{ "approaches": [ { "aliases": ["immigration--ice-accountability"], "analysis_frame": { "cause": "The theory is that lack of accountability, unclear cooperation rules, or federal overreach leads to excessive force, fear, or rights violations.", "evaluation_questions": [ "Is the row limiting enforcement, accepting enforcement with safeguards, or expanding support services?", "Which level of government has authority over the lever being proposed?", "What source evidence shows that ice accountability and cooperation conditions addresses the stated problem rather than just naming a topic?", "Which assumptions would have to be true for this to work in practice?", "Who pays, who benefits, and what gets worse if this approach is implemented?" ], "evidence_needed": [ "Comparable candidate sources that name the same problem and policy lever.", "Independent or administrative data that tests whether the lever can plausibly change outcomes." ], "evidence_signal": "This is the main comparative immigration cluster in the current artifact, but it does not adjudicate individual enforcement incidents.", "plausibility": "Plausible for transparency and state leverage; effectiveness depends on federal-state authority boundaries and enforcement follow-through.", "possible_solution": "Condition cooperation, require training or reporting, document misconduct, inspect detention, or pursue legal accountability.", "problem": "Immigration enforcement is framed as causing civil-rights, safety, or state-cooperation problems when conduct is opaque or abusive.", "problem_kind": "policy_problem", "related_problems": ["Civil rights", "Public safety", "State-federal authority"], "tradeoffs": [ "Can protect rights and clarify state posture, but may provoke federal conflict.", "Oversight can document misconduct without directly changing federal operations." ] }, "approach_id": "immigration--ice-accountability", "candidate_count": 5, "cause": "The theory is that lack of accountability, unclear cooperation rules, or federal overreach leads to excessive force, fear, or rights violations.", "claim_count": 7, "confidence": 0.79, "coverage_notes": [], "coverage_score": 100, "deduped_evidence_count": 7, "evidence": [ { "candidate_id": "antonio-villaraigosa", "candidate_name": "Antonio Villaraigosa", "claim_id": "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e413", "event_title": "Villaraigosa ICE accountability plan", "matched_keywords": [ "accountability", "court action", "detention", "ice", "misconduct", "misconduct documentation", "public reporting", "state inspections" ], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://www.antonio2026.com/ice", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.7, "stance_reason": "support_language", "text": "Use state inspections, child-protection systems, misconduct documentation, public reporting, and court action to hold ICE detention and enforcement accountable.", "theme_id": "immigration-civil-rights", "theme_label": "Immigration Civil Rights" }, { "candidate_id": "eric-swalwell", "candidate_name": "Eric Swalwell", "claim_id": "cl-app-source-pbs-newshour-swalwell-governor-campaign-launch-6b1cac6dbb167e-fac25709", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-pbs-newshour-swalwell-governor-campaign-launch-6b1cac6dbb167eed-fb5d213d", "event_title": "PBS NewsHour: Swalwell governor campaign launch", "matched_keywords": ["expanded ice actions", "ice", "trump administration overreach"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/u-s-rep-eric-swalwell-is-running-for-california-governor", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.76, "stance_reason": "rule_specific_support_language", "text": "Use the governor's office to protect Californians from Trump administration overreach and oppose expanded ICE actions in communities.", "theme_id": "federal-overreach-immigration-enforcement", "theme_label": "Federal Overreach Immigration Enforcement" }, { "candidate_id": "katie-porter", "candidate_name": "Katie Porter", "claim_id": "cl-app-source-porter-abolish-ice-priority-page-8466da53c55d9c32-79f2a1d1-ka-702c62b2", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-porter-abolish-ice-priority-page-8466da53c55d9c32-79f2a1d1", "event_title": "Porter abolish ICE priority page", "matched_keywords": ["ice"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://katieporter.com/priority/abolish-ice/", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.58, "stance_reason": "recommendation_default", "text": "Reject federal overreach, keep California communities as sanctuaries for immigrants, and work with federal partners to abolish ICE.", "theme_id": "immigration-civil-rights", "theme_label": "Immigration Civil Rights" }, { "candidate_id": "tom-steyer", "candidate_name": "Tom Steyer", "claim_id": "cl-app-source-steyer-abolish-ice-issue-page-d0367666a08a3365-07825b65-tom-s-e0a4e29e", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-steyer-abolish-ice-issue-page-d0367666a08a3365-07825b65", "event_title": "Steyer abolish ICE issue page", "matched_keywords": ["ice"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://www.tomsteyer.com/issues/abolish-ice", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.58, "stance_reason": "recommendation_default", "text": "Stop masked ICE agents from terrorizing Californians and seek authority for California to hold ICE agents accountable for violent or illegal conduct.", "theme_id": "immigration-civil-rights", "theme_label": "Immigration Civil Rights" }, { "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_id": "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-ton-801e915d", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-02-03", "event_id": "event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate", "event_title": "Black Action Alliance / KTVU / KTTV California gubernatorial debate", "matched_keywords": ["ice"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://www.blackactionalliance.org/events/2026-ca-gubernatorial-debate-hosted-by-black-action-alliance", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.76, "stance_reason": "rule_specific_support_language", "text": "Thurmond says California should create a pathway to citizenship and that he supports abolishing ICE.", "theme_id": "immigration", "theme_label": "Immigration" }, { "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_id": "cl-app-event-2026-03-26-kqed-political-breakdown-tony-thurmond-tony-k-thurm-2573ba61", "claim_type": "assertion", "date": "2026-03-26", "event_id": "event-2026-03-26-kqed-political-breakdown-tony-thurmond", "event_title": "KQED Political Breakdown: Tony Thurmond Makes His Case for Governor of California", "matched_keywords": ["detention", "ice"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://www.pbs.org/video/tony-thurmond-makes-his-case-for-governor-of-california-political-breakdown-zi6asl/", "stance": "qualify", "stance_confidence": 0.5, "stance_reason": "assertion_without_clear_policy_direction", "text": "Thurmond says he has passed legislation aimed at keeping ICE out of California schools and hospitals and at taxing companies that operate ICE detention centers.", "theme_id": "immigration", "theme_label": "Immigration" }, { "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_id": "cl-app-source-thurmond-campaign-priorities-de98e1de1a07cdf4-0b67999f-tony-k-972b79f1", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-thurmond-campaign-priorities-de98e1de1a07cdf4-0b67999f", "event_title": "Thurmond campaign priorities", "matched_keywords": ["detention", "ice"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://www.tonythurmond.com/priorities", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.7, "stance_reason": "support_language", "text": "Tax companies that operate ICE detention centers, protect sanctuary-state laws, fight to abolish ICE, and support a pathway to citizenship.", "theme_id": "immigration-civil-rights", "theme_label": "Immigration Civil Rights" } ], "evidence_groups": [ { "candidate_id": "antonio-villaraigosa", "candidate_name": "Antonio Villaraigosa", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:evidence:antonio-villaraigosa:support:235c38c52b", "matched_keywords": [ "accountability", "court action", "detention", "ice", "misconduct", "misconduct documentation", "public reporting", "state inspections" ], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e413", "event_title": "Villaraigosa ICE accountability plan", "source_url": "https://www.antonio2026.com/ice", "text": "Use state inspections, child-protection systems, misconduct documentation, public reporting, and court action to hold ICE detention and enforcement accountable." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "Use state inspections, child-protection systems, misconduct documentation, public reporting, and court action to hold ICE detention and enforcement accountable." }, { "candidate_id": "eric-swalwell", "candidate_name": "Eric Swalwell", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-pbs-newshour-swalwell-governor-campaign-launch-6b1cac6dbb167e-fac25709" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:evidence:eric-swalwell:support:700f5bec8a", "matched_keywords": ["expanded ice actions", "ice", "trump administration overreach"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-source-pbs-newshour-swalwell-governor-campaign-launch-6b1cac6dbb167e-fac25709", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-pbs-newshour-swalwell-governor-campaign-launch-6b1cac6dbb167eed-fb5d213d", "event_title": "PBS NewsHour: Swalwell governor campaign launch", "source_url": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/u-s-rep-eric-swalwell-is-running-for-california-governor", "text": "Use the governor's office to protect Californians from Trump administration overreach and oppose expanded ICE actions in communities." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "Use the governor's office to protect Californians from Trump administration overreach and oppose expanded ICE actions in communities." }, { "candidate_id": "katie-porter", "candidate_name": "Katie Porter", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-porter-abolish-ice-priority-page-8466da53c55d9c32-79f2a1d1-ka-702c62b2" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:evidence:katie-porter:support:9ccc4c7ece", "matched_keywords": ["ice"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-source-porter-abolish-ice-priority-page-8466da53c55d9c32-79f2a1d1-ka-702c62b2", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-porter-abolish-ice-priority-page-8466da53c55d9c32-79f2a1d1", "event_title": "Porter abolish ICE priority page", "source_url": "https://katieporter.com/priority/abolish-ice/", "text": "Reject federal overreach, keep California communities as sanctuaries for immigrants, and work with federal partners to abolish ICE." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "Reject federal overreach, keep California communities as sanctuaries for immigrants, and work with federal partners to abolish ICE." }, { "candidate_id": "tom-steyer", "candidate_name": "Tom Steyer", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-steyer-abolish-ice-issue-page-d0367666a08a3365-07825b65-tom-s-e0a4e29e" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:evidence:tom-steyer:support:0bfc9c78c3", "matched_keywords": ["ice"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-source-steyer-abolish-ice-issue-page-d0367666a08a3365-07825b65-tom-s-e0a4e29e", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-steyer-abolish-ice-issue-page-d0367666a08a3365-07825b65", "event_title": "Steyer abolish ICE issue page", "source_url": "https://www.tomsteyer.com/issues/abolish-ice", "text": "Stop masked ICE agents from terrorizing Californians and seek authority for California to hold ICE agents accountable for violent or illegal conduct." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "Stop masked ICE agents from terrorizing Californians and seek authority for California to hold ICE agents accountable for violent or illegal conduct." }, { "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-thurmond-campaign-priorities-de98e1de1a07cdf4-0b67999f-tony-k-972b79f1" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:evidence:tony-k-thurmond:support:f7233f6db8", "matched_keywords": ["detention", "ice"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-source-thurmond-campaign-priorities-de98e1de1a07cdf4-0b67999f-tony-k-972b79f1", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-thurmond-campaign-priorities-de98e1de1a07cdf4-0b67999f", "event_title": "Thurmond campaign priorities", "source_url": "https://www.tonythurmond.com/priorities", "text": "Tax companies that operate ICE detention centers, protect sanctuary-state laws, fight to abolish ICE, and support a pathway to citizenship." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "Tax companies that operate ICE detention centers, protect sanctuary-state laws, fight to abolish ICE, and support a pathway to citizenship." }, { "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-ton-801e915d" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-02-03", "group_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:evidence:tony-k-thurmond:support:62a24ff117", "matched_keywords": ["ice"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-ton-801e915d", "date": "2026-02-03", "event_id": "event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate", "event_title": "Black Action Alliance / KTVU / KTTV California gubernatorial debate", "source_url": "https://www.blackactionalliance.org/events/2026-ca-gubernatorial-debate-hosted-by-black-action-alliance", "text": "Thurmond says California should create a pathway to citizenship and that he supports abolishing ICE." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "Thurmond says California should create a pathway to citizenship and that he supports abolishing ICE." }, { "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-event-2026-03-26-kqed-political-breakdown-tony-thurmond-tony-k-thurm-2573ba61" ], "claim_type": "assertion", "date": "2026-03-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:evidence:tony-k-thurmond:qualify:c2b29ef66d", "matched_keywords": ["detention", "ice"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-event-2026-03-26-kqed-political-breakdown-tony-thurmond-tony-k-thurm-2573ba61", "date": "2026-03-26", "event_id": "event-2026-03-26-kqed-political-breakdown-tony-thurmond", "event_title": "KQED Political Breakdown: Tony Thurmond Makes His Case for Governor of California", "source_url": "https://www.pbs.org/video/tony-thurmond-makes-his-case-for-governor-of-california-political-breakdown-zi6asl/", "text": "Thurmond says he has passed legislation aimed at keeping ICE out of California schools and hospitals and at taxing companies that operate ICE detention centers." } ], "stance": "qualify", "statement": "Thurmond says he has passed legislation aimed at keeping ICE out of California schools and hospitals and at taxing companies that operate ICE detention centers." } ], "evidence_quality": "comparative", "evidence_signal": "This is the main comparative immigration cluster in the current artifact, but it does not adjudicate individual enforcement incidents.", "idea_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability", "idea_kind": "policy", "idea_slug": "ice-accountability", "issue_id": "immigration", "label": "ICE accountability and cooperation conditions", "matched_keywords": [ { "count": 7, "keyword": "ice" }, { "count": 3, "keyword": "detention" }, { "count": 1, "keyword": "accountability" }, { "count": 1, "keyword": "court action" }, { "count": 1, "keyword": "misconduct" }, { "count": 1, "keyword": "misconduct documentation" }, { "count": 1, "keyword": "public reporting" }, { "count": 1, "keyword": "state inspections" } ], "party_aggregates": [ { "candidate_count": 5, "claim_count": 7, "issue_candidate_count": 7, "party": "Democratic" } ], "plausibility": "Plausible for transparency and state leverage; effectiveness depends on federal-state authority boundaries and enforcement follow-through.", "problem": "Immigration enforcement is framed as causing civil-rights, safety, or state-cooperation problems when conduct is opaque or abusive.", "quality_flags": [], "related_problem_links": [], "related_problems": ["Civil rights", "Public safety", "State-federal authority"], "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "semantic_group_id": "idea-group:immigration:enforcement-accountability", "semantic_group_label": "Enforcement accountability and de-escalation", "semantic_group_slug": "enforcement-accountability", "solution": "Condition cooperation, require training or reporting, document misconduct, inspect detention, or pursue legal accountability.", "source_count": 7, "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 1, "record": 0, "support": 6, "unclear": 0 }, "summary": "Creates accountability, training, liability, or state-cooperation conditions for federal immigration agents.", "tradeoffs": [ "Can protect rights and clarify state posture, but may provoke federal conflict.", "Oversight can document misconduct without directly changing federal operations." ], "variants": [ { "candidate_count": 5, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-ton-801e915d", "cl-app-event-2026-03-26-kqed-political-breakdown-tony-thurmond-tony-k-thurm-2573ba61", "cl-app-source-pbs-newshour-swalwell-governor-campaign-launch-6b1cac6dbb167e-fac25709", "cl-app-source-porter-abolish-ice-priority-page-8466da53c55d9c32-79f2a1d1-ka-702c62b2", "cl-app-source-steyer-abolish-ice-issue-page-d0367666a08a3365-07825b65-tom-s-e0a4e29e", "cl-app-source-thurmond-campaign-priorities-de98e1de1a07cdf4-0b67999f-tony-k-972b79f1", "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f" ], "evidence_count": 7, "label": "ice", "matched_keyword": "ice", "matched_keywords": ["ice"], "slug": "ice", "source_count": 7, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:ice" }, { "candidate_count": 2, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-event-2026-03-26-kqed-political-breakdown-tony-thurmond-tony-k-thurm-2573ba61", "cl-app-source-thurmond-campaign-priorities-de98e1de1a07cdf4-0b67999f-tony-k-972b79f1", "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f" ], "evidence_count": 3, "label": "detention", "matched_keyword": "detention", "matched_keywords": ["detention"], "slug": "detention", "source_count": 3, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:detention" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f" ], "evidence_count": 1, "label": "accountability", "matched_keyword": "accountability", "matched_keywords": ["accountability"], "slug": "accountability", "source_count": 1, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:accountability" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f" ], "evidence_count": 1, "label": "court action", "matched_keyword": "court action", "matched_keywords": ["court action"], "slug": "court-action", "source_count": 1, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:court-action" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-pbs-newshour-swalwell-governor-campaign-launch-6b1cac6dbb167e-fac25709" ], "evidence_count": 1, "label": "expanded ice actions", "matched_keyword": "expanded ice actions", "matched_keywords": ["expanded ice actions"], "slug": "expanded-ice-actions", "source_count": 1, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:expanded-ice-actions" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f" ], "evidence_count": 1, "label": "misconduct", "matched_keyword": "misconduct", "matched_keywords": ["misconduct"], "slug": "misconduct", "source_count": 1, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:misconduct" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f" ], "evidence_count": 1, "label": "misconduct documentation", "matched_keyword": "misconduct documentation", "matched_keywords": ["misconduct documentation"], "slug": "misconduct-documentation", "source_count": 1, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:misconduct-documentation" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f" ], "evidence_count": 1, "label": "public reporting", "matched_keyword": "public reporting", "matched_keywords": ["public reporting"], "slug": "public-reporting", "source_count": 1, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:ice-accountability:public-reporting" } ] }, { "aliases": ["immigration--immigrant-services"], "analysis_frame": { "cause": "The theory is that legal complexity and fear prevent people from asserting rights or accessing help.", "evaluation_questions": [ "Is the row limiting enforcement, accepting enforcement with safeguards, or expanding support services?", "Which level of government has authority over the lever being proposed?", "What source evidence shows that legal services and immigrant support addresses the stated problem rather than just naming a topic?", "Which assumptions would have to be true for this to work in practice?", "Who pays, who benefits, and what gets worse if this approach is implemented?" ], "evidence_needed": [ "A source naming the protected group, right, enforcement tool, and remedy.", "Authority analysis showing which state or local institution can implement it." ], "evidence_signal": "The current artifact has limited candidate coverage, but the source rows describe concrete support services rather than only symbolic solidarity.", "plausibility": "Plausible for improving navigation and due process; it does not by itself change federal enforcement priorities.", "possible_solution": "Fund legal services, hotlines, know-your-rights education, and immigrant support programs.", "problem": "Immigrants and mixed-status families can lack legal help, trusted information, or service access during enforcement conflicts.", "problem_kind": "policy_problem", "related_problems": ["Civil rights", "Public-service access", "State-federal conflict"], "tradeoffs": [ "Can protect vulnerable residents, but requires funding and trusted delivery partners.", "Support services can reduce harm while leaving larger immigration-law disputes unresolved." ] }, "approach_id": "immigration--immigrant-services", "candidate_count": 3, "cause": "The theory is that legal complexity and fear prevent people from asserting rights or accessing help.", "claim_count": 3, "confidence": 0.63, "coverage_notes": [], "coverage_score": 64, "deduped_evidence_count": 3, "evidence": [ { "candidate_id": "chad-bianco", "candidate_name": "Chad Bianco", "claim_id": "cl-app-source-bianco-immigration-priority-page-b5f13b0a052d74d8-f3d0c3a7-ch-2a2fdd38", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-bianco-immigration-priority-page-b5f13b0a052d74d8-f3d0c3a7", "event_title": "Bianco immigration priority page", "matched_keywords": ["support"], "party": "Republican", "source_url": "https://biancoforgovernor.com/immigration/", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.7, "stance_reason": "support_language", "text": "End sanctuary-state limits for serious criminal cases, let local law enforcement cooperate with federal partners, and support lawful worker pathways.", "theme_id": "immigration", "theme_label": "Immigration" }, { "candidate_id": "matt-mahan", "candidate_name": "Matt Mahan", "claim_id": "cl-app-source-mahan-immigration-page-801021cf61bab09f-aaca6dbb-matt-mahan-i-7c90d148", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-mahan-immigration-page-801021cf61bab09f-aaca6dbb", "event_title": "Mahan immigration page", "matched_keywords": ["immigrant", "services", "support"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://www.mahanforcalifornia.com/immigration", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.7, "stance_reason": "support_language", "text": "Protect immigrant residents' access to local services, support emergency aid for immigrant families, and confront ICE actions that disrupt communities.", "theme_id": "immigration-civil-rights", "theme_label": "Immigration Civil Rights" }, { "candidate_id": "xavier-becerra", "candidate_name": "Xavier Becerra", "claim_id": "cl-app-source-becerra-federal-overreach-priority-page-3610c96ccec90a3c-5f08-27a2f874", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-becerra-federal-overreach-priority-page-3610c96ccec90a3c-5f085455", "event_title": "Becerra federal-overreach priority page", "matched_keywords": ["immigrant"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://www.xavierbecerra2026.com/priorities/fighting-donald-trump/", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.58, "stance_reason": "recommendation_default", "text": "Challenge federal overreach in court and defend health care, Dreamers, immigrant communities, workers, reproductive rights, and California environmental authority.", "theme_id": "federal-overreach-immigration-enforcement", "theme_label": "Federal Overreach Immigration Enforcement" } ], "evidence_groups": [ { "candidate_id": "chad-bianco", "candidate_name": "Chad Bianco", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-bianco-immigration-priority-page-b5f13b0a052d74d8-f3d0c3a7-ch-2a2fdd38" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:immigrant-services:evidence:chad-bianco:support:32fdabfa1b", "matched_keywords": ["support"], "party": "Republican", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-source-bianco-immigration-priority-page-b5f13b0a052d74d8-f3d0c3a7-ch-2a2fdd38", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-bianco-immigration-priority-page-b5f13b0a052d74d8-f3d0c3a7", "event_title": "Bianco immigration priority page", "source_url": "https://biancoforgovernor.com/immigration/", "text": "End sanctuary-state limits for serious criminal cases, let local law enforcement cooperate with federal partners, and support lawful worker pathways." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "End sanctuary-state limits for serious criminal cases, let local law enforcement cooperate with federal partners, and support lawful worker pathways." }, { "candidate_id": "matt-mahan", "candidate_name": "Matt Mahan", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-mahan-immigration-page-801021cf61bab09f-aaca6dbb-matt-mahan-i-7c90d148" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:immigrant-services:evidence:matt-mahan:support:4e36736d71", "matched_keywords": ["immigrant", "services", "support"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-source-mahan-immigration-page-801021cf61bab09f-aaca6dbb-matt-mahan-i-7c90d148", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-mahan-immigration-page-801021cf61bab09f-aaca6dbb", "event_title": "Mahan immigration page", "source_url": "https://www.mahanforcalifornia.com/immigration", "text": "Protect immigrant residents' access to local services, support emergency aid for immigrant families, and confront ICE actions that disrupt communities." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "Protect immigrant residents' access to local services, support emergency aid for immigrant families, and confront ICE actions that disrupt communities." }, { "candidate_id": "xavier-becerra", "candidate_name": "Xavier Becerra", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-becerra-federal-overreach-priority-page-3610c96ccec90a3c-5f08-27a2f874" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:immigrant-services:evidence:xavier-becerra:support:9d65f22ad1", "matched_keywords": ["immigrant"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-source-becerra-federal-overreach-priority-page-3610c96ccec90a3c-5f08-27a2f874", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-becerra-federal-overreach-priority-page-3610c96ccec90a3c-5f085455", "event_title": "Becerra federal-overreach priority page", "source_url": "https://www.xavierbecerra2026.com/priorities/fighting-donald-trump/", "text": "Challenge federal overreach in court and defend health care, Dreamers, immigrant communities, workers, reproductive rights, and California environmental authority." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "Challenge federal overreach in court and defend health care, Dreamers, immigrant communities, workers, reproductive rights, and California environmental authority." } ], "evidence_quality": "limited", "evidence_signal": "The current artifact has limited candidate coverage, but the source rows describe concrete support services rather than only symbolic solidarity.", "idea_id": "idea:immigration:immigrant-services", "idea_kind": "rights", "idea_slug": "immigrant-services", "issue_id": "immigration", "label": "Legal services and immigrant support", "matched_keywords": [ { "count": 2, "keyword": "support" }, { "count": 2, "keyword": "immigrant" }, { "count": 1, "keyword": "services" } ], "party_aggregates": [ { "candidate_count": 2, "claim_count": 2, "issue_candidate_count": 7, "party": "Democratic" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "claim_count": 1, "issue_candidate_count": 1, "party": "Republican" } ], "plausibility": "Plausible for improving navigation and due process; it does not by itself change federal enforcement priorities.", "problem": "Immigrants and mixed-status families can lack legal help, trusted information, or service access during enforcement conflicts.", "quality_flags": [], "related_problem_links": [], "related_problems": ["Civil rights", "Public-service access", "State-federal conflict"], "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "semantic_group_id": "idea-group:immigration:immigrant-support-services", "semantic_group_label": "Immigrant support services", "semantic_group_slug": "immigrant-support-services", "solution": "Fund legal services, hotlines, know-your-rights education, and immigrant support programs.", "source_count": 3, "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 3, "unclear": 0 }, "summary": "Expands hotlines, legal services, know-your-rights education, or immigrant support programs.", "tradeoffs": [ "Can protect vulnerable residents, but requires funding and trusted delivery partners.", "Support services can reduce harm while leaving larger immigration-law disputes unresolved." ], "variants": [ { "candidate_count": 2, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-becerra-federal-overreach-priority-page-3610c96ccec90a3c-5f08-27a2f874", "cl-app-source-mahan-immigration-page-801021cf61bab09f-aaca6dbb-matt-mahan-i-7c90d148" ], "evidence_count": 2, "label": "immigrant", "matched_keyword": "immigrant", "matched_keywords": ["immigrant"], "slug": "immigrant", "source_count": 2, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:immigrant-services:immigrant" }, { "candidate_count": 2, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-bianco-immigration-priority-page-b5f13b0a052d74d8-f3d0c3a7-ch-2a2fdd38", "cl-app-source-mahan-immigration-page-801021cf61bab09f-aaca6dbb-matt-mahan-i-7c90d148" ], "evidence_count": 2, "label": "support", "matched_keyword": "support", "matched_keywords": ["support"], "slug": "support", "source_count": 2, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:immigrant-services:support" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-mahan-immigration-page-801021cf61bab09f-aaca6dbb-matt-mahan-i-7c90d148" ], "evidence_count": 1, "label": "services", "matched_keyword": "services", "matched_keywords": ["services"], "slug": "services", "source_count": 1, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:immigrant-services:services" } ] }, { "aliases": ["immigration--lawful-enforcement-calming"], "analysis_frame": { "cause": "The theory is that the implementation style of enforcement can worsen community tension even when laws are enforced.", "evaluation_questions": [ "Is the row limiting enforcement, accepting enforcement with safeguards, or expanding support services?", "Which level of government has authority over the lever being proposed?", "What source evidence shows that lawful enforcement with de-escalation addresses the stated problem rather than just naming a topic?", "Which assumptions would have to be true for this to work in practice?", "Who pays, who benefits, and what gets worse if this approach is implemented?" ], "evidence_needed": [ "Comparable candidate sources that name the same problem and policy lever.", "Independent or administrative data that tests whether the lever can plausibly change outcomes." ], "evidence_signal": "The current rows show this as a distinct posture from ICE-accountability limits, with modest coverage.", "plausibility": "Plausible for reducing visible conflict if agencies cooperate and rules are clear; weak if the core dispute is the enforcement policy itself.", "possible_solution": "Accept enforcement while emphasizing peaceful execution, de-escalation, and local tension reduction.", "problem": "Immigration-law enforcement is framed as legitimate but socially destabilizing when it escalates fear or conflict.", "problem_kind": "policy_problem", "related_problems": ["ICE accountability", "Civil rights", "Community trust"], "tradeoffs": [ "May lower tensions, but can be seen as insufficient by rights-focused critics.", "De-escalation language can lack enforceable standards." ] }, "approach_id": "immigration--lawful-enforcement-calming", "candidate_count": 2, "cause": "The theory is that the implementation style of enforcement can worsen community tension even when laws are enforced.", "claim_count": 2, "confidence": 0.57, "coverage_notes": [], "coverage_score": 46, "deduped_evidence_count": 2, "evidence": [ { "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_id": "cl-app-source-california-official-voter-guide-candidate-statements-0adc75f3-fa798700", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-california-official-voter-guide-candidate-statements-0adc75f3506cf755-77e94c48", "event_title": "California official voter guide candidate statements", "matched_keywords": ["immigration enforcement"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/candidates/governor-candidate-statements.htm", "stance": "support", "stance_confidence": 0.58, "stance_reason": "recommendation_default", "text": "Abolish ICE and keep immigration enforcement out of California schools.", "theme_id": "immigration-education", "theme_label": "Immigration Education" }, { "candidate_id": "xavier-becerra", "candidate_name": "Xavier Becerra", "claim_id": "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-xav-eb571344", "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-02-03", "event_id": "event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate", "event_title": "Black Action Alliance / KTVU / KTTV California gubernatorial debate", "matched_keywords": ["immigration enforcement"], "party": "Democratic", "source_url": "https://www.blackactionalliance.org/events/2026-ca-gubernatorial-debate-hosted-by-black-action-alliance", "stance": "qualify", "stance_confidence": 0.56, "stance_reason": "qualified_or_causal_language", "text": "Becerra says he would have California proactively oversee federal immigration enforcement by “policing the immigration police” if elected governor.", "theme_id": "immigration", "theme_label": "Immigration" } ], "evidence_groups": [ { "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-california-official-voter-guide-candidate-statements-0adc75f3-fa798700" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-05-26", "group_id": "idea:immigration:lawful-enforcement-calming:evidence:tony-k-thurmond:support:98a857f3ff", "matched_keywords": ["immigration enforcement"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-source-california-official-voter-guide-candidate-statements-0adc75f3-fa798700", "date": "2026-05-26", "event_id": "source-california-official-voter-guide-candidate-statements-0adc75f3506cf755-77e94c48", "event_title": "California official voter guide candidate statements", "source_url": "https://voterguide.sos.ca.gov/candidates/governor-candidate-statements.htm", "text": "Abolish ICE and keep immigration enforcement out of California schools." } ], "stance": "support", "statement": "Abolish ICE and keep immigration enforcement out of California schools." }, { "candidate_id": "xavier-becerra", "candidate_name": "Xavier Becerra", "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-xav-eb571344" ], "claim_type": "recommendation", "date": "2026-02-03", "group_id": "idea:immigration:lawful-enforcement-calming:evidence:xavier-becerra:qualify:c2a6620614", "matched_keywords": ["immigration enforcement"], "party": "Democratic", "row_count": 1, "source_count": 1, "source_rows": [ { "claim_id": "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-xav-eb571344", "date": "2026-02-03", "event_id": "event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate", "event_title": "Black Action Alliance / KTVU / KTTV California gubernatorial debate", "source_url": "https://www.blackactionalliance.org/events/2026-ca-gubernatorial-debate-hosted-by-black-action-alliance", "text": "Becerra says he would have California proactively oversee federal immigration enforcement by “policing the immigration police” if elected governor." } ], "stance": "qualify", "statement": "Becerra says he would have California proactively oversee federal immigration enforcement by “policing the immigration police” if elected governor." } ], "evidence_quality": "limited", "evidence_signal": "The current rows show this as a distinct posture from ICE-accountability limits, with modest coverage.", "idea_id": "idea:immigration:lawful-enforcement-calming", "idea_kind": "policy", "idea_slug": "lawful-enforcement-calming", "issue_id": "immigration", "label": "Lawful enforcement with de-escalation", "matched_keywords": [ { "count": 2, "keyword": "immigration enforcement" } ], "party_aggregates": [ { "candidate_count": 2, "claim_count": 2, "issue_candidate_count": 7, "party": "Democratic" } ], "plausibility": "Plausible for reducing visible conflict if agencies cooperate and rules are clear; weak if the core dispute is the enforcement policy itself.", "problem": "Immigration-law enforcement is framed as legitimate but socially destabilizing when it escalates fear or conflict.", "quality_flags": [], "related_problem_links": [], "related_problems": ["ICE accountability", "Civil rights", "Community trust"], "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "semantic_group_id": "idea-group:immigration:enforcement-accountability", "semantic_group_label": "Enforcement accountability and de-escalation", "semantic_group_slug": "enforcement-accountability", "solution": "Accept enforcement while emphasizing peaceful execution, de-escalation, and local tension reduction.", "source_count": 2, "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 1, "record": 0, "support": 1, "unclear": 0 }, "summary": "Accepts immigration-law enforcement while emphasizing de-escalation, calm, or local tension reduction.", "tradeoffs": [ "May lower tensions, but can be seen as insufficient by rights-focused critics.", "De-escalation language can lack enforceable standards." ], "variants": [ { "candidate_count": 2, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-xav-eb571344", "cl-app-source-california-official-voter-guide-candidate-statements-0adc75f3-fa798700" ], "evidence_count": 2, "label": "immigration enforcement", "matched_keyword": "immigration enforcement", "matched_keywords": ["immigration enforcement"], "slug": "immigration-enforcement", "source_count": 2, "variant_id": "idea:immigration:lawful-enforcement-calming:immigration-enforcement" } ] } ], "candidate_stances": [ { "approach_id": "immigration--ice-accountability", "candidate_id": "antonio-villaraigosa", "candidate_name": "Antonio Villaraigosa", "claim_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-villaraigosa-ice-accountability-plan-3e4414a909232ba0-be00e41-1ccf5a7f" ], "confidence": 0.7, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Democratic", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 1, "unclear": 0 } }, { "approach_id": "immigration--ice-accountability", "candidate_id": "eric-swalwell", "candidate_name": "Eric Swalwell", "claim_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-pbs-newshour-swalwell-governor-campaign-launch-6b1cac6dbb167e-fac25709" ], "confidence": 0.76, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Democratic", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 1, "unclear": 0 } }, { "approach_id": "immigration--ice-accountability", "candidate_id": "katie-porter", "candidate_name": "Katie Porter", "claim_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-porter-abolish-ice-priority-page-8466da53c55d9c32-79f2a1d1-ka-702c62b2" ], "confidence": 0.58, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Democratic", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 1, "unclear": 0 } }, { "approach_id": "immigration--ice-accountability", "candidate_id": "tom-steyer", "candidate_name": "Tom Steyer", "claim_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-steyer-abolish-ice-issue-page-d0367666a08a3365-07825b65-tom-s-e0a4e29e" ], "confidence": 0.58, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Democratic", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 1, "unclear": 0 } }, { "approach_id": "immigration--ice-accountability", "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_count": 3, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-ton-801e915d", "cl-app-event-2026-03-26-kqed-political-breakdown-tony-thurmond-tony-k-thurm-2573ba61", "cl-app-source-thurmond-campaign-priorities-de98e1de1a07cdf4-0b67999f-tony-k-972b79f1" ], "confidence": 0.84, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Democratic", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 3, "stance": "support", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 1, "record": 0, "support": 2, "unclear": 0 } }, { "approach_id": "immigration--immigrant-services", "candidate_id": "chad-bianco", "candidate_name": "Chad Bianco", "claim_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-bianco-immigration-priority-page-b5f13b0a052d74d8-f3d0c3a7-ch-2a2fdd38" ], "confidence": 0.7, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Republican", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 1, "unclear": 0 } }, { "approach_id": "immigration--immigrant-services", "candidate_id": "matt-mahan", "candidate_name": "Matt Mahan", "claim_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-mahan-immigration-page-801021cf61bab09f-aaca6dbb-matt-mahan-i-7c90d148" ], "confidence": 0.7, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Democratic", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 1, "unclear": 0 } }, { "approach_id": "immigration--immigrant-services", "candidate_id": "xavier-becerra", "candidate_name": "Xavier Becerra", "claim_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-becerra-federal-overreach-priority-page-3610c96ccec90a3c-5f08-27a2f874" ], "confidence": 0.58, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Democratic", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 1, "unclear": 0 } }, { "approach_id": "immigration--lawful-enforcement-calming", "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-source-california-official-voter-guide-candidate-statements-0adc75f3-fa798700" ], "confidence": 0.58, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Democratic", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 1, "unclear": 0 } }, { "approach_id": "immigration--lawful-enforcement-calming", "candidate_id": "xavier-becerra", "candidate_name": "Xavier Becerra", "claim_count": 1, "claim_ids": [ "cl-app-event-2026-02-03-black-action-alliance-ktvu-kttv-governor-debate-xav-eb571344" ], "confidence": 0.56, "issue_id": "immigration", "party": "Democratic", "review_status": "generated_review_candidate", "source_count": 1, "stance": "qualify", "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 1, "record": 0, "support": 0, "unclear": 0 } } ], "evidence_groups": [], "generated_at": "2026-06-02T08:01:06.314093+00:00", "idea_groups": [ { "approach_ids": [ "immigration--ice-accountability", "immigration--lawful-enforcement-calming" ], "candidate_count": 6, "candidate_summaries": [ { "candidate_id": "tony-k-thurmond", "candidate_name": "Tony K. Thurmond", "claim_count": 4, "party": "Democratic", "source_count": 4, "stance": "support" }, { "candidate_id": "antonio-villaraigosa", "candidate_name": "Antonio Villaraigosa", "claim_count": 1, "party": "Democratic", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support" }, { "candidate_id": "eric-swalwell", "candidate_name": "Eric Swalwell", "claim_count": 1, "party": "Democratic", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support" }, { "candidate_id": "katie-porter", "candidate_name": "Katie Porter", "claim_count": 1, "party": "Democratic", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support" }, { "candidate_id": "tom-steyer", "candidate_name": "Tom Steyer", "claim_count": 1, "party": "Democratic", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support" }, { "candidate_id": "xavier-becerra", "candidate_name": "Xavier Becerra", "claim_count": 1, "party": "Democratic", "source_count": 1, "stance": "qualify" } ], "claim_count": 9, "curation_note": "Codex semantic grouping over deterministic source-backed approach clusters; source rows remain attached to the child approaches.", "evidence_quality": "comparative", "group_id": "idea-group:immigration:enforcement-accountability", "group_kind": "approach", "group_slug": "enforcement-accountability", "idea_ids": [ "idea:immigration:ice-accountability", "idea:immigration:lawful-enforcement-calming" ], "issue_id": "immigration", "label": "Enforcement accountability and de-escalation", "party_aggregates": [ { "candidate_count": 6, "claim_count": 9, "issue_candidate_count": 7, "party": "Democratic" } ], "primary_approach_id": "immigration--ice-accountability", "primary_idea_slug": "ice-accountability", "quality_flags": [], "review_status": "codex_curated_review_candidate", "source_count": 9, "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 2, "record": 0, "support": 7, "unclear": 0 }, "summary": "ICE accountability, state-cooperation conditions, lawful enforcement, and de-escalation approaches." }, { "approach_ids": ["immigration--immigrant-services"], "candidate_count": 3, "candidate_summaries": [ { "candidate_id": "chad-bianco", "candidate_name": "Chad Bianco", "claim_count": 1, "party": "Republican", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support" }, { "candidate_id": "matt-mahan", "candidate_name": "Matt Mahan", "claim_count": 1, "party": "Democratic", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support" }, { "candidate_id": "xavier-becerra", "candidate_name": "Xavier Becerra", "claim_count": 1, "party": "Democratic", "source_count": 1, "stance": "support" } ], "claim_count": 3, "curation_note": "Codex semantic grouping over deterministic source-backed approach clusters; source rows remain attached to the child approaches.", "evidence_quality": "limited", "group_id": "idea-group:immigration:immigrant-support-services", "group_kind": "rights", "group_slug": "immigrant-support-services", "idea_ids": ["idea:immigration:immigrant-services"], "issue_id": "immigration", "label": "Immigrant support services", "party_aggregates": [ { "candidate_count": 2, "claim_count": 2, "issue_candidate_count": 7, "party": "Democratic" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "claim_count": 1, "issue_candidate_count": 1, "party": "Republican" } ], "primary_approach_id": "immigration--immigrant-services", "primary_idea_slug": "immigrant-services", "quality_flags": [], "review_status": "codex_curated_review_candidate", "source_count": 3, "stance_counts": { "oppose": 0, "qualify": 0, "record": 0, "support": 3, "unclear": 0 }, "summary": "Legal services, hotlines, know-your-rights education, and immigrant support programs." } ], "issue": { "analysis_questions": [ "Is the row limiting enforcement, accepting enforcement with safeguards, or expanding support services?", "Which level of government has authority over the lever being proposed?", "What tradeoff exists between rights protection, public safety claims, federal-state conflict, and service access?" ], "approach_ids": [ "immigration--ice-accountability", "immigration--immigrant-services", "immigration--lawful-enforcement-calming" ], "candidate_count": 8, "claim_count": 12, "coverage_summary": { "average_score": 70, "by_quality": { "comparative": 1, "limited": 2 }, "warning": "Coverage summarizes normalized source rows only; missing rows are not opposition." }, "idea_group_ids": [ "idea-group:immigration:enforcement-accountability", "idea-group:immigration:immigrant-support-services" ], "issue_id": "immigration", "label": "Immigration", "party_denominators": [ { "candidate_count": 7, "party": "Democratic" }, { "candidate_count": 1, "party": "Republican" } ], "problem_statement": "Immigration rows separate federal enforcement posture, state cooperation, civil-rights limits, de-escalation, and support services for immigrant communities.", "summary": "Immigration enforcement, ICE conduct, legal protections, state cooperation, and immigrant services.", "theme_ids": [ "federal-overreach-immigration-enforcement", "immigration", "immigration-civil-rights", "immigration-education" ] }, "limitations": [ "This is a research prototype, not a voter guide, endorsement, or final assessment.", "Many rows are model-generated or unreviewed and should be treated as evidence-navigation aids.", "Missing or limited coverage means the dataset has not ingested, normalized, or balanced that surface yet; it is not evidence that a candidate lacks activity there.", "Use source URLs and record IDs when citing claims. Prefer the linked JSON/JSONL companion files for retrieval." ], "links": { "app_ideas": "https://polit.pages.dev/app/?view=ideas&issue=immigration", "app_issue": "https://polit.pages.dev/app/?view=issues&issue=immigration", "json": "https://polit.pages.dev/llm/issues/immigration.json", "markdown": "https://polit.pages.dev/llm/issues/immigration.md" }, "schema_version": "llm-static-exports/v1", "stance_guide": { "oppose": { "description": "Source rows reject or argue against the selected approach statement.", "label": "Opposes this approach" }, "qualify": { "description": "Source rows partly support, condition, or mix the selected approach with another claim.", "label": "Mixed / conditional signal" }, "record": { "description": "Source rows describe a record signal rather than a current position.", "label": "Record-only signal" }, "support": { "description": "Source rows back the selected approach statement.", "label": "Supports this approach" }, "unclear": { "description": "Source rows mention the topic but do not clearly support or oppose the approach.", "label": "Unclear signal" } } }