taxes on retirement funds and savings accounts.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_against:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 protects the retirement and savings for all Californians",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 protects retirement and savings for all Californians.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 42, new taxes on the ownership of financial assets or other personal property would not be allowed.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This is a billionaire-funded initiative designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 would undo Proposition 40.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This is a billionaire-funded initiative designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Billionaires fund Proposition 42.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This is a billionaire-funded initiative designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 was designed to undo Proposition 40.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 42 WOULD CANCEL OUT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 would cancel the California Billionaire Tax.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 was put on the ballot for one reason—because billionaires don’t want to pay their fair share.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 was put on the ballot because billionaires do not want to pay their fair share.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 would make a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "This initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 was created to trick voters into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 isn’t about preventing new taxes on personal property.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 was not written to prevent new taxes on personal property.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It’s about preventing one specific tax that billionaires want to avoid",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 was written to prevent one specific tax that billionaires want to avoid.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "they’d rather millions of working people lose healthcare than pay a modest, one-time tax on their extreme wealth.",
          "claim": "Billionaires supporting Proposition 42 would rather millions of working people lose healthcare than pay a one-time tax on their wealth.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "One of Prop. 42’s main funders is Google founder and Trump donor Sergey Brin",
          "claim": "Sergey Brin is one of Proposition 42's main funders.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "whose wealth has DOUBLED to nearly $300 billion since Trump’s election.",
          "claim": "Sergey Brin's wealth doubled to nearly $300 billion since Trump's election.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "he’s spent over $57 million to fund sham measures like Prop. 42",
          "claim": "Sergey Brin spent more than $57 million to fund measures including Proposition 42.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "that attempt to cancel out a billionaire tax.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 attempts to cancel a billionaire tax.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders called this arrogant move by Brin “unacceptable.”",
          "claim": "U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders called Brin's action unacceptable.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Donald Trump took money out of working peoples’ pockets and gave it to billionaires like Brin through massive tax breaks.",
          "claim": "Donald Trump shifted money from working people to billionaires such as Sergey Brin through tax breaks.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Now, the billionaires backing Prop. 42 want YOU to pay more for your healthcare.",
          "claim": "Billionaires backing Proposition 42 want voters to pay more for health care.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "We have a chance to make billionaires pay their fair share to keep hospitals open and healthcare affordable for California’s working families.",
          "claim": "Making billionaires pay their fair share would keep hospitals open and health care affordable for California working families.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "THIS IS ANOTHER BILLIONAIRE-FUNDED TRICK",
          "claim": "Billionaires fund Proposition 42.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 is not really about protecting your retirement savings from new taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 was not written to protect retirement savings from new taxes.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It’s a redundant, expensive trick to allow approximately 200 billionaires to keep avoiding paying their own taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 would allow approximately 200 billionaires to continue avoiding their own taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.83,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "while YOU get stuck with the bill.",
          "claim": "Voters would bear costs because of Proposition 42.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 42 WOULD CANCEL OUT THE BILLIONAIRE TAX",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 would cancel the California Billionaire Tax.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 is a billionaire-funded scheme designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 would undo Proposition 40.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 is a billionaire-funded scheme designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Billionaires fund Proposition 42.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 is a billionaire-funded scheme designed specifically to undo the California Billionaire Tax, Prop. 40.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 was designed to undo Proposition 40.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 42 was put on the ballot because billionaires don’t want to pay their fair share.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 was put on the ballot because billionaires do not want to pay their fair share.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "They’d rather millions of working people lose healthcare than pay a modest, one-time tax on their extreme wealth.",
          "claim": "Billionaires supporting Proposition 42 would rather millions of working people lose health care than pay a one-time tax on their wealth.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "The billionaires behind this don’t care about protecting your retirement savings.",
          "claim": "The billionaires behind Proposition 42 do not seek to protect voters' retirement savings.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "They’re protecting themselves.",
          "claim": "The billionaires behind Proposition 42 seek to protect themselves.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "They’ve been getting out of paying their own taxes for years through loopholes and tax breaks.",
          "claim": "The billionaires behind Proposition 42 have avoided paying their own taxes for years through loopholes and tax breaks.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "This sham initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 would make a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "If Proposition 42 receives more “yes” votes than Proposition 40 on this same ballot, then Proposition 40 could be stopped from becoming law even if it gets yes votes from a majority of voters.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "This sham initiative was created to trick voters like you into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "claim": "Proposition 42 was created to trick voters into making a billionaire tax impossible to enforce.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 40 WOULD ONLY TAX BILLIONAIRES’ $2 TRILLION IN WEALTH",
          "claim": "Proposition 40 would tax only billionaires' $2 trillion in wealth.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "The billionaires behind Prop. 42 have spread lies about the California Billionaire Tax (Prop. 40)",
          "claim": "Billionaires behind Proposition 42 made false statements about Proposition 40.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "trying to trick voters into thinking that their retirement and savings are at risk.",
          "claim": "Billionaires behind Proposition 42 sought to make voters think their retirement savings were at risk.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "The California Billionaires Tax ONLY applies to billionaires.",
          "claim": "The California Billionaires Tax applies only to billionaires.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It’s about making billionaires finally pay their fair share",
          "claim": "The California Billionaires Tax was written to make billionaires pay their fair share.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-42:rebuttal_to_for:21",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "so we’re not stuck with shuttered hospitals and skyrocketing healthcare costs.",
          "claim": "The California Billionaires Tax would prevent hospital closures and rising health care costs.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-42:analysis": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
            "vig:prop-42:arguments": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-42:overview",
        "vig:prop-42:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-42:analysis",
        "vig:prop-42:arguments",
        "vig:prop-42:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-42:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-43",
      "contest_id": "prop-43",
      "number": "43",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "LIMITS VOTERS’ ABILITY TO RAISE REVENUES FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT SERVICES. LEGISLATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.",
      "measure_type": "legislative_constitutional_amendment",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by the Legislature",
      "summary": "Limits voters’ ability to pass voter-proposed local special taxes by increasing percentage of votes needed to approve such ballot measures from a majority (over 50%) to two-thirds, beginning January 1, 2027.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Possibility that local government tax revenues will not go up as much in the future due to a higher vote threshold for certain taxes.",
      "supporters": "California Taxpayers Association; Family Business Association of California; California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce",
      "opponents": "California Professional Firefighters; California Federation of Teachers; Nurse Alliance of SEIU CA.",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: Certain local government taxes would require two-thirds approval by voters.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: Certain local government taxes could continue to be approved by voters with a majority vote.",
      "pro_short": "Prop. 43 protects taxpayers by restoring Proposition 13’s two-thirds vote requirement to pass local special taxes, including sales taxes, real estate taxes and utility taxes. Courts have allowed special interests to pass earmarked tax increases with fewer votes. Prop. 43 closes this loophole, protecting taxpayers, homeowners and renters. Vote yes.",
      "con_short": "PROPOSITION 43 LIMITS VOTERS’ ABILITY TO FUND ESSENTIAL LOCAL SERVICES including fire protection, 911 response, schools, roads, hospitals and affordable housing. It doesn’t cut your taxes and lets just 33.4% of voters veto what nearly 67% want. Protect your vote and majority rule. Vote NO on Proposition 43.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "Jon Coupal",
          "Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association",
          "1201 K Street, Suite 1030",
          "Sacramento, CA 95814",
          "(916) 444-9950",
          "(213) 384-9656",
          "info@hjta.org",
          "YESon43.com"
        ],
        "against": [
          "No on Prop. 43",
          "555 Capitol Mall, Suite 400",
          "Sacramento, CA 95814",
          "info@Noprop43CA.com",
          "Noprop43CA.com"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "info@hjta.org",
          "url": "mailto:info@hjta.org"
        },
        {
          "label": "YESon43.com",
          "url": "https://www.hjta.org/saveprop13/"
        },
        {
          "label": "info@Noprop43CA.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@Noprop43CA.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "Noprop43CA.com",
          "url": "https://www.noprop43ca.com/"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Currently, local governments must obtain two-thirds voter approval to impose, extend, or increase special taxes (taxes dedicated to a specific purpose) that they place on the ballot. However, this two-thirds vote requirement does not currently apply to special taxes put on ballot by voter signature gathering.",
        "This measure would limit voters’ ability to pass voter-proposed local special taxes by raising the percentage of votes needed to approve such ballot measures from a majority (over 50%) to two-thirds.",
        "Applies to voter-proposed ballot measures approved after January 1, 2027.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Possibility that local government tax revenues will not go up as much in the future due to a higher vote threshold for certain taxes.",
        "FINAL VOTES CAST BY THE LEGISLATURE ON ACA 22 (PROPOSITION 43) (CHAPTER 132, STATUTES OF 2026)",
        "Senate:",
        "Ayes 35",
        "Noes 1",
        "Assembly:",
        "Ayes 68",
        "Noes 2",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Local Governments in California. California has many local governments. These include cities, counties, special districts, and school districts.",
            "Vote Thresholds for Local Taxes. The State Constitution allows local governments to increase taxes with local voter approval. Tax increases can be put on a ballot by voters or a local governing board (such as a city council or board of supervisors). Increases in some types of local taxes require a two-thirds vote to approve them, while other types of taxes require a majority (more than half) vote to approve them. Some local tax increases are approved permanently, while others are approved for a limited period of time. Before those taxes expire, voters can be asked whether to extend them."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Local Governments in California",
              "text": "California has many local governments. These include cities, counties, special districts, and school districts.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Vote Thresholds for Local Taxes",
              "text": "The State Constitution allows local governments to increase taxes with local voter approval. Tax increases can be put on a ballot by voters or a local governing board (such as a city council or board of supervisors). Increases in some types of local taxes require a two-thirds vote to approve them, while other types of taxes require a majority (more than half) vote to approve them. Some local tax increases are approved permanently, while others are approved for a limited period of time. Before those taxes expire, voters can be asked whether to extend them.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Requires Certain Local Taxes Receive Two-Thirds Approval by Voters. Under current law, local taxes that are used for a specific purpose require a two-thirds vote to be approved. These are called special taxes. However, recent court decisions have allowed special taxes that are proposed by voters to be approved with a majority vote. Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Requires Certain Local Taxes Receive Two-Thirds Approval by Voters",
              "text": "Under current law, local taxes that are used for a specific purpose require a two-thirds vote to be approved. These are called special taxes. However, recent court decisions have allowed special taxes that are proposed by voters to be approved with a majority vote. Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Possibility for Lower Local Government Tax Revenues in the Future. Proposition 43 makes it harder for local governments to pass certain taxes. As a result, local governments’ tax revenues could be lower in the future than they otherwise would be. The actual revenue impact is unknown and would depend on future decisions by local governments and voters."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Possibility for Lower Local Government Tax Revenues in the Future",
              "text": "Proposition 43 makes it harder for local governments to pass certain taxes. As a result, local governments’ tax revenues could be lower in the future than they otherwise would be. The actual revenue impact is unknown and would depend on future decisions by local governments and voters.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "We all want relief from California’s high cost of living. But Proposition 43 doesn’t cut your taxes a penny. It attacks something far more valuable: the power of your vote.",
            "PROP. 43 WEAKENS YOUR VOTE.",
            "Today, when local voters decide how to fund their communities, the majority rules. Prop. 43 throws that out, letting just 33.4% of voters veto what nearly 67% want. Under Prop. 43, a NO vote counts twice as much as a YES. That isn’t fair, and it isn’t democracy.",
            "PROP. 43 DEEPENS THE HOUSING CRISIS.",
            "Across California, communities vote to build affordable homes for working families, seniors, and veterans. They are helping renters stay housed and move people off the streets. Prop. 43 hands a small minority the power to block those solutions, even when a clear majority of your neighbors support them.",
            "PROP. 43 TIES YOUR COMMUNITY’S HANDS.",
            "Prop. 43 makes it harder for you to fund the critical local services your community counts on: staffing fire stations and 911 response, preparing neighborhoods for wildfire, repairing crumbling roads, keeping schools, parks, and libraries open, and protecting local hospitals and clinics as Washington cuts healthcare funding. When funding is blocked, help arrives slower, classrooms grow more crowded, and communities are left less safe.",
            "KEEP THE POWER WHERE IT BELONGS—WITH YOU AND YOUR NEIGHBORS.",
            "That’s why teachers, nurses, firefighters, and housing advocates all oppose Prop. 43.",
            "VOTE NO ON PROPOSITION 43.",
            "www.NoProp43CA.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Nick Lapis, Director of Advocacy",
            "Californians Against Waste",
            "Bill Barnes, Director of Campaigns & Community",
            "Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California",
            "Steve Frisch, President",
            "Sierra Business Council"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Nick Lapis",
              "title": "Director of Advocacy",
              "organization": "Californians Against Waste"
            },
            {
              "name": "Bill Barnes",
              "title": "Director of Campaigns & Community",
              "organization": "Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Steve Frisch",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Sierra Business Council"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE YES ON PROP. 43 TO RESTORE TAXPAYER PROTECTIONS",
            "Californians already pay high taxes. But instead of prioritizing funding for critical services like police and fire, local politicians waste your money on their pet projects— then demand tax increases, claiming the need to fund the most important priorities.",
            "The state Constitution requires a two-thirds vote for taxes earmarked for a specific purpose, but recent court decisions created a loophole that allowed special taxes to pass with fewer votes. Now Californians are paying billions in taxes they should not have had to pay.",
            "Prop. 43 RESTORES the longstanding two-thirds vote requirement for local special taxes, protecting homeowners, renters, and small businesses from costly new sales and parcel taxes, taxes on electricity and gas, and real estate taxes.",
            "Prop. 43 GUARANTEES taxpayers the right to vote on new or higher local taxes and requires governments to spend taxpayer dollars for the specific purposes voters approved—preventing bait-and-switch schemes that make our sky-high cost of living even worse.",
            "Over the last decade, local governments have imposed 2,000 new or higher taxes. Prop. 43 CLOSES LOOPHOLES used to pass some of the most damaging tax increases, restores the protections voters originally approved under Proposition 13, and makes it harder for special interests to raise taxes without broad voter support.",
            "The Legislature’s nearly unanimous vote to place Prop. 43 on the ballot sends a clear message: activist courts exceeded voters’ intent by creating loopholes that weakened Proposition 13’s protections.",
            "Restore your right to vote on ALL local taxes.",
            "VOTE YES ON PROP. 43"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Jon Coupal, President",
            "Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association",
            "Michael Hedges, President",
            "California Small Business Association",
            "Greg Van Dyke, Chairman",
            "California Consumer Advocates for Affordability and Safety"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Jon Coupal",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Michael Hedges",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Small Business Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Greg Van Dyke",
              "title": "Chairman",
              "organization": "California Consumer Advocates for Affordability and Safety"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE YES ON PROP. 43: THE LOCAL TAXPAYER PROTECTION ACT",
            "California families are struggling with the highest income, sales, and gas taxes in the nation. Yet politicians and special interests keep pushing higher taxes that make our cost of living even more expensive.",
            "We can’t afford to pay ANY MORE in new or higher taxes. PROP. 43 RESTORES PROPOSITION 13 TAXPAYER PROTECTIONS",
            "Proposition 13 was designed to make it harder to raise taxes, but court decisions created loopholes that allow special interests to impose massive new tax increases by circumventing the taxpayer protections voters approved. Californians are paying billions in new or higher taxes they would not have to pay if it weren’t for these loopholes. Prop. 43 closes these loopholes and restores the two-thirds vote requirement to pass local special taxes.",
            "PROP. 43 MAKES IT HARDER TO RAISE YOUR TAXES",
            "Local governments have imposed over 2,000 new or higher taxes in the past decade, including higher sales, property and utility taxes—using the loopholes courts created in Prop. 13 to impose some of the most costly and damaging tax increases Californians face today.",
            "These new and higher taxes make everything we buy or use more expensive, from food and gas to utilities and housing.",
            "Prop. 43 guarantees voters the right to vote on all local taxes and restores the two-thirds vote for special local taxes.",
            "PROP. 43 PROTECTS HOMEOWNERS FROM COSTLY NEW REAL ESTATE TAXES",
            "California already has some of the highest housing costs in America, yet special interests are using court-created loopholes to add new taxes on the sale of homes, apartments and other real estate.",
            "Some cities now charge real estate transfer taxes as high as 6%. For California’s median-priced home of $900,000, that would cost a homeowner $54,000 simply for selling their house. Those costs steal homeowners’ equity, raise apartment rents, and make building new housing more expensive.",
            "Prop. 43 makes it much harder for special interests to impose these costly taxes on homeowners, renters, and small businesses.",
            "PROP. 43 STOPS THE BAIT-AND-SWITCH TAX TRICKS",
            "Politicians and special interests promise new taxes will fund schools, roads, and public safety—only to divert the money elsewhere and frustrate the will of voters. Prop. 43 requires governments to spend tax revenue for the specific purpose voters approved and restores the broad voter support required before politicians and special interests impose earmarked tax measures.",
            "If taxpayers are asked to pay more, they deserve the right to vote and the confidence their money will be spent as promised.",
            "PROP. 43 PUTS VOTERS BACK IN CHARGE",
            "Every election, politicians say they need just one more tax increase. Prop. 43 simply ensures TAXPAYERS are fully protected by the right to vote on taxes.",
            "Vote YES on Prop. 43:",
            "• Affirms the voters’ right to vote on all new or higher local taxes. • Restores the two-thirds vote requirement for local special taxes. • Protects Proposition 13 and closes court-created loopholes. • Makes it harder for special interests to raise taxes. • Protects homeowners, renters, and small businesses from new real estate taxes. • Strengthens accountability for how taxpayer dollars are spent."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Robert Gutierrez, President",
            "California Taxpayers Association",
            "Robert Rivinius, President",
            "Family Business Association of California",
            "Julian Canete, President",
            "California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Robert Gutierrez",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Taxpayers Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Robert Rivinius",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Family Business Association of California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Julian Canete",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROPOSITION 43 LIMITS VOTERS’ ABILITY TO FUND ESSENTIAL LOCAL SERVICES.",
            "Prop. 43 makes it harder for you to fund critical services like police and fire departments, fix and repair local roads, staff our local schools or backfill federal healthcare cuts. Prop. 43 undermines the voice of voters and the majority vote by letting just one-third of voters (33.4%) block local voter decisions—and it makes it easier for corporate special interests to avoid paying their fair share.",
            "PROP. 43 MAKES IT HARDER TO FUND FIRE AND POLICE SERVICES.",
            "Local police and firefighters can’t rely on Sacramento or Washington politicians. These services are funded at the local level. Prop. 43 wants to make it harder for local voters to direct new funding to services like police and fire. Without adequate funding, 911 response times are slower, fire stations sit understaffed, and families wait longer for help when every second counts. When a house fire breaks out—or a wildfire threatens our neighborhoods—that local funding is what protects us. Prop. 43 would let a small minority of voters block it. Even if 66% of voters say yes, Prop. 43 would prevent us from funding desperately needed local services.",
            "PROP. 43 MAKES IT HARDER TO FIX ROADS, FUND SCHOOLS, AND PROTECT HEALTHCARE.",
            "Across California, local voters have come together to repair crumbling roads and improve transportation, to fund their neighborhood schools, and to protect local hospitals and healthcare—especially as Washington cuts federal health funding. These are decisions communities make for themselves, by majority vote. Instead, Prop. 43 hands a small group of voters the power to veto those solutions, even when the majority supports them.",
            "PROP. 43 EMPOWERS 33.4% OF VOTERS OVER THE WILL OF THE MAJORITY.",
            "In America, we believe in one person, one vote—and the majority wins. Prop. 43 throws that out. It empowers just over one-third of voters to block what nearly 67% want. It puts the out-voted minority in charge—even if they are extremists. It makes their NO vote count twice as much as a YES vote.",
            "CORPORATE DONORS BENEFIT. NOT TAXPAYERS.",
            "Under Prop. 43, corporate donors who spend big in elections will benefit most. Right now, voters can hold these corporations and developers accountable at the ballot box, and make them pay their fair share for local needs. Prop. 43 is designed to take that power away—to protect the powerful few, at everyone else’s expense.",
            "That’s why these organizations are asking you to vote NO on Prop. 43:",
            "• California Professional Firefighters • Californians Against Waste • California Federation of Teachers • California School Employees Association • Communities for a Better Environment • AAPI Force • Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California • Nurses Alliance of SEIU California • Sierra Business Council",
            "Vote NO to protect your vote and majority rule. Keep the power where it belongs—with you and your neighbors.",
            "VOTE NO ON PROPOSITION 43.",
            "www.NoProp43CA.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Darrell Roberts, President",
            "California Professional Firefighters",
            "Chris Harkins, Executive Director",
            "Nurse Alliance of SEIU California",
            "Adam Weinberger, President",
            "California School Employees Association"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Darrell Roberts",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Professional Firefighters"
            },
            {
              "name": "Chris Harkins",
              "title": "Executive Director",
              "organization": "Nurse Alliance of SEIU California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Adam Weinberger",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California School Employees Association"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/43/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/43/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop43-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/43/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop43-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California families are struggling with the highest income, sales, and gas taxes in the nation.",
          "claim": "California has the nation's highest income, sales, and gas taxes.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "politicians and special interests keep pushing higher taxes",
          "claim": "Politicians and special interests continue to seek higher taxes.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "higher taxes that make our cost of living even more expensive.",
          "claim": "Higher taxes increase the cost of living.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 43 RESTORES PROPOSITION 13 TAXPAYER PROTECTIONS",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 restores Proposition 13 taxpayer protections.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 13 was designed to make it harder to raise taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 13 was intended to make tax increases harder.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "court decisions created loopholes that allow special interests to impose massive new tax increases by circumventing the taxpayer protections voters approved.",
          "claim": "Court decisions allow special interests to impose tax increases by circumventing voter-approved taxpayer protections.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "However, recent court decisions have allowed special taxes that are proposed by voters to be approved with a majority vote.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Californians are paying billions in new or higher taxes they would not have to pay if it weren’t for these loopholes.",
          "claim": "Court-created loopholes cause Californians to pay billions in new or higher taxes.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 closes these loopholes",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 closes loopholes created by court decisions.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "restores the two-thirds vote requirement to pass local special taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 requires a two-thirds vote to pass local special taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Local governments have imposed over 2,000 new or higher taxes in the past decade",
          "claim": "Local governments imposed more than 2,000 new or higher taxes in the past decade.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "using the loopholes courts created in Prop. 13 to impose some of the most costly and damaging tax increases Californians face today.",
          "claim": "Local governments used court-created Proposition 13 loopholes to impose costly tax increases.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "However, recent court decisions have allowed special taxes that are proposed by voters to be approved with a majority vote.",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "These new and higher taxes make everything we buy or use more expensive, from food and gas to utilities and housing.",
          "claim": "New and higher local taxes make food, gas, utilities, and housing more expensive.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 guarantees voters the right to vote on all local taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 guarantees voters a right to vote on all local taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "The State Constitution allows local governments to increase taxes with local voter approval. Tax increases can be put on a ballot by voters or a local governing board (such as a city council or board of supervisors).",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "restores the two-thirds vote for special local taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 restores a two-thirds vote requirement for special local taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California already has some of the highest housing costs in America",
          "claim": "California has some of the highest housing costs in the United States.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "special interests are using court-created loopholes to add new taxes on the sale of homes, apartments and other real estate.",
          "claim": "Special interests use court-created loopholes to add taxes on real-estate sales.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Some cities now charge real estate transfer taxes as high as 6%.",
          "claim": "Some cities charge real-estate transfer taxes of up to 6 percent.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "For California’s median-priced home of $900,000, that would cost a homeowner $54,000 simply for selling their house.",
          "claim": "A 6 percent transfer tax on a $900,000 home would cost a seller $54,000.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Those costs steal homeowners’ equity, raise apartment rents, and make building new housing more expensive.",
          "claim": "Real-estate transfer-tax costs reduce homeowners' equity.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 makes it much harder for special interests to impose these costly taxes on homeowners, renters, and small businesses.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 makes it harder to impose taxes on real-estate sales.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 43 makes it harder for local governments to pass certain taxes.",
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:21",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Politicians and special interests promise new taxes will fund schools, roads, and public safety—only to divert the money elsewhere and frustrate the will of voters.",
          "claim": "Politicians and special interests divert promised tax revenue away from schools, roads, and public safety.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:22",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 requires governments to spend tax revenue for the specific purpose voters approved",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 requires governments to spend tax revenue for the voter-approved specific purpose.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:23",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "restores the broad voter support required before politicians and special interests impose earmarked tax measures.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 restores broad voter-support requirements for earmarked tax measures.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under current law, local taxes that are used for a specific purpose require a two-thirds vote to be approved. These are called special taxes.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:24",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 simply ensures TAXPAYERS are fully protected by the right to vote on taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 fully protects taxpayers' right to vote on taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "The State Constitution allows local governments to increase taxes with local voter approval.",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:25",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Affirms the voters’ right to vote on all new or higher local taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 affirms voters' right to vote on all new or higher local taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:26",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Restores the two-thirds vote requirement for local special taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 restores a two-thirds vote requirement for local special taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:27",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Protects Proposition 13 and closes court-created loopholes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 protects Proposition 13 and closes court-created loopholes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "However, recent court decisions have allowed special taxes that are proposed by voters to be approved with a majority vote.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:28",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Makes it harder for special interests to raise taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 makes it harder for special interests to raise taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 43 makes it harder for local governments to pass certain taxes.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:29",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Protects homeowners, renters, and small businesses from new real estate taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 protects homeowners, renters, and small businesses from new real-estate taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_for:30",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Strengthens accountability for how taxpayer dollars are spent.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 strengthens accountability for government spending of taxpayer dollars.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Californians already pay high taxes.",
          "claim": "Californians pay high taxes.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "local politicians waste your money on their pet projects",
          "claim": "Local politicians waste public money on pet projects.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "then demand tax increases, claiming the need to fund the most important priorities.",
          "claim": "Local politicians seek tax increases while claiming that funding priorities require them.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The state Constitution requires a two-thirds vote for taxes earmarked for a specific purpose",
          "claim": "The state Constitution requires a two-thirds vote for taxes earmarked for a specific purpose.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under current law, local taxes that are used for a specific purpose require a two-thirds vote to be approved. These are called special taxes.",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "recent court decisions created a loophole that allowed special taxes to pass with fewer votes.",
          "claim": "Recent court decisions allowed special taxes to pass with fewer than a two-thirds vote.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "However, recent court decisions have allowed special taxes that are proposed by voters to be approved with a majority vote.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Now Californians are paying billions in taxes they should not have had to pay.",
          "claim": "Californians are paying billions in taxes because of the court decisions.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 RESTORES the longstanding two-thirds vote requirement for local special taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 restores a longstanding two-thirds vote requirement for local special taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "protecting homeowners, renters, and small businesses from costly new sales and parcel taxes, taxes on electricity and gas, and real estate taxes.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 protects homeowners, renters, and small businesses from new sales, parcel, utility, and real-estate taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 GUARANTEES taxpayers the right to vote on new or higher local taxes",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 guarantees taxpayers a right to vote on new or higher local taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "The State Constitution allows local governments to increase taxes with local voter approval.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "requires governments to spend taxpayer dollars for the specific purposes voters approved",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 requires governments to spend taxpayer dollars for voter-approved specific purposes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "preventing bait-and-switch schemes that make our sky-high cost of living even worse.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 prevents bait-and-switch schemes that worsen the cost of living.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Over the last decade, local governments have imposed 2,000 new or higher taxes.",
          "claim": "Local governments imposed 2,000 new or higher taxes over the last decade.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 CLOSES LOOPHOLES used to pass some of the most damaging tax increases",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 closes loopholes used to pass tax increases.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "restores the protections voters originally approved under Proposition 13",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 restores protections voters originally approved under Proposition 13.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "However, recent court decisions have allowed special taxes that are proposed by voters to be approved with a majority vote.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "makes it harder for special interests to raise taxes without broad voter support.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 makes it harder for special interests to raise taxes without broad voter support.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 43 makes it harder for local governments to pass certain taxes.",
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The Legislature’s nearly unanimous vote to place Prop. 43 on the ballot",
          "claim": "The Legislature voted nearly unanimously to place Proposition 43 on the ballot.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_against:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "activist courts exceeded voters’ intent by creating loopholes that weakened Proposition 13’s protections.",
          "claim": "Court decisions exceeded voters' intent by creating loopholes that weakened Proposition 13 protections.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "PROPOSITION 43 LIMITS VOTERS’ ABILITY TO FUND ESSENTIAL LOCAL SERVICES.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 limits voters' ability to fund essential local services.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 43 makes it harder for local governments to pass certain taxes. As a result, local governments’ tax revenues could be lower in the future than they otherwise would be.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 makes it harder for you to fund critical services like police and fire departments, fix and repair local roads, staff our local schools or backfill federal healthcare cuts.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 makes it harder to fund police and fire departments.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 43 makes it harder for local governments to pass certain taxes.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 undermines the voice of voters and the majority vote by letting just one-third of voters (33.4%) block local voter decisions",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 lets 33.4 percent of voters block local voter decisions.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "it makes it easier for corporate special interests to avoid paying their fair share.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 makes it easier for corporate special interests to avoid paying their fair share.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Local police and firefighters can’t rely on Sacramento or Washington politicians.",
          "claim": "Local police and firefighters cannot rely on state or federal politicians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "These services are funded at the local level.",
          "claim": "Police and fire services are funded locally.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 wants to make it harder for local voters to direct new funding to services like police and fire.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 is intended to make it harder for local voters to direct new funding to police and fire services.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Without adequate funding, 911 response times are slower, fire stations sit understaffed, and families wait longer for help when every second counts.",
          "claim": "Inadequate funding causes slower 911 response times.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "that local funding is what protects us.",
          "claim": "Local funding protects residents from house fires and wildfires.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 would let a small minority of voters block it.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 would let a small minority of voters block local funding.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Even if 66% of voters say yes, Prop. 43 would prevent us from funding desperately needed local services.",
          "claim": "If 66 percent of voters approve, Proposition 43 would prevent funding for local services through the affected taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Across California, local voters have come together to repair crumbling roads and improve transportation, to fund their neighborhood schools, and to protect local hospitals and healthcare",
          "claim": "Local voters have voted to repair roads and improve transportation.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "especially as Washington cuts federal health funding.",
          "claim": "The federal government is cutting federal health funding.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "These are decisions communities make for themselves, by majority vote.",
          "claim": "Communities make these funding decisions by majority vote.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Increases in some types of local taxes require a two-thirds vote to approve them, while other types of taxes require a majority (more than half) vote to approve them.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 hands a small group of voters the power to veto those solutions, even when the majority supports them.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 lets a small group of voters veto local solutions supported by a majority.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "In America, we believe in one person, one vote—and the majority wins.",
          "claim": "American elections operate on a majority-wins principle.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It empowers just over one-third of voters to block what nearly 67% want.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 allows just over one-third of voters to block what nearly 67 percent support.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It puts the out-voted minority in charge—even if they are extremists.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 puts an outvoted minority in charge.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It makes their NO vote count twice as much as a YES vote.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 makes a no vote count twice as much as a yes vote.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "corporate donors who spend big in elections will benefit most.",
          "claim": "Corporate donors who spend heavily in elections will benefit most from Proposition 43.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:21",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Right now, voters can hold these corporations and developers accountable at the ballot box, and make them pay their fair share for local needs.",
          "claim": "Voters can make corporations and developers pay for local needs through ballot measures.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:22",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 is designed to take that power away",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 was designed to take away voters' power to make corporations and developers pay for local needs.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:argument_against:23",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "to protect the powerful few, at everyone else’s expense.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 was designed to protect a powerful few at others' expense.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 43 doesn’t cut your taxes a penny.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 does not cut taxes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It attacks something far more valuable: the power of your vote.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 is intended to attack voters' power.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Today, when local voters decide how to fund their communities, the majority rules.",
          "claim": "Local voters currently decide community funding by majority vote.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Increases in some types of local taxes require a two-thirds vote to approve them, while other types of taxes require a majority (more than half) vote to approve them.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 throws that out, letting just 33.4% of voters veto what nearly 67% want.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 lets 33.4 percent of voters veto what nearly 67 percent support.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Under Prop. 43, a NO vote counts twice as much as a YES.",
          "claim": "Under Proposition 43, a no vote counts twice as much as a yes vote.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Across California, communities vote to build affordable homes for working families, seniors, and veterans.",
          "claim": "Communities in California vote to build affordable homes for working families, seniors, and veterans.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "They are helping renters stay housed and move people off the streets.",
          "claim": "Those community housing decisions help renters remain housed.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 hands a small minority the power to block those solutions, even when a clear majority of your neighbors support them.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 gives a small minority power to block housing solutions supported by a clear majority.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Under Proposition 43, beginning on January 1, 2027, any new, increased, or extended local special taxes proposed by voters would require a two-thirds vote.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 43 makes it harder for you to fund the critical local services your community counts on: staffing fire stations and 911 response, preparing neighborhoods for wildfire, repairing crumbling roads, keeping schools, parks, and libraries open, and protecting local hospitals and clinics as Washington cuts healthcare funding.",
          "claim": "Proposition 43 makes it harder to fund fire-station staffing and 911 response.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 43 makes it harder for local governments to pass certain taxes.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Washington cuts healthcare funding.",
          "claim": "The federal government is cutting healthcare funding.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-43:rebuttal_to_for:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "When funding is blocked, help arrives slower, classrooms grow more crowded, and communities are left less safe.",
          "claim": "Blocked funding makes help arrive more slowly.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-43:analysis": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
            "vig:prop-43:arguments": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-43:overview",
        "vig:prop-43:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-43:analysis",
        "vig:prop-43:arguments",
        "vig:prop-43:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-43:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-44",
      "contest_id": "prop-44",
      "number": "44",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "REQUIRES COMMUNITY HEALTH CLINICS SPEND 90% OF REVENUE ON PROGRAM SERVICES. INITIATIVE STATUTE.",
      "measure_type": "initiative_statute",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures",
      "summary": "Imposes penalties on nonprofit Federally Qualified Health Centers (community clinics providing primary care to medically underserved areas and populations) that spend less than 90% of revenue on “program services” advancing their charitable purpose, including but not limited to patient services.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Increased state costs in the low tens of millions of dollars per year, covered by fees.",
      "supporters": "None submitted",
      "opponents": "American Academy of Pediatrics CA; CA School Nurses Org; CA Academy of Family Physicians; CA Medical Assoc.",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: Certain private nonprofit health care clinics would have to spend at least 90 percent of their revenue each year on providing health care services.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: The new requirement on health care clinic spending would not go into effect.",
      "pro_short": "Prop. 44 holds community clinics and their executives accountable by requiring that 90% of clinic revenue be spent on clinics’ charitable mission: patient care and services that make care possible. It increases transparency, reduces wasteful executive spending, and ensures healthcare dollars go where they belong: caring for Californians in need.",
      "con_short": "Prop. 44 is a dangerous measure that will shut down hundreds of community health clinics and eliminate vital patient services for millions of Californians. American Academy of Pediatrics CA, California Medical Association, California Academy of Family Physicians, California School Nurses Organization, doctors, nurses and patients urge NO on 44! www.NOProp44.com",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "Gustavo Medina",
          "SEIU-UHW",
          "5480 Ferguson Drive",
          "Los Angeles, CA 90022",
          "(323) 805-0241",
          "contact@yesonprop44.com",
          "yesonproposition44.com"
        ],
        "against": [
          "No on Prop. 44—Stop the",
          "Attack on Patients and",
          "Community Health Clinics",
          "info@noprop44.com",
          "www.NoProp44.com"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "contact@yesonprop44.com",
          "url": "mailto:contact@yesonprop44.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "yesonproposition44.com",
          "url": "https://yesonprop44.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "info@noprop44.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@noprop44.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "www.NoProp44.com",
          "url": "https://noprop44.com/"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Imposes penalties on nonprofit Federally Qualified Health Centers (community clinics providing primary care to medically underserved areas and populations) that spend less than 90% of revenue on “program services” advancing their charitable purpose, including but not limited to patient services. Department of Public Health may waive spending requirements in exceptional circumstances.",
        "Authorizes Attorney General to publish guidance defining qualifying expenditures.",
        "Monetary penalties may be refunded if centers become compliant within five years.",
        "Authorizes criminal charges for false reports or artificially increasing spending ratio.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Increased state costs in the low tens of millions of dollars per year to enforce the new requirements on certain private nonprofit health care clinics, covered by fees charged to the affected clinics.",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Safety Net Clinics Serve Low-Income People. Clinics are places where people can access certain health care services, such as doctor’s visits. Many clinics are considered “safety net,” as they mainly serve low-income and uninsured people. The care they provide is often low cost or free to patients. There are about 2,000 safety net clinics in California. Most are private nonprofits, and the rest are run by public entities (such as counties).",
            "Clinics Spend Most of Their Revenue on Health Care Services. Clinics spend most of their revenue on providing health care to patients. They also have other expenses, such as administrative costs. Each year, private nonprofit safety net clinics in California report their revenues and expenses to the federal government and the state. These clinics currently report spending an average of about 80 percent of their revenue on providing health care services, though the percent varies across clinics."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Safety Net Clinics Serve Low-Income People",
              "text": "Clinics are places where people can access certain health care services, such as doctor’s visits. Many clinics are considered “safety net,” as they mainly serve low-income and uninsured people. The care they provide is often low cost or free to patients. There are about 2,000 safety net clinics in California. Most are private nonprofits, and the rest are run by public entities (such as counties).",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Clinics Spend Most of Their Revenue on Health Care Services",
              "text": "Clinics spend most of their revenue on providing health care to patients. They also have other expenses, such as administrative costs. Each year, private nonprofit safety net clinics in California report their revenues and expenses to the federal government and the state. These clinics currently report spending an average of about 80 percent of their revenue on providing health care services, though the percent varies across clinics.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Sets Minimum Spending on Health Care at Private Nonprofit Safety Net Clinics. Proposition 44 requires private nonprofit safety net clinics to spend at least 90 percent of their total revenue each year on providing health care services. This means that spending on other expenses, such as administrative costs, would be limited to no more than 10 percent of revenue. The California Attorney General would define in more detail which kinds of expenses are related to providing health care services, and which are other expenses, using existing reports to the federal government as a starting point. Affected clinics could ask the state for a temporary waiver of the requirements in some cases.",
            "Creates Penalty for Falling Short of Minimum. Proposition 44 requires affected clinics to pay a penalty to the state if they fall short of the new health care spending minimum. The penalty would equal the amount of spending needed to reach the 90 percent minimum. Clinics could get their money back if they comply with the spending requirements within five years. If clinics do not comply within five years, the state would keep the money and spend it on clinic workforce programs."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Sets Minimum Spending on Health Care at Private Nonprofit Safety Net Clinics",
              "text": "Proposition 44 requires private nonprofit safety net clinics to spend at least 90 percent of their total revenue each year on providing health care services. This means that spending on other expenses, such as administrative costs, would be limited to no more than 10 percent of revenue. The California Attorney General would define in more detail which kinds of expenses are related to providing health care services, and which are other expenses, using existing reports to the federal government as a starting point. Affected clinics could ask the state for a temporary waiver of the requirements in some cases.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Creates Penalty for Falling Short of Minimum",
              "text": "Proposition 44 requires affected clinics to pay a penalty to the state if they fall short of the new health care spending minimum. The penalty would equal the amount of spending needed to reach the 90 percent minimum. Clinics could get their money back if they comply with the spending requirements within five years. If clinics do not comply within five years, the state would keep the money and spend it on clinic workforce programs.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Creates State Enforcement Costs. Under Proposition 44, the state would enforce the new requirements on private nonprofit safety net clinics. This includes reviewing financial reports and investigating affected entities. State enforcement costs would be in the low tens of millions of dollars per year. The proposition directs the state to cover the costs by charging fees on affected clinics.",
            "Could Have Other Uncertain Costs. Proposition 44 could create other costs for the state and local governments. These costs are uncertain. They depend on (1) how the state Attorney General would define health care-related expenses and (2) whether affected clinics would meet the spending minimum. For example, affected clinics might spend more on direct health care services to comply with the requirement, which could increase state costs. This is because some of these services would be for patients in Medi-Cal, the state’s program that provides health care coverage for low-income Californians. Some clinics that could not meet the minimum spending requirement might close instead. This would create other uncertain effects on state and local costs."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Creates State Enforcement Costs",
              "text": "Under Proposition 44, the state would enforce the new requirements on private nonprofit safety net clinics. This includes reviewing financial reports and investigating affected entities. State enforcement costs would be in the low tens of millions of dollars per year. The proposition directs the state to cover the costs by charging fees on affected clinics.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Could Have Other Uncertain Costs",
              "text": "Proposition 44 could create other costs for the state and local governments. These costs are uncertain. They depend on (1) how the state Attorney General would define health care-related expenses and (2) whether affected clinics would meet the spending minimum. For example, affected clinics might spend more on direct health care services to comply with the requirement, which could increase state costs. This is because some of these services would be for patients in Medi-Cal, the state’s program that provides health care coverage for low-income Californians. Some clinics that could not meet the minimum spending requirement might close instead. This would create other uncertain effects on state and local costs.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROP. 44 IS A DANGEROUS SPECIAL INTEREST MEASURE THAT THREATENS CARE FOR MILLIONS",
            "Make no mistake: Prop. 44 is not about resources for patient care. Prop. 44 is a dangerous measure written and funded entirely by one special interest that threatens access to care for millions. Prop. 44 imposes unworkable restrictions that actually prevent community clinics from providing the care patients need.",
            "NURSES, DOCTORS AND PATIENT ADVOCATES ALL AGREE: PROP. 44 WILL HURT PATIENTS. Prop. 44 will:",
            "• Cut billions from health clinics every year. • Force clinics to shut down and cut services. • Eliminate care for millions. • Send more patients to hospital ERs—increasing wait times for all families.",
            "PROP. 44 IS UNNECESSARY. COMMUNITY CLINICS ARE STRICTLY REGULATED.",
            "Community clinics are heavily regulated, with strict rules requiring resources be spent on patient care and serving their communities. Federal and state laws require regular audits and public reporting of clinic spending. Every community clinic is not-for-profit—led by a board that includes patients—requiring funds to be spent on patient care and community benefits—not corporate profits.",
            "SPECIAL INTERESTS PUSHING PROP. 44 ARE USING PATIENTS AS PAWNS",
            "Prop. 44 is a shameful power play by one special interest abusing the ballot measure process to gain political leverage over health clinics. This same special interest has spent $140 million pushing dozens of harmful ballot measures against hospitals, clinics and physicians, including three unsuccessful dialysis propositions that voters overwhelmingly rejected.",
            "JOIN PATIENTS, NURSES, DOCTORS, AND COMMUNITY LEADERS: NO ON PROP. 44.",
            "Prop. 44 is opposed by:",
            "• American Academy of Pediatrics CA • California School Nurses Organization • California Medical Association • American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists District IX • Planned Parenthood Affiliates of CA • American College of Emergency Physicians CA • California Academy of Family Physicians",
            "www.NoProp44.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Brent K Sugimoto, MD, FAAFP, President-Elect",
            "California Academy of Family Physicians",
            "Kelly McCue, MD, Immediate Past Chair",
            "American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists District IX",
            "Susanne J. Spano, MD, FACEP, President",
            "American College of Emergency Physicians, California Chapter"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Brent K Sugimoto",
              "title": "MD, FAAFP, President-Elect",
              "organization": "California Academy of Family Physicians"
            },
            {
              "name": "Kelly McCue",
              "title": "MD, Immediate Past Chair",
              "organization": "American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists District IX"
            },
            {
              "name": "Susanne J. Spano",
              "title": "MD, FACEP, President",
              "organization": "American College of Emergency Physicians, California Chapter"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "DON’T BE FOOLED BY SCARE TACTICS.",
            "Highly paid clinic executives want you to believe this measure will close clinics, eliminate services, and hurt patients. Those claims are false.",
            "PROP. 44 PROTECTS PATIENT CARE—IT DOESN'T CUT IT.",
            "Proposition 44 simply requires that 90% of clinic revenue be spent on clinics’ non-profit mission: patient care and services that support care. This CAN INCLUDE: Transportation, language interpretation, care coordination, community outreach, nurse managers and clinical staff, medical equipment and information technology, and mental health, dental, and preventative care. The opposition falsely claims these services would be cut, but Prop. 44 is designed to protect spending that serves patients.",
            "PROP. 44 PREVENTS PRECIOUS RESOURCES FROM BEING DIVERTED AWAY FROM PATIENT CARE",
            "Prop. 44 seeks to reduce spending on: Excessive CEO pay, lavish events, expensive consultants, and unnecessary administrative spending. That means healthcare dollars would go where they belong: Caring for patients.",
            "WHY ARE CLINIC EXECUTIVES FIGHTING ACCOUNTABILITY?",
            "The campaign against Prop. 44 is funded by the same highly paid clinic executives who benefit from the current system. If today’s oversight were enough, some clinics wouldn’t be spending less than half of their funding on patient care and services. The real threat to clinics isn’t accountability, it’s devastating federal healthcare cuts. Patients can’t afford to see precious funding spent on excessive CEO compensation and other non-essentials while they wait months for appointments and healthcare workers struggle with understaffing and limited resources.",
            "PUT PATIENTS FIRST, NOT CLINIC CEOS.",
            "Vote YES on Proposition 44."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Shawna Brown, Initiative Proponent",
            "Brisa J. Barrera, Community Clinic Worker"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Shawna Brown",
              "title": "Initiative Proponent",
              "organization": null
            },
            {
              "name": "Brisa J. Barrera",
              "title": "Community Clinic Worker",
              "organization": null
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE YES ON PROP. 44 TO PUT PATIENTS FIRST AND HOLD CLINICS ACCOUNTABLE.",
            "California’s community health clinics receive billions of taxpayer dollars to provide care for people who need it most. Yet some clinics spend less than half of their funding on patient care and services, while large portions of their revenue go to bloated CEO salaries and other wasteful spending. As a result, patients wait months for appointments and healthcare workers struggle with staffing shortages, outdated equipment, and limited resources.",
            "WHY PROP. 44 IS NEEDED",
            "Community health clinics receive taxpayer funding for one purpose: to provide primary care, mental health services, dental care, prenatal care, vaccinations, and other essential services to millions of children, seniors, working families, and Californians with disabilities. Without access to these clinics, many patients would not get the care they urgently need. But some clinic CEOs are misusing taxpayer dollars by diverting millions to inflated executive salaries and other non-essentials.",
            "With massive federal healthcare cuts expected to eliminate billions in funding for California’s healthcare system, community clinics will be among the hardest hit. Clinics may be forced to reduce services, lay off staff, or even close their doors. That means every healthcare dollar matters more than ever. California taxpayers can’t afford to waste resources that should be helping patients receive timely, high-quality care.",
            "PROP. 44 DIRECTS HEALTHCARE DOLLARS TO PATIENT CARE",
            "Proposition 44 is simple. It requires community health clinics to spend at least 90% of their revenue on their non-profit mission—patient care and the services that make care possible. That could include medical visits, mental health care, dental care, medications, medical equipment, transportation, language interpretation, care coordination, outreach, and other services that serve the clinics’ charitable healthcare mission.",
            "What doesn’t count towards the 90%: excessive CEO pay, lavish events, bloated overhead, and other spending that takes resources away from the clinic’s core mission of caring for patients.",
            "PROP. 44 HOLDS CLINICS ACCOUNTABLE",
            "Proposition 44 will increase transparency by requiring clinics to publicly report how healthcare dollars are spent, so patients and taxpayers can hold them accountable. Currently, there are hundreds of millions of dollars in the clinic system that are not being spent on the core mission of patient care. Prop. 44 will make sure those healthcare dollars go where they can do the most good.",
            "This measure does not cut clinic funding or reduce services patients rely on. Clinics that meet the standard keep every dollar, and even clinics that fall short can recover any penalties by coming into compliance. Unrecovered penalties, if any, are redirected to recruiting, training, and retaining the healthcare workers our clinics desperately need. Every dollar stays in the healthcare system—prioritized for patient care instead of excessive overhead.",
            "Join healthcare workers, patients, and Californians who believe accountability strengthens our healthcare system.",
            "VOTE YES ON PROP. 44 TO PUT PATIENTS FIRST."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Shawna Brown, Initiative Proponent",
            "Brisa J. Barrera, Community Clinic Worker"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Shawna Brown",
              "title": "Initiative Proponent",
              "organization": null
            },
            {
              "name": "Brisa J. Barrera",
              "title": "Community Clinic Worker",
              "organization": null
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE NO ON PROP. 44: STOP THE ATTACK ON PATIENTS & COMMUNITY HEALTH CLINICS",
            "Prop. 44 is a dangerous, poorly drafted measure that would threaten care for millions of California patients.",
            "Prop. 44 imposes deeply flawed and unworkable restrictions that prevent community clinics from providing the care patients need. Economic and health experts warn Prop. 44 will:",
            "• Cut $1.7 billion from health clinics in the first year alone. • Cause 88% of all clinics in the state to operate at a loss. • Force thousands of clinics throughout the state to cut back patient services or shut down entirely. • Eliminate care for millions of Californians. • Send more patients to hospital emergency rooms—increasing wait times for all families.",
            "PROP. 44 ARBITRARILY RESTRICTS SPENDING ON VITAL PATIENT SERVICES",
            "Prop. 44 is so poorly written that it restricts clinics from spending resources on essential staff and services, including nurse managers, physician leaders, translation services, insurance assistance and community education. It even restricts clinics from funding mammogram, X-ray and CT machines, information technology and expanding or upgrading clinics.",
            "PROP. 44 DECIMATES THE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM AND HURTS ALL PATIENTS",
            "Community health clinics provide primary care, prenatal care, urgent care, mental and behavioral health services, telehealth, and dental services. They operate school-based health clinics that care for hundreds of thousands of children.",
            "Community clinics serve 1 in 4 Medi-Cal patients, the uninsured, working families, seniors, veterans, and children. In many rural and medically underserved communities, community health clinics are the only source of care within hundreds of miles.",
            "Prop. 44 will make our bad healthcare problems even worse— increasing patient wait times and eliminating the only source of care for many patients.",
            "PROP. 44 IS UNNECESSARY. COMMUNITY CLINICS ARE STRICTLY REGULATED.",
            "Community clinics are already heavily regulated by the federal and state governments, with strict funding rules on patient care and essential services, and regular mandatory public audits. All clinics are overseen by patient board members, to ensure care is focused on community needs. And clinics are non-profits legally required to focus resources on patient services and community benefits.",
            "PROP. 44 OPPOSED BY PATIENTS, NURSES, DOCTORS AND COMMUNITY LEADERS",
            "“Prop. 44 will eliminate the only source of care in many communities. Please vote NO.”—Kim Yu, MD, FAAFP, President, California Academy of Family Physicians",
            "“Community clinics are a lifeline for my family and millions across California. Please, protect patients like me. Reject Prop. 44.”—Carmen Huertero, Clinic Patient, San Marcos, CA",
            "“Prop. 44 threatens women’s access to healthcare at a time when it’s already under attack. Vote No.”—Jodi Hicks, President & CEO, Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California",
            "\"By shutting down clinics, Prop. 44 will force millions of patients into already overcrowded emergency rooms—increasing wait times for everyone.”—Susanne J Spano, MD, FACEP, President, American College of Emergency Physicians, California",
            "“Prop. 44 threatens to shut down hundreds of school-based clinics that provide primary care, vaccinations, health screenings and mental health services for tens of thousands of children. Vote NO.”—Katie Nilsson, RN, President, California School Nurses Organization",
            "Prop. 44 Opposed By:",
            "• American Academy of Pediatrics, California • California School Nurses Organization • California Medical Association • California Primary Care Association, representing thousands of community health centers and clinics • American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists District IX • Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California • National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter • American College of Emergency Physicians, California • California Academy of Family Physicians",
            "www.NoProp44.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Eric Ball, MD, FAAP, President",
            "American Academy of Pediatrics, California",
            "Katie Nilsson, RN, President",
            "California School Nurses Organization",
            "René Bravo, M.D., President",
            "California Medical Association"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Eric Ball",
              "title": "MD, FAAP, President",
              "organization": "American Academy of Pediatrics, California"
            },
            {
              "name": "Katie Nilsson",
              "title": "RN, President",
              "organization": "California School Nurses Organization"
            },
            {
              "name": "René Bravo",
              "title": "M.D., President",
              "organization": "California Medical Association"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/44/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/44/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop44-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/44/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop44-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California’s community health clinics receive billions of taxpayer dollars to provide care for people who need it most.",
          "claim": "California community health clinics receive billions of taxpayer dollars to provide care for people with high need.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "some clinics spend less than half of their funding on patient care and services",
          "claim": "Some clinics spend less than half of their funding on patient care and services.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "large portions of their revenue go to bloated CEO salaries and other wasteful spending.",
          "claim": "Large portions of some clinics' revenue go to CEO salaries and spending characterized as wasteful.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "patients wait months for appointments",
          "claim": "Patients wait months for appointments.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "healthcare workers struggle with staffing shortages, outdated equipment, and limited resources.",
          "claim": "Health care workers face staffing shortages, outdated equipment, and limited resources.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Community health clinics receive taxpayer funding for one purpose: to provide primary care, mental health services, dental care, prenatal care, vaccinations, and other essential services to millions of children, seniors, working families, and Californians with disabilities.",
          "claim": "Community health clinics receive taxpayer funding to provide specified health services to millions of children, seniors, working families, and Californians with disabilities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Without access to these clinics, many patients would not get the care they urgently need.",
          "claim": "Many patients would not receive urgently needed care without access to these clinics.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "some clinic CEOs are misusing taxpayer dollars by diverting millions to inflated executive salaries and other non-essentials.",
          "claim": "Some clinic chief executive officers divert millions of taxpayer dollars to executive salaries and nonessential spending.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "massive federal healthcare cuts expected to eliminate billions in funding for California’s healthcare system",
          "claim": "Federal health care cuts are expected to eliminate billions of dollars in funding for California's health care system.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "community clinics will be among the hardest hit.",
          "claim": "Community clinics will be among the entities most affected by expected federal health care cuts.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Clinics may be forced to reduce services, lay off staff, or even close their doors.",
          "claim": "Clinics may reduce services, lay off staff, or close because of expected federal health care cuts.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "It requires community health clinics to spend at least 90% of their revenue on their non-profit mission—patient care and the services that make care possible.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 requires community health clinics to spend at least 90 percent of revenue on patient care and supporting services.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 44 requires private nonprofit safety net clinics to spend at least 90 percent of their total revenue each year on providing health care services.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "That could include medical visits, mental health care, dental care, medications, medical equipment, transportation, language interpretation, care coordination, outreach, and other services that serve the clinics’ charitable healthcare mission.",
          "claim": "Spending counted toward the 90 percent requirement could include the listed medical and support services.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The California Attorney General would define in more detail which kinds of expenses are related to providing health care services, and which are other expenses, using existing reports to the federal government as a starting point.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "What doesn’t count towards the 90%: excessive CEO pay, lavish events, bloated overhead, and other spending that takes resources away from the clinic’s core mission of caring for patients.",
          "claim": "Excessive chief executive officer pay, lavish events, bloated overhead, and certain other spending do not count toward the 90 percent requirement.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The California Attorney General would define in more detail which kinds of expenses are related to providing health care services, and which are other expenses, using existing reports to the federal government as a starting point.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Proposition 44 will increase transparency by requiring clinics to publicly report how healthcare dollars are spent",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 requires clinics to publicly report how health care dollars are spent.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "there are hundreds of millions of dollars in the clinic system that are not being spent on the core mission of patient care.",
          "claim": "Hundreds of millions of dollars in the clinic system are not spent on patient care.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "This measure does not cut clinic funding or reduce services patients rely on.",
          "claim": "The measure does not reduce clinic funding or services on which patients rely.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Some clinics that could not meet the minimum spending requirement might close instead. This would create other uncertain effects on state and local costs.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Clinics that meet the standard keep every dollar",
          "claim": "Clinics that meet the spending standard do not pay the shortfall penalty.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 44 requires affected clinics to pay a penalty to the state if they fall short of the new health care spending minimum.",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "even clinics that fall short can recover any penalties by coming into compliance.",
          "claim": "Clinics that fall short of the requirement can recover penalties by later complying.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Clinics could get their money back if they comply with the spending requirements within five years.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Unrecovered penalties, if any, are redirected to recruiting, training, and retaining the healthcare workers our clinics desperately need.",
          "claim": "Unrecovered penalties are spent on recruiting, training, and retaining clinic health care workers.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "If clinics do not comply within five years, the state would keep the money and spend it on clinic workforce programs.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Highly paid clinic executives want you to believe this measure will close clinics, eliminate services, and hurt patients.",
          "claim": "Highly paid clinic executives are promoting claims that the measure will close clinics, eliminate services, and harm patients.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Those claims are false.",
          "claim": "Claims that the measure will close clinics, eliminate services, and harm patients are false.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "Some clinics that could not meet the minimum spending requirement might close instead. This would create other uncertain effects on state and local costs.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 44 simply requires that 90% of clinic revenue be spent on clinics’ non-profit mission: patient care and services that support care.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 requires 90 percent of clinic revenue to be spent on patient care and supporting services.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 44 requires private nonprofit safety net clinics to spend at least 90 percent of their total revenue each year on providing health care services.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "This CAN INCLUDE: Transportation, language interpretation, care coordination, community outreach, nurse managers and clinical staff, medical equipment and information technology, and mental health, dental, and preventative care.",
          "claim": "The 90 percent requirement can include spending on the listed support, staffing, equipment, technology, and health care services.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The California Attorney General would define in more detail which kinds of expenses are related to providing health care services, and which are other expenses, using existing reports to the federal government as a starting point.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The opposition falsely claims these services would be cut",
          "claim": "Opponents falsely claim the listed services would be cut.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "These costs are uncertain. They depend on (1) how the state Attorney General would define health care-related expenses and (2) whether affected clinics would meet the spending minimum.",
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 is designed to protect spending that serves patients.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 was designed to protect spending that serves patients.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 seeks to reduce spending on: Excessive CEO pay, lavish events, expensive consultants, and unnecessary administrative spending.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 seeks to reduce spending on excessive chief executive officer pay, lavish events, expensive consultants, and unnecessary administrative spending.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The campaign against Prop. 44 is funded by the same highly paid clinic executives who benefit from the current system.",
          "claim": "Highly paid clinic executives who benefit from the current system fund the campaign against Proposition 44.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "some clinics wouldn’t be spending less than half of their funding on patient care and services.",
          "claim": "Some clinics spend less than half of their funding on patient care and services.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "The real threat to clinics isn’t accountability, it’s devastating federal healthcare cuts.",
          "claim": "Federal health care cuts, rather than accountability requirements, are the main threat to clinics.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_against:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Patients can’t afford to see precious funding spent on excessive CEO compensation and other non-essentials while they wait months for appointments and healthcare workers struggle with understaffing and limited resources.",
          "claim": "Patients wait months for appointments and health care workers face understaffing and limited resources.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 is a dangerous, poorly drafted measure that would threaten care for millions of California patients.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 would threaten care for millions of California patients.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 imposes deeply flawed and unworkable restrictions that prevent community clinics from providing the care patients need.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 imposes restrictions that prevent community clinics from providing needed care.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Economic and health experts warn Prop. 44 will:",
          "claim": "Economic and health experts warn about Proposition 44's effects.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "other_records",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Cut $1.7 billion from health clinics in the first year alone.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will cut $1.7 billion from health clinics in its first year.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Cause 88% of all clinics in the state to operate at a loss.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will cause 88 percent of all California clinics to operate at a loss.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Force thousands of clinics throughout the state to cut back patient services or shut down entirely.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will force thousands of clinics to reduce services or close.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Eliminate care for millions of Californians.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will eliminate care for millions of Californians.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Send more patients to hospital emergency rooms—increasing wait times for all families.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will send more patients to hospital emergency rooms and increase wait times for all families.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "it restricts clinics from spending resources on essential staff and services, including nurse managers, physician leaders, translation services, insurance assistance and community education.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 restricts clinic spending on the listed staff and services.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The California Attorney General would define in more detail which kinds of expenses are related to providing health care services, and which are other expenses, using existing reports to the federal government as a starting point.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It even restricts clinics from funding mammogram, X-ray and CT machines, information technology and expanding or upgrading clinics.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 restricts clinic spending on the listed equipment, information technology, and clinic expansion or upgrades.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The California Attorney General would define in more detail which kinds of expenses are related to providing health care services, and which are other expenses, using existing reports to the federal government as a starting point.",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Community health clinics provide primary care, prenatal care, urgent care, mental and behavioral health services, telehealth, and dental services.",
          "claim": "Community health clinics provide the listed types of health care services.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Clinics are places where people can access certain health care services, such as doctor’s visits.",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "They operate school-based health clinics that care for hundreds of thousands of children.",
          "claim": "Community health clinics operate school-based clinics that care for hundreds of thousands of children.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Community clinics serve 1 in 4 Medi-Cal patients, the uninsured, working families, seniors, veterans, and children.",
          "claim": "Community clinics serve one in four Medi-Cal patients and serve uninsured people, working families, seniors, veterans, and children.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "In many rural and medically underserved communities, community health clinics are the only source of care within hundreds of miles.",
          "claim": "Community health clinics are the only care source within hundreds of miles in many rural and medically underserved communities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 will make our bad healthcare problems even worse— increasing patient wait times and eliminating the only source of care for many patients.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will increase patient wait times and eliminate the only care source for many patients.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:16",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Community clinics are already heavily regulated by the federal and state governments, with strict funding rules on patient care and essential services, and regular mandatory public audits.",
          "claim": "Federal and state governments heavily regulate community clinics through funding rules and regular mandatory public audits.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:17",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "All clinics are overseen by patient board members, to ensure care is focused on community needs.",
          "claim": "All clinics are overseen by patient board members.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:18",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "clinics are non-profits legally required to focus resources on patient services and community benefits.",
          "claim": "Clinics are nonprofits legally required to focus resources on patient services and community benefits.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Most are private nonprofits, and the rest are run by public entities (such as counties).",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:19",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "“Prop. 44 will eliminate the only source of care in many communities. Please vote NO.”—Kim Yu, MD, FAAFP, President, California Academy of Family Physicians",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will eliminate the only care source in many communities.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:20",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "“Prop. 44 threatens women’s access to healthcare at a time when it’s already under attack. Vote No.”—Jodi Hicks, President & CEO, Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 threatens women's access to health care.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:21",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "\"By shutting down clinics, Prop. 44 will force millions of patients into already overcrowded emergency rooms—increasing wait times for everyone.”—Susanne J Spano, MD, FACEP, President, American College of Emergency Physicians, California",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will shut down clinics, force millions of patients into emergency rooms, and increase wait times.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:argument_against:22",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "“Prop. 44 threatens to shut down hundreds of school-based clinics that provide primary care, vaccinations, health screenings and mental health services for tens of thousands of children. Vote NO.”—Katie Nilsson, RN, President, California School Nurses Organization",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 threatens to close hundreds of school-based clinics serving tens of thousands of children.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 is not about resources for patient care.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 was not written to address resources for patient care.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 is a dangerous measure written and funded entirely by one special interest that threatens access to care for millions.",
          "claim": "One special interest wrote and entirely funded Proposition 44.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 is a dangerous measure written and funded entirely by one special interest that threatens access to care for millions.",
          "claim": "One special interest wrote Proposition 44.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 is a dangerous measure written and funded entirely by one special interest that threatens access to care for millions.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 threatens access to care for millions of people.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 imposes unworkable restrictions that actually prevent community clinics from providing the care patients need.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 imposes restrictions that prevent community clinics from providing needed care.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "NURSES, DOCTORS AND PATIENT ADVOCATES ALL AGREE: PROP. 44 WILL HURT PATIENTS.",
          "claim": "Nurses, doctors, and patient advocates all agree that Proposition 44 will harm patients.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "other_records",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Cut billions from health clinics every year.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will cut billions of dollars from health clinics each year.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Force clinics to shut down and cut services.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will force clinics to close and reduce services.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Eliminate care for millions.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will eliminate care for millions of people.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Send more patients to hospital ERs—increasing wait times for all families.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 will send more patients to hospital emergency rooms and increase wait times for all families.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Community clinics are heavily regulated, with strict rules requiring resources be spent on patient care and serving their communities.",
          "claim": "Community clinics are heavily regulated by rules requiring resources to be spent on patient care and community service.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Federal and state laws require regular audits and public reporting of clinic spending.",
          "claim": "Federal and state laws require regular audits and public reporting of clinic spending.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Every community clinic is not-for-profit—led by a board that includes patients—requiring funds to be spent on patient care and community benefits—not corporate profits.",
          "claim": "Every community clinic is a nonprofit led by a board that includes patients and is required to spend funds on patient care and community benefits.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "background",
          "analysis_quote": "Most are private nonprofits, and the rest are run by public entities (such as counties).",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 44 is a shameful power play by one special interest abusing the ballot measure process to gain political leverage over health clinics.",
          "claim": "Proposition 44 was intended to give one special interest political leverage over health clinics.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-44:rebuttal_to_for:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "This same special interest has spent $140 million pushing dozens of harmful ballot measures against hospitals, clinics and physicians, including three unsuccessful dialysis propositions that voters overwhelmingly rejected.",
          "claim": "The special interest associated with Proposition 44 spent $140 million on dozens of ballot measures against hospitals, clinics, and physicians, including three unsuccessful dialysis propositions.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-44:analysis": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
            "vig:prop-44:arguments": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-44:overview",
        "vig:prop-44:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-44:analysis",
        "vig:prop-44:arguments",
        "vig:prop-44:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-44:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "prop-45",
      "contest_id": "prop-45",
      "number": "45",
      "jurisdiction": "state",
      "district": {
        "kind": "statewide",
        "id": "CA"
      },
      "title": "MODIFIES ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW FOR CERTAIN PROJECTS. INITIATIVE STATUTE.",
      "measure_type": "initiative_statute",
      "placed_by": "Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures",
      "summary": "Amends California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) to expedite environmental review for certain projects (including most housing, transportation, water, and health projects) by setting deadlines to complete environmental review and resolve lawsuits challenging project approvals.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Initial costs for state and local governments, likely in the high tens of millions of dollars—potentially exceeding $100 million—annually, partly covered by fees. Uncertain, potentially more significant positive or negative longer-term fiscal effects.",
      "supporters": "California Children’s Hospital Association; California Water Association; California Council for Affordable Housing",
      "opponents": "Coalition for Clean Air; CA Environmental Voters; Physicians for Social Responsibility, LA; National Wildlife Federation",
      "yes_means": "A YES vote on this measure means: Certain public and private projects would be eligible for new project review and court challenge procedures. For example, new procedures would tighten time limits for environmental review and reduce the scope of what courts can consider when reviewing legal challenges.",
      "no_means": "A NO vote on this measure means: Public and private projects would continue to use existing project review and court challenge procedures.",
      "pro_short": "The failing status quo is making California unaffordable. Prop. 45 fixes our broken system and lowers our high cost of living by cutting red tape to build housing, water, schools, hospitals, clean energy, and wildfire prevention faster—while maintaining California’s strong environmental protections. Vote YES for a more affordable California. YESonProp45.com",
      "con_short": "PROPOSITION 45 LIMITS ENVIRONMENTAL AND PUBLIC REVIEW OF PROJECTS BUILT IN YOUR COMMUNITY. It guts The California Environmental Quality Act—flipping California law to protect corporate profits over public health and our air and water. Prop. 45 won’t lower your costs: its utility and corporate funders profit while taxpayers pay more. VOTE NO.",
      "contacts": {
        "for": [
          "YES ON 45—BUILDING A",
          "MORE AFFORDABLE",
          "CALIFORNIA, A COALITION",
          "OF WATER, AFFORDABLE",
          "HOUSING, CLEAN ENERGY,",
          "SMALL BUSINESS,",
          "HEALTHCARE, AND",
          "COMMUNITY LEADERS",
          "info@YesonProp45.com",
          "YESonProp45.com"
        ],
        "against": [
          "No on Prop. 45",
          "555 Capitol Mall, Suite 400",
          "Sacramento, CA 95814",
          "info@Noprop45CA.com",
          "Noprop45CA.com"
        ]
      },
      "contact_links": [
        {
          "label": "info@YesonProp45.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@YesonProp45.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "YESonProp45.com",
          "url": "https://yesonprop45.com/"
        },
        {
          "label": "info@Noprop45CA.com",
          "url": "mailto:info@Noprop45CA.com"
        },
        {
          "label": "Noprop45CA.com",
          "url": "https://www.noprop45ca.com/"
        }
      ],
      "title_summary": [
        "Amends California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) to expedite environmental review for specified project categories (including most housing, transportation, water, health, wildfire mitigation, educational facility, internet access, and clean energy projects). For these types of projects, this measure:",
        "Sets deadlines for public agencies to complete environmental review and take required actions.",
        "Allows expedited review of environmental impacts, limiting public agencies’ current obligation to consider a range of feasible project alternatives to reduce environmental impacts.",
        "Establishes deadlines for filing and resolving lawsuits challenging project approvals; limits evidence courts may consider and relief courts can order.",
        "SUMMARY OF LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S ESTIMATE OF NET STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT FISCAL IMPACT:",
        "Initial costs for state and local governments, likely in the high tens of millions of dollars annually—potentially exceeding $100 million annually—to implement new project review and court challenge procedures for eligible projects. Fees paid by project applicants and people filing lawsuits would partly cover these costs.",
        "In the longer term, uncertain, but potentially more significant positive or negative fiscal effects for state and local governments. The overall effect depends, in part, on how the new procedures change the number of eligible projects that get built and whether those projects have different environmental impacts.",
        "Secretary of State Main Website",
        "Elections & Voter Information",
        "Feedback",
        "Find Your Polling Place",
        "Propositions",
        "Candidates",
        "Justices",
        "Quick Reference Guide",
        "Voter Information",
        "Audio/PDF/Large Print",
        "© California Secretary of State"
      ],
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "background",
          "heading": "BACKGROUND",
          "paragraphs": [
            "State Law Requires Government Agencies to Review the Environmental Impacts of Proposed Projects. State and local government agencies are responsible for reviewing and approving certain projects before they can be built. As part of this process, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires an agency to consider how a project might negatively affect the environment before approving it. CEQA applies to many types of public and private projects, such as housing developments, school facilities, and highway expansions. Some exceptions apply. For example, state law exempts certain housing developments located near public transit from needing a CEQA review.",
            "How the CEQA Process Works. The government agency first determines if CEQA applies to a project. If so, it then determines if the project could significantly affect the environment and if those impacts could be avoided or reduced with minor changes to the project. If making minor changes cannot avoid or reduce significant impacts, the agency must do a more detailed review called an environmental impact report (EIR). (The majority of projects do not require an EIR; however, EIRs are somewhat more common for large and complex projects.) The EIR analyzes possible environmental impacts the project could cause and considers alternatives that could reduce those impacts. After finishing the environmental review, the agency decides whether to approve the project. At certain times during this process, the government agency must seek and consider comments about the project’s environmental review from the public and other government agencies.",
            "People Can Sue the Government Agency About Its CEQA Review. After a government agency has completed the CEQA review and decided whether to approve a project, people who think the agency did not follow the CEQA process correctly can sue the agency. For example, a project opponent might argue that the environmental analysis was inadequate. If the court finds that the agency did not follow CEQA correctly, it can stop the whole project and require the agency to fix the part of the process that was problematic.",
            "Many Projects Also Need to Get Other Approvals. Besides CEQA review, many projects need approval or permits from other local and/or state government agencies before they can proceed. For example, a business that wants to build a health clinic might need the local government to change land use rules before it can proceed. It also may need state agencies to review and approve how the project might affect certain wildlife species and water quality."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "State Law Requires Government Agencies to Review the Environmental Impacts of Proposed Projects",
              "text": "State and local government agencies are responsible for reviewing and approving certain projects before they can be built. As part of this process, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires an agency to consider how a project might negatively affect the environment before approving it. CEQA applies to many types of public and private projects, such as housing developments, school facilities, and highway expansions. Some exceptions apply. For example, state law exempts certain housing developments located near public transit from needing a CEQA review.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": "How the CEQA Process Works",
              "text": "The government agency first determines if CEQA applies to a project. If so, it then determines if the project could significantly affect the environment and if those impacts could be avoided or reduced with minor changes to the project. If making minor changes cannot avoid or reduce significant impacts, the agency must do a more detailed review called an environmental impact report (EIR). (The majority of projects do not require an EIR; however, EIRs are somewhat more common for large and complex projects.) The EIR analyzes possible environmental impacts the project could cause and considers alternatives that could reduce those impacts. After finishing the environmental review, the agency decides whether to approve the project. At certain times during this process, the government agency must seek and consider comments about the project’s environmental review from the public and other government agencies.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": "People Can Sue the Government Agency About Its CEQA Review",
              "text": "After a government agency has completed the CEQA review and decided whether to approve a project, people who think the agency did not follow the CEQA process correctly can sue the agency. For example, a project opponent might argue that the environmental analysis was inadequate. If the court finds that the agency did not follow CEQA correctly, it can stop the whole project and require the agency to fix the part of the process that was problematic.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Many Projects Also Need to Get Other Approvals",
              "text": "Besides CEQA review, many projects need approval or permits from other local and/or state government agencies before they can proceed. For example, a business that wants to build a health clinic might need the local government to change land use rules before it can proceed. It also may need state agencies to review and approve how the project might affect certain wildlife species and water quality.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "proposal",
          "heading": "PROPOSAL",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Proposition 45 creates new procedures for reviewing certain types of projects that it defines as “essential.” Figure 1 lists the types of projects eligible for the new procedures. The proposition (1) tightens time limits for CEQA review, permits, and court challenges; (2) changes parts of the CEQA review process; and (3) changes the court’s review process for CEQA lawsuits. The proposition gives eligible project applicants the option of using the new procedures or existing procedures.",
            "Types of Projects Eligible to Use Proposition 45’s New Procedures • Housing. • Water system (not including Delta conveyance facilities). • Clean energy (not including nuclear power). • Health facility, clinic, and medical office building. • Fire, police, and sheriff’s stations. • Wildfire risk reduction. • Broadband Internet access. • Education facility. • Transportation (not including high-speed rail).",
            "Tightens Time Limits for Review and Court Challenges of Eligible Projects. Proposition 45 creates more binding time limits for state and local governments to do both CEQA and permitting reviews. This includes time limits for determining if a project application is complete, finishing the EIR, and granting other types of approvals and permits. For example, Proposition 45 allows an applicant to request an agency hearing— and potentially file a lawsuit with the courts—if an agency does not meet the 365-business-day time limit for finishing the EIR. The proposition also creates a time limit for courts to resolve legal challenges.",
            "Changes CEQA Review for Eligible Projects. For eligible projects, Proposition 45 makes several changes to the CEQA review process, including:",
            "Application Process. Requires the government agency to specify all information that must be included in an application before it is submitted. (Current law allows agencies to repeatedly request additional information or project changes.)",
            "How Environmental Impacts Are Assessed. Requires the agency to assess potential environmental impacts based on the laws and standards in place at the time the project application is submitted. (Current law lets the agency consider new information and revise its review standards when doing the EIR.)",
            "Project Alternatives. Allows the applicant to develop only one project alternative for the agency to consider. (Current law requires the agency—not the applicant—to develop and consider multiple project alternatives that could reduce environmental impacts.)",
            "Consultation With Native Tribes. Requires the agency and applicant to consult about the project only with California native tribes that have been formally recognized by the federal government. (Current law requires consultation with a wider range of tribes.)",
            "Public Comment Periods. Limits how long the agency can accept comments from the public and other government agencies about the project. (Current law sets a minimum number of days—not a maximum—for public review.)",
            "Changes How Courts Review Challenges to Eligible Projects. Proposition 45 makes several changes to the court’s review process when someone challenges a government agency’s approval of an eligible project. For example, it reduces the scope of what the court can consider in CEQA lawsuits. The proposition also prevents the court from stopping the whole project if it finds that the agency did not follow CEQA correctly. Instead, the court can only stop the part of the project where the environmental review did not comply with CEQA while the agency fixes the problem."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition 45 creates new procedures for reviewing certain types of projects that it defines as “essential.” Figure 1 lists the types of projects eligible for the new procedures. The proposition (1) tightens time limits for CEQA review, permits, and court challenges; (2) changes parts of the CEQA review process; and (3) changes the court’s review process for CEQA lawsuits. The proposition gives eligible project applicants the option of using the new procedures or existing procedures.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Types of Projects Eligible to Use Proposition 45’s New Procedures • Housing. • Water system (not including Delta conveyance facilities). • Clean energy (not including nuclear power). • Health facility, clinic, and medical office building. • Fire, police, and sheriff’s stations. • Wildfire risk reduction. • Broadband Internet access. • Education facility. • Transportation (not including high-speed rail).",
              "kind": "figure",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Tightens Time Limits for Review and Court Challenges of Eligible Projects",
              "text": "Proposition 45 creates more binding time limits for state and local governments to do both CEQA and permitting reviews. This includes time limits for determining if a project application is complete, finishing the EIR, and granting other types of approvals and permits. For example, Proposition 45 allows an applicant to request an agency hearing— and potentially file a lawsuit with the courts—if an agency does not meet the 365-business-day time limit for finishing the EIR. The proposition also creates a time limit for courts to resolve legal challenges.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Changes CEQA Review for Eligible Projects",
              "text": "For eligible projects, Proposition 45 makes several changes to the CEQA review process, including:",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Application Process. Requires the government agency to specify all information that must be included in an application before it is submitted. (Current law allows agencies to repeatedly request additional information or project changes.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "How Environmental Impacts Are Assessed. Requires the agency to assess potential environmental impacts based on the laws and standards in place at the time the project application is submitted. (Current law lets the agency consider new information and revise its review standards when doing the EIR.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Project Alternatives. Allows the applicant to develop only one project alternative for the agency to consider. (Current law requires the agency—not the applicant—to develop and consider multiple project alternatives that could reduce environmental impacts.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Consultation With Native Tribes. Requires the agency and applicant to consult about the project only with California native tribes that have been formally recognized by the federal government. (Current law requires consultation with a wider range of tribes.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Public Comment Periods. Limits how long the agency can accept comments from the public and other government agencies about the project. (Current law sets a minimum number of days—not a maximum—for public review.)",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": "Changes How Courts Review Challenges to Eligible Projects",
              "text": "Proposition 45 makes several changes to the court’s review process when someone challenges a government agency’s approval of an eligible project. For example, it reduces the scope of what the court can consider in CEQA lawsuits. The proposition also prevents the court from stopping the whole project if it finds that the agency did not follow CEQA correctly. Instead, the court can only stop the part of the project where the environmental review did not comply with CEQA while the agency fixes the problem.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "heading": "FISCAL EFFECTS",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Initial Costs for State and Local Governments. During the first several years, Proposition 45 likely would increase costs for the state and local governments, including state courts. These costs likely would be in the high tens of millions of dollars annually, potentially exceeding $100 million annually. For example, state and local governments would have costs to develop new guidelines and standards for reviewing eligible projects’ environmental impacts, meet tighter time limits, and address court challenges. Fees paid by project applicants and people filing lawsuits would cover some of these costs. After this initial period, while some costs could continue, others likely would decline over time. For example, the changes to how courts can review CEQA lawsuits could mean fewer people will sue in the future, which could reduce costs for agencies and state courts in the long term.",
            "In the Longer Term, Uncertain but Potentially More Significant Fiscal Effects. Proposition 45’s changes to project review and court challenge procedures for eligible projects could have various fiscal effects for state and local governments. The overall fiscal effect of these changes—positive or negative—is uncertain but could be more substantial than the near-term effects. For example, two effects that could have significant but uncertain impacts are:",
            "More Projects and Faster Timing. To the degree that Proposition 45’s changes to project review and court challenge procedures lead to eligible public projects being constructed more quickly, state and local governments likely would have lower project costs. Additionally, if the proposition’s changes result in more projects being completed overall, it could lead to an increase in tax revenues, such as from property taxes.",
            "Negative Environmental Impacts. To the degree that Proposition 45’s changes to project review and court challenge procedures lead to approval of projects with negative environmental impacts that would not have otherwise occurred, government agencies could face higher costs to respond to those impacts."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": "Initial Costs for State and Local Governments",
              "text": "During the first several years, Proposition 45 likely would increase costs for the state and local governments, including state courts. These costs likely would be in the high tens of millions of dollars annually, potentially exceeding $100 million annually. For example, state and local governments would have costs to develop new guidelines and standards for reviewing eligible projects’ environmental impacts, meet tighter time limits, and address court challenges. Fees paid by project applicants and people filing lawsuits would cover some of these costs. After this initial period, while some costs could continue, others likely would decline over time. For example, the changes to how courts can review CEQA lawsuits could mean fewer people will sue in the future, which could reduce costs for agencies and state courts in the long term.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": "In the Longer Term, Uncertain but Potentially More Significant Fiscal Effects",
              "text": "Proposition 45’s changes to project review and court challenge procedures for eligible projects could have various fiscal effects for state and local governments. The overall fiscal effect of these changes—positive or negative—is uncertain but could be more substantial than the near-term effects. For example, two effects that could have significant but uncertain impacts are:",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "More Projects and Faster Timing. To the degree that Proposition 45’s changes to project review and court challenge procedures lead to eligible public projects being constructed more quickly, state and local governments likely would have lower project costs. Additionally, if the proposition’s changes result in more projects being completed overall, it could lead to an increase in tax revenues, such as from property taxes.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Negative Environmental Impacts. To the degree that Proposition 45’s changes to project review and court challenge procedures lead to approval of projects with negative environmental impacts that would not have otherwise occurred, government agencies could face higher costs to respond to those impacts.",
              "kind": "text",
              "source_sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622"
            }
          ],
          "notes": [
            "Visit sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions/2026-ballot-measure-contribution-totals for a list of committees primarily formed to support or oppose this measure.",
            "Visit fppc.ca.gov/transparency/top-contributors.html to access the committee's top 10 contributors."
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROPOSITION 45 WON’T LOWER YOUR COSTS.",
            "It doesn’t require a single project to lower your rent, your mortgage, or your utility bills. 45’s corporate funders profit while you bear the cost of their pollution.",
            "PROP. 45 DOESN’T DELIVER AN AFFORDABLE CALIFORNIA. IT LIMITS ENVIRONMENTAL AND PUBLIC REVIEW AND RISKS PUBLIC HEALTH.",
            "Prop. 45 could have been about building what California needs. It isn’t. Funded by gas and electric utilities and corporate PACs, Prop. 45 cuts their costs, not yours. Prop. 45 flips California law to protect their projects, harming public health and our air and water.",
            "PROP. 45 PUTS YOUR HEALTH AT RISK AND STICKS YOU WITH THE BILL. Weaker environmental review means more pollution near homes and schools, more asthma and more emergency-room visits. When polluters don’t clean up, taxpayers and ratepayers pay more to cover the costs.",
            "PROP. 45 TAKES AWAY PUBLIC INPUT. It limits the environmental review of new projects and your right to provide input and be heard. 45 even gives developers new rights to challenge cities and counties, while making it more difficult for project opponents to successfully challenge an agency’s decision.",
            "Prop. 45 rewrites the rules that govern how California protects its citizens from the harm caused by major developments. Prop. 45 weakens environmental safeguards and radically shifts power to corporate polluters.",
            "Protect your air quality, your drinking water, your family’s health, your tax dollars, and your right to be heard.",
            "Join nurses, community and public health advocates.",
            "VOTE NO ON PROP. 45.",
            "www.NoProp45CA.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Chris Tarver, R.N., President",
            "American Nurses Association, CA",
            "Vanessa Forsythe, RN",
            "California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice",
            "Martha Arguello, Executive Director",
            "Physicians for Social Responsibility, LA"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Chris Tarver",
              "title": "R.N., President",
              "organization": "American Nurses Association, CA"
            },
            {
              "name": "Vanessa Forsythe",
              "title": "RN",
              "organization": "California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice"
            },
            {
              "name": "Martha Arguello",
              "title": "Executive Director",
              "organization": "Physicians for Social Responsibility, LA"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROP. 45 IS THE CHANGE WE NEED TO BUILD A MORE AFFORDABLE CALIFORNIA.",
            "The status quo is failing California. Families cannot afford to live here because we’re failing to deliver the basics. Endless delays, lawsuits and red tape are driving up the cost of essentials—housing, water, electricity, schools, roads, healthcare and wildfire protection.",
            "We have a choice: accept the failing status quo—or fix it. PROP. 45 FIXES OUR BROKEN PROJECT APPROVAL SYSTEM by eliminating unnecessary delays for essential projects—lowering our cost of living and improving our quality of life.",
            "PROP. 45’s OPPONENTS ARE MISLEADING VOTERS TO PROTECT THE BROKEN STATUS QUO.",
            "The same opponents fighting Prop. 45 have spent decades using these same scare tactics to block even modest reforms. They’re fighting to preserve the broken status quo that’s making California unaffordable and lowering our quality of life.",
            "WE DON’T HAVE TO CHOOSE BETWEEN PROTECTING THE ENVIRONMENT AND BUILDING ESSENTIAL PROJECTS.",
            "FACT: Prop. 45 maintains every federal, state and local environmental law protecting our air, water, wildlife, and public health, including the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act.",
            "FACT: Prop. 45 does not eliminate a single environmental law or exempt a single project from environmental review.",
            "FACT: Communities keep their voice. Residents maintain their right to provide public comments, oppose projects, and sue to stop projects.",
            "FACT: Prop. 45 only applies to essential projects: water, hospitals, housing, schools, roads, transit, clean energy, and wildfire prevention.",
            "THE CHOICE IS SIMPLE: accept the broken status quo—or fix it.",
            "VOTE YES ON PROP. 45 TO BUILD A MORE AFFORDABLE CALIFORNIA."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Ann-Louise Kuhns, President",
            "California Children’s Hospital Association",
            "Ruben Grijalva, Former California State Fire Marshal",
            "CAL FIRE",
            "Robert Rivinius, President",
            "Family Business Association of California"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Ann-Louise Kuhns",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Children’s Hospital Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Ruben Grijalva",
              "title": "Former California State Fire Marshal",
              "organization": "CAL FIRE"
            },
            {
              "name": "Robert Rivinius",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Family Business Association of California"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
        },
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "LENGTHY DELAYS AND RED TAPE ARE BLOCKING ESSENTIAL PROJECTS & DRIVING UP OUR COST OF LIVING.",
            "Families cannot afford to live in California because we are failing to deliver the basics. California’s outdated system for approving essential housing, water, clean energy, roads, schools, hospitals, and wildfire prevention projects is too slow, too bureaucratic, and too costly—driving up the cost of living for everyone.",
            "Endless delays, red tape, and frivolous lawsuits make life more expensive and block the projects Californians need—driving up costs for housing, electricity, and water; wasting taxpayer dollars; worsening wildfire risk; increasing traffic; overcrowding schools; and delaying hospital and infrastructure upgrades.",
            "PROP. 45 LOWERS OUR HIGH COST OF LIVING BY MAKING IT FASTER & LESS EXPENSIVE TO BUILD ESSENTIAL PROJECTS.",
            "Prop. 45 streamlines approvals by setting enforceable timelines for project approvals; requires courts and government agencies to base decisions on the laws and regulations in place when the project application is submitted; and creates a faster, more predictable process for legal challenges while reducing frivolous lawsuits.",
            "PROP. 45 STREAMLINES CALIFORNIA’S MOST-PRESSING ESSENTIAL PROJECTS, INCLUDING:",
            "• Water quality and supply projects • Hospitals and healthcare facilities • Housing, including homes and apartments • Wildfire prevention • Schools and classrooms • Roads, bridges and transit • Clean energy and electric grid reliability infrastructure",
            "PROP. 45 WILL:",
            "REDUCE THE COST OF HOUSING. Permitting delays add more than $75,000 to the cost of a new home. Prop. 45 will help lower rents and mortgages and save families tens of thousands of dollars on a home purchase.",
            "LOWER ELECTRICITY COSTS. Delays in building clean energy and electric grid infrastructure drive up electricity costs for working families. Prop. 45 helps lower electricity costs.",
            "PROTECT TAXPAYERS. Lengthy delays drive massive cost overruns on public projects—roads, schools, hospitals, water systems, and wildfire prevention—costing taxpayers billions more. Prop. 45 cuts costly delays, reduces costs, and helps keep projects on time and on budget.",
            "CREATE GOOD-PAYING JOBS AND STRENGTHEN OUR ECONOMY. Prop. 45 will create tens of thousands of good-paying jobs and billions in economic activity.",
            "PROP. 45 MAINTAINS CALIFORNIA’S STRONGEST-IN-THE-NATION ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONS.",
            "California should not have to choose between protecting the environment and building the essential projects we need. Under Prop. 45, projects must comply with all of California strong environmental laws protecting our air, water, wildlife, and health. Prop. 45 does not exempt a single project from environmental review.",
            "PROP. 45 PROTECTS COMMUNITY INPUT AND LOCAL DECISION MAKING.",
            "Under Prop. 45, cities and counties retain full authority to approve or deny projects, and residents keep a meaningful voice in decisions affecting their communities.",
            "AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVOCATES, HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS, EDUCATORS, WATER PROVIDERS, CLEAN ENERGY LEADERS AND CIVIL RIGHTS LEADERS SUPPORT PROP. 45.",
            "Prop. 45 is supported by a broad coalition of organizations, including:",
            "• American Clean Power—California • California League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) • NAACP California/Hawaii State Conference • California Taxpayers Association • Environmental Policy Innovation Center",
            "YES ON PROP. 45 TO BUILD A MORE AFFORDABLE CALIFORNIA.",
            "Every year of delay means Californians wait longer and pay more for the essential projects we need. It’s time to cut red tape, protect our environment and build the projects California needs to make life more affordable.",
            "VOTE YES ON PROP. 45.",
            "YESonProp45.com"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Ann-Louise Kuhns, President",
            "California Children’s Hospital Association",
            "Jennifer Capitolo, Executive Director",
            "California Water Association",
            "Jenna Abbott, Executive Director",
            "California Council on Affordable Housing"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Ann-Louise Kuhns",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "California Children’s Hospital Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Jennifer Capitolo",
              "title": "Executive Director",
              "organization": "California Water Association"
            },
            {
              "name": "Jenna Abbott",
              "title": "Executive Director",
              "organization": "California Council on Affordable Housing"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROPOSITION 45 LIMITS ENVIRONMENTAL AND PUBLIC REVIEW OF PROJECTS BUILT IN YOUR COMMUNITY. VOTE NO ON PROP. 45 TO PROTECT WATER, AIR QUALITY AND PUBLIC HEALTH.",
            "Proposition 45 limits both the environmental review of major new development projects and the public’s right to be heard. Prop. 45 lets projects move forward with far less scrutiny of their harms to air, water and public health.",
            "PROP. 45 WEAKENS CRITICAL PROTECTIONS FOR AIR AND WATER QUALITY BY GUTTING THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT (CEQA).",
            "CEQA is California’s most important air and water quality protection law. It requires public agencies to identify, publicly disclose, and consider reducing harm to air, water, and wildlife before approving projects. Prop. 45 eliminates many of CEQA’s existing protections— letting developers fast-track the polluting projects you don’t want next door, with fewer protections for the water you drink and air you breathe.",
            "PROP. 45 CUTS THE PUBLIC OUT OF DECISIONS THAT AFFECT YOUR FAMILY.",
            "Today, you have a voice in what’s built near you and your family. Prop. 45 reduces public agency requirements to consider public comments on proposed projects—comments that often expose potential contamination of air and water, and damage to our coast, rivers, and wildlife. If Prop. 45 passes, decisions about what gets built near your home, your children’s school, and your water supply would be made with less information and less public input. Prop. 45 reduces your ability to protect your family and community from harm.",
            "We need CEQA’s protections more than ever since federal protections have been weakened.",
            "THEY POLLUTE. YOU PAY.",
            "The nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office warns Prop. 45 could approve projects that result in “unintended negative environmental impacts.” When corporations aren’t required to reduce their pollution, taxpayers get stuck paying to clean up cancer-causing chemicals from our drinking water and contaminated lands.",
            "PROP. 45 WON’T LOWER YOUR COSTS.",
            "Prop. 45 doesn’t include any requirement to lower your housing costs or your utility bills. The corporations paying for Prop. 45 will profit while you keep paying.",
            "WHO’S BEHIND PROP. 45?",
            "Prop. 45 was written by the California Chamber of Commerce and financed by gas and electric utilities and corporate PACs. It gives the polluters and corporations funding Prop. 45 greater freedom to put whatever they want next to your home. Your family’s health and environmental quality are more important than corporate profits.",
            "JOIN A BROAD COALITION OF PUBLIC HEALTH, ENVIRONMENTAL, AND COMMUNITY GROUPS OPPOSING PROP. 45, INCLUDING:",
            "• National Wildlife Federation • California Communities Against Toxics • California Environmental Voters • California Environmental Justice Alliance • California Nurses for Environmental Health & Justice • Clean Water Action • Coalition for Clean Air • Physicians for Social Responsibility—Los Angeles",
            "Whether you’re a Democrat, a Republican, or an independent, vote NO on Prop. 45 to protect your air and water, your tax dollars, and your right to be heard.",
            "VOTE NO on Prop. 45.",
            "www.NoProp45CA.com."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Joe Lyou, President",
            "Coalition for Clean Air",
            "Jennifer Clary, California Director",
            "Clean Water Action",
            "Matt Abularach-Macias, Political Director",
            "California Environmental Voters"
          ],
          "signer_entries": [
            {
              "name": "Joe Lyou",
              "title": "President",
              "organization": "Coalition for Clean Air"
            },
            {
              "name": "Jennifer Clary",
              "title": "California Director",
              "organization": "Clean Water Action"
            },
            {
              "name": "Matt Abularach-Macias",
              "title": "Political Director",
              "organization": "California Environmental Voters"
            }
          ],
          "signer_block_in_markup": true,
          "source_sha256": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
        }
      },
      "links": [
        {
          "label": "Official Voter Information Guide",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/45/"
        },
        {
          "label": "Analysis by the Legislative Analyst",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/45/analysis.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "LAO analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop45-110326.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Arguments and rebuttals",
          "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/45/arguments-rebuttals.htm"
        },
        {
          "label": "Text of proposed law (PDF)",
          "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop45-text-proposed-laws.pdf"
        },
        {
          "label": "Committees formed to support or oppose (Secretary of State)",
          "url": "https://www.sos.ca.gov/campaign-lobbying/cal-access-resources/measure-contributions"
        }
      ],
      "vote_threshold": null,
      "vote_threshold_missing_reason": "The voter guide overview does not state the vote threshold.",
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "claims": [
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "LENGTHY DELAYS AND RED TAPE ARE BLOCKING ESSENTIAL PROJECTS & DRIVING UP OUR COST OF LIVING.",
          "claim": "Lengthy delays and red tape block essential projects.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Families cannot afford to live in California because we are failing to deliver the basics.",
          "claim": "California families cannot afford to live in the state because basic needs are not being delivered.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.87,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California’s outdated system for approving essential housing, water, clean energy, roads, schools, hospitals, and wildfire prevention projects is too slow, too bureaucratic, and too costly—driving up the cost of living for everyone.",
          "claim": "California's approval system for the listed projects is too costly.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.79,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "California’s outdated system for approving essential housing, water, clean energy, roads, schools, hospitals, and wildfire prevention projects is too slow, too bureaucratic, and too costly—driving up the cost of living for everyone.",
          "claim": "California's approval system for the listed projects is too slow.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Endless delays, red tape, and frivolous lawsuits make life more expensive and block the projects Californians need—driving up costs for housing, electricity, and water; wasting taxpayer dollars; worsening wildfire risk; increasing traffic; overcrowding schools; and delaying hospital and infrastructure upgrades.",
          "claim": "Delays, red tape, and frivolous lawsuits increase housing, electricity, and water costs.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "wasting taxpayer dollars",
          "claim": "Delays, red tape, and frivolous lawsuits waste taxpayer money.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "worsening wildfire risk",
          "claim": "Delays, red tape, and frivolous lawsuits worsen wildfire risk.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:8",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "increasing traffic",
          "claim": "Delays, red tape, and frivolous lawsuits increase traffic.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:9",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "overcrowding schools",
          "claim": "Delays, red tape, and frivolous lawsuits overcrowd schools.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:10",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "delaying hospital and infrastructure upgrades.",
          "claim": "Delays, red tape, and frivolous lawsuits delay hospital and infrastructure upgrades.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:11",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 45 LOWERS OUR HIGH COST OF LIVING BY MAKING IT FASTER & LESS EXPENSIVE TO BUILD ESSENTIAL PROJECTS.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 will lower the cost of living by making essential projects faster and less expensive to build.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "To the degree that Proposition 45’s changes to project review and court challenge procedures lead to eligible public projects being constructed more quickly, state and local governments likely would have lower project costs.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:12",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 streamlines approvals by setting enforceable timelines for project approvals;",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 sets enforceable timelines for project approvals.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 45 creates more binding time limits for state and local governments to do both CEQA and permitting reviews.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:13",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "requires courts and government agencies to base decisions on the laws and regulations in place when the project application is submitted;",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 requires courts and agencies to use laws and regulations in effect when an application is submitted.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Requires the agency to assess potential environmental impacts based on the laws and standards in place at the time the project application is submitted.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:14",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "creates a faster, more predictable process for legal challenges while reducing frivolous lawsuits.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 creates a faster process for legal challenges.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The proposition also creates a time limit for courts to resolve legal challenges.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:15",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "reducing frivolous lawsuits.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 will reduce frivolous lawsuits.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.77,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:16",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "• Water quality and supply projects • Hospitals and healthcare facilities • Housing, including homes and apartments • Wildfire prevention • Schools and classrooms • Roads, bridges and transit • Clean energy and electric grid reliability infrastructure",
          "claim": "The measure streamlines the listed project types.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Types of Projects Eligible to Use Proposition 45’s New Procedures • Housing. • Water system (not including Delta conveyance facilities). • Clean energy (not including nuclear power). • Health facility, clinic, and medical office building. • Fire, police, and sheriff’s stations. • Wildfire risk reduction. • Broadband Internet access. • Education facility. • Transportation (not including high-speed rail).",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:17",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Permitting delays add more than $75,000 to the cost of a new home.",
          "claim": "Permitting delays add more than $75,000 to the cost of a new home.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:18",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 will help lower rents and mortgages and save families tens of thousands of dollars on a home purchase.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 will help lower rents and mortgages.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:19",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Delays in building clean energy and electric grid infrastructure drive up electricity costs for working families.",
          "claim": "Delays in clean-energy and grid infrastructure increase electricity costs for working families.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:20",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 helps lower electricity costs.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 will help lower electricity costs.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:21",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Lengthy delays drive massive cost overruns on public projects—roads, schools, hospitals, water systems, and wildfire prevention—costing taxpayers billions more.",
          "claim": "Lengthy delays cause massive cost overruns on the listed public projects and cost taxpayers billions more.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.83,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:22",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 cuts costly delays, reduces costs, and helps keep projects on time and on budget.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 will cut delays, reduce costs, and help keep projects on time and on budget.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "The overall fiscal effect of these changes—positive or negative—is uncertain but could be more substantial than the near-term effects.",
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:23",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 will create tens of thousands of good-paying jobs and billions in economic activity.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 will create tens of thousands of good-paying jobs and billions in economic activity.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:24",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "PROP. 45 MAINTAINS CALIFORNIA’S STRONGEST-IN-THE-NATION ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONS.",
          "claim": "California has the nation's strongest environmental protections, and Proposition 45 maintains them.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:25",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "projects must comply with all of California strong environmental laws protecting our air, water, wildlife, and health.",
          "claim": "Projects under Proposition 45 must comply with all California environmental laws protecting air, water, wildlife, and health.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "For eligible projects, Proposition 45 makes several changes to the CEQA review process, including:",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:26",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 does not exempt a single project from environmental review.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 does not exempt any project from environmental review.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The proposition (1) tightens time limits for CEQA review, permits, and court challenges; (2) changes parts of the CEQA review process; and (3) changes the court’s review process for CEQA lawsuits.",
          "confidence": 0.79,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:27",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "cities and counties retain full authority to approve or deny projects,",
          "claim": "Cities and counties retain full authority to approve or deny projects under Proposition 45.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.72,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_for:28",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "argument_for",
          "quote": "residents keep a meaningful voice in decisions affecting their communities.",
          "claim": "Residents retain a meaningful voice in decisions affecting their communities under Proposition 45.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_against:1",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "Endless delays, lawsuits and red tape are driving up the cost of essentials—housing, water, electricity, schools, roads, healthcare and wildfire protection.",
          "claim": "Delays, lawsuits, and red tape increase the costs of the listed essentials.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_against:2",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 45 FIXES OUR BROKEN PROJECT APPROVAL SYSTEM by eliminating unnecessary delays for essential projects—lowering our cost of living and improving our quality of life.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 eliminates unnecessary delays for essential projects.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The proposition gives eligible project applicants the option of using the new procedures or existing procedures.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_against:3",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "PROP. 45 FIXES OUR BROKEN PROJECT APPROVAL SYSTEM by eliminating unnecessary delays for essential projects—lowering our cost of living and improving our quality of life.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 will lower the cost of living and improve quality of life.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_against:4",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "FACT: Prop. 45 maintains every federal, state and local environmental law protecting our air, water, wildlife, and public health, including the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 maintains every federal, state, and local environmental law protecting air, water, wildlife, and public health.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 45 makes several changes to the CEQA review process, including:",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_against:5",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "FACT: Prop. 45 does not eliminate a single environmental law or exempt a single project from environmental review.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 does not eliminate any environmental law or exempt any project from environmental review.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The proposition (1) tightens time limits for CEQA review, permits, and court challenges; (2) changes parts of the CEQA review process; and (3) changes the court’s review process for CEQA lawsuits.",
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": {
            "from_label": "supported_by_analysis",
            "to_label": "context_missing",
            "reason": "The cited passage says the measure tightens CEQA time limits and changes the review and court processes. It says nothing about eliminating laws or exempting projects, so it does not support the claim; the changes it lists are context the claim omits.",
            "reviewed_by": "agent s11-claims (Claude), PR #37 follow-up",
            "reviewed_at": "2026-10-08"
          },
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_against:6",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "FACT: Communities keep their voice. Residents maintain their right to provide public comments, oppose projects, and sue to stop projects.",
          "claim": "Residents retain the right to provide public comments, oppose projects, and sue to stop projects.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Limits how long the agency can accept comments from the public and other government agencies about the project. (Current law sets a minimum number of days—not a maximum—for public review.)",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_against:7",
          "side": "yes",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_against",
          "quote": "FACT: Prop. 45 only applies to essential projects: water, hospitals, housing, schools, roads, transit, clean energy, and wildfire prevention.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 applies only to the listed essential project types.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Types of Projects Eligible to Use Proposition 45’s New Procedures • Housing. • Water system (not including Delta conveyance facilities). • Clean energy (not including nuclear power). • Health facility, clinic, and medical office building. • Fire, police, and sheriff’s stations. • Wildfire risk reduction. • Broadband Internet access. • Education facility. • Transportation (not including high-speed rail).",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Proposition 45 limits both the environmental review of major new development projects and the public’s right to be heard.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 limits environmental review and public participation for major new development projects.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Public Comment Periods. Limits how long the agency can accept comments from the public and other government agencies about the project.",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 lets projects move forward with far less scrutiny of their harms to air, water and public health.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 allows projects to proceed with substantially less scrutiny of harms to air, water, and public health.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "For eligible projects, Proposition 45 makes several changes to the CEQA review process, including:",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "CEQA is California’s most important air and water quality protection law.",
          "claim": "CEQA is California's most important air and water quality protection law.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 eliminates many of CEQA’s existing protections— letting developers fast-track the polluting projects you don’t want next door, with fewer protections for the water you drink and air you breathe.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 eliminates many existing CEQA protections.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "For eligible projects, Proposition 45 makes several changes to the CEQA review process, including:",
          "confidence": 0.89,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "letting developers fast-track the polluting projects you don’t want next door",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 lets developers fast-track polluting projects near residents.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 reduces public agency requirements to consider public comments on proposed projects",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 reduces agencies' requirements to consider public comments on proposed projects.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Limits how long the agency can accept comments from the public and other government agencies about the project.",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "If Prop. 45 passes, decisions about what gets built near your home, your children’s school, and your water supply would be made with less information and less public input.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 would result in project decisions made with less information and public input.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Allows the applicant to develop only one project alternative for the agency to consider. (Current law requires the agency—not the applicant—to develop and consider multiple project alternatives that could reduce environmental impacts.)",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "We need CEQA’s protections more than ever since federal protections have been weakened.",
          "claim": "Federal protections have been weakened.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "The nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office warns Prop. 45 could approve projects that result in “unintended negative environmental impacts.”",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 could lead to approval of projects with unintended negative environmental impacts.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "To the degree that Proposition 45’s changes to project review and court challenge procedures lead to approval of projects with negative environmental impacts that would not have otherwise occurred, government agencies could face higher costs to respond to those impacts.",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "When corporations aren’t required to reduce their pollution, taxpayers get stuck paying to clean up cancer-causing chemicals from our drinking water and contaminated lands.",
          "claim": "When corporations are not required to reduce pollution, taxpayers pay to clean up cancer-causing chemicals in drinking water and contaminated land.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "government agencies could face higher costs to respond to those impacts.",
          "confidence": 0.83,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 doesn’t include any requirement to lower your housing costs or your utility bills.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 does not require lower housing costs or utility bills.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The proposition (1) tightens time limits for CEQA review, permits, and court challenges; (2) changes parts of the CEQA review process; and (3) changes the court’s review process for CEQA lawsuits.",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "The corporations paying for Prop. 45 will profit",
          "claim": "Corporations paying for Proposition 45 will profit from it.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 was written by the California Chamber of Commerce",
          "claim": "The California Chamber of Commerce wrote Proposition 45.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "financed by gas and electric utilities and corporate PACs.",
          "claim": "Gas and electric utilities and corporate political action committees finance Proposition 45.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:argument_against:15",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "argument_against",
          "quote": "It gives the polluters and corporations funding Prop. 45 greater freedom to put whatever they want next to your home.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 gives its corporate and polluter funders greater freedom to build projects next to homes.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The proposition gives eligible project applicants the option of using the new procedures or existing procedures.",
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:1",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It doesn’t require a single project to lower your rent, your mortgage, or your utility bills.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 does not require any project to lower rent, mortgage, or utility bills.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "The proposition (1) tightens time limits for CEQA review, permits, and court challenges; (2) changes parts of the CEQA review process; and (3) changes the court’s review process for CEQA lawsuits.",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
            "agrees": true
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:2",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "45’s corporate funders profit while you bear the cost of their pollution.",
          "claim": "People bear the cost of pollution from Proposition 45's corporate funders.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:3",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "45’s corporate funders profit while you bear the cost of their pollution.",
          "claim": "Corporate funders of Proposition 45 profit from it.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:4",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 could have been about building what California needs. It isn’t.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 was not written to build what California needs.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:5",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Funded by gas and electric utilities and corporate PACs,",
          "claim": "Gas and electric utilities and corporate political action committees fund Proposition 45.",
          "question": "financing",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "committee_filings",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:6",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 cuts their costs, not yours.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 reduces the costs of gas and electric utilities and corporate political action committees rather than voters' costs.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:7",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 flips California law to protect their projects, harming public health and our air and water.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 was written to protect the projects of its funders.",
          "question": "intent",
          "assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "needs_source": "proponent_statements",
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_assessable_here",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:8",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "harming public health and our air and water.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 will harm public health, air, and water.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "fiscal-effects",
          "analysis_quote": "To the degree that Proposition 45’s changes to project review and court challenge procedures lead to approval of projects with negative environmental impacts that would not have otherwise occurred, government agencies could face higher costs to respond to those impacts.",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:9",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Weaker environmental review means more pollution near homes and schools, more asthma and more emergency-room visits.",
          "claim": "Weaker environmental review will cause more pollution near homes and schools, asthma, and emergency-room visits.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:10",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "When polluters don’t clean up, taxpayers and ratepayers pay more to cover the costs.",
          "claim": "When polluters do not clean up, taxpayers and ratepayers pay more.",
          "question": "fiscal_effect",
          "assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "not_addressed_by_analysis",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:11",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "It limits the environmental review of new projects and your right to provide input and be heard.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 limits environmental review of new projects and public input rights.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Public Comment Periods. Limits how long the agency can accept comments from the public and other government agencies about the project.",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "supported_by_analysis",
          "check": {
            "checked_by": {
              "provider": "codex-cli",
              "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
              "thinking": "medium",
              "prompt_version": "measure-claims-check-prompt/v2"
            },
            "assessment": "context_missing",
            "agrees": false
          },
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:12",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "45 even gives developers new rights to challenge cities and counties, while making it more difficult for project opponents to successfully challenge an agency’s decision.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 gives developers new rights to challenge cities and counties.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Proposition 45 allows an applicant to request an agency hearing— and potentially file a lawsuit with the courts—if an agency does not meet the 365-business-day time limit for finishing the EIR.",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:13",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "Prop. 45 weakens environmental safeguards",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 weakens environmental safeguards.",
          "question": "legal_effect",
          "assessment": "context_missing",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": "proposal",
          "analysis_quote": "Project Alternatives. Allows the applicant to develop only one project alternative for the agency to consider. (Current law requires the agency—not the applicant—to develop and consider multiple project alternatives that could reduce environmental impacts.)",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "context_missing",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "prop-45:rebuttal_to_for:14",
          "side": "no",
          "source_role": "rebuttal_to_for",
          "quote": "radically shifts power to corporate polluters.",
          "claim": "Proposition 45 radically shifts power to corporate polluters.",
          "question": "other",
          "assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "needs_source": null,
          "analysis_section_id": null,
          "analysis_quote": null,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "method": {
            "provider": "codex-cli",
            "model": "gpt-5.6-terra",
            "thinking": "medium",
            "prompt_version": "measure-claims-prompt/v4"
          },
          "evidence_versions": {
            "vig:prop-45:analysis": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
            "vig:prop-45:arguments": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5"
          },
          "evidence_date": "2026-10-07",
          "review_status": "unreviewed",
          "first_pass_assessment": "opinion_or_prediction",
          "check": null,
          "label_rule": null,
          "label_override": null,
          "stale": false
        }
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "vig:prop-45:overview",
        "vig:prop-45:title_summary",
        "vig:prop-45:analysis",
        "vig:prop-45:arguments",
        "vig:prop-45:legal_text",
        "vig:prop-45:legal_text:text"
      ],
      "tier": "T2"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-ptrmd-rtm",
      "letter": "RTM",
      "jurisdiction": "special_district",
      "jurisdiction_name": "Public Transit Revenue Measure District",
      "district": {
        "kind": "county",
        "id": "santa-clara"
      },
      "title": "Regional Transit Measure",
      "measure_type": "regional_initiative",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "San Francisco depends on public transit to keep the city livable, power our economy, and connect neighborhoods. Strong transit supports local businesses, reduces congestion, improves air quality, and ensures everyone can get where they need to go affordably – families, seniors, people with disabilities, students, and workers.",
            "Today, Bay Area transit faces a turning point. Without new funding from the Regional Transit Measure, we will experience significant and deep cuts to Muni, BART, and Caltrain – setting us back decades.",
            "Without this measure, Muni could cut service by at least 30%, cancel at least 20 bus routes, end regular evening service, eliminate cable car service, and reduce fare discounts for vulnerable populations. BART could close 15 stations, including Colma, San Bruno, and South San Francisco, and reduce service by 70%. Caltrain could reduce service to one train per hour, and stop running entirely on weekends.",
            "The consequences would impact everyone, making commuting harder, hurt seniors and working families, and slow the City’s economic recovery. Thousands of people would be forced every day onto our already congested roads, freeways, and bridges, worsening air pollution, making traffic start earlier and last longer, and resulting in most of us spending more time driving and less time home with our families.",
            "The Regional Transit Measure protects Muni service while preserving regional transit that brings workers, customers, students, and visitors into San Francisco every day.",
            "The Regional Transit Measure protects public transit while requiring local transportation investments – with strong accountability and oversight that requires large transit agencies to show cost savings to continue receiving dedicated operating funding. And it doesn’t tax rent, utilities, prescription medicines, or most groceries.",
            "Join us and Vote Yes on the Regional Transit Measure: www.ConnectBayArea.com",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Senator Scott Wiener City Attorney David Chiu San Francisco Democratic Party League of Women Voters of the Bay Area Brandy Blau, Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital Nurse* Lian Chang, Transit Advocate",
            "*For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Senator Scott Wiener City Attorney David Chiu San Francisco Democratic Party League of Women Voters of the Bay Area Brandy Blau, Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital Nurse* Lian Chang, Transit Advocate *For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Proponents claim Bay Area transit systems, including SFMTA, face imminent collapse. The budget deficit stems from a manufactured crisis.",
            "Proponents argue revenue is necessary to maintain operations under the Regional Transit Measure framework. However, handing transit agencies an unaccountable, guaranteed blank check removes any incentive for structural reform.",
            "During the pandemic SFMTA gave out pay raises to Staff. Has failed to align service levels with ridership demand. Which remains roughly 15% below pre-pandemic levels. And continue to avoid implementing structural change that would close the deficit. Yet not impact service.",
            "SFMTA hasn’t earned San Franciscans trust to be asking for more money at the ballot box. SFMTA Staff hasn’t been able to answer questions relating to the budget. If SFMTA can’t be transparent and clean up their own mess before asking for more money. Why should voters trust them with more money?",
            "The consequences of the Regional Transit Measure is money taken out of San Francisco residents’ hard earned paychecks. At a time when the same people proposing this measure are crying foul about the high cost of living. Why should San Franciscans feel inclined to bail out SFMTA for mismanaging money and overspending?",
            "Voting NO is not anti-transit; it is a demand for accountability. Demand Fixes Before Funding. Require SFMTA to balance their budgets. Without relying on San Franciscans to bail them out.",
            "Vote NO on Regional Transit Measure.",
            "Learn more at https://nonewtransittax.com/solutions/",
            "Griffin Lee, Policy Lead at ConnectedSF"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Griffin Lee, Policy Lead at ConnectedSF"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The new Regional Transit Measure (RTM) Tax makes life in San Francisco less affordable. Vote NO!",
            "San Francisco already is an expensive place to live. Working class families are barely surviving. The RTM Tax would make it worse:",
            "• Prices of groceries, utilities, and rent keep rising. • Everybody would pay this tax every day, on most things you buy. • Necessities like prepared food, clothing, pet food, and over-the-counter medicines are taxed. • Seniors, students, the disabled, and low-income neighbors are hurt the most.",
            "San Francisco’s Sales Tax is Too High already.",
            "• RTM is the LARGEST Sales TAX INCREASE ever in San Francisco’s history. • RTM is a NEW TAX that would raise San Francisco’s Sales Tax rate to 9.625%. • You’d pay total Sales Tax around $1.00 for every $10.00 of prepared food and nearly $100 for a $1,000 smartphone. That’s too much! • As local small businesses struggle, the RTM Tax could scare away customers and eliminate jobs.",
            "The new RTM Tax is Too Big ($14,000,000,000.00) and lasts Too Long (14 years):",
            "• RTM’s Tax would collect nearly a Billion Dollars every year until 2041. • San Francisco unfairly pays double the tax rate of other counties.",
            "You can’t trust BART, Muni, and Caltrain with more of your tax money:",
            "• You already pay BART, Muni, and Caltrain $100,000,000.00s of sales taxes, property taxes, and bridge tolls every year – on top of fares if you ride. • They’re grossly mismanaged. BART and Muni gave pay/benefits above $250,000 to 539 and 338 employees respectively in 2024. RTM’s Tax picks your pocket to fill theirs. • BART claims it’s broke. But an unnecessary $13,000,000,000.00 extension with 4 new stations is under construction. • BART’s taxpayer subsidy per passenger increased 729% from 2019-2024. • You shouldn’t give them more money until they stop their wasteful spending.",
            "Vote NO on the Regional Transit Measure!",
            "NoNewTransitTax.com",
            "Quentin L. Kopp, San Francisco Taxpayers Association"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Quentin L. Kopp, San Francisco Taxpayers Association"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "It’s undeniable – severe BART, Caltrain and MUNI service cuts would affect all of us in San Francisco – worsening traffic jams and straining transportation options and connections for hundreds of thousands of Bay Area residents.",
            "Please consider the FACTS and don’t be misled by half-truths and exaggerations.",
            "FACT: Don’t be misled – the Regional Transit Measure does NOT tax rent, utilities, prescription medicines, or most groceries.",
            "FACT: Before supporting the Regional Transit Measure, business groups and local leaders ensured the measure included strong accountability and oversight – BART and MUNI must show cost savings to receive dedicated operating funding.",
            "FACT: Based on detailed analysis, transit agencies have been crystal clear – Without this measure, Muni could face severe service reductions, cancel 20 bus routes, end regular evening service, and reduce fare discounts for vulnerable populations. BART could close 15 stations, including Colma, San Bruno, and South San Francisco, and reduce service by 70%. Caltrain could reduce service to one train per hour, and stop running entirely on weekends.",
            "FACT: Without this measure, commutes would be longer and more unpredictable as people who depend on transit are forced onto already crowded city streets and highways.",
            "FACT: Taxpayers across San Francisco support the Regional Transit Measure, along with stakeholders who don’t always agree – business, labor, environmental, and community groups.",
            "VOTE YES on RTM to preserve our Bay Area quality of life for future generations: www.ConnectBayArea.com",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie President of the Board of Supervisors Rafael Mandelman Supervisor Matt Dorsey Supervisor Jackie Fielder Supervisor Bilal Mahmood Supervisor Myrna Melgar Supervisor Danny Sauter Supervisor Stephen Sherrill Former City Controller Ben Rosenfield San Francisco Firefighters Local 798 San Francisco Senior & Disability Action San Francisco Transit Riders Alice B. Toklas LGBTQ Democratic Club San Francisco Chamber of Commerce"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Supervisor Danny Sauter Supervisor Stephen Sherrill Former City Controller Ben Rosenfield San Francisco Firefighters Local 798 San Francisco Senior & Disability Action San Francisco Transit Riders Alice B. Toklas LGBTQ Democratic Club San Francisco Chamber of Commerce"
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 52",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=54"
        }
      ],
      "applies_to_counties": [
        "alameda",
        "contra-costa",
        "san-mateo",
        "santa-clara",
        "san-francisco"
      ],
      "summary": "A 14-year sales tax for Bay Area public transit: 1% in San Francisco and 0.5% in Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo and Santa Clara counties.",
      "yes_means": "Impose the sales tax for 14 years.",
      "no_means": "Do not impose this sales tax.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Estimated $980 million annually across the five-county district. This is a revenue forecast, not money already collected.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "district-counsel",
          "heading": "Impartial analysis by the district’s legal counsel",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Public Transit Revenue Measure District’s Legal Counsel Impartial Analysis of Regional Transit Measure This measure was placed on the ballot by voter initiative, signed by the requisite number of voters within the Public Transit Revenue Measure District (“District”).",
            "The District was created by the Legislature through Senate Bill 63 (“SB 63”) in 2025 (Government Code sections 67700-67788), which was enacted to preserve and improve public transit service in the San Francisco Bay Area. The District comprises the counties of Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo, and Santa Clara, and the City and County of San Francisco, and is governed by the same board that governs the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (“MTC”). SB 63 authorizes District voters to approve a retail transactions and use tax (commonly referred to as a sales tax) for specified purposes.",
            "This measure would impose a tax of 0.5% in the counties of Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo, and Santa Clara and 1.0% in the City and County of San Francisco. The tax would be imposed and collected in largely the same manner as a state-imposed sales tax. The tax would be in effect for 14 years and would not count toward the statutory limit on combined local sales tax rates.",
            "It is estimated that the tax would raise approximately $980 million per year. After payment of defined costs, including election costs and administrative expenses, the District must transfer all remaining revenues to MTC",
            "and county transportation agencies for distribution and expenditure according to percentages set forth in the measure, which vary by county and recipient. Recipients include BART, Muni, Caltrain, AC Transit, Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority, San Francisco Bay Ferry, Golden Gate Transit, smaller bus operators in Alameda and Contra Costa Counties, and county transportation agencies. Revenues would also support free and reduced-cost transit transfers, expansion of the Clipper START reduced-fare program, accessibility programs, mapping and wayfinding and transit priority projects and programs, and repavement projects for roads served by fixed-route transit.",
            "While the tax would be imposed throughout the District, the allocation of revenue generated in each county, and the authorized uses of those funds, would vary. For example, 64.70% of all revenues generated in Alameda County would be allocated to BART for transit operations expenses. By contrast, 84.37% of all revenues generated in Santa Clara County would be allocated to the Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority for public transit expenses and roadway repavement projects on roads served by fixed-route transit. Such repavement projects would be an authorized use of measure revenues in Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo, and Santa Clara counties, but would not be authorized in the City and County of San Francisco. Revenue allocation is set forth in Section 12 of the measure.",
            "Tax revenues would be subject to accountability requirements in SB 63, which requires BART, Muni, AC Transit, and Caltrain to undergo financial efficiency",
            "reviews and adopt implementation plans and authorizes MTC to withhold funds from any of those operators for noncompliance. The measure would also require an independent oversight committee to review whether all revenues are distributed as required.",
            "The tax would become effective if approved by a majority of those voting on the measure throughout the entire District.",
            "A “yes” vote is a vote to impose the tax described above for 14 years.",
            "A “no” vote is a vote against imposing the tax.",
            "/s/ Kathleen Kane Legal Counsel for the Public Transit Revenue Measure District"
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Public Transit Revenue Measure District’s Legal Counsel Impartial Analysis of Regional Transit Measure This measure was placed on the ballot by voter initiative, signed by the requisite number of voters within the Public Transit Revenue Measure District (“District”)."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The District was created by the Legislature through Senate Bill 63 (“SB 63”) in 2025 (Government Code sections 67700-67788), which was enacted to preserve and improve public transit service in the San Francisco Bay Area. The District comprises the counties of Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo, and Santa Clara, and the City and County of San Francisco, and is governed by the same board that governs the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (“MTC”). SB 63 authorizes District voters to approve a retail transactions and use tax (commonly referred to as a sales tax) for specified purposes."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure would impose a tax of 0.5% in the counties of Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo, and Santa Clara and 1.0% in the City and County of San Francisco. The tax would be imposed and collected in largely the same manner as a state-imposed sales tax. The tax would be in effect for 14 years and would not count toward the statutory limit on combined local sales tax rates."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "It is estimated that the tax would raise approximately $980 million per year. After payment of defined costs, including election costs and administrative expenses, the District must transfer all remaining revenues to MTC"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "and county transportation agencies for distribution and expenditure according to percentages set forth in the measure, which vary by county and recipient. Recipients include BART, Muni, Caltrain, AC Transit, Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority, San Francisco Bay Ferry, Golden Gate Transit, smaller bus operators in Alameda and Contra Costa Counties, and county transportation agencies. Revenues would also support free and reduced-cost transit transfers, expansion of the Clipper START reduced-fare program, accessibility programs, mapping and wayfinding and transit priority projects and programs, and repavement projects for roads served by fixed-route transit."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "While the tax would be imposed throughout the District, the allocation of revenue generated in each county, and the authorized uses of those funds, would vary. For example, 64.70% of all revenues generated in Alameda County would be allocated to BART for transit operations expenses. By contrast, 84.37% of all revenues generated in Santa Clara County would be allocated to the Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority for public transit expenses and roadway repavement projects on roads served by fixed-route transit. Such repavement projects would be an authorized use of measure revenues in Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo, and Santa Clara counties, but would not be authorized in the City and County of San Francisco. Revenue allocation is set forth in Section 12 of the measure."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Tax revenues would be subject to accountability requirements in SB 63, which requires BART, Muni, AC Transit, and Caltrain to undergo financial efficiency"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "reviews and adopt implementation plans and authorizes MTC to withhold funds from any of those operators for noncompliance. The measure would also require an independent oversight committee to review whether all revenues are distributed as required."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The tax would become effective if approved by a majority of those voting on the measure throughout the entire District."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “yes” vote is a vote to impose the tax described above for 14 years."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “no” vote is a vote against imposing the tax."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "/s/ Kathleen Kane Legal Counsel for the Public Transit Revenue Measure District"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "To prevent major service cuts to BART and other transit, avoid increased traffic, and reduce pollution by: Preserving BART, Caltrain, VTA, SamTrans, AC Transit, Muni, other transit for everyone, including workers, students, seniors, persons with disabilities; Supporting transit safety, cleanliness, affordability, reliability; Repairing targeted roads/potholes; Requiring financial transparency, oversight, accountability; shall the measure enacting a 0.5% (Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo, Santa Clara counties), and 1% (San Francisco) sales tax for 14 years generating approximately $980,000,000 annually, be adopted?",
      "pro_short": "Mayor Daniel Lurie argues in the official pamphlet: \"San Francisco depends on public transit to keep the city livable, power our economy, and connect neighborhoods. Strong transit supports local businesses, reduces congestion, improves air quality, and ensures everyone can get where they need to go affordably – families, seniors, people with disabilities, students, and workers. Today, Bay Area transit faces a turning point. Without new funding from the…\"",
      "con_short": "Quentin L. Kopp, argues in the official pamphlet: \"The new Regional Transit Measure (RTM) Tax makes life in San Francisco less affordable. Vote NO! San Francisco already is an expensive place to live. Working class families are barely surviving. The RTM Tax would make it worse:…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-ptrmd-rtm",
      "number": "RTM",
      "county": "santa-clara",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sunnyvale-g",
      "letter": "G",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "City of Sunnyvale",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "sunnyvale"
      },
      "applies_to_precincts": null,
      "title": "City Charter Amendment - Public Works Contracting",
      "measure_type": "charter_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "majority",
      "vote_threshold_as_printed": "Majority Vote Required",
      "question": "Shall Section 1309 of the City Charter be amended to allow the City Council to adopt an ordinance giving the City more options for delivery of public works construction projects by authorizing use of any purchasing or contracting method allowed by California law to select contractors for such projects, and to make clarifying changes to the wording of Section 1309 that do not alter the meaning of the section?",
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Primary argument in favor (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-g-city-charter-amendment-public-works-contract-primary-arguemnt-in-favor_redacted.pdf?VersionId=KV4agcxsN4.yMpIY7Db2XOef2kwosl_g"
        },
        {
          "label": "Rebuttal to argument in favor (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-g-city-charter-amendment-public-works-contract-rebuttal-to-primary-argument-in-favor_redacted.pdf?VersionId=pqz0M7KFXVsc_UCf_8vykMh5YJaA.cBP"
        },
        {
          "label": "Primary argument against (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-g-city-charter-amendment-public-works-contract-primary-arguemnt-against_redacted.pdf?VersionId=nnyacvTwkcq9LkYgiZ...YKPKcbNPPHP"
        },
        {
          "label": "Rebuttal to argument against (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-g-city-charter-amendment-public-works-contract-rebuttal-to-primary-argument-against_redacted.pdf?VersionId=u2mBGahV2DCuUeyiR8FGjPOkZetodC1R"
        },
        {
          "label": "Impartial analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-g-city-of-sunnyvale_charter-amendment-ia_08-18-2026_redacted.pdf?VersionId=2FIpf3MHgfhEG7rneDG2smFwbjLrc5SX"
        },
        {
          "label": "Official accessible-guide source record",
          "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/published/06085/1968/vg/728_md.json"
        }
      ],
      "arguments_filed": {
        "argument_for": true,
        "rebuttal_to_for": true,
        "argument_against": true,
        "rebuttal_to_against": true
      },
      "source_keys": [
        "scc:list-local-measures",
        "scc:sample-ballot-3004",
        "scc:accessible-g",
        "sunnyvale:council-charter-report"
      ],
      "summary": "This measure would amend Sunnyvale City Charter Section 1309 to allow the City to use alternative methods to select contractors for public works contracts, and authorize the City Council to establish, by ordinance, any regulations for the award, use, evaluation, and approval of these contracts.",
      "yes_means": "A \"YES\" vote amends the Charter so that the Council can authorize the use of alternative project delivery methods for public works contracts and make clarifying changes to the wording of Charter Section 1309.",
      "no_means": "A \"NO\" vote would not add any options to use alternative project delivery methods for public works contracts and would not change the wording of Charter Section 1309.",
      "fiscal_impact": "The official impartial analysis does not give a quantified estimate of costs or savings.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "impartial",
          "heading": "Impartial analysis by the City Attorney",
          "paragraphs": [
            "This measure would amend Sunnyvale City Charter Section 1309 to allow the City to use alternative methods to select contractors for public works contracts, and authorize the City Council to establish, by ordinance, any regulations for the award, use, evaluation, and approval of these contracts.",
            "The Council placed this measure on the ballot on recommendation by a Charter Review Committee of appointed Sunnyvale residents.",
            "Currently, Section 1309 of the Sunnyvale City Charter requires the City to use a traditional system for awarding public works contracts, known as \"design-bid-build.\" This method requires separate contract awards for the design and construction phases of the project. Unless there is a recognized exemption, such as emergency work, the City first contracts with architects or engineers to design the project. After the project design is completed, the City then advertises the completed design for construction bids, and finally awards the construction contract to the lowest \"responsive and responsible\" bidder. This competitive bidding process is based on the bid price alone and does not permit the City to consider the construction contractor's qualifications, technical experience, or other factors, so long as the contractor meets the minimum requirements.",
            "The Sunnyvale Charter does not allow any other project delivery methods for procuring and contracting work for public works projects, even when those methods are permitted by state law. For example, two alternatives are \"design-build\" and \"construction manager-at-risk.\" Under a design-build approach, the design and construction phases are combined into a single contract, and a single entity is responsible for both the design and construction of a public works project. Further, the City would select a contractor through a qualifications-based process that can take into account various factors other than the lowest bid. Under a construction manager-at-risk approach, the City would hire a construction manager to perform both pre-construction and construction management services within a guaranteed maximum price (GMP), and the construction manager would be responsible for any construction costs that exceed the GMP.",
            "This measure would authorize the City Council to choose alternative options for the delivery of public works construction projects so long as those options are allowed by California law. The measure would authorize the Council to adopt ordinances regulating the award, use, evaluation, and approval of public works contracts using such alternative methods. In addition, this measure would make clarifying changes to some existing language in Section 1309 without altering the meaning.",
            "A \"YES\" vote amends the Charter so that the Council can authorize the use of alternative project delivery methods for public works contracts and make clarifying changes to the wording of Charter Section 1309.",
            "A \"NO\" vote would not add any options to use alternative project delivery methods for public works contracts and would not change the wording of Charter Section 1309.",
            "This amendment will become effective if a majority of those voting on the measure vote \"yes.\"",
            "/s/ Rebecca L. Moon | City Attorney",
            "To obtain copy of Measure G, call the elections official at 408-730-7483 and a copy will be provided at no cost to you."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure would amend Sunnyvale City Charter Section 1309 to allow the City to use alternative methods to select contractors for public works contracts, and authorize the City Council to establish, by ordinance, any regulations for the award, use, evaluation, and approval of these contracts."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Council placed this measure on the ballot on recommendation by a Charter Review Committee of appointed Sunnyvale residents."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Currently, Section 1309 of the Sunnyvale City Charter requires the City to use a traditional system for awarding public works contracts, known as \"design-bid-build.\" This method requires separate contract awards for the design and construction phases of the project. Unless there is a recognized exemption, such as emergency work, the City first contracts with architects or engineers to design the project. After the project design is completed, the City then advertises the completed design for construction bids, and finally awards the construction contract to the lowest \"responsive and responsible\" bidder. This competitive bidding process is based on the bid price alone and does not permit the City to consider the construction contractor's qualifications, technical experience, or other factors, so long as the contractor meets the minimum requirements."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Sunnyvale Charter does not allow any other project delivery methods for procuring and contracting work for public works projects, even when those methods are permitted by state law. For example, two alternatives are \"design-build\" and \"construction manager-at-risk.\" Under a design-build approach, the design and construction phases are combined into a single contract, and a single entity is responsible for both the design and construction of a public works project. Further, the City would select a contractor through a qualifications-based process that can take into account various factors other than the lowest bid. Under a construction manager-at-risk approach, the City would hire a construction manager to perform both pre-construction and construction management services within a guaranteed maximum price (GMP), and the construction manager would be responsible for any construction costs that exceed the GMP."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure would authorize the City Council to choose alternative options for the delivery of public works construction projects so long as those options are allowed by California law. The measure would authorize the Council to adopt ordinances regulating the award, use, evaluation, and approval of public works contracts using such alternative methods. In addition, this measure would make clarifying changes to some existing language in Section 1309 without altering the meaning."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A \"YES\" vote amends the Charter so that the Council can authorize the use of alternative project delivery methods for public works contracts and make clarifying changes to the wording of Charter Section 1309."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A \"NO\" vote would not add any options to use alternative project delivery methods for public works contracts and would not change the wording of Charter Section 1309."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This amendment will become effective if a majority of those voting on the measure vote \"yes.\""
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "/s/ Rebecca L. Moon | City Attorney"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "To obtain copy of Measure G, call the elections official at 408-730-7483 and a copy will be provided at no cost to you."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote YES to Modernize Sunnyvale's Public Works Contracting.",
            "Sunnyvale's rules for building public infrastructure have not kept pace with modern times. Under current Charter constraints, the City is required to use an outdated \"lowest-bid\" method that separates project design from construction. This rigid requirement often results in communication gaps, costly mid-project change orders, and frustrating construction delays.",
            "This measure updates Charter Section 1309 to grant Sunnyvale access to the same flexible, modern project delivery methods already authorized by California State Law and successfully used by nearby cities and school districts.",
            "Why a YES Vote Makes Sense:",
            "Saves Taxpayer Money: By allowing modern delivery models like \"Design-Build,\" the City can combine design and construction into a single, unified contract. This means the team that designs the project builds it, significantly reducing errors, change orders, and budget overruns.",
            "Speeds Up Projects: Combining design and construction means critical civic improvements and infrastructure projects get completed much faster, minimizing disruption to our community.",
            "Prioritizes Quality and Value: Sunnyvale would be allowed to consider a contractor's specialized qualifications, proven track record, and technical expertise—not just the lowest bid—ensuring high-quality infrastructure built to last.",
            "Strict Safeguards Remain Intact",
            "This measure does not eliminate competitive bidding. Traditional lowest-bid tracking will still be used for everyday maintenance projects. For complex projects, any alternative method must be explicitly authorized by the City Council on a case-by-case basis under strict, transparent ordinances.",
            "Following an intensive, multi-year review, the independent, citizen-led Charter Review Committee and your City Council recommended this upgrade. Let's build a more efficient, cost-effective Sunnyvale.",
            "Vote YES for higher quality infrastructure at lower cost.",
            "/s/ Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "/s/ Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "/s/ Gail Rubino | Housing Advocate",
            "/s/ Murali Srinivasan | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "/s/ Charlsie Chang | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "Gail Rubino | Housing Advocate",
            "Murali Srinivasan | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "Charlsie Chang | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Supposedly Measure G \"modernizes\" contracting. Actually, it leads to favoritism and higher costs. Currently, city contracts go to the lowest bidder. City council members have no say in selecting the winner─preventing favoritism. Bidding is already restricted to qualified bidders─we don't need \"best value\" to ensure that!",
            "Measure G replaces objective \"low-bid-wins\" with subjective \"best-value\" scoring, handing Council members the power to handpick contractors. Campaign donors get a direct track to city contracts leading inevitably to inflated contracts. Taxpayer dollars funneled to political donors turning $Thousand campaign contributions into $Million contracts. Donors expect a return on their investment.",
            "Multiple convictions in 2024 $Multi-Million \"pay-for-vote\" bribery involving Los Angeles City Councilmembers, building developers, and Deputy Mayor Chan.",
            "August, 2022─San Francisco Public Works Director (salary $278,000) gets 7 years in prison. Judge Orrick: \"you made the city's decision-making and competitive bidding a farce... in exchange for money, gifts,...\"",
            "California electric utilities donated $200 Million to political campaigns leading to 2nd highest electricity rates in the US.",
            "Apartment owners and construction PACs consistently funnel campaign contributions to City Council candidates. Even candidates running unopposed collect $Thousands!",
            "Audits heavily criticized California High-Speed Rail Authority for using \"design-build\". Costs for initial contract segments doubled!",
            "San Francisco Bay Bridge \"Loma Prieta Earthquake\" rebuild was to be $1.3Billion over 4-7 years, instead cost $6.5 Billion (500% increase!) taking 11 years!",
            "Measure G removes vital checks on public spending.",
            "Let's keep corruption illegal in Sunnyvale!",
            "Protect taxpayers from pay-to-play contracting.",
            "More at MeetingTheTwain.BlogSpot.com",
            "Vote NO on Measure G!",
            "/s/ Michael S. Goldman | Former Councilmember, Sunnyvale",
            "/s/ Andy Frazer",
            "/s/ Jeannine Avila Pierce | Retiree"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Michael S. Goldman | Former Councilmember, Sunnyvale",
            "Andy Frazer",
            "Jeannine Avila Pierce | Retiree"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "NO on G! California makes it legal but it's a terrible idea!",
            "Purposely vague Measure G would allow \"design-build\" and \"best value\" to be used instead of competitive bidding for the design and construction of City buildings. Sunnyvale currently has one bid for design—another bid for the construction. Low bid wins.",
            "\"Design-build\" makes designer and builder the same, incentivizing expensive design. The independent designer who normally protects the public by flagging problems, preventing corner-cutting is gone. When the builder oversees themselves, taxpayers bear the risk.",
            "Measure G allows contracts awarded on subjective \"best value\" scoring instead of \"low-bid\". Los Angeles saw the consequences: Councilmember José Huizar pleaded guilty to accepting $1.5 million in bribes benefiting developers, involving $Billions in city projects because of \"best value\" procurement. The Los Angeles District Attorney warned subjective \"best value\" evaluations used in \"design-build\" can enable favoritism, undermining public trust.",
            "\"Design-build\" incentivizes contractors to \"lowball\" projects knowing \"unforeseen\" changes will increase costs—which taxpayers will pay. City Council members inexperienced with building construction go along with whatever the contractor tells them is \"unexpectedly\" needed.",
            "Belmont Learning Center: a Los Angeles Unified School District \"design-build\" project doubled in cost, rising from $150 million to over $300 million, one of the most expensive high schools in U.S. history. Environmental hazards were missed, oversight broke down; investigations found \"design-build\" contributed to the disaster.",
            "Sunnyvale staff in a 2016 report acknowledged that \"design-build\" raises conflict-of-interest concerns. The developer claimed it \"minimizes change orders\", but that came from the contractor(!), who benefits from lack of competition.",
            "More examples and discussion at:",
            "https://meetingthetwain.blogspot.com/2026/08/2026-against-sunnyvale-measure-g.html",
            "Keep Sunnyvale's competitive system to protect residents!",
            "If it ain't broke, don't fix it!",
            "NO on Measure G.",
            "/s/ Michael S. Goldman | Former Sunnyvale City Councilmember",
            "/s/ Andy Frazer | Engineer"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Michael S. Goldman | Former Sunnyvale City Councilmember",
            "Andy Frazer | Engineer"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Design-build construction has been a tried and proven bid process in California for more than thirty years. Unifying design and construction under a single contractor improves efficiency and communication, speeding project delivery and improving quality.",
            "The opposition says \"If it ain't broke, don't fix it\". But the current system is broken. That's why City staff proposed allowing design-build contracting. They understand what the current system costs us all in money, time, and litigation. And that's why Senate Bill 935 (R-Choi) passed with unanimous bipartisan support to permanently authorize local agencies to use design-build, \"which has streamlined project delivery, reduced costs, and encouraged innovation in public works for decades.\"",
            "The opposition's remaining arguments are also misleading. They claim that design-build will lead to \"lowball\" contract submissions, but that's the problem with the current \"low-bid\" system, which primarily evaluates proposals on cost. They cite the Belmont Learning Center, but LAUSD chose to site BLC on an active earthquake fault and former oil field (www.presstelegram.com/2008/04/10/a-400-million-lesson/). They cite Jose Huizar's corruption conviction, but he was jailed for dealings with private developers, not city contractors (https://abc7.com/post/disgraced-former-la-city-councilman-jose-huizar-due-to-begin-prison-sentence/15401128/). These arguments aren't just wrong—they're irrelevant.",
            "Sunnyvale's professional city staff recommended bringing the option of design-build construction to you, the voters. The independent, citizen-led Charter Review Committee and your elected City Council unanimously agreed. Sunnyvale residents deserve the best value and efficiency, not just the lowest bid.",
            "Learn more at www.YES-on-GHI.com, and vote YES on Measure G.",
            "/s/ Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "/s/ Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "/s/ Mary Bradley | Community Leader",
            "/s/ Murali Srinivasan | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "/s/ Eileen Le | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "Mary Bradley | Community Leader",
            "Murali Srinivasan | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "Eileen Le | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ]
        }
      },
      "pro_short": "Larry Klein argues in the official guide: \"Vote YES to Modernize Sunnyvale's Public Works Contracting. Sunnyvale's rules for building public infrastructure have not kept pace with modern times. Under current Charter constraints, the City is required to use an outdated \"lowest-bid\" method that separates project design from construction. This rigid requirement often results in communication gaps, costly mid-project change orders, and frustrating construction delays.\"",
      "con_short": "Michael S. Goldman argues in the official guide: \"NO on G! California makes it legal but it's a terrible idea! Purposely vague Measure G would allow \"design-build\" and \"best value\" to be used instead of competitive bidding for the design and construction of City buildings. Sunnyvale currently has one bid for design—another bid for the construction. Low bid wins.\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sunnyvale-g",
      "number": "G",
      "county": "santa-clara",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sunnyvale-h",
      "letter": "H",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "City of Sunnyvale",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "sunnyvale"
      },
      "applies_to_precincts": null,
      "title": "City Charter Amendment - City Manager's Authority to Settle Claims",
      "measure_type": "charter_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "majority",
      "vote_threshold_as_printed": "Majority Vote Required",
      "question": "Shall Section 1314 of the City Charter be amended to authorize the City Council to adopt an ordinance establishing the maximum amount the City Manager may approve to settle legal claims against the City, instead of the current $50,000 limit established by state law and unchanged since 1989, while retaining City Council approval authority for settlements exceeding the amount set by the ordinance?",
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Primary argument in favor (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-h-city-charter-amenedment-city-manager-settlement-authority-argument-in-favor_08112026_redacted-v2.pdf?VersionId=ag4SPlW2c4p4QFfzTuFRVjFSN1uX.BEX"
        },
        {
          "label": "Impartial analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-h-city-of-sunnyvale_charter-amendment_city-manager-settlement-ia_08-18-2026_redacted.pdf?VersionId=u0NQH_OffrKMK0muimLYT_.EANViwaMs"
        },
        {
          "label": "Official accessible-guide source record",
          "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/published/06085/1968/vg/729_md.json"
        }
      ],
      "arguments_filed": {
        "argument_for": true,
        "rebuttal_to_for": false,
        "argument_against": false,
        "rebuttal_to_against": false
      },
      "arguments_note": "The registrar lists the primary argument against as \"(none filed)\".",
      "source_keys": [
        "scc:list-local-measures",
        "scc:sample-ballot-3004",
        "scc:accessible-h",
        "sunnyvale:council-charter-report"
      ],
      "summary": "This measure would amend Sunnyvale City Charter Section 1314 to give the City Council the authority to adopt an ordinance setting the City Manager's maximum authority to settle claims against the City.",
      "yes_means": "A \"YES\" vote amends the Charter so that the Council can adopt an ordinance setting the amount of the City Manager's settlement authority at a different limit than Government Code Section 935.4.",
      "no_means": "A \"NO\" vote keeps the current rule requiring the City to use the settlement authority limit established by Government Code section 935.4, currently $50,000.",
      "fiscal_impact": "The official impartial analysis does not give a quantified estimate of costs or savings.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "impartial",
          "heading": "Impartial analysis by the City Attorney",
          "paragraphs": [
            "This measure would amend Sunnyvale City Charter Section 1314 to give the City Council the authority to adopt an ordinance setting the City Manager's maximum authority to settle claims against the City.",
            "The Council placed this measure on the ballot on recommendation of a Charter Review Committee of appointed Sunnyvale residents.",
            "Currently, the City follows Government Code Section 935.4, which requires the City Council to approve all settlements of lawsuits and claims greater than $50,000. The California Legislature set the $50,000 limit in 1989 and has not adjusted it for inflation. Government Code Section 935.4 requires an amendment to the City Charter to change the $50,000 limit.",
            "If a settlement is within the City Manager's authority, it means that the City Manager or their designee, such as the Risk Manager, can approve the settlement without involving the City Council. If a proposed settlement is over the City Manager's authority, staff will present the case to the City Council in a confidential closed session. The Council may approve or disapprove the settlement, or authorize staff to negotiate a settlement up to a certain amount.",
            "This measure would authorize the City Council to set the City Manager's maximum settlement authority by ordinance. The City Council could adjust this amount (up or down) in the future by adopting another ordinance; no further Charter amendment will be necessary. In August 2026, the City Council adopted an ordinance that will take effect if this measure passes, setting the City Manager's settlement authority at $250,000, the same amount as the City Manager's current authority to approve contracts. Any settlement above the Council-set limit in the ordinance would require City Council approval, and the closed session procedures for City Council approval of settlements over the amount set by the ordinance would remain the same.",
            "A \"YES\" vote amends the Charter so that the Council can adopt an ordinance setting the amount of the City Manager's settlement authority at a different limit than Government Code Section 935.4.",
            "A \"NO\" vote keeps the current rule requiring the City to use the settlement authority limit established by Government Code section 935.4, currently $50,000.",
            "This amendment will become effective if a majority of those voting on the measure vote \"yes.\"",
            "/s/ Rebecca L. Moon | City Attorney",
            "To obtain copy of Measure H, call the elections official at 408-730-7483 and a copy will be provided at no cost to you."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure would amend Sunnyvale City Charter Section 1314 to give the City Council the authority to adopt an ordinance setting the City Manager's maximum authority to settle claims against the City."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Council placed this measure on the ballot on recommendation of a Charter Review Committee of appointed Sunnyvale residents."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Currently, the City follows Government Code Section 935.4, which requires the City Council to approve all settlements of lawsuits and claims greater than $50,000. The California Legislature set the $50,000 limit in 1989 and has not adjusted it for inflation. Government Code Section 935.4 requires an amendment to the City Charter to change the $50,000 limit."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "If a settlement is within the City Manager's authority, it means that the City Manager or their designee, such as the Risk Manager, can approve the settlement without involving the City Council. If a proposed settlement is over the City Manager's authority, staff will present the case to the City Council in a confidential closed session. The Council may approve or disapprove the settlement, or authorize staff to negotiate a settlement up to a certain amount."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure would authorize the City Council to set the City Manager's maximum settlement authority by ordinance. The City Council could adjust this amount (up or down) in the future by adopting another ordinance; no further Charter amendment will be necessary. In August 2026, the City Council adopted an ordinance that will take effect if this measure passes, setting the City Manager's settlement authority at $250,000, the same amount as the City Manager's current authority to approve contracts. Any settlement above the Council-set limit in the ordinance would require City Council approval, and the closed session procedures for City Council approval of settlements over the amount set by the ordinance would remain the same."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A \"YES\" vote amends the Charter so that the Council can adopt an ordinance setting the amount of the City Manager's settlement authority at a different limit than Government Code Section 935.4."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A \"NO\" vote keeps the current rule requiring the City to use the settlement authority limit established by Government Code section 935.4, currently $50,000."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This amendment will become effective if a majority of those voting on the measure vote \"yes.\""
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "/s/ Rebecca L. Moon | City Attorney"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "To obtain copy of Measure H, call the elections official at 408-730-7483 and a copy will be provided at no cost to you."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote YES to cut bureaucratic red tape and save valuable public meeting time.",
            "Currently, the Charter caps the City Manager's authority to settle routine, clear-cut legal claims at just $50,000—a limit set nearly 40 years ago. Because of decades of inflation, $50,000 in 1989 is worth over $130,000 today. As a result, even minor administrative claims—like a city vehicle clipping a fender—frequently exceed this low threshold.",
            "This creates a bureaucratic bottleneck. Your elected City Council is required to repeatedly stop their work to agendize, review, and vote on minor, routine legal settlements. This wastes taxpayer-funded staff hours, delays fair resolutions for residents, and clutters public meetings.",
            "Voting YES replaces this rigid, outdated $50,000 cap and empowers the City Council to set realistic limits by ordinance. In July, Council passed an ordinance to set this threshold to 250 thousand dollars if this measure passes. This directly aligns settlement authority with the City Manager's current day-to-day purchasing and contract approval limits.",
            "This measure maintains strict accountability:",
            "Preserves Council Oversight: Your elected City Council retains exclusive authority to review and vote on all major, high-dollar legal settlements.",
            "Protects Public Resources: Resolving minor claims quickly saves city staff hours, avoids protracted litigation, and reduces overall legal expenses.",
            "Focuses on Priorities: Clears the clutter from Council agendas so your leaders can focus on critical community issues like housing, traffic, and public safety.",
            "Vote YES for efficient, accountable, and modernized city management.",
            "/s/ Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "/s/ Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "/s/ Gustav Larsson | Former Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "/s/ Linda Sell | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "/s/ Alysa Cisneros | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "Gustav Larsson | Former Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "Linda Sell | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "Alysa Cisneros | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "not_submitted",
          "paragraphs": [],
          "signers": []
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "not_submitted",
          "paragraphs": [],
          "signers": []
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "not_submitted",
          "paragraphs": [],
          "signers": []
        }
      },
      "pro_short": "Larry Klein argues in the official guide: \"Vote YES to cut bureaucratic red tape and save valuable public meeting time. Currently, the Charter caps the City Manager's authority to settle routine, clear-cut legal claims at just $50,000—a limit set nearly 40 years ago. Because of decades of inflation, $50,000 in 1989 is worth over $130,000 today. As a result, even minor administrative claims—like a city vehicle clipping a fender—frequently exceed this low threshold.\"",
      "con_short": "No argument against Measure H was submitted to the official voter guide.",
      "contest_id": "local-sunnyvale-h",
      "number": "H",
      "county": "santa-clara",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sunnyvale-i",
      "letter": "I",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "City of Sunnyvale",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "sunnyvale"
      },
      "applies_to_precincts": null,
      "title": "City Charter Amendment - City Council Vacancies",
      "measure_type": "charter_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "majority",
      "vote_threshold_as_printed": "Majority Vote Required",
      "question": "Shall Section 606 of the City Charter be amended to require that a person appointed to fill a vacancy on the City Council serve until a successor is elected at the next General Municipal Election (November of even-numbered years), rather than until an earlier election date that could be consolidated with a statewide election?",
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Primary argument in favor (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-i-appointed-incumbent-to-serve-until-sucessor-is-elected-primary-arguemnt-in-favor_redacted-v2.pdf?VersionId=3.MYtyA3I7uBQtnUxJFeUjx.Li3au6mt"
        },
        {
          "label": "Rebuttal to argument in favor (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-i-city-charter-amendment-appointed-incumbent-to-serve-until-successor-is-elected-rebuttal-to-primary-argument-in-favor_redacted.pdf?VersionId=up1VsX4SHiK24xt6k.NOn_ec2jGo03Hp"
        },
        {
          "label": "Primary argument against (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-i-appointed-incumbent-to-serve-until-sucessor-is-elected-primary-arguemnt-against_redacted.pdf?VersionId=EvC4AVSBsSDH070dSBnOLrdjCrF7mwrs"
        },
        {
          "label": "Rebuttal to argument against (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-i-city-charter-amendment-appointed-incumbent-to-serve-until-successor-is-elected-rebuttal-to-primary-argument-against_redacted_0.pdf?VersionId=4Q52bzbAOM3KbsWqUF4HQ0wVrtsaNj7K"
        },
        {
          "label": "Impartial analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-i-city-of-sunnyvale_charter-amendment-appointed-incumbent-to-serve-ia_08-18-2026_redacted.pdf?VersionId=imvy7ZqTTofyfOsTOOMxSr3kVQoj46UK"
        },
        {
          "label": "Official accessible-guide source record",
          "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/published/06085/1968/vg/730_md.json"
        }
      ],
      "arguments_filed": {
        "argument_for": true,
        "rebuttal_to_for": true,
        "argument_against": true,
        "rebuttal_to_against": true
      },
      "source_keys": [
        "scc:list-local-measures",
        "scc:sample-ballot-3004",
        "scc:accessible-i",
        "sunnyvale:council-charter-report"
      ],
      "summary": "This measure would amend Sunnyvale City Charter Section 606 to specify that when the City Council appoints a person to fill a vacant seat on the Council, an election to fill the seat will be held at the next General Municipal Election.",
      "yes_means": "A \"YES\" vote amends the Charter so that a council vacancy filled by appointment goes to voters at the next November election in an even-numbered year, and makes a clarifying change to the wording of Section 606(c).",
      "no_means": "A \"NO\" vote keeps the existing Charter requirement that a council vacancy filled by appointment go to the voters at the next Special Municipal Election consolidated with the next statewide election or the next General Municipal Election, whichever is sooner, and makes no changes to the wording.",
      "fiscal_impact": "The official impartial analysis does not give a quantified estimate of costs or savings.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "impartial",
          "heading": "Impartial analysis by the City Attorney",
          "paragraphs": [
            "This measure would amend Sunnyvale City Charter Section 606 to specify that when the City Council appoints a person to fill a vacant seat on the Council, an election to fill the seat will be held at the next General Municipal Election.",
            "The Council placed this measure on the ballot on recommendation of a Charter Review Committee of appointed Sunnyvale residents.",
            "When a seat on the City Council becomes vacant, Charter Section 606 gives the Council two options: either call a special election to fill the vacancy, or fill the vacancy by appointment. This decision must be made by four affirmative votes. If the Council chooses to appoint, the existing Charter provides that the appointee serves until the next General Municipal Election or the next Special Municipal Election consolidated with a statewide election, whichever is sooner.",
            "This measure would remove the requirement to hold a Special Municipal Election on the soonest available date when a seat is filled by appointment. The Council could still choose not to appoint anyone and call a special election instead. This measure would not change the existing Charter provision that prohibits having more than two appointees on the Council at the same time.",
            "Depending on when a vacancy occurs, this measure could have the effect of lengthening the time that an appointee serves on the City Council. For example, if the first opportunity for a Special Municipal Election is the statewide primary in March or June of an even-numbered year, or an earlier statewide special election, the appointee will serve longer under the proposed amendment than under the existing Charter provision. At the same time, this measure avoids a situation where the City must hold a special election to fill a vacancy at the March or June primary followed by a General Municipal Election in November of the same year.",
            "This measure also re-words Section 606, subsection (c), to refer to the City Council votes rather than \"councilmembers\" since the Council now includes the mayor.",
            "A \"YES\" vote amends the Charter so that a council vacancy filled by appointment goes to voters at the next November election in an even-numbered year, and makes a clarifying change to the wording of Section 606(c).",
            "A \"NO\" vote keeps the existing Charter requirement that a council vacancy filled by appointment go to the voters at the next Special Municipal Election consolidated with the next statewide election or the next General Municipal Election, whichever is sooner, and makes no changes to the wording.",
            "This amendment will become effective if a majority of those voting on the measure vote \"yes.\"",
            "/s/ Rebecca L. Moon | City Attorney",
            "To obtain copy of Measure I, call the elections official at 408-730-7483 and a copy will be provided at no cost to you."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure would amend Sunnyvale City Charter Section 606 to specify that when the City Council appoints a person to fill a vacant seat on the Council, an election to fill the seat will be held at the next General Municipal Election."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Council placed this measure on the ballot on recommendation of a Charter Review Committee of appointed Sunnyvale residents."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "When a seat on the City Council becomes vacant, Charter Section 606 gives the Council two options: either call a special election to fill the vacancy, or fill the vacancy by appointment. This decision must be made by four affirmative votes. If the Council chooses to appoint, the existing Charter provides that the appointee serves until the next General Municipal Election or the next Special Municipal Election consolidated with a statewide election, whichever is sooner."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure would remove the requirement to hold a Special Municipal Election on the soonest available date when a seat is filled by appointment. The Council could still choose not to appoint anyone and call a special election instead. This measure would not change the existing Charter provision that prohibits having more than two appointees on the Council at the same time."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Depending on when a vacancy occurs, this measure could have the effect of lengthening the time that an appointee serves on the City Council. For example, if the first opportunity for a Special Municipal Election is the statewide primary in March or June of an even-numbered year, or an earlier statewide special election, the appointee will serve longer under the proposed amendment than under the existing Charter provision. At the same time, this measure avoids a situation where the City must hold a special election to fill a vacancy at the March or June primary followed by a General Municipal Election in November of the same year."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure also re-words Section 606, subsection (c), to refer to the City Council votes rather than \"councilmembers\" since the Council now includes the mayor."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A \"YES\" vote amends the Charter so that a council vacancy filled by appointment goes to voters at the next November election in an even-numbered year, and makes a clarifying change to the wording of Section 606(c)."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A \"NO\" vote keeps the existing Charter requirement that a council vacancy filled by appointment go to the voters at the next Special Municipal Election consolidated with the next statewide election or the next General Municipal Election, whichever is sooner, and makes no changes to the wording."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This amendment will become effective if a majority of those voting on the measure vote \"yes.\""
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "/s/ Rebecca L. Moon | City Attorney"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "To obtain copy of Measure I, call the elections official at 408-730-7483 and a copy will be provided at no cost to you."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote YES to fix an expensive election flaw in our City Charter.",
            "Right now, when the City Council fills a vacancy by appointment, the Charter can require Sunnyvale to hold two elections for the same seat in the same year. one consolidated with a March or June primary, then another in November for the full term. Taxpayers pay for both. Candidates run two campaigns. The winner of the first election can serve as little as five months.",
            "This measure makes a common-sense fix: a councilmember appointed to fill a vacancy serves until the next regularly scheduled November Sunnyvale election in even numbered years, when the most voters can choose a successor.",
            "A YES vote:",
            "SAVES MONEY. It eliminates the possibility of paying for two elections for one seat in a single year, and November elections cost the City less than primary elections.",
            "INCLUDES MORE VOTERS. November general elections in Sunnyvale draw roughly 60% turnout. Primary Elections draw about 40%. It is best practice for Council elections to be decided when voter turnout is highest.",
            "KEEPS VOTERS IN CHARGE. Voters still elect every Councilmember and Mayor. But the whole electorate at the next November election chooses the new councilmember instead of a low-turnout primary.",
            "This fix was recommended by Sunnyvale’s Charter Review Committee, after more than a year of study. Your City Council voted unanimously to place it on the ballot, and it builds directly on the vacancy reforms approved previously by Sunnyvale voters after the costly 2016 Special Election.",
            "Vote YES for efficient elections and maximum voter participation.",
            "/s/ Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "/s/ Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "/s/ Kristel Wickham | Community Volunteer",
            "/s/ Murali Srinivasan | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "/s/ Eileen Le | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "Kristel Wickham | Community Volunteer",
            "Murali Srinivasan | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "Eileen Le | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote NO on Measure I. Save our elections.",
            "A current office holder often wins an election, enjoying name recognition and more resources than competitors. Measure I deepens this incumbency advantage.",
            "The importance of an earlier election to fill a vacancy outweighs possible concerns over two elections for the same seat in the same even-year.",
            "Measure I primarily benefits the appointee by eliminating the earlier opportunity for election competition.",
            "ODD-YEAR STATEWIDE SPECIAL ELECTIONS FURTHER REDUCE possibility for two elections in the same even-year. Since 1990, 33% of the odd-years (6 of 18) had California statewide special elections.",
            "IT'S BEEN ONLY 8 YEARS since voters approved the charter language in 2018 for filling vacancies. It balanced costs and democratic ideals. | Measure I upsets this balance.",
            "APPOINTMENT POWERS CAN BE ABUSED. From 1913 to 1975, repeated resignation generated vacancies were mostly filled by appointments. Incumbents were rarely defeated due to Incumbency advantage.",
            "Elections are an investment in a representative Sunnyvale City Council.",
            "Filling a mayor vacancy with a district council member creates another vacancy. Currently filling that new City Council vacancy by appointment means two simultaneous appointments on Sunnyvale City Council. Many voters are unaware of this possibility. This measure's longer appointments will make this worse.",
            "Shown below, two district elections cost about 1/3 as much as one citywide election. The expense for a primary election is reasonable:",
            "Estimated potential at-large vacancy election | (6 district approx.) | June 7, 2022 | $227,188",
            "Districts 3 and 5 (2 districts expense) | Nov. 8, 2022 | $76,727",
            "More information: https://tinyurl.com/NO-on-Measure-I",
            "Take charge. NO on Measure I.",
            "/s/ Mei-Ling Shek-Stefan | Retired Scientist",
            "/s/ Carlene Nakagawa",
            "/s/ Jaswant S. Jessie | Enrolled Agent",
            "/s/ Daryl Jamgotchian"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mei-Ling Shek-Stefan | Retired Scientist",
            "Carlene Nakagawa",
            "Jaswant S. Jessie | Enrolled Agent",
            "Daryl Jamgotchian"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote NO to avoid 2+ year appointments and avoid greater appointee incumbency advantage. Preserve earlier opportunities to vote.",
            "If passed, this will cut the eligible elections to fill vacancies by at least half. This is done by eliminating the existing requirement to use an earlier election consolidated with a statewide election, a primary election for example. Longer appointments and appointee incumbency advantage allows council to handpick successors. While you may like the current city council, that may change in 15-20 years. Do you want that council making extended appointments?",
            "Primary election voters are well engaged and informed. Larger turnout in even-year November elections does not justify sacrificing earlier opportunities to vote. Money spent on elections can be a very good investment.",
            "This measure raises significant concerns:",
            "ALLOWS LONGER APPOINTMENTS, UP TO 2+ YEARS. Chances for simultaneous appointees increase.",
            "EXPANDS PATH TO ARRANGED APPOINTMENTS. Including bestowing incumbency advantage. By 1975 four of seven sitting council members had originally been appointed.",
            "APPOINTMENT POWERS CAN BE ABUSED. As shown by Sunnyvale’s history. A 2009-2010 County Civil Grand Jury Report criticized Sunnyvale regarding the 2009 interim council appointment.",
            "The Sunnyvale 2018 charter update already produced major cost savings in filling a vacancy by avoiding most stand-alone elections. There is no need to go too far. A district election costs only a fraction compared to one citywide.",
            "Sunnyvale’s 2020 shift to districts and a separate mayor increased the chances for council vacancies. Three district council member’s terms don’t align with the directly elected mayor’s. If one of those council members successfully runs for mayor, a two-year vacancy is generated. This measure distracts from deeper issues.",
            "Vote NO to prevent excessively long council appointments. Protect voter rights to democratically choose our elected officials at the earliest statewide election.",
            "/s/ Stephen Scandalis | Retired Engineer/Program Manager",
            "/s/ Andy Frazer",
            "/s/ Richard Lesher | Chartered Financial Analyst",
            "/s/ Jennifer Tasseff",
            "/s/ Susan Selna"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Stephen Scandalis | Retired Engineer/Program Manager",
            "Andy Frazer",
            "Richard Lesher | Chartered Financial Analyst",
            "Jennifer Tasseff",
            "Susan Selna"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "American democracy is under attack as big money, special interests, and sensationalized media undermine our national elections. At times like these, local governments must work to strengthen democracy and increase voter turnout. That's why passing Measure I is so important.",
            "Sunnyvale Charter Section 606.d states that appointees \"shall hold office until the next General Municipal Election or Special Municipal Election consolidated with the next statewide election.\" Depending on timing, a vacant seat can go up for BOTH the primary AND general elections. A vacancy triggered a double-election in 2016 and nearly triggered one in 2022.",
            "This is a problem. We need as many residents voting for City Council as possible. Consolidating council races with low-turnout primary and special elections, when voters don't expect them, depresses turnout and weakens local democracy.",
            "Running for office costs time, money, and stress. Having to run two campaigns in a year will deter qualified candidates, while having to double-fundraise will favor those with deep pockets or wealthy backers. We already have trouble attracting candidates: since 2022, half of our City Council races have gone uncontested. Why make that problem worse?",
            "The opposition worries about longer appointed terms, but Measure I only adds months at most. They cite outdated reports and problems that Sunnyvale addressed years ago. They note mayoral elections can create vacancies, but Measure I doesn't affect this.",
            "The opposition's arguments simply don't make sense, and double elections don't either.",
            "Protect local democracy and maximize turnout. Learn more at www.YES-on-GHI.com, and vote YES on Measure I.",
            "/s/ Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "/s/ Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "/s/ Larry Stone | Former Sunnyvale Mayor and Former County Assessor",
            "/s/ Murali Srinivasan | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "/s/ Charlsie Chang | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Larry Klein | Sunnyvale Mayor",
            "Richard Mehlinger | Sunnyvale Vice Mayor",
            "Larry Stone | Former Sunnyvale Mayor and Former County Assessor",
            "Murali Srinivasan | Sunnyvale Councilmember",
            "Charlsie Chang | Sunnyvale Councilmember"
          ]
        }
      },
      "pro_short": "Larry Klein argues in the official guide: \"Vote YES to fix an expensive election flaw in our City Charter. Right now, when the City Council fills a vacancy by appointment, the Charter can require Sunnyvale to hold two elections for the same seat in the same year. one consolidated with a March or June primary, then another in November for the full term. Taxpayers pay for both. Candidates run two campaigns. The winner of the first election can serve as little as five months.\"",
      "con_short": "Stephen Scandalis argues in the official guide: \"Vote NO to avoid 2+ year appointments and avoid greater appointee incumbency advantage. Preserve earlier opportunities to vote. If passed, this will cut the eligible elections to fill vacancies by at least half. This is done by eliminating the existing requirement to use an earlier election consolidated with a statewide election, a primary election for example. Longer appointments and appointee incumbency advantage allows council to handpick successors. While you may like the current city council, that may change in 15-20 years. Do you want that council making extended appointments?\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sunnyvale-i",
      "number": "I",
      "county": "santa-clara",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-echd-s",
      "letter": "S",
      "jurisdiction": "special_district",
      "jurisdiction_name": "El Camino Healthcare District",
      "district": {
        "kind": "special",
        "id": "el-camino-healthcare-district"
      },
      "applies_to_precincts": [
        "3008"
      ],
      "title": "Limit District Directors to Four Four-Year Terms",
      "measure_type": "bylaw_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "majority",
      "vote_threshold_as_printed": "Majority Vote Required",
      "question": "Shall the measure amending the Bylaws of the El Camino Healthcare District to limit District Directors to four four-year terms be adopted?",
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Primary argument in favor (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-s-el-camino-healthcare-district-echd-primary-argument-in-favor_redacted.pdf?VersionId=WMZ_ALjnrC.OXzcX4sTcqpOqQyuWXdhR"
        },
        {
          "label": "Impartial analysis (PDF)",
          "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-08/measure-s-el-camino-healthcare-district-term-limit-ia-redacted-20260818.pdf?VersionId=xmPSrlttoIZIT1LZ.IX2_wKliVkdpmT3"
        },
        {
          "label": "Official accessible-guide source record",
          "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/published/06085/1968/vg/740_md.json"
        }
      ],
      "arguments_filed": {
        "argument_for": true,
        "rebuttal_to_for": false,
        "argument_against": false,
        "rebuttal_to_against": false
      },
      "arguments_note": "The registrar lists the primary argument against as \"(none filed)\".",
      "source_keys": [
        "scc:list-local-measures",
        "scc:district-lookup",
        "scc:sample-ballot-3008",
        "scc:accessible-s"
      ],
      "summary": "California law permits a district's governing body to propose a measure to limit the number of terms a member of the governing body may serve. Here, the Board of Directors of the El Camino Healthcare District (District) has placed on the ballot a Measure to amend the District Bylaws to limit District Directors to serving four (4) four-year terms. The District currently has no limit on the number of terms a Director may serve.",
      "yes_means": "A \"yes\" vote is a vote to amend the District Bylaws to prohibit District Directors from serving more than four full terms, for terms beginning on or after December 1, 2026.",
      "no_means": "A \"no\" vote is a vote to not amend the District Bylaws.",
      "fiscal_impact": "The official impartial analysis does not give a quantified estimate of costs or savings.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "impartial",
          "heading": "Impartial analysis by County Counsel",
          "paragraphs": [
            "California law permits a district's governing body to propose a measure to limit the number of terms a member of the governing body may serve. Here, the Board of Directors of the El Camino Healthcare District (District) has placed on the ballot a Measure to amend the District Bylaws to limit District Directors to serving four (4) four-year terms. The District currently has no limit on the number of terms a Director may serve.",
            "If a majority of voters approve this Measure, the District Bylaws will be amended to provide that:",
            "For terms beginning on or after December 1, 2026, no person may serve more than four full terms as a District Director;",
            "If for any reason a District Director serves a partial term—such as when a Director is appointed to fill a vacancy—that partial term shall not be counted as a term for purposes of the four-term limit; and",
            "Terms served prior to December 1, 2026, whether full or partial, are not included toward the maximum number of terms.",
            "A \"yes\" vote is a vote to amend the District Bylaws to prohibit District Directors from serving more than four full terms, for terms beginning on or after December 1, 2026.",
            "A \"no\" vote is a vote to not amend the District Bylaws.",
            "Tony LoPresti | County Counsel",
            "By: /s/ Nick DeFiesta | Deputy County Counsel"
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "California law permits a district's governing body to propose a measure to limit the number of terms a member of the governing body may serve. Here, the Board of Directors of the El Camino Healthcare District (District) has placed on the ballot a Measure to amend the District Bylaws to limit District Directors to serving four (4) four-year terms. The District currently has no limit on the number of terms a Director may serve."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "If a majority of voters approve this Measure, the District Bylaws will be amended to provide that:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "For terms beginning on or after December 1, 2026, no person may serve more than four full terms as a District Director;"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "If for any reason a District Director serves a partial term—such as when a Director is appointed to fill a vacancy—that partial term shall not be counted as a term for purposes of the four-term limit; and"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Terms served prior to December 1, 2026, whether full or partial, are not included toward the maximum number of terms."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A \"yes\" vote is a vote to amend the District Bylaws to prohibit District Directors from serving more than four full terms, for terms beginning on or after December 1, 2026."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A \"no\" vote is a vote to not amend the District Bylaws."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Tony LoPresti | County Counsel"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "By: /s/ Nick DeFiesta | Deputy County Counsel"
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Measure S will establish term limits for the El Camino Healthcare District Board of Directors. It is commonsense reform.",
            "Good governance requires fresh perspectives. El Camino Healthcare District serves our entire community, and our Board of Directors should reflect that community, not a small group of long-tenured insiders who face no structural incentive to make way for new voices.",
            "This measure establishes a straightforward limit: no Director may serve more than four full four-year terms. That is 16 years of service—a meaningful commitment. The measure ensures fairness: only full terms count. Directors who briefly fill a vacancy or complete an unexpired term will not be penalized. The limit applies only to terms beginning on or after December 1, 2026, so only future terms are affected.",
            "Term limits work. They create opportunities for qualified candidates, including those who have been underrepresented, to run for seats that would otherwise remain occupied indefinitely. They reduce entrenchment and the institutional resistance to change. And they ensure that our Board stays accountable to the community it serves, not simply to the habits and relationships of long-term incumbents.",
            "El Camino Healthcare District has a proud record of service. This measure protects that record by ensuring our Board continues to earn the public's trust through accountability, renewal, and openness to new leadership.",
            "Vote YES on Measure S",
            "/s/ Julia E. Miller | Board Secretary, El Camino Healthcare District Board"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Julia E. Miller | Board Secretary, El Camino Healthcare District Board"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "not_submitted",
          "paragraphs": [],
          "signers": []
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "not_submitted",
          "paragraphs": [],
          "signers": []
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "not_submitted",
          "paragraphs": [],
          "signers": []
        }
      },
      "pro_short": "Julia E. Miller argues in the official guide: \"Measure S will establish term limits for the El Camino Healthcare District Board of Directors. It is commonsense reform. Good governance requires fresh perspectives. El Camino Healthcare District serves our entire community, and our Board of Directors should reflect that community, not a small group of long-tenured insiders who face no structural incentive to make way for new voices.\"",
      "con_short": "No argument against Measure S was submitted to the official voter guide.",
      "contest_id": "local-echd-s",
      "number": "S",
      "county": "santa-clara",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-a",
      "letter": "A",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "Charter Changes Affecting Various City Departments and Commissions",
      "measure_type": "charter_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "MAYOR LURIE & SUPERMAJORITY OF SUPERVISORS SAY YES ON PROP A TO CLEAN UP OUR OUTDATED CHARTER.",
            "About every 30 years, City Hall sets aside its differences to clean up old, broken, and conflicting parts of our city’s governing document called the city charter.",
            "Department heads, commissions, and the public suggest changes through a transparent, months-long process. The mayor and a supermajority of the Board of Supervisors agreed on 110 small fixes that will help city government serve you better.",
            "The fixes fall into four categories:",
            "OUTDATED TECHNOLOGY New technology can make old laws pointless. For example, the current system still requires the city to employ a bookbinder and to publish laws in daily print editions of the Chronicle that no longer exist.",
            "WASTEFUL DUPLICATION Sometimes two city departments are required to do the exact same job. For example, multiple departments being required to create the same report, forcing employees into busy work that wastes time and money.",
            "ZOMBIE COMMISSIONS Our bureaucracy has 60 advisory bodies and commissions that can’t be updated without a vote at the ballot. After decades the charter can end up with zombie commissions that serve no purpose. For example, the Sanitation and Streets Commission oversees a department that doesn’t exist, and the charter still references a Parking Authority that voters removed a decade ago.",
            "CONFUSING OR BADLY WORDED LAWS Lawmakers sometimes make typos and mistakes when writing legislation, leaving behind laws that are confusing or just don’t make sense. Prop A cleans up some of the worst examples.",
            "VOTE YES ON PROP A THE CITYWIDE GOOD GOVERNMENT CONSENSUS MEASURE",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Supervisor Alan Wong Supervisor Bilal Mahmood Supervisor Chyanne Chen Supervisor Danny Sauter Supervisor Matt Dorsey Supervisor Myrna Melgar Supervisor Steven Sherrill State Senator Scott Wiener Assemblywoman Catherine Stefani Assemblyman Matt Haney"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Supervisor Alan Wong Supervisor Bilal Mahmood Supervisor Chyanne Chen Supervisor Danny Sauter Supervisor Matt Dorsey Supervisor Myrna Melgar Supervisor Steven Sherrill State Senator Scott Wiener Assemblywoman Catherine Stefani Assemblyman Matt Haney"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "A love letter to San Francisco",
            "What makes San Francisco special? Is it the views, the hills, the parks, the food, the victorians? A big part of what is special about San Francisco is San Franciscans. We are active and informed. We stand up for what we believe in! We get involved in the things we are passionate about. We believe in flourishing democracies. Prop A is taking a lot of that away.",
            "A healthy democracy requires a balance of power. A healthy government has plenty of citizen participation. Debate leads us to the best answers. These are all reasons to vote No on A.",
            "Our current city government as represented by our elected officials is primarily monolithic, representing monied and corporate interests, whether couched in suave niceties or smug indifference.",
            "They are trying to take away much of what makes San Francisco special. They all go along with each other, no matter how bad the idea is, as long as Trump’s billionaires benefit.",
            "When you boil it down, today’s San Francisco needs to protect people power more than ever.",
            "Reject the power grab. No SF Kings.",
            "Vote No on A and while you’re at it, Vote No on D E and F.",
            "Coalition on Homelessness"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Coalition on Homelessness"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The charter should be improved, but not at the expense of transparency, and checks on government power. There are grievous mistakes in Prop A that threaten participatory democracy by removing commissions put in place by voters.",
            "Take independent oversight for November 2018 Proposition C. The measure allows the Board of Supervisors to remove independent oversight with a majority vote. Prop C, “Our City, Our Home”, is a deeply vetted people’s initiative placed on the ballot by Coalition on Homelessness alongside over 700 housed/unhoused volunteers and supported by 215,491 voters. It is a tax on mega corporations to fund homeless solutions. Due to careful planning by the oversight body, the fund has housed over 8,400 people, including 2,800 children, thousands prevented from becoming homeless, and receiving behavioral health treatment services.",
            "Rising rents up and down the west coast have skyrocketed homelessness. Unlike west coast cities without a local revenue measure, SF has seen a steady decline in street homelessness. Portland saw an enourmous 67% increase and San Diego a 26% increase in 2024. SF was poised to see exploding homelessness due to the pandemic, but planning by the oversight body staved that off.",
            "While Prop C has been wildly successful, progress is at risk. Rising rents create a dire need for using funds to permanently solve and prevent homelessness. The oversight body is charged with digging into data and centering unhoused people’s needs including hidden needs of homeless children. Each year they struggle against Mayoral Administrations who favor ruling by sound bites, and shiny failed quick fixes over data driven proven solutions.",
            "Prop A attempts to silence the voices of homeless people and their allies that challenge power, and this particular body was targeted only because of its effectiveness in doing so.",
            "No on A.",
            "Coalition on Homelessness"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Coalition on Homelessness"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Prop A is a good government housekeeping measure that cleans up and modernizes San Francisco’s lengthy, outdated charter to serve you better.",
            "Currently five separate, overlapping commissions oversee homeless services in San Francisco. None of them are removed by Prop A.",
            "But right now, even small administrative updates to some of these commissions — like adjusting how often they meet, or the qualifications of their members — have to go before voters as a ballot measure.",
            "Making such routine updates should not be delayed through an entire election cycle or require hundreds of thousands of dollars in campaign costs. Prop A lets the Board handle those small fixes through ordinary legislation instead.",
            "Requiring a citywide election to fix a typo or fix outdated language isn’t democracy, it just makes City Hall less accountable for delivering results for voters.",
            "Join us as we make San Francisco’s charter serve you better!",
            "VOTE YES ON PROP A — THE GOOD GOVERNMENT CONSENSUS MEASURE",
            "Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Mayor Daniel Lurie"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Mayor Daniel Lurie"
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 64",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=66"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Proposition A would align the Charter with how some City departments currently operate, change some processes, and eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies. Proposition A would require the Board of Supervisors to amend voter-approved laws to enact some of these changes. Proposition A would: • change the language of the Charter to reflect how some City departments currently operate in order to clarify responsibilities and update rules, procedures, and reporting requirements. • change some processes. For example: allowing legal settlements to be approved by resolution instead of by ordinance. • require a task force to meet every ten years to recommend changes to commissions. • eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies by, for example: eliminating some commissions and advisory bodies, combining and renaming some advisory bodies, and moving some commissions and advisory bodies from the Charter into the Municipal Code.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want to amend the Charter to align it with how some City departments currently operate, change some processes, eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies, and require the Board of Supervisors to amend voter-approved laws to enact some of these changes.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a moderate impact on the cost of government, saving $365,000 to $450,000 annually. Additional costs and savings are dependent on the decisions that the Mayor and Board of Supervisors make through the normal budget process.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: The Charter is the City’s constitution and establishes the organization, powers, and responsibilities for many City departments. The Charter and other voter-approved laws also create many City commissions and advisory bodies and describe their powers, duties, membership and removal rules, and reporting requirements.",
            "Over time, some of these laws have become obsolete.",
            "The Charter and most laws passed by the voters can only be changed with voter approval.",
            "The Proposal: Proposition A would align the Charter with how some City departments currently operate, change some processes, and eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies. Proposition A would require the Board of Supervisors to amend voter-approved laws to enact some of these changes.",
            "Proposition A would:",
            "• change the language of the Charter to reflect how some City departments currently operate in order to clarify responsibilities and update rules, procedures, and reporting requirements. • change some processes. For example: allowing legal settlements to be approved by resolution instead of by ordinance. • require a task force to meet every ten years to recommend changes to commissions. • eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies by, for example: eliminating some commissions and advisory bodies, combining and renaming some advisory bodies, and moving some commissions and advisory bodies from the Charter into the Municipal Code.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to amend the Charter to align it with how some City departments currently operate, change some processes, eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies, and require the Board of Supervisors to amend voter-approved laws to enact some of these changes.",
            "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: The Charter is the City’s constitution and establishes the organization, powers, and responsibilities for many City departments. The Charter and other voter-approved laws also create many City commissions and advisory bodies and describe their powers, duties, membership and removal rules, and reporting requirements."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Over time, some of these laws have become obsolete."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Charter and most laws passed by the voters can only be changed with voter approval."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Proposal: Proposition A would align the Charter with how some City departments currently operate, change some processes, and eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies. Proposition A would require the Board of Supervisors to amend voter-approved laws to enact some of these changes."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition A would:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• change the language of the Charter to reflect how some City departments currently operate in order to clarify responsibilities and update rules, procedures, and reporting requirements. • change some processes. For example: allowing legal settlements to be approved by resolution instead of by ordinance. • require a task force to meet every ten years to recommend changes to commissions. • eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies by, for example: eliminating some commissions and advisory bodies, combining and renaming some advisory bodies, and moving some commissions and advisory bodies from the Charter into the Municipal Code."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to amend the Charter to align it with how some City departments currently operate, change some processes, eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies, and require the Board of Supervisors to amend voter-approved laws to enact some of these changes."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition A:",
            "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a moderate impact on the cost of government, saving $365,000 to $450,000 annually. Additional costs and savings are dependent on the decisions that the Mayor and Board of Supervisors make through the normal budget process.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment (1) modifies boards, commissions, and advisory bodies; (2) changes departmental operations and reporting requirements; (3) changes how the Board of Supervisors must approve settlements or dismissals of legal proceedings recommended by the City Attorney; (4) removes provisions allowing disciplinary action against non-Police and Fire striking employees; and (5) makes other edits and changes to the Charter and past voter-approved ordinances. The Charter amendment may reduce required staff time to support boards, commissions, and advisory bodies—freeing staff to work on other government functions.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment creates cost savings ranging from $365,000 to $450,000 annually by eliminating",
            "the Sanitation and Streets Commission, Public Works Commission, and the Street Artists and Craftsmen Examiners Advisory Committee. The Sanitation and Streets Commission and Public Works Commission shared two full-time staff members with annual costs of $336,000.",
            "Convening the Commission Streamlining Task Force (CSTF) every ten years would require staff to implement and administer the CSTF, including conducting analyses, writing public reports, and holding public meetings. The proposed Charter amendment removes the existing requirements for the Budget and Legislative Analyst to prepare a report and the City Attorney to prepare a draft Charter amendment implementing the CTSF’s recommendations from CSTF’s mandate. For context, convening the CSTF in 2025 required approximately 5,900 hours of staff time.",
            "Additional costs and savings are dependent on the decisions that the Mayor and Board of Supervisors make through the normal budget process. For example, the proposed Charter amendment removes the restriction on compensating Youth Commission members which may lead to future costs, likely ranging from $5,000 to $85,000 annually, should policymakers seek compensation for the members. Certain appointive boards and commissions pay stipends to the commissioners on a per meeting basis ranging from $25 to $500 per meeting. Other commissioners are paid between $100 and $500 per month. Not all commissioners receive stipends. The amount of cost savings attributed to removing the requirement of hiring an executive secretary for commissions cannot be determined at this time as bodies may opt not to fill the position.",
            "The proposed amendment updates commission responsibilities and membership requirements for remaining commissions and boards but will not directly impact the total cost to government. The amount of staff time needed to support commissions and boards may decrease—freeing staff to work on other government functions, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time.",
            "Note that the proposed amendment would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition A:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a moderate impact on the cost of government, saving $365,000 to $450,000 annually. Additional costs and savings are dependent on the decisions that the Mayor and Board of Supervisors make through the normal budget process."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment (1) modifies boards, commissions, and advisory bodies; (2) changes departmental operations and reporting requirements; (3) changes how the Board of Supervisors must approve settlements or dismissals of legal proceedings recommended by the City Attorney; (4) removes provisions allowing disciplinary action against non-Police and Fire striking employees; and (5) makes other edits and changes to the Charter and past voter-approved ordinances. The Charter amendment may reduce required staff time to support boards, commissions, and advisory bodies—freeing staff to work on other government functions."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment creates cost savings ranging from $365,000 to $450,000 annually by eliminating"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "the Sanitation and Streets Commission, Public Works Commission, and the Street Artists and Craftsmen Examiners Advisory Committee. The Sanitation and Streets Commission and Public Works Commission shared two full-time staff members with annual costs of $336,000."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Convening the Commission Streamlining Task Force (CSTF) every ten years would require staff to implement and administer the CSTF, including conducting analyses, writing public reports, and holding public meetings. The proposed Charter amendment removes the existing requirements for the Budget and Legislative Analyst to prepare a report and the City Attorney to prepare a draft Charter amendment implementing the CTSF’s recommendations from CSTF’s mandate. For context, convening the CSTF in 2025 required approximately 5,900 hours of staff time."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Additional costs and savings are dependent on the decisions that the Mayor and Board of Supervisors make through the normal budget process. For example, the proposed Charter amendment removes the restriction on compensating Youth Commission members which may lead to future costs, likely ranging from $5,000 to $85,000 annually, should policymakers seek compensation for the members. Certain appointive boards and commissions pay stipends to the commissioners on a per meeting basis ranging from $25 to $500 per meeting. Other commissioners are paid between $100 and $500 per month. Not all commissioners receive stipends. The amount of cost savings attributed to removing the requirement of hiring an executive secretary for commissions cannot be determined at this time as bodies may opt not to fill the position."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed amendment updates commission responsibilities and membership requirements for remaining commissions and boards but will not directly impact the total cost to government. The amount of staff time needed to support commissions and boards may decrease—freeing staff to work on other government functions, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Note that the proposed amendment would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City amend the Charter to align it with how some City departments currently operate, change some processes, eliminate or reorganize certain commissions and advisory bodies, and require the Board of Supervisors to amend voter-approved laws to enact some of these changes?",
      "pro_short": "Mayor Daniel Lurie argues in the official pamphlet: \"MAYOR LURIE & SUPERMAJORITY OF SUPERVISORS SAY YES ON PROP A TO CLEAN UP OUR OUTDATED CHARTER. About every 30 years, City Hall sets aside its differences to clean up old, broken, and conflicting parts of our city’s governing document called the city charter.…\"",
      "con_short": "Coalition on Homelessness argues in the official pamphlet: \"The charter should be improved, but not at the expense of transparency, and checks on government power. There are grievous mistakes in Prop A that threaten participatory democracy by removing commissions put in place by voters. Take independent oversight for November 2018 Proposition C. The measure allows the Board of Supervisors to remove independent oversight with a majority vote. Prop…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-a",
      "number": "A",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-b",
      "letter": "B",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "Establishing a Municipal Finance Corporation and a Public Bank",
      "measure_type": "charter_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Prop B will ensure that a San Francisco Public Bank is fiscally responsible, independent from political influence, and serves San Francisco’s priorities.",
            "A Public Bank puts the people of San Francisco over private profits to finance the things we need. The shareholders would be the people of San Francisco, so we benefit not only from our bank’s profits but also the San Francisco projects it supports.",
            "Prop B is a crucial step in creating a Public Bank. A Public Bank will provide affordable loans for:",
            "• Affordable housing development, • Affordable homeownership, • Small business development, • Environmental sustainability, and • Environmental justice.",
            "Prop B ensures that the Public Bank will be run by banking professionals, not politicians, and creates a public oversight body, so every San Franciscan has the opportunity to monitor and provide input. A public bank is about making sure San Franciscans’ money benefits San Franciscans.",
            "Passing Prop B now allows us to take advantage of the time-limited state law that enables local cities to create public banks. A public bank creates a powerful new tool to address some of our city’s most urgent priorities. Public banking is a proven development model. Globally 25% of banking assets are held in public banks, and Germany holds 40% of its banking assets in public banks.",
            "Prop B establishes the purpose and structure of a public bank. Prop B is not a tax, and will not raise taxes for San Franciscans.",
            "The San Francisco Foundation San Francisco Public Bank Coalition District 11 Supervisor Chyanne Chen District 5 Supervisor Bilal Mahmood District 7 Supervisor Myrna Melgar District 8 Supervisor Rafael Mandelman District 9 Supervisor Jackie Fielder District 10 Supervisor Shamann Walton San Francisco Labor Council San Francisco Climate Emergency Coalition Affordable Housing Alliance San Francisco Tenants Union"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "The San Francisco Foundation San Francisco Public Bank Coalition District 11 Supervisor Chyanne Chen District 5 Supervisor Bilal Mahmood District 7 Supervisor Myrna Melgar District 8 Supervisor Rafael Mandelman District 9 Supervisor Jackie Fielder District 10 Supervisor Shamann Walton San Francisco Labor Council San Francisco Climate Emergency Coalition Affordable Housing Alliance San Francisco Tenants Union"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "San Francisco’s financial support for housing, infrastructure and small business is limited for good reason. Proposition B empowers the far left to dismantle and politicize those limits.",
            "A “public bank” is a politically directed lending machine that puts billions of taxpayer dollars at risk. The Controller estimates $310-$460 million just to capitalize and operate it. Once the Bank takes deposits, the City can park rainy-day funds and investment-pool reserves inside it, multiplying the risk by lending and leverage. The Bank can issue securities bought by the City itself. High-risk loans inevitably go bad; the losses land on taxpayers.",
            "Public banking has a litany of failure. The Los Angeles Community Development Bank collapsed under a mountain of bad loans. Any bank whose mission is climate-justice, racial preferences and loans refused by private lenders is fundamentally unsound. California law requires FDIC insurance; no public bank has successfully obtained it while pursuing this radical agenda.",
            "Nothing in Proposition B meaningfully checks the Bank’s political priorities. Pressure will build for reparations-style lending and loans to non-citizens, unleashing a smear of red ink across the general fund.",
            "This is the same socialist model in Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib’s Public Banking Act, co-sponsored by Ilhan Omar and the Squad.",
            "Don’t be a piker.",
            "Vote No on Proposition B.",
            "Larry S. Marso, Esq.",
            "Mr. Marso, a Nob Hill resident, ran financial institution M&A practices at two Wall Street investment banks, represented banks and insurers as a New York attorney, and served as an economic analyst at the Federal Reserve Board."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Larry S. Marso, Esq. Mr. Marso, a Nob Hill resident, ran financial institution M&A practices at two Wall Street investment banks, represented banks and insurers as a New York attorney, and served as an economic analyst at the Federal Reserve Board."
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote No on Proposition B.",
            "Proposition B asks San Francisco voters to create a City Hall-controlled public bank and municipal finance corporation — without any dedicated funding, without proven demand, and at a time when the City already faces massive budget shortfalls.",
            "Supporters claim this will unlock affordable housing and small business lending. In reality, it creates a new politically appointed entity with the power to take significant financial risks using public resources. The City’s own working group previously estimated hundreds of millions of dollars would be needed to capitalize such an institution. Proposition B provides none of that capital. It simply builds the structure and leaves taxpayers holding the bag later.",
            "San Francisco already has tools to support housing and small businesses through existing programs, nonprofit lenders, and credit unions. Creating a new City-controlled bank adds bureaucracy, political risk, and potential conflicts of interest without solving the underlying problems of high costs and slow permitting.",
            "We cannot afford another ambitious, underfunded experiment. Vote No on Proposition B.",
            "— No on Prop B – San Franciscans for Fiscal Responsibility",
            "— Leslie Huang, Dorothy Joan Leone, Stephanie Jeong, and Kathleen Louise Trewin"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "— No on Prop B – San Franciscans for Fiscal Responsibility — Leslie Huang, Dorothy Joan Leone, Stephanie Jeong, and Kathleen Louise Trewin"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Proposition B is a simple measure. It establishes a San Francisco Public Bank, which could help fund housing, green energy, and small businesses, and sets rules to prevent the bank or its funds from being misused.",
            "As the opponents point out, Prop B is NOT a tax and will not raise taxes on residents or businesses.",
            "Opponents claim that the bank would be rife with political instability and risky lending, but that is untrue. Instead, it would be the most regulated bank in America, subject to all typical banking regulations of private banks, in addition to California regulations and the oversight systems of Prop B.",
            "Prop B empowers San Francisco to pursue funding for our bank from state, federal, and philanthropic sources. Opportunities like the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund in Biden’s Climate bill present billions of dollars San Francisco could access. These are opportunities we have missed out on because we do not have a MFC or Public Bank. We must pass Prop B to be ready for these generational opportunities.",
            "A Public Bank would support our existing nonprofit, city, and credit union ecosystem, making the most efficient use of taxpayer money.",
            "We can’t afford to miss this opportunity to build an economic engine to stabilize San Francisco and make sure money is going where it’s needed, for housing, green energy, and supporting our small businesses.",
            "Matt Dorsey, Supervisor Chyanne Chen, Supervisor San Francisco Labor Council San Francisco Public Bank Coalition The San Francisco Foundation"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Matt Dorsey, Supervisor Chyanne Chen, Supervisor San Francisco Labor Council San Francisco Public Bank Coalition The San Francisco Foundation"
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 70",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=72"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Proposition B would amend the City Charter to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation if the City has sufficient funding and resources. After three years of operation, the municipal finance corporation may become a public bank. The MFC would make loans but would not take deposits. If the MFC becomes a public bank, the public bank would make loans and also take deposits. The MFC and public bank would provide services to support: • affordable housing development, • affordable homeownership, • small business development, • environmental sustainability, and • environmental justice. These services would be available to individual City residents and to projects and businesses located in the City. Under Proposition B, the MFC and public bank would each be governed by a board of directors. Each board would be appointed and overseen by its own oversight commission. The members of each oversight commission would be appointed by the Board of Supervisors, Mayor, Treasurer-Tax Collector, Controller, and City Attorney.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation and a public bank.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation and a public bank.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would not directly impact the cost of government as the Charter amendment does not require the City to create a Municipal Finance Corporation (MFC) that could transition into a Public Bank. However, if the City moves forward with establishing a MFC and subsequently a Public Bank, as authorized by the proposed Charter amendment, the costs would be significant, ranging from approximately $310 million to $460 million over an eight-year period, according to 2023 Reinvestment Working Group (RWG) estimates, which could be significantly higher or lower depending on interest rates and changing economic conditions.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: A municipal finance corporation (MFC) is a government-owned non-profit corporation that makes loans but does not take deposits. A public bank is a government-owned non-profit corporation that both makes loans and takes deposits.",
            "There is no local law authorizing the City to create a municipal finance corporation or a public bank.",
            "The Proposal: Proposition B would amend the City Charter to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation if the City has sufficient funding and resources. After three years of operation, the municipal finance corporation may become a public bank.",
            "The MFC would make loans but would not take deposits. If the MFC becomes a public bank, the public bank would make loans and also take deposits.",
            "The MFC and public bank would provide services to support:",
            "• affordable housing development, • affordable homeownership, • small business development, • environmental sustainability, and • environmental justice.",
            "These services would be available to individual City residents and to projects and businesses located in the City.",
            "Under Proposition B, the MFC and public bank would each be governed by a board of directors. Each board would be appointed and overseen by its own oversight",
            "commission. The members of each oversight commission would be appointed by the Board of Supervisors, Mayor, Treasurer-Tax Collector, Controller, and City Attorney.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation and a public bank.",
            "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation and a public bank."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: A municipal finance corporation (MFC) is a government-owned non-profit corporation that makes loans but does not take deposits. A public bank is a government-owned non-profit corporation that both makes loans and takes deposits."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "There is no local law authorizing the City to create a municipal finance corporation or a public bank."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Proposal: Proposition B would amend the City Charter to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation if the City has sufficient funding and resources. After three years of operation, the municipal finance corporation may become a public bank."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The MFC would make loans but would not take deposits. If the MFC becomes a public bank, the public bank would make loans and also take deposits."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The MFC and public bank would provide services to support:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• affordable housing development, • affordable homeownership, • small business development, • environmental sustainability, and • environmental justice."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "These services would be available to individual City residents and to projects and businesses located in the City."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Under Proposition B, the MFC and public bank would each be governed by a board of directors. Each board would be appointed and overseen by its own oversight"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "commission. The members of each oversight commission would be appointed by the Board of Supervisors, Mayor, Treasurer-Tax Collector, Controller, and City Attorney."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation and a public bank."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation and a public bank."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition B:",
            "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would not directly impact the cost of government as the Charter amendment does not require the City to create a Municipal Finance Corporation (MFC) that could transition into a Public Bank. However, if the City moves forward with establishing a MFC and subsequently a Public Bank, as authorized by the proposed Charter amendment, the costs would be significant, ranging from approximately $310 million to $460 million over an eight-year period, according to 2023 Reinvestment Working Group (RWG) estimates, which could be significantly higher or lower depending on interest rates and changing economic conditions.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment sets up the governance framework for a new MFC and Public Bank. If the Charter amendment is approved, and the Treasurer-Tax Collector determines that adequate funding exists, the MFC and an MFC Oversight Commission may be established. In the",
            "event the MFC becomes financially sustainable, which is not guaranteed, the MFC may request state and federal regulatory approval to transition to a Public Bank.",
            "The funding required to set up an MFC could cost approximately $4 million annually for approximately one year or longer, depending on when the MFC is set up, excluding capitalization costs. These costs include the cost to hire staff, staff salaries, legal services, supporting professional services, technology procurement and administrative operations.",
            "In 2022, the County Local Area Formation Commission convened the RWG to develop a business and governance plan to establish a non-depository lending corporation. According to a 2023 report of the RWG, costs to capitalize and fund the MFC could cost approximately $26 million in the first year and increase to $30 million annually by the third year for a total of $90 million for the first three years of the MFC. The RWG explored a variety of capitalization and funding levels including cumulative totals of $45 million to $242 million over the first three years. Capitalization and funding costs could be financed by City grants and forgivable loans which are unlikely to be repaid. The capitalization and funding costs are choices dependent on future decisions by the MFC Board of Directors and future policy and budget decisions by the Mayor and the Board of Supervisors. The costs associated with establishing an MFC may be significantly higher or lower than the 2023 RWG estimates.",
            "In the event the MFC becomes financially sustainable and receives regulatory approval to operate as a depository bank, it may become a Public Bank. The cost to operate a Public Bank would be approximately $80 million in year 4, decreasing to approximately $30 to $40 million annually for a total of approximately $220 million over years four through eight. These costs include capital funds and operating costs, including staff salaries, office leases, technology, and administrative costs. The Public Bank may use its income to fund its operating costs if available, requiring less funding appropriated by the City.",
            "Finally, the MFC and Public Bank would require an MFC Oversight Commission or Bank Oversight Commission which could cost between $550,000 to $600,000 annually for staff salaries, commissioner stipends, and operating costs. There is a high degree of uncertainty in the cost to government of establishing an MFC or Public Bank. There may be significant unforeseen costs to the City in the event the Public Bank is not financially sustainable.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment gives a high degree of independence to the Oversight Commissions and the Board of Directors, such that the City would have limited control over the MFC’s or Public Bank’s financial outcomes and decisions on how funds would be used.",
            "Note that the proposed amendment would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition B:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would not directly impact the cost of government as the Charter amendment does not require the City to create a Municipal Finance Corporation (MFC) that could transition into a Public Bank. However, if the City moves forward with establishing a MFC and subsequently a Public Bank, as authorized by the proposed Charter amendment, the costs would be significant, ranging from approximately $310 million to $460 million over an eight-year period, according to 2023 Reinvestment Working Group (RWG) estimates, which could be significantly higher or lower depending on interest rates and changing economic conditions."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment sets up the governance framework for a new MFC and Public Bank. If the Charter amendment is approved, and the Treasurer-Tax Collector determines that adequate funding exists, the MFC and an MFC Oversight Commission may be established. In the"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "event the MFC becomes financially sustainable, which is not guaranteed, the MFC may request state and federal regulatory approval to transition to a Public Bank."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The funding required to set up an MFC could cost approximately $4 million annually for approximately one year or longer, depending on when the MFC is set up, excluding capitalization costs. These costs include the cost to hire staff, staff salaries, legal services, supporting professional services, technology procurement and administrative operations."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "In 2022, the County Local Area Formation Commission convened the RWG to develop a business and governance plan to establish a non-depository lending corporation. According to a 2023 report of the RWG, costs to capitalize and fund the MFC could cost approximately $26 million in the first year and increase to $30 million annually by the third year for a total of $90 million for the first three years of the MFC. The RWG explored a variety of capitalization and funding levels including cumulative totals of $45 million to $242 million over the first three years. Capitalization and funding costs could be financed by City grants and forgivable loans which are unlikely to be repaid. The capitalization and funding costs are choices dependent on future decisions by the MFC Board of Directors and future policy and budget decisions by the Mayor and the Board of Supervisors. The costs associated with establishing an MFC may be significantly higher or lower than the 2023 RWG estimates."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "In the event the MFC becomes financially sustainable and receives regulatory approval to operate as a depository bank, it may become a Public Bank. The cost to operate a Public Bank would be approximately $80 million in year 4, decreasing to approximately $30 to $40 million annually for a total of approximately $220 million over years four through eight. These costs include capital funds and operating costs, including staff salaries, office leases, technology, and administrative costs. The Public Bank may use its income to fund its operating costs if available, requiring less funding appropriated by the City."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Finally, the MFC and Public Bank would require an MFC Oversight Commission or Bank Oversight Commission which could cost between $550,000 to $600,000 annually for staff salaries, commissioner stipends, and operating costs. There is a high degree of uncertainty in the cost to government of establishing an MFC or Public Bank. There may be significant unforeseen costs to the City in the event the Public Bank is not financially sustainable."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment gives a high degree of independence to the Oversight Commissions and the Board of Directors, such that the City would have limited control over the MFC’s or Public Bank’s financial outcomes and decisions on how funds would be used."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Note that the proposed amendment would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City amend the Charter to authorize the City to establish a municipal finance corporation and a public bank?",
      "pro_short": "The San Francisco Foundation argues in the official pamphlet: \"Prop B will ensure that a San Francisco Public Bank is fiscally responsible, independent from political influence, and serves San Francisco’s priorities. A Public Bank puts the people of San Francisco over private profits to finance the things we need. The shareholders would be the people of San Francisco, so we benefit not only from our bank’s profits but also…\"",
      "con_short": "— No on Prop B argues in the official pamphlet: \"Vote No on Proposition B. Proposition B asks San Francisco voters to create a City Hall-controlled public bank and municipal finance corporation — without any dedicated funding, without proven demand, and at a time when the City already faces massive budget shortfalls.…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-b",
      "number": "B",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-c",
      "letter": "C",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "Contributions to the Housing Trust Fund",
      "measure_type": "charter_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "San Francisco’s housing crisis is simple: rents and home prices have climbed faster than paychecks, and teachers, nurses, and multigenerational families are being priced out of the neighborhoods they grew up in or serve. Proposition C won’t solve that alone, but it renews San Francisco’s most significant source of funding for affordable housing.",
            "For over a decade, the Housing Trust Fund has been San Francisco’s foundation for building affordable housing, helping first-time buyers purchase a home, keeping first responders in the city they serve, and giving seniors a way to stay in their communities.",
            "Prop C renews the Housing Trust Fund through 2058 and increases its annual funding to $125 million. Every year we wait, the fund stays capped while rents keep climbing.",
            "Prop C does not raise anyone’s taxes. It reallocates money the City already collects, and it is fiscally responsible by design. Funding only grows when the City’s own property tax or general fund revenue grows. The City can pause or reduce contributions during a real budget deficit. This is a careful, sustainable plan, not a blank check.",
            "That is why Prop C is a true consensus measure. It was placed on the ballot unanimously by the Board of Supervisors and supported by labor and housing advocates across the city.",
            "Prop C will build and rehabilitate affordable housing, fund down payment assistance for teachers and first responders, provide rent assistance to prevent seniors from being displaced, convert vacant lots into real housing, and fund needed infrastructure.",
            "Every dollar is legally dedicated to affordable housing and subject to independent audit.",
            "This is the responsible way to keep San Francisco affordable. Vote YES on Prop C.",
            "www.HomesforSF.com",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Supervisor Myrna Melgar Assemblymember Catherine Stefani Rebecca Foster, CEO Housing Accelerator Fund* Malcolm Yeung, CEO Chinatown Community Development Center*",
            "*For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Supervisor Myrna Melgar Assemblymember Catherine Stefani Rebecca Foster, CEO Housing Accelerator Fund* Malcolm Yeung, CEO Chinatown Community Development Center* *For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Yes campaign touts the long list of things Prop C could fund. That’s nothing to brag about. Prop C gives the Fund more money, more responsibilities, and more eligible recipients — spreading taxpayer dollars across an ever-broader mission. The more things a program is asked to do, the harder it is to prioritize, measure results, and hold anyone accountable.",
            "The promised “independent audit” is no substitute for performance standards. Prop C requires no minimum number of new homes, no maximum cost per unit, and no cost-effectiveness benchmark. An audit after the money is spent is no substitute for measurable results written into law.",
            "Before committing billions in taxpayer dollars through 2058, voters must demand measurable results, cost accountability, and fiscal discipline.",
            "Vote NO on Prop C.",
            "The San Francisco Republican Party"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "The San Francisco Republican Party"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "It Couldn’t Do the Job It Had. Now It Wants a Bigger One.",
            "San Francisco’s Housing Trust Fund was established in 2012 to help working families afford housing. It has failed. Local reporting calls the fund “a letdown” and “an existing program that has yielded little.” Since the fund’s creation, the cost to build a single affordable unit in San Francisco has roughly doubled, running close to $1 million per unit today.",
            "Instead of a fix, this measure doubles the fund’s size, locks it in for 30 more years, and stretches it thinner:",
            "– Raises the homebuyer income cap from 120% to 200% of “median income” — up to $402,000 for a family of four, in a city where the real median household income is $141,000. – Let’s the Board of Supervisors raise that cap again anytime, with no vote required. – Opens the fund to new uses like city-owned “social housing” and co-ops, all competing for the same dollars. – Swaps a specific, accountable neighborhood fund for a vague, open-ended one.",
            "Nothing in the measure requires a single additional unit to get built. There’s no unit target. No benchmark. Meanwhile, San Francisco remains tens of thousands of units short of its own housing goals.",
            "A program that already failed at one job doesn’t get fixed by giving it five new jobs and more money. Fix what’s broken first.",
            "Vote No on C.",
            "The San Francisco Republican Party"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "The San Francisco Republican Party"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Proposition C renews and expands a program San Francisco voters already created: the Housing Trust Fund, dedicated to building affordable homes, helping teachers and first responders become homeowners, and keeping seniors from losing their housing.",
            "It includes real fiscal guardrails. The City can freeze contributions during a genuine budget deficit and reduce them by up to 10 percent in years when it draws on the Rainy Day Reserve.",
            "Funding only grows when the City’s own property tax or general fund revenue grow. This is not a blank check. It is a formula built for both growth and restraint. Every dollar is legally restricted to affordable housing, homeownership assistance, and rent relief.",
            "San Francisco’s housing costs can’t wait. Teachers, nurses, and multigenerational families are being priced out right now, and the fund that helps them is set to run out.",
            "That is why Prop C earned support from elected leaders, organized labor, and housing advocates citywide. It is the responsible, accountable way to keep this program going without raising anyone’s taxes.",
            "Vote YES on Prop C.",
            "Supervisor Myrna Melgar Assemblymember Matt Haney, Chair of the Housing and Community Development Committee Bill Barnes, Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California Nicholas Lake, Teacher* Mario Flaherty, Secretary, San Francisco Firefighters Local 798*",
            "*For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Supervisor Myrna Melgar Assemblymember Matt Haney, Chair of the Housing and Community Development Committee Bill Barnes, Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California Nicholas Lake, Teacher* Mario Flaherty, Secretary, San Francisco Firefighters Local 798* *For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 78",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=80"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Proposition C would change how the City’s annual contributions to the Housing Trust Fund (HTF) are set, increase funding and expand programs for affordable housing, and extend the Fund’s expiration date. • Starting in 2028, the City’s annual contribution would grow based on the greater of either: • any increases in local property tax revenue, or • the percentage increase in the unrestricted General Fund from the prior year. The City would increase its contributions to the HTF until the annual contribution meets or exceeds $125 million. After that, annual increases are capped at 3% based on increases in the General Fund. The City could pause contributions when a projected City deficit exceeds $250 million. This threshold would be adjusted each year based on changes in the General Fund. The City could also reduce contributions by up to 10% during years when the City may use its Rainy Day Reserve. • Expand affordable housing programs by: • increasing funding to create and preserve more affordable housing; • raising the household income limit for downpayment assistance loans from 120% to 200% of AMI, and allow the Board of Supervisors to change that limit by ordinance; • replacing the grant program for specific types of neighborhood improvements by authorized spending on affordable housing-related infrastructure such as sidewalks, streets, and utilities; • extending the Fund’s expiration date from 2043 to 2058.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want to amend the Charter to change how the City’s annual contributions to the Housing Trust Fund are set, increase funding and expand programs for affordable housing, and extend the Fund to 2058.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a significant impact on the cost of government of approximately $6 million in additional General Fund costs starting in Fiscal Year 2028-29, growing over time to approximately $60 million annually by Fiscal Year 2034-35.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: The City has a Housing Trust Fund (HTF) to support the creation or preservation of affordable housing and affordable home ownership. Every year, the City provides funding to the HTF, and the annual contribution is adjusted up or down based on changes in the City’s unrestricted General Fund revenue. Last year, the City contributed $50.8 million to the HTF.",
            "The City may use HTF funds for:",
            "• building, purchasing, and improving affordable housing; • downpayment assistance loans for households earning up to 120% of Area Median Income (AMI) and for emergency first responders; • assistance to households earning up to 120% of AMI to improve their housing and avoid housing loss; • grant programs for specific types of neighborhood improvements; and • administrative costs.",
            "The Housing Trust Fund that supports these programs is set to expire in 2043.",
            "The Proposal: Proposition C would change how the City’s annual contributions to the Housing Trust Fund (HTF) are set, increase funding and expand programs for affordable housing, and extend the Fund’s expiration date.",
            "• Starting in 2028, the City’s annual contribution would grow based on the greater of either: • any increases in local property tax revenue, or • the percentage increase in the unrestricted General Fund from the prior year.",
            "The City would increase its contributions to the HTF until the annual contribution meets or exceeds $125 million. After that, annual increases are capped at 3% based on increases in the General Fund.",
            "The City could pause contributions when a projected City deficit exceeds $250 million. This threshold would be adjusted each year based on changes in the General Fund.",
            "The City could also reduce contributions by up to 10% during years when the City may use its Rainy Day Reserve.",
            "• Expand affordable housing programs by: • increasing funding to create and preserve more affordable housing; • raising the household income limit for downpayment assistance loans from 120% to 200% of AMI, and allow the Board of Supervisors to change that limit by ordinance; • replacing the grant program for specific types of neighborhood improvements by authorized spending on affordable housing-related infrastructure such as sidewalks, streets, and utilities; • extending the Fund’s expiration date from 2043 to 2058.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to amend the Charter to change how the City’s annual contributions to the Housing Trust Fund are set, increase funding and expand programs for affordable housing, and extend the Fund to 2058.",
            "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: The City has a Housing Trust Fund (HTF) to support the creation or preservation of affordable housing and affordable home ownership. Every year, the City provides funding to the HTF, and the annual contribution is adjusted up or down based on changes in the City’s unrestricted General Fund revenue. Last year, the City contributed $50.8 million to the HTF."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The City may use HTF funds for:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• building, purchasing, and improving affordable housing; • downpayment assistance loans for households earning up to 120% of Area Median Income (AMI) and for emergency first responders; • assistance to households earning up to 120% of AMI to improve their housing and avoid housing loss; • grant programs for specific types of neighborhood improvements; and • administrative costs."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Housing Trust Fund that supports these programs is set to expire in 2043."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Proposal: Proposition C would change how the City’s annual contributions to the Housing Trust Fund (HTF) are set, increase funding and expand programs for affordable housing, and extend the Fund’s expiration date."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Starting in 2028, the City’s annual contribution would grow based on the greater of either: • any increases in local property tax revenue, or • the percentage increase in the unrestricted General Fund from the prior year."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The City would increase its contributions to the HTF until the annual contribution meets or exceeds $125 million. After that, annual increases are capped at 3% based on increases in the General Fund."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The City could pause contributions when a projected City deficit exceeds $250 million. This threshold would be adjusted each year based on changes in the General Fund."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The City could also reduce contributions by up to 10% during years when the City may use its Rainy Day Reserve."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Expand affordable housing programs by: • increasing funding to create and preserve more affordable housing; • raising the household income limit for downpayment assistance loans from 120% to 200% of AMI, and allow the Board of Supervisors to change that limit by ordinance; • replacing the grant program for specific types of neighborhood improvements by authorized spending on affordable housing-related infrastructure such as sidewalks, streets, and utilities; • extending the Fund’s expiration date from 2043 to 2058."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to amend the Charter to change how the City’s annual contributions to the Housing Trust Fund are set, increase funding and expand programs for affordable housing, and extend the Fund to 2058."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition C:",
            "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a significant impact on the cost of government of approximately $6 million in additional General Fund costs starting in Fiscal Year 2028-29, growing over time to approximately $60 million annually by Fiscal Year 2034-35.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment is projected to increase the existing Housing Trust Fund (Fund) General Fund spending mandate for affordable housing and extends the mandate by an additional fifteen years from 2043 to 2058. A General Fund spending mandate is a voter-adopted spending requirement that directs the government to appropriate funding for specific purposes in future years without identifying a new funding source. For context, voter-adopted spending requirements currently total approximately $2 billion, or 30%, of the approximately $7 billion General Fund sources. Extending the life of the Housing Trust Fund and increasing contributions as projected would reallocate funds that would otherwise be available in the General Fund.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment modifies the required funding formula to accelerate the growth of the Fund until the annual contribution reaches $125 million, likely in Fiscal Year (FY) 2034-2035, at which point the growth of the fund could slow. For context, in FY2024-25, approximately $50 million was appropriated to the Fund. As compared to projected Fund contributions under current law, the proposed Charter amendment is projected to increase contributions to the fund by approximately $6 million in FY2028-29 and $13 million in FY2029-30. In subsequent years, the General Fund cost of the proposal is projected to grow by an additional $9 million annually, reaching approximately $60 million in additional growth by FY2034-35, resulting in a total expected contribution of $125 million in FY2034-35. Without the Charter amendment, the required funding formula is projected to be approximately $65 million in FY2034-35. The additional $60 million under the proposed modified funding formula represents the additional money the City would be required to appropriate into the Fund in FY2034-35 and subsequent years. The projected costs above do not assume temporary freezes or reductions in the City’s annual contribution to the Fund.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment allows the Mayor or the Board of Supervisors to introduce ordinances during the annual budget process to temporarily freeze or reduce the City’s annual contributions. If the City projects a budget deficit exceeding $250 million, the annual contribution to the Fund may be temporarily frozen at the then-current amount. If the City is authorized to withdraw funds from the City Rainy Day Reserve, the annual contribution to the Fund may be temporarily reduced by up to 10%.",
            "The fund may be used to (1) create, acquire, or rehabilitate affordable rental and ownership housing, (2) provide down payment loans and housing stabilization for qualified households meeting required income levels, and (3) fund housing-related infrastructure, including streetscape improvements. The Charter amendment removes obsolete language regarding (1) past allocations to the Fund, (2) eliminating the Fund before 2013, (3) how the Controller’s Office may determine General Fund Discretionary Revenue, and (4) discretion to reduce Fund contributions based on debt service for SB 2113 Affordable Housing Bonds. Additionally, the proposed Charter amendment eliminates the Complete Neighborhoods Infrastructure Grant Program, which has not been funded since FY2019-20.",
            "This proposed amendment is not in compliance with a non-binding, voter-adopted City policy regarding voter-adopted spending requirements. The policy seeks to limit General Fund spending mandates which reduce General Fund dollars that could otherwise be allocated by the Mayor and the Board of Supervisors in the annual budget process. For context, voter-adopted spending requirements currently total approximately $2 billion, or 30%, of the approximately $7 billion General Fund sources.",
            "Note that the proposed amendment would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition C:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a significant impact on the cost of government of approximately $6 million in additional General Fund costs starting in Fiscal Year 2028-29, growing over time to approximately $60 million annually by Fiscal Year 2034-35."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment is projected to increase the existing Housing Trust Fund (Fund) General Fund spending mandate for affordable housing and extends the mandate by an additional fifteen years from 2043 to 2058. A General Fund spending mandate is a voter-adopted spending requirement that directs the government to appropriate funding for specific purposes in future years without identifying a new funding source. For context, voter-adopted spending requirements currently total approximately $2 billion, or 30%, of the approximately $7 billion General Fund sources. Extending the life of the Housing Trust Fund and increasing contributions as projected would reallocate funds that would otherwise be available in the General Fund."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment modifies the required funding formula to accelerate the growth of the Fund until the annual contribution reaches $125 million, likely in Fiscal Year (FY) 2034-2035, at which point the growth of the fund could slow. For context, in FY2024-25, approximately $50 million was appropriated to the Fund. As compared to projected Fund contributions under current law, the proposed Charter amendment is projected to increase contributions to the fund by approximately $6 million in FY2028-29 and $13 million in FY2029-30. In subsequent years, the General Fund cost of the proposal is projected to grow by an additional $9 million annually, reaching approximately $60 million in additional growth by FY2034-35, resulting in a total expected contribution of $125 million in FY2034-35. Without the Charter amendment, the required funding formula is projected to be approximately $65 million in FY2034-35. The additional $60 million under the proposed modified funding formula represents the additional money the City would be required to appropriate into the Fund in FY2034-35 and subsequent years. The projected costs above do not assume temporary freezes or reductions in the City’s annual contribution to the Fund."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment allows the Mayor or the Board of Supervisors to introduce ordinances during the annual budget process to temporarily freeze or reduce the City’s annual contributions. If the City projects a budget deficit exceeding $250 million, the annual contribution to the Fund may be temporarily frozen at the then-current amount. If the City is authorized to withdraw funds from the City Rainy Day Reserve, the annual contribution to the Fund may be temporarily reduced by up to 10%."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The fund may be used to (1) create, acquire, or rehabilitate affordable rental and ownership housing, (2) provide down payment loans and housing stabilization for qualified households meeting required income levels, and (3) fund housing-related infrastructure, including streetscape improvements. The Charter amendment removes obsolete language regarding (1) past allocations to the Fund, (2) eliminating the Fund before 2013, (3) how the Controller’s Office may determine General Fund Discretionary Revenue, and (4) discretion to reduce Fund contributions based on debt service for SB 2113 Affordable Housing Bonds. Additionally, the proposed Charter amendment eliminates the Complete Neighborhoods Infrastructure Grant Program, which has not been funded since FY2019-20."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This proposed amendment is not in compliance with a non-binding, voter-adopted City policy regarding voter-adopted spending requirements. The policy seeks to limit General Fund spending mandates which reduce General Fund dollars that could otherwise be allocated by the Mayor and the Board of Supervisors in the annual budget process. For context, voter-adopted spending requirements currently total approximately $2 billion, or 30%, of the approximately $7 billion General Fund sources."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Note that the proposed amendment would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City amend the Charter to change how the City’s annual contributions to the Housing Trust Fund are set, increase funding and expand programs for affordable housing, and extend the Fund to 2058?",
      "pro_short": "Mayor Daniel Lurie argues in the official pamphlet: \"San Francisco’s housing crisis is simple: rents and home prices have climbed faster than paychecks, and teachers, nurses, and multigenerational families are being priced out of the neighborhoods they grew up in or serve. Proposition C won’t solve that alone, but it renews San Francisco’s most significant source of funding for affordable housing. For over a decade, the Housing Trust…\"",
      "con_short": "The San Francisco Republican Party argues in the official pamphlet: \"It Couldn’t Do the Job It Had. Now It Wants a Bigger One. San Francisco’s Housing Trust Fund was established in 2012 to help working families afford housing. It has failed. Local reporting calls the fund “a letdown” and “an existing program that has yielded little.” Since the fund’s creation, the cost to build a single affordable unit in San…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-c",
      "number": "C",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-d",
      "letter": "D",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "Changes to Ballot Measure Process",
      "measure_type": "charter_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Clean Up City Hall is a package of Props A, D, E and F to improve neighborhood services, speed up permitting and reduce wasteful spending so we can invest in our great city.",
            "PROPOSITION D GIVES MORE VOTERS A VOICE ON WHAT APPEARS ON BALLOTS.",
            "Currently a minority of supervisors, just 2% of voters or the mayor acting alone, can throw anything on the ballot without public input, transparency or proven community support.",
            "“Even well-intentioned ideas can include mistakes and unintended consequences.” - Ben Hur, former SF Ethics Chair.",
            "San Francisco is the only city in California that allows these low thresholds — and that’s why we have the longest and most confusing ballots in the state.",
            "PROP D REQUIRES MORE TRANSPARENCY, COMPROMISE & COMMUNITY INPUT.",
            "Proposition D requires a public vote of the majority of supervisors or signatures from 8% of voters. It removes the mayor’s sole authority to place measures on the ballot to ensure a fair balance of power. The signature requirement remains below the state standard of 10% and neighboring cities like Oakland.",
            "THE RESULT OF THESE MODEST REFORMS WILL BE MORE OPEN DEBATE AND CITIZEN PARTICIPATION BEFORE MEASURES ARE ON THE BALLOT.",
            "San Francisco works best when we work in coalitions together. Please join the citywide coalition to make the system accountable to all!",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi Nancy Tung, San Francisco Democratic Party Former SF Ethics Chair Ben Hur Former Deputy City Attorney Jim Lazarus SFSU Associate Professor of Political Science Jason McDaniel Former City Controller Ben Rosenfield Former Fire Chief Joanne Hayes-White Dan Calamuci, Carpenters Local 22* Anthony Travis Jr., Laborers Local 261* Charles Lavery, Operating Engineers Local 3* Teamsters Local 665 Council of District Merchant Associations Chinatown History and Culture Association",
            "*For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi Nancy Tung, San Francisco Democratic Party Former SF Ethics Chair Ben Hur Former Deputy City Attorney Jim Lazarus SFSU Associate Professor of Political Science Jason McDaniel Former City Controller Ben Rosenfield Former Fire Chief Joanne Hayes-White Dan Calamuci, Carpenters Local 22* Anthony Travis Jr., Laborers Local 261* Charles Lavery, Operating Engineers Local 3* Teamsters Local 665 Council of District Merchant Associations Chinatown History and Culture Association *For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "No on D: It silences San Francisco voters",
            "Proponents call it “modest reform.” A fourfold increase is not modest. It’s extreme.",
            "Quadrupling signature requirements from 10,600 to 42,500 will require hiring paid signature firms to qualify and cost one million dollars or more.",
            "That extreme cost will price out neighborhood groups, unions and community advocates from participating in the initiative process.",
            "Proponents have raised $8.6 million, collected from a small number of billionaires and venture capitalists. They can afford the higher costs. But the rest of us can’t.",
            "Ending citizen initiatives won’t move San Francisco forwards. Instead, it takes us back to 1898, when San Francisco became one of the first California cities to win this right.",
            "If this passes, San Francisco will have the highest signature requirement of any California county. Higher than Los Angeles and San Jose. Over three times higher than statewide measures which require 2.4%.",
            "Proponents want you to believe that raising the threshold from 2% to 8% is modest. But that’s like raising your rent from $2000 to $8000. It’s extreme – and extremely harmful.",
            "Don’t be fooled. Don’t rob our right to vote. Vote NO on D.",
            "San Francisco Labor Council San Francisco Senior & Disability Action United Educators of San Francisco San Francisco Women’s Political Committee San Francisco Tenants Union Indivisible SF Coleman Advocates for Children & Youth San Francisco Rising Action Fund"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "San Francisco Labor Council San Francisco Senior & Disability Action United Educators of San Francisco San Francisco Women’s Political Committee San Francisco Tenants Union Indivisible SF Coleman Advocates for Children & Youth San Francisco Rising Action Fund"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "NO ON D: DON’T ROB OUR RIGHT TO VOTE.",
            "Don’t be fooled. This isn’t about streamlining or state standards. Prop D takes away rights San Franciscans have held for 125 years: to put citizen initiatives on the ballot.",
            "Robbing it away. San Francisco was the first California city to have this right. Now, wealthy tech billionaires are spending millions to take it away. They would quadruple the signatures required from 10,600 to 42,500, a limit so high only the very wealthy can reach it.",
            "Follow the money. Wealthy interests can afford to pay one million dollars to collect 42,500 signatures. Neighborhood groups, labor unions and community advocates will be priced out. We’ll lose our voice in the democratic process.",
            "10,600 signatures is tough and fair. Since 1932, around 10,600 signatures have been required to qualify a measure. It’s not easy: citizen-initiatives are only 15% of all ballot measures. But when City Hall ignores us, citizens have the power to act. A check and balance.",
            "42,500 signatures is out of reach. It will be impossible for citizen-led, grassroots organizations to qualify a measure. After 125 years, it will silence the voices of some San Franciscans forever.",
            "Citizens’ initiatives make a difference. They have increased the minimum wage, ensured large corporations pay their fair share of taxes, provided legal aid for renters facing eviction, banned corrupt contributions to politicians, passed Sunshine laws, established rent control, and funded schools, childcare and affordable housing.",
            "After 125 years of direct democracy, don’t let them rob it away. Vote NO on D.",
            "San Francisco Labor Council San Francisco Senior & Disability Action United Educators of San Francisco San Francisco Women’s Political Committee San Francisco Tenants Union Indivisible SF Community Tenants Association Coleman Advocates for Children & Youth San Francisco Rising Action Fund"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "San Francisco Labor Council San Francisco Senior & Disability Action United Educators of San Francisco San Francisco Women’s Political Committee San Francisco Tenants Union Indivisible SF Community Tenants Association Coleman Advocates for Children & Youth San Francisco Rising Action Fund"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "D ENDS THE INSIDER MONOPOLY ON POWER AT THE BALLOT",
            "The insiders are misleading voters because their monopoly on power is being challenged. They think the system works great. San Franciscans know the system is broken: keeping us in a constant state of confusion, dividing neighbors, and producing bad outcomes.",
            "D is a set of modest reforms requiring transparency, compromise, and community input before issues get on the ballot so that voters can weigh in on well thought-out measures. None of these reforms add a financial cost.",
            "D REBALANCES POWER TO VOTERS",
            "Currently a minority of supervisors, just 2% of voters, or the mayor acting alone can throw anything on the ballot without public input, transparency, or proven community support. Political insiders exploit these rules regularly. That is why San Francisco has the longest and most confusing ballots in the state.",
            "D REQUIRES TRANSPARENCY, COMPROMISE AND COMMUNITY INPUT.",
            "With D, placing a measure on the ballot requires a public vote of a majority of the Supervisors or a modest amount of signatures. D also removes the mayor’s sole authority to place measures on the ballot, ensuring a fair balance of power.",
            "Opponents claim today’s rules date to 1932. The Controller’s report confirms the current threshold was set in 2022, requiring approximately 9,000 fewer signatures than before. San Francisco will still have one of the lowest signature thresholds in California, including other large cities like Oakland, San Diego, and Long Beach.",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Former Controller Ben Rosenfield"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Former Controller Ben Rosenfield"
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 84",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=86"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Proposition D would amend the Charter to increase the requirements to put measures on the ballot by: • Increasing the number of signatures required to place a signature initiative on the ballot from 2% to 8% (currently from about 10,600 to about 42,500 signatures) of the registered voters in San Francisco. • Increasing the number of signatures required to call a special election on an ordinance from 10% of the votes cast for Mayor in the last election to 10% of the registered voters in San Francisco. Currently, this is about 53,100 signatures. Proposition D would allow signature initiatives to be withdrawn up to 102 days before the election. Proposition D would also change the requirements to put measures on the ballot by: • Removing the ability of four or more Board members to place a measure on the ballot without a Board vote; • Removing the ability of the Mayor to independently place a measure on the ballot; The Board could still place measures on the ballot by a majority vote.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want to increase the requirements for signature initiatives from 2% to 8% of registered voters (currently from about 10,600 to about 42,500 signatures), increase the requirements for special elections, allow signature initiatives to be withdrawn, and remove the ability of a minority of Board members or the Mayor to place measures on the ballot.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a minimal impact on the cost of government.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: The San Francisco Board of Supervisors (Board) has 11 members. A measure can be either an ordinance to change the law or a declaration of policy. Under the City Charter, measures can be placed on the ballot in several ways, including:",
            "• By a majority vote of the Board; • By four or more Board members without a Board vote; • By the Mayor without a Board vote; or • By a signature initiative (petition) signed by at least 2% of the registered voters in San Francisco, currently about 10,600 signatures.",
            "Currently San Francisco has over 530,000 registered voters.",
            "Signature initiatives usually appear on the ballot at the next regularly scheduled election.",
            "Signature initiatives may call for an earlier “special” election on an ordinance if the petition is signed by at least 10% of the votes cast for all candidates for Mayor in the last election. Currently, this is about 39,000 signatures.",
            "Once a signature initiative is submitted to the Department of Elections, it cannot be withdrawn.",
            "The Proposal: Proposition D would amend the Charter to increase the requirements to put measures on the ballot by:",
            "• Increasing the number of signatures required to place a signature initiative on the ballot from 2% to 8% (currently from about 10,600 to about 42,500 signatures) of the registered voters in San Francisco.",
            "• Increasing the number of signatures required to call a special election on an ordinance from 10% of the votes cast for Mayor in the last election to 10% of the registered voters in San Francisco. Currently, this is about 53,100 signatures.",
            "Proposition D would allow signature initiatives to be withdrawn up to 102 days before the election.",
            "Proposition D would also change the requirements to put measures on the ballot by:",
            "• Removing the ability of four or more Board members to place a measure on the ballot without a Board vote; • Removing the ability of the Mayor to independently place a measure on the ballot;",
            "The Board could still place measures on the ballot by a majority vote.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to increase the requirements for signature initiatives from 2% to 8% of registered voters (currently from about 10,600 to about 42,500 signatures), increase the requirements for special elections, allow signature initiatives to be withdrawn, and remove the ability of a minority of Board members or the Mayor to place measures on the ballot.",
            "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: The San Francisco Board of Supervisors (Board) has 11 members. A measure can be either an ordinance to change the law or a declaration of policy. Under the City Charter, measures can be placed on the ballot in several ways, including:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• By a majority vote of the Board; • By four or more Board members without a Board vote; • By the Mayor without a Board vote; or • By a signature initiative (petition) signed by at least 2% of the registered voters in San Francisco, currently about 10,600 signatures."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Currently San Francisco has over 530,000 registered voters."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Signature initiatives usually appear on the ballot at the next regularly scheduled election."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Signature initiatives may call for an earlier “special” election on an ordinance if the petition is signed by at least 10% of the votes cast for all candidates for Mayor in the last election. Currently, this is about 39,000 signatures."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Once a signature initiative is submitted to the Department of Elections, it cannot be withdrawn."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Proposal: Proposition D would amend the Charter to increase the requirements to put measures on the ballot by:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Increasing the number of signatures required to place a signature initiative on the ballot from 2% to 8% (currently from about 10,600 to about 42,500 signatures) of the registered voters in San Francisco."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Increasing the number of signatures required to call a special election on an ordinance from 10% of the votes cast for Mayor in the last election to 10% of the registered voters in San Francisco. Currently, this is about 53,100 signatures."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition D would allow signature initiatives to be withdrawn up to 102 days before the election."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition D would also change the requirements to put measures on the ballot by:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Removing the ability of four or more Board members to place a measure on the ballot without a Board vote; • Removing the ability of the Mayor to independently place a measure on the ballot;"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Board could still place measures on the ballot by a majority vote."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to increase the requirements for signature initiatives from 2% to 8% of registered voters (currently from about 10,600 to about 42,500 signatures), increase the requirements for special elections, allow signature initiatives to be withdrawn, and remove the ability of a minority of Board members or the Mayor to place measures on the ballot."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition D:",
            "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a minimal impact on the cost of government.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment would (1) require the approval of a majority of the Board of Supervisors to place an ordinance on the ballot, (2) eliminate the Mayor’s ability to directly place an ordinance on the ballot, (3) increase the voter signature threshold for initiatives from 2% to 8% (currently from about 10,600 to about 42,500 signatures) of the registered voters in San Francisco, (4) allow proponents to withdraw a measure after it qualifies for the ballot, and (5) raise the threshold for special elections from 10% of the votes for mayor in the last general municipal election to 10% of registered voters.",
            "The proposed amendment is likely to reduce costs at levels that cannot be determined at this time. Since the proposed Charter amendment raises the voter signature threshold, fewer initiatives may qualify for the ballot which may reduce the volume of printed pages included in the voter information pamphlet (VIP). On average, each page in the VIP costs $11,400 to prepare, print, and distribute to all registered voters. The proposed increase in the voter signature threshold may also reduce the number of special elections called which would result in cost savings for the Department of Elections. The estimated minimum cost for a citywide special election is $5 million with a one-card ballot and less than 50-page VIP.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment may impact the Department of Elections’ workload. It may result in a reduction in ballot ordinances which would reduce the associated workload for the Department of Elections— freeing staff to work on other government functions. Conversely, the Department of Elections may see an increase in workload to validate more voter signatures for a measure to qualify for the ballot and to remove qualified measures at the proponents’ request."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition D:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a minimal impact on the cost of government."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment would (1) require the approval of a majority of the Board of Supervisors to place an ordinance on the ballot, (2) eliminate the Mayor’s ability to directly place an ordinance on the ballot, (3) increase the voter signature threshold for initiatives from 2% to 8% (currently from about 10,600 to about 42,500 signatures) of the registered voters in San Francisco, (4) allow proponents to withdraw a measure after it qualifies for the ballot, and (5) raise the threshold for special elections from 10% of the votes for mayor in the last general municipal election to 10% of registered voters."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed amendment is likely to reduce costs at levels that cannot be determined at this time. Since the proposed Charter amendment raises the voter signature threshold, fewer initiatives may qualify for the ballot which may reduce the volume of printed pages included in the voter information pamphlet (VIP). On average, each page in the VIP costs $11,400 to prepare, print, and distribute to all registered voters. The proposed increase in the voter signature threshold may also reduce the number of special elections called which would result in cost savings for the Department of Elections. The estimated minimum cost for a citywide special election is $5 million with a one-card ballot and less than 50-page VIP."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment may impact the Department of Elections’ workload. It may result in a reduction in ballot ordinances which would reduce the associated workload for the Department of Elections— freeing staff to work on other government functions. Conversely, the Department of Elections may see an increase in workload to validate more voter signatures for a measure to qualify for the ballot and to remove qualified measures at the proponents’ request."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City amend the Charter to increase the requirements for signature initiatives from 2% to 8% of registered voters in San Francisco (currently from about 10,600 to about 42,500 signatures), increase the requirements for calling special elections, allow signature initiatives to be withdrawn before an election, and remove the ability of a minority of Board of Supervisors members or the Mayor to place measures on the ballot?",
      "pro_short": "Mayor Daniel Lurie argues in the official pamphlet: \"Clean Up City Hall is a package of Props A, D, E and F to improve neighborhood services, speed up permitting and reduce wasteful spending so we can invest in our great city. PROPOSITION D GIVES MORE VOTERS A VOICE ON WHAT APPEARS ON BALLOTS.…\"",
      "con_short": "San Francisco Labor Council argues in the official pamphlet: \"NO ON D: DON’T ROB OUR RIGHT TO VOTE. Don’t be fooled. This isn’t about streamlining or state standards. Prop D takes away rights San Franciscans have held for 125 years: to put citizen initiatives on the ballot.…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-d",
      "number": "D",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-e",
      "letter": "E",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "City Administrator’s Authority and Changes to City Contracting",
      "measure_type": "charter_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Over decades, San Francisco’s governing system - or city charter - has increasingly grown to reward city insiders. Mayor Lurie is leading a citywide coalition to make the system more accountable to everyday San Franciscans.",
            "Clean Up City Hall is a package of Props A, D, E and F to improve neighborhood services, speed up permitting and reduce wasteful spending so we can invest in our great city.",
            "PROP E SLASHES WASTE IN CITY CONTRACTING. It can cost more than $25,000 to run a single contracting process. Basic purchases take years to deliver. Costs balloon out of control. That’s because every year San Francisco hands out more than $5 billion in contracts with no limited oversight or accountability. The system creates waste at every level and is easily exploited.",
            "STOPS CORRUPT DEALMAKING. Investigators have caught six department heads running contracting schemes in the last five years. Multiple department heads have gone to prison. E empowers a professional City Administrator to set transparent standards so contracts are awarded based on who is best for the job, not who is best connected.",
            "MORE ACCOUNTABILITY FOR BETTER RESULTS. “San Francisco pays thousands of businesses and nonprofits but doesn’t have a contracting system built for results. E ensures public dollars are invested in better and faster city services instead of lost to waste and delay.” - Ben Rosenfield, former San Francisco Controller",
            "STRONGER CHECKS AND BALANCES. The mayor or a board majority can reject proposed contracting changes within 60 days, ensuring accountability runs through the entire system.",
            "San Francisco works best when we work in coalitions together. Please join the citywide coalition to make the system accountable to all!",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi Nancy Tung, San Francisco Democratic Party Former SF Ethics Chair Ben Hur Former Deputy City Attorney Jim Lazarus SFSU Associate Professor of Political Science Jason McDaniel Former City Controller Ben Rosenfield Former Fire Chief Joanne Hayes-White Firefighters Local 798 SF Building Trades Dan Calamuci, Carpenters Local 22* Anthony Travis Jr., Laborers Local 261* Charles Lavery, Operating Engineers Local 3* Teamsters Local 665 Council of District Merchant Associations Chinatown History and Culture Association",
            "*For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi Nancy Tung, San Francisco Democratic Party Former SF Ethics Chair Ben Hur Former Deputy City Attorney Jim Lazarus SFSU Associate Professor of Political Science Jason McDaniel Former City Controller Ben Rosenfield Former Fire Chief Joanne Hayes-White Firefighters Local 798 SF Building Trades Dan Calamuci, Carpenters Local 22* Anthony Travis Jr., Laborers Local 261* Charles Lavery, Operating Engineers Local 3* Teamsters Local 665 Council of District Merchant Associations Chinatown History and Culture Association *For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Mayor Lurie scours the city with paid signature gatherers. He has not recruited pragmatist candidates to challenge ideologues and obstructionists on the Board of Supervisors, or built a working majority to pass his agenda legislatively. He treats checks and balances as the enemy, and seeks to concentrate power in his own hands through Propositions D, E and F.",
            "Similar patterns appear in his aggressive advocacy for Proposition H, the massive parcel tax to prop up MUNI. Rather than force real reform of a stultified, bloated agency, he asks voters to lock in $2.4 billion in new taxes to continue its bleeding pre-pandemic, pre-technology model of mostly empty steel cages. Proposition H subsidizes low-ridership service, weak fare enforcement and bureaucratic inertia.",
            "Look around! Autonomous vehicles promise radical cost declines and flexible mobility. While tired climate rhetoric demands everyone abandon their cars, automobiles have become cleaner, electric, driverless, shareable, robotic and able-assisting. The future is arriving. Mayor Lurie remains allergic to it.",
            "The mayor refuses to clean his own party’s house amidst rising extremism. He seeks permanent new executive power and sweeping new taxes harking back to glory days of big infrastructure. These are authoritarian, socialist impulses he should be fighting.",
            "Don’t be a piker.",
            "Vote No on D, E, F... and H!",
            "Larry S. Marso, Esq.",
            "Mr. Marso, a Nob Hill resident, was ballot opponent of the 2024 $400 million MUNI bond—rejected by voters in a tremendous victory for taxpayers!"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Larry S. Marso, Esq. Mr. Marso, a Nob Hill resident, was ballot opponent of the 2024 $400 million MUNI bond—rejected by voters in a tremendous victory for taxpayers!"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The current Board of Supervisors refuses to enact Mayor Daniel Lurie’s core priorities—to cut the deficit, trim bureaucracy, centralize contracting and hold department heads accountable. However Lurie, instead of challenging head-on the far-left socialists and obstructionist ideologues of his own party to get pragmatist Supervisors elected, treats the system of checks and balances itself as the enemy. He raised millions for paid signature gatherers to rewrite the City Charter and concentrate power in his hands.",
            "This is the authoritarian temptation. Fearing radicals inside their own coalition, leaders turn against institutional constraints that limit their personal power. SPUR stated the impulse with chilling clarity: a mayor should “resolve issues through leadership rather than at the ballot”—translation: by mayoral decree. Democratic procedure just gets in the way.",
            "That same impulse drives presidents who prefer executive orders to the harder work of defeating “in name only” members of their own party who block their agenda.",
            "One measure expands City Administrator authority, raising the dollar threshold for Supervisor approval of major contracts. Another revives deputy mayors—a patronage system exposed by Quentin Kopp and abolished by voters in 1991—while amplifying the mayor’s power to hire, fire and reorganize. The third quadruples the signature requirement for citizen initiatives, after Lurie himself used the low bar he now seeks to close, locking the door behind him.",
            "Most of what Lurie claims these changes would deliver could be achieved through legislation and regular order if he led his own party toward fiscal discipline, drove the most ideological members off the Board and fought the increasing far-left extremism infecting Democrat leadership. Instead, he flirts with the same breed of authoritarianism.",
            "Don’t be a piker.",
            "Vote No on D, E, and F.",
            "Larry S. Marso, Esq."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Larry S. Marso, Esq."
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROP E IS IS ABOUT ENDING WASTE AND CORRUPTION IN CITY CONTRACTING",
            "Under our current system, San Francisco became an international punch line when it was announced that one public toilet in Noe Valley would cost $1.7 million dollars to build.",
            "Under our current system, multiple city employees, including 6 department heads, were investigated for running contracting schemes that landed some of them in prison.",
            "Under our current system, it costs more than $25,000 to run a single contracting process, and simple purchases drag on for years.",
            "But the city continues to hand out $6 billion in contracts a year without the oversight and accountability that common sense demands.",
            "How the city buys staplers, builds public restrooms, or purchases software can’t be a political football.",
            "Prop E empowers a professional City Administrator to set clear, transparent rules for who gets city contracts. It’s a necessary step to end waste, fraud, and ballooning costs that frankly should have been done decades ago.",
            "City Hall insiders want to keep our current system because it works for them. But San Francisco voters have made it clear that it’s time for a change.",
            "Join us in bringing sanity back to purchasing and contracting.",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Former Controller Ben Rosenfield"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Former Controller Ben Rosenfield"
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 94",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=96"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Proposition E would: • Rules Regulating Purchasing: Give the City Administrator exclusive authority to propose ordinances that change how the City selects contractors and enters into contracts for goods, services, construction, and grants (Purchasing). The Board and Mayor may not amend the ordinances, but they can: • Approve or reject the ordinances within 60 days, or • If no action is taken within 60 days, the ordinances would be approved. Proposition E does not change the current Board authority for Purchasing ordinances that mainly address wages, workplace health and safety, utilization of local business, or labor agreements. • Board Approval of Various Agreements: Increase the dollar amount requiring Board approval to: • Contracts and leases that bring in $4,500,000 or more in revenue to the City, • Contracts that cost the City $25,000,000 or more. Starting in 2032, the City’s Controller would adjust these dollar amounts every five years for inflation. Proposition E would require Board approval for major amendments to these agreements. • City Administrator’s Term: Increase the City Administrator’s term from five to ten years. • City Administrator’s Authority: The City Administrator would set Purchasing rules and processes for all goods, services, construction, and grants that all City departments must follow, except as limited by other laws. Most departments would now be subject to the City Administrator’s authority regarding technology policies and the disposal of City personal property. These rules would override those departments’ conflicting rules and policies.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want to give the City Administrator more authority by centralizing the City’s Purchasing rules and processes, changing how the City approves Purchasing rules, changing when contracts and leases require Board approval, and extending the City Administrator’s term.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a minimal impact on the cost of government, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: The City Administrator’s Office is responsible for most of the City’s purchasing. However, authority for the City’s purchasing and technology is shared among the City Administrator’s Office, the Board of Supervisors, the Mayor, and some City departments.",
            "• Rules Regulating Purchasing: The Board of Supervisors (Board) may adopt ordinances that set the rules about how the City selects contractors and enters into contracts for goods, services, construction, and grants (referred to below as Purchasing).",
            "• Board Approval of Various Agreements: With some exceptions, the City’s Charter requires the Board to approve:",
            "• Contracts and leases that bring in $1,000,000 or more in revenue to the City, and • Contracts that cost the City $10,000,000 or more.",
            "The Board must also approve certain amendments to these agreements.",
            "• City Administrator’s Term: The Mayor appoints the City Administrator to a five-year term, subject to Board approval.",
            "• City Administrator’s Authority: The City Administrator sets Purchasing rules and processes governing goods and services except for some goods and services of the Municipal Transportation Agency, Public Utilities Commission, Port Commission, and some arts departments. The City Administrator also oversees technology policies and manages disposal of City personal property for most departments.",
            "The Proposal: Proposition E would:",
            "• Rules Regulating Purchasing: Give the City Administrator exclusive authority to propose ordinances that change how the City selects contractors and enters into contracts for goods, services, construction, and grants (Purchasing). The Board and Mayor may not amend the ordinances, but they can:",
            "• Approve or reject the ordinances within 60 days, or • If no action is taken within 60 days, the ordinances would be approved.",
            "Proposition E does not change the current Board authority for Purchasing ordinances that mainly address wages, workplace health and safety, utilization of local business, or labor agreements.",
            "• Board Approval of Various Agreements: Increase the dollar amount requiring Board approval to:",
            "• Contracts and leases that bring in $4,500,000 or more in revenue to the City, • Contracts that cost the City $25,000,000 or more.",
            "Starting in 2032, the City’s Controller would adjust these dollar amounts every five years for inflation.",
            "Proposition E would require Board approval for major amendments to these agreements.",
            "• City Administrator’s Term: Increase the City Administrator’s term from five to ten years.",
            "• City Administrator’s Authority: The City Administrator would set Purchasing rules and processes for all goods, services, construction, and grants that all City departments must follow, except as limited by other laws. Most departments would now be subject to the",
            "City Administrator’s authority regarding technology policies and the disposal of City personal property. These rules would override those departments’ conflicting rules and policies.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to give the City Administrator more authority by centralizing the City’s Purchasing rules and processes, changing how the City approves Purchasing rules, changing when contracts and leases require Board approval, and extending the City Administrator’s term.",
            "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: The City Administrator’s Office is responsible for most of the City’s purchasing. However, authority for the City’s purchasing and technology is shared among the City Administrator’s Office, the Board of Supervisors, the Mayor, and some City departments."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Rules Regulating Purchasing: The Board of Supervisors (Board) may adopt ordinances that set the rules about how the City selects contractors and enters into contracts for goods, services, construction, and grants (referred to below as Purchasing)."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Board Approval of Various Agreements: With some exceptions, the City’s Charter requires the Board to approve:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Contracts and leases that bring in $1,000,000 or more in revenue to the City, and • Contracts that cost the City $10,000,000 or more."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Board must also approve certain amendments to these agreements."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• City Administrator’s Term: The Mayor appoints the City Administrator to a five-year term, subject to Board approval."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• City Administrator’s Authority: The City Administrator sets Purchasing rules and processes governing goods and services except for some goods and services of the Municipal Transportation Agency, Public Utilities Commission, Port Commission, and some arts departments. The City Administrator also oversees technology policies and manages disposal of City personal property for most departments."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Proposal: Proposition E would:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Rules Regulating Purchasing: Give the City Administrator exclusive authority to propose ordinances that change how the City selects contractors and enters into contracts for goods, services, construction, and grants (Purchasing). The Board and Mayor may not amend the ordinances, but they can:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Approve or reject the ordinances within 60 days, or • If no action is taken within 60 days, the ordinances would be approved."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition E does not change the current Board authority for Purchasing ordinances that mainly address wages, workplace health and safety, utilization of local business, or labor agreements."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Board Approval of Various Agreements: Increase the dollar amount requiring Board approval to:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Contracts and leases that bring in $4,500,000 or more in revenue to the City, • Contracts that cost the City $25,000,000 or more."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Starting in 2032, the City’s Controller would adjust these dollar amounts every five years for inflation."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition E would require Board approval for major amendments to these agreements."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• City Administrator’s Term: Increase the City Administrator’s term from five to ten years."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• City Administrator’s Authority: The City Administrator would set Purchasing rules and processes for all goods, services, construction, and grants that all City departments must follow, except as limited by other laws. Most departments would now be subject to the"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Administrator’s authority regarding technology policies and the disposal of City personal property. These rules would override those departments’ conflicting rules and policies."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to give the City Administrator more authority by centralizing the City’s Purchasing rules and processes, changing how the City approves Purchasing rules, changing when contracts and leases require Board approval, and extending the City Administrator’s term."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition E:",
            "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a minimal impact on the cost of government, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment would (1) give the City Administrator the exclusive authority to introduce ordinances that govern City contracting, with some exceptions; (2) grant the City Administrator the authority to set Citywide rules for contracting; (3) provide the City Administrator the authority to establish policies, standards, and practices for technology uses across departments; (4) extend the City Administrator’s term from five to ten years; (5) increase the Board of Supervisors’ approval threshold from $1 million to $4.5 million for revenue generating contracts and real property lease agreements; and (6) increase in the Board of Supervisors’ approval threshold from $10 million to $25 million for expenditure contracts.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment gives the City Administrator greater authority to set contract standards, by introducing ordinances or adopting rules, regulations or policies, which may allow for greater efficiencies in citywide contracting. The proposed amendment establishes a more unified City procurement approach, which may result in reduced costs for the purchase of goods or services and staff time savings in the long run. The amendment may result in changed staffing but does not specify organizational or staffing changes within the City.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment also increases the Board of Supervisors’ contract approval monetary thresholds. These changes may reduce the amount of time the Board of Supervisors spend reviewing contracts and the time department staff spend preparing for the Board of Supervisors’ review, freeing the Board of Supervisors, their staff, and department staff to work on other government functions, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition E:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a minimal impact on the cost of government, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment would (1) give the City Administrator the exclusive authority to introduce ordinances that govern City contracting, with some exceptions; (2) grant the City Administrator the authority to set Citywide rules for contracting; (3) provide the City Administrator the authority to establish policies, standards, and practices for technology uses across departments; (4) extend the City Administrator’s term from five to ten years; (5) increase the Board of Supervisors’ approval threshold from $1 million to $4.5 million for revenue generating contracts and real property lease agreements; and (6) increase in the Board of Supervisors’ approval threshold from $10 million to $25 million for expenditure contracts."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment gives the City Administrator greater authority to set contract standards, by introducing ordinances or adopting rules, regulations or policies, which may allow for greater efficiencies in citywide contracting. The proposed amendment establishes a more unified City procurement approach, which may result in reduced costs for the purchase of goods or services and staff time savings in the long run. The amendment may result in changed staffing but does not specify organizational or staffing changes within the City."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment also increases the Board of Supervisors’ contract approval monetary thresholds. These changes may reduce the amount of time the Board of Supervisors spend reviewing contracts and the time department staff spend preparing for the Board of Supervisors’ review, freeing the Board of Supervisors, their staff, and department staff to work on other government functions, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City amend the Charter to give the City Administrator more authority by centralizing the City’s purchasing rules and processes, changing how the City approves purchasing rules, changing when contracts and leases require Board of Supervisors approval, and extending the City Administrator’s term?",
      "pro_short": "Mayor Daniel Lurie argues in the official pamphlet: \"Over decades, San Francisco’s governing system - or city charter - has increasingly grown to reward city insiders. Mayor Lurie is leading a citywide coalition to make the system more accountable to everyday San Franciscans. Clean Up City Hall is a package of Props A, D, E and F to improve neighborhood services, speed up permitting and reduce wasteful spending…\"",
      "con_short": "Larry S. Marso, Esq. argues in the official pamphlet: \"The current Board of Supervisors refuses to enact Mayor Daniel Lurie’s core priorities—to cut the deficit, trim bureaucracy, centralize contracting and hold department heads accountable. However Lurie, instead of challenging head-on the far-left socialists and obstructionist ideologues of his own party to get pragmatist Supervisors elected, treats the system of checks and balances itself as the enemy. He raised millions…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-e",
      "number": "E",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-f",
      "letter": "F",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "Changes to Executive Branch Management",
      "measure_type": "charter_amendment",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Over decades, San Francisco’s governing system - or city charter - has increasingly grown to reward city insiders. Mayor Lurie is leading a citywide coalition to make the system more accountable to everyday San Franciscans.",
            "Clean Up City Hall is a package of Props A, D, E and F to improve neighborhood services, speed up permitting and reduce wasteful spending so we can invest in our great city.",
            "PROP F TACKLES CITY HALL CORRUPTION. The current system allows departments to operate as independent fiefdoms instead of coordinated parts of government. It protects the insiders instead of holding them accountable. Six department heads have been indicted or investigated for corruption in the last decade. The mayor can only hire and remove a handful of department heads when self-dealing is exposed or they fail to do their job.",
            "CLEAR LINES OF ACCOUNTABILITY. Allowing the mayor to hire and remove most of their department heads will ensure city officials are accountable to the public.",
            "BETTER ORGANIZED DEPARTMENTS FOR BETTER RESULTS. Better organized and more accountable departments will deliver faster permits, cleaner streets and projects done on time and on budget.",
            "EXPOSES SELF-DEALING. “Departments that act as their own kingdoms are where corruption can grow. F makes it clear that every department head is ultimately accountable to the people of San Francisco” - Louise Renne, former San Francisco City Attorney & CA Deputy Attorney General",
            "STRENGTHENS CHECKS AND BALANCES. The Board of Supervisors will still have oversight over city departments and a majority of the Board can reject any changes the mayor makes. Watchdog commissions like Ethics and police oversight remain fully independent.",
            "San Francisco works best when we work in coalitions together. Please join the citywide coalition to make the system accountable to all!",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi Nancy Tung, San Francisco Democratic Party Former Deputy City Attorney Jim Lazarus SFSU Associate Professor of Political Science Jason McDaniel Former City Controller Ben Rosenfield Former Fire Chief Joanne Hayes-White Firefighters Local 798 SF Building Trades Dan Calamuci, Carpenters Local 22* Anthony Travis Jr., Laborers Local 261* Charles Lavery, Operating Engineers Local 3* Teamsters Local 665 Council of District Merchant Associations Chinatown History and Culture Association",
            "*For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi Nancy Tung, San Francisco Democratic Party Former Deputy City Attorney Jim Lazarus SFSU Associate Professor of Political Science Jason McDaniel Former City Controller Ben Rosenfield Former Fire Chief Joanne Hayes-White Firefighters Local 798 SF Building Trades Dan Calamuci, Carpenters Local 22* Anthony Travis Jr., Laborers Local 261* Charles Lavery, Operating Engineers Local 3* Teamsters Local 665 Council of District Merchant Associations Chinatown History and Culture Association *For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "NO ON F — FAILS TO SOLVE CORRUPTION. EMPOWERS BILLIONAIRES.",
            "Proponents say they want to stop corruption. But if that’s the assignment, Prop F gets an F. It concentrates power in the executive, stripping away checks and balances. That will only enable corruption - just look at Washington.",
            "PROP F GIVES MAYORS SWEEPING NEW POWERS to alter departments’ core objectives, merge and eliminate departments without a single public hearing. Even if you trust this Mayor, Prop F puts this power in the hands of all future Mayors. A Mayor could also fire appointed commissioners without cause, undermining independent citizen oversight.",
            "MAYORS CAN ALREADY EASILY REMOVE CORRUPT OFFICIALS. They need only demonstrate misconduct or convince a majority of the Board of Supervisors. But Prop F lets the Mayor unilaterally remove public servants who’ve done nothing wrong. That’s a recipe for politically-motivated removals of whistleblowers who would expose corruption.",
            "BILLIONAIRES BACK PROP F FOR A REASON. Local tech billionaires spent over $8 million to get Propositions D, E, and F on the ballot. The ultra-rich rarely bankroll campaigns out of the goodness of their hearts. Like the billionaires funding our President’s White House ballroom, they expect something in return. Prop F makes the Mayor’s office a one-stop shop for them to buy influence and override democratic input.",
            "Prop F deserves a failing grade. Vote no.",
            "Democratic Socialists of America - San Francisco Jackie Fielder, San Francisco Supervisor* Dean Preston, Former San Francisco Supervisor* Theresa Imperial, Former San Francisco Planning Commissioner* Sophia Andary, Commissioner, San Francisco Commission on the Status of Women*",
            "*For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Jackie Fielder, San Francisco Supervisor* Dean Preston, Former San Francisco Supervisor* Theresa Imperial, Former San Francisco Planning Commissioner* Sophia Andary, Commissioner, San Francisco Commission on the Status of Women* *For identification purposes only; author is signing as an individual and not on behalf of an organization."
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Clean Up City Hall campaign has spent over 4 million dollars to put 3 Charter measures on the ballot favoring the Mayor and wealthy corporate interests. • These measures were never heard by the Board. • 5 of 11 Board Supervisors have declined to endorse them. • They had no public scrutiny and have had no cost analysis. • These are NOT consensus measures",
            "Prop F removes essential checks & balances. Today, the Board of Supervisors and Oversight Commissions have opportunities to hold public hearings and approve changes to department leadership, structure and spending. Checks and balances are essential to good governance and ensuring that the public has opportunities to give comment to substantial changes that will impact the delivery of services.",
            "EVEN IF you do like this Mayor & trust this Mayor to have your interests in mind, you may not like or trust the next Mayor or the one after that.",
            "And concentrating so much power in the hands of one person can lead to disastrous effects that parallel what we’ve seen in DC.",
            "Simply put, Prop F goes too far. • It allows the Mayor to remove Commissioners for any reason not just cause. Removing commissioner’s ability to effectively question the policies and spending of the departments they’re supposed to be overseeing. • It allows the Mayor to hire and fire Department Heads without Commission hearings • Even more problematic It allows the Mayor to re-arrange Departments, combining their staff – or eliminating Departments altogether. And the Board will then only have 60 days to object or the Mayor’s changes go into effect without a single public hearing.",
            "Vote No on F to keep essential checks and balances the Board of Supervisors and Oversight Commissions provide.",
            "Small Business Forward"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Small Business Forward"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "PROP F CAME FROM AN OPEN, COLLABORATIVE PROCESS. Mayor Lurie and Board President Mandelman convened San Francisco’s first citywide Charter Reform Working Group in decades, followed by dozens of stakeholder meetings and labor negotiations leading to real compromise. The City Controller has completed a full cost analysis, and the citywide coalition of people across the political spectrum backing these common sense reforms is broad and growing.",
            "CHECKS AND BALANCES STAY INTACT. Watchdog agencies like ethics and police oversight remain fully independent. No department functions can be eliminated without a vote of the people. The executive branch can only combine services where costly overlaps slow down city services, like Planning and DBI.",
            "HOLDS DEPARTMENT HEADS ACCOUNTABLE. The system allows departments to operate as independent fiefdoms. Department heads have been indicted, and when self dealing is exposed, the mayor can’t easily remove them.",
            "COMMISSIONERS ANSWER TO THE PUBLIC. Commission seats have long been handed out as rewards, with no accountability to voters. F doesn’t eliminate a single commission, but lets the Mayor and Board remove commissioners who don’t show up, don’t do the work, or are corrupt.",
            "F isn’t about one person. It’s about making government work for everyday people, no matter who holds office. The insiders are misleading because they are being challenged. They think the system works great. San Franciscans know the system is broken.",
            "It’s time for a change.",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Former Controller Ben Rosenfield"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Board of Supervisors President Rafael Mandelman Former Controller Ben Rosenfield"
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 100",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=102"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Proposition F would amend the Charter to allow the Mayor to do the following: • Transfer of Functions: Transfer responsibilities between most departments or combine departments under a single department head, regardless of whether the Department was established by ordinance or Charter and as long as the Board does not object. The Mayor cannot eliminate any responsibilities established by Charter. The Mayor could also assign the oversight of these transferred responsibilities to that department’s commission. The Mayor cannot transfer responsibilities of these departments: • City Administrator, Controller, Board of Appeals, Port, Airport, Asian Art Museum, Fine Arts Museums, San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency, Public Utilities Commission, Civil Service Commission, Department of Human Resources, Retirement Board, Health Service System, Department of Elections, Ethics Commission, or departments headed by other elected officials. The responsibilities of the Department of Police Accountability cannot be transferred to the Police Department, and the responsibilities of the Sheriff’s Inspector General cannot be transferred to the Sheriff. • Deputy Mayors: Hire deputy mayors to supervise most departments established by the Charter. • Department Heads: Hire some and fire most department heads without board or commission involvement. The Mayor cannot hire or fire certain department heads that are exempt (see List of Exemptions in Words You Need To Know). • Commissioners: In addition to the Mayor, the Board and other officials who appoint board and commission members could remove them at any time without cause. This does not apply to the Board of Appeals, Civil Service Commission, or Ethics Commission. The Mayor cannot eliminate any board or commission established by the Charter.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want to expand the Mayor’s authority to transfer responsibilities, hire deputy mayors, hire some and fire most department heads, and allow City officials to remove members of boards or commissions without cause.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a minimal impact on the cost of government, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: The Mayor is the chief executive officer of the City. The Mayor directly supervises nearly 50 City departments, which are established by Charter or ordinance. Most City departments are established by Charter.",
            "• Transfer of Functions: The Mayor can transfer responsibilities between departments established by ordinance, as long as the Board of Supervisors (Board) does not object. The Mayor cannot transfer responsibilities for departments established by the Charter.",
            "• Deputy Mayors: The Mayor cannot hire deputy mayors to supervise most departments established by the Charter.",
            "• Department Heads: In most cases, the Mayor must select a department head from candidates recommended by the board or commission that oversees that department. Usually, the board or commission can fire the department head, but the Mayor cannot.",
            "• Commissioners: In addition to the Mayor, the Board and other officials appoint members to City boards and commissions. Appointed members can usually only be suspended or removed if the member engaged in official misconduct or committed certain felonies.",
            "The Proposal: Proposition F would amend the Charter to allow the Mayor to do the following:",
            "• Transfer of Functions: Transfer responsibilities between most departments or combine departments under a single department head, regardless of whether the",
            "Department was established by ordinance or Charter and as long as the Board does not object. The Mayor cannot eliminate any responsibilities established by Charter. The Mayor could also assign the oversight of these transferred responsibilities to that department’s commission. The Mayor cannot transfer responsibilities of these departments:",
            "• City Administrator, Controller, Board of Appeals, Port, Airport, Asian Art Museum, Fine Arts Museums, San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency, Public Utilities Commission, Civil Service Commission, Department of Human Resources, Retirement Board, Health Service System, Department of Elections, Ethics Commission, or departments headed by other elected officials.",
            "The responsibilities of the Department of Police Accountability cannot be transferred to the Police Department, and the responsibilities of the Sheriff’s Inspector General cannot be transferred to the Sheriff.",
            "• Deputy Mayors: Hire deputy mayors to supervise most departments established by the Charter.",
            "• Department Heads: Hire some and fire most department heads without board or commission involvement. The Mayor cannot hire or fire certain department heads that are exempt (see List of Exemptions in Words You Need To Know).",
            "• Commissioners: In addition to the Mayor, the Board and other officials who appoint board and commission members could remove them at any time without cause. This does not apply to the Board of Appeals, Civil Service Commission, or Ethics Commission. The Mayor cannot eliminate any board or commission established by the Charter.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to expand the Mayor’s authority to transfer responsibilities, hire deputy mayors, hire some and fire most department heads, and allow City officials to remove members of boards or commissions without cause.",
            "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: The Mayor is the chief executive officer of the City. The Mayor directly supervises nearly 50 City departments, which are established by Charter or ordinance. Most City departments are established by Charter."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Transfer of Functions: The Mayor can transfer responsibilities between departments established by ordinance, as long as the Board of Supervisors (Board) does not object. The Mayor cannot transfer responsibilities for departments established by the Charter."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Deputy Mayors: The Mayor cannot hire deputy mayors to supervise most departments established by the Charter."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Department Heads: In most cases, the Mayor must select a department head from candidates recommended by the board or commission that oversees that department. Usually, the board or commission can fire the department head, but the Mayor cannot."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Commissioners: In addition to the Mayor, the Board and other officials appoint members to City boards and commissions. Appointed members can usually only be suspended or removed if the member engaged in official misconduct or committed certain felonies."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Proposal: Proposition F would amend the Charter to allow the Mayor to do the following:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Transfer of Functions: Transfer responsibilities between most departments or combine departments under a single department head, regardless of whether the"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Department was established by ordinance or Charter and as long as the Board does not object. The Mayor cannot eliminate any responsibilities established by Charter. The Mayor could also assign the oversight of these transferred responsibilities to that department’s commission. The Mayor cannot transfer responsibilities of these departments:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• City Administrator, Controller, Board of Appeals, Port, Airport, Asian Art Museum, Fine Arts Museums, San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency, Public Utilities Commission, Civil Service Commission, Department of Human Resources, Retirement Board, Health Service System, Department of Elections, Ethics Commission, or departments headed by other elected officials."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The responsibilities of the Department of Police Accountability cannot be transferred to the Police Department, and the responsibilities of the Sheriff’s Inspector General cannot be transferred to the Sheriff."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Deputy Mayors: Hire deputy mayors to supervise most departments established by the Charter."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Department Heads: Hire some and fire most department heads without board or commission involvement. The Mayor cannot hire or fire certain department heads that are exempt (see List of Exemptions in Words You Need To Know)."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Commissioners: In addition to the Mayor, the Board and other officials who appoint board and commission members could remove them at any time without cause. This does not apply to the Board of Appeals, Civil Service Commission, or Ethics Commission. The Mayor cannot eliminate any board or commission established by the Charter."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to expand the Mayor’s authority to transfer responsibilities, hire deputy mayors, hire some and fire most department heads, and allow City officials to remove members of boards or commissions without cause."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition F:",
            "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a minimal impact on the cost of government, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment would (1) expand the Mayor’s authority to hire and remove most departments heads; (2) allow most commissioners to be removed at will by their appointing authority; (3) authorize the Mayor to reorganize departments and adjust reporting relationships within the executive branch, subject to potential rejection by the Board of Supervisors; and (4) allow the use of deputy mayors.",
            "The proposed Charter amendment authorizes the Mayor to utilize deputy mayors. The average annual cost for a deputy mayor would be approximately $250,000. The proposed Charter amendment allows the Mayor to restructure departments and reorient reporting relationships within the executive branch. The potential costs or savings incurred for such changes cannot be determined without knowing which departments would be involved and how the departments would be restructured. For example, in Fiscal Year 2022-23 when the Department of Sanitation and Streets merged into the Department of Public Works, the Controller’s Office estimated cost savings of $3.5 million in the first year and $2.5 million in the second year of the merger. Cost savings came from removing duplicative administrative and information technology staff, departmental leadership, and one-time and ongoing costs, such as equipment and professional services."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition F:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Should the proposed Charter amendment be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would have a minimal impact on the cost of government, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment would (1) expand the Mayor’s authority to hire and remove most departments heads; (2) allow most commissioners to be removed at will by their appointing authority; (3) authorize the Mayor to reorganize departments and adjust reporting relationships within the executive branch, subject to potential rejection by the Board of Supervisors; and (4) allow the use of deputy mayors."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed Charter amendment authorizes the Mayor to utilize deputy mayors. The average annual cost for a deputy mayor would be approximately $250,000. The proposed Charter amendment allows the Mayor to restructure departments and reorient reporting relationships within the executive branch. The potential costs or savings incurred for such changes cannot be determined without knowing which departments would be involved and how the departments would be restructured. For example, in Fiscal Year 2022-23 when the Department of Sanitation and Streets merged into the Department of Public Works, the Controller’s Office estimated cost savings of $3.5 million in the first year and $2.5 million in the second year of the merger. Cost savings came from removing duplicative administrative and information technology staff, departmental leadership, and one-time and ongoing costs, such as equipment and professional services."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City amend the Charter to expand the Mayor’s authority to transfer responsibilities between departments, hire deputy mayors, and hire some and fire most department heads; and to allow City officials to remove members of boards and commissions without cause?",
      "pro_short": "Mayor Daniel Lurie argues in the official pamphlet: \"Over decades, San Francisco’s governing system - or city charter - has increasingly grown to reward city insiders. Mayor Lurie is leading a citywide coalition to make the system more accountable to everyday San Franciscans. Clean Up City Hall is a package of Props A, D, E and F to improve neighborhood services, speed up permitting and reduce wasteful spending…\"",
      "con_short": "Small Business Forward argues in the official pamphlet: \"The Clean Up City Hall campaign has spent over 4 million dollars to put 3 Charter measures on the ballot favoring the Mayor and wealthy corporate interests. • These measures were never heard by the Board. • 5 of 11 Board Supervisors have declined to endorse them. • They had no public scrutiny and have had no cost analysis. •…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-f",
      "number": "F",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-g",
      "letter": "G",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "Allowing Private Vehicles on the Upper Great Highway in Sunset Dunes Park",
      "measure_type": "ordinance",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Yes on G: Safe streets and great parks. We need both.",
            "Since the Great Highway closed, traffic injuries in Sunset neighborhoods have risen sharply – a serious and unacceptable threat to public safety.",
            "That’s why Westside neighbors led a citywide volunteer effort to gather 16,000 signatures and place Proposition G on the ballot. We support great parks, but Prop G gives us both a great park AND the safe streets and neighborhoods our families deserve.",
            "Yes on G restores the compromise in place from 2021 to 2024: it keeps the Great Highway closed on weekends, allowing access to it as a park, but opens it to vehicle travel Monday through Friday.",
            "This compromise was working until Sunset Supervisor Joel Engardio, without a single community meeting, put forward a measure permanently closing the Great Highway. His betrayal of Sunset families cost him his job – he was recalled through a volunteer-led neighborhood campaign.",
            "Prop G gives us both safe streets AND a great park:",
            "• Allows weekday vehicle access on the Great Highway, helping keep traffic off neighborhood streets. • Maintains the whole space as a park on weekends and holidays. • Retains access to walking paths, bike lanes, and all off-road amenities, every day of the week.",
            "Every San Franciscan deserves safe streets, whether they’re walking, biking, taking Muni, or driving. We do not have to choose between great recreational spaces and public safety. We need both. Great public spaces should bring our city together, not create harmful consequences for our communities.",
            "Great parks make our city better. Safe streets save lives. Prop G gives us both. And when safety is at stake, we have a duty to respond.",
            "Vote Yes on Prop G.",
            "Richard Corriea, SFPD Commander Ret."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Richard Corriea, SFPD Commander Ret."
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "As Sunset neighbors and merchants, we ask you to vote NO on closing Sunset Dunes park. Don’t spend $20 million over five years to close our thriving coastal park.",
            "• Our streets are safer with Sunset Dunes. Analyzing public data, independent sources like The Frisc and Streetsblog agree: crashes in our neighborhood are down since the park opened. The Frisc confirms: “there’s no evidence of increased street mayhem around the closed Great Highway. In fact, it’s the opposite.” • Prop G is a park closure, not a compromise. Prop G removes every park feature added since Sunset Dunes opened — the playground, the skate park, and every bench. It also kills a majority of park visits, as nearly 60% happen on weekdays. That’s not a compromise — it’s a closure. A closed road is not a park, and can never become a world-class coastal promenade. • Traffic is flowing fine. Data also show that commute times remain within prior projections. The most impacted trips are 2-4 minutes longer during rush hour, while most trips are unaffected. • The park is good for our community. Sunset Dunes became our neighborhood’s town square and has boosted local business revenue — some up to 50%. • The coast belongs to you. Our city’s coast belongs to all San Franciscans, not just the lucky few who live near it. Sunset Dunes opens our coast for everyone to enjoy.",
            "Thank you for voting NO on G to save Sunset Dunes park. See you at the park!",
            "Outer Sunset Neighbors Sunset Merchants Association Sunset Parent Advocates"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Outer Sunset Neighbors Sunset Merchants Association Sunset Parent Advocates"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Proposition G would destroy Sunset Dunes park",
            "In San Francisco, we don’t destroy our parks; we protect them. With over 2 million visits since last year’s opening, Sunset Dunes is one of San Francisco’s most visited parks.",
            "Proposition G asks you to spend nearly $10 million to demolish a coastal park (plus up to $1.9 million every year for added roadway maintenance), to remove all amenities, and to end the nearly 60% of visits that are on weekdays.",
            "Please join us in voting NO on G to save our coastal park because:",
            "• Proposition G destroys a thriving park. Proposition G would require the city to remove all park features to make space for traffic. That means no more playground, skate park, or oceanview seating. No more park. • Proposition G guts the majority of park visits. Nearly 60% of visits to Sunset Dunes are on weekdays. Proposition G would remove all of those visits and prevent service workers who work weekends from using the park at all. • Proposition G is a solution in search of a problem. Traffic fears have not materialized; three independent analyses confirm traffic impacts are minimal. The most impacted trips are 2-4 minutes longer during rush hour, with most trips unaffected. • Proposition G replaces progress with pollution. San Francisco’s leading environmental groups are united: Sunset Dunes is the best plan for our coastal environment as we adapt to climate change and sea-level rise. • Proposition G locks our coast into being a road forever. Community planning is underway to transform the coast into a world-class park, but Proposition G kills all future park improvements.",
            "How will future generations judge us if we destroy our successful coastal park?",
            "Join us in voting NO on Proposition G.",
            "Senator Scott Wiener Supervisor Matt Dorsey Supervisor Bilal Mahmood Supervisor Rafael Mandelman Supervisor Myrna Melgar Supervisor Danny Sauter Sierra Club"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Senator Scott Wiener Supervisor Matt Dorsey Supervisor Bilal Mahmood Supervisor Rafael Mandelman Supervisor Myrna Melgar Supervisor Danny Sauter Sierra Club"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Scott Wiener turns his back on serious safety concerns. Why? He’s ABSENT from the Westside.",
            "Scott Wiener was part of the backroom deal that closed the Great Highway without community meetings or input from neighbors.",
            "Now, Wiener turns his nose up once again at Westside residents concerned for the safety of our children, elders, and families.",
            "Wiener calls the sharp rise in traffic injuries since the Great Highway closed “minimal.” That can only be because Scott Wiener doesn’t walk our streets and neighborhoods.",
            "More than 16,000 San Franciscans signed the petition to put Prop G on the ballot. We organized because City Hall refused to listen. We believe Prop G is a sensible solution that gives San Francisco both great parks AND safe streets.",
            "Prop G gives us:",
            "• Recreation seven days a week. Walking paths, bike lanes, the beach, and other amenities remain available every day. • Weekday vehicle access that helps keep traffic off our neighborhood streets. • A car-free park on weekends and holidays.",
            "Prop G doesn’t “destroy” a park. It gives us both.",
            "We had a compromise that worked. Out-of-touch politicians took it away. Prop G gives it back.",
            "Our safety cannot be ignored. Vote Yes on Prop G.",
            "Richard Corriea, SFPD Commander Ret."
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Richard Corriea, SFPD Commander Ret."
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 108",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=110"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Proposition G would close Sunset Dunes Park from Monday at 4:00 a.m. through Friday at 6:00 p.m., unless a holiday falls on a weekday, in order to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles during that time. The Upper Great Highway will remain open to emergency vehicles, official government vehicles, intra-park transit shuttle buses, and similar authorized vehicles. Proposition G would require the City to obtain all necessary approvals, including any permits required by the California Coastal Act or from other government agencies, to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want to close Sunset Dunes Park from Monday at 4:00 a.m. through Friday at 6:00 p.m., unless a holiday falls on a weekday, in order to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles during that time.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want the City to make these changes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Should the proposed Ordinance be approved by the voters and the roadway is open to private vehicles, in my opinion, it would significantly increase the cost of government by approximately $9.8 million in one-time capital costs and by approximately $500,000 to $1.9 million annually. The cost of the proposed Ordinance, should it be approved",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: Sunset Dunes Park is an open recreational space that replaced the Great Highway between Lincoln Way and Sloat Boulevard (Upper Great Highway) and is closed to private vehicles at all times.",
            "Sunset Dunes Park (former Upper Great Highway) is open to emergency vehicles, official government vehicles, intra-park transit shuttle buses, and similar authorized vehicles.",
            "Map provided by San Francisco Recreation and Park Department.",
            "The Proposal: Proposition G would close Sunset Dunes Park from Monday at 4:00 a.m. through Friday at 6:00 p.m., unless a holiday falls on a weekday, in order to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles during that time.",
            "The Upper Great Highway will remain open to emergency vehicles, official government vehicles, intra-park transit shuttle buses, and similar authorized vehicles.",
            "Proposition G would require the City to obtain all necessary approvals, including any permits required by the California Coastal Act or from other government agencies, to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to close Sunset Dunes Park from Monday at 4:00 a.m. through Friday at 6:00 p.m., unless a holiday falls on a weekday, in order to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles during that time.",
            "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want the City to make these changes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: Sunset Dunes Park is an open recreational space that replaced the Great Highway between Lincoln Way and Sloat Boulevard (Upper Great Highway) and is closed to private vehicles at all times."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Sunset Dunes Park (former Upper Great Highway) is open to emergency vehicles, official government vehicles, intra-park transit shuttle buses, and similar authorized vehicles."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Map provided by San Francisco Recreation and Park Department."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Proposal: Proposition G would close Sunset Dunes Park from Monday at 4:00 a.m. through Friday at 6:00 p.m., unless a holiday falls on a weekday, in order to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles during that time."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Upper Great Highway will remain open to emergency vehicles, official government vehicles, intra-park transit shuttle buses, and similar authorized vehicles."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition G would require the City to obtain all necessary approvals, including any permits required by the California Coastal Act or from other government agencies, to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to close Sunset Dunes Park from Monday at 4:00 a.m. through Friday at 6:00 p.m., unless a holiday falls on a weekday, in order to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles during that time."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want the City to make these changes."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Deputy City Controller ChiaYu Ma has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition G:",
            "Should the proposed Ordinance be approved by the voters and the roadway is open to private vehicles, in my opinion, it would significantly increase the cost of government by approximately $9.8 million in one-time capital costs and by approximately $500,000 to $1.9 million annually. The cost of the proposed Ordinance, should it be approved",
            "by the voters, is dependent on decisions that the Mayor and Board of Supervisors make through the budget process and operational decisions made by departments, as an ordinance cannot bind future Mayors and Boards of Supervisors to provide funding for this or any other purpose.",
            "The proposed initiative ordinance would amend the Park Code to restrict private vehicles on the Upper Great Highway between Lincoln Way and Sloat Boulevard from Friday at 6:00 PM until Monday at 4:00 AM and on holidays.",
            "Depending on future operational decisions made by City departments, the proposed Ordinance could result in annual cost increases ranging from $500,000 to $1.9 million. This includes traffic signal maintenance costs, annualized roadway maintenance and replacement costs, and an additional cost for sand removal and dune reshaping. The sand removal and dune reshaping would cost approximately $100,000 and $1.5 million more each year, which represents an increase over current levels of service. Sand removal costs are highly dependent on the defined level of service, weather conditions and funding availability, which results in a wide range of potential costs. For context, sand removal and dune reshaping for Sunset Dunes Park was approximately $290,000 in FY 2024-2025 and $330,000 in FY 2025-2026. In prior years when the roadway was open to vehicles on weekdays, actual expenditures for sand removal and dune reshaping was approximately $860,000 in FY 2022-2023 and $420,000 in FY 2023-2024. The proposed Ordinance would also result in decreased staffing needs and maintenance of Sunset Dunes Park as a park during weekdays, reducing costs and freeing staff to work on other functions. For context, staffing at Sunset Dunes Park costs approximately $300,000 annually for 1.5 full-time-equivalent positions.",
            "Additionally, the proposed Ordinance would likely result in increased, one-time capital project costs of approximately $9.8 million. This would include approximately $750,000 to remove existing park elements and restore roadway segments, $8.8 million in new traffic signals at 8 intersections, and $200,000 for temporary and permanent restriping and signage. A full signal upgrade would be necessary approximately every 30 years. Installation of signals at the intersection of the Upper Great Highway and Sloat Boulevard would result in changes to the Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project, which could result in additional project costs for redesigning elements of the planned plaza.",
            "Finally, the proposed Ordinance would require a coastal development permit. Applying for the coastal development permit may prompt additional requirements, including studies or permit conditions, that may increase the cost of government, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Deputy City Controller ChiaYu Ma has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition G:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Should the proposed Ordinance be approved by the voters and the roadway is open to private vehicles, in my opinion, it would significantly increase the cost of government by approximately $9.8 million in one-time capital costs and by approximately $500,000 to $1.9 million annually. The cost of the proposed Ordinance, should it be approved"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "by the voters, is dependent on decisions that the Mayor and Board of Supervisors make through the budget process and operational decisions made by departments, as an ordinance cannot bind future Mayors and Boards of Supervisors to provide funding for this or any other purpose."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed initiative ordinance would amend the Park Code to restrict private vehicles on the Upper Great Highway between Lincoln Way and Sloat Boulevard from Friday at 6:00 PM until Monday at 4:00 AM and on holidays."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Depending on future operational decisions made by City departments, the proposed Ordinance could result in annual cost increases ranging from $500,000 to $1.9 million. This includes traffic signal maintenance costs, annualized roadway maintenance and replacement costs, and an additional cost for sand removal and dune reshaping. The sand removal and dune reshaping would cost approximately $100,000 and $1.5 million more each year, which represents an increase over current levels of service. Sand removal costs are highly dependent on the defined level of service, weather conditions and funding availability, which results in a wide range of potential costs. For context, sand removal and dune reshaping for Sunset Dunes Park was approximately $290,000 in FY 2024-2025 and $330,000 in FY 2025-2026. In prior years when the roadway was open to vehicles on weekdays, actual expenditures for sand removal and dune reshaping was approximately $860,000 in FY 2022-2023 and $420,000 in FY 2023-2024. The proposed Ordinance would also result in decreased staffing needs and maintenance of Sunset Dunes Park as a park during weekdays, reducing costs and freeing staff to work on other functions. For context, staffing at Sunset Dunes Park costs approximately $300,000 annually for 1.5 full-time-equivalent positions."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Additionally, the proposed Ordinance would likely result in increased, one-time capital project costs of approximately $9.8 million. This would include approximately $750,000 to remove existing park elements and restore roadway segments, $8.8 million in new traffic signals at 8 intersections, and $200,000 for temporary and permanent restriping and signage. A full signal upgrade would be necessary approximately every 30 years. Installation of signals at the intersection of the Upper Great Highway and Sloat Boulevard would result in changes to the Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project, which could result in additional project costs for redesigning elements of the planned plaza."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Finally, the proposed Ordinance would require a coastal development permit. Applying for the coastal development permit may prompt additional requirements, including studies or permit conditions, that may increase the cost of government, although at a level that cannot be determined at this time."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City close Sunset Dunes Park from Monday at 4:00 a.m. through Friday at 6:00 p.m., unless a holiday falls on a weekday, in order to reopen the roadway known as the Upper Great Highway to private vehicles during that time?",
      "pro_short": "Richard Corriea, SFPD Commander Ret. argues in the official pamphlet: \"Yes on G: Safe streets and great parks. We need both. Since the Great Highway closed, traffic injuries in Sunset neighborhoods have risen sharply – a serious and unacceptable threat to public safety.…\"",
      "con_short": "Senator Scott Wiener argues in the official pamphlet: \"Proposition G would destroy Sunset Dunes park In San Francisco, we don’t destroy our parks; we protect them. With over 2 million visits since last year’s opening, Sunset Dunes is one of San Francisco’s most visited parks.…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-g",
      "number": "G",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-h",
      "letter": "H",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "Parcel Tax to Fund Muni Operations",
      "measure_type": "ordinance",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "VOTE YES ON H FOR STRONGER MUNI.",
            "MUNI IS A LIFELINE FOR WORKERS, SENIORS, STUDENTS",
            "“Muni is essential for our seniors, many of whom don’t drive, and need Muni to get groceries, go to appointments and move independently.” – Anni Chung, Self-Help for the Elderly",
            "“Working people depend on affordable, reliable, and safe Muni every day—to get to work, take their kids to school, and keep San Francisco moving.” - Olga Miranda, President, SEIU Local 87",
            "MUNI POWERS OUR ECONOMY.",
            "“40% of San Franciscans who work downtown take Muni. Public transit is one of the smartest investments we can make in our local economy. Without H, Muni service will be severely reduced, killing the engine of our economic recovery and causing future cuts to emergency response, parks, and other city services.” – former Controller Ben Rosenfield",
            "MORE ACCOUNTABLE MUNI. Muni eliminated 500 vacant positions, trimmed management and doubled fare inspectors. Muni customer satisfaction recently hit a 25 year high due to safer and more reliable service.",
            "MUNI FACES DEEP SERVICE CUTS. For years, one-time federal and state Covid relief kept Muni running. That money is gone. Despite strong actions to save $137 million dollars annually, without Prop H, service could be cut by 30%, at least 20 bus routes eliminated, and far worse traffic in our neighborhoods.",
            "H ONLY FUNDS MUNI SERVICE. “Strong oversight and independent audits ensures every dollar goes to safe, reliable and affordable Muni service that can never be redirected.” – Mayor Daniel Lurie",
            "San Franciscans from every corner of the city have united to vote Yes on H. The Labor Council and Chamber of Commerce. The San Francisco Apartment Association and Tenants Union. Small business owners and transit advocates. Mayor Lurie and the entire Board of Supervisors.",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi San Francisco Democratic Party Senator Scott Wiener Assemblymember Catherine Stefani Assemblymember Matt Haney Supervisors: Rafael Mandelman Connie Chan Steven Sherrill Danny Sauter Alan Wong Bilal Mahmood Matt Dorsey",
            "Myrna Melgar Jackie Fielder Shamann Walton Chyanne Chen Former Controller Ben Rosenfield SF Tenants Union SF Labor Council SF Chamber of Commerce SF Council of District Merchants Firefighters Local 798 Transit Workers Union 250A Teamsters Local 665 Chinatown Transportation Research and Improvement Project"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi San Francisco Democratic Party Senator Scott Wiener Assemblymember Catherine Stefani Assemblymember Matt Haney Supervisors: Rafael Mandelman Connie Chan Steven Sherrill Danny Sauter Alan Wong Bilal Mahmood Matt Dorsey",
            "Myrna Melgar Jackie Fielder Shamann Walton Chyanne Chen Former Controller Ben Rosenfield SF Tenants Union SF Labor Council SF Chamber of Commerce SF Council of District Merchants Firefighters Local 798 Transit Workers Union 250A Teamsters Local 665 Chinatown Transportation Research and Improvement Project"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Everyone wants safe, reliable Muni. The question is whether a 15-year tax with no strings attached will deliver it.",
            "The Yes campaign warns of devastating service cuts if Prop H fails. But that dodges the real question: Why guarantee SFMTA a new tax revenue stream without requiring it to meet a single efficiency or performance target?",
            "Supporters boast that Muni has eliminated vacant positions, trimmed management and found $137 million in annual savings. Great. That proves reform is possible. Prop H should require more reform, not guarantee new revenue regardless of results.",
            "They also promise “strong oversight and independent audits.” But oversight is not accountability. Prop H requires an efficiency review, but does not require SFMTA to implement its recommendations. There are no binding efficiency targets, performance benchmarks, or requirements that future tax dollars depend on results.",
            "And who pays? Prop H taxes property based on square footage, not value. A modest home can owe nearly the same tax as a far more valuable home of similar size. Renters aren’t spared, either, since landlords can pass through part of the tax.",
            "Muni is too important to keep funding the same way and hoping for different results.",
            "Before approving a 15-year tax, voters must demand binding reforms, measurable performance standards, and real accountability.",
            "Vote NO on Prop H.",
            "The San Francisco Republican Party"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "The San Francisco Republican Party"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "San Franciscans are being asked to fund Muni’s $300 million deficit for 15 years with no strings attached.",
            "False threats. Nobody wants longer wait times or service cuts, but a new tax isn’t the only option. Nothing in this proposition requires SFMTA to cut costs, hit efficiency targets, or act on a spending review as a condition of receiving this money.",
            "No sunset tied to results. The tax runs through 2042 regardless of whether ridership, fares, or costs ever normalize.",
            "A toothless review, collected after the money’s already in hand. The measure calls for an “efficiency review,” but not until April 2028, nine months after the tax kicks in. Even then, the review only has to report its findings to SFMTA’s own board. Nothing requires the agency to act on a single recommendation, and nothing ties future funding to whether it does.",
            "A flat tax, not a fair one. The tax is based on square footage, not property value. A modest home and a far more valuable one of similar size nearby will pay nearly the same amount. Renters aren’t spared either, since landlords can pass through the tax increase to tenants.",
            "A 15-year tax with no results-based sunset, no binding reforms, and no independent check on whether the money is spent well isn’t the accountability that SFMTA needs. It’s a blank check.",
            "Vote No on H.",
            "The San Francisco Republican Party"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "The San Francisco Republican Party"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Trump’s Federal spending cuts have devastated transportation systems across the country. Given these cuts and the loss of other funding, Muni faces 30% service cuts and the elimination of at least 20 bus routes. That’s just a fact.",
            "Mayor Lurie has taken bold action to make Muni more efficient BEFORE ever proposing H for the ballot. With new leadership, the agency eliminated 500 vacant positions, cut management, and froze non-operator hiring, saving $140 million. Muni doubled fare inspectors and reduced fare evasion by 30%. Wait times and reliability have improved, and Muni’s favorability is at an all time high.",
            "The tax isn’t flat. The San Francisco Republican Party is wrong. H is the first fair, tiered parcel tax in San Francisco history. 95% of homeowners pay the lowest amount. Large commercial buildings and mansions pay the most. 70% of the revenue comes from the city’s largest properties. Rent-controlled units are protected and won’t pay more than $65 a year.",
            "Strong oversight. H requires independent audits and mandates citizen oversight for the life of the tax. And not one penny can be spent on anything other than Muni operations.",
            "World-class public transportation requires investment. “Investing in Muni is just smart economics. The economic activity Muni generates funds emergency response, parks, and libraries.” - Former Controller Ben Rosenfield.",
            "We owe it to the next generation of San Franciscans to make sure that Muni remains the system we all love.",
            "Vote Yes on H.",
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Rodney Fong, SF Chamber of Commerce Tony Delorio, Teamsters Local 665 Kat Siegal, Transit Advocate"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Mayor Daniel Lurie Rodney Fong, SF Chamber of Commerce Tony Delorio, Teamsters Local 665 Kat Siegal, Transit Advocate"
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 124",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=126"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Starting July 1, 2027, and continuing until June 30, 2042, Proposition H would fund Muni service through a new annual parcel tax on real estate in San Francisco. The tax would be adjusted annually for inflation. The proposed 2027 tax rates would be: • Single-Family Residential Parcels: • A base tax of $129. • For buildings with more than 3,000 square feet of building area: • $0.42 per square foot between 3,001 and 5,000, and • $1.99 per square foot over 5,000. • Multifamily Residential Parcels: • A base tax of $249. • For buildings with more than 5,000 square feet of building area: • $0.195 per square foot over 5,000. • This tax is capped at $50,000 per parcel. • Non-Residential Parcels: • A base tax of $799. • For buildings with more than 5,000 square feet of building area: • $0.76 per square foot between 5,001 and 50,000, • $0.84 per square foot between 50,001 and 250,000, and • $0.99 per square foot over 250,000. • This tax is capped at $400,000 per parcel. • Mixed-Use Parcels: • A base tax of $799. • For buildings with more than 5,000 square feet of building area: • A combination of the marginal rates for residential and non-residential parcels above. • This tax is capped at $400,000 per parcel. • Parcels with No Buildings: • No base tax. • $392 for land area over 2,000 square feet. The tax would not apply to: 1. Properties or portions of properties not required to pay standard property taxes; and 2. Single Room Occupancy (SRO) units and their shared facilities such as kitchens or bathrooms. Most homeowners aged 65 or older living in their primary home would get a discount or pay no tax. Revenues from the tax would only be used for Muni service and administering the tax. In addition to the annual required audit by an independent auditor, an annual report and efficiency review would be required. This measure would increase the City’s spending limit for four years. Owners could pass up to 50% of the tax onto tenants in rent-controlled units where the rent was set before June 1, 2027, up to a maximum of $65 per unit per year.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want the City to fund Muni service through a new annual parcel tax on real estate.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Should the proposed parcel tax be approved by the voters, in my opinion, based on currently available parcel data it would generate approximately $177 million annually for Muni transit service starting in Fiscal Year (FY) 2027-2028, and would increase over time as the per parcel taxes are adjusted for inflation each year. The cost to government to administer this parcel tax could range from approximately $2 million to $3 million in one-time startup costs, and from approximately $4 million to $6 million annually in ongoing costs.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: The Municipal Railway (Muni) provides public transit in San Francisco, including bus, light rail, streetcar, and cable car. Muni provides over 500,000 rides per weekday. Muni service is funded by transit fares and local, state and federal sources, but not through a parcel tax.",
            "State law limits the total revenue, including tax revenue, that the City may spend each year. The voters may approve increases to this limit for up to four years.",
            "Owners of rent-controlled residential property in the City are generally limited in what costs they can pass onto their tenants.",
            "The Proposal: Starting July 1, 2027, and continuing until June 30, 2042, Proposition H would fund Muni service through a new annual parcel tax on real estate in San Francisco. The tax would be adjusted annually for inflation.",
            "The proposed 2027 tax rates would be:",
            "• Single-Family Residential Parcels: • A base tax of $129. • For buildings with more than 3,000 square feet of building area: • $0.42 per square foot between 3,001 and 5,000, and • $1.99 per square foot over 5,000.",
            "• Multifamily Residential Parcels: • A base tax of $249. • For buildings with more than 5,000 square feet of building area: • $0.195 per square foot over 5,000. • This tax is capped at $50,000 per parcel.",
            "• Non-Residential Parcels: • A base tax of $799. • For buildings with more than 5,000 square feet of building area: • $0.76 per square foot between 5,001 and 50,000, • $0.84 per square foot between 50,001 and 250,000, and • $0.99 per square foot over 250,000. • This tax is capped at $400,000 per parcel.",
            "• Mixed-Use Parcels: • A base tax of $799. • For buildings with more than 5,000 square feet of building area: • A combination of the marginal rates for residential and non-residential parcels above. • This tax is capped at $400,000 per parcel.",
            "• Parcels with No Buildings: • No base tax. • $392 for land area over 2,000 square feet.",
            "The tax would not apply to:",
            "1. Properties or portions of properties not required to pay standard property taxes; and 2. Single Room Occupancy (SRO) units and their shared facilities such as kitchens or bathrooms.",
            "Most homeowners aged 65 or older living in their primary home would get a discount or pay no tax.",
            "Revenues from the tax would only be used for Muni service and administering the tax. In addition to the annual required audit by an independent auditor, an annual report and efficiency review would be required.",
            "This measure would increase the City’s spending limit for four years.",
            "Owners could pass up to 50% of the tax onto tenants in rent-controlled units where the rent was set before June 1, 2027, up to a maximum of $65 per unit per year.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want the City to fund Muni service through a new annual parcel tax on real estate.",
            "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: The Municipal Railway (Muni) provides public transit in San Francisco, including bus, light rail, streetcar, and cable car. Muni provides over 500,000 rides per weekday. Muni service is funded by transit fares and local, state and federal sources, but not through a parcel tax."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "State law limits the total revenue, including tax revenue, that the City may spend each year. The voters may approve increases to this limit for up to four years."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Owners of rent-controlled residential property in the City are generally limited in what costs they can pass onto their tenants."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Proposal: Starting July 1, 2027, and continuing until June 30, 2042, Proposition H would fund Muni service through a new annual parcel tax on real estate in San Francisco. The tax would be adjusted annually for inflation."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed 2027 tax rates would be:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Single-Family Residential Parcels: • A base tax of $129. • For buildings with more than 3,000 square feet of building area: • $0.42 per square foot between 3,001 and 5,000, and • $1.99 per square foot over 5,000."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Multifamily Residential Parcels: • A base tax of $249. • For buildings with more than 5,000 square feet of building area: • $0.195 per square foot over 5,000. • This tax is capped at $50,000 per parcel."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Non-Residential Parcels: • A base tax of $799. • For buildings with more than 5,000 square feet of building area: • $0.76 per square foot between 5,001 and 50,000, • $0.84 per square foot between 50,001 and 250,000, and • $0.99 per square foot over 250,000. • This tax is capped at $400,000 per parcel."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Mixed-Use Parcels: • A base tax of $799. • For buildings with more than 5,000 square feet of building area: • A combination of the marginal rates for residential and non-residential parcels above. • This tax is capped at $400,000 per parcel."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Parcels with No Buildings: • No base tax. • $392 for land area over 2,000 square feet."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The tax would not apply to:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "1. Properties or portions of properties not required to pay standard property taxes; and 2. Single Room Occupancy (SRO) units and their shared facilities such as kitchens or bathrooms."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Most homeowners aged 65 or older living in their primary home would get a discount or pay no tax."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Revenues from the tax would only be used for Muni service and administering the tax. In addition to the annual required audit by an independent auditor, an annual report and efficiency review would be required."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure would increase the City’s spending limit for four years."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Owners could pass up to 50% of the tax onto tenants in rent-controlled units where the rent was set before June 1, 2027, up to a maximum of $65 per unit per year."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want the City to fund Muni service through a new annual parcel tax on real estate."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition H:",
            "Should the proposed parcel tax be approved by the voters, in my opinion, based on currently available parcel data it would generate approximately $177 million annually for Muni transit service starting in Fiscal Year (FY) 2027-2028, and would increase over time as the per parcel taxes are adjusted for inflation each year. The cost to government to administer this parcel tax could range from approximately $2 million to $3 million in one-time startup costs, and from approximately $4 million to $6 million annually in ongoing costs.",
            "Revenues would be deposited into the Stronger Muni Fund to support Muni transit service operations and administration.",
            "The proposed tax would start at $129 per year for single-family residential parcel building areas that are up to 3,000 square feet, $249 for multifamily residential parcel building areas that are up to 5,000 square feet and $799 for non-residential parcel and mixed-use parcel building areas up to 5,000 square feet. The tax for each property would increase with the square footage of the building area and would have a maximum tax amount for non-single family residential parcels. For unimproved parcels with 2,001 or more square feet of land area, the tax would be $392. Seniors of 65 years or older and some other groups can apply to SFMTA for an exemption or reduction from the tax. Total revenue will depend on the number of exemptions requested and granted.",
            "Landlords of rent-controlled residential units are limited in the amount of the parcel tax they can pass through to tenants to 50% of the parcel tax for a maximum of $65 per unit annually, unless the unit is exempt from the parcel tax or base rent is set on or after June 1, 2027. Properties or portions of properties that are exempt from ad valorem",
            "property taxes, as well as single-family parcels whose owners are sixty-five or older and occupy the property as a primary residence, would be exempt from the parcel tax. A deduction of $249 would apply for each unit in a multi-family residential parcel that is occupied by an owner that is sixty-five or older and that occupies the property as a primary residence.",
            "The City does not currently use square footage, parcel use type, or unit number data as a basis for taxation. The cost to validate and maintain these data, establish and maintain exemptions and manage appeals would increase the cost of government by approximately $2 million to $3 million in one-time startup costs, then approximately $4 million to $6 million annually, likely decreasing over time. The total cost would be dependent on future operational and staffing decisions made by the SFMTA. Additional costs may include the financial efficiency review, ongoing community outreach and education costs, and other administrative costs to implement the tax.",
            "Note that the proposed measure would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition H:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Should the proposed parcel tax be approved by the voters, in my opinion, based on currently available parcel data it would generate approximately $177 million annually for Muni transit service starting in Fiscal Year (FY) 2027-2028, and would increase over time as the per parcel taxes are adjusted for inflation each year. The cost to government to administer this parcel tax could range from approximately $2 million to $3 million in one-time startup costs, and from approximately $4 million to $6 million annually in ongoing costs."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Revenues would be deposited into the Stronger Muni Fund to support Muni transit service operations and administration."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The proposed tax would start at $129 per year for single-family residential parcel building areas that are up to 3,000 square feet, $249 for multifamily residential parcel building areas that are up to 5,000 square feet and $799 for non-residential parcel and mixed-use parcel building areas up to 5,000 square feet. The tax for each property would increase with the square footage of the building area and would have a maximum tax amount for non-single family residential parcels. For unimproved parcels with 2,001 or more square feet of land area, the tax would be $392. Seniors of 65 years or older and some other groups can apply to SFMTA for an exemption or reduction from the tax. Total revenue will depend on the number of exemptions requested and granted."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Landlords of rent-controlled residential units are limited in the amount of the parcel tax they can pass through to tenants to 50% of the parcel tax for a maximum of $65 per unit annually, unless the unit is exempt from the parcel tax or base rent is set on or after June 1, 2027. Properties or portions of properties that are exempt from ad valorem"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "property taxes, as well as single-family parcels whose owners are sixty-five or older and occupy the property as a primary residence, would be exempt from the parcel tax. A deduction of $249 would apply for each unit in a multi-family residential parcel that is occupied by an owner that is sixty-five or older and that occupies the property as a primary residence."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The City does not currently use square footage, parcel use type, or unit number data as a basis for taxation. The cost to validate and maintain these data, establish and maintain exemptions and manage appeals would increase the cost of government by approximately $2 million to $3 million in one-time startup costs, then approximately $4 million to $6 million annually, likely decreasing over time. The total cost would be dependent on future operational and staffing decisions made by the SFMTA. Additional costs may include the financial efficiency review, ongoing community outreach and education costs, and other administrative costs to implement the tax."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Note that the proposed measure would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City fund Muni service through a new annual parcel tax on real estate at rates ranging from $129 per parcel up to a maximum of $400,000 per parcel, depending on the type of property and its size and adjusted annually for inflation, for estimated revenue of $177 million a year for 15 years?",
      "pro_short": "Mayor Daniel Lurie argues in the official pamphlet: \"VOTE YES ON H FOR STRONGER MUNI. MUNI IS A LIFELINE FOR WORKERS, SENIORS, STUDENTS…\"",
      "con_short": "The San Francisco Republican Party argues in the official pamphlet: \"San Franciscans are being asked to fund Muni’s $300 million deficit for 15 years with no strings attached. False threats. Nobody wants longer wait times or service cuts, but a new tax isn’t the only option. Nothing in this proposition requires SFMTA to cut costs, hit efficiency targets, or act on a spending review as a condition of receiving this…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-h",
      "number": "H",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-i",
      "letter": "I",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "Changes to Real Property Transfer Tax",
      "measure_type": "ordinance",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "YES ON I: KEEP THE PROMISE. AFFORDABLE HOUSING WITH NO NEW TAXES.",
            "San Francisco’s housing crisis is pushing families, seniors, teachers, nurses, artists, immigrants, and young people out of the city they love.",
            "In 2020, voters approved a tax on the sale of properties worth more than $10 million, specifically so that money could fund affordable housing and rent relief.",
            "It worked until politicians ignored the will of voters. This tax on San Francisco’s wealthiest property owners provided emergency rent relief to more than 10,000 households and helped preserve and build hundreds of affordable homes.",
            "But it wasn’t guaranteed. In the past two years, none of this revenue has gone to affordable housing.",
            "Prop I will finally keep the promise and implement the measure voters approved.",
            "• Doesn’t raise taxes -- uses only revenue from a tax voters already approved. • Cuts the transfer tax for new housing construction, so we keep building the homes we need. • Independent oversight -- mandatory annual audits by the City Controller, filed publicly. • The only measure on the ballot that guarantees both innovative social housing and ongoing rental assistance.",
            "This November, San Franciscans have a historic opportunity: two measures on the ballot that guarantee affordable housing funding without raising anyone’s taxes.",
            "Vote YES on Prop I to guarantee this funding finally does what voters intended.",
            "Read more: YesonISF.com",
            "Affordable Housing Alliance San Francisco Tenants Union Small Business Forward United Educators of San Francisco Service Employees International Union SEIU 1021 Council of Community Housing Coalitions Faith in Action Bay Area Senior and Disability Action Anti Displacement Coalition Community Tenants Association Housing Rights Committee Tenants Together Democratic Socialist of America - San Francisco San Franciscans for Social Housing"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Affordable Housing Alliance San Francisco Tenants Union Small Business Forward United Educators of San Francisco Service Employees International Union SEIU 1021 Council of Community Housing Coalitions Faith in Action Bay Area Senior and Disability Action Anti Displacement Coalition Community Tenants Association Housing Rights Committee Tenants Together Democratic Socialist of America - San Francisco San Franciscans for Social Housing"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "DON’T BE FOOLED: PROP I CREATES A NONPROFIT SLUSH FUND AND DOESN’T GUARANTEE NEW HOUSING",
            "Prop I’s proponents say this measure “keeps the promise” of affordable housing without raising taxes. That is not what Prop I does.",
            "Prop I would lock roughly $120 million a year away from the General Fund without requiring that a single new unit of housing be built.",
            "30% must go to “social housing.” Another 25% can go to nonprofits to buy existing apartments. Another 10% can fund nonprofit programs that do not build new homes. Five percent can go to administration.",
            "That means at least 70% of the money does not have to build housing.",
            "Audits do not fix Prop I’s fundamental flaw. It can be perfectly audited and still spend most of its money without building a single new home. A transfer-tax cut does not change that. How much new housing does Prop I require? None.",
            "The budget damage goes further. Pulling $120 million out of the General Fund shrinks funding baselines, including Muni’s. Amid a Muni funding crisis, Prop I would drastically cut transit funding while reducing resources for firefighters, public safety, clean streets, and other essential services.",
            "The San Francisco Building and Construction Trades Council represents workers who actually build housing. We support affordable housing, not a measure that promises housing without guaranteeing new homes.",
            "Vote NO on Prop I.",
            "San Francisco Building and Construction Trades Council"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "San Francisco Building and Construction Trades Council"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote NO on the Affordable Housing Guarantee Act.",
            "While affordable housing is an important priority, locking transfer tax revenues into rigid set-asides is fiscal mismanagement that threatens San Francisco’s financial stability.",
            "1. Creates Dangerous Budget Earmarks San Francisco’s General Fund pays for vital everyday services—including police officers, firefighters, 911 dispatchers, street cleaning, and public parks. Carving out transfer tax revenues into a restricted fund starves the General Fund of essential dollars, forcing severe service cuts across the city during lean budget years.",
            "2. Relies on Highly Volatile Revenue Real estate transfer taxes are notoriously unpredictable. Basing housing commitments on real estate sales creates an unstable funding cycle that collapses whenever property values or commercial transactions drop. Managing long-term programs on volatile tax revenues is fiscally reckless.",
            "3. Deepens Downtown Economic Stagnation San Francisco’s commercial real estate market is already struggling with historically high vacancy rates. Increasing burden or restricting tax policy on high-value properties discourages investment, depresses property values, and weakens our overall tax base—ultimately reducing total revenue available for public services.",
            "4. Reduces Flexibility and Oversight City leaders need the flexibility to adapt to economic downturns and emerging local emergencies. Tying revenue up in permanent structural mandates removes budget oversight and prevents the City from reallocating resources where they are needed most.",
            "Protect core city services and financial stability.",
            "Vote NO on Measure I.",
            "Judge Quentin L Kopp San Francisco Taxpayers Association"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Judge Quentin L Kopp San Francisco Taxpayers Association"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "YES ON I — AFFORDABLE HOUSING. NO NEW TAXES.",
            "Opponents call affordable housing “an important priority.” They’re right. But they oppose Prop I, which builds affordable housing without raising taxes. That’s plain wrong.",
            "San Francisco’s state-mandated housing plan calls for 46,000 affordable homes to be built by 2031. Prop I is a step forward. It will create thousands of affordable homes without costing taxpayers a dime.",
            "Prop I keeps a promise made to voters in 2020 which city hall politicians have ignored. It requires the city to use an existing tax on sales of properties valued at ten million dollars or more to fund affordable housing.",
            "For the first few years, politicians kept the promise. But over the last two years, not one dollar of this revenue has gone to housing.",
            "Prop I is accountable:",
            "• Every dollar in Prop I will be managed by the Mayor’s Office of Housing • Mandatory annual audits will be conducted by the City Controller • Taxes on new housing are reduced to encourage growth • And it won’t raise taxes!",
            "Our housing crisis demands innovative solutions, not tired opposition from people who have opposed affordable housing for decades. Join us and Vote Yes on I.",
            "Council of Community Housing Organizations San Francisco Tenants Union Small Business Forward Affordable Housing Alliance Service Employees International Union SEIU 1021 Senior and Disability Action SF Anti Displacement Coalition Housing Rights Committee Democratic Socialists of America - San Francisco San Franciscans for Social Housing"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Small Business Forward Affordable Housing Alliance Service Employees International Union SEIU 1021 Senior and Disability Action SF Anti Displacement Coalition Housing Rights Committee Democratic Socialists of America - San Francisco San Franciscans for Social Housing"
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 132",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=134"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Proposition I would dedicate half of the transfer tax revenues when certain real estate with a value or sales price of more than $10,000,000 changes hands, to be spent only on affordable housing, including social housing developments and housing assistance. Specifically, the measure would: Transfer Tax For properties with a sales price or value between $10,000,000 and under $25,000,000: • Reduce the current transfer tax from 5.5% to 2.75% • Impose a new transfer tax of 2.75% For properties with a sales price or value at $25,000,000 or more: • Reduce the transfer tax from 6% to 3% • Impose a new transfer tax of 3% This measure will not increase the tax rate on the transfer of any property above what is charged today. The same exemptions and tax reductions from the current transfer tax would still apply to the new transfer tax. The new transfer tax would also exempt the first sale of certain multifamily real estate if it is sold within 5 years of completion of new residential units. Tax Revenue Spending The City could spend revenue from the new transfer tax only on: • At least 60% for affordable housing production, with at least half to social housing developments; • At least 25% towards the acquisition or rehabilitation of affordable housing, with at least 60% to acquisition of existing housing units; and • At least 10% to tenant stabilization/homeless prevention programs, with at least half to eviction defense and prevention; The Board could only change the transfer tax consistent with the purpose of the tax. All other changes would require voter approval. Proposition I would approve an unlimited number of new affordable housing units for low-income households funded by revenue from the new transfer tax. Proposition I would require the City to submit annual reports to the Board and Mayor on the use of the new tax revenue. Proposition I would increase the City’s spending limit for four years.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want to dedicate half of the transfer tax revenues when certain real estate with a value or sales price of more than $10,000,000 changes hands, to be spent only on affordable housing, including social housing developments and housing assistance.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Because the ordinance would replace existing General Fund taxes with a new dedicated tax, it would limit the City’s fiscal flexibility and increase the City’s General Fund deficit, most recently projected at $741.7 million and $1.1 billion in FY 2028-29 and FY 2029-30, respectively. The House SF special revenue fund and tax would represent the City’s 24th voter-mandated funding requirement that limits the City’s budget flexibility. For context, voter-mandated funding requirements currently total approximately $2 billion, or 30%, of the approximately $7 billion General Fund sources. The proposed ordinance requires the City to appropriate the House SF Fund in the following ways: (1) no less than 60% must be spent on affordable housing production programs, (2) no less than 25% must be spent on preservation or acquisition programs, (3) no less than 10% must be spent on tenant stabilization or homelessness prevention programs, and (4) no more than 5% may be spent on the departmental administration of the Fund and administration of the House SF Tax. The proposed ordinance would allow the Board of Supervisors to amend the Real Property Transfer Tax without voter approval only to exempt rent-restricted affordable housing or to make other changes consistent with the stated purposes of the House SF Tax. However, it would remove the existing authority of the Board of Supervisors to reduce, suspend, or repeal the Real Property Transfer Tax without voter approval. The proposed ordinance would also require the Controller’s Office to perform an annual audit on the House SF Fund and file it with the Board of Supervisors. Note that the proposed measure would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: The City collects a transfer tax when most real estate changes hands. The tax rates depend on the property’s sales price or value and the two highest tax rates are: • 5.5% for properties between $10,000,000 and under $25,000,000, and • 6% for properties at $25,000,000 or more. Some real estate transfers are exempt from the tax or are subject to reduced rates. Revenues generated from the transfer tax may be spent for any governmental purpose. The Board of Supervisors (Board) may amend, reduce, suspend, or repeal the transfer tax without voter approval. Voters must approve any increase of the transfer tax. State law limits the total revenue, including tax revenue, the City may spend each year. The voters may approve increases to this limit for up to four years. The Proposal: Proposition I would dedicate half of the transfer tax revenues when certain real estate with a value or sales price of more than $10,000,000 changes hands, to be spent only on affordable housing, including social housing developments and housing assistance. Specifically, the measure would: Transfer Tax For properties with a sales price or value between $10,000,000 and under $25,000,000: • Reduce the current transfer tax from 5.5% to 2.75% • Impose a new transfer tax of 2.75% For properties with a sales price or value at $25,000,000 or more:",
            "• Reduce the transfer tax from 6% to 3% • Impose a new transfer tax of 3%",
            "This measure will not increase the tax rate on the transfer of any property above what is charged today. The same exemptions and tax reductions from the current transfer tax would still apply to the new transfer tax. The new transfer tax would also exempt the first sale of certain multifamily real estate if it is sold within 5 years of completion of new residential units. Tax Revenue Spending The City could spend revenue from the new transfer tax only on: • At least 60% for affordable housing production, with at least half to social housing developments; • At least 25% towards the acquisition or rehabilitation of affordable housing, with at least 60% to acquisition of existing housing units; and • At least 10% to tenant stabilization/homeless prevention programs, with at least half to eviction defense and prevention; The Board could only change the transfer tax consistent with the purpose of the tax. All other changes would require voter approval. Proposition I would approve an unlimited number of new affordable housing units for low-income households funded by revenue from the new transfer tax. Proposition I would require the City to submit annual reports to the Board and Mayor on the use of the new tax revenue. Proposition I would increase the City’s spending limit for four years.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to dedicate half of the transfer tax revenues when certain real estate with a value or sales price of more than $10,000,000 changes hands, to be spent only on affordable housing, including social housing developments and housing assistance. A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: The City collects a transfer tax when most real estate changes hands. The tax rates depend on the property’s sales price or value and the two highest tax rates are: • 5.5% for properties between $10,000,000 and under $25,000,000, and • 6% for properties at $25,000,000 or more. Some real estate transfers are exempt from the tax or are subject to reduced rates. Revenues generated from the transfer tax may be spent for any governmental purpose. The Board of Supervisors (Board) may amend, reduce, suspend, or repeal the transfer tax without voter approval. Voters must approve any increase of the transfer tax. State law limits the total revenue, including tax revenue, the City may spend each year. The voters may approve increases to this limit for up to four years. The Proposal: Proposition I would dedicate half of the transfer tax revenues when certain real estate with a value or sales price of more than $10,000,000 changes hands, to be spent only on affordable housing, including social housing developments and housing assistance. Specifically, the measure would: Transfer Tax For properties with a sales price or value between $10,000,000 and under $25,000,000: • Reduce the current transfer tax from 5.5% to 2.75% • Impose a new transfer tax of 2.75% For properties with a sales price or value at $25,000,000 or more:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "• Reduce the transfer tax from 6% to 3% • Impose a new transfer tax of 3%"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "This measure will not increase the tax rate on the transfer of any property above what is charged today. The same exemptions and tax reductions from the current transfer tax would still apply to the new transfer tax. The new transfer tax would also exempt the first sale of certain multifamily real estate if it is sold within 5 years of completion of new residential units. Tax Revenue Spending The City could spend revenue from the new transfer tax only on: • At least 60% for affordable housing production, with at least half to social housing developments; • At least 25% towards the acquisition or rehabilitation of affordable housing, with at least 60% to acquisition of existing housing units; and • At least 10% to tenant stabilization/homeless prevention programs, with at least half to eviction defense and prevention; The Board could only change the transfer tax consistent with the purpose of the tax. All other changes would require voter approval. Proposition I would approve an unlimited number of new affordable housing units for low-income households funded by revenue from the new transfer tax. Proposition I would require the City to submit annual reports to the Board and Mayor on the use of the new tax revenue. Proposition I would increase the City’s spending limit for four years."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to dedicate half of the transfer tax revenues when certain real estate with a value or sales price of more than $10,000,000 changes hands, to be spent only on affordable housing, including social housing developments and housing assistance. A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition I: Should the proposed ordinance be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would represent a moderate annual decrease of approximately $1 million to the City’s overall revenues starting in Fiscal Year (FY) 2027-28. However, the ordinance would also shift $120 million per year of existing revenue from the more flexible General Fund to a special revenue fund dedicated to affordable housing programming and support. Because the ordinance would remove existing revenue from the General Fund, it would increase the City’s projected General Fund deficit by $120 million annually. The ordinance would lower the City’s General Fund Real Property Transfer Tax rates established by Proposition I in November 2020 and subsequently establish a new Real Property Transfer Tax at near identical rates, which could only be used for specific affordable housing programs. The ordinance would reduce the Real Property Transfer Tax rate on transfers of properties with consideration or value from $10 million to under $25 million from 5.5% to 2.75%, and on transfers of properties with consideration or value of $25 million or more from 6% to 3%. This change would result in a reduction in revenue of $120 million from the City’s General Fund, which the City can spend on any government purpose. At the same time, the ordinance would establish a new Real Property Transfer Tax called the House SF Tax and collect the revenue in a special fund, the House SF Fund, which the City could only spend on specific affordable housing programs. The House SF Tax would tax transfers of properties with consideration or value between $10 million and $25 million at a rate of 2.75%, and transfers of properties with consideration or value of $25 million or more at 3%. The ordinance also includes a new exemption from the House SF Tax for certain recently constructed multi-family housing properties, reducing the collected revenue by approximately $1 million annually, so the proposed House SF Fund would generate approximately $119 million annually.",
            "Because the ordinance would replace existing General Fund taxes with a new dedicated tax, it would limit the City’s fiscal flexibility and increase the City’s General Fund deficit, most recently projected at $741.7 million and $1.1 billion in FY 2028-29 and FY 2029-30, respectively. The House SF special revenue fund and tax would represent the City’s 24th voter-mandated funding requirement that limits the City’s budget flexibility. For context, voter-mandated funding requirements currently total approximately $2 billion, or 30%, of the approximately $7 billion General Fund sources. The proposed ordinance requires the City to appropriate the House SF Fund in the following ways: (1) no less than 60% must be spent on affordable housing production programs, (2) no less than 25% must be spent on preservation or acquisition programs, (3) no less than 10% must be spent on tenant stabilization or homelessness prevention programs, and (4) no more than 5% may be spent on the departmental administration of the Fund and administration of the House SF Tax. The proposed ordinance would allow the Board of Supervisors to amend the Real Property Transfer Tax without voter approval only to exempt rent-restricted affordable housing or to make other changes consistent with the stated purposes of the House SF Tax. However, it would remove the existing authority of the Board of Supervisors to reduce, suspend, or repeal the Real Property Transfer Tax without voter approval. The proposed ordinance would also require the Controller’s Office to perform an annual audit on the House SF Fund and file it with the Board of Supervisors. Note that the proposed measure would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition I: Should the proposed ordinance be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would represent a moderate annual decrease of approximately $1 million to the City’s overall revenues starting in Fiscal Year (FY) 2027-28. However, the ordinance would also shift $120 million per year of existing revenue from the more flexible General Fund to a special revenue fund dedicated to affordable housing programming and support. Because the ordinance would remove existing revenue from the General Fund, it would increase the City’s projected General Fund deficit by $120 million annually. The ordinance would lower the City’s General Fund Real Property Transfer Tax rates established by Proposition I in November 2020 and subsequently establish a new Real Property Transfer Tax at near identical rates, which could only be used for specific affordable housing programs. The ordinance would reduce the Real Property Transfer Tax rate on transfers of properties with consideration or value from $10 million to under $25 million from 5.5% to 2.75%, and on transfers of properties with consideration or value of $25 million or more from 6% to 3%. This change would result in a reduction in revenue of $120 million from the City’s General Fund, which the City can spend on any government purpose. At the same time, the ordinance would establish a new Real Property Transfer Tax called the House SF Tax and collect the revenue in a special fund, the House SF Fund, which the City could only spend on specific affordable housing programs. The House SF Tax would tax transfers of properties with consideration or value between $10 million and $25 million at a rate of 2.75%, and transfers of properties with consideration or value of $25 million or more at 3%. The ordinance also includes a new exemption from the House SF Tax for certain recently constructed multi-family housing properties, reducing the collected revenue by approximately $1 million annually, so the proposed House SF Fund would generate approximately $119 million annually."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Because the ordinance would replace existing General Fund taxes with a new dedicated tax, it would limit the City’s fiscal flexibility and increase the City’s General Fund deficit, most recently projected at $741.7 million and $1.1 billion in FY 2028-29 and FY 2029-30, respectively. The House SF special revenue fund and tax would represent the City’s 24th voter-mandated funding requirement that limits the City’s budget flexibility. For context, voter-mandated funding requirements currently total approximately $2 billion, or 30%, of the approximately $7 billion General Fund sources. The proposed ordinance requires the City to appropriate the House SF Fund in the following ways: (1) no less than 60% must be spent on affordable housing production programs, (2) no less than 25% must be spent on preservation or acquisition programs, (3) no less than 10% must be spent on tenant stabilization or homelessness prevention programs, and (4) no more than 5% may be spent on the departmental administration of the Fund and administration of the House SF Tax. The proposed ordinance would allow the Board of Supervisors to amend the Real Property Transfer Tax without voter approval only to exempt rent-restricted affordable housing or to make other changes consistent with the stated purposes of the House SF Tax. However, it would remove the existing authority of the Board of Supervisors to reduce, suspend, or repeal the Real Property Transfer Tax without voter approval. The proposed ordinance would also require the Controller’s Office to perform an annual audit on the House SF Fund and file it with the Board of Supervisors. Note that the proposed measure would change the duties of the Controller’s Office, which has prepared this statement."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City permanently dedicate half of the transfer tax revenues collected when certain real estate with a value or sales price of more than $10,000,000 changes hands, which will continue to be taxed at rates of 5.5% to 6%, to be spent only on affordable housing, including social housing developments and housing assistance, and exempt certain sales from the dedicated portion of the tax, for an estimated annual revenue decrease of approximately $1 million?",
      "pro_short": "Affordable Housing Alliance argues in the official pamphlet: \"YES ON I: KEEP THE PROMISE. AFFORDABLE HOUSING WITH NO NEW TAXES. San Francisco’s housing crisis is pushing families, seniors, teachers, nurses, artists, immigrants, and young people out of the city they love.…\"",
      "con_short": "Judge Quentin L Kopp argues in the official pamphlet: \"Vote NO on the Affordable Housing Guarantee Act. While affordable housing is an important priority, locking transfer tax revenues into rigid set-asides is fiscal mismanagement that threatens San Francisco’s financial stability.…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-i",
      "number": "I",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    },
    {
      "measure_id": "local-sf-j",
      "letter": "J",
      "jurisdiction": "city",
      "jurisdiction_name": "San Francisco",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city",
        "id": "san-francisco"
      },
      "title": "Removal of Foreclosure Exemption for Real Property Transfer Tax",
      "measure_type": "ordinance",
      "vote_threshold": "Majority",
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:voter-pamphlet",
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ],
      "arguments": {
        "argument_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote YES on Proposition J",
            "PROP J ENDS THE UNFAIR TAX BREAK FOR CORPORATE LENDERS",
            "Right now, corporate lenders are taking advantage of a tax break that was meant for struggling homeowners. And it’s draining the fund we use to pay for our firefighters, street cleaners, and public health workers.",
            "In 1984, to protect San Francisco families who were financially struggling, the city created a tax break for homeowners who couldn’t pay their mortgage and would lose their homes to foreclosure. But the same tax break is also being given to financial institutions and corporate lenders when they acquire office towers, mega apartment complexes, and industrial buildings through foreclosure.",
            "That’s not fair, and it’s costing San Francisco hundreds of millions of dollars.",
            "Written by Supervisor Bilal Mahmood and Mayor Daniel Lurie, Proposition J will raise between $100 million and 150 million every year for our general fund. It keeps the tax break for homeowners and small residential buildings, but makes sure that corporate lenders can’t take advantage of this tax relief meant for struggling San Francisco families.",
            "Our city is dealing with a budget shortfall, and we are facing cuts to city services. Prop J helps close that gap by ending a giveaway to corporate lenders that are foreclosing on our residents.",
            "PROPOSITION J is endorsed by:",
            "• Mayor Daniel Lurie • State Senator Scott Wiener • Assemblymember Matt Haney • Assemblymember Catherine Stefani • SEIU 1021 • SEIU 2015 • Teamsters 665 • Board President Rafael Mandelman • Supervisor Bilal Mahmood • Supervisor Myrna Melgar • Supervisor Danny Sauter • Supervisor Alan Wong • Supervisor Matt Dorsey • Supervisor Chyanne Chen • San Francisco Democratic Party • Saikat Chakrabarti"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "• Mayor Daniel Lurie • State Senator Scott Wiener • Assemblymember Matt Haney • Assemblymember Catherine Stefani • SEIU 1021 • SEIU 2015 • Teamsters 665 • Board President Rafael Mandelman • Supervisor Bilal Mahmood • Supervisor Myrna Melgar • Supervisor Danny Sauter • Supervisor Alan Wong • Supervisor Matt Dorsey • Supervisor Chyanne Chen • San Francisco Democratic Party • Saikat Chakrabarti"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_for": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote NO on Proposition J",
            "Proposition J is not about “fairness” or protecting struggling families—it is a misguided tax hike that will worsen San Francisco’s economic crisis and housing shortage.",
            "The proponents claim this measure closes an “unfair tax break” and will generate up to $150 million for our general fund. What they fail to mention is that this money has no strings attached. It flows directly into the City’s general fund, acting as a blank check for politicians rather than legally guaranteeing a single cent for the “firefighters, street cleaners, and public health workers” they mention.",
            "Furthermore, penalizing lenders who take over distressed “office towers, mega apartment complexes, and industrial buildings” through foreclosure will have catastrophic downstream effects. San Francisco is already suffering from record-high commercial vacancies. By increasing the financial burden on institutions trying to stabilize and resell these failing properties, Prop J will stall recovery efforts. Instead of revitalizing our downtown and neighborhoods, distressed properties will sit abandoned, deepening the budget shortfall as overall property values and tax revenues plummet.",
            "The original 1984 tax rules were designed to keep the real estate market functioning during crises. Changing these rules now will deter the investment San Francisco desperately needs. When lenders face higher operational costs, those costs are inevitably passed down to everyday San Franciscans through higher interest rates, stricter lending requirements, and reduced access to capital for local projects.",
            "Don’t give City Hall another blank check while stalling our economic recovery.",
            "Vote NO on Proposition J.",
            "Quentin L Kopp San Francisco Taxpayers Association"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Quentin L Kopp San Francisco Taxpayers Association"
          ]
        },
        "argument_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "Vote NO on eliminating the real property transfer tax foreclosure exemption.",
            "This measure imposes heavy tax penalties on property foreclosures and deeds-in-lieu, severely crippling San Francisco’s economic recovery and housing market by creating a punitive, unpredictable environment for commercial and residential lending.",
            "1. Disproportionately Harms San Francisco’s Credit and Lending Environment No other major city in California imposes transfer taxes on distressed lenders taking back collateral. By penalizing banks, community lenders, and credit unions when a borrower defaults, this measure makes lending in San Francisco significantly riskier and more expensive than anywhere else in the state. Lenders will respond by raising interest rates, demanding higher down payments, or avoiding San Francisco real estate entirely.",
            "2. Stifles Housing Production and Downtown Recovery San Francisco urgently needs investment to build multi-family housing and revitalize downtown commercial space. Chilling the credit market directly undermines housing development, deters adaptive reuse projects, and makes it harder for property owners to restructure debt during economic downturns.",
            "3. Forces Destructive Fire Sales and Abandonment When distressed properties face massive tax bills just to clear bad debt, lenders and property owners will be forced into drawn-out legal battles or distressed fire sales. This depresses neighborhood property values and leaves vacant buildings blighting local corridors.",
            "San Francisco cannot afford policies that scare away capital, freeze lending, and penalize financial resolution. Protect local economic stability and housing credit.",
            "Vote NO on Measure J.",
            "Judge Quentin L Kopp San Francisco Taxpayers Association"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Judge Quentin L Kopp San Francisco Taxpayers Association"
          ]
        },
        "rebuttal_to_against": {
          "status": "submitted",
          "paragraphs": [
            "YES ON J — TAX CORPORATE LENDERS WHEN THEY FORECLOSE ON BUILDINGS",
            "Prop J doesn’t touch families losing their homes. It only removes the tax break for corporate lenders that foreclose on office towers, mega apartment complexes, and industrial buildings. Homeowners and small residential buildings keep the exemption. That’s written into the measure.",
            "WONT HARM THE MARKET: This tax break was created in 1984 to protect struggling families, not to subsidize lenders. Investment firms and corporate lenders that foreclose on large commercial properties are sophisticated players who already price risk into every deal. A modest transfer tax on a handful of major transactions a year isn’t going to freeze lending citywide. It just closes a loophole those lenders were never supposed to use.",
            "WONT HURT HOUSING PRODUCTION: The foreclosure tax will apply to office towers, industrial buildings, and mega-complexes that already exist, not new housing construction. Prop J doesn’t tax builders. It taxes lenders. That won’t affect how new housing gets built.",
            "PROTECTS CITY SERVICES: Prop J’s opponents are asking San Franciscans to keep giving a tax break to the very institutions that already benefit most from foreclosure, at the expense of the fund that pays for firefighters, street cleaners, and public health workers.",
            "The choice is simple. Keep an unfair corporate tax break meant for families. Or put millions of dollars back into our fund for city services.",
            "Vote YES on Prop J.",
            "Supervisor Bilal Mahmood"
          ],
          "signers": [
            "Supervisor Bilal Mahmood"
          ]
        }
      },
      "documents": [
        {
          "label": "Official voter pamphlet, printed page 144",
          "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf#page=146"
        }
      ],
      "summary": "Proposition J would apply a transfer tax for properties such as commercial, industrial, and large residential real estate that a lender takes through foreclosure or is handed over to the lender to avoid foreclosure. Starting March 1, 2027, these properties would be taxed on their full market value. The tax break would still apply to the transfer of: 1. single-family residences, 2. multi-family residential buildings with fewer than five units, and 3. mixed-use properties with fewer than five residential units and only one floor of non-residential space. Proposition J would increase the City’s spending limit for four years.",
      "yes_means": "If you vote “yes,” you want to apply a transfer tax for properties such as commercial, industrial, and large residential properties, that are transferred to a lender because of foreclosure.",
      "no_means": "If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes.",
      "fiscal_impact": "Should the proposed initiative ordinance be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would significantly increase the City’s Real Property Transfer Tax revenues although the amount generated each year would be unpredictable and likely to change significantly year-to-year. The measure could bring an average of $100 million to $150 million annually over the first five years. The total revenue in any given year will be highly dependent on the number of foreclosures and real estate conditions. It is likely that revenue increases would be highest in the near term then decline significantly over time.",
      "analysis": [
        {
          "section_id": "digest",
          "heading": "Digest by the Ballot Simplification Council",
          "paragraphs": [
            "The Way It Is Now: San Francisco charges a tax when most real estate property in the City changes hands. The amount of the tax depends on the property’s sales price or value.",
            "When a lender takes over a property through foreclosure, or when an owner hands over a property to the lender to avoid foreclosure, there is a tax break. The lender pays tax only on the difference between what the property sold for and what is still owed to the lender, including interest and foreclosure costs.",
            "State law limits the total revenue, including tax revenue, the City may spend each year. The voters may approve increases to this limit for up to four years.",
            "The Proposal: Proposition J would apply a transfer tax for properties such as commercial, industrial, and large residential real estate that a lender takes through foreclosure or is handed over to the lender to avoid foreclosure. Starting March 1, 2027, these properties would be taxed on their full market value.",
            "The tax break would still apply to the transfer of:",
            "1. single-family residences, 2. multi-family residential buildings with fewer than five units, and 3. mixed-use properties with fewer than five residential units and only one floor of non-residential space.",
            "Proposition J would increase the City’s spending limit for four years.",
            "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to apply a transfer tax for properties such as commercial, industrial, and large residential properties, that are transferred to a lender because of foreclosure.",
            "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Way It Is Now: San Francisco charges a tax when most real estate property in the City changes hands. The amount of the tax depends on the property’s sales price or value."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "When a lender takes over a property through foreclosure, or when an owner hands over a property to the lender to avoid foreclosure, there is a tax break. The lender pays tax only on the difference between what the property sold for and what is still owed to the lender, including interest and foreclosure costs."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "State law limits the total revenue, including tax revenue, the City may spend each year. The voters may approve increases to this limit for up to four years."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The Proposal: Proposition J would apply a transfer tax for properties such as commercial, industrial, and large residential real estate that a lender takes through foreclosure or is handed over to the lender to avoid foreclosure. Starting March 1, 2027, these properties would be taxed on their full market value."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The tax break would still apply to the transfer of:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "1. single-family residences, 2. multi-family residential buildings with fewer than five units, and 3. mixed-use properties with fewer than five residential units and only one floor of non-residential space."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Proposition J would increase the City’s spending limit for four years."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “YES” Vote Means: If you vote “yes,” you want to apply a transfer tax for properties such as commercial, industrial, and large residential properties, that are transferred to a lender because of foreclosure."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "A “NO” Vote Means: If you vote “no,” you do not want to make these changes."
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "section_id": "controller",
          "heading": "City Controller’s fiscal statement",
          "paragraphs": [
            "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition J:",
            "Should the proposed initiative ordinance be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would significantly increase the City’s Real Property Transfer Tax revenues although the amount generated each year would be unpredictable and likely to change significantly year-to-year. The measure could bring an average of $100 million to $150 million annually over the first five years. The total revenue in any given year will be highly dependent on the number of foreclosures and real estate conditions. It is likely that revenue increases would be highest in the near term then decline significantly over time.",
            "Currently the City partially exempts transfers of real property to a lender by foreclosure or in lieu of foreclosure from its Real Property Transfer Tax, which imposes a tax ranging from 0.5% to 6% of properties’ consideration or value when they are transferred. The proposed ordinance would retain the existing partial exemption for foreclosures of residential and mixed-use properties with fewer than five residential units. However, the proposed ordinance would remove the foreclosure exemption from other",
            "property types and subject those transfers to the tax on the fair market value of the properties at the same rates as non-foreclosed properties.",
            "The revenue generated by this measure will be highly dependent on the number of foreclosures and distressed properties in the City. The number of distressed properties has risen since the COVID-19 pandemic because of the decline in property values resulting from the pandemic. If real estate recovers quickly and the number of foreclosures decreases, the proposed ordinance would bring in less revenue. But if the real estate market does not recover quickly and the number of foreclosures remains high, the proposed ordinance will generate more revenue.",
            "For context, in Fiscal Year (FY) 2021-2022, before the City’s real estate market declined due to the pandemic, the proposed ordinance would have generated $3.2 million. However, several years later in FY 2025-26, the proposed ordinance would have generated $232.5 million. Based on the City’s experience in the early 1990s recession and the Great Recession in the late 2000s, the number of foreclosure-related transactions will likely fall over a four-to-six-year period back to non-crisis levels.",
            "Revenue from this proposed measure is likely to be significantly more unpredictable than the current Real Property Transfer Tax. It falls on a very narrow and highly cyclical portion of property transfers in the City. There may be years where the proposed measure generates next to no new tax revenue."
          ],
          "blocks": [
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "City Controller Greg Wagner has issued the following statement on the fiscal impact of Proposition J:"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Should the proposed initiative ordinance be approved by the voters, in my opinion, it would significantly increase the City’s Real Property Transfer Tax revenues although the amount generated each year would be unpredictable and likely to change significantly year-to-year. The measure could bring an average of $100 million to $150 million annually over the first five years. The total revenue in any given year will be highly dependent on the number of foreclosures and real estate conditions. It is likely that revenue increases would be highest in the near term then decline significantly over time."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Currently the City partially exempts transfers of real property to a lender by foreclosure or in lieu of foreclosure from its Real Property Transfer Tax, which imposes a tax ranging from 0.5% to 6% of properties’ consideration or value when they are transferred. The proposed ordinance would retain the existing partial exemption for foreclosures of residential and mixed-use properties with fewer than five residential units. However, the proposed ordinance would remove the foreclosure exemption from other"
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "property types and subject those transfers to the tax on the fair market value of the properties at the same rates as non-foreclosed properties."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "The revenue generated by this measure will be highly dependent on the number of foreclosures and distressed properties in the City. The number of distressed properties has risen since the COVID-19 pandemic because of the decline in property values resulting from the pandemic. If real estate recovers quickly and the number of foreclosures decreases, the proposed ordinance would bring in less revenue. But if the real estate market does not recover quickly and the number of foreclosures remains high, the proposed ordinance will generate more revenue."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "For context, in Fiscal Year (FY) 2021-2022, before the City’s real estate market declined due to the pandemic, the proposed ordinance would have generated $3.2 million. However, several years later in FY 2025-26, the proposed ordinance would have generated $232.5 million. Based on the City’s experience in the early 1990s recession and the Great Recession in the late 2000s, the number of foreclosure-related transactions will likely fall over a four-to-six-year period back to non-crisis levels."
            },
            {
              "lead": null,
              "text": "Revenue from this proposed measure is likely to be significantly more unpredictable than the current Real Property Transfer Tax. It falls on a very narrow and highly cyclical portion of property transfers in the City. There may be years where the proposed measure generates next to no new tax revenue."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "question": "Shall the City permanently apply a transfer tax of between 0.5% and 6% of a property’s fair market value, on the transfer of properties such as commercial, industrial, and large residential properties, that are transferred to a lender because of foreclosure or to avoid foreclosure, for estimated annual revenue of $100 million to $150 million?",
      "pro_short": "• Mayor Daniel Lurie argues in the official pamphlet: \"Vote YES on Proposition J PROP J ENDS THE UNFAIR TAX BREAK FOR CORPORATE LENDERS…\"",
      "con_short": "Judge Quentin L Kopp argues in the official pamphlet: \"Vote NO on eliminating the real property transfer tax foreclosure exemption. This measure imposes heavy tax penalties on property foreclosures and deeds-in-lieu, severely crippling San Francisco’s economic recovery and housing market by creating a punitive, unpredictable environment for commercial and residential lending.…\"",
      "contest_id": "local-sf-j",
      "number": "J",
      "county": "san-francisco",
      "claims": [],
      "funding": null,
      "funding_missing_reason": "Funding by side is not ingested yet.",
      "tier": "T1"
    }
  ],
  "offices_not_on_ballot": [
    {
      "office": "Sunnyvale City Council, District 6",
      "district": {
        "kind": "city_council",
        "id": "sunnyvale-6"
      },
      "reason": "Not up for election in 2026. Only Districts 1, 3, and 5 are elected on November 3, 2026.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:sunnyvale-write-in-guide",
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ]
    },
    {
      "office": "Board of Supervisors, District 3",
      "district": {
        "kind": "county_supervisor",
        "id": "3"
      },
      "reason": "Not on the county's sample ballot, and the county's list of offices has no supervisor seat in this election.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ]
    },
    {
      "office": "County Assessor, Sheriff, District Attorney, and Superior Court judges",
      "district": {
        "kind": "county",
        "id": "santa-clara"
      },
      "reason": "The district lookup lists these offices for the address. The county's sample ballot lists none of them, and the county's list of offices has no county or Superior Court seat in this election.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ]
    },
    {
      "office": "Fremont Union High School District, Trustee Area 2",
      "district": {
        "kind": "school",
        "id": "fuhsd-2"
      },
      "reason": "Not up for election in 2026. The county's list of offices has Fremont Union trustee areas 1, 3, and 4 in 2026.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ],
      "applies_to_precincts": [
        "3005"
      ]
    },
    {
      "office": "West Valley-Mission Community College District, Trustee Area 1",
      "district": {
        "kind": "school",
        "id": "wvm-1"
      },
      "reason": "Not up for election in 2026. The county's list of offices has West Valley-Mission trustee areas 3, 5, and 7 in 2026.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ],
      "applies_to_precincts": [
        "3004",
        "3008",
        "3176"
      ]
    },
    {
      "office": "Santa Clara County Board of Education, Trustee Area 5",
      "district": {
        "kind": "school",
        "id": "sccoe-5"
      },
      "reason": "Not up for election in 2026. The county's list of offices has trustee areas 2, 6, and 7 in 2026.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ]
    },
    {
      "office": "Santa Clara Valley Water District, District 3",
      "district": {
        "kind": "special",
        "id": "valley-water-3"
      },
      "reason": "Not up for election in 2026. The county's list of offices has districts 1, 4, 6, and 7 in 2026.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ]
    },
    {
      "office": "Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District, Ward 5",
      "district": {
        "kind": "special",
        "id": "midpen-5"
      },
      "reason": "Only one candidate, Karen C. Holman, filed, so the district appoints her instead of holding an election.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-bos-in-lieu-memo",
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ]
    },
    {
      "office": "El Camino Healthcare District, two at-large seats",
      "district": {
        "kind": "special",
        "id": "el-camino-healthcare-district"
      },
      "reason": "Only two candidates filed for the two seats, so the Board of Supervisors appointed them on October 6, 2026.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-bos-in-lieu-memo",
        "pilot:scc-bos-in-lieu-resolution",
        "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3008"
      ],
      "applies_to_precincts": [
        "3008"
      ]
    },
    {
      "office": "Santa Clara Unified School District, Trustee Area 3",
      "district": {
        "kind": "school",
        "id": "scusd-3"
      },
      "reason": "The county lists Santa Clara Unified trustee areas 1, 3, 4, and 6 as open in 2026, but the county's sample ballot for this precinct does not list this seat. The reason is not confirmed.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ],
      "applies_to_precincts": [
        "3004",
        "3008",
        "3176"
      ],
      "check_status": "unresolved"
    },
    {
      "office": "Sunnyvale School District, Trustee Area 5",
      "district": {
        "kind": "school",
        "id": "sesd-5"
      },
      "reason": "The county lists Sunnyvale School District trustee areas 1, 3, and 5 as open in 2026, but the sample ballot the county serves for this precinct does not list this seat. The reason is not confirmed.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ],
      "applies_to_precincts": [
        "3005"
      ],
      "check_status": "unresolved"
    },
    {
      "office": "Foothill-De Anza Community College District, Trustee Area 2",
      "district": {
        "kind": "school",
        "id": "fhda-2"
      },
      "reason": "The county lists Foothill-De Anza trustee areas 2 and 4 as open in 2026, but the sample ballot the county serves for this precinct does not list this seat. The reason is not confirmed.",
      "source_keys": [
        "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
        "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
        "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004"
      ],
      "applies_to_precincts": [
        "3005"
      ],
      "check_status": "unresolved"
    }
  ],
  "ballot_samples": [
    {
      "sample_id": "3004",
      "precincts": [
        "3004",
        "3005",
        "3176"
      ],
      "own_sample_for": [
        "3004"
      ],
      "ballot_type": "38",
      "item_count": 37,
      "local_office_count": 0,
      "ordered_ids": [
        "governor",
        "lieutenant-governor",
        "secretary-of-state",
        "controller",
        "treasurer",
        "attorney-general",
        "insurance-commissioner",
        "boe-2",
        "us-house-cd-17",
        "state-senate-sd-10",
        "state-assembly-ad-26",
        "retention-supreme-court-joshua-groban",
        "retention-supreme-court-kelli-m-evans",
        "retention-appeal-6-charles-e-wilson-ii",
        "retention-appeal-6-frederick-s-chung",
        "retention-appeal-6-charles-f-adams",
        "retention-appeal-6-allison-marston-danner",
        "retention-appeal-6-daniel-h-bromberg",
        "superintendent-of-public-instruction",
        "prop-1",
        "prop-2",
        "prop-3",
        "prop-4",
        "prop-5",
        "prop-37",
        "prop-38",
        "prop-39",
        "prop-40",
        "prop-41",
        "prop-42",
        "prop-43",
        "prop-44",
        "prop-45",
        "local-ptrmd-rtm",
        "local-sunnyvale-g",
        "local-sunnyvale-h",
        "local-sunnyvale-i"
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "scc:sample-ballot-3004",
        "scc:sample-ballot-selector"
      ]
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "3008",
      "precincts": [
        "3008"
      ],
      "own_sample_for": [
        "3008"
      ],
      "ballot_type": "40",
      "item_count": 38,
      "local_office_count": 0,
      "ordered_ids": [
        "governor",
        "lieutenant-governor",
        "secretary-of-state",
        "controller",
        "treasurer",
        "attorney-general",
        "insurance-commissioner",
        "boe-2",
        "us-house-cd-17",
        "state-senate-sd-10",
        "state-assembly-ad-26",
        "retention-supreme-court-joshua-groban",
        "retention-supreme-court-kelli-m-evans",
        "retention-appeal-6-charles-e-wilson-ii",
        "retention-appeal-6-frederick-s-chung",
        "retention-appeal-6-charles-f-adams",
        "retention-appeal-6-allison-marston-danner",
        "retention-appeal-6-daniel-h-bromberg",
        "superintendent-of-public-instruction",
        "prop-1",
        "prop-2",
        "prop-3",
        "prop-4",
        "prop-5",
        "prop-37",
        "prop-38",
        "prop-39",
        "prop-40",
        "prop-41",
        "prop-42",
        "prop-43",
        "prop-44",
        "prop-45",
        "local-ptrmd-rtm",
        "local-sunnyvale-g",
        "local-sunnyvale-h",
        "local-sunnyvale-i",
        "local-echd-s"
      ],
      "source_keys": [
        "scc:sample-ballot-3008",
        "scc:sample-ballot-selector"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "presets": [
    {
      "preset_id": "north-sunnyvale-tasman",
      "label": "North Sunnyvale (Tasman Dr)",
      "districts": {
        "city": "sunnyvale",
        "county": "santa-clara",
        "sd": "10",
        "cd": "17",
        "ad": "26",
        "boe": "2",
        "appellate": "6"
      },
      "precincts": [
        "3004",
        "3005",
        "3008",
        "3176"
      ],
      "precinct_note": "Four precincts split this address by unit number, and county unit ranges overlap. Only precinct 3008 votes on Measure S.",
      "district_layers": {
        "city": "Incorporated Places",
        "county": "Counties",
        "sd": "2026 State Legislative Districts - Upper",
        "cd": "120th Congressional Districts",
        "ad": "2026 State Legislative Districts - Lower"
      },
      "geocoder_source_key": "geocoder:north-sunnyvale-tasman"
    }
  ],
  "areas": [
    {
      "area_id": "san-francisco",
      "label": "San Francisco",
      "districts": {
        "city": "san-francisco",
        "county": "san-francisco"
      },
      "source_keys": [
        "sf:qualified-measures"
      ]
    },
    {
      "area_id": "sunnyvale",
      "label": "Sunnyvale",
      "districts": {
        "city": "sunnyvale",
        "county": "santa-clara"
      },
      "source_keys": [
        "scc:list-local-measures"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "sources": [
    {
      "key": "fec:house-totals:1",
      "url": "https://api.open.fec.gov/v1/candidates/totals/?state=CA&office=H&election_year=2026&election_full=true&per_page=100&page=1&sort=district",
      "sha256": "50fd72dcefc6558dc07de2ddbb445f4fe197035ecc96e5531b6c38784f87625d",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:09+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "fec:house-totals:2",
      "url": "https://api.open.fec.gov/v1/candidates/totals/?state=CA&office=H&election_year=2026&election_full=true&per_page=100&page=2&sort=district",
      "sha256": "29736dc135a150bef61e7d635c63b7274bc6809dc78d5159782e348174dba4b6",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:10+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "fec:house-totals:3",
      "url": "https://api.open.fec.gov/v1/candidates/totals/?state=CA&office=H&election_year=2026&election_full=true&per_page=100&page=3&sort=district",
      "sha256": "59735aec6335fe999d736017f8ff6e0726717eb097861c6ca9756c7e2fbca868",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:10+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "fec:house-totals:4",
      "url": "https://api.open.fec.gov/v1/candidates/totals/?state=CA&office=H&election_year=2026&election_full=true&per_page=100&page=4&sort=district",
      "sha256": "4ee6bdf55d7ab8a48f1e13f161b58d321ba1d774399163eedee57bec49983ac0",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:11+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "fec:house-totals:5",
      "url": "https://api.open.fec.gov/v1/candidates/totals/?state=CA&office=H&election_year=2026&election_full=true&per_page=100&page=5&sort=district",
      "sha256": "0bcec4688e8517f8ce2310bac14599f208346a3e4613a33fd840ce32a5619c23",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:11+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "geocoder:north-sunnyvale-tasman",
      "url": "https://geocoding.geo.census.gov/geocoder/geographies/onelineaddress?address=%5Baddress+preset+north-sunnyvale-tasman%5D&benchmark=Public_AR_Current&vintage=Current_Current&layers=all&format=json",
      "sha256": "233e30207bbaf31aea0a794e08967af9cfc5b0bfc5843c232ae8e60ff46574fa",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:12+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:echd-boundary",
      "url": "https://www.google.com/maps/d/kml?mid=1nlokC-26K3QOzKA5ydllKYSj9crbivnR&forcekml=1",
      "sha256": "c944581beb68312567722027971648fa89d34b033fcd3e71b6e9681175f56c8e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:56+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:fhda-trustee-areas",
      "url": "https://www.fhda.edu/trustee-areas/_draft_maps/Foothill%20De%20Anza%20CCD%20Final%20Plan%202022.pdf",
      "sha256": "089c31687a9c80457e9295ae9d21b5836bf59831f2e1d9e6c7faad3ea7ea4d92",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:58+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:fuhsd-trustee-areas",
      "url": "https://resources.finalsite.net/images/f_auto,q_auto,t_image_size_6/v1714155037/fuhsdorg/g95f79zvxrfvmnsool70/Scenario5PDFChartsandMapwSequencing_Page_1.jpg",
      "sha256": "5da3a474da3ba961532227d10290317bc3b38c3c86b594c106dd36f765ce733a",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:41:33+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:midpen-wards",
      "url": "https://services2.arcgis.com/qmhndvC947rDNl6t/arcgis/rest/services/Ward_Boundary_(public)/FeatureServer/0/query?where=1%3D1&outFields=WARDNUM,DIRECNAME&f=geojson",
      "sha256": "0ad73ce76d497ff095bb598f85e2f0c5dcacb2163d8eb57a2c0b4ceb1a975e24",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:55+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-bos-in-lieu-memo",
      "url": "https://sccgov.iqm2.com/Citizens/FileOpen.aspx?Type=30&ID=231449",
      "sha256": "b74db94904a2bc014b47ab24da62fb86e78195d934b5f653e97d7eb579cc8bf2",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:52+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-bos-in-lieu-memo:text",
      "url": "https://sccgov.iqm2.com/Citizens/FileOpen.aspx?Type=30&ID=231449",
      "sha256": "944dda5e1afd074f45da664d9c831789dfcb3c9e62357e03d8b8ebc51dd1fa44",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:52+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-bos-in-lieu-resolution",
      "url": "https://sccgov.iqm2.com/Citizens/FileOpen.aspx?Type=4&ID=273253",
      "sha256": "79b613416691d6c32d61c8ba941d53f9c8f88fe801b5655c226acc39258902a4",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:52+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-bos-in-lieu-resolution:text",
      "url": "https://sccgov.iqm2.com/Citizens/FileOpen.aspx?Type=4&ID=273253",
      "sha256": "861839d33676ec0954407aba21545665f6681145b5aac4c4d53ba18ee4d2bc19",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:52+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-district-lookup",
      "url": "https://rovservices.sccgov.org/",
      "sha256": "0191100a07d5175173911f2d2aa0e3fa48d157daedd7fe5d0bea82917b6425f2",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:08:08.076Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-district-lookup-pdf",
      "url": "https://rovservices.sccgov.org/",
      "sha256": "202fae39d89e221eddd7fee50bb1f4d074112fc568e36c6501b93211a27eb550",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:13:58Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-list-local-measures",
      "url": "https://vote.santaclaracounty.gov/list-local-measures-4",
      "sha256": "2bb2baabe7594516bcd5128f463b631946b074a297d2da48383ed1f0eb6a8b8a",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T18:35:38Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-list-local-measures-html",
      "url": "https://vote.santaclaracounty.gov/list-local-measures-4",
      "sha256": "f957d041e8070ee032701898c61805649c6d3b36d4bfcf3d53d73a364955cada",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T18:35:38Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-list-of-offices",
      "url": "https://vote.santaclaracounty.gov/november-3-2026-general-election-list-offices",
      "sha256": "b2bdee7b465164c8d14975be3a4ed448c420699fd8002831e48a668ac497bf3b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:09:07.022Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-list-of-offices-pdf",
      "url": "https://vote.santaclaracounty.gov/november-3-2026-general-election-list-offices",
      "sha256": "2ce25c52d45463548c6ec375a40fc87aea9d77c2e2c65004348c8cd9843e311c",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:16:32Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-notice-of-election",
      "url": "https://www.saratogafire.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Notice-of-Election-Nov-3-2026-General-Election.pdf",
      "sha256": "615663486d3829647acc3a54de356f2f0e4ff03d0b8ebd10f0462f8fc23e8973",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:42:28+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-notice-of-election:text",
      "url": "https://www.saratogafire.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Notice-of-Election-Nov-3-2026-General-Election.pdf",
      "sha256": "d75c885cfbb547e4f9c11f0ba83a9d6e032cc92287fcaa5f3ac152bca8b2a9ab",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:41:31+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-qualified-local-candidates-block-page",
      "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-09/qualified-list-of-local-candidates-9-28-26.pdf?VersionId=CM6jbwAVTLFIjLakj6hJku2l9KPAIxli",
      "sha256": "9c63f688cad52ab2f4997bab27369cba1169f989e3b913d5216ee5a98ec1e75e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:08:56.217Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003004&lang=en",
      "sha256": "1c368d7d4c1cc785d58d53a8772953ad9fe8fa366b8b0017849f71b50c0df167",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:14:15.206Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004-pdf",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003004&lang=en",
      "sha256": "34269632458e941eeabd7179c891b85662d4736e7bbd5d1b4b85ba7a9d28289e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:15:02Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3004-pdf-text",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003004&lang=en",
      "sha256": "aaa59b602cb038a1bac3adeff6563ec4e116f4f687677a2736d8c8bce8aa2cd4",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:15:02Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3008",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003008&lang=en",
      "sha256": "1c08412d076645c41be1e077cc06ad70580570db6aee4747ad08f0e0d84db764",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:15:12.823Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3008-pdf",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003008&lang=en",
      "sha256": "9bf749313f3dc131af55f72acdad0bed1164815fa23bbb0a0b2f6ff962403ea3",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:15:40Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-ballot-3008-pdf-text",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003008&lang=en",
      "sha256": "7d58aa3f7fad0854d23158f5e582b5e351f7b434933185376a8409f56c6d8361",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:15:40Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-direct-3005",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003005&lang=en",
      "sha256": "c6c3acdd852e82746bfbdca2a4b53db01fb1917a53b95a798559eabe49bdda97",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:24:26.599Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-direct-3176",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003176&lang=en",
      "sha256": "c6c3acdd852e82746bfbdca2a4b53db01fb1917a53b95a798559eabe49bdda97",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:24:37.693Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-lookup",
      "url": "https://rovservices.sccgov.org/",
      "sha256": "f22ed594bf625bf5a91331fdd2c2fc4d9e94551b0079411d580bf0d3c7ed2b10",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:13:02.709Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-route-3005",
      "url": "https://rovservices.sccgov.org/",
      "sha256": "a304f577b4148481e6285bd892fa13bb4e1f4a0074ce82dbcf036da028d7703d",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:14:48.487Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-route-3008",
      "url": "https://rovservices.sccgov.org/",
      "sha256": "3a20c5651909810b5639a872d0afd3e0b73b672978e13397dc82e86ffe14b45c",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:17:21.058Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-route-3176",
      "url": "https://rovservices.sccgov.org/",
      "sha256": "a4fabc609b3d795f6e650c732cbeeda20a4f3eed628c534efbd5aeb268a2ad1b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:15:02.843Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:scc-sample-unit-mapping",
      "url": "https://rovservices.sccgov.org/",
      "sha256": "875000484ca183709a5b4abaf24c09da69720823de031f550bde080355f101ee",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:13:32.633Z"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:sccoe-trustee-areas",
      "url": "https://www.arcgis.com/sharing/rest/content/items/ae07e563224d49d281b6a8a9a0b84dd6/data?f=json",
      "sha256": "523dadf36476d51728870d409062b4768d8303e3f9c40bbb9b8680c491d34e69",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:53+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:sesd-trustee-areas",
      "url": "https://resources.finalsite.net/images/v1748860215/sesdorg/opg3uiwpeb5ntuoikzyl/ApprovedTrusteeAreas_withoutTrustees.pdf",
      "sha256": "96e812b2b0d1b0d6ac407be03e908a91a6eda466d36640483ce05a3d1830ccc1",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:42:31+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:sunnyvale-council-districts",
      "url": "https://www.arcgis.com/sharing/rest/content/items/c104aeaa742047ceae81fa8e3c96563e/data",
      "sha256": "e7d7fb2f58fa1e55bacf68fb87973ee4f5ba6847daf65b68275df0cc1a6a46df",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:42:31+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:sunnyvale-measures-action",
      "url": "https://webapi.legistar.com/v1/sunnyvaleca/matters/16985/histories",
      "sha256": "ef565bd1442d2bc65a1c9b9ceae23c2082397ee566ef66802c647be139a713e3",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:41:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:sunnyvale-write-in-guide",
      "url": "https://legistar.granicus.com/Sunnyvale/attachments/6e42e5d8-8aa5-49f2-bf19-21714fdaae71.pdf",
      "sha256": "485d6f18eb6dd77c8b7720a67b8aec26dad95b1432b611ee67c6e7638e1e4daa",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T19:42:30+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:sunnyvale-write-in-guide:text",
      "url": "https://legistar.granicus.com/Sunnyvale/attachments/6e42e5d8-8aa5-49f2-bf19-21714fdaae71.pdf",
      "sha256": "66d22c91acfca5e9855c306ca92b5777b96fdee312a8081f0d292d8a0acff35e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:41:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:valley-water-districts",
      "url": "https://services2.arcgis.com/9KdAx8qBsHiGXOEw/arcgis/rest/services/SCVWD_Board_of_Directors_Boundaries/FeatureServer/0/query?where=1%3D1&outFields=DISTRICT,DIRECTOR&f=geojson",
      "sha256": "117ee3eae5b12fa8ca149ffe89b09e53658fb5bfa636778a589f3c4d90185fe7",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:54+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "pilot:wvm-trustee-areas",
      "url": "https://www.wvm.edu/board/redistricting/_documents/plans/wvmccd-trustee-area-maps-of-plan-adopted-2-15-22-revised-8-2-22.pdf",
      "sha256": "cad0ca950703c9b20f0c5a79675fb8e25e0b073487722188aa3f71a00c6112e2",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T02:21:58+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:audit-homelessness-2024",
      "url": "https://www.auditor.ca.gov/reports/2023-102-1/",
      "sha256": "ee5d60cdf5462ddc897521880f58e80f45978465c766a510acca21eae2a4c5af",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:audit-housing-2014",
      "url": "https://information.auditor.ca.gov/reports/summary/2014-037",
      "sha256": "2e6eb9db32e01d531aef2e8da679cb49804c770baacc3fb0ee4e49535728ced1",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:audit-housing-2018",
      "url": "https://information.auditor.ca.gov/reports/2018-037/summary.html",
      "sha256": "6e378a72e896454330fd545a3849a03910efad0996c36502dcd341bdb0aab52a",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:audit-housing-followup",
      "url": "https://information.auditor.ca.gov/reports/recommendations/2018-037",
      "sha256": "165c6e731527470540d1fcfb6d64170407748cbf87a1564c5bb20d8ae5f6e9dc",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:chp-housing-needs-2026",
      "url": "https://calhousingpartnership.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/CHP_2026-Housing-Needs-Report-FINAL.pdf",
      "sha256": "ddd4460b44f5cae36f85cf2b7673dafa14cb6655fdda6a9b14e31a33336cd766",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:chp-housing-needs-2026:text",
      "url": "https://calhousingpartnership.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/CHP_2026-Housing-Needs-Report-FINAL.pdf",
      "sha256": "a18491087297e104795c652875d4ab4c746dd0fc0b64b58d3d4c1f536fe9b843",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:enterprise-pipeline-2026",
      "url": "https://www.enterprisecommunity.org/sites/default/files/2026-03/2026_State_Pipeline_Brief.pdf",
      "sha256": "284333e703a9992f9d1a77cfdc16d7aa8c5aa01773425b12c8d7727281f8338c",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:enterprise-pipeline-2026:text",
      "url": "https://www.enterprisecommunity.org/sites/default/files/2026-03/2026_State_Pipeline_Brief.pdf",
      "sha256": "d7ee830246749271089ddd9259fb91c30b148f32a94c3c17c2fdfd4b6c7a560f",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:hcd-annual-2024",
      "url": "https://www.hcd.ca.gov/sites/default/files/docs/policy-and-research/plan-report/annual-report-23-24.pdf",
      "sha256": "c9d063c0700872f7e102e36ae599614cdbe2774c8bb5704a412f9e2fc3665322",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:hcd-annual-2024:text",
      "url": "https://www.hcd.ca.gov/sites/default/files/docs/policy-and-research/plan-report/annual-report-23-24.pdf",
      "sha256": "2091eb283843d27c4f784844a12db77dc0b2506ecc516b5f7c49430e7a2ba9e6",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:hcd-caper-2025",
      "url": "https://www.hcd.ca.gov/sites/default/files/docs/policy-and-research/plan-report/2024-25-state-of-california-caper.pdf",
      "sha256": "6d823bc2ca1d85a094a0cf519dbf3192a6e34905cb5c9704c5d98e4a7e11a208",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:hcd-caper-2025:text",
      "url": "https://www.hcd.ca.gov/sites/default/files/docs/policy-and-research/plan-report/2024-25-state-of-california-caper.pdf",
      "sha256": "0792ff600c0cc267de4ae7405e229b6641226de60d9ed00f32063abd392a96b2",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:hcd-nplh-2024",
      "url": "https://website-prod.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2025-12/2023-24-nplh.pdf",
      "sha256": "e14197909290fa97211d21b16d0c65380964a9f4bcd1ffe59f6819c1afa37b6e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:hcd-nplh-2024:text",
      "url": "https://website-prod.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2025-12/2023-24-nplh.pdf",
      "sha256": "c0529f4158e01f7a4a87ba892184f9b7505ce3b172f4459577ab21fa18d8d19a",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:hdfc-consolidation",
      "url": "https://www.hdfc.ca.gov/",
      "sha256": "4bc0b311dee4f9a3fae4e8836112776db0a869a389198fe3f9a06e605ef66b3b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:lao-prop1-2018",
      "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2018/prop1-110618.pdf",
      "sha256": "f5528668fdd3164be8c844ccd64699d281260996e89c2a7181c07a5ee8d45554",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:lao-prop1-2018:text",
      "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2018/prop1-110618.pdf",
      "sha256": "caf99ecb9d68b51d8092c857c47a961b05352607f8e69c1ea5152ea54dd6d44f",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-1:terner-financing-2025",
      "url": "https://ternercenter.berkeley.edu/research-and-policy/reducing-the-complexity-in-californias-affordable-housing-finance-system/",
      "sha256": "9d751bcf14653ccf6aee69e45350c9cc9fc38d5327f50a091899c0628bf53f1f",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:28:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:calmatters-prop38-selection-2026",
      "url": "https://calmatters.org/politics/elections/2026/07/proposition-38-california/",
      "sha256": "bda30ba11de104a735421671fb0571f06f9324ff422a0a16b694bed1b7f4b1a8",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-economic-study-2019",
      "url": "https://www.cirm.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/archive/files/about_cirm/CIRM_Economic%20Impact%20Report_10_3_19%20v.2.pdf",
      "sha256": "6a1a614d18b4b9e75bf73953b5690691d233927e2ac02ebe98a15ef6a43373b9",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-economic-study-2019:text",
      "url": "https://www.cirm.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/archive/files/about_cirm/CIRM_Economic%20Impact%20Report_10_3_19%20v.2.pdf",
      "sha256": "0e4a964dfb41d199b8fe6753bb0f45f30ec3709901799293926065ce81051f9e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-financial-2024",
      "url": "https://www.cirm.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/15a.-20260129-FY-23-24-Financial-Audit-Report-ICOC-updated-260122.pdf",
      "sha256": "392cd93699fa249346692c9eeda4e24517d3076270a9fce4c31499bc4d09bb63",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-financial-2024:text",
      "url": "https://www.cirm.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/15a.-20260129-FY-23-24-Financial-Audit-Report-ICOC-updated-260122.pdf",
      "sha256": "ee88298343eaefcab9781e0c0a2907a88b475821878554ac20922a0600165157",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-infrastructure",
      "url": "https://www.cirm.ca.gov/program-and-building-infrastructure/",
      "sha256": "afd36ca46756a1df87aeddcd68516d4f0ee950221b979670a92c918b80a9abd5",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-kresladi-2026",
      "url": "https://www.cirm.ca.gov/about-cirm/newsroom/press-releases/first-therapy-funded-by-california-taxpayer-dollars-is-approved-to-treat-rare-childhood-disorder/",
      "sha256": "ba4620c6d3fbabb76cd6c0df35c0b309fa0d1bdf935476fee0bd5de5cc34df9d",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-magrolimab-2020",
      "url": "https://blog.cirm.ca.gov/clinical-trials/cirm-funded-treatment-for-cancer-granted-fda-breakthrough-therapy-designation/",
      "sha256": "888b23dce6febe91f9465408430c04c5109c1633adf5e402c826d072516d1bdc",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-performance-2023",
      "url": "https://www.cirm.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/14.-CIRM-2023-Performance-Audit-FINAL-1.pdf",
      "sha256": "42be32e10c165912776c07e52268d0054981d815e7407727cbbbdb4848a5aabb",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-performance-2023:text",
      "url": "https://www.cirm.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/14.-CIRM-2023-Performance-Audit-FINAL-1.pdf",
      "sha256": "47aff33cd0c1cd5634d98bd899fa92fb9f8625ee866553d12731b4401e25b445",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-performance-followup-2024",
      "url": "https://www.sco.ca.gov/Files-EO/CFAOC/Item_8_Performance_Audit_Update_Presentation.pdf",
      "sha256": "16c8da2c5f5c1aa52f29196345c8dd7a93808918d0144da92a81e4c6bbae9b60",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:cirm-performance-followup-2024:text",
      "url": "https://www.sco.ca.gov/Files-EO/CFAOC/Item_8_Performance_Audit_Update_Presentation.pdf",
      "sha256": "c7c76e3ddd9d039b9cdf66b331c710383319e91ec9ea03544c447631a8fd883c",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:fda-kresladi-2026",
      "url": "https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-approves-first-gene-therapy-severe-leukocyte-adhesion-deficiency-type-i",
      "sha256": "13a08c18f7db34dfdc28309f01abaad312780fae97a36e3d5104ed4d1a16b601",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:gilead-magrolimab-2024",
      "url": "https://www.gilead.com/company/company-statements/2024/gilead-statement-on-discontinuation-of-phase-3-enhance-3-study-in-aml",
      "sha256": "e656ae1416ca72db54efad41fa1d496e1cd140b0f3d093c9a5f83107c4ca0cea",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:lao-prop14-2020",
      "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2020/Prop14-110320.pdf",
      "sha256": "22096e91c45bd606c91656dbdcc20a91cf119caa880c7c97b5cda25b353b8d2f",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:lao-prop14-2020:text",
      "url": "https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2020/Prop14-110320.pdf",
      "sha256": "1777b7f4c76dea17a8bf22c985b27aca2665a681bd1fa1a9eefe335cbb02514d",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:nejm-ada-scid-2025",
      "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/research/bionlp/RESTful/pubmed.cgi/BioC_xml/41092330/unicode",
      "sha256": "7003e7c9fded2758571c3b3ee86e4dfe3440a76000c4dc0a9fb5e7064175af5d",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:nejm-ada-scid-2025:text",
      "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/research/bionlp/RESTful/pubmed.cgi/BioC_xml/41092330/unicode",
      "sha256": "9a696582840076a2638ebc2b019cc6f1140a40ef0641f6f9a4dc452fdfebb507",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-38:ucla-ada-scid-2025",
      "url": "https://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/gene-therapy-delivers-lasting-immune-protection-children-rare-disorder",
      "sha256": "836be2a184710792d9e7befd2305cb091e77c0a10a18210569a6bb044bde9f8a",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T20:49:02+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-44:altamed-990-2024",
      "url": "https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202533219349322468/IRS990",
      "sha256": "8f0357c914c92690dc2873a9f0246a60578257c7b3a5f797787ae12ee992719b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:31:42+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-44:chcf-clinics-2026",
      "url": "https://www.chcf.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/CommunityClinicsAlmanac_2026.pdf",
      "sha256": "299bd7d12cc581efcf2e4ead603205286e6630f832e12d8291d87d94baa4478a",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:31:42+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-44:chcf-clinics-2026:text",
      "url": "https://www.chcf.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/CommunityClinicsAlmanac_2026.pdf",
      "sha256": "4f075ae497a12540424fdf374427ab72be7a7eb39167c4ab35e0cf44956abb8c",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:31:42+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-44:gardner-audit-2024",
      "url": "https://gardnerhealthservices.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/GHS-2024-AFS-Final.pdf",
      "sha256": "ed1be55e653be9b62e9eeab35b5ca9ee9edadc3760d5caa87d78080456d9da38",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:31:42+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-44:gardner-audit-2024:text",
      "url": "https://gardnerhealthservices.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/GHS-2024-AFS-Final.pdf",
      "sha256": "fbefa311958445eebb9e2bc3d695621cae9ddded344559edf02b25c88037cef8",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:31:42+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-44:gardner-audit-2025",
      "url": "https://gardnerhealthservices.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/GHS-2025-AFS-Final.pdf",
      "sha256": "2b4aa53467072e2bcc57d0f27127fdc8c59773df07c95b8cae40dd02eafe847d",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:31:42+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-44:gardner-audit-2025:text",
      "url": "https://gardnerhealthservices.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/GHS-2025-AFS-Final.pdf",
      "sha256": "b8aa0af1f426804dff39e49563f38fb38d00dc6f354059dc0721456d130620dd",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:31:42+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "research:prop-44:irs-990-instructions",
      "url": "https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i990",
      "sha256": "b9dcb2820f72659910bfab0e7da91c73f5b5f528b40f31cfea1f822828c6987e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-13T21:31:42+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sos:cert-list",
      "url": "https://elections.cdn.sos.ca.gov/statewide-elections/2026-general/cert-list-candidates.pdf",
      "sha256": "0e514ae7b14378b1837bcea99c07e6a05ce35baa9db4c3d3a2297704dc7e6017",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:08+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sos:cert-list:text",
      "url": "https://elections.cdn.sos.ca.gov/statewide-elections/2026-general/cert-list-candidates.pdf",
      "sha256": "4dc423642623028602bfe9ecc52480265dd2c8dbad9c654b33ffd2772f5f486e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:08+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sos:sov:superintendent-of-public-instruction",
      "url": "https://elections.cdn.sos.ca.gov/sov/2026-primary/sov/113-spi.xlsx",
      "sha256": "4cbc9e2fa696f802535ac6dc16c2da7fdc7d9852d2d764b00637679095009fad",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:08+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sos:sov:voter-nominated",
      "url": "https://elections.cdn.sos.ca.gov/sov/2026-primary/sov/csv-voter-nominated.xlsx",
      "sha256": "d5950110771e66e0c94b68404abb8fdb7a031e8130bf81f1452514a3f8042b13",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:08+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:index",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/",
      "sha256": "7e49039f5161c1c3881d1b190278a40e0eb8227ccbf5146558bae99375027cf8",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:12+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-1:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/1/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "46fbe3a091502527403bbf6445eac44124560cb9d12771e78fdf516da6c26590",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:23+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-1:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/1/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "92caa96ed0d6591c9a917ca6f7274ffb6adbc11e14080b5350cdb5d707593801",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:23+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-1:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop1-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "478fea52ef5e9cec96e0c0ed8bf3176fdfcd10d92b893ba570c1c54884fefce4",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:18+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-1:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop1-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "e061a3db9441cbfb8843a5f8eb6e24c7eae6919262e559b105c39908713052a3",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:18+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-1:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/1/index.htm",
      "sha256": "34efc9521347f449d476e2d2e09626c635b77fc3e73ac0543e7bdcf41fd835b1",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:23+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-1:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/1/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "90f3e8e6130893ce1459ba1d35a69098acbff9d434a48a043c52bf05286063a5",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:23+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-2:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/2/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "09d1c1782c4711e6023dce674cd9718af57a94367b9862cb23b8965f9d25d893",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:24+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-2:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/2/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "47cbafe3189add801520a69debb91734588ef97e6231441b553d405ed319921c",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:24+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-2:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop2-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "2db2dd8fab47c6aff35343d7481c8aa04869bb0f9c785554f105f6312692e74c",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:18+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-2:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop2-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "38f70e8e0b29dae1959342a5a76f7349b19c16ba23e6af5fce6f7805b43d4ea6",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:18+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-2:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/2/index.htm",
      "sha256": "03bf6642bfa3aec8a81d5deb03b8240bf5bf6ca7955478b78d4ed135fbfede42",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:23+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-2:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/2/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "670c77791464bd54b80b337273b84c061f4f15fbd3df7e2ae365f38b62b84430",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:24+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-37:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/37/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "3a3c107d0700abce9ab9dd46d157d44c8023439a6d0a6df25c097d75b961d030",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:28+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-37:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/37/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "e3e980bccba0c106bfb8d23527d5b0d2bb665e94459e6e420de877b61709567c",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:28+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-37:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop37-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "22fa3050627c8638301ec94bc3df10a0043cc8fbcfa94c5acc50b0a37f9c9671",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:19+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-37:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop37-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "8c826715624c2ca1a09f3c9cd43cf2142acceec1f3fff81f70b12b0da8b855c1",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:19+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-37:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/37/index.htm",
      "sha256": "fcf1017e60156e3dcbd4a147ac9c3f90d8e0208044c405bb9db7c0edf7fe6d6f",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:27+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-37:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/37/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "66c2b7320c9a2fa9dbec1ea6413fff1e7f938731f2c898d512008a02121709fd",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:27+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-38:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/38/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "ccbe3691feb93db500868b369952afe37bd7f810742906ef8e8cde3a83952db4",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:29+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-38:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/38/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "0d213061313e6a074c7a181bdcfbfa5665c58b909b684904b780a2a03ffbb36b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:29+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-38:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop38-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "910930e58c49e66c3e83fcc618ddf1b1aee32a498321d79b2888fdda35749fb8",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:20+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-38:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop38-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "6ddc592537ff8599092e57826de1cab2bb82e669ac37777de1a0c71f5ac208bd",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:20+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-38:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/38/index.htm",
      "sha256": "718dfb35fa814d6319e2f17b8e85b169c9bd645360dc60a464fd1e93758ebad2",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:28+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-38:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/38/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "43bb1afb2cff709f2396442ef655366e196db91cc5d3183687f740e7afeac046",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:29+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-39:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/39/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "fcfb42cfcde5b30713ae9e59761238a0e1041199cf206d35e7de80e5c941c6ff",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:30+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-39:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/39/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "9afec88a0aae3ad78ad3a378e295c1b5a3cad3968fb008042684a9c87c8f2b0e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:30+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-39:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop39-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "ad13b5199738f74a1af0039bd9aaa53ecd6cc5a930f95c7270125a1281202a99",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:20+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-39:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop39-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "4b1a078f959c998cfecb291ca6f695fc6363fb53967cebf691d4063ff3dfb54b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:20+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-39:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/39/index.htm",
      "sha256": "0816ecfb99d3bb303bae9b0e90064a5e46717142a3b13e4e38e09520205c7ca4",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:29+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-39:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/39/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "f31a073ca69c7261562ebe746247795827016b75573b27cc98fd2383e2ffc997",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:30+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-3:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/3/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "26543790afa4a32c3db561ee983abc2e675a72b4b4dbfc10a897344726066ce9",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:25+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-3:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/3/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "7de52eec8b67b3300e71986fa3620a4ab5c628e1407acb824be139061ad77c46",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:25+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-3:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop3-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "6df0061d0b7af757a09fbf360c7eba725f9df11c24135f3825cbaab2eebc4978",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:18+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-3:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop3-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "cbe6f332d193082ca7998c763167606b2ad64664c9db95e5a47ceb8c513d233f",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:18+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-3:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/3/index.htm",
      "sha256": "967778d8fa1fb0ba8ad5c87eb626cace0506a95a4493b4f5fd541e30683a0d33",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:24+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-3:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/3/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "a9e0b1a604bab444c385d16c8aa4e17c992e877ead2bb0c063a24c4b88c3d039",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:24+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-40:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/40/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "4550a874b0364825b59f4cd4f384573b7cf088496a8aad282268687237c7842e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:31+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-40:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/40/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "24ed6259507b3dc065d821c951e6ca6ac020bd02de13a510135ed806b63d5442",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:31+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-40:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop40-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "07afc5d301b6d0612440ed094d27acb2ff3ab813fb44b374aa8479a210890c68",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:20+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-40:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop40-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "9d5467fdebc0a74e42817152b28b35be86ca95cc927fbfa15c45182fde60d6d8",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:20+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-40:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/40/index.htm",
      "sha256": "4c049ee3a87fb499bc743498626f1dd16997eac44705c367c770aec139e65dcb",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:30+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-40:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/40/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "fbc281aa9b64cbfaf9d9c6047fee71c20280c33180dc671918206f1f8f9394a8",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:30+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-41:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/41/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "778d17137360b4d771884417e94e0e6335a8446ade15659e21ee6def66b4a386",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-41:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/41/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "84167bc8f76dc1be1f8afb9bdb0ce1f174e57961b43e075571eee3b602f4f9b3",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-41:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop41-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "c5126121aa12fa592bb5a430f12270a4f2c6962fd22f8106c95089062275b9e8",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:20+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-41:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop41-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "2ae99ab7ed5b440b2705ff31c871ae2b79e2a7763649401236e408b74d5534af",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:20+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-41:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/41/index.htm",
      "sha256": "89b4a31c012737fbac85479b89a82761b6361017d329b80c9ed6a7d5f8dd941b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:31+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-41:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/41/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "6f669a594c8630fa029a7ecce9ddc654167f887ae225ecd2b24b19c159823017",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:31+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-42:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "0acb2b60222fa388d02a31cd5bac3cff0d1a18304085305e9717c4a30041d38b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:33+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-42:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "8ca587ee753527bdc21652872ad4de626e8f0e582936b15109496d15b3671a88",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:33+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-42:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop42-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "21c9d7e166220d9609eb0e9e85d050c2f0a8dedfc15b07e4690d2a5ed48bb111",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:21+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-42:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop42-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "15e18e4ab103e784baf61b38c397948a2b7b64aad3ed183d1fe6fdca9c4c63c6",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:21+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-42:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/index.htm",
      "sha256": "cd9f663d495aa11b0ee18caed04399859d0a3974cebeaeb0504aba712e55407b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-42:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/42/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "a83aad34622eb9590e509c13c5e81b21c7b3c9d7e9b121b3a9098efdd1bfdf6f",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:32+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-43:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/43/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "c09ff07e8ab6acec8418d9b7f42193c9406059cc5526900c8a4102541916c145",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:34+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-43:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/43/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "2acb254876230743e85809d95e58500ce1dc5c0afd8044d6d70641f8807c0ada",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:34+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-43:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop43-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "277f1953f56e8752a61b9c4208905cd9f40caeabedd60b16e9595de6a0765d0a",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:21+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-43:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop43-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "0fd147b3e6cd0b6e53c2dbecf4a2b34e09fd5acc816f2661e0ca87a337b68f8c",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:21+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-43:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/43/index.htm",
      "sha256": "7f2e2514e2886155adf6d6d659689c6d2d735b6eef433165b8f43042246f8717",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:33+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-43:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/43/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "cbec9ac4c3d6c0050059071ee242e52c1698a3e158e1d3b85fbe729585ad6dbe",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:33+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-44:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/44/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "0c07238abf9a8e3141ae0c08b42a7182a476fee17c8597aad7f690822ae25524",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:35+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-44:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/44/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "6917c6ec14f7226dc8e88c56724d3f52329053f2faa31c159f9fab1f562a02b8",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:35+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-44:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop44-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "83d066f46a18aba90f6ac80b1caf062ccdba82a8b7629be9b5cc0165a916f794",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:21+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-44:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop44-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "718f3cfa5cfff3005e1248098625b2e58f233bc1a75260d9a135e0596ba368db",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:21+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-44:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/44/index.htm",
      "sha256": "12d4fb6663712c8f99fec296ad515bb92bdbc2aee1b63bf9040d76dcf9f69334",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:34+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-44:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/44/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "d4027331a16886e5e24d6df5fb5f4f3978a94fc3f05c0ff5a74a03a6a7b62598",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:34+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-45:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/45/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "45c8655b27a861bb46fe597a5f2a207f2638f717766d738b469473747c97f622",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:36+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-45:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/45/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "c5f6eab5a093189a8e99d4abb29232cac7f5fbb04faecf7be58c6ea97a12f4d5",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:36+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-45:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop45-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "0dae76bf9a088e26cf3d98c6fce04c4b52f7c91e4df7a56e5aa20917ed5ad55f",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:22+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-45:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop45-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "a106a357b72d7f37205f5e096cd391a38f439ccd14b1f3735c602cd72fe19276",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:22+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-45:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/45/index.htm",
      "sha256": "760f391de842d503f261c2ef371ddfa706a75c9e3ab9f16a24e050f6f8d8967e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:35+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-45:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/45/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "57daf5e3577f9e945126ddc6c823b9c8ff77b1ce65093fb9c9aceaab569fc11d",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:35+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-4:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/4/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "3bc1a6eebee10465700848d4fa1764ee659ba0db53ff33df4b8b830dd7679bab",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:26+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-4:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/4/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "7b7b3fec3e2397e671dfee750e21e4b44b637df3f6c2905bf5369317077bb952",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:26+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-4:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop4-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "d99518df7425e3d264f9fadb8dc669926414ce41387ae7364e8961de97693dae",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:19+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-4:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop4-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "00215c0d317039f92b8b74efbd0c742331c61f9a509a8bd09c07cd4aa8a0f0a1",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:19+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-4:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/4/index.htm",
      "sha256": "786726984818267939dfb33793801a52c8d4c3850cccc3e83777dfc82e76af1a",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:25+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-4:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/4/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "fbd4c79fc82e4f166e57307857e8635b3bbbd4616dff118af71ad9d1cfd0896b",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:25+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-5:analysis",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/5/analysis.htm",
      "sha256": "bbbb9a72f804736bc49a594589d933792f049d8a21476c0119f001fdb9be88be",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:27+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-5:arguments",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/5/arguments-rebuttals.htm",
      "sha256": "034daa963091fb48af9566cca078cbb261ef9243743f57f2e3d35d41c5a8129e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:27+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-5:legal_text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop5-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "8ba2b6327a12a45ce29641b82932170f6cb785336b47fa786bb3b46dbc1bc096",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:19+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-5:legal_text:text",
      "url": "https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2026/general/pdf/prop5-text-proposed-laws.pdf",
      "sha256": "1c281d0589aa37f1eed3076d0a09fdd373de7e35115c4fab3196f5a90ba35dd6",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-09T01:36:19+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-5:overview",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/5/index.htm",
      "sha256": "048e15da71d02ba6a659d6868767cd5680594610caf7b1dc8621c63d6d737745",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:26+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "vig:prop-5:title_summary",
      "url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/propositions/5/title-summary.htm",
      "sha256": "9d33e0556bd8d5e26544bae3899cf5bc2d74a72c4236e75bf6f44f489a27e0ea",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-07T19:35:26+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:list-local-measures",
      "label": "Santa Clara County ROV: List of Local Measures, November 3, 2026",
      "url": "https://vote.santaclaracounty.gov/list-local-measures-4",
      "snapshot_status": "blocked_manual_review",
      "checked_at": "2026-10-09"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:list-of-offices",
      "label": "Santa Clara County ROV: November 3, 2026 General Election List of Offices",
      "url": "https://vote.santaclaracounty.gov/november-3-2026-general-election-list-offices",
      "snapshot_status": "blocked_manual_review",
      "checked_at": "2026-10-09"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:qualified-local-candidates",
      "label": "Santa Clara County ROV: Qualified List of Local Candidates (9/28/2026)",
      "url": "https://files.santaclaracounty.gov/exjcpb1296/2026-09/qualified-list-of-local-candidates-9-28-26.pdf?VersionId=CM6jbwAVTLFIjLakj6hJku2l9KPAIxli",
      "snapshot_status": "blocked_manual_review",
      "checked_at": "2026-10-09"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:district-lookup",
      "label": "Santa Clara County ROV: Look Up Your Districts",
      "url": "https://rovservices.sccgov.org/Home/IndexPost?selected=dt&distance=0&navtab=pm&asm=simple",
      "snapshot_status": "blocked_manual_review",
      "checked_at": "2026-10-09"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:sample-ballot-3004",
      "label": "Santa Clara County sample ballot, precinct 3004, Ballot Type 38 (a sample, not an official ballot)",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003004&lang=en"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:sample-ballot-3008",
      "label": "Santa Clara County sample ballot, precinct 3008, Ballot Type 40 (a sample, not an official ballot)",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/sites/06085/site/app/cvig/vg/ballot?eid=148&pid=0003008&lang=en"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:sample-ballot-selector",
      "label": "Santa Clara County ROV: View Sample Ballot lookup (unit group to sample link)",
      "url": "https://rovservices.sccgov.org/"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:accessible-g",
      "label": "Santa Clara County accessible guide: Measure G",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/published/06085/1968/vg/728_md.json",
      "sha256": "a0056828f1bf7146b4fc02ee100b46b12a1228e1c75d14cd3f5d138fd28817d2",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:21:13.252605+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:accessible-h",
      "label": "Santa Clara County accessible guide: Measure H",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/published/06085/1968/vg/729_md.json",
      "sha256": "8a535f60f827eb77621cd038ef8f006a2701b1c9a3c4c4e9e116412ab472aebb",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:21:13.666130+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:accessible-i",
      "label": "Santa Clara County accessible guide: Measure I",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/published/06085/1968/vg/730_md.json",
      "sha256": "4138ac7ae5ec5af99338386abc6419bf4742d0f9c580e3f1d9500f0294386bde",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:21:14.106432+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "scc:accessible-s",
      "label": "Santa Clara County accessible guide: Measure S",
      "url": "https://ca.omniballot.us/published/06085/1968/vg/740_md.json",
      "sha256": "f7aebf10780a3ff216656185aec641c13cf7c0baab9822f0c84767fb018abe2a",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:21:14.473737+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sunnyvale:council-charter-report",
      "label": "Sunnyvale Report to Council 26-0622",
      "url": "https://webapi.legistar.com/v1/sunnyvaleca/matters/16985/texts/17062",
      "sha256": "0b8ff5174092a7e9f39cb1415dbe036ef24960e4e0659d339998421d3280ef9e",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T05:25:49.759643+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sf:qualified-measures",
      "url": "https://www.sf.gov/qualified-ballot-measures",
      "label": "San Francisco government qualified-measures",
      "sha256": "fb3b95a8a06dfb5c970a007db027e810da0bc7a15aa9f5265e37fb8bf053f2cc",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T00:18:39.079949+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sf:voter-pamphlet",
      "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/N26_EN_VIP.pdf",
      "label": "San Francisco government voter-pamphlet",
      "sha256": "9c6bcf0b49b5a04c1f03de363d5727458c673d8807ef2932c2912ed40d786136",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T00:18:40.072461+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sf:rwg-member-letters-2023",
      "url": "https://www.sf.gov/documents/52367/rwg053123_RWG-Item-3.pdf",
      "label": "San Francisco government rwg-member-letters-2023",
      "sha256": "11a4b88abbfde9e25efa6e66e9fb9fe6cd2186378f99fe09b1fdd01b66b52f47",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T00:21:47.227058+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sf:investment-pool-legal-memo-2021",
      "url": "https://www.sfcityattorney.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Public-memo-re-Investment-Pool.pdf",
      "label": "San Francisco City Attorney investment-pool-legal-memo-2021",
      "sha256": "48ef718ec47a10db3ef622809f5d2ce75e75bc11329567fc9f912711a6fcf8b6",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T00:21:29.355596+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sf:great-highway-traffic-report-2025",
      "url": "https://www.sfmta.com/media/42914/download?inline",
      "label": "SFMTA great-highway-traffic-report-2025",
      "sha256": "cb9727718ca999f2329361271f29513dd28381607deab9fd4b4cfff1b87d5939",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T00:22:25.360211+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sf:mohcd-annual-report-2024-25",
      "url": "https://www.sf.gov/documents/49216/MOHCD_FY_2024-2025_Annual_Report.pdf",
      "label": "San Francisco government mohcd-annual-report-2024-25",
      "sha256": "f01ee5da8a136919cf5317489d5cc08cf2b99754d836a40e68508f5d16d475f4",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T00:22:55.350481+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sf:public-integrity-status-2026",
      "url": "https://media.api.sf.gov/documents/Public_Integrity_Assessment_-_2026_Status_Update_Report_09.16.2026.pdf",
      "label": "San Francisco government public-integrity-status-2026",
      "sha256": "d9f9a9078b3b9a69279b622a0f18894a6854f5867f50f2ab32040e063111bd28",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T00:23:04.392304+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sf:housing-trust-fund-report-2018-23",
      "url": "https://www.sf.gov/documents/28380/120882_-_Housing_Trust_Fund_Five-Year_Report_-_2018-2023.pdf",
      "label": "San Francisco government housing-trust-fund-report-2018-23",
      "sha256": "c5653c262d90ecfbfb2a5014eff910733807a522343d592f81fa467e1234c306",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T00:23:39.543912+00:00"
    },
    {
      "key": "sf:sfmta-adopted-budget-2026-28",
      "url": "https://www.sfmta.com/project-updates/sfmta-approved-budget-fy-2026-27-and-fy-2027-28",
      "label": "SFMTA sfmta-adopted-budget-2026-28",
      "sha256": "0bd150f0a7ad3d770b4ba1cbf50a85427ed3f2d17c2b1aa776203923f2e57f21",
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-14T00:24:04.242443+00:00"
    }
  ],
  "generated_at": "2026-10-14T05:41:48+00:00",
  "quality": {
    "errors": 0,
    "warnings": 0,
    "issues": []
  }
}
