{"approaches":[{"aliases":["education-childcare--school-investment"],"analysis_frame":{"cause":"The theory is that schools lack enough targeted resources, training, or support systems to meet student needs.","evaluation_questions":["Is the row investing in public-school capacity, changing governance, or lowering education/child-care costs?","Does it identify a delivery mechanism such as funding, staffing, curriculum authority, tuition relief, or care slots?","What source evidence shows that public school investment addresses the stated problem rather than just naming a topic?","Which assumptions would have to be true for this to work in practice?","Who pays, who benefits, and what gets worse if this approach is implemented?"],"evidence_needed":["Comparable candidate sources that name the same problem and policy lever.","Independent or administrative data that tests whether the lever can plausibly change outcomes."],"evidence_signal":"The artifact has several education rows, but many are program-specific and need source expansion for a full comparison.","plausibility":"Plausible when investments are targeted to evidence-backed interventions; weaker when funding lacks implementation detail or outcome metrics.","possible_solution":"Invest in teachers, tutoring, literacy, facilities, family engagement, learning recovery, or redesigned high-school supports.","problem":"Student outcomes, literacy, and school capacity are framed as underperforming or under-supported.","problem_kind":"policy_problem","related_problems":["State budget","Workforce readiness","Child care and family support"],"tradeoffs":["Can address capacity gaps, but depends on sustained funding and district execution.","Broad investment language may hide disagreements about curriculum, accountability, and staffing."]},"approach_id":"education-childcare--school-investment","candidate_count":1,"cause":"The theory is that schools lack enough targeted resources, training, or support systems to meet student needs.","claim_count":2,"confidence":0.75,"coverage_notes":["Only one candidate currently has source rows here."],"coverage_score":37,"deduped_evidence_count":2,"evidence":[{"candidate_id":"steve-hilton","candidate_name":"Steve Hilton","claim_id":"cl-app-source-hilton-policy-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade-6757427149928-e6bf007b","claim_type":"recommendation","date":"2026-05-26","event_id":"source-hilton-policy-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade-6757427149928efb-d083d951","event_title":"Hilton policy: fix public education by 3rd grade","matched_keywords":["public","school","teacher"],"party":"Republican","source_url":"https://stevehiltonforgovernor.com/policies/making-californias-schools-work-again","stance":"support","stance_confidence":0.7,"stance_reason":"support_language","text":"Require phonics-based early reading, publish school letter grades, reform teacher tenure and evaluation, restore a parent-trigger path for failing schools, and expand choice through education savings accounts and open enrollment.","theme_id":"education","theme_label":"Education"},{"candidate_id":"steve-hilton","candidate_name":"Steve Hilton","claim_id":"cl-app-source-hilton-third-grade-education-policy-53444d2490f2c8e2-48fe412f-6ff171f3","claim_type":"assertion","date":"2026-05-26","event_id":"source-hilton-third-grade-education-policy-53444d2490f2c8e2-48fe412f","event_title":"Hilton third-grade education policy","matched_keywords":["funding"],"party":"Republican","source_url":"https://stevehiltonforgovernor.com/policy/steve-hiltons-plan-to-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade/","stance":"qualify","stance_confidence":0.56,"stance_reason":"qualified_or_causal_language","text":"Hilton argues California’s declining education outcomes are a leadership and accountability problem rather than a funding problem despite high per-student spending.","theme_id":"education","theme_label":"Education"}],"evidence_groups":[{"candidate_id":"steve-hilton","candidate_name":"Steve Hilton","claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-policy-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade-6757427149928-e6bf007b"],"claim_type":"recommendation","date":"2026-05-26","group_id":"idea:education-childcare:school-investment:evidence:steve-hilton:support:e9d4d84f6c","matched_keywords":["public","school","teacher"],"party":"Republican","row_count":1,"source_count":1,"source_rows":[{"claim_id":"cl-app-source-hilton-policy-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade-6757427149928-e6bf007b","date":"2026-05-26","event_id":"source-hilton-policy-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade-6757427149928efb-d083d951","event_title":"Hilton policy: fix public education by 3rd grade","source_url":"https://stevehiltonforgovernor.com/policies/making-californias-schools-work-again","text":"Require phonics-based early reading, publish school letter grades, reform teacher tenure and evaluation, restore a parent-trigger path for failing schools, and expand choice through education savings accounts and open enrollment."}],"stance":"support","statement":"Require phonics-based early reading, publish school letter grades, reform teacher tenure and evaluation, restore a parent-trigger path for failing schools, and expand choice through education savings accounts and open enrollment."},{"candidate_id":"steve-hilton","candidate_name":"Steve Hilton","claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-third-grade-education-policy-53444d2490f2c8e2-48fe412f-6ff171f3"],"claim_type":"assertion","date":"2026-05-26","group_id":"idea:education-childcare:school-investment:evidence:steve-hilton:qualify:427abc8354","matched_keywords":["funding"],"party":"Republican","row_count":1,"source_count":1,"source_rows":[{"claim_id":"cl-app-source-hilton-third-grade-education-policy-53444d2490f2c8e2-48fe412f-6ff171f3","date":"2026-05-26","event_id":"source-hilton-third-grade-education-policy-53444d2490f2c8e2-48fe412f","event_title":"Hilton third-grade education policy","source_url":"https://stevehiltonforgovernor.com/policy/steve-hiltons-plan-to-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade/","text":"Hilton argues California’s declining education outcomes are a leadership and accountability problem rather than a funding problem despite high per-student spending."}],"stance":"qualify","statement":"Hilton argues California’s declining education outcomes are a leadership and accountability problem rather than a funding problem despite high per-student spending."}],"evidence_quality":"single_candidate","evidence_signal":"The artifact has several education rows, but many are program-specific and need source expansion for a full comparison.","idea_id":"idea:education-childcare:school-investment","idea_kind":"policy","idea_slug":"school-investment","issue_id":"education-childcare","label":"Public school investment","matched_keywords":[{"count":3,"keyword":"school"},{"count":3,"keyword":"literacy"},{"count":2,"keyword":"teacher"},{"count":2,"keyword":"learning"},{"count":1,"keyword":"lausd"},{"count":1,"keyword":"partnership for los angeles schools"},{"count":1,"keyword":"public"},{"count":1,"keyword":"funding"}],"missing_ballot_candidates":["Xavier Becerra"],"party_aggregates":[{"candidate_count":1,"claim_count":2,"issue_candidate_count":1,"party":"Republican"}],"plausibility":"Plausible when investments are targeted to evidence-backed interventions; weaker when funding lacks implementation detail or outcome metrics.","problem":"Student outcomes, literacy, and school capacity are framed as underperforming or under-supported.","quality_flags":["single_candidate"],"related_problem_links":[],"related_problems":["State budget","Workforce readiness","Child care and family support"],"review_status":"generated_review_candidate","semantic_group_id":"idea-group:education-childcare:school-investment-and-governance","semantic_group_label":"School investment and governance","semantic_group_slug":"school-investment-and-governance","solution":"Invest in teachers, tutoring, literacy, facilities, family engagement, learning recovery, or redesigned high-school supports.","source_count":2,"stance_counts":{"oppose":0,"qualify":1,"record":0,"support":1,"unclear":0},"summary":"Invests in teachers, students, public schools, school facilities, or learning recovery.","tradeoffs":["Can address capacity gaps, but depends on sustained funding and district execution.","Broad investment language may hide disagreements about curriculum, accountability, and staffing."],"variants":[{"candidate_count":1,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-policy-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade-6757427149928-e6bf007b"],"evidence_count":1,"label":"school","matched_keyword":"school","matched_keywords":["school"],"slug":"school","source_count":1,"variant_id":"idea:education-childcare:school-investment:school"},{"candidate_count":1,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-policy-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade-6757427149928-e6bf007b"],"evidence_count":1,"label":"teacher","matched_keyword":"teacher","matched_keywords":["teacher"],"slug":"teacher","source_count":1,"variant_id":"idea:education-childcare:school-investment:teacher"}]},{"aliases":["education-childcare--parent-control"],"analysis_frame":{"cause":"The theory is that centralized or institutional decisions override family preferences and weaken trust.","evaluation_questions":["Is the row investing in public-school capacity, changing governance, or lowering education/child-care costs?","Does it identify a delivery mechanism such as funding, staffing, curriculum authority, tuition relief, or care slots?","What source evidence shows that parental control over schools addresses the stated problem rather than just naming a topic?","Which assumptions would have to be true for this to work in practice?","Who pays, who benefits, and what gets worse if this approach is implemented?"],"evidence_needed":["Comparable candidate sources that name the same problem and policy lever.","Independent or administrative data that tests whether the lever can plausibly change outcomes."],"evidence_signal":"The current rows show this as a visible education/family-policy approach, but coverage is limited.","plausibility":"Plausible for increasing parental voice; effects on student outcomes depend on the specific governance change.","possible_solution":"Give parents more control over curriculum, school governance, or family-policy choices.","problem":"Some candidates frame school or family policy as insufficiently accountable to parents.","problem_kind":"policy_problem","related_problems":["Curriculum governance","Civil rights in schools","Family policy"],"tradeoffs":["Can increase family trust, but may politicize curriculum or create conflicts between parent groups.","Local control can improve fit while reducing consistency."]},"approach_id":"education-childcare--parent-control","candidate_count":1,"cause":"The theory is that centralized or institutional decisions override family preferences and weaken trust.","claim_count":1,"confidence":0.57,"coverage_notes":["Only one candidate currently has source rows here.","Coverage comes from one source URL."],"coverage_score":28,"deduped_evidence_count":1,"evidence":[{"candidate_id":"steve-hilton","candidate_name":"Steve Hilton","claim_id":"cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766","claim_type":"recommendation","date":"2026-05-26","event_id":"source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467","event_title":"Hilton Family First agenda","matched_keywords":["control","family","family policy","family stability","marriage","parental"],"party":"Republican","source_url":"https://stevehiltonforgovernor.com/policy/the-family-first-agenda/","stance":"support","stance_confidence":0.58,"stance_reason":"recommendation_default","text":"Put family policy at the center of state government, including parental control in education and policies favoring marriage and family stability.","theme_id":"family-social-policy","theme_label":"Family Social Policy"}],"evidence_groups":[{"candidate_id":"steve-hilton","candidate_name":"Steve Hilton","claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766"],"claim_type":"recommendation","date":"2026-05-26","group_id":"idea:education-childcare:parent-control:evidence:steve-hilton:support:6316bd4646","matched_keywords":["control","family","family policy","family stability","marriage","parental"],"party":"Republican","row_count":1,"source_count":1,"source_rows":[{"claim_id":"cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766","date":"2026-05-26","event_id":"source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467","event_title":"Hilton Family First agenda","source_url":"https://stevehiltonforgovernor.com/policy/the-family-first-agenda/","text":"Put family policy at the center of state government, including parental control in education and policies favoring marriage and family stability."}],"stance":"support","statement":"Put family policy at the center of state government, including parental control in education and policies favoring marriage and family stability."}],"evidence_quality":"single_candidate","evidence_signal":"The current rows show this as a visible education/family-policy approach, but coverage is limited.","idea_id":"idea:education-childcare:parent-control","idea_kind":"policy","idea_slug":"parent-control","issue_id":"education-childcare","label":"Parental control over schools","matched_keywords":[{"count":2,"keyword":"family"},{"count":2,"keyword":"parental"},{"count":1,"keyword":"control"},{"count":1,"keyword":"family policy"},{"count":1,"keyword":"family stability"},{"count":1,"keyword":"marriage"}],"missing_ballot_candidates":["Xavier Becerra"],"party_aggregates":[{"candidate_count":1,"claim_count":1,"issue_candidate_count":1,"party":"Republican"}],"plausibility":"Plausible for increasing parental voice; effects on student outcomes depend on the specific governance change.","problem":"Some candidates frame school or family policy as insufficiently accountable to parents.","quality_flags":["single_candidate","single_source"],"related_problem_links":[],"related_problems":["Curriculum governance","Civil rights in schools","Family policy"],"review_status":"generated_review_candidate","semantic_group_id":"idea-group:education-childcare:school-investment-and-governance","semantic_group_label":"School investment and governance","semantic_group_slug":"school-investment-and-governance","solution":"Give parents more control over curriculum, school governance, or family-policy choices.","source_count":1,"stance_counts":{"oppose":0,"qualify":0,"record":0,"support":1,"unclear":0},"summary":"Gives parents more control over curriculum, family policy, or school governance.","tradeoffs":["Can increase family trust, but may politicize curriculum or create conflicts between parent groups.","Local control can improve fit while reducing consistency."],"variants":[{"candidate_count":1,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766"],"evidence_count":1,"label":"family","matched_keyword":"family","matched_keywords":["family"],"slug":"family","source_count":1,"variant_id":"idea:education-childcare:parent-control:family"},{"candidate_count":1,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766"],"evidence_count":1,"label":"parental","matched_keyword":"parental","matched_keywords":["parental"],"slug":"parental","source_count":1,"variant_id":"idea:education-childcare:parent-control:parental"},{"candidate_count":1,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766"],"evidence_count":1,"label":"control","matched_keyword":"control","matched_keywords":["control"],"slug":"control","source_count":1,"variant_id":"idea:education-childcare:parent-control:control"},{"candidate_count":1,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766"],"evidence_count":1,"label":"family policy","matched_keyword":"family policy","matched_keywords":["family policy"],"slug":"family-policy","source_count":1,"variant_id":"idea:education-childcare:parent-control:family-policy"},{"candidate_count":1,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766"],"evidence_count":1,"label":"family stability","matched_keyword":"family stability","matched_keywords":["family stability"],"slug":"family-stability","source_count":1,"variant_id":"idea:education-childcare:parent-control:family-stability"},{"candidate_count":1,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766"],"evidence_count":1,"label":"marriage","matched_keyword":"marriage","matched_keywords":["marriage"],"slug":"marriage","source_count":1,"variant_id":"idea:education-childcare:parent-control:marriage"}]}],"baseline_date":"2026-11-03","candidate_stances":[{"approach_id":"education-childcare--school-investment","candidate_id":"steve-hilton","candidate_name":"Steve Hilton","claim_count":2,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-policy-fix-public-education-by-3rd-grade-6757427149928-e6bf007b","cl-app-source-hilton-third-grade-education-policy-53444d2490f2c8e2-48fe412f-6ff171f3"],"confidence":0.74,"issue_id":"education-childcare","party":"Republican","review_status":"generated_review_candidate","source_count":2,"stance":"support","stance_counts":{"oppose":0,"qualify":1,"record":0,"support":1,"unclear":0}},{"approach_id":"education-childcare--parent-control","candidate_id":"steve-hilton","candidate_name":"Steve Hilton","claim_count":1,"claim_ids":["cl-app-source-hilton-family-first-agenda-cdfcfd339777d776-cff14467-steve-hi-f4fbd766"],"confidence":0.58,"issue_id":"education-childcare","party":"Republican","review_status":"generated_review_candidate","source_count":1,"stance":"support","stance_counts":{"oppose":0,"qualify":0,"record":0,"support":1,"unclear":0}}],"election_id":"ca-2026-11-03-general","evidence_groups":[],"evidence_note":"Evidence baseline captured 2026-11-03.","generated_at":"2026-11-03T15:38:28.889426-08:00","idea_groups":[{"approach_ids":["education-childcare--school-investment","education-childcare--parent-control"],"candidate_count":1,"candidate_summaries":[{"candidate_id":"steve-hilton","candidate_name":"Steve Hilton","claim_count":3,"party":"Republican","source_count":3,"stance":"support"}],"claim_count":3,"curation_note":"Codex semantic grouping over deterministic source-backed approach clusters; source rows remain attached to the child approaches.","evidence_quality":"single_candidate","group_id":"idea-group:education-childcare:school-investment-and-governance","group_kind":"approach","group_slug":"school-investment-and-governance","idea_ids":["idea:education-childcare:school-investment","idea:education-childcare:parent-control"],"issue_id":"education-childcare","label":"School investment and governance","party_aggregates":[{"candidate_count":1,"claim_count":3,"issue_candidate_count":1,"party":"Republican"}],"primary_approach_id":"education-childcare--school-investment","primary_idea_slug":"school-investment","quality_flags":["single_candidate","single_source"],"review_status":"codex_curated_review_candidate","source_count":3,"stance_counts":{"oppose":0,"qualify":1,"record":0,"support":2,"unclear":0},"summary":"Public-school investment, student supports, parental control, and school-governance approaches."}],"issue":{"analysis_questions":["Is the row investing in public-school capacity, changing governance, or lowering education/child-care costs?","Does it identify a delivery mechanism such as funding, staffing, curriculum authority, tuition relief, or care slots?","What tradeoff exists between access, quality, parental control, state funding, and local implementation?"],"approach_ids":["education-childcare--school-investment","education-childcare--parent-control"],"candidate_count":1,"claim_count":3,"coverage_summary":{"average_score":33,"by_quality":{"single_candidate":2},"warning":"Coverage summarizes normalized source rows only; missing rows are not opposition."},"idea_group_ids":["idea-group:education-childcare:school-investment-and-governance"],"issue_id":"education-childcare","label":"Education & Child Care","party_denominators":[{"candidate_count":1,"party":"Republican"}],"problem_statement":"Education and child-care rows combine student outcomes, school governance, higher-education affordability, child-care capacity, and workforce preparation.","summary":"Schools, higher education, child care, parental control, and workforce training.","theme_ids":["child-care","education","education-affordability","education-budget","education-workforce-costs","family-social-policy","financial-education","high-school-redesign","higher-education","literacy"]},"limitations":["This is a research prototype, not a voter guide, endorsement, or final assessment.","Many rows are model-generated or unreviewed and should be treated as evidence-navigation aids.","Missing or limited coverage means the dataset has not ingested, normalized, or balanced that surface yet; it is not evidence that a candidate lacks activity there.","Use source URLs and record IDs when citing claims. Prefer the linked JSON/JSONL companion files for retrieval."],"links":{},"schema_version":"llm-static-exports/v1","stance_guide":{"oppose":{"description":"Source rows reject or argue against the selected approach statement.","label":"Opposes this approach"},"qualify":{"description":"Source rows partly support, condition, or mix the selected approach with another claim.","label":"Mixed / conditional signal"},"record":{"description":"Source rows describe a record signal rather than a current position.","label":"Record-only signal"},"support":{"description":"Source rows back the selected approach statement.","label":"Supports this approach"},"unclear":{"description":"Source rows mention the topic but do not clearly support or oppose the approach.","label":"Unclear signal"}}}
